Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed
4 Pages  1 2 3 > » Bottom

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 FI/RE - Financial Independence / Retire Early, Share your experience

views
     
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 01:29 PM, updated 7y ago

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


All, there are active communities in oversea that working on FI/RE by hard saving, investing and living below our means.
For sure there are also FI or already RE people in here.

Appreciate to share your experience; Pre-FI/RE and Post-FI/RE life.

Thanks

#I’m working towards FI/RE and currently saving/invest 50-60% of my monthly salary. (On top of this around 20-25% spent for commitment like ASB loans and properties).


I like to hear sharing from all who working towards FI/RE so we can learn in term of planning, lifestyle, achievement, obstacles and etc.

-Update-

FI/FF is the priority that we need to work on - planning, executions, monitoring and improvement

RE - Decision is yours once achieved FI/FF

______

This post has been edited by meonkutu11: Jul 5 2018, 12:14 PM
hoimangkuk
post Jul 3 2018, 01:37 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
214 posts

Joined: Jul 2006
From: from the country that only know complaining


Park here...

got interested in FIRE from Reddit but dont know the best way to do it in Malaysia..

this might help me alot
icemanfx
post Jul 3 2018, 03:35 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012



With about 3% of adults have over us$100k net worth, those with practical experience is fewer than most expected.


ZeaXG
post Jul 3 2018, 04:11 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
342 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


Also working towards FIRE here. Current saving about 60% of monthly salary plus all of my passive income which is about 25% of salary.

My lifestyle is really boring to a lot of people though.
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 05:01 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(hoimangkuk @ Jul 3 2018, 01:37 PM)
Park here...

got interested in FIRE from Reddit but dont know the best way to do it in Malaysia..

this might help me alot
*
Hopefully those who already achieve FIRE will share their life experience.
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 05:02 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Jul 3 2018, 03:35 PM)
With about 3% of adults have over us$100k net worth, those with practical experience is fewer than most expected.
*
Hopefully some of those will be willing to share their experience here. rclxms.gif
chamelion
post Jul 3 2018, 05:05 PM

Back to Bricking
*******
Senior Member
2,755 posts

Joined: Dec 2004
anyone tried reit?
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 05:08 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(ZeaXG @ Jul 3 2018, 04:11 PM)
Also working towards FIRE here. Current saving about 60% of monthly salary plus all of my passive income which is about 25% of salary.

My lifestyle is really boring to a lot of people though.
*
Great move ZeaXG. rclxms.gif rclxms.gif rclxms.gif

Boring now for happiness and freedom in future. I think it is worth it.

Can you share the financial planning after FIRE, it is will follow 4% SWR or you have your own set of numbers/calculations?

Thanks. Well Done.
jack2
post Jul 3 2018, 05:21 PM

Mr
********
All Stars
15,192 posts

Joined: Oct 2004
How to work with FIRE
SetsunaSoon
post Jul 3 2018, 05:27 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
12 posts

Joined: Mar 2018


I am glad that there are Msian blogs/forum on FIRE.

I am currently working in SG and intends to achieve FIRE before 40 and enjoy life in Ipoh.
I am saving about 42% of my current take home pay and currently taking part-time tuition jobs.

I have been living like a monk, most of the time staying at home smile.gif
ZeaXG
post Jul 3 2018, 05:27 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
342 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 05:08 PM)

Can you share the financial planning after FIRE, it is will follow 4% SWR or you have your own set of numbers/calculations?

*
Actually I haven't set an amount for retirement. I just save as much as possible. Right now, I am keeping track of my passive income (which is mainly dividends from shares) to see if it can eventually overtake my salary. Once it's close to overtaking, then I'll see if I can FIRE.


barista
post Jul 3 2018, 05:30 PM

I want to retire
*****
Senior Member
883 posts

Joined: Aug 2008


Cannot just keep all the money. Must invest in health while you are young, otherwise you will not get to enjoy your retirement also.
SetsunaSoon
post Jul 3 2018, 05:37 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
12 posts

Joined: Mar 2018


QUOTE(ZeaXG @ Jul 3 2018, 05:27 PM)
Actually I haven't set an amount for retirement. I just save as much as possible. Right now, I am keeping track of my passive income (which is mainly dividends from shares) to see if it can eventually overtake my salary. Once it's close to overtaking, then I'll see if I can FIRE.
*
Do you invest with heigher weightage in MREITs?
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 05:40 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(SetsunaSoon @ Jul 3 2018, 05:27 PM)
I am glad that there are Msian blogs/forum on FIRE.

I am currently working in SG and intends to achieve FIRE before 40 and enjoy life in Ipoh.
I am saving about 42% of my current take home pay and currently taking part-time tuition jobs.

I have been living like a monk, most of the time staying at home smile.gif
*
Well Done on your saving rate and passive income.


mind to share what is your age now? Also, what is your target annual income after FIRE (in term of % of current income)?

Keep it up!
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 05:43 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(barista @ Jul 3 2018, 05:30 PM)
Cannot just keep all the money. Must invest in health while you are young, otherwise you will not get to enjoy your retirement also.
*
Agree with that.

Keep up with your health and doing sports also can translate to more live cost saving! Instead of everyday having teh tarik and eating mamak with friend, spend more time in public park, jogging etc.
Its free. biggrin.gif
SetsunaSoon
post Jul 3 2018, 05:48 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
12 posts

Joined: Mar 2018


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 05:40 PM)
Well Done on your saving rate and passive income.
mind to share what is your age now? Also, what is your target annual income after FIRE (in term  of % of current income)?

Keep it up!
*
My current age is 28.

It's hard to say because I am earning SGD salary but my plan is to have about RM3500 per month from my passive income portfolio when I reach FIRE.
I intend to diversify my portfolio by investing in income stocks listed in both SGX and Bursa.
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 06:54 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(SetsunaSoon @ Jul 3 2018, 05:48 PM)
My current age is 28.

It's hard to say because I am earning SGD salary but my plan is to have about RM3500 per month from my passive income portfolio when I reach FIRE.
I intend to diversify my portfolio by investing in income stocks listed in both SGX and Bursa.
*
Good job SetsunaSoon. I believe if you persistent you will successfully achieve your goals.

Keep on sharing Bro.


SetsunaSoon
post Jul 3 2018, 07:01 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
12 posts

Joined: Mar 2018


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 06:54 PM)
Good job SetsunaSoon. I believe if you persistent you will successfully achieve your goals.

Keep on sharing Bro.
*
Thanks for the encouragement bro!

Let us encourage more Msian to join FIRE movement to end this meaningless cycle of rat race through this forum.

polarzbearz
post Jul 3 2018, 07:08 PM

Gracie
*******
Senior Member
4,816 posts

Joined: Apr 2007


Just started to look into FIRE after procrastinating for quite a while due to life circumstances plus some excuses. Hopefully not too late yet!
howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 07:57 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(icemanfx @ Jul 3 2018, 03:35 PM)
With about 3% of adults have over us$100k net worth, those with practical experience is fewer than most expected.
*

That 3% figure cannot be correct.

For sure, a lot more people have over USD100k (RM405k) net worth.

This post has been edited by howszat: Jul 3 2018, 07:57 PM
ZeaXG
post Jul 3 2018, 09:17 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
342 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(SetsunaSoon @ Jul 3 2018, 05:37 PM)
Do you invest with heigher weightage in MREITs?
*
About 20% in MREITs
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 09:37 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(SetsunaSoon @ Jul 3 2018, 07:01 PM)
Thanks for the encouragement bro!

Let us encourage more Msian to join FIRE movement to end this meaningless cycle of rat race through this forum.
*
That’s what we need to do. Give support and encouragement.
I believe FIRE is not only chasing for our own escape from rat race BUT will also later on contributes and giving back to society.


TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 09:39 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(polarzbearz @ Jul 3 2018, 07:08 PM)
Just started to look into FIRE after procrastinating for quite a while due to life circumstances plus some excuses. Hopefully not too late yet!
*
Welcome Bro.

Everyone has their own battle. That’s understandable.
But we need to start somewhere, so lets work towards it and keep sharing your journey.

Good luck!
Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 09:42 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


FIRE is just glamorous word for be fugal and invest wisely. How many can give up the YOLO lifestyle and be frugal? To be frugal need discipline and dedication.
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 09:57 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 09:42 PM)
FIRE is just glamorous word for  be fugal and invest wisely. How many can give up the YOLO lifestyle and be frugal? To be frugal need discipline and dedication.
*
Yes, really need discipline and dedication.

But I think it is doable in Malaysia. Only from my short observations, many of us spending more than it should be on non-important stuffs and easy to follow others lifestyle in order to keep up the standard.

I’m consider myself lucky because working outside with a small team and less to none after hour activity. So less friend’s influence and more time with family.




howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 10:11 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
FIRE makes no sense.

Retire earlier, then do what? Eat and sleep? FIRE is about saving and sacrificing like shit, and then what?

It makes more sense to find something sustainable to do over your working life, rather than make monetary achievements and earlier retirement the objective.

Don't go for these bullshit acronyms just like that.
Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 10:16 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 10:11 PM)
FIRE makes no sense.

Retire earlier, then do what? Eat and sleep? FIRE is about saving and sacrificing like shit, and then what?

It makes more sense to find something sustainable to do over your working life, rather than make monetary achievements and earlier retirement the objective.

Don't go for these bullshit acronyms just like that.
*
The option to work or not to work. If you don't have FIRE, you work until retirement. By having that option, you can semi retire, quit your job and have more time to yourself.
polarzbearz
post Jul 3 2018, 10:17 PM

Gracie
*******
Senior Member
4,816 posts

Joined: Apr 2007


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 09:39 PM)
Welcome Bro.

Everyone has their own battle. That’s understandable.
But we need to start somewhere, so lets work towards it and keep sharing your journey.

Good luck!
*
Not a bro but a sis sweat.gif

For me it was a sudden realization / slap that I ended up in the "Rat Race" altho few years ago I've been reading on some of these topics. Thought I'd avoid the trap since it should be obvious having some "upfront warning" but little did I know all I need was a sudden downfall and I just got deeper into the race.

My goal is really to invest time now to free up time in the long run to do things I want to without worrying on the consequences.
howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 10:23 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 10:16 PM)
The option to work or not to work. If you don't have FIRE, you work until retirement. By having that option, you can semi retire, quit your job and have more time to yourself.
*

Aiya, so childish.

More time to yourself to do what? Eat and sleep, and just generally waste your life away?



Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 10:27 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 10:23 PM)
Aiya, so childish.

More time to yourself to do what? Eat and sleep, and just generally waste your life away?
*
There's so much you can do. No need to force yourself to go to work, stress up over work issue, come back late because of work. You get to live how you like. Get up what time you want, do gardening, go hiking, go jungle tracking without big bosses breathing down your neck.
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 10:31 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 10:11 PM)
FIRE makes no sense.

Retire earlier, then do what? Eat and sleep? FIRE is about saving and sacrificing like shit, and then what?

It makes more sense to find something sustainable to do over your working life, rather than make monetary achievements and earlier retirement the objective.

Don't go for these bullshit acronyms just like that.
*
There is so many things you can do when you achieved FI. If you want to continue working, nobody will stop you. But the point is you have options and you can decide which way you want to go.

Many people as Ramjade said cannot give up YOLO and that why comes with a lot of excuses.

Maybe for example we can see Mark Chua who was also active in this forum. He chose to resign because he can afford to. Then by chance (maybe) became a well known author. And now he is back into what he likes and good at. He once quoted "I work because I want to Not because I have to"....so again, options.

And of course we do not want our body just rotten on the couch.


howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 10:34 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 10:27 PM)
There's so much you can do. No need to force yourself to go to work, stress up over work issue, come back late because of work. You get to live how you like. Get up what time you want, do gardening, go hiking, go jungle tracking without big bosses breathing down your neck.
*

So why is Early Retirement THE objective?

Why force yourself, and get stressed about achieving RETIREMENT funds, so that you can do nothing after that?

Why not pace yourself before and after, and spread out the stress?
howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 10:38 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 10:31 PM)
There is so many things you can do when you achieved FI. If you want to continue working, nobody will stop you.
*

Aiyo, you missed the point.

Of course everybody wants to achieve FI. So that is not the point.

My point is there is a cost. You need to make sacrifices. You either make sacrifices earlier, or you spread it out.
Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 10:42 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 10:34 PM)
So why is Early Retirement THE objective?

Why force yourself, and get stressed about achieving RETIREMENT funds, so that you can do nothing after that?

Why not pace yourself before and after, and spread out the stress?
*
Who said anything about not doing anything? There's so much thing you can do.

First, which job allow you to set your own pace? How many of us are lucky to end up with such jobs?
With FIRE, you have that option about setting the pace you like. If you don't work, there's still money coming in to pay your bills and whatever stuff you need. If you don't work you still can afford to go on vacation as money is coming in.

QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 10:38 PM)
Aiyo, you missed the point.

Of course everybody wants to achieve FI. So that is not the point.

My point is there is a cost. You need to make sacrifices. You either make sacrifices earlier, or you spread it out.
*
Make sacrifice early. Rather work until full retirement.

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Jul 3 2018, 10:43 PM
howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 10:54 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 10:42 PM)
Who said anything about not doing anything? There's so much thing you can do.

First, which job allow you to set your own pace? How many of us are lucky to end up with such jobs?
With FIRE, you have that option about setting the pace you like. If you don't work, there's still money coming in to pay your bills and whatever stuff you need. If you don't work you still can afford to go on vacation as money is coming in.
Make sacrifice early. Rather work until full retirement.
*

You are assuming the earlier sacrifices is best for other people. That's a naive assumption.
Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 11:00 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 10:54 PM)
You are assuming the earlier sacrifices is best for other people. That's a naive assumption.
*
If you want to work until retirement, be my guest. No way I am working 12h+ and not compensated well for it.

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Jul 3 2018, 11:04 PM
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 11:01 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(polarzbearz @ Jul 3 2018, 10:17 PM)
Not a bro but a sis sweat.gif

For me it was a sudden realization / slap that I ended up in the "Rat Race" altho few years ago I've been reading on some of these topics. Thought I'd avoid the trap since it should be obvious having some "upfront warning" but little did I know all I need was a sudden downfall and I just got deeper into the race.

My goal is really to invest time now to free up time in the long run to do things I want to without worrying on the consequences.
*
Sorry, my bad sweat.gif

Good luck with your journey. It is not easy but it is not impossible.

I believe in order to keep us in-line, we need to have a clear current financial status and target (monthly/annually) that we want to achieve.

Mind to share (in %) what's your current expenses?


howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 11:08 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 11:00 PM)
If you want to work until retirement, be my guest. No way I am working 12h+ and not compensated well for it.
*

Who said anything about 12h+?

My post was making the point about "balance". I guess you are too inflexible to understand what "balance" means



Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 11:16 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 11:08 PM)
Who said anything about 12h+?

My post was making the point about "balance". I guess you are too inflexible to understand what "balance" means
*
Like I said which job let you have balance and how many are lucky to end up with that kind of job?
If we are not lucky, we need to think of ways out either by
1) quiting the job - no money how to quit?
2) finding a replacement - is not easy to find jobs nowadays?

My job is 12h+ and there are many people who are in the same boat with me. Besides if you have achieve FIRE, you don't need to think about being retrenh when economy is bad as money will still come in. Peace of mind is priceless.

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Jul 3 2018, 11:19 PM
Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 11:17 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 11:01 PM)
Sorry, my bad sweat.gif

Good luck with your journey. It is not easy but it is not impossible.

I believe in order to keep us in-line, we need to have a clear current financial status and target (monthly/annually) that we want to achieve.

Mind to share (in %) what's your current expenses?
*
1st rule in FIRE, know the difference between needs and wants and spend only on the needs
2nd rule of FIRE spend less than what you earn.

Here's a blogger who is closer to us than those mat salleh blogger.
http://singaporeanstocksinvestor.blogspot....ive-income.html
http://singaporeanstocksinvestor.blogspot....s-of-ak71s.html

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Jul 3 2018, 11:22 PM
howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 11:21 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 11:16 PM)
Like I said which job let you have balance and how many are lucky to end up with that kind of job?
If we are not lucky, we need to think of ways out either by
1) quiting the job - no money how to quit?
2) finding a replacement - is not easy to find jobs nowadays?

My job is 12h+ and there are many people who are in the same boat with me.
*

Still don't understand?

My point was don't get flat out to achieve "retirement" as in FIRE, so you can do gardening after "retirement".

Have some balance. You don't undertand still, I cannot provide any more enlightenment.

TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 3 2018, 11:23 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 10:38 PM)
Aiyo, you missed the point.

Of course everybody wants to achieve FI. So that is not the point.

My point is there is a cost. You need to make sacrifices. You either make sacrifices earlier, or you spread it out.
*
Sacrifice early for future happiness, I will go for it.

It is not only about money, it translated to more free time.

More time to help you keep up with long lost family, doing volunteering, traveling, doing part times, etc.

Not everyone loves what they are doing but stay put because of the good package they received. (One type of sacrifice)


Anyway, I respect your input and wish you good luck!



Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 11:24 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 11:21 PM)
Still don't understand?

My point was don't get flat out to achieve "retirement" as in FIRE, so you can do gardening after "retirement".

Have some balance. You don't undertand still, I cannot provide any more enlightenment.
*
Let me give you my example. Working 12h+/day with only one day off/week. Mine working hours are basically about 14h/day How are you going to find balance after work? I am all ears to suggestion.
howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 11:34 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 11:24 PM)
Let me give you my example. Working 12h+/day with only one day off/week. Mine working hours are basically about 14h/day How are you going to find balance after work? I am all ears to suggestion.
*

I was simply saying that there is no clear line before/after that you need to achieve as far as retirement is concerned.

You need to consider what before/after factors are relevant to your way of thinking, and your personal circumstances.

But I would suggest that if you are working 12h+/day, you need to get higher paying jobs which includes getting degrees/diplomas/certificates. With PTPTN, you can get loans and qualifications.

Spend more time on getting a qualification, and less time on forums.

icemanfx
post Jul 3 2018, 11:43 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 07:57 PM)
That 3% figure cannot be correct.

For sure, a lot more people have over USD100k (RM405k) net worth.
*
This 3% number is from a investment bank i.e. independent, is consistent with data from epf.

howszat
post Jul 3 2018, 11:50 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(icemanfx @ Jul 3 2018, 11:43 PM)
This 3% number is from a investment bank i.e. independent, is consistent with data from epf.
*

If you consider the average house price, as well as the number of Mercedes, BMW, Camry, Accords around, and 20k earners, you can see the 3% is too low.

Got a link?

icemanfx
post Jul 3 2018, 11:53 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 11:50 PM)
If you consider the average house price, as well as the number of Mercedes, BMW, Camry, Accords around, and 20k earners, you can see the 3% is too low.

Got a link?
*
Many of these are bought with borrowing, which is reflected in elevated household debt.

Ramjade
post Jul 3 2018, 11:54 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 11:34 PM)
I was simply saying that there is no clear line before/after that you need to achieve as far as retirement is concerned.

You need to consider what before/after factors are relevant to your way of thinking, and your personal circumstances.

But I would suggest that if you are working 12h+/day, you need to get higher paying jobs which includes getting degrees/diplomas/certificates. With PTPTN, you can get loans and qualifications.

Spend more time on getting a qualification, and less time on forums.
*
Actually my job requires a degree. No qualification, can't get in. Well that's what you get for working in Malaysia without proper labour laws. People in other country in the same field works like only 8 hours and get much higher paid.

QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 11:50 PM)
If you consider the average house price, as well as the number of Mercedes, BMW, Camry, Accords around, and 20k earners, you can see the 3% is too low.

Got a link?
*
Agreed. 3% is too low and when was this data publish.
icemanfx
post Jul 4 2018, 12:08 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 3 2018, 11:54 PM)
Actually my job requires a degree. No qualification, can't get in. Well that's what you get for working in Malaysia without proper labour laws. People in other country in the same field works like only 8 hours and get much higher paid.
Agreed. 3% is too low and when was this data publish.
*
Numbers published yearly, about 3% was last year.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Jul 4 2018, 12:09 AM
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 4 2018, 12:11 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


I believe everyone have their own plan post-FIRE.

For myself it is simple. Free time I will dedicate to myself, family and giving back to society.

Pre-FIRE, I’m one of the lucky guy that while saving 50-60% of salary, my family don’t have to live too frugal. Thanks to company that provided me full expat package. Earning USD and spending with lower currency is a good stuffs.

Also back in Malaysia,
- No car loan (settled)
- No Personal Loan
- No PTPTN Loan
- No outstanding on Credit Card

Post- FIRE targeting to live same or slightly below what we are now. Insurance as usual, education fund for kids ready (fully paid property), excess money for charity works & travel oversea at least once a year.

Remember we will have different numbers to achieve FIRE but let it be reasonable and achievable. Most importantly we have free time to choose what we want to do to make us happy and lively.





Showtime747
post Jul 4 2018, 09:40 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
"FIRE" is a scam ! Sorry to burst the bubble for those young ones who posted here....

It's a scam devised by the elderly, society, parents, bosses, including MLM/insurance etc (collectively known as "beneficiaries") so that the beneficiaries can motivate young people to work hard for them

It's a carrot that looks sweet, but eventually if you get it, it is just a normal plain old carrot.

The whole FIRE concept is wrong in the first place. It assumes "work life is shit, and retirement is heaven". For those young people who suffer much while working, it fits perfectly into their true experience. But no, the assumption is not correct.

Have you considered that to be in the heaven, you not only require financial freedom ? To be able to just live day-to-day plain survival life, you will not enjoy life. Meaning if you just watch TV, surf internet, gardening, exercise, (and all those activities that cost very little) which you thought is stress free and enjoyable life, then you will find out soon human beings are species which will get bored easily. Human needs more than food to live happily. Human is also greedy so living with minimum necessity will not make him/her happy.

In other words, human needs a lot of other stuff besides money to be happy. Love, sense of success, recognition, health, to be the best in the field, seeing people around you to be successful and happy......etc etc depending on individuals

Come back to the assumption that "work life is shit, retirement is heaven". If you feel that work is shit, then you are just pushing the blame to the boss. The core problem is not with the work, but your attitude ! The fact is you cannot face stress in your life. Who told you making money and work is easy in the first place ? They are not ! So, if you change your attitude that work is not easy and you have to deal with problems everyday, eventually you will get used to the stress, and work is no more shit. Work and problems are normal phenomenon which happens everyday. You should be happy there are problems for you to solve. Otherwise, you are redundant and have no job !

If there is no problem for one day, that is just a bonus, but entitlement.

If you can get your perspective right, then you will look at the problem as a challenge. If you can overcome any challenge in life, then nothing will make you unhappy.

I don't expect young people to understand and appreciate what I said. Because when I was young, I think like all of you too. But as you experience life when it unfolds, both extreme happy and sad events, you will reach a stage that everyday is a blessing to you. Work or retire has no difference anymore. No more mood difference be it a Monday or Friday. Work is just a small part of your life. There are many more important stuff.

So, don't be influenced by the FIRE concept. It tells you life is a drink which tastes bitter first, sweet later. Is the drink taste all the same for everybody ? Most probably not. What if you find out your drink also taste bitter later ? It will be too late.

If you can ditch the FIRE concept, change your attitude towards life, then you actually start enjoying a nice drink (with all taste of life) for the remaining 50-70 years...





aspartame
post Jul 4 2018, 09:49 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 01:29 PM)
All, there are active communities in oversea that working on FIRE by hard saving, investing and living below our means.
For sure there are also FI or already RE people in here.

Appreciate to share your experience; Pre-FIRE and Post-FIRE life.

Thanks

#I’m working towards FIRE and currently saving/invest 50-60% of my monthly salary. (On top of this around 20-25% spent for commitment like ASB loans and properties).

Before someone asking, I like to make it clear that I'm currently under full expat package which company provide accommodation, transportation and COLA.

BUT AGAIN, I like to hear sharing from all who working towards FIRE so we can learn in term of planning, lifestyle, achievement, obstacles and etc.
*
It is only logical that only a small % of population can achieve FIRE, especially early FIRE. Otherwise, there won't be enough rats running in the treadmill to generate power to sustain the whole society. So, how to become the minority? To do what the majority can't or won't do. Spending is easy. Saving is hard. So, u must do the opposite. Savings is earnings less spending. Do your best to climb up the ladddr to increase earnings. Then, while earnings increase, do not increase spending like most people do. Maintain spending, increase savings. Invest the savings. That's it.

Many aim to achieve FIRE before age 40. Close to impossible unless u live like a monk after that. Why quit when earnings is at its highest? Delay to about 45 to 50 at least would be good. Meantime, I know it sounds contradictory, but u dun want to live like a peasant now. Whatever people enjoy now, u also go for it but less frequently. It's a fine line.. because spending begets more spending. This is where discipline comes in. Otherwise, life is too dull. Why sit at home when u r most youthful. Go for those low expense activities. "You dun want to save up sex for when u r old."..Warran Buffett.
Ramjade
post Jul 4 2018, 10:10 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Jul 4 2018, 09:40 AM)
"FIRE" is a scam ! Sorry to burst the bubble for those young ones who posted here....

It's a scam devised by the elderly, society, parents, bosses, including MLM/insurance etc (collectively known as "beneficiaries") so that the beneficiaries can motivate young people to work hard for them

It's a carrot that looks sweet, but eventually if you get it, it is just a normal plain old carrot.

The whole FIRE concept is wrong in the first place. It assumes "work life is shit, and retirement is heaven". For those young people who suffer much while working, it fits perfectly into their true experience. But no, the assumption is not correct.

Have you considered that to be in the heaven, you not only require financial freedom ? To be able to just live day-to-day plain survival life, you will not enjoy life. Meaning if you just watch TV, surf internet, gardening, exercise, (and all those activities that cost very little) which you thought is stress free and enjoyable life, then you will find out soon human beings are species which will get bored easily. Human needs more than food to live happily. Human is also greedy so living with minimum necessity will not make him/her happy.

In other words, human needs a lot of other stuff besides money to be happy. Love, sense of success, recognition, health, to be the best in the field, seeing people around you to be successful and happy......etc etc depending on individuals

Come back to the assumption that "work life is shit, retirement is heaven". If you feel that work is shit, then you are just pushing the blame to the boss. The core problem is not with the work, but your attitude ! The fact is you cannot face stress in your life. Who told you making money and work is easy in the first place ? They are not ! So, if you change your attitude that work is not easy and you have to deal with problems everyday, eventually you will get used to the stress, and work is no more shit. Work and problems are normal phenomenon which happens everyday. You should be happy there are problems for you to solve. Otherwise, you are redundant and have no job !

If there is no problem for one day, that is just a bonus, but entitlement.

If you can get your perspective right, then you will look at the problem as a challenge. If you can overcome any challenge in life, then nothing will make you unhappy.

I don't expect young people to understand and appreciate what I said. Because when I was young, I think like all of you too. But as you experience life when it unfolds, both extreme happy and sad events, you will reach a stage that everyday is a blessing to you. Work or retire has no difference anymore. No more mood difference be it a Monday or Friday. Work is just a small part of your life. There are many more important stuff.

So, don't be influenced by the FIRE concept. It tells you life is a drink which tastes bitter first, sweet later. Is the drink taste all the same for everybody ? Most probably not. What if you find out your drink also taste bitter later ? It will be too late.

If you can ditch the FIRE concept, change your attitude towards life, then you actually start enjoying a nice drink (with all taste of life) for the remaining 50-70 years...
*
Try me bro. I eat the same food in out on a daily basis (prepared at home). But I never get tired of them. Why? Because
1) I make sure they are nice
2) and all food turns to shit.

For me, nutritional value of the food is better than the taste. Again try me bro. I have the cash to buy the latest gadget, cars, indulge in YOLO lifestyle, go for overseas vocation but I don't. I don't follow the herd mentality of YOLO. I don't need those "wants" nor do I intend or embrace them. I prefer my simple lifestyle. Why do you think my friends look at me one kind when I am talking about FIRE, savings, investing? It's because they are not doing that and don't see the urgency for it. They prefer to "live the moment". They are eagerly awaiting the month's paycheck as
1) their bank account is dry
2) eager to go shopping/indulge in good food/go on expensive vacation.

I look forward to the month's paycheck too but not for the reasons above. I look forward as it's a means to increase my warchest, ready for deployment. biggrin.gif

I don't drink starbucks/dine at fancy restaurants/o high tea/ buffet or buy branded clothes, buy apple products (except their ipad which I am still using to this day - ipad air 2). My clothes are all pasar malam/bundle shops clothes. My sandals cost < RM10/pair and can last a year. My Laptop and my phones last min 5 years. I eat at your regular economy rice stall. So try me bro. biggrin.gif


Businesses will hate people like me as I don't spend. I only spend when is needed.

For me, I like the option to work or not to work rather than force to work.

The concept of FIRE is having the option to work or not to work and not force to work. o need to worry about when the next paycheck is coming in/no need to worry whether you will be retrench.

QUOTE(aspartame @ Jul 4 2018, 09:49 AM)
It is only logical that only a small % of population can achieve FIRE, especially early FIRE. Otherwise, there won't be enough rats running in the treadmill to generate power to sustain the whole society. So, how to become the minority? To do what the majority can't or won't do. Spending is easy. Saving is hard. So, u must do the opposite. Savings is earnings less spending. Do your best to climb up the laddder to increase earnings. Then, while earnings increase, do not increase spending like most people do. Maintain spending, increase savings. Invest the savings. That's it.

Many aim to achieve FIRE before age 40. Close to impossible unless u live like a monk after that. Why quit when earnings is at its highest? Delay to about 45 to 50 at least would be good. Meantime, I know it sounds contradictory, but u dun want to live like a peasant now. Whatever people enjoy now, u also go for it but less frequently. It's a fine line.. because spending begets more spending. This is where discipline comes in. Otherwise, life is too dull. Why sit at home when u r most youthful. Go for those low expense activities. "You dun want to save up sex for when u r old."..Warran Buffett.
*
Agreed. If more and more people get into FIRE, there's nothing to power the economy as consumerism will drop. Again agreed. Never let inflation lifestyle hit you.

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Jul 4 2018, 10:35 AM
cherroy
post Jul 4 2018, 10:33 AM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


I agreed on FI, but not RE.

FI is a good goal to set upon, so that one can escape the rat race.

RE - it sounds glamour for younger generation.

Why it sounds glamour? Because we (or majority youngster) are in rat race, need to work long hours, little time and money to pursuit personal interest due to work commitment etc.
But once you get older enough and accumulate decent wealth aka FI, then the mindset might be change completely.

It is just like 20~30 years ago, eating outside like having dinner at fast food chain, seems like luxury, sound glamour, many people/kids are happy can get a meal at there.

But 30 years later, when majority people earning power increased, then taking fast food everyday is seemed become a non-healthy life by some.

So the view can change, so does on the RE issue.

So work on FI, and forget about RE.

You can't be RE when you don't have FI. Only think on RE when the time arrived.
Personally, I think RE is a bad concept to be introduced especially to youngster. More often I see RE being used/exploited in marketing tool to lure people into something vested interest purpose only.

More effort should be on FI, how to work towards it.



Ramjade
post Jul 4 2018, 10:41 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(cherroy @ Jul 4 2018, 10:33 AM)
I agreed on FI, but not RE.

FI is a good goal to set upon, so that one can escape the rat race.

RE - it sounds glamour for younger generation.

Why it sounds glamour? Because we (or majority youngster) are in rat race, need to work long hours, little time and money to pursuit personal interest due to work commitment etc.
But once you get older enough and accumulate decent wealth aka FI, then the mindset might be change completely.

It is just like 20~30 years ago, eating outside like having dinner at fast food chain, seems like luxury, sound glamour, many people/kids are happy can get a meal at there.

But 30 years later, when majority people earning power increased, then taking fast food everyday is seemed become a non-healthy life by some.

So the view can change, so does on the RE issue.

So work on FI, and forget about RE.

You can't be RE when you don't have FI. Only think on RE when the time arrived.
Personally, I think RE is a bad concept to be introduced especially to youngster. More often I see RE being used/exploited in marketing tool to lure people into something vested interest purpose only.

More effort should be on FI, how to work towards it.
*
I think both is relevant as it let my generations know they have a choice then working paycheck to paycheck. The question is are they willing to take the leap of faith to start their journey towards FIRE.

The question is how many are willing to forgo their current lifestyle? biggrin.gif


cherroy
post Jul 4 2018, 10:48 AM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 4 2018, 10:41 AM)
I think both is relevant as it let my generations know they have a choice then working paycheck to paycheck. The question is are they willing to take the leap of faith to start their journey towards FIRE.

The question is how many are willing to forgo their current lifestyle?  biggrin.gif
*
A lot of time, I see FIRE being used/exploited thoroughly (like selling "dream) in MLMs, or something try to lure investors or recruitment purposes, instead talking about how to achieve FI, or proper personal financial planning. whistling.gif
biggrin.gif

55665566
post Jul 4 2018, 10:50 AM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



Age 25, aim to retire at 45 with RM500k in ASX while pay off all debts and live happily ever after. Why is it impossible?


55665566
post Jul 4 2018, 10:54 AM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



QUOTE(cherroy @ Jul 4 2018, 10:48 AM)
A lot of time, I see FIRE being used/exploited thoroughly (like selling "dream) in MLMs, or something try to lure investors or recruitment purposes, instead talking about how to achieve FI, or proper personal financial planning.  whistling.gif
biggrin.gif
*
Agree. Funny to see youngsters nowadays say want to retire by 30y/o.
Not impossible, but they don't know how much they need to do/sacrifice including face, friend, social life JUST FOR THAT UNSURE RE.

Once, a friend of mine ask me, what will you do if you have RM1mil now?
My 1st answer, do business and retire loh! That is what majority ppl will answer.
but wait, do business doesn't mean you retire. As long as you still need to watch that shop, you're not even near to retire.

My next answer, put 1mil in long term investment that can give at least 4-6% interest per year.
With that, you could have passive income of ~4-5k monthly and retire. Why not?
Jordy
post Jul 4 2018, 11:08 AM

Entrepreneur
Group Icon
Elite
5,626 posts

Joined: Nov 2004
From: Klang, Selangor


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 01:29 PM)
All, there are active communities in oversea that working on FIRE by hard saving, investing and living below our means.
For sure there are also FI or already RE people in here.

Appreciate to share your experience; Pre-FIRE and Post-FIRE life.

Thanks

#I’m working towards FIRE and currently saving/invest 50-60% of my monthly salary. (On top of this around 20-25% spent for commitment like ASB loans and properties).

Before someone asking, I like to make it clear that I'm currently under full expat package which company provide accommodation, transportation and COLA.

BUT AGAIN, I like to hear sharing from all who working towards FIRE so we can learn in term of planning, lifestyle, achievement, obstacles and etc.
*
I would like to join this FIRE community too, as I have been working on it for years. I have joined the workforce for 3 years now since I quit my long stint in entrepreneurship and doing few years of freelance jobs, and I am 33 this year.
Currently in a stable job and being able to save in between 65% - 70% of my NET take home salary (after deduction of EPF/Socso/PCB). I live quite a comfortable lifestyle and providing for my mother. Apart from my employment salary, I have also built up a passive income of approximately 30% of my GROSS salary (which is tax free).

Based on my calculation (barring any unforeseen circumstances and assuming NO increment in savings amount) and a timeframe of 12 years (until I am 45), I should be able to achieve 100% of my current GROSS salary post-FIRE, while maintaining my lifestyle or possibly upgrading my lifestyle to include more travelling if the inflation remains low.
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 4 2018, 11:18 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


I agree that we need to work towards FI first. That will be the hard part.
Then we will have option whether to go for RE or continue working.

I see people misunderstand the concept of RE. It is not completely retire and doing nothing the rest of our life. But rather stop working on what we have to do and start working what we want to do. So, there many things that we can do out there.

Most of the time we see people not willing to give up YOLO attitude and trying to impress other people with what we have.

“We buy things we don't need with money we don't have to impress people we don't like."

Buying luxury things and living YOLO style will not give us permanent happiness.

And I believe can live moderately as same lifestyle while continue to have "happiness" factor in daily life.

I felt sorry for some of my friends which having good paycheck, buying Mercedes/GTR and living hipster kind of lifestyle while do not having an investment other than their own house.

In my industry which is depending much on the Oil Price, having a good financial planning and saving rate and good investment is a must.

During good old days, people especially US guys stock up with new boats and trucks (I guess in Malaysia also same) and when downturn, they are crying when get retrenched.
Thats is 40-50 years old guys. Crying!

-So start early, save and invest wisely to achieve FI, Then we have luxury to choose RE or not-

#I'm not selling anything so there is no taking advantage session here, just sharing.




TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 4 2018, 11:20 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(Jordy @ Jul 4 2018, 11:08 AM)
I would like to join this FIRE community too, as I have been working on it for years. I have joined the workforce for 3 years now since I quit my long stint in entrepreneurship and doing few years of freelance jobs, and I am 33 this year.
Currently in a stable job and being able to save in between 65% - 70% of my NET take home salary (after deduction of EPF/Socso/PCB). I live quite a comfortable lifestyle and providing for my mother. Apart from my employment salary, I have also built up a passive income of approximately 30% of my GROSS salary (which is tax free).

Based on my calculation (barring any unforeseen circumstances and assuming NO increment in savings amount) and a timeframe of 12 years (until I am 45), I should be able to achieve 100% of my current GROSS salary post-FIRE, while maintaining my lifestyle or possibly upgrading my lifestyle to include more travelling if the inflation remains low.
*
rclxms.gif rclxms.gif rclxms.gif

Well Done. Keep sharing your journey. Thanks.
SUSyklooi
post Jul 4 2018, 11:31 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


I achieved FI b4 40 yrs old....
During that time, i planned to open a barber shop....watch astro daily in the shop...chats with friends when they visited me during my barbershop openning hours.....i don't really needed the earning from the barber shop.....bcos i had passive income arranged.
Well that was the plan, then as faith or some called it, prelife planned journies.....i met a girl, went out for few dates......liked itthen continued a few more dates.....as times goes by......got married, got dependents, got new properties, got many more liabilities.......
Now, still have to work ......
My moral of the story is....yes, we can plan, but in the end it is someone higher up there are the arranger of life's journeys.
Who would have known GE14 changed the lives of many FIRE peoples.....

mephyll
post Jul 4 2018, 11:43 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
428 posts

Joined: Sep 2017
QUOTE(55665566 @ Jul 4 2018, 10:54 AM)
Agree. Funny to see youngsters nowadays say want to retire by 30y/o.
Not impossible, but they don't know how much they need to do/sacrifice including face, friend, social life JUST FOR THAT UNSURE RE.

Once, a friend of mine ask me, what will you do if you have RM1mil now?
My 1st answer, do business and retire loh! That is what majority ppl will answer.
but wait, do business doesn't mean you retire. As long as you still need to watch that shop, you're not even near to retire.

My next answer, put 1mil in long term investment that can give at least 4-6% interest per year.
With that, you could have passive income of ~4-5k monthly and retire. Why not?
*
if i could have RM1mil, my answer as per bold above.
looks tired to manage a company..
wongmunkeong
post Jul 4 2018, 11:48 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


Like what Cherroy shared, FI (Financial Independence) is the core component, RE.. hm.. things may change when U reach FI or reaching FI.

During my days, no such acronym, FIRE. Just focused on FI thus have options - option to continue working current job/Co., to change to another Co., to change entirely to another field that is more in-line with one's "purpose", no more "cold sweat middle-of-night awakening" due to monetary worries, etc.

Thus, if RE means freedom of options, FIRE has been around for ages, though known as a different thing smile.gif.

------
Sharing:
1. Financial independence/freedom (FF)
a. Personally, I was supposed to be FF in my 40s (now late 40s) but life happens - divorce, complicated birth, children, etc. Now, pushing it back to 50s to ensure children's education option.

b. I know the numbers needed - looks scary at first but do-able as we keep our focus, live below means (also good for planet, less destruction/wastage) & keep on growing investment assets.

c. I save 100% of my investment returns + at least 20% of my net income (excluding EPF/CPF), + IF there's bonus, >=50% is saved for investments & remaining is gifted & used for "feel good".

2. Man-at-work Vs Man-avoiding-work
Maybe i'm lucky, i enjoy what i do +i get paid well enough to be able to save & invest. Not many enjoy what they do, thus they just focus on "getting out" - which should not be the case. If U do not like the Co., then move. If U do not like your field, then learn other fields while working - suffer the 80% to get to the 20% of cheese/dream.

3. Ignore the noise
Be CRYSTAL CLEAR on what U want, ignore others - it's your life. When you're crystal, U literally just smile at "others' good intention/advice" - they aren't U, they can say/feel/opine whatever.

Just like Ramjade, loads of friends/colleagues/relatives will say things like:
a. What - U eating that again? Every day, how can U tahan?
b. Why U buy local car lar - U can afford ****
c. Eh, buy together lar holiday home - together gether cheaper, worth it la..
etc.
BTW, most of these folks.. they are the ones complaining not enough $ lar, blame employer for not paying earlier during Raya/CNY/Christmas la, blame Gov for too much tax lar, this lar, that lar tongue.gif

Also, most of these folks are either overweight or not able to do body-weight excercises - telling me to eat better tongue.gif

Apologies for the wall of text - just sharing my FIDO (Financial Independence, Doing Options) for U to convert to better FIRE.
hoimangkuk
post Jul 4 2018, 12:28 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
214 posts

Joined: Jul 2006
From: from the country that only know complaining


I think a lot doesnt understand the RE concept...

RE - retired early from being a kuli, then pursue whatever work that you like, without having to think about basic income for survival...

like being an artist or innovator...
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 4 2018, 12:35 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(yklooi @ Jul 4 2018, 11:31 AM)
I achieved FI b4 40 yrs old....
During that time, i planned to open a barber shop....watch astro daily in the shop...chats with friends when they visited me during my barbershop openning hours.....i don't really needed the earning from the barber shop.....bcos i had passive income arranged.
Well that was the plan, then as faith or some called it, prelife planned journies.....i met a girl, went out for few dates......liked itthen continued a few more dates.....as times goes by......got married, got dependents, got new properties, got many more liabilities.......
Now, still have to work ......
My moral of the story is....yes, we can plan, but in the end it is someone higher up there are the arranger of life's journeys.
Who would have known GE14 changed the lives of many FIRE peoples.....
*
Thank you for sharing this.

like people said "Fail to plan is planning for failure".

So I guess it is better to have a plan and work with that plan and adjust accordingly.

Anything beyond our control we cannot do anything.

Also, in planning always factored in contingency or safety margin to cover as best as we can things that we not expected.

TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 4 2018, 12:38 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(wongmunkeong @ Jul 4 2018, 11:48 AM)
Like what Cherroy shared, FI (Financial Independence) is the core component, RE.. hm.. things may change when U reach FI or reaching FI.

During my days, no such acronym, FIRE. Just focused on FI thus have options - option to continue working current job/Co., to change to another Co., to change entirely to another field that is more in-line with one's "purpose", no more "cold sweat middle-of-night awakening" due to monetary worries, etc.

Thus, if RE means freedom of options, FIRE has been around for ages, though known as a different thing smile.gif.

------
Sharing:
1. Financial independence/freedom (FF)
a. Personally, I was supposed to be FF in my 40s (now late 40s) but life happens - divorce, complicated birth, children, etc. Now, pushing it back to 50s to ensure children's education option.

b. I know the numbers needed - looks scary at first but do-able as we keep our focus, live below means (also good for planet, less destruction/wastage) & keep on growing investment assets.

c. I save 100% of my investment returns + at least 20% of my net income (excluding EPF/CPF), + IF there's bonus, >=50% is saved for investments & remaining is gifted & used for "feel good".

2. Man-at-work Vs Man-avoiding-work
Maybe i'm lucky, i enjoy what i do +i get paid well enough to be able to save & invest. Not many enjoy what they do, thus they just focus on "getting out" - which should not be the case. If U do not like the Co., then move. If U do not like your field, then learn other fields while working - suffer the 80% to get to the 20% of cheese/dream.

3. Ignore the noise
Be CRYSTAL CLEAR on what U want, ignore others - it's your life. When you're crystal, U literally just smile at "others' good intention/advice" - they aren't U, they can say/feel/opine whatever.

Just like Ramjade, loads of friends/colleagues/relatives will say things like:
a. What - U eating that again? Every day, how can U tahan?
b. Why U buy local car lar - U can afford ****
c. Eh, buy together lar holiday home - together gether cheaper, worth it la..
etc.
BTW, most of these folks.. they are the ones complaining not enough $ lar, blame employer for not paying earlier during Raya/CNY/Christmas la, blame Gov for too much tax lar, this lar, that lar tongue.gif

Also, most of these folks are either overweight or not able to do body-weight excercises - telling me to eat better tongue.gif

Apologies for the wall of text - just sharing my FIDO (Financial Independence, Doing Options) for U to convert to better FIRE.
*
Exactly.

Priority work towards FI and choose on RE later.

RE is still relevant just its up to individual to choose and live their post-FIRE.

TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 4 2018, 12:39 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(hoimangkuk @ Jul 4 2018, 12:28 PM)
I think a lot doesnt understand the RE concept...

RE - retired early from being a kuli, then pursue whatever work that you like, without having to think about basic income for survival...

like being an artist or innovator...
*
Exactly!
rapple
post Jul 4 2018, 01:05 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 4 2018, 12:39 PM)
Exactly!
*
You know, you don't need to reply individually every single post. You can multi quote.

I don't see myself retiring unless I'm force to retired.

My aim is to quit my job and work on my freelance.

For now my job salary ratio to my freelance income is 1 : 0.75, my aim is to reach 1 : 3 before i can really commit quitting my work.

Still long way to go.




kingz113
post Jul 4 2018, 01:07 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
323 posts

Joined: Jul 2006


reposting.

This post has been edited by kingz113: Jul 5 2018, 09:04 PM
SUSyklooi
post Jul 4 2018, 01:37 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 4 2018, 12:35 PM)
Thank you for sharing this.

like people said "Fail to plan is planning for failure".

So I guess it is better to have a plan and work with that plan and adjust accordingly.

Anything beyond our control we cannot do anything.

Also, in planning always factored in contingency or safety margin to cover as best as we can things that we not expected.
*
what ever it is,....have a little plan, NOT overly focused on THE Plan...
else, one may missed the meaning of being alive in this world.

Plan is a must, just don't overly focused on it.....

wise words to ponder about indeed...
QUOTE(aspartame @ Jul 4 2018, 09:49 AM)
......
"You dun want to save up sex for when u r old."..Warran Buffett.
*
QUOTE(howszat @ Jul 3 2018, 11:08 PM)
......
My post was making the point about "balance". I guess you are too inflexible to understand what "balance" means
*
i liked this.....
“Suppose your monthly income is only 2,000, you can live well.
I can help you put money into five sets of funds.
The first $600, second $400, third $300, fourth $200, fifth $500.”
for more,..read this...
Asia’s Richest Man “Li Ka-Shing” Shares Advice For Young Entrepreneurs
https://addicted2success.com/success-advice...-entrepreneurs/

This post has been edited by yklooi: Jul 4 2018, 01:37 PM
icemanfx
post Jul 4 2018, 02:51 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


In economics, the more people try to achieve financial independent, the more difficult it will get.

Most if not all passive income is from someone who worked e.g rental, interest, dividend, etc payment.

If many achieved financial independent, could the remaining working population sustain? Shrinking work force will cause wages inflation, drop in demand or both that diminish passive income.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Jul 4 2018, 02:56 PM
Showtime747
post Jul 4 2018, 03:46 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 4 2018, 10:10 AM)
Try me bro. I eat the same food in out on a daily basis (prepared at home). But I never get tired of them. Why? Because
1) I make sure they are nice
2) and all food turns to shit.

For me, nutritional value of the food is better than the taste. Again try me bro. I have the cash to buy the latest gadget, cars, indulge in YOLO lifestyle, go for overseas vocation but I don't. I don't follow the herd mentality of YOLO. I don't need those "wants" nor do I intend or embrace them. I prefer my simple lifestyle. Why do you think my friends look at me one kind when I am talking about FIRE, savings, investing? It's because they are not doing that and don't see the urgency for it. They prefer to "live the moment". They are eagerly awaiting the month's paycheck as
1) their bank account is dry
2) eager to go shopping/indulge in good food/go on expensive vacation.

I look forward to the month's paycheck too but not for the reasons above. I look forward as it's a means to increase my warchest, ready for deployment.  biggrin.gif

I don't drink starbucks/dine at fancy restaurants/o high tea/ buffet or buy branded clothes, buy apple products (except their ipad which I am still using to this day - ipad air 2). My clothes are all pasar malam/bundle shops clothes. My sandals cost < RM10/pair and can last a year. My Laptop and my phones last min 5 years. I eat at your regular economy rice stall. So try me bro.  biggrin.gif
Businesses will hate people like me as I don't spend. I only spend when is needed.

For me, I like the option to work or not to work rather than force to work.

The concept of FIRE is having the option to work or not to work and not force to work. o need to worry about when the next paycheck is coming in/no need to worry whether you will be retrench.

*
My main point is not about nutritional food, YOLO, business people hates a miser.... etc

I'll explain again. My point is very simple :

1. FIRE concept implies that work is shit. That's why you strive for financial freedom and retirement early (ie don't need to work)
2. If work is not shit, but an enjoyable adventure you do everyday, then the FIRE concept is not needed anymore

Agree ?

To give you an analogy :

3. Those who believe in FIRE is similar to treating their job as a prostitute.
4. They feel that they get fxxked everyday in the job to make money
5. That's why they want to end their working life as early as possible

My point is :

6. If you treat your job as a gigolo instead, your job is instead fxxk other people and get paid
7. You help solve other people's problem by satisfying them
8. And you get paid along the way

Of course, it is just an analogy (I am assuming being fxxked is bad, and fxxk other people is good. This may not be true in real life)


Yes. It is hard to swallow, but the fact is those who believe in FIRE concept deep down is thinking they are "prostitute". They can't wait to retire.

The challenge is how to turn it around and become a "gigolo" instead

If your everyday work is to orgasm, your client/boss treat you like a god and get paid at the same time, who want to retire ?






Ramjade
post Jul 4 2018, 03:56 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Jul 4 2018, 03:46 PM)
My main point is not about nutritional food, YOLO, business people hates a miser.... etc

I'll explain again. My point is very simple :

1. FIRE concept implies that work is shit. That's why you strive for financial freedom and retirement early (ie don't need to work)
2. If work is not shit, but an enjoyable adventure you do everyday, then the FIRE concept is not needed anymore

Agree ?

To give you an analogy :

3. Those who believe in FIRE is similar to treating their job as a prostitute.
4. They feel that they get fxxked everyday in the job to make money
5. That's why they want to end their working life as early as possible

My point is :

6. If you treat your job as a gigolo instead, your job is instead fxxk other people and get paid
7. You help solve other people's problem by satisfying them
8. And you get paid along the way

Of course, it is just an analogy (I am assuming being fxxked is bad, and fxxk other people is good. This may not be true in real life)
Yes. It is hard to swallow, but the fact is those who believe in FIRE concept deep down is thinking they are "prostitute". They can't wait to retire.

The challenge is how to turn it around and become a "gigolo" instead

If your everyday work is to orgasm, your client/boss treat you like a god and get paid at the same time, who want to retire ?
*
Couldn't agree more with your analogy tongue.gif tongue.gif but how many lucky enough to lend a job they like? Majority need a job to put food on the table. So they force to take any job which comes their way.


But you are forgetting one thing, majority people my age don't save, don't invest and live paycheck to paycheck. They prefer to live the moment. Well is just going to backfire on them in the future.
wongmunkeong
post Jul 4 2018, 03:57 PM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Jul 4 2018, 03:46 PM)
--SNIP--
..
..
Of course, it is just an analogy (I am assuming being fxxked is bad, and fxxk other people is good. This may not be true in real life)
Yes. It is hard to swallow, but the fact is those who believe in FIRE concept deep down is thinking they are "prostitute". They can't wait to retire.

The challenge is how to turn it around and become a "gigolo" instead

If your everyday work is to orgasm, your client/boss treat you like a god and get paid at the same time, who want to retire ?
*
good lord, i nearly choked on my drink when i read these laugh.gif

This post has been edited by wongmunkeong: Jul 4 2018, 03:59 PM
55665566
post Jul 4 2018, 04:35 PM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Jul 4 2018, 03:46 PM)
My main point is not about nutritional food, YOLO, business people hates a miser.... etc

I'll explain again. My point is very simple :

1. FIRE concept implies that work is shit. That's why you strive for financial freedom and retirement early (ie don't need to work)
2. If work is not shit, but an enjoyable adventure you do everyday, then the FIRE concept is not needed anymore

Agree ?

To give you an analogy :

3. Those who believe in FIRE is similar to treating their job as a prostitute.
4. They feel that they get fxxked everyday in the job to make money
5. That's why they want to end their working life as early as possible

My point is :

6. If you treat your job as a gigolo instead, your job is instead fxxk other people and get paid
7. You help solve other people's problem by satisfying them
8. And you get paid along the way

Of course, it is just an analogy (I am assuming being fxxked is bad, and fxxk other people is good. This may not be true in real life)
Yes. It is hard to swallow, but the fact is those who believe in FIRE concept deep down is thinking they are "prostitute". They can't wait to retire.

The challenge is how to turn it around and become a "gigolo" instead

If your everyday work is to orgasm, your client/boss treat you like a god and get paid at the same time, who want to retire ?
*
doh.gif I like the analogy so much until my boss saw me smiling like donkey on the screen.
Gigolo vs Prostitute, thumbup.gif
NightHeart
post Jul 4 2018, 05:57 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
FIRE is just a sugar coated excuse or reason or justification for people to go through hardship at work. A carrot or a dream dangled in front of people for them to go through the present moment with a hope of a much better future.

Some calls it scam cause it's a long journey, 10 - 20 years down the road. A lot of things can & will happen in between. You may or may not obtain the carrot/dream or perhaps you may partially achieve what you wanted. Nevertheless, it's still a good motivation tool for people who are still headless chickens at work.

As mentioned by others already, the key is to strike a balance between FIRE & YOLO. Those are 2 extremes has been around since ancient time. It's probably known as something else back then & most likely be called something else in the future. So find your balance or your middle path between the 2 extremes. Everyone's middle path is different, there's no 1 single middle path for all. So those who are more tilted towards FIRE, stop imposing your ideals/beliefs onto those who are more tilted towards YOLO. Same goes to those who are more tilted towards YOLO, don't pressure those who are more tilted towards FIRE. Everyone's different.

For those who complain job sucks, boss sucks, client sucks, work sucks, I'm unlucky, s/he is fortunate etc etc. Learn to seek for answers within rather than blaming everyone & everything else. More often than not, the solution is within - just need to look & work on it.
Showtime747
post Jul 4 2018, 10:22 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 4 2018, 03:56 PM)
Couldn't agree more with your analogy tongue.gif tongue.gif but how many lucky enough to lend a job they like? Majority need a job to put food on the table. So they force to take any job which comes their way.
You are looking everything from your own tunnel of vision, and assuming the world is as what you see

From my experience of almost 40 years of working life, I have encountered many types of colleague, staff, bosses...from high level to low level.

There are a very wide spread of characters and their approach towards their job.

Some are really passionate about what they do. While some characters are hopeless. They are unhappy no matter what they do

Proactive, pragmatic, positive, hardworking, easy going, responsible, strong leadership are some common characters which make a person a happy worker who can excel in their career. These are the "gigolo" type of workers



QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 4 2018, 03:56 PM)
But you are forgetting one thing,  majority people my age don't save,  don't invest and live paycheck to paycheck. They prefer to live the moment. Well is just going to backfire on them in the future.
*
From day 1 I have already mentioned this to you in stock market forum :

Wealth is not accumulated through cost savings. It is accumulated through how you expand your income

Cost saving can only allow you to reach a certain level. To go beyond that, you must know how to make money


Showtime747
post Jul 4 2018, 10:24 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(wongmunkeong @ Jul 4 2018, 03:57 PM)
good lord, i nearly choked on my drink when i read these  laugh.gif
*
QUOTE(55665566 @ Jul 4 2018, 04:35 PM)
doh.gif I like the analogy so much until my boss saw me smiling like donkey on the screen.
Gigolo vs Prostitute,  thumbup.gif
*
biggrin.gif biggrin.gif biggrin.gif
jimmyng
post Jul 4 2018, 10:33 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
221 posts

Joined: May 2017
From: Negeri Sembilan


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Jul 4 2018, 10:22 PM)
You are looking everything from your own tunnel of vision, and assuming the world is as what you see

From my experience of almost 40 years of working life, I have encountered many types of colleague, staff, bosses...from high level to low level.

There are a very wide spread of characters and their approach towards their job.

Some are really passionate about what they do. While some characters are hopeless. They are unhappy no matter what they do

Proactive, pragmatic, positive, hardworking, easy going, responsible, strong leadership are some common characters which make a person a happy worker who can excel in their career. These are the "gigolo" type of workers
From day 1 I have already mentioned this to you in stock market forum :

Wealth is not accumulated through cost savings. It is accumulated through how you expand your income

Cost saving can only allow you to reach a certain level. To go beyond that, you must know how to make money
*
Yup, agree with you.
You need to use some of your savings to buy assets and get rid of those liabilities
Ramjade
post Jul 5 2018, 07:39 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Jul 4 2018, 10:22 PM)
You are looking everything from your own tunnel of vision, and assuming the world is as what you see

From my experience of almost 40 years of working life, I have encountered many types of colleague, staff, bosses...from high level to low level.

There are a very wide spread of characters and their approach towards their job.

Some are really passionate about what they do. While some characters are hopeless. They are unhappy no matter what they do

Proactive, pragmatic, positive, hardworking, easy going, responsible, strong leadership are some common characters which make a person a happy worker who can excel in their career. These are the "gigolo" type of workers
From day 1 I have already mentioned this to you in stock market forum :

Wealth is not accumulated through cost savings. It is accumulated through how you expand your income

Cost saving can only allow you to reach a certain level. To go beyond that, you must know how to make money
*
Actually both are important.
https://stestocksinvestingjourney.blogspot....f-dividend.html
https://stestocksinvestingjourney.blogspot....-of-saving.html

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Jul 5 2018, 07:40 AM
ketupatlazat
post Jul 5 2018, 10:39 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
555 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
From: Bolehland
I like the FI concept but not RE.

Retiring early at 40s seems a little silly when earnings potential is at its peek, as well as commitments - vacations, occational outings to nice places, trust/education funds for kids, probably a bigger house since kids have grown in size hence need more space etc. My belief is that do not shortchange you family when you have the ability to do so. Relying totally on passive/investment income to fund these things would be a bit of a stretch, unless we talkin about having an 8-figure pool already

On FI, I prefer the middle ground - struggle a little for now, hit a target, then I can cruise a little afterwards - by this I mean maximizing the 200k limit on both ASB and ASB2 accounts (via cold hard cash savings, not by financing) by 30 yrs old, and just let the interests compound to an aggregate of RM2/3mil by age 55/60, which I hope could provide a 100% passive net inc of 12/16k every month

So by 30 yrs old, I would know that I had provided a solid cushion on my retirement, and I also have EPF to support as well. Spouse portion is another extra too.

After hitting that goal by 30 then I can lax a lil bit more, increase my spending more here n there. Perhaps I'll finally go for equities to increase my risk exposure

But if life happens that requires me to withdraw those principals then that's another story



TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 5 2018, 12:00 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(ketupatlazat @ Jul 5 2018, 10:39 AM)
I like the FI concept but not RE.

Retiring early at 40s seems a little silly when earnings potential is at its peek, as well as commitments - vacations, occational outings to nice places, trust/education funds for kids, probably a bigger house since kids have grown in size hence need more space etc. My belief is that do not shortchange you family when you have the ability to do so. Relying totally on passive/investment income to fund these things would be a bit of a stretch, unless we talkin about having an 8-figure pool already

On FI, I prefer the middle ground - struggle a little for now, hit a target, then I can cruise a little afterwards - by this I mean maximizing the 200k limit on both ASB and ASB2 accounts (via cold hard cash savings, not by financing) by 30 yrs old, and just let the interests compound to an aggregate of RM2/3mil by age 55/60, which I hope could provide a 100% passive net inc of 12/16k every month

So by 30 yrs old, I would know that I had provided a solid cushion on my retirement, and I also have EPF to support as well. Spouse portion is another extra too.

After hitting that goal by 30 then I can lax a lil bit more, increase my spending more here n there. Perhaps I'll finally go for equities to increase my risk exposure

But if life happens that requires me to withdraw those principals then that's another story
*
Thanks for sharing. good you have your own plan.
Can you share what is your total saving rate monthly (%)?

Thanks.
mephyll
post Jul 5 2018, 03:03 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
428 posts

Joined: Sep 2017
been follow this topic few days...
read most of the posts..

What i found myself is
before married, easily can hit FI since saving is easily 50% of my salary... no commitment at all except food and fun.
(which age to meet, i not really count)

after married, still ok, saving still in good performance, acceptable.

after got kids, FI is too far for me to achieve. dont even to think about RE.
Saving left 17% per month.

what can be done now is compound my previous saving learn to go for some investment + save the 17% every month

what my opinion is, FI/ FIRE is so challenge for those who have family.
so, start your financial planning as young as you can.
ketupatlazat
post Jul 5 2018, 04:14 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
555 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
From: Bolehland
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 5 2018, 12:00 PM)
Thanks for sharing. good you have your own plan.
Can you share what is your total saving rate monthly (%)?

Thanks.
*
close to 50% of nett, with 1 roof to pay and extra 2 mouths to feed
petirbuas
post Jul 9 2018, 06:56 PM

( 。◕ ‿‿ ◕。)
*****
Senior Member
898 posts

Joined: Dec 2009
From: The Internet



Argument against FIRE(on finding the balance) does echo with most people out there.
Many didn't quite understand the RI part. Its not about being lazy bump, but rather freedom to do what we want without worrying about money.
Manipulative bosses? resign
Tired of working? just take few years off
Ugly coworker? quit

I used to save half of my salary for few years. Currently only 15% due to personal circumstances.
My immediate target, is at least 40% saving so I may retire comfortably in 15 years.

My only worry is, to get my wife onboard. She's younger and easily swayed by all those hipster food and travel . I blame instagram lol


Early Retirement Calculator: https://networthify.com/calculator/earlyretirement
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 9 2018, 07:27 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(petirbuas @ Jul 9 2018, 06:56 PM)
Argument against FIRE(on finding the balance) does echo with most people out there.
Many didn't quite understand the RI part. Its not about being lazy bump, but rather freedom to do what we want without worrying about money.
Manipulative bosses? resign
Tired of working? just take few years off
Ugly coworker? quit

I used to save half of my salary for few years. Currently only 15% due to personal circumstances.
My immediate target, is at least 40% saving so I may retire comfortably in 15 years.

My only worry is, to get my wife onboard. She's younger and easily swayed by all those hipster food and travel . I blame instagram lol
Early Retirement Calculator: https://networthify.com/calculator/earlyretirement
*
Agreed and thanks for your input. Exactly wife is one of the inportant elements in getting in line with FI/RE targets.

*there a lot of personal shopper out there that makes them easily spend on unnecessary stuffs*


TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 11 2018, 01:14 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 3 2018, 01:29 PM)
All, there are active communities in oversea that working on FI/RE by hard saving, investing and living below our means.
For sure there are also FI or already RE people in here.

Appreciate to share your experience; Pre-FI/RE and Post-FI/RE life.

Thanks

#I’m working towards FI/RE and currently saving/invest 50-60% of my monthly salary. (On top of this around 20-25% spent for commitment like ASB loans and properties).
I like to hear sharing from all who working towards FI/RE so we can learn in term of planning, lifestyle, achievement, obstacles and etc.

-Update-

FI/FF is the priority that we need to work on - planning, executions, monitoring and improvement

RE - Decision is yours once achieved FI/FF

______
*
I tendered my resignation this week and leaving my MYR500,000/annum salary and MYR100,000/annum cash incentive plus company share. smile.gif

Now in process of repatriate back to Malaysia.

It is hard decision but I believe that I’m ready to let it go and move on to next chapter.

I will share from time to time whether this works or not.

Next plan, back to KL and waiting for my shipment.

- Go for family trip locally
- Visiting long lost relatives and friends
- Back to focus on renovating newly VP house (will get 2 houses this year)
- Will living with dividen from ASNB (maxed up 4 accounts/asb&asb2 - combination cash and loan) and have some funds in ASW,ASD,ASM,AS1M
- Most of the properties paid the installment from rental. (Monthly income from rental ~10,000)
- Withdraw some funds from company saving plans.
- Will be learning new stuffs
- Join volunteering programs

I wish we all have a quality life ahead.
mephyll
post Jul 11 2018, 02:22 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
428 posts

Joined: Sep 2017
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 11 2018, 01:14 PM)
I tendered my resignation this week and leaving my MYR500,000/annum salary and MYR100,000/annum cash incentive plus company share.  smile.gif

Now in process of repatriate back to Malaysia.

It is hard decision but I believe that I’m ready to let it go and move on to next chapter.

I will share from time to time whether this works or not.

Next plan, back to KL and waiting for my shipment.

- Go for family trip locally
- Visiting long lost relatives and friends
- Back to focus on renovating newly VP house (will get 2 houses this year)
- Will living with dividen from ASNB (maxed up 4 accounts/asb&asb2 - combination cash and loan) and have some funds in ASW,ASD,ASM,AS1M
- Most of the properties paid the installment from rental. (Monthly income from rental ~10,000)
- Withdraw some funds from company saving plans.
- Will be learning new stuffs
- Join volunteering programs

I wish we all have a quality life ahead.
*
cool and inspiring..
what i learn from your post is.... saving as young as possible + compound interest from saving.
R93
post Jul 14 2018, 04:12 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
34 posts

Joined: Jul 2018
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 11 2018, 01:14 PM)
I tendered my resignation this week and leaving my MYR500,000/annum salary and MYR100,000/annum cash incentive plus company share.  smile.gif

Now in process of repatriate back to Malaysia.

It is hard decision but I believe that I’m ready to let it go and move on to next chapter.

I will share from time to time whether this works or not.

Next plan, back to KL and waiting for my shipment.

- Go for family trip locally
- Visiting long lost relatives and friends
- Back to focus on renovating newly VP house (will get 2 houses this year)
- Will living with dividen from ASNB (maxed up 4 accounts/asb&asb2 - combination cash and loan) and have some funds in ASW,ASD,ASM,AS1M
- Most of the properties paid the installment from rental. (Monthly income from rental ~10,000)
- Withdraw some funds from company saving plans.
- Will be learning new stuffs
- Join volunteering programs

I wish we all have a quality life ahead.
*
Congratulation to your move, which country are you working now? I wish my day will come soon whistling.gif whistling.gif
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 14 2018, 06:28 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(mephyll @ Jul 11 2018, 02:22 PM)
cool and inspiring..
what i learn from your post is.... saving as young as possible + compound interest from saving.
*
Yes and also have a good equity in investment (property). I may not able to cover expenses for the rest of my life with current cash but I always have option to dispose one or two of my properties in case I need lifeline. Current property portfolio is almost MYR6mil.


QUOTE(R93 @ Jul 14 2018, 04:12 AM)
Congratulation to your move, which country are you working now? I wish my day will come soon  whistling.gif  whistling.gif
*
Indonesia. I wish you goodluck.
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 14 2018, 08:11 AM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
this thread is alive...

share my opinion here.

the only way can fire is that inheritance.

some people I know they got rental yield 8% pa from 2 assets.

besides he is a doctor abroad.

seriously can consider retire. but 3 kids arrive. fire is doable but will be very tight. so he just cont the job done is a good stable paying job in abroad. compared to Malaysia.
lots cash but no investment thinking. I so eager to tell him to invest. but will eventually make me like want to con his money. leave him la lol

another people I know also rich fag kid. family business control 1 districts fnn bernas calsberg distribution.
got 3 males including him. too bad he never realized the 2 elder brother are toying him spoiling him. no study whatever. just hang here and there. parents also give up on him. can't imagine the drama saga incoming. I know his mother want him to be successor. lol. the 2 elder brother outsmart the mother.

a lot story want to share.

fire is doable. if you got the right way right mid right time to do it.
toiletwater
post Jul 14 2018, 09:14 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
531 posts

Joined: Mar 2012


This is also my desire~~ but I am less ambitious, I only want to retire right before the age of 50.

My strategy is a simple lifestyle and a booglehead style of investing (in low-cost index ETFs) and hopefully some great property deals.

Kena burnt by a few local mutual funds and local stock trading already. Now, I only buy really solid stockpicks, but gosh, they move so slow. Still learning

Planning to have kids next year, not sure how much that will impact my finances.
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 15 2018, 07:12 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 14 2018, 08:11 AM)
this thread is alive...

share my opinion here.

the only way can fire is that inheritance.

a lot story want to share.

fire is doable. if you got the right way right mind right time to do it.
*
Thanks for sharing the stories.
I believe inheritance NOT the only way to achieve FI/RE.

As you said at the end “fire is doable. if you got the right way right mind right time to do it.”

I didn’t come from a rich family but I’m lucky to land a good jobs with good packages. But my awareness also didn’t come until I relocated to oversea. Before that, I like most people who enjoyed spending on things that not necessary. i.e karaoke, high installment car etc.

Living in a small village in South America and balance working/living culture made me and family really enjoy saving the money.

QUOTE(toiletwater @ Jul 14 2018, 09:14 AM)
This is also my desire~~ but I am less ambitious, I only want to retire right before the age of 50.

My strategy is a simple lifestyle and a booglehead style of investing (in low-cost index ETFs) and hopefully some great property deals.

Kena burnt by a few local mutual funds and local stock trading already. Now, I only buy really solid stockpicks, but gosh, they move so slow. Still learning

Planning to have kids next year, not sure how much that will impact my finances.
*
Goodluck with your journey.

Maybe you can diversify some into ASNB fixed funds.

My personal opinion, mutual funds always make the agent (or so called financial consultant) rich before you.

LoTek
post Jul 15 2018, 09:27 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
To inspire those who don't work overseas...and prove the naysayers (like my older relatives) who keep saying a job overseas is the only way to make it in life...I believe its possible to achieve goals early even for those working locally. Its all about controlling your lifestyle. I've built up a property portfolio in the 7 figures with an average yield of 6%, with a net worth also of 7 figures, and have never been based out of KL for longer than a few weeks at a time.

Fyi I have been in the workforce for 5 years and am in my mid 20s. No, I did not receive any boosts from my parents not even for studies (full scholarship with allowance) and they did not assist me in any way for any of my properties except that I stay under their roof and receive some moral support and family love.

To consistently invest 70-80% of income, may not sound easy but just ask yourself if you really need to drive that Jap or Continental car around in the traffic mess of KL? (I drive a fully paid off local vehicle and am frequent Mrt/Lrt user) Do you need to go on cafe-hops...? Why not just stick to one? Do you need a starbucks every morning? Make your own! Do you really need to have your entertainment outside? Have house parties with duty free booze. Is it a must to watch latest movies every other day? Go torrent or iflix or something. The list goes on...

This post has been edited by LoTek: Jul 15 2018, 09:30 AM
MUM
post Jul 15 2018, 09:39 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 09:27 AM)
To inspire those who don't work overseas...and prove the naysayers (like my older relatives) who keep saying a job overseas is the only way to make it in life...I believe its possible to achieve goals early even for those working locally. Its all about controlling your lifestyle. I've built up a property portfolio in the 7 figures with an average yield of 6%, with a net worth also of 7 figures, and have never been based out of KL for longer than a few weeks at a time.

Fyi I have been in the workforce for 5 years and am in my mid 20s. No, I did not receive any boosts from my parents not even for studies (full scholarship with allowance) and they did not assist me in any way for any of my properties except that I stay under their roof and receive some moral support and family love.

To consistently invest 70-80% of income, may not sound easy but just ask yourself if you really need to drive that Jap or Continental car around in the traffic mess of KL? (I drive a fully paid off local vehicle and am frequent Mrt/Lrt user) Do you need to go on cafe-hops...? Why not just stick to one? Do you need a starbucks every morning? Make your own! Do you really need to have your entertainment outside? Have house parties with duty free booze. Is it a must to watch latest movies every other day? Go torrent or iflix or something. The list goes on...
*
hmm.gif What are the total cumulative % of these ("lifestyle expenses") are/will be in relation to your income?

wtih your investment experience in properties...what do you advise newbies that intent to follow you footsteps in the current properties environment?

55665566
post Jul 15 2018, 09:39 AM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 09:27 AM)
To inspire those who don't work overseas...and prove the naysayers (like my older relatives) who keep saying a job overseas is the only way to make it in life...I believe its possible to achieve goals early even for those working locally. Its all about controlling your lifestyle. I've built up a property portfolio in the 7 figures with an average yield of 6%, with a net worth also of 7 figures, and have never been based out of KL for longer than a few weeks at a time.

Fyi I have been in the workforce for 5 years and am in my mid 20s. No, I did not receive any boosts from my parents not even for studies (full scholarship with allowance) and they did not assist me in any way for any of my properties except that I stay under their roof and receive some moral support and family love.

To consistently invest 70-80% of income, may not sound easy but just ask yourself if you really need to drive that Jap or Continental car around in the traffic mess of KL? (I drive a fully paid off local vehicle and am frequent Mrt/Lrt user) Do you need to go on cafe-hops...? Why not just stick to one? Do you need a starbucks every morning? Make your own! Do you really need to have your entertainment outside? Have house parties with duty free booze. Is it a must to watch latest movies every other day? Go torrent or iflix or something. The list goes on...
*
7 figures nett worth in mid 20 is brilliant, but I doubt so.
Assuming you are JPA student (full loan + allowances), working as director in listed company. That still doesn't give you sufficient income to let you generate that much of nett worth in within 5 years. Or maybe I misunderstood your 'nett worth' definition?

MUM
post Jul 15 2018, 09:47 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

deleted...

This post has been edited by MUM: Jul 15 2018, 09:59 AM
LoTek
post Jul 15 2018, 10:00 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 15 2018, 09:39 AM)
hmm.gif What are the total cumulative % of these ("lifestyle expenses") are/will be in relation to your income?

wtih your investment experience in properties...what do you advise newbies that intent to follow you footsteps in the current properties environment?
*
Invest/save about 70-80% of income. So the other 20-30% is for my indulgences.

I personally think property market now is in limbo, it's neither up nor down, and generally with terrible yields. Have to shop for months for each property, I usually view more than 10 units in a development before making offers. I like to concentrate only on high yield student rentals or Airbnb now. Oh yes, please don't buy from developer, 99% chance that you'll never make money fast enough to even meet FD rate. Burnt once already.

QUOTE(55665566 @ Jul 15 2018, 09:39 AM)
7 figures nett worth in mid 20 is brilliant, but I doubt so.
Assuming you are JPA student (full loan + allowances), working as director in listed company. That still doesn't give you sufficient income to let you generate that much of nett worth in within 5 years. Or maybe I misunderstood your 'nett worth' definition?
*
I'm not a JPA student. I actually did not complete SPM, but I sat for O and A levels as a private candidate, at an earlier than usual age, as a quick jump method to apply for my scholarship. It was from overseas: studied in the so called " Asia's No. 1 Uni" tongue.gif Didn't feel that way but it does open doors at times. I calc net worth as total assets (current cash+property/units/stocks @ current market value) - total liabilities (which are only properties loans). My job isn't a fixed salary contract btw, and I just achieved the net worth 7 figures recently lah, and it begins with a 1 tongue.gif

This post has been edited by LoTek: Jul 15 2018, 10:01 AM
icemanfx
post Jul 15 2018, 10:14 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012



Working overseas with expat pay is a more realistic approach to fire.

TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 15 2018, 10:16 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 09:27 AM)
To inspire those who don't work overseas...and prove the naysayers (like my older relatives) who keep saying a job overseas is the only way to make it in life...I believe its possible to achieve goals early even for those working locally. Its all about controlling your lifestyle. I've built up a property portfolio in the 7 figures with an average yield of 6%, with a net worth also of 7 figures, and have never been based out of KL for longer than a few weeks at a time.

Fyi I have been in the workforce for 5 years and am in my mid 20s. No, I did not receive any boosts from my parents not even for studies (full scholarship with allowance) and they did not assist me in any way for any of my properties except that I stay under their roof and receive some moral support and family love.

To consistently invest 70-80% of income, may not sound easy but just ask yourself if you really need to drive that Jap or Continental car around in the traffic mess of KL? (I drive a fully paid off local vehicle and am frequent Mrt/Lrt user) Do you need to go on cafe-hops...? Why not just stick to one? Do you need a starbucks every morning? Make your own! Do you really need to have your entertainment outside? Have house parties with duty free booze. Is it a must to watch latest movies every other day? Go torrent or iflix or something. The list goes on...
*
Well done bro. Good to know from REAL people out there.

Achievers rather than complainers

This post has been edited by meonkutu11: Jul 15 2018, 10:26 AM
MUM
post Jul 15 2018, 10:26 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 10:00 AM)
Invest/save about 70-80% of income. So the other 20-30% is for my indulgences.

I personally think property market now is in limbo, it's neither up nor down, and generally with terrible yields. Have to shop for months for each property, I usually view more than 10 units in a development before making offers. I like to concentrate only on high yield student rentals or Airbnb now. Oh yes, please don't buy from developer, 99% chance that you'll never make money fast enough to even meet FD rate. Burnt once already.
I'm not a JPA student. I actually did not complete SPM, but I sat for O and A levels as a private candidate, at an earlier than usual age, as a quick jump method to apply for my scholarship. It was from overseas: studied in the so called " Asia's No. 1 Uni"  tongue.gif  Didn't feel that way but it does open doors at times. I calc net worth as total assets (current cash+property/units/stocks @ current market value) - total liabilities (which are only properties loans). My job isn't a fixed salary contract btw, and I just achieved the net worth 7 figures recently lah, and it begins with a 1 tongue.gif
*
hmm.gif with no help from papamama....started to work for 5 years
IF needed at least 8 months ~1 year of proof of income to secure a loan
IF the complete process of getting loan to subsequent dispose of it will take another 6 months

hmm.gif unless worked in the place where the " Asia's No. 1 Uni" is located.....

worked a few years, saved a pool and converted back to RM..... thumbup.gif

wow,...must have alot of paycheck amount to sustain the 20~30% to be used for self indulgences KL notworthy.gif

This post has been edited by MUM: Jul 15 2018, 10:37 AM
LoTek
post Jul 15 2018, 10:43 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 15 2018, 10:26 AM)
hmm.gif with no help from papamama....started to work for 5 years
IF needed at least 8 months ~1 year of proof of income to secure a loan
IF the complete process of getting loan to subsequent dispose of it will take another 6 months

hmm.gif unless worked in the place where the " Asia's No. 1 Uni" is located.....

worked a few years, saved a pool and converted back to RM..... thumbup.gif 

wow,...must have alot of paycheck amount to sustain the 20~30% to be used for self indulgences KL  notworthy.gif
*
Yup only starting investing in props 3 years ago. I haven't disposed any property before... I worked on and off during study time, came back right after grad

Nolah like I said, am quite frugal in non investment expenditure. Will enjoy life by retiring early, not keep working to sustain a lifestyle.
MUM
post Jul 15 2018, 10:57 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 10:43 AM)
Yup only starting investing in props 3 years ago. I haven't disposed any property before... I worked on and off during study time, came back right after grad

Nolah like I said, am quite frugal in non investment expenditure. Will enjoy life by retiring early, not keep working to sustain a lifestyle.
*
thumbup.gif
btw,...worth to consider... aforummer once mentioned something sort of about ....."try not to save too much sex for the old age......for there are things where life is meant to be spend at a younger age....for after that life age range...it won't be that much fun even when having to be at that scenario...."

thumbup.gif good to know you did have the 7 digit nett worth at this young age...
so, I guess the important thing is not sorely the capability to invest 70~80% of income, but where that income (USD/MYR, SGD/RMY) had be coming from too

This post has been edited by MUM: Jul 15 2018, 11:01 AM
perplexedstill
post Jul 15 2018, 11:19 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
143 posts

Joined: Oct 2017
QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 10:00 AM)
Invest/save about 70-80% of income. So the other 20-30% is for my indulgences.

I personally think property market now is in limbo, it's neither up nor down, and generally with terrible yields. Have to shop for months for each property, I usually view more than 10 units in a development before making offers. I like to concentrate only on high yield student rentals or Airbnb now. Oh yes, please don't buy from developer, 99% chance that you'll never make money fast enough to even meet FD rate. Burnt once already.
I'm not a JPA student. I actually did not complete SPM, but I sat for O and A levels as a private candidate, at an earlier than usual age, as a quick jump method to apply for my scholarship. It was from overseas: studied in the so called " Asia's No. 1 Uni"  tongue.gif  Didn't feel that way but it does open doors at times. I calc net worth as total assets (current cash+property/units/stocks @ current market value) - total liabilities (which are only properties loans). My job isn't a fixed salary contract btw, and I just achieved the net worth 7 figures recently lah, and it begins with a 1 tongue.gif
*
Mind to share why don't buy from developers? If so, buy from who?

I also did not complete SPM. Always want to continue study. Can i PM you and ask more about how to continue study since it is out topic here.

This post has been edited by perplexedstill: Jul 15 2018, 11:20 AM
LoTek
post Jul 15 2018, 11:41 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 15 2018, 10:57 AM)
thumbup.gif
btw,...worth to consider... aforummer once mentioned something sort of about ....."try not to save too much sex for the old age......for there are things where life is meant to be spend at a younger age....for after that life age range...it won't be that much fun even when having to be at that scenario...."

thumbup.gif good to know you did have the 7 digit nett worth at this young age...
so, I guess the important thing is not sorely the capability to invest 70~80% of income, but where that income (USD/MYR, SGD/RMY) had be coming from too
*
Haha sex brows.gif brows.gif brows.gif Don't worry friend, I'm pretty happy with life as whole, I get to travel on business so I don't feel the need to take holidays much and I can live without a good car. Rather be comfortable enough to not worry overly about finances than enjoy doodads. My income is like 95% myr and that's...not so good haha sad.gif Income is useless without self control...I have a few friends who are at my income level but with their BMWs and Iphones and what not, I can see why they have 0 properties and are in negative net worth territory.

QUOTE(perplexedstill @ Jul 15 2018, 11:19 AM)
Mind to share why don't buy from developers? If so, buy from who?

I also did not complete SPM. Always want to continue study. Can i PM you and ask more about how to continue study since it is out topic here.
*
Sure, prop I would buy from subsale, and press hard on the price. Developers all sell at future pricing, future promises, have to wait years to realize any gain (or loss), and you don't get to view the finished product and all yield/gain is hypothetical till then.

This post has been edited by LoTek: Jul 15 2018, 11:43 AM
SUSyklooi
post Jul 15 2018, 12:19 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


confused.gif
mid 20's
started to work 5 years ago in KL after graduating from over seas (only do partime there)
no $$ helps from FAMA
70~80% of income used for investment

invested in properties, from just 3 years ago

have not let go of any properties yet. (so no flipping here)

having a 7 digit net worth....yes net worth

I think it is ok to get loans for the 1st one and 2 properties, assuming the pay is used to sustain the repayment of your first 1 & 2nd properties.
assuming again 10% down payment (100k for 1 million property)

the rental yield of these 2 properties must be definitely very good and stable to be able to get sustained income to get another property ...

thus whatever earned from the 2 properties will be use to get the 3rd property (30% downpayment at 300K for the 1 million property)

then, the rental yield of these 3 properties must be definitely very good and stable to be able to get sustained income to get another properties ...

it is amazing, how much money can be made (7 digits net worth) in 3 years

you hit the jack pot....repeat the cycles few times,, one can buy a village.

thumbup.gif thumbsup.gif notworthy.gif



Ramjade....can try follow this?... since you're having some attributes similarity...young, frugal and money saving smart...

This post has been edited by yklooi: Jul 15 2018, 01:51 PM
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 15 2018, 01:21 PM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
don't know choose to trust or not to trust....
seems like living in fairy-tale.....
<5 yrs....
no supp
3 props in KV...
sub sale....
80% income for invest
20% for usage in KV.....
80:20 ratio is doable... when you have 5 digit salary... or the 3 prop must be paid really well.
prop loan....
mid 20... around 25?

wow that's new
aspartame
post Jul 15 2018, 04:52 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(yklooi @ Jul 15 2018, 12:19 PM)
:confused:
mid 20's
started to work 5 years ago in KL after graduating from over seas (only do partime there)
no $$ helps from FAMA
70~80% of income used for investment

invested in properties, from just 3 years ago

have not let go of any properties yet. (so no flipping here)

having a 7 digit net worth....yes net worth

I think it is ok to get loans for the 1st one and 2 properties, assuming the pay is used to sustain the repayment of your first 1 & 2nd properties.
assuming again 10% down payment (100k for 1 million property)

the rental yield of these 2 properties must be definitely very good and stable to be able to get sustained income to get another property ...

thus whatever earned from the 2 properties will be use to get the 3rd property (30% downpayment at 300K for the 1 million property)

then, the rental yield of these 3 properties must be definitely very good and stable to be able to get sustained income to get another properties ...

it is amazing, how much money can be made (7 digits net worth) in 3 years

you hit the jack pot....repeat the cycles few times,, one can buy a village.

thumbup.gif  :thumbsup:  notworthy.gif
Ramjade....can try follow this?... since you're having some attributes similarity...young, frugal and money saving smart...
*
First purchase of prop in 2015....that time till now, property price can say stagnant .... means 3 properties can assume no capital gains lah...

Means net worth of RM1mil earned during this 5 years all from salary...average 1 year save RM200k or RM16,700 per month... this means your average income per month is about RM24k (since savings of 70%)....(ignoring income tax because also ignoring employer EPF contributions for ease of calculation )

Otherwise, I also cannot see how net worth of 1 mil...

Conclusion: average ktards income per month is above RM20k
icemanfx
post Jul 15 2018, 05:06 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(aspartame @ Jul 15 2018, 04:52 PM)
Conclusion: average ktards income per month is above RM20k
*
Bnm report on kv property is unaffordable to most, epf statistics on income, elevated household debt is fake news.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Jul 15 2018, 05:06 PM
Ramjade
post Jul 15 2018, 05:20 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Jul 15 2018, 05:06 PM)
Bnm report on kv property is unaffordable to most , epf statistics on income, elevated household debt is fake news.
*
The nodded one I experienced myself.
ZoomGarde
post Jul 15 2018, 05:27 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
172 posts

Joined: Mar 2018
QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 15 2018, 01:21 PM)
don't know choose to trust or not to trust....
seems like living in fairy-tale.....
<5 yrs....
no supp
3 props in KV...
sub sale....
80% income for invest
20% for usage in KV.....
80:20 ratio is doable... when you have 5 digit salary... or the 3 prop must be paid really well.
prop loan....
mid 20... around 25?

wow that's new
*
All this talk talk talk easy job.. talk and hold no water.. come here and make people feel bad feel jealous only.


000022
post Jul 15 2018, 05:49 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
761 posts

Joined: Aug 2006
QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 11:41 AM)
Haha sex  brows.gif  brows.gif brows.gif Don't worry friend, I'm pretty happy with life as whole, I get to travel on business so I don't feel the need to take holidays much and I can live without a good car. Rather be comfortable enough to not worry overly about finances than enjoy doodads. My income is like 95% myr and that's...not so good haha sad.gif Income is useless without self control...I have a few friends who are at my income level but with their BMWs and Iphones and what not, I can see why they have 0 properties and are in negative net worth territory.
Sure, prop I would buy from subsale, and press hard on the price. Developers all sell at future pricing, future promises, have to wait years to realize any gain (or loss), and you don't get to view the finished product and all yield/gain is hypothetical till then.
*
You are probably in the negative net worth territory tbh, might be wrong though. We mostly all are, those who took a loan from the bank. Unless you're overly optimistic about your properties current worth.
LoTek
post Jul 15 2018, 06:26 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
I see my post is dubious to many.

Since my studies was fully covered including expenses, whatever I earned part time, i slowly brought back home, its 5 figures in SGD. And no I'm not in some illegal or immoral industry. I worked all sorts of jobs there in whatever spare time I had, photography, crew, promoter, tutor...anywhere from 8-50 sgd an hour type of jobs. Since starting full time work, which started in KL and still is in KL, my income has always been in 5 figure territory. I do not only rely on FD to grow savings that is not invested in props.

1st and 2nd prop is residential, subsequent is commercial. 1st was a mistake, bought from dev, yield is just over 4% which don't even meet the interest: am trying to exit. 2nd was the effort of 8 months of patience, non stop viewing and lowballing sellers until I got a unit more than 6 figures below market value. Believe seller was in dire financial difficulties, and he actually already had an interested buyer, who just wanted to push him another few k down from his asking, I offered to buy at the asking price and got it. Student rental play prop, yield is 9% counted at the market value, more than 10% at the price I got, incl renovate and furnish. I don't think I am not overestimating the value of my props: I take an average of the latest transactions listed on brickz and from the owner group chats.

Sorry to those who feel bad or disbelieve me, I'm being honest, I don't want to boast, I just wanted to inspire some young people my age smile.gif and its not about the income. Its about the discipline in work, expenses and investments. Some of my work days are as long as 14 hours when I need to. Never buy investments without weeks (or months) of study, made that mistake on my first prop. Never overspend. Some of my friends with 4k income a month probably think I earn less than them, from my lifestyle. I grew up in my grandfathers' attic, sleeping on the floor, eating rice with fruits and veges that me and my grandma stole from neighbours' gardens (sorry guys XD) or expiring old meat that my uncle, a wet market worker, was allowed to bring home. When I see people my age spending 110% of their income, with the 10% from parents or credit, and all the spending going to non investment expenditure, it just pisses me off.

This post has been edited by LoTek: Jul 15 2018, 07:25 PM
TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 15 2018, 07:10 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 06:26 PM)
I see my post is dubious to many.

Since my studies was fully covered including expenses, whatever I earned part time, i slowly brought back home, its 5 figures in SGD. And no I'm in some illegal or immoral industry. I worked all sorts of jobs there in whatever spare time I had, photography, crew, promoter, tutor...anywhere from 8-50 sgd an hour type of jobs. Since starting full time work, which started in KL and still is in KL, my income has always been in 5 figure territory. I do not only rely on FD to grow savings that is not invested in props.

1st and 2nd prop is residential, subsequent is commercial. 1st was a mistake, bought from dev, yield is just over 4% which don't even meet the interest: am trying to exit. 2nd was the effort of 8 months of patience, non stop viewing and lowballing sellers until I got a unit more than 6 figures below market value. Believe seller was in dire financial difficulties, and he actually already had an interested buyer, who just wanted to push him another few k down from his asking, I offered to buy at the asking price and got it. Student rental play prop, yield is 9% counted at the market value, more than 10% at the price I got, incl renovate and furnish. I don't think I am not overestimating the value of my props: I take an average of the latest transactions listed on brickz and from the owner group chats.

Sorry to those who feel bad or disbelieve me, I'm being honest, I don't want to boast, I just wanted to inspire some young people my age smile.gif and its not about the income. Its about the discipline in work, expenses and investments. Some of my work days are as long as 14 hours when I need to. Never buy investments without weeks (or months) of study, made that mistake on my first prop. Never overspend. Some of my friends with 4k income a month probably think I earn less than them, from my lifestyle. I grew up in my grandfathers' attic, sleeping on the floor, eating rice with fruits and veges that me and my grandma stole from neighbours' gardens (sorry guys XD) or expiring old meat that my uncle, a wet market worker, was allowed to bring home. When I see people my age spending 110% of their income, with the 10% from parents or credit, and all the spending going to expenditure, it just pisses me off.
*
Don’t worry mate. Let them in their non-believers and denial.
You know yourselves better.
Some of them in that position maybe because they are older than you but not started early or maybe just ignorance.

Keep it up! Keep positive.

LoTek
post Jul 15 2018, 07:25 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 15 2018, 07:10 PM)
Don’t worry mate. Let them in their non-believers and denial.
You know yourselves better.
Some of them in that position maybe because they are older than you but not started early or maybe just ignorance.

Keep it up! Keep positive.
*
notworthy.gif
aspartame
post Jul 15 2018, 10:06 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 06:26 PM)
I see my post is dubious to many.

Since my studies was fully covered including expenses, whatever I earned part time, i slowly brought back home, its 5 figures in SGD. And no I'm not in some illegal or immoral industry. I worked all sorts of jobs there in whatever spare time I had, photography, crew, promoter, tutor...anywhere from 8-50 sgd an hour type of jobs. Since starting full time work, which started in KL and still is in KL, my income has always been in 5 figure territory. I do not only rely on FD to grow savings that is not invested in props.

1st and 2nd prop is residential, subsequent is commercial. 1st was a mistake, bought from dev, yield is just over 4% which don't even meet the interest: am trying to exit. 2nd was the effort of 8 months of patience, non stop viewing and lowballing sellers until I got a unit more than 6 figures below market value. Believe seller was in dire financial difficulties, and he actually already had an interested buyer, who just wanted to push him another few k down from his asking, I offered to buy at the asking price and got it. Student rental play prop, yield is 9% counted at the market value, more than 10% at the price I got, incl renovate and furnish. I don't think I am not overestimating the value of my props: I take an average of the latest transactions listed on brickz and from the owner group chats.

Sorry to those who feel bad or disbelieve me, I'm being honest, I don't want to boast, I just wanted to inspire some young people my age smile.gif and its not about the income. Its about the discipline in work, expenses and investments. Some of my work days are as long as 14 hours when I need to. Never buy investments without weeks (or months) of study, made that mistake on my first prop. Never overspend. Some of my friends with 4k income a month probably think I earn less than them, from my lifestyle. I grew up in my grandfathers' attic, sleeping on the floor, eating rice with fruits and veges that me and my grandma stole from neighbours' gardens (sorry guys XD) or expiring old meat that my uncle, a wet market worker, was allowed to bring home. When I see people my age spending 110% of their income, with the 10% from parents or credit, and all the spending going to non investment expenditure, it just pisses me off.
*
Impressive! At such young age, u r already at least top 1% or less of your peers. Once yr assets snowball, your wealth will grow exponentially. You now have capital, discipline, high income and most importantly time on your side. Your future is limitless! Kudos!
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 16 2018, 08:55 PM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 06:26 PM)
I see my post is dubious to many.

Since my studies was fully covered including expenses, whatever I earned part time, i slowly brought back home, its 5 figures in SGD. And no I'm not in some illegal or immoral industry. I worked all sorts of jobs there in whatever spare time I had, photography, crew, promoter, tutor...anywhere from 8-50 sgd an hour type of jobs. Since starting full time work, which started in KL and still is in KL, my income has always been in 5 figure territory. I do not only rely on FD to grow savings that is not invested in props.

1st and 2nd prop is residential, subsequent is commercial. 1st was a mistake, bought from dev, yield is just over 4% which don't even meet the interest: am trying to exit. 2nd was the effort of 8 months of patience, non stop viewing and lowballing sellers until I got a unit more than 6 figures below market value. Believe seller was in dire financial difficulties, and he actually already had an interested buyer, who just wanted to push him another few k down from his asking, I offered to buy at the asking price and got it. Student rental play prop, yield is 9% counted at the market value, more than 10% at the price I got, incl renovate and furnish. I don't think I am not overestimating the value of my props: I take an average of the latest transactions listed on brickz and from the owner group chats.

Sorry to those who feel bad or disbelieve me, I'm being honest, I don't want to boast, I just wanted to inspire some young people my age smile.gif and its not about the income. Its about the discipline in work, expenses and investments. Some of my work days are as long as 14 hours when I need to. Never buy investments without weeks (or months) of study, made that mistake on my first prop. Never overspend. Some of my friends with 4k income a month probably think I earn less than them, from my lifestyle. I grew up in my grandfathers' attic, sleeping on the floor, eating rice with fruits and veges that me and my grandma stole from neighbours' gardens (sorry guys XD) or expiring old meat that my uncle, a wet market worker, was allowed to bring home. When I see people my age spending 110% of their income, with the 10% from parents or credit, and all the spending going to non investment expenditure, it just pisses me off.
*
Now, this only clear all my doubt. your previous post isn't complete with the details. You can re-read back.
1st official job already 5 figures. That's a very good start. In fact a huge jump start. And with the attitude, no surprise for owning props. Nice one.
Almost having same pattern with you except the 5 figures salary la, but my life damn boring :|

Besides, another conclusion.
Picking up a job or field is very important. Some people work for 16 hours in hospital (junior doc) end up only 5-6k per month lol. Some teachers work 9 hours in school also 5-6k lol. But on the other hand, same rank doc in Australia pays higher than in Malaysia with better benefits. Malaysia oh Malaysia.
blackseed202
post Jul 16 2018, 09:22 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Mar 2016
Looking forward for FIRE during my forties. Currently will be there in 20 yrs. But i could achieve it earlier if i increase my income over the years. I have maybe about 80% savings now of my income.
icemanfx
post Jul 16 2018, 09:34 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 15 2018, 07:10 PM)
Don’t worry mate. Let them in their non-believers and denial.
You know yourselves better.
Some of them in that position maybe because they are older than you but not started early or maybe just ignorance.

Keep it up! Keep positive.
*
People could believe in many things e.g Robert kiyosaki's "rich Dad poor Dad". The question is how realistic and practical?

Oh ya, "rich Dad poor Dad" is as real as Harry Potter.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Jul 16 2018, 09:35 PM
polarzbearz
post Jul 16 2018, 09:38 PM

Gracie
*******
Senior Member
4,816 posts

Joined: Apr 2007


QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 06:26 PM)
I see my post is dubious to many.

Since my studies was fully covered including expenses, whatever I earned part time, i slowly brought back home, its 5 figures in SGD. And no I'm not in some illegal or immoral industry. I worked all sorts of jobs there in whatever spare time I had, photography, crew, promoter, tutor...anywhere from 8-50 sgd an hour type of jobs. Since starting full time work, which started in KL and still is in KL, my income has always been in 5 figure territory. I do not only rely on FD to grow savings that is not invested in props.

1st and 2nd prop is residential, subsequent is commercial. 1st was a mistake, bought from dev, yield is just over 4% which don't even meet the interest: am trying to exit. 2nd was the effort of 8 months of patience, non stop viewing and lowballing sellers until I got a unit more than 6 figures below market value. Believe seller was in dire financial difficulties, and he actually already had an interested buyer, who just wanted to push him another few k down from his asking, I offered to buy at the asking price and got it. Student rental play prop, yield is 9% counted at the market value, more than 10% at the price I got, incl renovate and furnish. I don't think I am not overestimating the value of my props: I take an average of the latest transactions listed on brickz and from the owner group chats.

Sorry to those who feel bad or disbelieve me, I'm being honest, I don't want to boast, I just wanted to inspire some young people my age smile.gif and its not about the income. Its about the discipline in work, expenses and investments. Some of my work days are as long as 14 hours when I need to. Never buy investments without weeks (or months) of study, made that mistake on my first prop. Never overspend. Some of my friends with 4k income a month probably think I earn less than them, from my lifestyle. I grew up in my grandfathers' attic, sleeping on the floor, eating rice with fruits and veges that me and my grandma stole from neighbours' gardens (sorry guys XD) or expiring old meat that my uncle, a wet market worker, was allowed to bring home. When I see people my age spending 110% of their income, with the 10% from parents or credit, and all the spending going to non investment expenditure, it just pisses me off.
*
Haters will always be hating and "grapes that we can't eat is always sour". So don't mind them. Impressive achievement you have there. I know of 5 figures earner of early 20's but are nowhere close to what you achieved due to lifestyle spending being the priority than portfolios growth. smile.gif

TSmeonkutu11
post Jul 16 2018, 10:00 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Jul 16 2018, 09:34 PM)
People could believe in many things e.g Robert kiyosaki's "rich Dad poor Dad". The question is how realistic and practical?

Oh ya, "rich Dad poor Dad" is as real as Harry Potter.
*
Agree; realistic and practical.

But again, it is depend on individual’s income, lifestyles and etc.

Thus this thread is to get people sharing their journey and perhaps obstacles that can be lesson learned to others.

Some of forumers here instead of asking for more clarifications, they just got ignores people’s achievements and saying “bluffed, living in fantasy” and that kind of response.

I believe we need to be more positive and seek for more information if we dont understand the whole picture, rather than assuming and shot blindly.

I acknowledge that we all different and hopefully some of the sharing will fit with our current situation and it will become a guide/reference/point to start the FI/RE journey.




LoTek
post Jul 16 2018, 10:24 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 16 2018, 08:55 PM)
Now, this only clear all my doubt. your previous post isn't complete with the details. You can re-read back.
1st official job already 5 figures. That's a very good start. In fact a huge jump start. And with the attitude, no surprise for owning props. Nice one.
Almost having same pattern with you except the 5 figures salary la, but my life damn boring :|

Besides, another conclusion.
Picking up a job or field is very important. Some people work for 16 hours in hospital (junior doc) end up only 5-6k per month lol. Some teachers work 9 hours in school also 5-6k lol. But on the other hand, same rank doc in Australia pays higher than in Malaysia with better benefits. Malaysia oh Malaysia.
*
Sorry about that man, I guess I'm not a good story teller XD. Yes agreed that field sometimes really determines the expected salary range... unfortunately in my industry, although the jumpstart sounds good to you, I cannot expect my income to increase much over the next say 20 to 30 years and actually has more likelihood go down as I age. So... that's extra motivation to get a steady investment portfolio asap.
LoTek
post Jul 16 2018, 10:30 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
QUOTE(aspartame @ Jul 15 2018, 10:06 PM)
Impressive! At such young age, u r already at least top 1% or less of your peers. Once yr assets snowball, your wealth will grow exponentially. You now have capital, discipline, high income and most importantly time on your side. Your future is limitless! Kudos!
*
notworthy.gif I hope so.

QUOTE(polarzbearz @ Jul 16 2018, 09:38 PM)
Haters will always be hating and "grapes that we can't eat is always sour". So don't mind them. Impressive achievement you have there. I know of 5 figures earner of early 20's but are nowhere close to what you achieved due to lifestyle spending being the priority than portfolios growth. smile.gif
*
notworthy.gif Yeah I really don't like to see people spend so much of their income on lifestyle...with the justification that they can always continue earning. Never know what life throws at us.
icemanfx
post Jul 17 2018, 05:52 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(polarzbearz @ Jul 16 2018, 09:38 PM)
Haters will always be hating and "grapes that we can't eat is always sour". So don't mind them. Impressive achievement you have there. I know of 5 figures earner of early 20's but are nowhere close to what you achieved due to lifestyle spending being the priority than portfolios growth. smile.gif
*
Why must a person doubting "rich dad poor Dad" story is a hater? Classifying different in opinion a hater could only from zealous cult e.g those highly geared and believe property price will uuu regardless.
polarzbearz
post Jul 17 2018, 06:08 AM

Gracie
*******
Senior Member
4,816 posts

Joined: Apr 2007


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Jul 17 2018, 05:52 AM)
Why must a person doubting "rich dad poor Dad" story is a hater? Classifying different in opinion a hater could only from zealous cult e.g those highly geared and believe property price will uuu regardless.
*
EDITED: 2nd edit to provide better clarity.

Doubting is fine. If in doubt, seek clarification. The only problem is that when negative energy are associated when seeking clarifications. If you look few posts back especially the last few comments, before LoTek clarified. Those posts are really rclxub.gif

If we don't believe, that's fine. Nothing wrong with it. But we can also ask nicely instead of labelling on the spot, right?

On Rich Dad, Poor Dad's book / practicality, again in the end its about mindset. Not everything will be usable or even practical but what's important are the new values gained from the book, right?

Unless you are saying that you did not gain any positive values from the book, then I rest my case.

This post has been edited by polarzbearz: Jul 17 2018, 07:29 AM
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 17 2018, 07:24 AM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
aiyo....
don't fight over a book la. alamak.
polarzbearz
post Jul 17 2018, 07:34 AM

Gracie
*******
Senior Member
4,816 posts

Joined: Apr 2007


QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 17 2018, 07:24 AM)
aiyo....
don't fight over a book la. alamak.
*
Not fighting also laugh.gif
Not really so much about the books but their negativity 'shutdown styles' of comment against things that they don't believe in.
wongmunkeong
post Jul 17 2018, 08:28 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Jul 16 2018, 10:00 PM)
Agree; realistic and practical.

But again, it is depend on individual’s income, lifestyles and etc.

Thus this thread is to get people sharing their journey and perhaps obstacles that can be lesson learned to others.

Some of forumers here instead of asking for more clarifications, they just got ignores people’s achievements and saying “bluffed, living in fantasy” and that kind of response.

I believe we need to be more positive and seek for more information if we dont understand the whole picture, rather than assuming and shot blindly.

I acknowledge that we all different and hopefully some of the sharing will fit with our current situation and it will become a guide/reference/point to start the FI/RE journey.
*
80/20 rule bro, thus 80% "like that" tongue.gif
Anyhow, life has taught me - it's good that the majority are "like that", else making a living or growing our portfolios will be ultra competitive laugh.gif

This post has been edited by wongmunkeong: Jul 17 2018, 08:29 AM
SUSyklooi
post Jul 17 2018, 09:00 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


I will make a gross assumption here....
this 80/20 rules will has great variance in the income grade.
those in the 3 digit income upon graduation
those in the 4 digit income upon graduation
those in the 5 digit income upon graduation
those that are not graduated
those that has great and financially sound parents,
those that are not so educated, experienced, exposed,
etc, etc...

my assumption, is also,,,,for those with 5 digit income, .....the chance of making a 1 million networth after a few years of working will definitedly be a lot higher than those at lower grade.

thus, we are all different and hopefully these posts, will just be a morning easy reads and be forgotten later in the day. For those shared posts, may not will fit with our current situation, our philosophy, our risk appetite, financial mishaps learnt, etc, etc and it will just be a good read to me....and definitely this is not a place for me to follow these posts as a guide/reference/point to start the FI/RE journey or what ever they are called.

Thus, not need to be envy, jealous, trying to emulate, etc, etc.....for one man's meat, maybe another man's poison.

a friend of mine shared this in my whatsapp this morning....

"We sacrifice our time on relationship/health to make wealth, then we scarifice our wealth to get back our families/friends/health".

thus no need to fights in support or oppose to these posts......we are all different in many ways...... notworthy.gif notworthy.gif




55665566
post Jul 17 2018, 09:10 AM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



QUOTE(yklooi @ Jul 17 2018, 09:00 AM)
I will make a gross assumption here....
this 80/20 rules will has great variance in the income grade.
those in the 3 digit income upon graduation
those in the 4 digit income upon graduation
those in the 5 digit income upon graduation
those that are not graduated
those that has great and financially sound parents,
those that are not so educated, experienced, exposed,
etc, etc...

my assumption, is also,,,,for those with 5 digit income, .....the chance of making a 1 million networth after a few years of working will definitedly be a lot higher than those at lower grade.

thus, we are all different and hopefully these posts, will just be a morning easy reads and be forgotten later in the day. For those shared posts, may not will fit with our current situation, our philosophy, our risk appetite, financial mishaps learnt, etc, etc and it will just be a good read to me....and definitely this is not a place for me to follow these posts as a guide/reference/point to start the FI/RE journey or what ever they are called.

Thus, not need to be envy, jealous, trying to emulate, etc, etc.....for one man's meat, maybe another man's poison.

a friend of mine shared this in my whatsapp this morning....

"We sacrifice our time on relationship/health to make wealth, then we scarifice our wealth to get back our families/friends/health".

thus no need to fights in support or oppose to these posts......we are all different in many ways...... notworthy.gif  notworthy.gif
*
That is why we need to FIREarly! So that we have time to spend our wealth on enjoying life instead of paying for medicals.
SUSyklooi
post Jul 17 2018, 09:12 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


QUOTE(55665566 @ Jul 17 2018, 09:10 AM)
That is why we need to FIREarly! So that we have time to spend our wealth on enjoying life instead of paying for medicals.
*
need FIRE to be able to afford insurance premium?
if that is what you meant


55665566
post Jul 17 2018, 09:16 AM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



QUOTE(yklooi @ Jul 17 2018, 09:12 AM)
need FIRE to be able to afford insurance premium?
if that is what you meant
*
Nah, I mean don't wait until no time/health to spend your wealth.
As for me, I will always have insurance to cover me up in case of any unwanted circumstance.
It's like protecting my wealth.
SUSyklooi
post Jul 17 2018, 09:23 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


QUOTE(55665566 @ Jul 17 2018, 09:16 AM)
Nah, I mean don't wait until no time/health to spend your wealth.
As for me, I will always have insurance to cover me up in case of any unwanted circumstance.
It's like protecting my wealth.
*
rclxms.gif good for you
thus, your circumstances may not be applicable to some too.
some may be too overly focused on meeting their preset saving goals thus maybe lead them to neglect or taking chances of possiblity of medical situations (may or may not happens) (young vs old chances)

thus i said earlier.....no need to fights in support or oppose to these posts......we are all different in many ways.


rapple
post Jul 17 2018, 09:58 AM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
Sometimes I found it funny, property investor took the latest value of the property price and then valued that property at that price, just to make their own net worth higher.

It's like people who keep stocks but valued their stock at selling price instead of the cost price.

Sorry, it looks unrealistic. There's no actual gain but a number for boasting only.

This post has been edited by rapple: Jul 17 2018, 09:58 AM
spiderman17
post Jul 17 2018, 10:29 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
309 posts

Joined: Nov 2011
QUOTE(yklooi @ Jul 17 2018, 09:00 AM)
I will make a gross assumption here....
this 80/20 rules will has great variance in the income grade.
those in the 3 digit income upon graduation
those in the 4 digit income upon graduation
those in the 5 digit income upon graduation
those that are not graduated
those that has great and financially sound parents,
those that are not so educated, experienced, exposed,
etc, etc...

my assumption, is also,,,,for those with 5 digit income, .....the chance of making a 1 million networth after a few years of working will definitedly be a lot higher than those at lower grade.

thus, we are all different and hopefully these posts, will just be a morning easy reads and be forgotten later in the day. For those shared posts, may not will fit with our current situation, our philosophy, our risk appetite, financial mishaps learnt, etc, etc and it will just be a good read to me....and definitely this is not a place for me to follow these posts as a guide/reference/point to start the FI/RE journey or what ever they are called.

Thus, not need to be envy, jealous, trying to emulate, etc, etc.....for one man's meat, maybe another man's poison.

a friend of mine shared this in my whatsapp this morning....

"We sacrifice our time on relationship/health to make wealth, then we scarifice our wealth to get back our families/friends/health".

thus no need to fights in support or oppose to these posts......we are all different in many ways...... notworthy.gif  notworthy.gif
*
Unfortunately, time and wealth is an unequal trade.
Wealth cannot buy back those lost moments of life,
Eg. not being there when your child is growing up.

It's still a personal choice, no right or wrong.
melvin471
post Jul 17 2018, 10:57 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
228 posts

Joined: Jan 2011
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 4 2018, 01:05 PM)
You know, you don't need to reply individually every single post. You can multi quote.

I don't see myself retiring unless I'm force to retired.

My aim is to quit my job and work on my freelance.

For now my job salary ratio to my freelance income is 1 : 0.75, my aim is to reach 1 : 3 before i can really commit quitting my work.

Still long way to go.
*
that's very impressive, mind sharing what you do as a freelance?


rapple
post Jul 17 2018, 12:19 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(melvin471 @ Jul 17 2018, 10:57 AM)
that's very impressive, mind sharing what you do as a freelance?
*
Accounting.

Very tedious work.

A few Sdn Bhd clients vouchers and invoices filing makes me wanna puke..




aspartame
post Jul 17 2018, 12:49 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 09:58 AM)
Sometimes I found it funny, property investor took the latest value of the property price and then valued that property at that price, just to make their own net worth higher.

It's like people who keep stocks but valued their stock at selling price instead of the cost price.

Sorry, it looks unrealistic. There's no actual gain but a number for boasting only.
*
I find your thinking funny. If net worth is not valued at market price, then at what price? Cost price? Lol. Guess Warren Buffett is just a millionaire.
NightHeart
post Jul 17 2018, 12:56 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 12:19 PM)
Accounting.

Very tedious work.

A few Sdn Bhd clients vouchers and invoices filing makes me wanna puke..
*
But your accounting freelance is basically trading your extra time for money no? Your time is 24 hours a day only. So there's some sorta limit (aka not so scale-able), unless your increase your earning per hour rates. How practical is it to achieve 1:3 day job to freelance income ratio?

Take it with a pinch of salt, but from my observation....accountants or whoever working in the finance department can climb up quite obviously. The CFO from my last MNC company climbed his way through from a normal exec from the Big 4. I noticed the same trend for those working in the accounts department in each of my previous employment. The key difference is, the one that tends to climb up very quickly exhibits very obvious leadership characteristics on top of being good at their work.

What I'm suggesting is, increasing your daytime job income via self-improvement should be the better path instead of increasing freelance income as the opportunity is much better no? If you suck at your daytime job, chances of you suck at your freelance is kinda likely too no? Both daytime job & freelance is basically trading your time for income.

IMO, the function of freelance is to gain extra pocket money or something to keep your mind active when you retire at 60.
rapple
post Jul 17 2018, 01:37 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(aspartame @ Jul 17 2018, 12:49 PM)
I find your thinking funny. If net worth is not valued at market price, then at what price? Cost price? Lol. Guess Warren Buffett is just a millionaire.
*
I wouldn't valued my properties at market price.

When you valued your property at market price, then the return from your rental income will drop unless he can raised the rental as he wish. He claims his average rental yield at 6%. Is the 6% yield on his property is based on market price or cost price?

QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 17 2018, 12:56 PM)
But your accounting freelance is basically trading your extra time for money no? Your time is 24 hours a day only. So there's some sorta limit (aka not so scale-able), unless your increase your earning per hour rates. How practical is it to achieve 1:3 day job to freelance income ratio?

Take it with a pinch of salt, but from my observation....accountants or whoever working in the finance department can climb up quite obviously. The CFO from my last MNC company climbed his way through from a normal exec from the Big 4. I noticed the same trend for those working in the accounts department in each of my previous employment. The key difference is, the one that tends to climb up very quickly exhibits very obvious leadership characteristics on top of being good at their work.

What I'm suggesting is, increasing your daytime job income via self-improvement should be the better path instead of increasing freelance income as the opportunity is much better no? If you suck at your daytime job, chances of you suck at your freelance is kinda likely too no? Both daytime job & freelance is basically trading your time for income.

IMO, the function of freelance is to gain extra pocket money or something to keep your mind active when you retire at 60.
*
A small Company where I work, I only have 1 account to work on. I will let you guess, how much time I need to finish one month of accounting work?

Company that has less than 1m revenue per year and requires monthly accounts, I can charge at least 300 per month. My time cost is probably less than 3 hours/month.

Now, you know my average fees / hour, do you still think 1:3 ratio is not achievable given the time i have at work and after work.

Edit: The only thing I need more, is the connections. As accounting work is all confidential, I can't go sell my service because I'm unknown to them. Most of my clients is recommended by friends or clients.

This post has been edited by rapple: Jul 17 2018, 01:51 PM
aspartame
post Jul 17 2018, 02:07 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 01:37 PM)
I wouldn't valued my properties at market price.

When you valued your property at market price, then the return from your rental income will drop unless he can raised the rental as he wish. He claims his average rental yield at 6%. Is the 6% yield on his property is based on market price or cost price?
A small Company where I work, I only have 1 account to work on. I will let you guess, how much time I need to finish one month of accounting work?

Company that has less than 1m revenue per year and requires monthly accounts, I can charge at least 300 per month. My time cost is probably less than 3 hours/month.

Now, you know my average fees / hour, do you still think 1:3 ratio is not achievable given the time i have at work and after work.

Edit: The only thing I need more, is the connections. As accounting work is all confidential, I can't go sell my service because I'm unknown to them. Most of my clients is recommended by friends or clients.
*
Calculation of net worth should be at market price, whether we are talking about property or stocks. If you personally want to value at cost price, of course you can, but u can't say u feel funny because others value at market price. Those who value their net worth at market price are free to apply a 10% or more discount to whatever net worth to derive their own conservative net worth. I personally will value stocks at market price and properties at average of last few transacted price. I dun apply discounts to this figure .

For both stock and properties , there are market yields and yield on cost depending on what base u choose for your denominator. In any case , yields have no relevance in the calculation of net worth. Net worth is new worth. Yield on net worth is another thing.

This post has been edited by aspartame: Jul 17 2018, 02:08 PM
cherroy
post Jul 17 2018, 02:35 PM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 01:37 PM)
I wouldn't valued my properties at market price.

When you valued your property at market price, then the return from your rental income will drop unless he can raised the rental as he wish. He claims his average rental yield at 6%. Is the 6% yield on his property is based on market price or cost price?

*
Property or asset should be valued at market price to show the real truth and situation.

A property that bought 100k ago, now worth 1 mil.
The rental income is 10k pa.

One can "syiok sendiri" by saying, the property generate 10% return.

But in actual fact, the property only yield 1%, a bad yield.
As if sell off the property at 1 mil and put in FD at 4%, the return would be 40K pa.

Same when property bought at high price.
Bought at 1 mil, but if now worth 700k,
One should view the property net worth is 700k or instead "syiok sendiri" again say the property worth 1 mil?

Yes, those are unrealised gain or net worth until one sells it off, but unrealised worth at market price, is the real worth one is having now.
That's why in accounting, we have unrealised gain vs realised gain difference.

Same with other assets, be it stock, unit trust or whatever, a yield should be justified based on current worth, to show the actual truth situation, so that one can make good decision on it.



rapple
post Jul 17 2018, 02:39 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(aspartame @ Jul 17 2018, 02:07 PM)
Calculation of net worth should be at market price, whether we are talking about property or stocks. If you personally want to value at cost price, of course you can, but  u can't say u feel funny because others value at market price. Those who value their net worth at market price are free to apply a 10% or more discount to whatever net worth to derive their own conservative net worth. I personally will value stocks at market price and properties at average of last few transacted price. I dun apply discounts to this figure .

For both stock and properties , there are market yields and yield on cost depending on what base u choose for your denominator. In any case , yields have no relevance in the calculation of net worth. Net worth is new worth. Yield on net worth is another thing.
*
You are right that yield will not shown in any net worth statement but it still comes from the properties.

How can you valued your properties at market price and have your yield based on the cost price. Isn't this misleading on the yield?

Are you going to calculate your dividends received against the current stock market value also?






aspartame
post Jul 17 2018, 02:58 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 02:39 PM)
You are right that yield will not shown in any net worth statement but it still comes from the properties.

How can you valued your properties at market price and have your yield based on the cost price. Isn't this misleading on the yield?

Are you going to calculate your dividends received against the current stock market value also?
*
I seldom calculate yields on properties except when I am looking to buy. I more regularly calculate yield on stocks based on market price to determine buying or selling decisions. Yield on cost is quite irrelevant to me because cost price is history and historical yield is useless except maybe u want to shiok sendiri and say u have locked in a high yield based on cost.
cherroy
post Jul 17 2018, 03:04 PM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 02:39 PM)
You are right that yield will not shown in any net worth statement but it still comes from the properties.

How can you valued your properties at market price and have your yield based on the cost price. Isn't this misleading on the yield?

Are you going to calculate your dividends received against the current stock market value also?
*
Yes,
Stock, reit also the same, and should be judged based on its current yield based on current price.

eg.
Bought a stock at 1.00, now is 2.00, it gives dividend 10 cents pa.
It should be viewed as 5% yield, instead 10%.

And decision to sell or buy from now on, should be based on the 5%, as it is the real yield.

As if the share price goes up to 4.00, and still gives 10 cents pa.
One may consider to sell it, as it no longer a good yielding stock, as it is only 2.5% yield, no longer a 10% yield (syiok sendiri approach)
Sell at 4.00, put in FD 4%, you get 16 cents, instead of 10 cents dividend. So FD yield is better than stock yield already.

But if one uses 10% (syiok sendiri) approach, it is masking the real situation.
A so called 10% yield return (10 cents) worst than 4% FD (16 cents)

rapple
post Jul 17 2018, 03:09 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(cherroy @ Jul 17 2018, 03:04 PM)
Yes,
Stock, reit also the same, and should be judged based on its current yield based on current price.

eg.
Bought a stock at 1.00, now is 2.00, it gives dividend 10 cents pa.
It should be viewed as 5% yield, instead 10%.

And decision to sell or buy from now on, should be based on the 5%, as it is the real yield.

As if the share price goes up to 4.00, and still gives 10 cents pa.
One may consider to sell it, as it no longer a good yielding stock, as it is only 2.5% yield, no longer a 10% yield (syiok sendiri approach)
Sell at 4.00, put in FD 4%, you get 16 cents, instead of 10 cents dividend. So FD yield is better than stock yield already.

But if one uses 10% (syiok sendiri) approach, it is masking the real situation.
A so called 10% yield return (10 cents) worst than 4% FD (16 cents)
*
hmm.gif Really something that I've never think about.

I guess I have done too much DCA to lower cost instead of thinking of actual worth.
NightHeart
post Jul 17 2018, 03:29 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 01:37 PM)
A small Company where I work, I only have 1 account to work on. I will let you guess, how much time I need to finish one month of accounting work?

Company that has less than 1m revenue per year and requires monthly accounts, I can charge at least 300 per month. My time cost is probably less than 3 hours/month.

Now, you know my average fees / hour, do you still think 1:3 ratio is not achievable given the time i have at work and after work.

Edit: The only thing I need more, is the connections. As accounting work is all confidential, I can't go sell my service because I'm unknown to them. Most of my clients is recommended by friends or clients.
*
RM300 per 3 hours, assuming you spend 3 hours each working day, that’s RM6k per month assuming you have roughly 20 clients. RM9k per month assuming you work 30 days for 30 different clients, right?

If you climb up the ladder, you could earn more than your freelance & network with higher profile people. The higher you go up, the higher level people you get to meet. Attend annual budget seminar = meet more high leveled people from your industry. Manage a whole department = network with other head of departments & more.

That’s why I was throwing some food for thoughts for you to reconsider growing your day job income instead of being too focused on your freelance. But don’t get me wrong, doing freelance is great too. Just that depending on what you’re planning to achieve at the end of your career, balance out between day job & freelance.

QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 03:09 PM)
hmm.gif Really something that I've never think about.

I guess I have done too much DCA to lower cost instead of thinking of actual worth.
*
The amazing wonders of having a more open mind; you’ll learn really fast from various different perspectives.
cherroy
post Jul 17 2018, 03:38 PM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 17 2018, 03:29 PM)
RM300 per 3 hours, assuming you spend 3 hours each working day, that’s RM6k per month assuming you have roughly 20 clients. RM9k per month assuming you work 30 days for 30 different clients, right?

If you climb up the ladder, you could earn more than your freelance & network with higher profile people. The higher you go up, the higher level people you get to meet. Attend annual budget seminar = meet more high leveled people from your industry. Manage a whole department = network with other head of departments & more.

That’s why I was throwing some food for thoughts for you to reconsider growing your day job income instead of being too focused on your freelance. But don’t get me wrong, doing freelance is great too. Just that depending on what you’re planning to achieve at the end of your career, balance out between day job & freelance. 
The amazing wonders of having a more open mind; you’ll learn really fast from various different perspectives.
*
Freelance is a good step ladder to become own boss.
Many become own boss through this way as well.

While too focus on freelance job may jeopardize one job career path (climb up the ladder within the company as employed)

No right or wrong in between, it is personal choice, as sometimes, climbing up the ladder involves a lot of office politics as well.
A lot of time, not the best or better person get promoted. I guess many get what I mean.

Not mean to encourage or discourage which way one should go.

Yes, an open mind indeed is essential in learning path in any financial planning/career.



rapple
post Jul 17 2018, 04:25 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 17 2018, 03:29 PM)
RM300 per 3 hours, assuming you spend 3 hours each working day, that’s RM6k per month assuming you have roughly 20 clients. RM9k per month assuming you work 30 days for 30 different clients, right?

If you climb up the ladder, you could earn more than your freelance & network with higher profile people. The higher you go up, the higher level people you get to meet. Attend annual budget seminar = meet more high leveled people from your industry. Manage a whole department = network with other head of departments & more.

That’s why I was throwing some food for thoughts for you to reconsider growing your day job income instead of being too focused on your freelance. But don’t get me wrong, doing freelance is great too. Just that depending on what you’re planning to achieve at the end of your career, balance out between day job & freelance. 
The amazing wonders of having a more open mind; you’ll learn really fast from various different perspectives.
*
Honestly, what can i ask more when my boss gives me tons of free time with a good pay and I'm the only person in the office.

Corporate life is tough and I'm not really keen on it.

I have met different sets of people with different businesses background through my freelance work.

Then I'm also actually lucky that my wife boss (A Company Sec.) will introduce clients to me for accounting work and my friend who runs an auditing firm.


QUOTE(cherroy @ Jul 17 2018, 03:38 PM)
Freelance is a good step ladder to become own boss.
Many become own boss through this way as well.

While too focus on freelance job may jeopardize one job career path (climb up the ladder within the company as employed)

No right or wrong in between, it is personal choice, as sometimes, climbing up the ladder involves a lot of office politics as well.
A lot of time, not the best or better person get promoted. I guess many get what I mean.

Not mean to encourage or discourage which way one should go.

Yes, an open mind indeed is essential in learning path in any financial planning/career.
*
Income will reach till a point where it won't increase anymore due to my non-flexible time and that's when I'll have to make a decision to commit to a full time freelancer or just be grateful for what I have at that time.

NightHeart
post Jul 17 2018, 05:15 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(cherroy @ Jul 17 2018, 03:38 PM)
Freelance is a good step ladder to become own boss.
Many become own boss through this way as well.

While too focus on freelance job may jeopardize one job career path (climb up the ladder within the company as employed)

No right or wrong in between, it is personal choice, as sometimes, climbing up the ladder involves a lot of office politics as well.
A lot of time, not the best or better person get promoted. I guess many get what I mean.

Not mean to encourage or discourage which way one should go.

Yes, an open mind indeed is essential in learning path in any financial planning/career.
*
Yes it's a great stepping stone indeed. Agree with you, the key is to find the balance between both that can help achieve their personal long term plan; whether to become a highly positioned person in the corporate world before retiring into a freelancer or to leave corporate world earlier & build own accounting firm.

QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 04:25 PM)
Honestly, what can i ask more when my boss gives me tons of free time with a good pay and I'm the only person in the office.

Corporate life is tough and I'm not really keen on it.

I have met different sets of people with different businesses background through my freelance work.

Then I'm also actually lucky that my wife boss (A Company Sec.) will introduce clients to me for accounting work and my friend who runs an auditing firm.
Income will reach till a point where it won't increase anymore due to my non-flexible time and that's when I'll have to make a decision to commit to a full time freelancer or just be grateful for what I have at that time.
*
Seems like the opportunity presented at you now is gearing you towards existing corporate life earlier to pursue your own accounting firm thumbup.gif
Opportunity comes & goes, capitalize on it while the window is still open.

Have you met or do you have client from the retail world?
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 17 2018, 09:26 PM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
QUOTE(cherroy @ Jul 17 2018, 02:35 PM)
Property or asset should be valued at market price to show the real truth and situation.

A property that bought 100k ago, now worth 1 mil.
The rental income is 10k pa.

One can "syiok sendiri" by saying, the property generate 10% return.

But in actual fact, the property only yield 1%, a bad yield.
As if sell off the property at 1 mil and put in FD at 4%, the return would be 40K pa.

Same when property bought at high price.
Bought at 1 mil, but if now worth 700k,
One should view the property net worth is 700k or instead "syiok sendiri" again say the property worth 1 mil?

Yes, those are unrealised gain or net worth until one sells it off, but unrealised worth at market price, is the real worth one is having now.
That's why in accounting, we have unrealised gain vs realised gain difference.

Same with other assets, be it stock, unit trust or whatever, a yield should be justified based on current worth, to show the actual truth situation, so that one can make good decision on it.
*
Great explanation.
Dose that mean need 80k pa for rental only then meet he 8%pa? meaning 6.6k per month.
A few houses I see worth 1.2 also rented out as 2.5k per month at lost 3.5k barely touch 5k....

Meaning the owner is at lost?
I thought as long as the rental can cover all expenses and loan amount (per month) consider an ok condition? If having surplus eg: loan 400 per month rent out 800 per month.

This post has been edited by [Ancient]-XinG-: Jul 17 2018, 09:29 PM
NightHeart
post Jul 17 2018, 09:38 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 17 2018, 09:26 PM)
Great explanation.
Dose that mean need 80k pa for rental only then meet he 8%pa? meaning 6.6k per month.
A few houses I see worth 1.2 also rented out as 2.5k per month at lost 3.5k barely touch 5k....

Meaning the owner is at lost?
*
Yes. As your property price increase, rental should increase in tandem too. But in reality it's not always the case. Buy & Sell market is often different from Rental market.

Some places, people dislike buying those properties but lotsa people wanna rent. So the rental rates increase, you can sometimes collect more rent than the monthly installment. On the other spectrum, there are places that people prefer to buy instead of rent. So the rental rates are low while the transacting price is high, this is a losing end for landlords.

icemanfx
post Jul 17 2018, 10:19 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 17 2018, 09:26 PM)
Great explanation.
Dose that mean need 80k pa for rental only then meet he 8%pa? meaning 6.6k per month.
A few houses I see worth 1.2 also rented out as 2.5k per month at lost 3.5k barely touch 5k....

Meaning the owner is at lost?
I thought as long as the rental can cover all expenses and loan amount (per month) consider an ok condition? If having surplus eg: loan 400 per month rent out 800 per month.
*
Except those bought years ago, if rental could cover loan instalment, qualified tenant would have bought.

with about 3% of adults in this country have over us$100k net worth, those could afford to retire early are few and far in between.


This post has been edited by icemanfx: Jul 17 2018, 11:01 PM
LoTek
post Jul 17 2018, 10:49 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,259 posts

Joined: Jan 2018
QUOTE(aspartame @ Jul 17 2018, 12:49 PM)
I find your thinking funny. If net worth is not valued at market price, then at what price? Cost price? Lol. Guess Warren Buffett is just a millionaire.
*
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 01:37 PM)
I wouldn't valued my properties at market price.

When you valued your property at market price, then the return from your rental income will drop unless he can raised the rental as he wish. He claims his average rental yield at 6%. Is the 6% yield on his property is based on market price or cost price? recommended by friends or clients.
*
Yields based on market price, total rental income p.a (income, not profit, in case anyone queries) is in 6 figures.





You know what this is turning ridiculous, as if I have to defend myself, stopped posting regularly especially with my old account due to noise, just starting to get busy with this account but I'm probably just going to back to being a reader whistling.gif Feel free to PM me if you want to chat.

This post has been edited by LoTek: Jul 17 2018, 10:51 PM
R93
post Jul 17 2018, 11:34 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
34 posts

Joined: Jul 2018
FI ultimately means that you can shape your life without taking money into consideration, FIRE doesn’t necessarily mean you have to quit your job, my first goal is to achieve FI, everyone "enough" number for retirement is different, to me, RM4mil with debt free is good enough. Saving money into EPF is the only saving I have smile.gif , if the average dividend is 5.6%, by age 55, my account should have at least RM1.5mil, so the dividend is sufficient to support my monthly expenses (hopefully Malaysia is not going bankruptcy or the inflation rate don't go beyond 10% wish.gif). However, it is still a long way to go... laugh.gif
MUM
post Jul 17 2018, 11:53 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(R93 @ Jul 17 2018, 11:34 PM)
FI ultimately means that you can shape your life without taking money into consideration, FIRE doesn’t necessarily mean you have to quit your job, my first goal is to achieve FI, everyone "enough" number for retirement is different, to me, RM4mil with debt free is good enough. Saving money into EPF is the only saving I have smile.gif , if the average dividend is 5.6%, by age 55, my account should have at least RM1.5mil, so the dividend is sufficient to support my monthly expenses (hopefully Malaysia is not going bankruptcy or the inflation rate don't go beyond 10%  wish.gif).  However, it is still a long way to go...  laugh.gif
*
thumbup.gif interesting .....
btw,...any idea what is the actual current inflation number per annum are for the past few years?
R93
post Jul 18 2018, 01:27 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
34 posts

Joined: Jul 2018
QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 17 2018, 11:53 PM)
thumbup.gif interesting .....
btw,...any idea what is the actual current inflation number per annum are for the past few years?
*
Some website shown the past few years data consumer inflation rate is <3% in average, I not sure how accurate is, I only know when the sugar price increase 10sen/kg, Teh tarik will increase 10sen as well devil.gif , any sifu can advise here? confused.gif
MUM
post Jul 18 2018, 06:32 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(R93 @ Jul 18 2018, 01:27 AM)
Some website shown the past few years data consumer inflation rate is <3% in average, I not sure how accurate is, I only know when the sugar price increase 10sen/kg, Teh tarik will increase 10sen as well devil.gif , any sifu can advise here?  confused.gif
*
sweat.gif Thus on this, ".....Saving money into EPF is the only saving I have , if the average dividend is 5.6%, by age 55, my account should have at least RM1.5mil, so the dividend is sufficient to support my monthly expenses ....", just be aware that the purchasing power of that RM1.5mil at that time will not be like what it is today... sweat.gif
R93
post Jul 18 2018, 07:02 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
34 posts

Joined: Jul 2018
QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 18 2018, 06:32 AM)
sweat.gif  Thus on this, ".....Saving money into EPF is the only saving I have  , if the average dividend is 5.6%, by age 55, my account should have at least RM1.5mil, so the dividend is sufficient to support my monthly expenses ....", just be aware that the purchasing power of that RM1.5mil at that time will not be like what it is today...  sweat.gif
*
oh ya, Rm1.5mil might be not enough at that time, in order to achieve FI, my plan is to sell one of the property next year, hopefully the market is still growing... blush.gif
MUM
post Jul 18 2018, 07:11 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(R93 @ Jul 18 2018, 07:02 AM)
oh ya, Rm1.5mil might be not enough at that time, in order to achieve FI, my plan is to sell one of the property next year, hopefully the market is still growing... blush.gif
*
hmm.gif mind sharing where to channel the proceed from the sale of your property to?
which investment vehicle?
some of the previous postings consider property as a good investment....
55665566
post Jul 18 2018, 08:26 AM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 18 2018, 07:11 AM)
hmm.gif mind sharing where to channel the proceed from the sale of your property to?
which investment vehicle?
some of the previous postings consider property as a good investment....
*
Personaly I don't trust property investment much if only for rental yield. If you want rental yield, you might as well go for REITS. No loans needed smaller capital.

Property for me is much like the capital appreciation. Although not all property price will increase, but most of them does. Its matter of more or less only.
toiletwater
post Jul 18 2018, 08:37 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
531 posts

Joined: Mar 2012


In my experience, there is a certain risk element (or some call it luck) to direct property investing. E.g, getting good reliable tenants, someone to buy the property off your hands at a higher price, things breaking down and needing repairs, good agents to sell/rent your property, market timings (imagine you have to sell the property for personal reasons, but the market is at the end of its boom cycle)

My relative has had sh*tty luck when it comes to tenants. He had to evict 2 tenants in the span of 12 months - which is time consuming and costly.

But this is also why the returns are on average much better than investing in property through REITS. Risk - reward tradeoff.
R93
post Jul 18 2018, 08:40 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
34 posts

Joined: Jul 2018
QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 18 2018, 07:11 AM)
hmm.gif mind sharing where to channel the proceed from the sale of your property to?
which investment vehicle?
some of the previous postings consider property as a good investment....
*
To be frank, my Malaysia properties are still stuck on the market bangwall.gif , I also looking for lubang to sell.... since the US property market is still hot, will sell the US property next year to achieve my FI goal icon_idea.gif
rapple
post Jul 18 2018, 08:52 AM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 17 2018, 05:15 PM)
Yes it's a great stepping stone indeed. Agree with you, the key is to find the balance between both that can help achieve their personal long term plan; whether to become a highly positioned person in the corporate world before retiring into a freelancer or to leave corporate world earlier & build own accounting firm. 
Seems like the opportunity presented at you now is gearing you towards existing corporate life earlier to pursue your own accounting firm  thumbup.gif
Opportunity comes & goes, capitalize on it while the window is still open.

Have you met or do you have client from the retail world?
*
When one window closes, another opens. I believe there's always opportunity around us, we just need to meet with the right people and a right timing.

Yes, I do have a few clients who is running retail businesses. They are running the business under sole-proprietorship, so their account is quite simple and lesser things to do compare to a Sdn Bhd. They don't use any invoicing software so the filing work it's just a nightmare.

Keeping track of cost for a retailer who sells lots of products, it'a challenge. I've thought about it, I think the best system should be those bar code system that supermarket uses but for a small SME to invest into those software it's a big investment. If you could code every single of them and then trace back using excel, I think it should do the trick.






MUM
post Jul 18 2018, 09:09 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(R93 @ Jul 18 2018, 08:40 AM)
To be frank, my Malaysia properties are still stuck on the market  bangwall.gif , I also looking for lubang to sell....  since the US property market is still hot, will sell the US property next year to achieve my FI goal  icon_idea.gif
*
thumbup.gif
since you have property in the US....mind sharing the legal fees amount like and any property gain tax applicable to aliens?

then mind sharing where to channel the proceed from the sale of your property to?
which investment vehicle?

notworthy.gif

This post has been edited by MUM: Jul 18 2018, 09:10 AM
R93
post Jul 18 2018, 10:06 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
34 posts

Joined: Jul 2018
QUOTE(MUM @ Jul 18 2018, 09:09 AM)
thumbup.gif
since you have property in the US....mind sharing the legal fees amount like and any property gain tax applicable to aliens?

then mind sharing where to channel the proceed from the sale of your property to?
which investment vehicle?

notworthy.gif
*
I forgot the legal fees blush.gif but the seller commission to agent is high, about 5-6% of the selling price, you may googled of the tax applicable icon_idea.gif

I ask my friend who work as property agent to sell my property happy.gif
MUM
post Jul 18 2018, 10:11 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(R93 @ Jul 18 2018, 10:06 AM)
I forgot the legal fees blush.gif but the seller commission to agent is high, about 5-6% of the selling price, you may googled of the tax applicable icon_idea.gif

I ask my friend who work as property agent to sell my property  happy.gif
*
wow...5~6% of the selling....
I think I don't need to google the tax applicable...for I don't have a property in the US for sale.
I think if the seller is an alien and really have a property for sale in the US, he/she should google the tax implications . icon_idea.gif

This post has been edited by MUM: Jul 18 2018, 10:17 AM
ShinG3e
post Jul 18 2018, 11:28 AM

o0o
******
Senior Member
1,550 posts

Joined: Feb 2013
QUOTE(SetsunaSoon @ Jul 3 2018, 05:48 PM)
My current age is 28.

It's hard to say because I am earning SGD salary but my plan is to have about RM3500 per month from my passive income portfolio when I reach FIRE.
I intend to diversify my portfolio by investing in income stocks listed in both SGX and Bursa.
*
similar goal. tongue.gif

but the difference is earning MYR. so it takes x3 longer to reach a passive income from dividend yields. mega_shok.gif

but yea i get the idea of getting paid while u just sit and wait. truly beautiful.
NightHeart
post Jul 18 2018, 11:42 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 18 2018, 08:52 AM)
When one window closes, another opens. I believe there's always opportunity around us, we just need to meet with the right people and a right timing.

Yes, I do have a few clients who is running retail businesses. They are running the business under sole-proprietorship, so their account is quite simple and lesser things to do compare to a Sdn Bhd. They don't use any invoicing software so the filing work it's just a nightmare.

Keeping track of cost for a retailer who sells lots of products, it'a challenge. I've thought about it, I think the best system should be those bar code system that supermarket uses but for a small SME to invest into those software it's a big investment. If you could code every single of them and then trace back using excel, I think it should do the trick.
*
Don't use invoicing software? You're referring to softwares like Autocount, MYOB, Peachtree or cloud ones like Financio, Biztory & QuickBooks? Then each & every sale will have an physical invoice generated? Only half of my sales have invoices i.e. sale to other businesses (B2B). While my B2C sales don't have any physical invoices. So ideally even my B2C should have an invoice too for my own recording & filing?

Yes I am facing a huge problem tracking my cost, especially to determine my COGS. My COGS fluctuates so regularly to the point that in my inventory, even for the same identical product, they has different COGS because they're bought at different periods. Is there any method to solve this challenge with MS Excel? Barcoding may solve this issue because each item details can be captured & tracked. But woah, the software alone will cost several thousand, the printer will cost several hundred & the stickers will cost few hundreds too. Then not to mention the labor cost to stick the barcode on all the products during inbound phase rclxub.gif
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 18 2018, 11:58 AM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 17 2018, 09:38 PM)
Yes. As your property price increase, rental should increase in tandem too. But in reality it's not always the case. Buy & Sell market is often different from Rental market.

Some places, people dislike buying those properties but lotsa people wanna rent. So the rental rates increase, you can sometimes collect more rent than the monthly installment. On the other spectrum, there are places that people prefer to buy instead of rent. So the rental rates are low while the transacting price is high, this is a losing end for landlords.
*
QUOTE(icemanfx @ Jul 17 2018, 10:19 PM)
Except those bought years ago, if rental could cover loan instalment, qualified tenant would have bought.

with about 3% of adults in this country have over us$100k net worth, those could afford to retire early are few and far in between.
*
but as a rule of thumb. Isnt that rental more than loan amount considered an ok investment. But for sure haven't factor in other fees of course.
Because as I notice, some prop can project real high and the rental cant even pick up to 6% of the prop market value. Because it will be ridiculous to rent a house of 8k per month for a prop of market value of 1.0.

QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 17 2018, 10:49 PM)
Yields based on market price, total rental income p.a (income, not profit, in case anyone queries) is in 6 figures.
You know what this is turning ridiculous, as if I have to defend myself, stopped posting regularly especially with my old account due to noise, just starting to get busy with this account but I'm probably just going to back to being a reader whistling.gif Feel free to PM me if you want to chat.
*
Nani, you dupeeeee??
oh god whyyyy
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 18 2018, 12:01 PM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
QUOTE(55665566 @ Jul 18 2018, 08:26 AM)
Personaly I don't trust property investment much if only for rental yield. If you want rental yield, you might as well go for REITS. No loans needed smaller capital.

Property for me is much like the capital appreciation. Although not all property price will increase, but most of them does. Its matter of more or less only.
*
REIT market perf ok nowadays? seems so shaky beside the dividend paid. Capital appreciation shaky.

I know some place is a strategic place and sure got tenant due to booming. But not enough cash for dp. Saddddd
ch_leong
post Jul 18 2018, 12:04 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
439 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


Property is long term asset/low liquidity you calculate at book/cost value. Furthermore you have debts on the property.

Stock is a short term/mid term asset/high liquidity you calculate at market value.

Use this method will be easy and handy.

On the other hand, you can apply fair value to your property / stock if you really want to calculate the yield. Of course Fair Value is very subjective but you will have better feel. E.g. Bought XXX apartment 400K. Current Market Value is 600K. So you think you can sell it immediately for 560K. Then U can apply 'Fair Value' as 560K to use it in your yield calculation. Fair Value is very useful but you have to be honest. If you buy 500K and current market value at 300K and actually you think you can only sell it at 260K, so you will apply fair value between 260K-300K.

Applying which value in yield calculation will depends on your honesty and feel good factor.

BTW, I'm not talking about Accounting for company.

QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 17 2018, 02:39 PM)
You are right that yield will not shown in any net worth statement but it still comes from the properties.

How can you valued your properties at market price and have your yield based on the cost price. Isn't this misleading on the yield?

Are you going to calculate your dividends received against the current stock market value also?
*
rapple
post Jul 18 2018, 12:15 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 18 2018, 11:42 AM)
Don't use invoicing software? You're referring to softwares like Autocount, MYOB, Peachtree or cloud ones like Financio, Biztory & QuickBooks? Then each & every sale will have an physical invoice generated? Only half of my sales have invoices i.e. sale to other businesses (B2B). While my B2C sales don't have any physical invoices. So ideally even my B2C should have an invoice too for my own recording & filing?

Yes I am facing a huge problem tracking my cost, especially to determine my COGS. My COGS fluctuates so regularly to the point that in my inventory, even for the same identical product, they has different COGS because they're bought at different periods. Is there any method to solve this challenge with MS Excel? Barcoding may solve this issue because each item details can be captured & tracked. But woah, the software alone will cost several thousand, the printer will cost several hundred & the stickers will cost few hundreds too. Then not to mention the labor cost to stick the barcode on all the products during inbound phase  rclxub.gif
*
Yes, no software at all. That's why filing those invoices back to sequence it's a nightmare. All books invoice starts with different numbering and to keep cost low they just purchase those cash book from stationary shops. puke.gif

For B2C you could just sum them up once a month and generate an invoice for your own keeping.

Use those colorful stickers that you can find on stationary shops. Not sure what those are called.

Then stick it on every single one of your products:-

Product A purchase on 23/01/2018 cost 60 - Code as A230120180060
Product B purchase on 23/01/2018 cost 70 - Code as B230120180070

When you sell, just key in the code then excel should be able to sort or show the things you need.

Any good stock control need time to implement and a trustworthy staff to manage it without that, the best software also can't help it.

I do have a excel template cater for this due to client requested a control and also me to do stock check mad.gif ranting.gif

Not sure if it will help you, but if you need the template I can send it to you.






icemanfx
post Jul 18 2018, 12:20 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(ch_leong @ Jul 18 2018, 12:04 PM)
Property is long term asset/low liquidity you calculate at book/cost value. Furthermore you have debts on the property.

Stock is a short term/mid term asset/high liquidity you calculate at market value.

Use this method will be easy and handy.

On the other hand, you can apply fair value to your property / stock if you really want to calculate the yield. Of course Fair Value is very subjective but you will have better feel. E.g. Bought XXX apartment 400K. Current Market Value is 600K. So you think you can sell it immediately for 560K. Then U can apply 'Fair Value' as 560K to use it in your yield calculation. Fair Value is very useful but you have to be honest. If you buy 500K and current market value at 300K and actually you think you can only sell it at 260K, so you will apply fair value between 260K-300K.

Applying which value in yield calculation will depends on your honesty and feel good factor.

BTW, I'm not talking about Accounting for company.
*
Property unlike stocks, commodities, Bitcoin, etc is not trade on exchange. Difference between asking/perceived market price and transacted price could be significant. Except during bull run, vendor asking/perceived market price is often syok sendiri.

Many invested in property because of leverage. Leverage is a double edges sword, amplify profit as well as losses.

Given growing magnitude of oversupply in kv property, price is expected to stay depressed for extended periods.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Jul 18 2018, 12:23 PM
NightHeart
post Jul 18 2018, 12:25 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 18 2018, 11:58 AM)
but as a rule of thumb. Isnt that rental more than loan amount considered an ok investment. But for sure haven't factor in other fees of course.
Because as I notice, some prop can project real high and the rental cant even pick up to 6% of the prop market value. Because it will be ridiculous to rent a house of 8k per month for a prop of market value of 1.0.
*
Rather than calling it a rule of thumb, I'd prefer to call it an ideal scenario laugh.gif
It really depends on what you're trying to achieve; capital gains from flipping or steady income from rental. Those aiming for

A lot of people shares the same rule of thumb like you too, met a lot of them already. That's why you see sometimes a unit is left empty for so long without tenant cause the landlord stubbornly refuse to rent below their monthly installment despite most other landlords around them are renting at a significantly lower price. Mostly is due to ego la haha & they're super rich anyway with multiple units around KL vacant. They easily can afford to go tenant-less for years, I was so so so tempted to become their property manager to earn some pocket money from short termed tenants until they get a long term tenant laugh.gif

If you're in the property market, you'll know which developer's project can buy & which developer to ignore one la. Some developers are indeed hopeless, so don't need waste time with their projects. Especially those that are busy promoting in the malls & every property events. Good projects will be half sold already before launching - internal staffs including the boss & all their friends will sapu first.

I bought a brand new property in Shah Alam for RM180k, been collecting rental 20% higher than my monthly installment. After RPGT is gone, hopefully can sell RM300k+ & snowball to next project.

NightHeart
post Jul 18 2018, 12:34 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 18 2018, 12:15 PM)
Use those colorful stickers that you can find on stationary shops. Not sure what those are called.

Then stick it on every single one of your products:-

Product A purchase on 23/01/2018 cost 60 - Code as A230120180060
Product B purchase on 23/01/2018 cost 70 - Code as B230120180070

When you sell, just key in the code then excel should be able to sort or show the things you need.

Any good stock control need time to implement and a trustworthy staff to manage it without that, the best software also can't help it.

I do have a excel template cater for this due to client requested a control and also me to do stock check mad.gif  ranting.gif

Not sure if it will help you, but if you need the template I can send it to you.
*
Ho mai gaddd.....that's basically a manual barcode method aka stone age barcoding lol.gif
Only viable for those al-cheapo misers lol, this method will make accountant smile but retailer puke puke.gif Looks like for this issue, somebody have to puke - either the accountant or the retailer lol.gif
rapple
post Jul 18 2018, 12:59 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 18 2018, 12:34 PM)
Ho mai gaddd.....that's basically a manual barcode method aka stone age barcoding  lol.gif
Only viable for those al-cheapo misers lol, this method will make accountant smile but retailer puke  puke.gif  Looks like for this issue, somebody have to puke - either the accountant or the retailer lol.gif
*
el-cheapo thumbup.gif "a cents to them it's as big as a tractor wheel"

Even though it's a very traditional way of doing it but it does serve it purpose.

1 of my client also uses stock cards, and they are a big group of companies.

They are super rich but they are always the last to go home from their office. notworthy.gif
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Jul 18 2018, 01:16 PM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 18 2018, 12:25 PM)
Rather than calling it a rule of thumb, I'd prefer to call it an ideal scenario  laugh.gif
It really depends on what you're trying to achieve; capital gains from flipping or steady income from rental. Those aiming for

A lot of people shares the same rule of thumb like you too, met a lot of them already. That's why you see sometimes a unit is left empty for so long without tenant cause the landlord stubbornly refuse to rent below their monthly installment despite most other landlords around them are renting at a significantly lower price. Mostly is due to ego la haha & they're super rich anyway with multiple units around KL vacant. They easily can afford to go tenant-less for years, I was so so so tempted to become their property manager to earn some pocket money from short termed tenants until they get a long term tenant  laugh.gif

If you're in the property market, you'll know which developer's project can buy & which developer to ignore one la. Some developers are indeed hopeless, so don't need waste time with their projects. Especially those that are busy promoting in the malls & every property events. Good projects will be half sold already before launching - internal staffs including the boss & all their friends will sapu first.

I bought a brand new property in Shah Alam for RM180k, been collecting rental 20% higher than my monthly installment. After RPGT is gone, hopefully can sell RM300k+ & snowball to next project.
*
I am not flipper type.
I just want to have capital growth and rental income only.
if the market not allowed to be rent more than loan, what to do? just follow lo. we can't do shit. that's why must look location and dev also. don't just buy for the sake of buy.
I got one low cost apartment unit in selayang. many years ago la. 90k only. loan 400 per month flat using gov loan. rent out 600 per month. quite ok la. recent 3 years up to 750. the rental there really stagnant like that. I can't do much also. but good thing is only fork out 9k for the unit. lol.
spiderman17
post Jul 18 2018, 01:31 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
309 posts

Joined: Nov 2011
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 18 2018, 11:42 AM)
Don't use invoicing software? You're referring to softwares like Autocount, MYOB, Peachtree or cloud ones like Financio, Biztory & QuickBooks? Then each & every sale will have an physical invoice generated? Only half of my sales have invoices i.e. sale to other businesses (B2B). While my B2C sales don't have any physical invoices. So ideally even my B2C should have an invoice too for my own recording & filing?

Yes I am facing a huge problem tracking my cost, especially to determine my COGS. My COGS fluctuates so regularly to the point that in my inventory, even for the same identical product, they has different COGS because they're bought at different periods. Is there any method to solve this challenge with MS Excel? Barcoding may solve this issue because each item details can be captured & tracked. But woah, the software alone will cost several thousand, the printer will cost several hundred & the stickers will cost few hundreds too. Then not to mention the labor cost to stick the barcode on all the products during inbound phase  rclxub.gif
*
why not track the COGS as a running average for each product? when buying, add $ to inventory value, add count to inventory count.
when selling, reduce 1x average cost from inventory value, and reduce one count from inventory count.
NightHeart
post Jul 18 2018, 02:01 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 18 2018, 12:59 PM)
el-cheapo  thumbup.gif "a cents to them it's as big as a tractor wheel"

Even though it's a very traditional way of doing it but it does serve it purpose.

1 of my client also uses stock cards, and they are a big group of companies.

They are super rich but they are always the last to go home from their office.  notworthy.gif
*
Ok, I'll put more thoughts into it & see if can innovate something from there or not flex.gif

QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Jul 18 2018, 01:16 PM)
I am not flipper type.
I just want to have capital growth and rental income only.
if the market not allowed to be rent more than loan, what to do? just follow lo. we can't do shit. that's why must look location and dev also. don't just buy for the sake of buy.
I got one low cost apartment unit in selayang. many years ago la. 90k only. loan 400 per month flat using gov loan. rent out 600 per month. quite ok la. recent 3 years up to 750. the rental there really stagnant like that. I can't do much also. but good thing is only fork out 9k for the unit. lol.
*
If you're not a flipper, then find those places that you foresee people would prefer to rent than to buy. Then the rental market will increase & hopefully exceed the monthly installment. Yes it's mainly the market forces in action.

QUOTE(spiderman17 @ Jul 18 2018, 01:31 PM)
why not track the COGS as a running average for each product? when buying, add $ to inventory value, add count to inventory count.
when selling, reduce 1x average cost from inventory value, and reduce one count from inventory count.
*
Hang on, I'm lost half way there cause I suck at accounting - need more layman terms lol.gif
Basically when I buy, I add in the actual cost incurred value into the inventory?
But when I sell, i minus off an average cost instead? If that's the case, the figures won't tally no even when I sell off the whole inventory? Cause a variable cost is added in while a fixed cost is minus-ed out.
rapple
post Jul 18 2018, 03:16 PM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Jul 18 2018, 02:01 PM)
Ok, I'll put more thoughts into it & see if can innovate something from there or not  flex.gif
If you're not a flipper, then find those places that you foresee people would prefer to rent than to buy. Then the rental market will increase & hopefully exceed the monthly installment. Yes it's mainly the market forces in action.
Hang on, I'm lost half way there cause I suck at accounting - need more layman terms lol.gif
Basically when I buy, I add in the actual cost incurred value into the inventory?
But when I sell, i minus off an average cost instead? If that's the case, the figures won't tally no even when I sell off the whole inventory? Cause a variable cost is added in while a fixed cost is minus-ed out.
*
Attached Image

Average cost would be easier to do.

FIFO gives a more accurate profit margin.


NightHeart
post Jul 18 2018, 04:43 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(rapple @ Jul 18 2018, 03:16 PM)
Attached Image

Average cost would be easier to do.

FIFO gives a more accurate profit margin.
*
Thanks! I'll research further into that, hopefully it won't be too confusing to me thumbsup.gif
TruboXL
post Jul 29 2018, 05:58 PM

Keep on keeping on! 👍
******
Senior Member
1,050 posts

Joined: Jan 2016
From: Land of floods, Kota Tinggi


QUOTE(LoTek @ Jul 15 2018, 06:26 PM)
I see my post is dubious to many.

Since my studies was fully covered including expenses, whatever I earned part time, i slowly brought back home, its 5 figures in SGD. And no I'm not in some illegal or immoral industry. I worked all sorts of jobs there in whatever spare time I had, photography, crew, promoter, tutor...anywhere from 8-50 sgd an hour type of jobs. Since starting full time work, which started in KL and still is in KL, my income has always been in 5 figure territory. I do not only rely on FD to grow savings that is not invested in props.

1st and 2nd prop is residential, subsequent is commercial. 1st was a mistake, bought from dev, yield is just over 4% which don't even meet the interest: am trying to exit. 2nd was the effort of 8 months of patience, non stop viewing and lowballing sellers until I got a unit more than 6 figures below market value. Believe seller was in dire financial difficulties, and he actually already had an interested buyer, who just wanted to push him another few k down from his asking, I offered to buy at the asking price and got it. Student rental play prop, yield is 9% counted at the market value, more than 10% at the price I got, incl renovate and furnish. I don't think I am not overestimating the value of my props: I take an average of the latest transactions listed on brickz and from the owner group chats.

Sorry to those who feel bad or disbelieve me, I'm being honest, I don't want to boast, I just wanted to inspire some young people my age smile.gif and its not about the income. Its about the discipline in work, expenses and investments. Some of my work days are as long as 14 hours when I need to. Never buy investments without weeks (or months) of study, made that mistake on my first prop. Never overspend. Some of my friends with 4k income a month probably think I earn less than them, from my lifestyle. I grew up in my grandfathers' attic, sleeping on the floor, eating rice with fruits and veges that me and my grandma stole from neighbours' gardens (sorry guys XD) or expiring old meat that my uncle, a wet market worker, was allowed to bring home. When I see people my age spending 110% of their income, with the 10% from parents or credit, and all the spending going to non investment expenditure, it just pisses me off.
*
good you have let me sink bottom to depression

i am in early 20s, still in uni and haven't even join the workforce yet and already start reading this full of boasting thread

damn working towards fi look tough for me t.t
Singh_Kalan
post Jul 29 2018, 06:43 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,031 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
QUOTE(55665566 @ Jul 4 2018, 10:50 AM)
Age 25, aim to retire at 45 with RM500k in ASX while pay off all debts and live happily ever after. Why is it impossible?
*
I knew someone close that FI/RE at age 38 with more than RM 1M in net worth. RE is not his option but its because of the company had wound up. Due to lack of motivation to work for other ppl, he decided to concentrate on investment alone. Now with alot of freetime, same lifestyle/spending and networth keep increasing.

This post has been edited by Singh_Kalan: Jul 29 2018, 06:48 PM
Ramjade
post Jul 29 2018, 07:23 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(TruboXL @ Jul 29 2018, 05:58 PM)
good you have let me sink bottom to depression

i am in early 20s, still in uni and haven't even join the workforce yet and already start reading this full of boasting thread

damn working towards fi look tough for me t.t
*
Start early. Be super frugal. With more cash on hand, you have more money to invest.

There are only 2 ways to make more money
1) save more
2) earn more

Are you prepared to give up YOLO lifestyle/overseas vacation? I am. Have been doing it since I was in 2ndary school.
cynthusc
post Jul 29 2018, 08:01 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
503 posts

Joined: Nov 2006
Interesting discussion. I believe I am FI but I am not interested in RE bcos I am already doing what I like. I started my business at 32 and am now 10 years in. The first 2 years was hard but manageable. I guess since I am a giggolo and not a prostitute (to borrow Showtime's analogy) I have no interest in retiring early. I love what I do. My normal work day is 11 am to 4pm with occasional all nighters. I am not interested much in luxury vehicles and items but I do enjoy travelling 3 to 4 times a year. Not 5 star travelling but more 3 star with the occasional 4 star. I intend to continue this semi retired lifestyle well into my 60s or 70s if health permits because I realise that I am not cut out for staying at home, gardening and the like.
coolguy_0925
post Jul 29 2018, 08:38 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,537 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
Just curious on the following 2 points:-

1. What is the true definition of FI? Able to sustain even without active income?
2. If RE like 40yo, won't be too boring doing nothing? Because with no active income it is hard to travel or "enjoy" every now and then and more like living a savvy lifestyle and only can afford once or twice trips a year

Again, just curious smile.gif
Ramjade
post Jul 29 2018, 09:20 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(coolguy_0925 @ Jul 29 2018, 08:38 PM)
Just curious on the following 2 points:-

1. What is the true definition of FI? Able to sustain even without active income?
2. If RE like 40yo, won't be too boring doing nothing? Because with no active income it is hard to travel or "enjoy" every now and then and more like living a savvy lifestyle and only can afford once or twice trips a year

Again, just curious smile.gif
*
1. Yes able to sustain without the need to work.
2. Nope. Not if you have plenty of things to do. So many things you can do with the the freed up time instead of clocking in 9-5 or more than that.
coolguy_0925
post Jul 29 2018, 09:30 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,537 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Jul 29 2018, 09:20 PM)
1. Yes able to sustain without the need to work.
2. Nope. Not if you have plenty of things to do. So many things you can do with the the freed up time instead of clocking in 9-5 or more than that.
*
FI if single I think it is possible with determination to save and invest. But if with wife and kids...

I think if RE one thing we can do is live a healthy life, eat breakfast, lunch before 1pm, dinner before 6pm and sleep early. Of course no work stress and unrealistic expectations
Ramjade
post Jul 29 2018, 09:46 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(coolguy_0925 @ Jul 29 2018, 09:30 PM)
FI if single I think it is possible with determination to save and invest. But if with wife and kids...

I think if RE one thing we can do is live a healthy life, eat breakfast, lunch before 1pm, dinner before 6pm and sleep early. Of course no work stress and unrealistic expectations
*
Possible if your wife/panther is the frugal type. Not possible if your opposite likes YOLO lifestyle/freq go for overseas holiday
kingz113
post Jul 29 2018, 10:05 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
323 posts

Joined: Jul 2006


I think the transition to FI takes some practice and you really have to make an effort to ensure your passive income replaces your income on a monthly basis.

I've heard of some possible strategies like
1. Opening few FD that matures every month.
2. Living on rental income
3. Living on shares dividends.
4. 4% withdrawal rule
5. Living off a set amount of savings and let the above replenishes itself from the above.

Curious to know some real FI strategies that you guys implement.

Personally we are a young family, 31 and after some business opportunity that paid off, we have accumulated enough assets to be FI.

We have a few investment properties which the loan is paying itself off thru rental.

Something that I did consider was to paying off all our loans, but the yield on investment property staggers around 4%, which is pretty poor considering FD rates are higher.

Thus we have this net worth that's locked up in diversified investments, but they don't necessarily translate to monthly income. For me to be perfectly FI is to generate the highest return for my assets, yet liquid enough to provide me with at least a quarterly income.

However as a passive investor, I rarely cash in on my investments and it just sits in the account growing. Will be interested in some advice as to how people with large amounts of equities or UT turns it into a fixed stream of income.

As of now, I'm just continuing my biz to pay off monthly expenses. We have alot of disposable income every month (55-65%) even without cashing in on our investment returns. We are not frugal but not lavish spenders either. I'm just afraid of losing this flexibility if i close up my biz and purely depend on my investments.


chonghe
post Aug 6 2018, 07:11 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


I like the idea of financial freedom/independence, mainly because of the option to quit the job if I want to, no need to hang on to the job just because of the paycheck
This world is realistic, any company can, and will sack anyone if they would like to, as long as they can find a cheaper substitute.
So we have got to have an option for ourselves, i.e., our plan B

Have been working towards it for few years

Don't think RM 1M is enough though, perhaps at least RM 5M, enough to separate a few portions, e.g., 1 for FD, 1 for long term investment and 1 for short term investment or the like (didn't plan for so details as things changes all the time)
Anyway I tihink if can reach RM 5M net capital, then with the ability, there should be no problem at all to be FI/RE and do the things that I want to do

All the best guys
aspartame
post Aug 6 2018, 09:07 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(chonghe @ Aug 6 2018, 07:11 PM)
I like the idea of financial freedom/independence, mainly because of the option to quit the job if I want to, no need to hang on to the job just because of the paycheck
This world is realistic, any company can, and will sack anyone if they would like to, as long as they can find a cheaper substitute.
So we have got to have an option for ourselves, i.e., our plan B

Have been working towards it for few years

Don't think RM 1M is enough though, perhaps at least RM 5M, enough to separate a few portions, e.g., 1 for FD, 1 for long term investment and 1 for short term investment or the like (didn't plan for so details as things changes all the time)
Anyway I tihink if can reach RM 5M net capital, then with the ability, there should be no problem at all to be FI/RE and do the things that I want to do

All the best guys
*
To be safe, need at least RM10mil.

Dividend Magic
post Aug 6 2018, 09:27 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
376 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
Nice! FIRE arrives on Lowyat.

Count me in as another FI person here. Working towards RM3K a month in passive income currently. Not even half way there. =(
TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 6 2018, 10:33 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(Dividend Magic @ Aug 6 2018, 09:27 PM)
Nice! FIRE arrives on Lowyat.

Count me in as another FI person here. Working towards RM3K a month in passive income currently. Not even half way there. =(
*
Well done bro. Keep on sharing your journey, tips and any obstacles that you faced.


flight
post Aug 7 2018, 01:30 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
So easy make millions meh..
TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 7 2018, 01:56 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


I keep wondering do we really need to have 5-10mil in order to achieve FI and can have option (peace of mind) to RE?

Maybe YES for some of us that now maybe spending more than 20k permonth. (Active income should be more than that).

For average people, with avg household income maybe RM10k permonth I believe they dont need that high $$$ in order to achieve FI. (Or rather wont get that much from active job).

Myself, family with one kid spent less than 50% of active income. So, my thinking if I have enough savings and investment that can generates 40%-60% of passive income, I can fired my boss (if I want to, and what I did last month).

Take a short break, and will learn and doing new things that maybe can generates additional incomes.

Or maybe after a while or if company offered a job, can consider to go back to do what you good at. But this time by choice and not because of bills to pay.


wongmunkeong
post Aug 7 2018, 11:10 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 7 2018, 01:56 AM)
I keep wondering do we really need to have 5-10mil in order to achieve FI and can have option (peace of mind) to RE?

Maybe YES for some of us that now maybe spending more than 20k permonth. (Active income should be more than that).

For average people, with avg household income maybe RM10k permonth I believe they dont need that high $$$ in order to achieve FI. (Or rather wont get that much from active job).

Myself, family with one kid spent less than 50% of active income. So, my thinking if I have enough savings and investment that can generates 40%-60% of passive income, I can fired my boss (if I want to, and what I did last month).

Take a short break, and will learn and doing new things that maybe can generates additional incomes.

Or maybe after a while or if company offered a job, can consider to go back to do what you good at. But this time by choice and not because of bills to pay.
*
Agreed.
Lots of folks can't even hit the basic level of financial freedom (ie. BASIC living, not lifeSTYLE) BUT one shot want to hit level 2 or 3 liao.
Step by step is the best - achieve "level basic" first, then think about adding gravy if wanted. If i looked at the gravy only, instead of hitting the basic living first, i'd have totally given up before trying tongue.gif

----------------
To share simple maths on "how much is enough" (my own PoV la, for those who's unsure or totally no idea how much they need):
1. Life style expenses wanted in future value of $ = current value of $ * (1+4%)^years
eg. 60K pa *(1+4% inflation per year) ^20 years time
= $131,467.39 pa needed in future value of $

2. Minimum investments/savings needed to generate (1.) pa = $131,467.39 / 4% returns = $3,286,684.71
Note - eg uses FD only. If U are an asset allocator & investor, 6%pa on total is very doable, thus need way less seeding / investment assets.

3. To be safe, assuming we spend only half of (2.) + invest the other half to keep ahead of inflation = $6,573,369.43
This is the safest place to be - high probability to be able to leave something behind +have safety buffers.

NOTEs:
a. the above, even (2.) is assuming we do not eat into the seed capital / investment assets, just skimming 4%pa off the top, thus (2.) works as if one doesn't plan to leave $ behind. To be even safer (i'm a worrier, so...)

b. (3.) would be a "safer place" + U may want to run Monte Carlo simulations on your projections (at least 1000 iterations) if your assets are allocated in highly fluctuating investment assets, eg. in stocks, businesses even properties (look at rentals for residentials & offices nowadays due to the overhangs)

Just sharing PoVs ya - no absolute right/wrong in personal financial planning. It is PERSONAL after all.

This post has been edited by wongmunkeong: Aug 7 2018, 11:15 AM
sky18
post Aug 7 2018, 11:48 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
calling simplylegendary on FIRE topic.

Once you exceed the basic need of living, the "PERSONAL" FI magic figure is very subjective. To be more precise, you had to track your networth, spending and what's your anticipation on future expanses(eg: travel, big ticket like house or car upgrade, daddy/mummy-kasi fund). The later part is more important to folks calling for RE before 40+ and below OR those still single & planned to establish family with kids.








icemanfx
post Aug 7 2018, 11:54 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(wongmunkeong @ Aug 7 2018, 11:10 AM)
Agreed.
Lots of folks can't even hit the basic level of financial freedom (ie. BASIC living, not lifeSTYLE) BUT one shot want to hit level 2 or 3 liao.
Step by step is the best - achieve "level basic" first, then think about adding gravy if wanted. If i looked at the gravy only, instead of hitting the basic living first, i'd have totally given up before trying tongue.gif

----------------
To share simple maths on "how much is enough" (my own PoV la, for those who's unsure or totally no idea how much they need):
1. Life style expenses wanted in future value of $ = current value of $ * (1+4%)^years
eg. 60K pa *(1+4% inflation per year) ^20 years time
= $131,467.39 pa needed in future value of $

2. Minimum investments/savings needed to generate (1.) pa = $131,467.39 / 4% returns = $3,286,684.71
Note - eg uses FD only. If U are an asset allocator & investor, 6%pa on total is very doable, thus need way less seeding / investment assets.

3. To be safe, assuming we spend only half of (2.) + invest the other half to keep ahead of inflation =  $6,573,369.43
This is the safest place to be - high probability to be able to leave something behind +have safety buffers.

NOTEs:
a. the above, even (2.) is assuming we do not eat into the seed capital / investment assets, just skimming 4%pa off the top, thus (2.) works as if one doesn't plan to leave $ behind. To be even safer (i'm a worrier, so...)

b. (3.) would be a "safer place" + U may want to run Monte Carlo simulations on your projections (at least 1000 iterations) if your assets are allocated in highly fluctuating investment assets, eg. in stocks, businesses even properties (look at rentals for residentials & offices nowadays due to the overhangs)

Just sharing PoVs ya - no absolute right/wrong in personal financial planning. It is PERSONAL after all.
*
According to reports, less than 0.4% of adults in this country have over us$1m net worth.

sky18
post Aug 7 2018, 12:27 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 7 2018, 11:54 AM)
According to reports, less than 0.4% of adults in this country have over us$1m net worth.
*
Source? Individual or household?
wongmunkeong
post Aug 7 2018, 12:52 PM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 7 2018, 11:54 AM)
According to reports, less than 0.4% of adults in this country have over us$1m net worth.
*
IMHO, even at USD$1M net worth, may not be enough due to:
1. extreme "gravy wanted" / lifeSTYLE
2. net worth includes non-$ making items like home, cars, super bikes, yatchts (?!!), etc. tongue.gif
3. ever inflating lifeSTYLE due to more income, instead of tapering off once certain comfort levels have been reached
icemanfx
post Aug 7 2018, 01:02 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(sky18 @ Aug 7 2018, 12:27 PM)
Source? Individual or household?
*
Wealth report by investment bank. Adults.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Aug 7 2018, 01:03 PM
TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 7 2018, 01:23 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


We cannot always look-look up up and keep competing with our rich friends or neighbours.

Sometimes we need to look down at less fortunate people and see how they can live happily while managing their tight household incomes. If we lucky to get higher active income but keep our lifestyle like people less fortunate (not too extremely frugal), I’m quite sure that many people can achieve FI.

Also still living happily with our beloved family.
wongmunkeong
post Aug 7 2018, 01:57 PM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 7 2018, 01:23 PM)
We cannot always look-look up up and keep competing with our rich friends or neighbours.

Sometimes we need to look down at less fortunate people and see how they can live happily while managing their tight household incomes. If we lucky to get higher active income but keep our lifestyle like people less fortunate (not too extremely frugal),  I’m quite sure that many people can achieve FI.

Also still living happily with our beloved family.
*
momma says - one mountain got one mountain higher tongue.gif
thus, best to compare with oneself, ie. yesterday's self and try to better that.
maybe different mommas teach different things kua laugh.gif , ie. some teach children to keep up with the Joneses brows.gif

This post has been edited by wongmunkeong: Aug 7 2018, 01:57 PM
cherroy
post Aug 7 2018, 03:21 PM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(wongmunkeong @ Aug 7 2018, 12:52 PM)
IMHO, even at USD$1M net worth, may not be enough due to:
1. extreme "gravy wanted" / lifeSTYLE
2. net worth includes non-$ making items like home, cars, super bikes, yatchts (?!!), etc. tongue.gif
3. ever inflating lifeSTYLE due to more income, instead of tapering off once certain comfort levels have been reached
*
If net worth including car, and home, then it is not good yield stick to determine FI.

It is ability to generate passive income from the gross/net worth which is more important that determine the FI.
Eg.
A lives in a house that worth 5.5 mil, but has nothing else, A net worth is 5.5 mil. But has zero passive income, A is not FI at this point, until A liquidates the house.

B lives in 500k house, and has other investment/asset worth 5 mil that generates 5% average or 250K pa passive income, B is FI.

Cash money is needed for paying daily expenses, not net worth.
Don't be surprise this cashflow management 101 that even some big corporate, listed company failed to do so.
sky18
post Aug 7 2018, 04:25 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(wongmunkeong @ Aug 7 2018, 12:52 PM)
IMHO, even at USD$1M net worth, may not be enough due to:
1. extreme "gravy wanted" / lifeSTYLE
2. net worth includes non-$ making items like home, cars, super bikes, yatchts (?!!), etc. tongue.gif
3. ever inflating lifeSTYLE due to more income, instead of tapering off once certain comfort levels have been reached
*
Nowaday its more effective manifest your thoughts in opposite ways. biggrin.gif

One more year syndrome always hit FIRE folks when reached original target, finding contentment is way more important prior calling for RE. Kudos to meonkutu11
chonghe
post Aug 9 2018, 10:03 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


If 5M then based on 4% FD it is about 200k/year which is about 17k per month

It definitely looks a lot for now, even for a family with a reasonable good lifestyle

I think the main consideration here is in the future 10 years or so perhaps there is no more guarantee return of 4% per year in FD, who knows the interest rate will decrease to a new low. Therefore at least RM 5M is just to be safe and worry free.

Again I think if someone can achieve RM 5M current asset (easily disposable to generate cash such as bank savings, stocks, unit trust etc), then his/her ability at that time will be enough to continue surviving, and growing the capital without working
TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 9 2018, 10:36 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(chonghe @ Aug 9 2018, 10:03 PM)
If 5M then based on 4% FD it is about 200k/year which is about 17k per month

It definitely looks a lot for now, even for a family with a reasonable good lifestyle

I think the main consideration here is in the future 10 years or so perhaps there is no more guarantee return of 4% per year in FD, who knows the interest rate will decrease to a new low. Therefore at least RM 5M is just to be safe and worry free.

Again I think if someone can achieve RM 5M current asset (easily disposable to generate cash such as bank savings, stocks, unit trust etc), then his/her ability at that time will be enough to continue surviving, and growing the capital without working
*
Fully agree that some of people need this much. Maybe current lifestyle and commitments with kids and etc needing that much monthly expenses. But thats some of us, and I believe not the most of people.

If you see not many getting their salary growth passes 10k in 10years. Take government servant for example but we will see even with 2-3 kids, they are managing their life better.

Even fresh graduates now, when I started (11yrs ago) around 2500 and I believe that company still paid freshie with same basic salary.

My point is, I believe in 10years time, we maybe dont need x3,x4,x5 of our current expenses in order to survive. Even so, we always can do side job/part time to get additional income. Rather than keep stuck in rat race thinking that we still dont have enough money (which will never enough).

People say “reducing/controlling our expenses is easier than increasing our income”.

-Only my opinion-


wongmunkeong
post Aug 10 2018, 09:41 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 9 2018, 10:36 PM)
Fully agree that some of people need this much. Maybe current lifestyle and commitments with kids and etc needing that much monthly expenses. But thats some of us, and I believe not the most of people.

If you see not many getting their salary growth passes 10k in 10years. Take government servant for example but we will see even with 2-3 kids, they are managing their life better.

Even fresh graduates now, when I started (11yrs ago) around 2500 and I believe that company still paid freshie with same basic salary.

My point is, I believe in 10years time, we maybe dont need x3,x4,x5 of our current expenses in order to survive. Even so, we always can do side job/part time to get additional income. Rather than keep stuck in rat race thinking that we still dont have enough money (which will never enough).

People say “reducing/controlling our expenses is easier than increasing our income”.

-Only my opinion-
*
reminds me of 'The quality of the Question greatly affects the quality of the Answer" laugh.gif

eg.
when we dunno how much we need /for goals/whys
AND how much we have,
thus can plan & explore how to "get there",
HOW la to "have enough" leh? "Enough" also no idea what number or why

Thus, the Q of "how much is enough".. maybe better Qs are "what do i want to achieve, why, by when" to make things clear/prioritize,
then the "how tos" can be filled in - with many many options/choices.

Just a thought, no absolute right/wrong - just Wong tongue.gif
[Ancient]-XinG-
post Aug 10 2018, 09:56 AM

20k VIP club
*******
Senior Member
5,750 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 9 2018, 10:36 PM)
Fully agree that some of people need this much. Maybe current lifestyle and commitments with kids and etc needing that much monthly expenses. But thats some of us, and I believe not the most of people.

If you see not many getting their salary growth passes 10k in 10years. Take government servant for example but we will see even with 2-3 kids, they are managing their life better.

Even fresh graduates now, when I started (11yrs ago) around 2500 and I believe that company still paid freshie with same basic salary.


My point is, I believe in 10years time, we maybe dont need x3,x4,x5 of our current expenses in order to survive. Even so, we always can do side job/part time to get additional income. Rather than keep stuck in rat race thinking that we still dont have enough money (which will never enough).

People say “reducing/controlling our expenses is easier than increasing our income”.

-Only my opinion-
*
this. why ar. why don't move one ar. then how youngster can save? lol
louzie
post Aug 10 2018, 10:26 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
102 posts

Joined: Feb 2009


Do we have anything similar to what the FI/RE ppl of US uses.
Nearly all of them emphasize Betterment .

wongmunkeong
post Aug 10 2018, 11:47 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(Ancient-XinG- @ Aug 10 2018, 09:56 AM)
this. why ar. why don't move one ar. then how youngster can save? lol
*
so.. focusing on that only = cant?
FYI - during my parents' time, no investment books, no forums to learn from, no computers & Internet, etc.
Ya, $ was "big" then but houses still costs several donkey years' wages.

my time - just had dial-up modem + BBS, luckily have investment books + security firms for stocks & mutual funds
heck 1990s was a challenging year to find good paying starter jobs. i started as a warehousing assistant, driving forklifts and even climbing several stories of racking..

nowadays, U young ones have access to the WORLD via online brokerages, online tools, info, etc.
heck, nowadays banks giving free $ in terms of 0% 6 to 15 months balance transfer or cash into account. dont have to believe me - check it out with HSBC, HLB, PB, Aeon Credit and MBB on/off.

not downplaying your challenges - just stating every generation have their challenges. so.. roll-over & play dead or learn & adapt?

This post has been edited by wongmunkeong: Aug 10 2018, 11:49 AM
fun_feng
post Aug 11 2018, 09:38 PM

One Cat to Rule Them ALL
*******
Senior Member
2,289 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Stairway to Heaven
How u guys plan for kids education fund?

My kids only toddler stage, i don't know how much they need?
Garysydney
post Aug 12 2018, 08:47 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


I read with great interest this thread. I have pondered for a long time whether i should put in my perspective about Financial Independence/ Retire Early and i have finally decided maybe i should.
I have lived and worked in Sydney for just under 40 years and plan to retire next year (in Msia). I can continue to work if i want to and can add about A$60-70k/yr extra to my retirement fund if i decide to work longer but i have decided not to as i have no kids and my wife also has some retirement money having worked to 50 herself. If i retire next year, both our retirement assets can generate a minimum of RM14k/mth (based on a conservative 3% return). If i work another few more years, this figure will probably go into RM20k+/mth and all my friends (and relatives) are telling me not to stop as i have a very cushy job and know most things like the back of my hand.
I ask myself how much money do i need to be in 'happy' in retirement? My wife has always been pushing me to retire as she thinks that we have quite sufficient funds to retire in Msia. I have been researching this passive income subject for a long time and how much is 'enough' as my relatives are saying that i am making a big mistake by retiring at such a young age (in Sydney most people continue to work and don't stop because of the cost of living is so high).
After a lot of analysis and research, i find that this happiness (about how much passive income we need so we will be satisfied whether we plan to retire or not) is very strong connected to contentment. I am an easily contented person (in-built in my personality) and is satisfied with the simple things in life (although my weak spot is food which is what i think will take up most of my retirement expenses).
Just my 2c worth of reading for a Sunday morning.
wongmunkeong
post Aug 12 2018, 10:14 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(fun_feng @ Aug 11 2018, 09:38 PM)
How u guys plan for kids education fund?

My kids only toddler stage, i don't know how much they need?
*
like life, it HEAVILY depends..
1. on Gov Uni?
a. cheap lar compared to (2.)

2. on Private Uni/College?
a. If totally local, current cost is about MYR150K+/- for a UK/AU computer science degree
b. If 3+1 or 2+2 etc. - the cost of living overseas is the main pain
c. Ivy league? <faints>

3. on type of degree
a. Engineering & other stuff needing specialized tools?
b. Medical? get ready with at least $500K if without subsidy / scholarship
c. general stuff like biz, computing, accounting, etc.? "cheapest"

I'd suggest:
take the above $ cost, then calculate FUTURE COST = CURRENT COST *(1 +xx%) ^yy
xx% = education inflation expected, eg. 6%pa 8%pa
yy = number of years to uni, eg. kid now 3, thus around 15 years time
using above eg. in Excel, FUTURE COST = 150K * (1+6%)^15
in English, "^" is "power of"

the current costs can easily be found via googling the local campuses & their programmes

hope the above idea/guide helps


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 12 2018, 08:47 AM)
I read with great interest this thread. I have pondered for a long time whether i should put in my perspective about Financial Independence/ Retire Early and i have finally decided maybe i should.
I have lived and worked in Sydney for just under 40 years and plan to retire next year (in Msia). I can continue to work if i want to and can add about A$60-70k/yr extra to my retirement fund if i decide to work longer but i have decided not to as i have no kids and my wife also has some retirement money having worked to 50 herself.  If i retire next year, both our retirement assets can generate a minimum of RM14k/mth (based on a conservative 3% return). If i work another few more years, this figure will probably go into RM20k+/mth and all my friends (and relatives) are telling me not to stop as i have a very cushy job and know most things like the back of my hand.
I ask myself how much money do i need to be in 'happy' in retirement? My wife has always been pushing me to retire as she thinks that we have quite sufficient funds to retire in Msia. I have been researching this passive income subject for a long time and how much is 'enough' as my relatives are saying that i am making a big mistake by retiring at such a young age (in Sydney most people continue to work and don't stop because of the cost of living is so high).
After a lot of analysis and research, i find that this happiness (about how much passive income we need so we will be satisfied whether we plan to retire or not) is very strong connected to contentment. I am an easily contented person (in-built in my personality) and is satisfied with the simple things in life (although my weak spot is food which is what i think will take up most of my retirement expenses).
Just my 2c worth of reading for a Sunday morning.
*
It's a great feeling having nailed down a goal / clarity, thus focus eh. thumbsup.gif notworthy.gif

Just some data, just in case (my apologies for assuming if U already know) to help in your planning, since i'm living in MY for (like ever! tongue.gif ):
1. FD here - if yearly, U can get 4%pa +/- unless MY goes crazy up or down, i've seen 10%pa+ before but that was like in 1980s

2. Food is generally "cheap" comparatively - per pax, eating out MYR20-30, unless U are talking about fine dining which can be easily MYRXXX to MYRX,XXX per pax. If U are like me - likes food & eats anywhere but eats a lot, per pax range from MYR12 to MYR35 - from good wanton noodles to bahkutteh dry+wet (told U i eat like a pig tongue.gif )

3. Rentals? heavily dependant on area
Cost of home? also heavily dependant on area & landed or apartment-types.
eg. rentals for a landed house ranges from MYR1.5K to MYR2K currently VS purchasing a house MYR800K to MYR1.xM,
in Subang Jaya & Petaling Jaya (my normal haunts)

4. Inflation - officially around 4%pa+/-
Unofficially.. gawd.. it can be bad if one's lifeSTYLE is crazy or it can be nearly half that, ie. 2%+, if one is frugal (not into Starbucks and the likes of branded only lifeSTYLE)

5. Cost of maintenance - car, home, wiring, water-related, airconds, etc.
Still "cheap enough" to "outsource" for middle-income families in MY compared to developed nations.

6. Suggestion to look up MALAYSIA MY SECOND HOME if you're an Aussie planning to retire in MY - why not leverage on what is available smile.gif

Just some thoughts ya, and my bad if U already know all the above (and more) notworthy.gif

This post has been edited by wongmunkeong: Aug 12 2018, 10:30 AM
fun_feng
post Aug 12 2018, 10:36 AM

One Cat to Rule Them ALL
*******
Senior Member
2,289 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Stairway to Heaven
QUOTE(wongmunkeong @ Aug 12 2018, 10:14 AM)
like life, it HEAVILY depends..
1. on Gov Uni?
a. cheap lar compared to (2.)

2. on Private Uni/College?
a. If totally local, current cost is about MYR150K+/- for a UK/AU computer science degree
b. If 3+1 or 2+2 etc. - the cost of living overseas is the main pain
c. Ivy league? <faints>

3. on type of degree
a. Engineering & other stuff needing specialized tools?
b. Medical? get ready with at least $500K if without subsidy / scholarship
c. general stuff like biz, computing, accounting, etc.? "cheapest"

I'd suggest:
take the above $ cost, then calculate FUTURE COST = CURRENT COST *(1 +xx%) ^yy
xx% = education inflation expected, eg. 6%pa 8%pa
yy = number of years to uni, eg. kid now 3, thus around 15 years time
using above eg. in Excel, FUTURE COST = 150K * (1+6%)^15
in English, "^" is "power of"

the current costs can easily be found via googling the local campuses & their programmes
Well the provlem is we wont know what courses they will take....
just assume medicine as the worst? mega_shok.gif
wongmunkeong
post Aug 12 2018, 10:42 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(fun_feng @ Aug 12 2018, 10:36 AM)
Well the provlem is we wont know what courses they will take....
just assume medicine as the worst? mega_shok.gif
*
IMHO, in all budgeting & cash flow planning, it's a matter of probability or median lor
if assume highest or 0, then either stressed like kaka or no need to save
thus, personally, i'm using MYR200K+ as current cost then add inflation.
i've been doing this since 2012 and my extrapolation of costs then, is very near the $200K+ cost now. thus, ok lar - works for me as a clear focus
sky18
post Aug 12 2018, 11:25 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 12 2018, 08:47 AM)
I read with great interest this thread. I have pondered for a long time whether i should put in my perspective about Financial Independence/ Retire Early and i have finally decided maybe i should.
I have lived and worked in Sydney for just under 40 years and plan to retire next year (in Msia). I can continue to work if i want to and can add about A$60-70k/yr extra to my retirement fund if i decide to work longer but i have decided not to as i have no kids and my wife also has some retirement money having worked to 50 herself.  If i retire next year, both our retirement assets can generate a minimum of RM14k/mth (based on a conservative 3% return). If i work another few more years, this figure will probably go into RM20k+/mth and all my friends (and relatives) are telling me not to stop as i have a very cushy job and know most things like the back of my hand.
I ask myself how much money do i need to be in 'happy' in retirement? My wife has always been pushing me to retire as she thinks that we have quite sufficient funds to retire in Msia. I have been researching this passive income subject for a long time and how much is 'enough' as my relatives are saying that i am making a big mistake by retiring at such a young age (in Sydney most people continue to work and don't stop because of the cost of living is so high).
After a lot of analysis and research, i find that this happiness (about how much passive income we need so we will be satisfied whether we plan to retire or not) is very strong connected to contentment. I am an easily contented person (in-built in my personality) and is satisfied with the simple things in life (although my weak spot is food which is what i think will take up most of my retirement expenses).
Just my 2c worth of reading for a Sunday morning.
*
Agreed. After all, "what is enough" & contentment is very subjective to a person; Eg: Birkin bag is basic need for Rosmah but Bata slippers is enough for TunM.

I'm doing a lots of study on contentment, mindfulness as well lately and found following pretty insightful too.
> https://beherenownetwork.com/category/joseph-goldstein/ (series of podcast, [as a freethinker, take away the religion elements] it's good to learn his views and interprete the life)
> https://www.thesimpledollar.com/the-wisdom-...final-thoughts/









SUSyklooi
post Aug 12 2018, 12:14 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


QUOTE(sky18 @ Aug 12 2018, 11:25 AM)
Agreed. After all, "what is enough" & contentment is very subjective to a person; Eg: Birkin bag is basic need for Rosmah but Bata slippers is enough for TunM.

I'm doing a lots of study on contentment, mindfulness as well lately and found following pretty insightful too.
> https://beherenownetwork.com/category/joseph-goldstein/  (series of podcast, [as a freethinker, take away the religion elements] it's good to learn his views and interprete the life)
> https://www.thesimpledollar.com/the-wisdom-...final-thoughts/
*
thumbup.gif that is very true. notworthy.gif

I had a close friend told me once,.....it is not a good holistic feeling to have in life, when one has reached a stage in which, one felt not much joy in having some extra money given to him.....
for he will just put it into his saving/investment vehicle....they just keep on adding up.
for he had preplanned and arranged most of the needs in advance.

he continue to reflect in comparison to the time when we felt so much joy when his boss suddenly gives him some extra pocket money as bonus.

thus will contentment rob something of one's joy in a way? (ex: the joy of having some windfall in comparison to others?)

yeah,...I had reached that stage too.....a small % in relation to my friend I guess, for a times,.....when I saw 10 cents on the road,.....I just pointed to the next guy and tell him to pick it up.
yeah,....i guess i kind of understand how my friend felt.....at that in that time.



Garysydney
post Aug 12 2018, 12:28 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(sky18 @ Aug 12 2018, 11:25 AM)
Agreed. After all, "what is enough" & contentment is very subjective to a person;  Eg: Birkin bag is basic need for Rosmah but Bata slippers is enough for TunM.

I'm doing a lots of study on contentment, mindfulness as well lately and found following pretty insightful too.
> https://beherenownetwork.com/category/joseph-goldstein/  (series of podcast, [as a freethinker, take away the religion elements] it's good to learn his views and interprete the life)
> https://www.thesimpledollar.com/the-wisdom-...final-thoughts/
*
I actually didn't know how much i would need for a comfortable retirement for me in Msia even going back 1-2 years ago which is why i was so interested in retirement/cost of living threads esp in this forum (which actually is the only forum that i read/join). My relatives were all telling me how stupid i was quitting my job when my package is so good and that i could easily work another 5 years and build up a bigger retirement fund. My siblings are all calling me stupid fool behind my back!! I then tell myself - how much is enough? My wife has been bugging me for years to retire (as she is home alone most of the time as she has stopped working at 50 and we are the same age).
If i were to live and retire in Sydney (next year), then the assets i have would only give me a very modest retirement because cost of living is very high in Sydney esp when you want to enjoy a bit in life like eating out and overseas travel because Sydney is so far away from everywhere! I have been doing a detailed budget each time (last 1-2 years) recently when i go back to Kl for a holiday (i have been going back to KL for holidays every 5 months for about 4-5 weeks and i love it!) and i have been doing this for the past 4-5 years. I spent about rm3k/week (not incl my air tickets) when i was on holiday staying in Bangsar Baru (i inherited the house from my mum) and this involves eating out everyday and short trips to nearby towns (Ipoh, Muar, Melaka). I also pay for those who accompanies me around and i would eat at canton-i, i-dragon, Din Tai Fung, Greenview Rest and Overseas Imbi quite a fair bit but i don't usually order live seafood (because my wife doesn't allow me to eat live animals/seafood due to her religion!). I am not going to spend like this if i retire in KL (we might go out and every every couple of days but not everyday!). I only concluded (in the last 2-3months) i have got much more than i need to retire in Msia but knowing my thrifty lifestyle that i have led in the last 40 years in Sydney, i think i will need a lot less than rm3k/week when i am really retired next year in Msia.
Also the fact that i am an easily contented person which is the most important (i feel) gives me even more confidence that i have enough to live on and i don't need to work more.

Added later: Lastly i would like to add this - i think i will probably need about rm5-7k/mth for the lifestyle i am currently used to and even though my retirement income were to skyrocket and hit rm30k/mth, i think my lifestyle will not change much from what i am doing now and also my satisfaction/happiness level will not have increased at all since i am already very happy with my lifestyle now.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 12 2018, 03:58 PM
icemanfx
post Aug 12 2018, 04:19 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 12 2018, 12:28 PM)
I actually didn't know how much i would need for a comfortable retirement for me in Msia even going back 1-2 years ago which is why i was so interested in retirement/cost of living threads esp in this forum (which actually is the only forum that i read/join). My relatives were all telling me how stupid i was quitting my job when my package is so good and that i could easily work another 5 years and build up a bigger retirement fund. My siblings are all calling me stupid fool behind my back!! I then tell myself - how much is enough? My wife has been bugging me for years to retire (as she is home alone most of the time as she has stopped working at 50 and we are the same age).
If i were to live and retire in Sydney (next year), then the assets i have would only give me a very modest retirement because cost of living is very high in Sydney esp when you want to enjoy a bit in life like eating out and overseas travel because Sydney is so far away from everywhere! I have been doing a detailed budget each time (last 1-2 years) recently when i go back to Kl for a holiday (i have been going back to KL for holidays every 5 months for about 4-5 weeks and i love it!) and i have been doing this for the past 4-5 years. I spent about rm3k/week (not incl my air tickets) when i was on holiday staying in Bangsar Baru (i inherited the house from my mum) and this involves eating out everyday and short trips to nearby towns (Ipoh, Muar, Melaka). I also pay for those who accompanies me around and i would eat at canton-i, i-dragon, Din Tai Fung, Greenview Rest and Overseas Imbi quite a fair bit but i don't usually order live seafood (because my wife doesn't allow me to eat live animals/seafood due to her religion!). I am not going to spend like this if i retire in KL (we might go out and every every couple of days but not everyday!). I only concluded (in the last 2-3months) i have got much more than i need  to retire in Msia but knowing my thrifty lifestyle that i have led in the last 40 years in Sydney, i think i will need a lot less than rm3k/week when i am really retired next year in Msia.
Also the fact that i am an easily contented person which is the most important (i feel) gives me even more confidence that i have enough to live on and i don't need to work more.

Added later: Lastly i would like to add this - i think i will probably need about rm5-7k/mth for the lifestyle i am currently used to and even though my retirement income were to skyrocket and hit rm30k/mth, i think my lifestyle will not change much from what i am doing now and also my satisfaction/happiness level will not have increased at all since i am already very happy with my lifestyle now.
*
Staying for short term is different from long term. Eating out may seems cheaper in kl but quality you get is lower also. Foods in supermarket in kl could be more expensive than Australia. Private hospital in kl is not cheap.

If one is willing to compromise quality for cheaper price, could consider ipoh, taiping, udon thani, ching Mai, etc.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Aug 12 2018, 04:32 PM
Garysydney
post Aug 12 2018, 06:31 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 12 2018, 04:19 PM)
Staying for short term is different from long term. Eating out may seems cheaper in kl but quality you get is lower also. Foods in supermarket in kl could be more expensive than Australia. Private hospital in kl is not cheap.

If one is willing to compromise quality for cheaper price, could consider ipoh, taiping, udon thani, ching Mai, etc.
*
My wife and I prefer Asian food to Western food. Asian food is a lot better in Msia compared to Sydney. I must admit the beef steaks are of better quality in Sydney compared to the steakhouses in KL. We don't really go for Western food in Sydney (except pizzas and steaks) but we will come back for a visit to Sydney once in a while. Food in supermarkets here (Coles, Woolies and Aldi) are cheaper only with some products but there are things cheaper in Msia supermarkets as well. I guess when i am in Msia, i will be eating more local fruits/products but we can still afford cherries, golden kiwis, plums and other imported fruits. In fact when i was in Msia (on holiday), i would often buy quite a lot of imported fruits for my relatives and i find that the imported fruits are only slightly more expensive compared to Sydney.
Healthcare may be the only big setback living in KL (if i give up my PR as i will not be able to fulfil the condition to live 2 years in 5 in Aust). Both my wife and myself are now in excellent health but you cannot tell what sickness you get until you get older. I guess i just have to take the risk but i have a few years to decide whether i will give up my Aussie PR. Alternatively I can take up Aussie passport and apply for MM2H but i don't like this idea as i think there is a very good chance i will like it in Msia.
Even though the smaller towns in Msia sounds good, i think friends and relatives are very important in old age. My relatives are all in KL and i still have quite a lot of old friends in KL.
TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 13 2018, 07:17 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


garysydney

First of all, I would like to thank you for the contribution and sharing. This is what this thread for. Not only people who stay/living in Malaysia but also for those who still love and planning to come back to Malaysia.

As already shared by our friends here, “how much is enough “ is always depending on individual (or family) lifestyle and commitments you have current and Post-FIRE. Also be aware and prepare of cost of healthcare and house (should be ok for you as you inherited the house), kids education fund.

My personal observations from what you shared, you already in a good shape (financially and attitude/mindset) to go into FIRE phase. Many people not only don’t have the enough reserve/saving but worst their lifestyle cost is way beyond their capabilities. (Dont event talk about investment)

Myself (family with one kid) just entered this new phase (or rather called semi-retired/in transition) and currently learning and starting to do new things to keep myself busy and hopefully earning additional income.

I just completed repatriate back to home from neighbour country where I got NETT income USD127k per annum, company shares, cash incentives, accommodation and transportation provided. I’m mid 30s.

Now living with RM15,000 permonth that includes giving to my father, in-law, installment/top up of my properties.

My decision to fired my boss after I received my wife’s blessing.😁

I hope you will make a good decision for your life and your family. You and your wife know better about your financial and your capabilities.

Keep on sharing Bro. Thank you.

T231H
post Aug 13 2018, 08:21 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
5,143 posts

Joined: Jan 2015
How Much do You Need to Retire
by Wong Sui Jau

If we start with more modest expectations I believe a lot more people will then find that having enough money for retirement is achievable. From there, you can then work on having more than enough so that you can either improve your retirement lifestyle or have a bigger buffer in your nest egg for your retirement to guard against unexpected events. So, take that first step, find out how much you need for retirement. Then you will be able to work out a plan to gather the nest egg you need for that retirement!

https://secure.fundsupermart.com/main/resea...SJBlog_20151104

Garysydney
post Aug 13 2018, 08:59 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 13 2018, 07:17 AM)
garysydney

First of all, I would like to thank you for the contribution and sharing. This is what this thread for. Not only people who stay/living in Malaysia but also for those who still love and planning to come back to Malaysia.

As already shared by our friends here, “how much is enough “ is always depending on individual (or family) lifestyle and commitments you have current and Post-FIRE. Also be aware and prepare of cost of healthcare and house (should be ok for you as you inherited the house), kids education fund.

My personal observations from what you shared, you already in a good shape (financially and attitude/mindset) to go into FIRE phase. Many people not only don’t have the enough reserve/saving but worst their lifestyle cost is way beyond their capabilities. (Dont event talk about investment)

Myself (family with one kid) just entered this new phase (or rather called semi-retired/in transition) and currently learning and starting to do new things to keep myself busy and hopefully earning additional income.

I just completed repatriate back to home from neighbour country where I got NETT income USD127k per annum, company shares, cash incentives, accommodation and transportation provided. I’m mid 30s.

Now living with RM15,000 permonth that includes giving to my father, in-law, installment/top up of my properties.

My decision to fired my boss after I received my wife’s blessing.😁

I hope you will make a good decision for your life and your family. You and your wife know better about your financial and your capabilities.

Keep on sharing Bro. Thank you.
*
My friends and relatives are all saying that i am stupid to give up a very cushy job at 57. Actually it is now 10.30am in Sydney and i just got in to work and i am very free at work which is why i am writing now. I would normally have nothing much to do so i just walk around the office chatting with other staff. I then would go for a 1-hour walk down to Glebe Point Bay (my office is very close to the bay) and then i would have my lunch in my room (i have my own room which can sit 2 persons but we don't need a second person). I would normally go home around 4pm so my day goes by quite slowly as most of the time i am surfing the net and bored. My package is pretty good with my base a little over a A$100k and my employer pays my defined-benefit super (epf) of about A$25-26k after-tax so my package is actually in excess of A$130k+ because of my employer contribution being tax-free. I am hoping they would give me redundancy which would give me an extra A$150-200k but i don't think they will because they need someone in this building.

The other problem i have is my relatives are saying that i am stupid to come back to KL to live because everyone in KL is migrating overseas and I am returning. Aust has probably the best old-age pension in the world where at the age of 67, you get an automatic pension of A$700/wk for couples if your retirement assets are not over A$400k (the house that you are living in is not counted as an asset as you need somewhere to live). This is one of the best pension in the world and is available to everyone who is either a PR or citizen. It is a safety net just in case our retirement investments plunges. If your retirement savings are between A$400-800k, you get a pro-rata rate of the A$700/wk. You don't get the pension if your retirement assets exceed A$800k. My wife and i probably will not qualify as we are over that A$800k but it is a good safety net to have as you can't predict stockmarket movements.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 13 2018, 09:00 AM
utellme
post Aug 13 2018, 02:29 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
919 posts

Joined: May 2005
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 13 2018, 08:59 AM)
My friends and relatives are all saying that i am stupid to give up a very cushy job at 57. Actually it is now 10.30am in Sydney and i just got in to work and i am very free at work which is why i am writing now. I would normally have nothing much to do so i just walk around the office chatting with other staff. I then would go for a 1-hour walk down to Glebe Point Bay (my office is very close to the bay) and then i would have my lunch in my room (i have my own room which can sit 2 persons but we don't need a second person). I would normally go home around 4pm so my day goes by quite slowly as most of the time i am surfing the net and bored. My package is pretty good with my base a little over a A$100k and my employer pays my defined-benefit super (epf) of about A$25-26k after-tax so my package is actually in excess of A$130k+ because of my employer contribution being tax-free. I am hoping they would give me redundancy which would give me an extra A$150-200k but i don't think they will because they need someone in this building.

The other problem i have is my relatives are saying that i am stupid to come back to KL to live because everyone in KL is migrating overseas and I am returning. Aust has probably the best old-age pension in the world where at the age of 67, you get an automatic pension of A$700/wk for couples if your retirement assets are not over A$400k (the house that you are living in is not counted as an asset as you need somewhere to live). This is one of the best pension in the world and is available to everyone who is either a PR or citizen. It is a safety net just in case our retirement investments plunges. If your retirement savings are between A$400-800k, you get a pro-rata rate of the A$700/wk. You don't get the pension if your retirement assets exceed A$800k. My wife and i probably will not qualify as we are over that A$800k but it is a good safety net to have as you can't predict stockmarket movements.
*
Hi Gary,

I've been travelled to Melbourne and Sydney several times last two years on my work and visiting my children in Australia and I not sure $Aus 800K is enough to cover the retirement plan for a couple period of 20 years in Sydney assuming both of you leave very modest liftstyle like $1000 per week.
TerryCath1028
post Aug 13 2018, 02:58 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
28 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
I'm working hard to achieve my FIRE also... I'm 33 this year and feel that I'm abit late to start on my FIRE... sad.gif I just started while I'm 31... and due to my very high monthly commitment that each month i only can have very little fund can be put into my FIRE plan by investing in Bursa mainly on those share with regular dividend distribution..

Even is abit late for me...but still is a good start for me... Wish i can achieve my FIRE by the passive income can cover my family commitment...

chonghe
post Aug 13 2018, 09:52 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


QUOTE(TerryCath1028 @ Aug 13 2018, 02:58 PM)
I'm working hard to achieve my FIRE also... I'm 33 this year and feel that I'm abit late to start on my FIRE... sad.gif I just started while I'm 31... and due to my very high monthly commitment that each month i only can have very little fund can be put into my FIRE plan by investing in Bursa mainly on those share with regular dividend distribution..

Even is abit late for me...but still is a good start for me... Wish i can achieve my FIRE by the passive income can cover my family commitment...
*
My personal opinion is, unless your capital is really large to generate sufficient passive income on stocks dividend, otherwise aiming for capital gain is a way to grow your capital (of course this comes with a greater risk)
It all depends on the person, perhaps you can split your capital into a few portions which buy different stocks for capital gain or dividend income

All the best!
issac96
post Aug 13 2018, 11:40 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
205 posts

Joined: Jan 2016


Hello. I'm 22. I do not have much knowledge on FIRE. I saw some replies on FIRE but I have no idea, can someone briefly explain to me? I would really appreciate that!
j.passing.by
post Aug 14 2018, 01:07 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,639 posts

Joined: Nov 2010
QUOTE(issac96 @ Aug 13 2018, 11:40 PM)
Hello. I'm 22. I do not have much knowledge on FIRE. I saw some replies on FIRE but I have no idea, can someone briefly explain to me? I would really appreciate that!
*
It is a catchy acronym for being financial independence and able to retire early. Officially our retirement age in Malaysia is 60 years old, while in some countries the age is 65 or more.

So how early is early? I think the most talk about age would be in the late forties - around 46 to 49. Age 50 to 55 is not that "early" since our retirement age used to be 55.

Mid thirties to mid forties would be too early... these are the most productitve age for most in their careers, where they would be due for job promotions and higher earnings.

If I am in your shoes at your age of 22, I would not be too concern about resigning and retiring from work... more concern with the job and job promotion and earning higher and higher salary. Learn to live within the salary, with some savings aside from our savings in EPF.

And try to be free of debts as soon as possible... so there is no burden and commitment to service the debts every month. Just in case you need to walk away from your job before the official retirement age. As you grow older, there could be ethical issues involved in your job.

When you are pressured to do something unethical by your boss or immediate superiors, being debt-free and financially independence would allow you the luxury to say 'screw this job' and walk away.




Garysydney
post Aug 14 2018, 05:11 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(utellme @ Aug 13 2018, 02:29 PM)
Hi Gary,

I've been travelled to Melbourne and Sydney several times last two years on my work and visiting my children in Australia and I not sure $Aus 800K is enough to cover the retirement plan for a couple period of 20 years in Sydney assuming both of you leave very modest liftstyle like $1000 per week.
*
For a couple at 67, if your retirement savings drop below A$800k, the government will start giving you a government pension. If you have say A$700k after age 67, you will roughly get about A$140/wk pension from the government and this applies to all PR and citizens. Together with this benefit, you get a lot of other assistance as well like your car rego (road tax) free for 1 car, electricity discount 25% off, council rates discount 25%(DBKL assesment), pharmaceutical discount (pay only A$6/ for most kind of medications) and a whole lot of other discounts. You will get the full pension benefit when your retirement savings drop to A$400k - it means you get the full A$700/wk a couple from the government. This aged pension welfare bill is costing the Aussie government more than A$45 billion/year and the government says that they cannot afford it and is trying to raise the pension age to 70 but dare not do it as they will definitely lose the election if they do so.

I have a few very good friends who worked with me and have now retired after they were made redundant and are all above 67 years of age. They have retirement savings of around A$600k and they tell me that with the govt assistance, their balance have not dropped for a few years and have remained pretty much the same. It goes to show how important this assistance is from the govt but then it is something the govt really can't afford. I will say the govt will have no choice but to raise the pension age to 70 in future.

I must also emphasize that the house you live in is not counted as an asset so if you live in a A$10mil house and have no other assets, you will still be entitled to the full pension of A$700/wk per couple. Can you see how crazy the welfare system is in Australia?

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 14 2018, 05:14 AM
TerryCath1028
post Aug 14 2018, 08:56 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
28 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
QUOTE(chonghe @ Aug 13 2018, 09:52 PM)
My personal opinion is, unless your capital is really large to generate sufficient passive income on stocks dividend, otherwise aiming for capital gain is a way to grow your capital (of course this comes with a greater risk)
It all depends on the person, perhaps you can split your capital into a few portions which buy different stocks for capital gain or dividend income

All the best!
*
Yup, I also understand what you meant. And of cause I knew about that.. That's y my investment i split to 2 portion now.. 1 portion aiming for dividend share and another portion will be aiming for capital gain.
cheefai7
post Aug 14 2018, 12:01 PM

making coffee constantly
****
Senior Member
609 posts

Joined: Apr 2006



QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 13 2018, 08:59 AM)
My friends and relatives are all saying that i am stupid to give up a very cushy job at 57. Actually it is now 10.30am in Sydney and i just got in to work and i am very free at work which is why i am writing now. I would normally have nothing much to do so i just walk around the office chatting with other staff. I then would go for a 1-hour walk down to Glebe Point Bay (my office is very close to the bay) and then i would have my lunch in my room (i have my own room which can sit 2 persons but we don't need a second person). I would normally go home around 4pm so my day goes by quite slowly as most of the time i am surfing the net and bored. My package is pretty good with my base a little over a A$100k and my employer pays my defined-benefit super (epf) of about A$25-26k after-tax so my package is actually in excess of A$130k+ because of my employer contribution being tax-free. I am hoping they would give me redundancy which would give me an extra A$150-200k but i don't think they will because they need someone in this building.

The other problem i have is my relatives are saying that i am stupid to come back to KL to live because everyone in KL is migrating overseas and I am returning. Aust has probably the best old-age pension in the world where at the age of 67, you get an automatic pension of A$700/wk for couples if your retirement assets are not over A$400k (the house that you are living in is not counted as an asset as you need somewhere to live). This is one of the best pension in the world and is available to everyone who is either a PR or citizen. It is a safety net just in case our retirement investments plunges. If your retirement savings are between A$400-800k, you get a pro-rata rate of the A$700/wk. You don't get the pension if your retirement assets exceed A$800k. My wife and i probably will not qualify as we are over that A$800k but it is a good safety net to have as you can't predict stockmarket movements.
*
Maybe considering contributing back to the community of Malaysia, especially helping youth or young's in your vast working experience/specialization. I believed it will give you more fulfillment than your last employment.
Garysydney
post Aug 14 2018, 12:52 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(cheefai7 @ Aug 14 2018, 12:01 PM)
Maybe considering contributing back to the community of Malaysia, especially helping youth or young's in your vast working experience/specialization. I believed it will give you more fulfillment than your last employment.
*
Defintely agree with you strongly here. Post retirement, we will have plenty of time and one of the best things to do is helping out with the disadvantaged esp i have been very fortunate in life and never went through much hardship. My wife is very religious and would probably be telling me what i need to do to help people out. smile.gif
samquah
post Aug 14 2018, 01:00 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
603 posts

Joined: Aug 2005


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 13 2018, 07:17 AM)
garysydney

First of all, I would like to thank you for the contribution and sharing. This is what this thread for. Not only people who stay/living in Malaysia but also for those who still love and planning to come back to Malaysia.

As already shared by our friends here, “how much is enough “ is always depending on individual (or family) lifestyle and commitments you have current and Post-FIRE. Also be aware and prepare of cost of healthcare and house (should be ok for you as you inherited the house), kids education fund.

My personal observations from what you shared, you already in a good shape (financially and attitude/mindset) to go into FIRE phase. Many people not only don’t have the enough reserve/saving but worst their lifestyle cost is way beyond their capabilities. (Dont event talk about investment)

Myself (family with one kid) just entered this new phase (or rather called semi-retired/in transition) and currently learning and starting to do new things to keep myself busy and hopefully earning additional income.

I just completed repatriate back to home from neighbour country where I got NETT income USD127k per annum, company shares, cash incentives, accommodation and transportation provided. I’m mid 30s.

Now living with RM15,000 permonth that includes giving to my father, in-law, installment/top up of my properties.

My decision to fired my boss after I received my wife’s blessing.😁

I hope you will make a good decision for your life and your family. You and your wife know better about your financial and your capabilities.

Keep on sharing Bro. Thank you.
*
can you survive with rm15k/mth? how old is your kid?
samquah
post Aug 14 2018, 01:05 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
603 posts

Joined: Aug 2005


QUOTE(cherroy @ Aug 7 2018, 03:21 PM)
If net worth including car, and home, then it is not good yield stick to determine FI.

It is ability to generate passive income from the gross/net worth which is more important that determine the FI.
Eg.
A lives in a house that worth 5.5 mil, but has nothing else, A net worth is 5.5 mil. But has zero passive income, A is not FI at this point, until A liquidates the house.

B lives in 500k house, and has other investment/asset worth 5 mil that generates 5% average or 250K pa passive income, B is FI.

Cash money is needed for paying daily expenses, not net worth.
Don't be surprise this cashflow management 101 that even some big corporate, listed company failed to do so.
*
i currently have passive income avg 6% generating rm5k monthly. Planning to work for another 10 years and should have epf balance rm1.5 mil. If this 1.5 mil can generate another 6% giving another rm7500 monthly.


I foresee the total 12500rm passive income

i am un sure if this can sustain me, wife n kid in Msia. But think should be fine.

Currently looking for ways to improve cash standings so i can FiRE my boss
Garysydney
post Aug 14 2018, 01:35 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(samquah @ Aug 14 2018, 01:05 PM)
i currently have passive income avg 6% generating rm5k monthly. Planning to work for another 10 years and should have epf balance rm1.5 mil. If this 1.5 mil can generate another 6% giving another rm7500 monthly.
I foresee the total 12500rm passive income

i am un sure if this can sustain me, wife n kid in Msia.  But  think should be fine.

Currently looking for ways to improve cash standings so i can FiRE my boss
*
In 10 years time, your epf's 1.5mil is not the same as today's 1.5mil in epf. There is inflation every year and therefore the 12.5k passive income (in 10 years time) will be a lot less in today's term.
TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 14 2018, 11:37 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(samquah @ Aug 14 2018, 01:00 PM)
can you survive with rm15k/mth? how old is your kid?
*
Yes sir. My kid 1yr plus. I bought one flat in oversea for his education fund.
cherroy
post Aug 15 2018, 09:30 AM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(samquah @ Aug 14 2018, 01:05 PM)
i currently have passive income avg 6% generating rm5k monthly. Planning to work for another 10 years and should have epf balance rm1.5 mil. If this 1.5 mil can generate another 6% giving another rm7500 monthly.
I foresee the total 12500rm passive income

i am un sure if this can sustain me, wife n kid in Msia.  But  think should be fine.

Currently looking for ways to improve cash standings so i can FiRE my boss
*
6% consistent passive income is not a figure easy to achieve.
Also, there is no guaranteed that EPF payout will be 6% as well.

EPF shouldn't be taken into consideration for FI at the moment, as you can't touch those money until reach retirement age.

This post has been edited by cherroy: Aug 15 2018, 09:30 AM
sky18
post Aug 15 2018, 09:42 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(cherroy @ Aug 15 2018, 09:30 AM)
6% consistent passive income is not a figure easy to achieve.
Also, there is no guaranteed that EPF payout will be 6% as well.

EPF shouldn't be taken into consideration for FI at the moment, as you can't touch those money until reach retirement age.
*
Not absolute correct. You can withdraw if epf exceed 1mil.
cherroy
post Aug 15 2018, 09:45 AM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(sky18 @ Aug 15 2018, 09:42 AM)
Not absolute correct. You can withdraw if epf exceed 1mil.
*
Not aware of this, thanks for the head up.
sky18
post Aug 15 2018, 09:52 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(cherroy @ Aug 15 2018, 09:45 AM)
Not aware of this, thanks for the head up.
*
In fact, one may treat epf as bond and estimate with average 5% return as part of overall portfolio. Self contribution CAN max up to 60K a year. This works better for those high salary earners but super conservative where parking their saving in FD.
samquah
post Aug 15 2018, 10:26 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
603 posts

Joined: Aug 2005


QUOTE(cherroy @ Aug 15 2018, 09:30 AM)
6% consistent passive income is not a figure easy to achieve.
Also, there is no guaranteed that EPF payout will be 6% as well.

EPF shouldn't be taken into consideration for FI at the moment, as you can't touch those money until reach retirement age.
*
6% based on government bonds like ASNB. (i think this is safer compared to share market)

and as sky18 mentioned, can withdraw epf after in excess rm1 mil in case need the funds.


samquah
post Aug 15 2018, 10:27 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
603 posts

Joined: Aug 2005


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 14 2018, 11:37 PM)
Yes sir. My kid 1yr plus. I bought one flat in oversea for his education fund.
*
how much did you budget for your kids edu fund? will rm1 mil be ok?
samquah
post Aug 15 2018, 10:30 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
603 posts

Joined: Aug 2005


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 14 2018, 01:35 PM)
In 10 years time, your epf's 1.5mil is not the same as today's 1.5mil in epf. There is inflation every year and therefore the 12.5k passive income (in 10 years time) will be a lot less in today's term.
*
if i double up the amount of savings?

now passive rm5k/month
epf in 10 years rm1.5 mil
(additional cash savings@ retirement =rm1.5 mil) - maybe from insurance payout, company bonus and gratuity

btw with the assumption house/car fully paid off

will this be enough?
Garysydney
post Aug 15 2018, 10:57 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(samquah @ Aug 15 2018, 10:30 AM)
if i double up the amount of savings?

now passive rm5k/month
epf in 10 years rm1.5 mil
(additional cash savings@ retirement =rm1.5 mil) - maybe from insurance payout, company bonus and gratuity

btw with the assumption house/car fully paid off

will this be enough?
*
How much a person/couple actually needs to generate (in passive income) is a very subjective thing. Now there are a lot of old-aged couples with less than rm3k/mth income (in KL) and they survive very well. Some say they need rm20k/mth (in passive income) to be happy. Most of the time i feel how much we need is actually highly correlated to how much we currently earn (and how much income our income-producing assets can generate). Generally, we tend to spend more when our income increases and this is a behavior that is very consistent in humans (unless we have gone through a lot of financial hardships earlier in life for whatever reasons and this has affected the way we treat money). That is why a lot of financial gurus recommend before we retire, our passive income after retirement should at least be about 60-75% of our take-home income before we retired. So say someone in KL has a income of rm10k/mth before they retire, ideally their investment (epf, dividends, bonds,...) income should be able to generate around rm6,000-7,500/mth in retirement. Don't forget there is inflation every year so maybe have a little buffer to adjust for the inflation. Don't forget if you intend to retire early (like 30s or even 40s), have plenty of buffer because you may live till 90-100. So it is good if a person is very thrifty since their money can go a much longer way and if you have kids you may have to work a lot longer since education in Msia in quite expensive esp if you plan to have your kids go overseas.

I guess if you have no vices (gambling, women, alcohol and cigarettes), your expenses would also be a lot lower than someone who has esp gambling because the addiction is very hard to kick. Also among all the vices, gambling ranks no.1

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 15 2018, 10:58 AM
cherroy
post Aug 15 2018, 11:22 AM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 15 2018, 10:57 AM)
How much a person/couple actually needs to generate (in passive income) is a very subjective thing. Now there are a lot of old-aged couples with less than rm3k/mth income (in KL) and they survive very well. Some say they need rm20k/mth (in passive income) to be happy. Most of the time i feel how much we need is actually highly correlated to how much we currently earn (and how much income our income-producing assets can generate). Generally, we tend to spend more when our income increases and this is a behavior that is very consistent in humans (unless we have gone through a lot of financial hardships earlier in life for whatever reasons and this has affected the way we treat money).
*
There is no standard answer for such question " how much is enough".

I had seen how a person that earn Rm2k per month manage to raise a family.
I also had seen how a professional who earned Rm20K+ per month, needed to borrow heavy and "run away".

Some even earn billion, still live in basic way.
While some even just a few thousand, but always want to buy a 5K worth of smart phone.

It is down to the person spending habit and individual behaviour.
We can talk until cow come home, also won't have any conclusion how much is enough. Mainly because we don't know when we will die (don't need money anymore... laugh.gif )

Garysydney
post Aug 15 2018, 12:16 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(cherroy @ Aug 15 2018, 11:22 AM)
There is no standard answer for such question " how much is enough".

I had seen how a person that earn Rm2k per month manage to raise a family.
I also had seen how a professional who earned Rm20K+ per month, needed to borrow heavy and "run away".

Some even earn billion, still live in basic way.
While some even just a few thousand, but always want to buy a 5K worth of smart phone.

It is down to the person spending habit and individual behaviour.
We can talk until cow come home, also won't have any conclusion how much is enough. Mainly because we don't know when we will die (don't need money anymore... laugh.gif )
*
Yes - definitely agree with you.

Most times it is our 'expectation' that gets us into a worry-some state. We worry for nothing. Now when we retire, we will have a 'must-have' (or prerequisite) and a 'optional' (or luxury) basket. For someone with low expectations, his 'must-have' basket has only a couple of things in it - he may have only
(1) 3 simple meals/day
(2) enough money to buy medication if sick
(3) enough clothes to wear

and he has a few in his 'optional' basket, namely,
1) mobile phone
2) wireless at home
3) a small used car
4) occasional eat-out

Now tell me in KL, if he has only those 3 expectations in his 'must-have' basket, how much would he need with only those few expections like that per month? He can probably survive with rm2k/mth for a couple with that few basic necessities.
--------------------------------------------
Now we compare that with a 20+ young man who wants enough passive income to retire. His 'must-have' has a list with about 50 things in it and he probably has only one item in the 'optional' list which is a flight to the moon. biggrin.gif Now this young man's 'expectations' are very high and to maintain that lifestyle, he probably needs rm50k/mth.

It all boils down to 'expectations' and if we have only a few items in our 'must-have' basket for our retirement, we don't really need a lot of money to retire.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 15 2018, 12:17 PM
TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 15 2018, 04:18 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


QUOTE(samquah @ Aug 15 2018, 10:27 AM)
how much did you budget for your kids edu fund? will rm1 mil be ok?
*
I bought the flat at MYR800k.
I believe it is more than enough when my kid needs the fund. And he is not necessarily going to oversea University. But the fund is still there. Me only from local public university but lucky to work with oversea company.
L7Awesome
post Aug 16 2018, 08:04 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
418 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Aug 15 2018, 04:18 PM)
I bought the flat at MYR800k.
I believe it is more than enough when my kid needs the fund. And he is not necessarily going to oversea University. But the fund is still there. Me only from local public university but lucky to work with oversea company.
*
Nice experience sharing meonkutu11. Good for those who work in other countries and retire back in Malaysia.
L7Awesome
post Aug 16 2018, 08:14 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
418 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(issac96 @ Aug 13 2018, 11:40 PM)
Hello. I'm 22. I do not have much knowledge on FIRE. I saw some replies on FIRE but I have no idea, can someone briefly explain to me? I would really appreciate that!
*
I advised my kids to work towards FI and that's when you upgrade your job from need to work to want to work. Start to save and invest. Good to know a 22 years old asking this question. I wish I asked this question when I was 22.

Please be aware of the pressure to own the latest phone or purchase a new car with loan or monthly payment.
Ramjade
post Aug 16 2018, 09:08 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(issac96 @ Aug 13 2018, 11:40 PM)
Hello. I'm 22. I do not have much knowledge on FIRE. I saw some replies on FIRE but I have no idea, can someone briefly explain to me? I would really appreciate that!
*
FIRE is basically the option to work not, don't need to worry if you're retrenched.

To achieve that is through combination of saving and investing. Some does not like the idea of saving.

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Aug 16 2018, 09:09 AM
sky18
post Aug 16 2018, 10:27 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(issac96 @ Aug 13 2018, 11:40 PM)
Hello. I'm 22. I do not have much knowledge on FIRE. I saw some replies on FIRE but I have no idea, can someone briefly explain to me? I would really appreciate that!
*
FI pave a way to allow more options and ways to go about life; be it continue enjoy your corporate life, business, charity works, etc.

In general, it go thru these stages,

i. Financial epiphany or slowly awaken & subscribe to the idea

ii. Learn and goal setting.
> getting obsess about FIRE and learn how other archive it
> what is enough? wants and needs.
> pan out your own financial goal, budget, spending tracking etc.

iii. Accumulation stage (of course, many will re-tune their goal along the way as adopt new perspective as aging), if you excel in follow aspects, usually easier and faster reaching the goal.
> Increase earning.
> Control spending.
> Improve return from investment.

iv. Freedom stage.
Practically, you choose what works best for you.
For those who choose retire early (RE) and step way from corporate & business life, likely it need get thru
> cash flow planning and withdrawal strategy.
> mental fighting & inner reset against greed, fear of uncertainty, what if X tragedy happened, etc. which lead to "one more year syndrome".

p/s: Anywhere, if merely view from financial standing aspect, probably can refer here https://www.getrichslowly.org/stages-of-financial-freedom/


ZeaXG
post Aug 16 2018, 10:36 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
342 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


Not sure if anyone shared this but this guy's blog (Mr Money Mustache) can be a good start to setting a frugal mindset.

Here's the introduction post in his blog...
https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/02/22/...-one-blog-post/
Garysydney
post Aug 16 2018, 12:17 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(ZeaXG @ Aug 16 2018, 10:36 AM)
Not sure if anyone shared this but this guy's blog (Mr Money Mustache) can be a good start to setting a frugal mindset.

Here's the introduction post in his blog...
https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/02/22/...-one-blog-post/
*
In life, if you are a very frugal/thrifty person, that is an extremely healthy attitude to adopt because later on in life when your income drops you will not be greatly affected by this dilemma because chances are you will have assets accumulated in the earlier good days - this is why people say 'make hay while it shines' because you will get periods in your life when it doesn't shine esp when you get older and is 'over the hill'. The term 'live within/below your means' makes great sense when it comes to achieving early financial independence which enables you to stop worrying about money matters later on in life.

I am 56 now but if i had known about all this, i could have afforded to stop work a lot younger - when i was young, nobody taught me all this and i have always associated the word thrifty as 'being a loser' in my younger days. Now i can see how wrong i was.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 16 2018, 12:20 PM
sky18
post Aug 16 2018, 01:05 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 16 2018, 12:17 PM)
In life, if you are a very frugal/thrifty person, that is an extremely healthy attitude to adopt because later on in life when your income drops you will not be greatly affected by this dilemma because chances are you will have assets accumulated in the earlier good days - this is why people say 'make hay while it shines' because you will get periods in your life when it doesn't shine esp when you get older and is 'over the hill'. The term 'live within/below your means' makes great sense when it comes to achieving early financial independence which enables you to stop worrying about money matters later on in life.

I am 56 now but if i had known about all this, i could have afforded to stop work a lot younger - when i was young, nobody taught me all this and i have always associated the word thrifty as 'being a loser' in my younger days. Now i can see how wrong i was.
*
Sometime ignorance is bliss, when u gain this new perspective at late game, isn't it wanderful when u learned that already hit the magic number and can transit into RE.

Many of folks out there struggling during accumulation stage especially those with a less desirable job and escape route is far ahead.
Garysydney
post Aug 16 2018, 01:38 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(sky18 @ Aug 16 2018, 01:05 PM)
Sometime ignorance is bliss, when u gain this new perspective at late game, isn't it wanderful when u learned that already hit the magic number and can transit into RE.

Many of folks out there struggling during accumulation stage especially those with a less desirable job and escape route is far ahead.
*
This is very true. If i had known about this earlier, i would have thrown the towel in a lot earlier. Even though i have a very easy job, i don't quite enjoy going to work because i still have to go in to office and my work is not interesting. My wife always remind me to be grateful because she says i am getting 'gaji buta'. She keeps reminding me otherwise i would have quit a long time ago.
ziniowong
post Aug 16 2018, 02:18 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
471 posts

Joined: Nov 2015
QUOTE(ZeaXG @ Aug 16 2018, 10:36 AM)
Not sure if anyone shared this but this guy's blog (Mr Money Mustache) can be a good start to setting a frugal mindset.

Here's the introduction post in his blog...
https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/02/22/...-one-blog-post/
*
i've been following his blog for few months now.....still havent finish reading...hahahaha

icemanfx
post Aug 16 2018, 03:48 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(ZeaXG @ Aug 16 2018, 10:36 AM)
Not sure if anyone shared this but this guy's blog (Mr Money Mustache) can be a good start to setting a frugal mindset.

Here's the introduction post in his blog...
https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/02/22/...-one-blog-post/
*
If one could live like a monk in monastery, life would be frugal and could fi/re at early age; daily life is basically waiting to eat, sleep and die.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Aug 16 2018, 04:47 PM
joe_average
post Aug 16 2018, 04:35 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
8 posts

Joined: Jan 2011


QUOTE(ZeaXG @ Aug 16 2018, 10:36 AM)
Not sure if anyone shared this but this guy's blog (Mr Money Mustache) can be a good start to setting a frugal mindset.

Here's the introduction post in his blog...
https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/02/22/...-one-blog-post/
*
My go-to blog when I need to get my monthly/daily dose of FI talks to get me stay motivated.

TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 16 2018, 06:45 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


Thank you all for keep this thread going and throw a lot of positiveness into the discussions.

Keep on sharing guys. Thanks
chonghe
post Aug 16 2018, 09:12 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


Wanted to share my opinion on debts. A lot of people want to be debt free, because debt free is free from worries etc.

This is not entirely through in my opinion. While in the process of getting FIRE, taking debt can speed up the process, if manage properly. Yea debt free is good after you reach getting old or after you have the ability to FIRE. While still

I used to thought I need to be debt free at all time so that I don't have to worry about it. Now I realise that having a manageable amount of debt can be beneficial. For example:

i) Using credit card effectively to manage cash flow. This also includes the use of 0% balance transfer to spread out the payment over a longer period of time.
ii) Some loans like hire purchase repayment already calculate the interest till the end, so I find it no point to pay off it earlier (although pay off earlier will get some discount, not much).
iii) Share margin financing is such a great tool to borrow money at a low interest rate. Be sure to only buy good counter with SMF
iv) Some will refinance the house to cash out since the mortgage loan is only ~4.5%.

Things like that can help us along the way to achieve FIRE. The cash obtained from the above can be used as you like, e.g., investment

I wish to stress that the debt must be manageable and within your control to make it beneficial. Using debt is like a small leverage of your asset and it is a two-edge sword, if used improperly will bring terrible outcome

Feel free to discuss
wongmunkeong
post Aug 17 2018, 09:12 AM

Barista FIRE
Group Icon
Elite
5,608 posts

Joined: May 2011
From: Here, There, Everywhere


QUOTE(chonghe @ Aug 16 2018, 09:12 PM)
Wanted to share my opinion on debts. A lot of people want to be debt free, because debt free is free from worries etc.

This is not entirely through in my opinion. While in the process of getting FIRE, taking debt can speed up the process, if manage properly. Yea debt free is good after you reach getting old or after you have the ability to FIRE. While still

I used to thought I need to be debt free at all time so that I don't have to worry about it. Now I realise that having a manageable amount of debt can be beneficial. For example:

i) Using credit card effectively to manage cash flow. This also includes the use of 0% balance transfer to spread out the payment over a longer period of time.
ii) Some loans like hire purchase repayment already calculate the interest till the end, so I find it no point to pay off it earlier (although pay off earlier will get some discount, not much).
iii) Share margin financing is such a great tool to borrow money at a low interest rate. Be sure to only buy good counter with SMF
iv) Some will refinance the house to cash out since the mortgage loan is only ~4.5%.

Things like that can help us along the way to achieve FIRE. The cash obtained from the above can be used as you like, e.g., investment

I wish to stress that the debt must be manageable and within your control to make it beneficial. Using debt is like a small leverage of your asset and it is a two-edge sword, if used improperly will bring terrible outcome

Feel free to discuss
*
Yup yup.
Debt, like fire or water, if used properly can be a great boost for financial freedom. However, for some who can't control "unlimited wants", can kill easily.

Personally, i prefer to keep a D/E ratio of around 30%+/- - using the debts for assets or $ generating stuff.
eg.1 Balance Transfers 0% 6-12-15 months even though i can pay off total, then use the cash in hand for investments (REITs), flexi mortgage prepayments, money market, FDs, etc.

eg. 2 Hire Purchase of vehicle - 9 years loan, effective rate 5.3%pa. - also using the cash for investments (REITs) + some holding in flexi mortgage for opportunities, which cost me 1.3%pa (5.3%pa-4.6%pa)

eg. 3 Keeping my flexi mortgage until the end and extend/refinance if worthwhile smile.gif , even when there's enough cash flow to pay off. For "leveraged lelong purchases" when extreme value presents themselves - think market fears during Presidentials, BrExit, Brazil index crashes, Shanghai index crashes

Bottom line - borrow money when available & cheap, coz when kaka happens & financial institutions turns off the flow, it's expensive / hard to get when U want or need it for investments, biz cash flow, etc.

Just personal thoughts/practices ya - no gospel truths, PERSONAL finance is personal after all notworthy.gif
SUSyklooi
post Aug 17 2018, 09:28 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


QUOTE(wongmunkeong @ Aug 17 2018, 09:12 AM)
Yup yup.
..................
Bottom line - borrow money when available & cheap, coz when kaka happens & financial institutions turns off the flow, it's expensive / hard to get when U want or need it for investments, biz cash flow, etc.

Just personal thoughts/practices ya - no gospel truths, PERSONAL finance is personal after all  notworthy.gif
*
thumbup.gif that is very true (from what I saw and heard too)
if wanted to use collateral at time of business cashflow crisis.....
they don't really interested in how much machinery assets you have or how much they are valued now.
they will "MOST prefer" to be shown how much your business property or building valued

that bottom line of your is thumbup.gif
notworthy.gif notworthy.gif
Garysydney
post Aug 18 2018, 06:33 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 16 2018, 03:48 PM)
If one could live like a monk in monastery, life would be frugal and could fi/re at early age; daily life is basically waiting to eat, sleep and die.
*
Actually when you look at someone who is frugal/thrifty, you will find that with such attitudes, you will definitely cut down your living costs. I never thought (in my earlier days of my youth) that frugality was important for achieving early retirement/financial independence. I always thought it is crucial (absolutely compulsory!) to build income-producing assets (by gearing) and i have always lived with this attitude all my life until recently in the last couple years when i start to think more deeper about retirement expenses. No doubt building income-producing assets is important but if one doesn't have a very expensive lifestyle (usually because they are frugal), they require a lot less income-producing assets to sustain their lifestyle and hence can become FI/RE because any extra income will just add on to their buffer (as an insurance for periods where their expenses may grow due to unexpected events in life like major illness, etc...).

A lot of my friends in their 60s (in Sydney) are still working because they tell me they need A$55-70k/yr in expenses. All of them are professionals and they keep telling me they cannot retire because they don't have much income-producing assets. All have children who are in their 20s/30s and independent. They tell me that when their children were little, they just couldn't managed to save as everything comes in goes out immediately and they have been made redundant a couple of times. I tried to convince them their lifestyle is way too expensive (a lot of eating out - oldies like them like to drink good wine with some reds costing a couple of hundred bucks). When i analyze their lifestyle, i can easily see they can reduce their living costs by $15-20k/yr but they are accustomed to that kind of lifestyle so cutting down will become miserable/intolerable for them so they are happy to continue working. They tell me they will not stop working until they get retrenched.
icemanfx
post Aug 18 2018, 12:30 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 18 2018, 06:33 AM)
Actually when you look at someone who is frugal/thrifty, you will find that with such attitudes, you will definitely cut down your living costs. I never thought (in my earlier days of my youth) that frugality was important for achieving early retirement/financial independence. I always thought it is crucial (absolutely compulsory!) to build income-producing assets (by gearing) and i have always lived with this attitude all my life until recently in the last couple years when i start to think more deeper about retirement expenses. No doubt building income-producing assets is important but if one doesn't have a very expensive lifestyle (usually because they are frugal), they require a lot less income-producing assets to sustain their lifestyle and hence can become FI/RE because any extra income will just add on to their buffer (as an insurance for periods where their expenses may grow due to unexpected events in life like major illness, etc...).

A lot of my friends in their 60s (in Sydney) are still working because they tell me they need A$55-70k/yr in expenses. All of them are professionals and they keep telling me they cannot retire because they don't have much income-producing assets. All have children who are in their 20s/30s and independent. They tell me that when their children were little, they just couldn't managed to save as everything comes in goes out immediately and they have been made redundant a couple of times. I tried to convince them their lifestyle is way too expensive (a lot of eating out - oldies like them like to drink good wine with some reds costing a couple of hundred bucks). When i analyze their lifestyle, i can easily see they can reduce their living costs by $15-20k/yr but they are accustomed to that kind of lifestyle so cutting down will become miserable/intolerable for them so they are happy to continue working. They tell me they will not stop working until they get retrenched.
*
There is no right or wrong with individual lifestyle. Fi/re is not meant for everyone and few could achieved. If one needs to work til late age to sustain his lifestyle is his choice. If they enjoy lavish lifestyle and willing to work, it is a fulfillment. Perhaps after they retired or made redundant, they will adjust to frugal lifestyle and live within their mean.

TSmeonkutu11
post Aug 18 2018, 12:46 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


One good thing and I guess most important thing that we see nowadays (at least here😁) that the awareness towards financial management from younger people.

It is a good sign and hoping it will keep growing.

Most people cannot “tahan” with temptations and always want to keep up (showing off) with friends and neighbours. End of the month no money and some will borrow some more from friends 😅
Garysydney
post Aug 18 2018, 02:28 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 18 2018, 12:30 PM)
There is no right or wrong with individual lifestyle. Fi/re is not meant for everyone and few could achieved. If one needs to work til late age to sustain his lifestyle is his choice. If they enjoy lavish lifestyle and willing to work, it is a fulfillment. Perhaps after they retired or made redundant, they will adjust to frugal lifestyle and live within their mean.
*
I don't quite understand what you might mean by 'fulfillment' but after 60+, most people work because they need to (because they don't have the funds to sustain their current lifestyle). I can tell these people dread their job because they complain they are all required to meet strict kpi(s). If given the choice of sitting at home and going to work, you can guess which they will choose. They are all wage-earners and they are unlike people with their own business where all profits generated goes to their own pockets and thus the sense of fulfillment comes in. I am 56 and i can tell you my job doesn't give me any fulfillment. I am strictly in there for the money. I don't have any stress at work because my kpi(s) are easily met and i am bored at work because i am so free which is why my wife keeps reminding me about me getting 'gaji buta'. However, not everyone is as lucky as me and a few of them comes to badminton to 'de-stress'. If they had got used to surviving with a cheaper lifestyle, i suspect a lot of them would have stopped work. After all, most of us migrated because we hope life would be better (and easier) in a foreign country - if we need to continue to work till we are in our seventies, would you think that migrating to Aust is a mistake? All the friends that i was referring to have all migrated to Aust from Msia in the 70/80s like me.
sky18
post Aug 18 2018, 02:47 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 18 2018, 02:28 PM)
I don't quite understand what you might mean by 'fulfillment' but after 60+, most people work because they need to (because they don't have the funds to sustain their current lifestyle). I can tell these people dread their job because they complain they are all required to meet strict kpi(s). If given the choice of sitting at home and going to work, you can guess which they will choose. They are all wage-earners and they are unlike people with their own business where all profits generated goes to their own pockets and thus the sense of fulfillment comes in. I am 56 and i can tell you my job doesn't give me any fulfillment. I am strictly in there for the money. I don't have any stress at work because my kpi(s) are easily met and i am bored at work because i am so free which is why my wife keeps reminding me about me getting 'gaji buta'. However, not everyone is as lucky as me and a few of them comes to badminton to 'de-stress'. If they had got used to surviving with a cheaper lifestyle, i suspect a lot of them would have stopped work. After all, most of us migrated because we hope life would be better (and easier) in a foreign country - if we need to continue to work till we are in our seventies, would you think that migrating to Aust is a mistake? All the friends that i was referring to have all migrated to Aust from Msia in the 70/80s like me.
*
Well, it is easy for the frugal to become extravagant,but very difficult to reverse the process.


Added:
Especially for those employed in corporate world, the passion will be wane off over the years regardless you were once passionate or top employee. There will come a time when you will take up a job just for the money and nothing else. There're ton of reasons will make you not going to smile to your job; looks, we had friends get bored as too free, too stress due to insane target and timeline, nice boss replaced with a mean boss, victim of office politic, meaningless job routine, physically or illness no longer fit to jobs.

This post has been edited by sky18: Aug 18 2018, 03:07 PM
flight
post Aug 18 2018, 03:50 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
Once the wages goes up the lifestyle follows, thats probably the same with almost everyone.

Some ppl want to work. Rather than have to work.
ChessRook
post Aug 18 2018, 05:01 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
375 posts

Joined: Mar 2018
QUOTE(chonghe @ Aug 16 2018, 09:12 PM)
Wanted to share my opinion on debts. A lot of people want to be debt free, because debt free is free from worries etc.

This is not entirely through in my opinion. While in the process of getting FIRE, taking debt can speed up the process, if manage properly. Yea debt free is good after you reach getting old or after you have the ability to FIRE. While still

I used to thought I need to be debt free at all time so that I don't have to worry about it. Now I realise that having a manageable amount of debt can be beneficial. For example:

i) Using credit card effectively to manage cash flow. This also includes the use of 0% balance transfer to spread out the payment over a longer period of time.
ii) Some loans like hire purchase repayment already calculate the interest till the end, so I find it no point to pay off it earlier (although pay off earlier will get some discount, not much).
iii) Share margin financing is such a great tool to borrow money at a low interest rate. Be sure to only buy good counter with SMF
iv) Some will refinance the house to cash out since the mortgage loan is only ~4.5%.

Things like that can help us along the way to achieve FIRE. The cash obtained from the above can be used as you like, e.g., investment

I wish to stress that the debt must be manageable and within your control to make it beneficial. Using debt is like a small leverage of your asset and it is a two-edge sword, if used improperly will bring terrible outcome

Feel free to discuss
*
What if one loses their job and their spouse fell into chronic care which requires lots of $$$ for treatment at about the same time. Bad luck can happen and that debt can put more pressure. I am not meaning to bash you but just the situation of someone I know.
Garysydney
post Aug 18 2018, 07:57 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(sky18 @ Aug 18 2018, 02:47 PM)
Well, it is easy for the frugal to become extravagant,but very difficult to reverse the process.
Added:
Especially for those employed in corporate world, the passion will be wane off over the years regardless you were once passionate or top employee. There will come a time when you will take up a job just for the money and nothing else. There're ton of reasons will make you not going to smile to your job; looks, we had friends get bored as too free, too stress due to insane target and timeline, nice boss replaced with a mean boss, victim of office politic, meaningless job routine,  physically or illness no longer fit to jobs.
*
Totally agree with you.

In the corporate world, i hear a lot of people get 'burnt out' and they hate their jobs but have no choice because they need the money. This is precisely the reason why if we need to establish enough income-producing assets so that can fire our boss. This can be achieved a lot earlier if our lifestyle is maintained at the lower end by having a simple way of life. This is not always easy as forummer 'flight' has suggested that as income increases so does our lifestyle. In fact, it is very difficult to live a 'modest lifestyle' esp when our income shoots up. I must admit that i myself can't do that but i guess as long as we don't become too 'extravagant', our goal is accomplished. Even if we do indulge in a little luxury, i guess as long as we don't do it all the time, that i think is quite 'acceptable'

Your first sentence sums it all up - that it is very difficult to reverse the process of being extravagant. We will suffer like a drug addict getting withdrawal symptoms when we try to reverse the process so i always keep reminding myself constantly - 'keep the lifestyle simple with minimal luxuries'.
Ramjade
post Aug 18 2018, 08:53 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(flight @ Aug 18 2018, 03:50 PM)
Once the wages goes up the lifestyle follows, thats probably the same with almost everyone.

Some ppl want to work. Rather than have to work.
*
Not true. Well in my case.

I am still spending as if I am still on student budget even though I am working already.

Is all about discipline to achieve what you want. Will is everything.
chonghe
post Aug 18 2018, 09:00 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


QUOTE(ChessRook @ Aug 18 2018, 05:01 PM)
What if one loses their job and their spouse fell into chronic care which requires lots of $$$ for treatment at about the same time. Bad luck can happen and that debt can put more pressure. I am not meaning to bash you but just the situation of someone I know.
*
For illness part - this is why exactly we need insurance. Insurance is crucial in financial management, it helps to avoid large spending on medical treatments. Without insurance it is quite common to find someone who has lots of saving only to find it gives to the doctors

As for losing job, if finance is managed well, there is usually a few months of backup fund to prepare for this situation.
ChessRook
post Aug 18 2018, 10:19 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
375 posts

Joined: Mar 2018
QUOTE(chonghe @ Aug 18 2018, 09:00 PM)
For illness part - this is why exactly we need insurance. Insurance is crucial in financial management, it helps to avoid large spending on medical treatments. Without insurance it is quite common to find someone who has lots of saving only to find it gives to the doctors

As for losing job, if finance is managed well, there is usually a few months of backup fund to prepare for this situation.
*
Yes insurance and well budget can prepare but you can't discount the fact that debt adds an element of risk into the equation.
sky18
post Aug 18 2018, 11:39 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Aug 18 2018, 08:53 PM)
Not true. Well in my case.

I am still spending as if I am still on student budget even though I am working already.

Is all about discipline to achieve what you want. Will is everything.
*
Lifestyle inflation can be avoided once one found the contentment.


Just do yourself an experiment, try be relax, mindful and present to the moment to savor a cup of coffee at normal kopitiam, be an observer ppl around and environment of the shop; it's much better than spend 10++ for a starbuck coffee but actually tasteless if you're just rushing to DRINK it but mind ful of anxiety & thoughts about rushing job schedule.


From your statement, my guess you're likely 20+ to at most 30. Just don't push yourself too hard but find an acceptable balance. Pursuing FIRE doesn't means one must strictly maintain ZERO lifestyle inflation. Once you reached your number, you might feel some of your uphold during young time might actually unnecessary. In duality world, almost all of the matter is not an absolute black or white, but fall in between. Just imaging your big-fat bonus @ 20+ after fully committed and hardwork thorughout a year, now it merely 1 month of your paycheck at age 40+ where relax most of the time throughout the month.



Garysydney
post Aug 19 2018, 07:47 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(sky18 @ Aug 18 2018, 11:39 PM)
Lifestyle inflation can be avoided once one found the contentment.
Just do yourself an experiment, try be relax, mindful and present to the moment to savor a cup of coffee at normal kopitiam, be an observer ppl around and environment of the shop; it's much better than spend 10++ for a starbuck coffee but actually tasteless if you're just rushing to DRINK it but mind ful of anxiety & thoughts about rushing job schedule.
From your statement, my guess you're likely 20+ to at most 30. Just don't push yourself too hard but find an acceptable balance. Pursuing FIRE doesn't means one must strictly maintain ZERO lifestyle inflation. Once you reached your number, you might feel some of your uphold during young time might actually unnecessary. In duality world, almost all of the matter is not an absolute black or white, but fall in between. Just imaging your big-fat bonus @ 20+ after fully committed and hardwork thorughout a year, now it merely 1 month of your paycheck at age 40+ where relax most of the time throughout the month.
*
I think generally humans like to associate with friends/relatives who portray 'strong confidence' in themselves in the hope that one day they will be like that. Now what are the traits of someone who displays 'strong confidence in themselves', you may ask? Most people associate the term 'confidence' with being 'successful'. This brings us to the question - what are the traits of a successful person? You will see that in human behavior that what people see in someone who is successful is usually associated with material things - like an S-class Mercedes (less than 2-3 years old, not 20-year old), wears a Rolex Day-date with diamonds on the bezel and dial, wife takes a Birkin/Chanel/LV. Usually people don't know what kind of house you live in (free-standing bungalow, terrace or unit) but they probably judge by the suburb you live in (Bukit Tunku, Taman Duta, Pantai Hill,..). Now if you possess those assets and flaunt them, you will have many friends because they view you as being successful and they want to be like you! Things like humility/humble, honest/trustworthy and nice personality is viewed as less important because you may be worth rm50mil but because you don't flaunt your wealth (because you are humble and you may view this as being the important thing in life), you will be viewed as being less likeable than the one who flaunts his wealth (even though the one who is flaunting may be surviving on borrowed money). This is just the follies of modern human being and no-one can change this.
sky18
post Aug 19 2018, 10:32 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 19 2018, 07:47 AM)
I think generally humans like to associate with friends/relatives who portray 'strong confidence' in themselves in the hope that one day they will be like that. Now what are the traits of someone who displays 'strong confidence in themselves', you may ask? Most people associate the term 'confidence' with being 'successful'. This brings us to the question - what are the traits of a successful person? You will see that in human behavior that what people see in someone who is successful is usually associated with material things - like an S-class Mercedes (less than 2-3 years old, not 20-year old), wears a Rolex Day-date with diamonds on the bezel and dial, wife takes a Birkin/Chanel/LV. Usually people don't know what kind of house you live in (free-standing bungalow, terrace or unit) but they probably judge by the suburb you live in (Bukit Tunku, Taman Duta, Pantai Hill,..). Now if you possess those assets and flaunt them, you will have many friends because they view you as being successful and they want to be like you! Things like humility/humble, honest/trustworthy and nice personality is viewed as less important because you may be worth rm50mil but because you don't flaunt your wealth (because you are humble and you may view this as being the important thing in life), you will be viewed as being less likeable than the one who flaunts his wealth (even though the one who is flaunting may be surviving on borrowed money). This is just the follies of modern human being and no-one can change this.
*
LOL....very true.

Some good read on pseudo affluent: https://thinksaveretire.com/pseudo-affluent/

icemanfx
post Aug 19 2018, 12:21 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 18 2018, 06:33 AM)
Actually when you look at someone who is frugal/thrifty, you will find that with such attitudes, you will definitely cut down your living costs. I never thought (in my earlier days of my youth) that frugality was important for achieving early retirement/financial independence. I always thought it is crucial (absolutely compulsory!) to build income-producing assets (by gearing) and i have always lived with this attitude all my life until recently in the last couple years when i start to think more deeper about retirement expenses. No doubt building income-producing assets is important but if one doesn't have a very expensive lifestyle (usually because they are frugal), they require a lot less income-producing assets to sustain their lifestyle and hence can become FI/RE because any extra income will just add on to their buffer (as an insurance for periods where their expenses may grow due to unexpected events in life like major illness, etc...).

A lot of my friends in their 60s (in Sydney) are still working because they tell me they need A$55-70k/yr in expenses. All of them are professionals and they keep telling me they cannot retire because they don't have much income-producing assets. All have children who are in their 20s/30s and independent. They tell me that when their children were little, they just couldn't managed to save as everything comes in goes out immediately and they have been made redundant a couple of times. I tried to convince them their lifestyle is way too expensive (a lot of eating out - oldies like them like to drink good wine with some reds costing a couple of hundred bucks). When i analyze their lifestyle, i can easily see they can reduce their living costs by $15-20k/yr but they are accustomed to that kind of lifestyle so cutting down will become miserable/intolerable for them so they are happy to continue working. They tell me they will not stop working until they get retrenched.
*
Your friends spend a$70k p.a on living expenses because their choose to and obviously they enjoy the lifestyle. They may complaint about need to work but in return they live what they want. They could adjust to frugal lifestyle after retired.

icemanfx
post Aug 19 2018, 12:31 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 18 2018, 02:28 PM)
I don't quite understand what you might mean by 'fulfillment' but after 60+, most people work because they need to (because they don't have the funds to sustain their current lifestyle). I can tell these people dread their job because they complain they are all required to meet strict kpi(s). If given the choice of sitting at home and going to work, you can guess which they will choose. They are all wage-earners and they are unlike people with their own business where all profits generated goes to their own pockets and thus the sense of fulfillment comes in. I am 56 and i can tell you my job doesn't give me any fulfillment. I am strictly in there for the money. I don't have any stress at work because my kpi(s) are easily met and i am bored at work because i am so free which is why my wife keeps reminding me about me getting 'gaji buta'. However, not everyone is as lucky as me and a few of them comes to badminton to 'de-stress'. If they had got used to surviving with a cheaper lifestyle, i suspect a lot of them would have stopped work. After all, most of us migrated because we hope life would be better (and easier) in a foreign country - if we need to continue to work till we are in our seventies, would you think that migrating to Aust is a mistake? All the friends that i was referring to have all migrated to Aust from Msia in the 70/80s like me.
*
There is no free lunch, if one wants to have a lavish lifestyle needs to find income to sustain, dreading to work is a price to pay. If he find work is too heavy to bare, he will cut back, similarly for lifestyle. Similarly, if one choose to retire early, need to live frugally and save early and save more.

If one intended to retire at older age, amount of saving needed is less.

Whether to live a fulfilled or frugal life is subjective e.g what is a point to live like a monk til 100 y.o?

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Aug 19 2018, 12:51 PM
Ramjade
post Aug 19 2018, 01:03 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 19 2018, 12:31 PM)
There is no free lunch, if one wants to have a lavish lifestyle needs to find income to sustain, dreading to work is a price to pay. If he find work is too heavy to bare, he will cut back, similarly for lifestyle. Similarly, if one choose to retire early, need to live frugally and save early and save more.

If one intended to retire at older age, amount of saving needed is less.

Whether to live a fulfilled or frugal life is subjective e.g what is a point to live like a monk til 100 y.o?
*
Not true. If want can increase income and saving rate, is doable to live current lifestyle. Only if lifestyle >income rate + saving then is trouble.
icemanfx
post Aug 19 2018, 04:55 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


In countries that have state pension e.g Australia, u.k and if state pension is enough to live a frugal life, one need not save more or invest more at early stage.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Aug 19 2018, 04:57 PM
silverviolet
post Aug 19 2018, 10:01 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
181 posts

Joined: Nov 2008
QUOTE(Singh_Kalan @ Jul 29 2018, 06:43 PM)
I knew someone close that FI/RE at age 38 with more than RM 1M in net worth.  RE is not his option but its because of the company had wound up.  Due to lack of motivation to work for other ppl, he decided to concentrate on investment alone.  Now with alot of freetime, same lifestyle/spending and networth keep increasing.
*
the net worth include epf?
Garysydney
post Aug 20 2018, 04:03 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 19 2018, 04:55 PM)
In countries that have state pension e.g Australia, u.k and if state pension is enough to live a frugal life, one need not save more or invest more at early stage.
*
This is very true. In Aust at 67 years of age, you can get A$700/wk per couple (old-aged pension by Govt) if you have less than A$400k in retirement savings so your basic retirement costs are already covered. Most average people will need about A$40-45k/yr with a bit of eating out occasionally and overseas travel. This old-aged pension has been already there for as long as i can remember. If you have a few hundred thousand dollars (Aussie) in retirement savings at 67 (which is very easy to achieve) and you own outright your own home and car (no debts), you live quite well in this 'lucky country'. The govt has been hinting that the pension age will eventually go to 70 but no parties (Lib/Nat and Lab) is willing to do it as it is political suicide. The biggest spend in this country now by the govt is welfare esp. old-age pension (the biggest category in welfare spending) followed by health (most visits to see a GP is free as most of them bulk-bill).

The govt pays for all this by having very high personal income tax rates and company tax is 30% which is very high compared to world standards.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 20 2018, 04:05 AM
firedfire2018
post Aug 20 2018, 10:30 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
1 posts

Joined: Aug 2018


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 20 2018, 04:03 AM)
This is very true. In Aust at 67 years of age, you can get A$700/wk per couple (old-aged pension by Govt) if you have less than A$400k in retirement savings so your basic retirement costs are already covered. Most average people will need about A$40-45k/yr with a bit of eating out occasionally and overseas travel. This old-aged pension has been already there for as long as i can remember. If you have a few hundred thousand dollars (Aussie) in retirement savings at 67 (which is very easy to achieve) and you own outright your own home and car (no debts), you live quite well in this 'lucky country'. The govt has been hinting that the pension age will eventually go to 70 but no parties (Lib/Nat and Lab) is willing to do it as it is political suicide. The biggest spend in this country now by the govt is welfare esp. old-age pension (the biggest category in welfare spending) followed by health (most visits to see a GP is free as most of them bulk-bill).

The govt pays for all this by having very high personal income tax rates and company tax is 30% which is very high compared to world standards.
*
FI RE D - Financial Independence Retire Early Done

so i have decided to be fired and need advise from all here. Please only valuable advise.

1. Quit job 17 August 2018 (one of the most stressful workplace)
2. Managed to pay of car and house
3. 1 Kid
4. 1 wife
5. Passive income from interest rm3500
6. No bad habits
7. KWSP 800K (cannot touch for 15 years)
8. Other savings rm600k (including benefits & insurance termination from company) -- in process
8. Other income 7k pm
9. Healthy
10. Family expenses pm rm3k-4k


why quit? too much stress and empty promises.

what am i considered now? jobless? or retired?

plan to just reinvest the cash and generated interest. Waiting for the payout which plan to just put in FD or ASNB ( 4-6% interest ) 2-3k pm

Consider generation of monthly income rm3500 + 7000 + 2500 = 13000

with my current expenses only 3-4k pm, can save up another rm10k pm but some months indeed have other expenses like insurance or etc which i say maybe rm10k per annum. so saving per year approx (rm13k-4k) x 12 - 10k = rm98000 and again to be invested in safe deposits to generate interest.


did i make a wise decision?
Singh_Kalan
post Aug 20 2018, 10:58 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,031 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
QUOTE(silverviolet @ Aug 19 2018, 10:01 PM)
the net worth include epf?
*
Yup.. the definition of Networth = Asset - Liabilities. EPF is part of the asset.
fun_feng
post Aug 20 2018, 01:28 PM

One Cat to Rule Them ALL
*******
Senior Member
2,289 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Stairway to Heaven
Hi guys, i want to ask you, if I can settle my home and car loan by 40, then purely save money from then onward for retirement... Is it doable?
MUM
post Aug 20 2018, 01:31 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(fun_feng @ Aug 20 2018, 01:28 PM)
Hi guys, i want to ask you, if I can settle my home and car loan by 40, then purely save money from then onward for retirement... Is it doable?
*
hmm.gif i guess depends alot on
on the amount you wanted to save,
the duration of time till you want to be FIRE,
the amount of money you wish to spend during FIRE and
the amount of time from FIRE till end of time
Ramjade
post Aug 20 2018, 04:31 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(fun_feng @ Aug 20 2018, 01:28 PM)
Hi guys, i want to ask you, if I can settle my home and car loan by 40, then purely save money from then onward for retirement... Is it doable?
*
Yes possible. Why? Money used for car loan and home loan can be diverted to investment. Of course provided you investment is making money.

But still best to start early.
Ramjade
post Aug 20 2018, 04:32 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(devilspade @ Aug 20 2018, 03:27 PM)
I probably have some extra money in pocket and need ideas investing. Got only rm30k to invest. Can anyone give me suggestion what kind of investment should I do?

Got few ideas

ASB
TABUNG HAJI
Resort Investment
Buy business
Stock trader full time

** Prefer to have monthly income as I’m planning to be a fulltime housewife.

Please help!
*
Best to read this thread for ideas.
NightHeart
post Aug 20 2018, 06:32 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(fun_feng @ Aug 20 2018, 01:28 PM)
Hi guys, i want to ask you, if I can settle my home and car loan by 40, then purely save money from then onward for retirement... Is it doable?
*
As mentioned by @MUM, it depends on several factors. Is it doable? Yes of course but is it wise? That's something to consider.

Car loan is a very straight forward one, due to its fixed interest (nominal interest rate). So if you can generate more ROI than your car loan's Interest Rate, then just keep the car loan & continue using your extra funds to generate better returns. Can service your loan & can even get some extra pocket money for yourself.

Home loan is a bit different cause the rates aren't fixed, it's a bit more complex but same logic applies: If you can generate better ROI than your loan's interest rate, keep the loan & use the extra funds to generate more money for you.

There's good debts & bad debts, understand the difference & learn to leverage on good debts to bring you higher. A lot of people here has the mentality that debts = bad bad bad. Hope this opens up your vision a bit.
icemanfx
post Aug 20 2018, 07:17 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(NightHeart @ Aug 20 2018, 06:32 PM)
As mentioned by @MUM, it depends on several factors. Is it doable? Yes of course but is it wise? That's something to consider.

Car loan is a very straight forward one, due to its fixed interest (nominal interest rate). So if you can generate more ROI than your car loan's Interest Rate, then just keep the car loan & continue using your extra funds to generate better returns. Can service your loan & can even get some extra pocket money for yourself.

Home loan is a bit different cause the rates aren't fixed, it's a bit more complex but same logic applies: If you can generate better ROI than your loan's interest rate, keep the loan & use the extra funds to generate more money for you.

There's good debts & bad debts, understand the difference & learn to leverage on good debts to bring you higher. A lot of people here has the mentality that debts = bad bad bad. Hope this opens up your vision a bit.
*
Given cheap and easy credit available since 2011; if consistent and high roi investment is easy to find there should be more than 3% of adults in this country have over us$100k net worth.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Aug 20 2018, 07:40 PM
devilspade
post Aug 21 2018, 01:41 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
214 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(Ramjade @ Aug 20 2018, 04:32 PM)
Best to read this thread for ideas.
*
thank you so much!! rclxms.gif rclxms.gif icon_rolleyes.gif notworthy.gif
sky18
post Aug 21 2018, 05:03 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(devilspade @ Aug 21 2018, 01:41 PM)
thank you so much!!  rclxms.gif  rclxms.gif  icon_rolleyes.gif  notworthy.gif
*
Enjoy the hidden message from KungFu Panda too...


Garysydney
post Aug 22 2018, 06:46 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


Actually i joined this forum to find out how much it will cost a couple to be relatively comfortable in retirement (in Msia) and i did so much research until i read recently that a good gauge is how much income does a MM2H need before they qualify. Under MM2h, you are required to show that you can generate an income of rm10k/mth (and also about rm500k in fixed deposits). This is for an expat who plans to retire in Msia. So if someone can generate a consistent income of rm10k, that should be pretty comfortable (assumes you don't need to pay rent, i.e. you own outright your home as well as no car loan).

For a local, the amount needed for a comfortable retirement will probably be a lot lower. I have asked a lot of retirees (when i was holidaying in KL) how much they need, most tell me rm5k is enough. This indicates to me that a lot of retirees in KL are quite happy to retire on rm5k.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 22 2018, 06:47 AM
kingz113
post Aug 22 2018, 08:35 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
323 posts

Joined: Jul 2006


I'm young but love to speak to seniors regarding retirement.

When they're retired, seniors almost everyday cook at home, not because they have no choice, but because the food at home taste better, way more nutritious and of course because they have all the time in the world. Not to mention their intake is so little with just plain food.

One couple who is retired for 10 years said 3k is way more than enough. This is a simple couple who do not do much travelling.

Another couple also gave a similar figure. When I asked is 5k a month sufficient, I was met with a light ridicule saying what are they gonna do with so much money a month. This is a couple who travels 8-10 times overseas a year, has potentially upwards of 10m in assets. They live a simple life but made good financial decisions hence the extremes in assets value and frugal mentality. Their travels are paid for by what the husband earns on a PT basis selling niche handmade hardware (USD). They are one of the happiest couple I know.

Based on the above, I can safely conclude that 3-4k a month is enough, with a sellable PT skillset, sufficient medical coverage and a comfortable nest egg. Provided your kids education, house and cars are paid for.
Garysydney
post Aug 22 2018, 09:41 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(kingz113 @ Aug 22 2018, 08:35 AM)
I'm young but love to speak to seniors regarding retirement.

When they're retired, seniors almost everyday cook at home, not because they have no choice, but because the food at home taste better, way more nutritious and of course because they have all the time in the world. Not to mention their intake is so little with just plain food.

One couple who is retired for 10 years said 3k is way more than enough. This is a simple couple who do not do much travelling.

Another couple also gave a similar figure. When I asked is 5k a month sufficient, I was met with a light ridicule saying what are they gonna do with so much money a month. This is a couple who travels 8-10 times overseas a year, has potentially upwards of 10m in assets. They live a simple life but made good financial decisions hence the extremes in assets value and frugal mentality. Their travels are paid for by what the husband earns on a PT basis selling niche handmade hardware (USD). They are one of the happiest couple I know.

Based on the above, I can safely conclude that 3-4k a month is enough, with a sellable PT skillset, sufficient medical coverage and a comfortable nest egg. Provided your kids education, house and cars are paid for.
*
Good to know this - by the way are those people you are talking to in KL? It's because if you want to live in a smaller town upon retirement, the amount required is a lot less than KL.

Having a side-income after retirement is very good if you still enjoy doing it as it helps supplement your retirement income.

One thing is over-estimating (rather than under-estimating) how much you need upon retirement is more desirable as you build a bit of buffer into the figures. Only realizing you need a lot more than you budgeted for may push you back to the workforce when you don't really feel like working anymore!!
kingz113
post Aug 22 2018, 10:15 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
323 posts

Joined: Jul 2006


Yes theyre smack in the centre of PJ where everything is more expensive. I've observed that it is super imperative for me to be somewhere super convenient and strategic during retirement. First being the convenience. Second being ppl tend to visit u more. Thirdly u have a better community with more entertainment options (ppl are more willing to do things undeterred by distance for a wider range of activities).

From my close observations of retirees, there is a stark difference between those who have a PT gig, and those that isolate themselves at home doing gardening everyday. Those without a side gig tend to be more reclused (a natural consequence of isolation) and alot more intolerable by just being a pain to be with. The years of boredom will take a toll on someone's mental health.

Those that do a side gig (for supplementing income or otherwise) can be the gentlest nicest ppl to talk to. It's like they've reached this level of zen when they leave the busyness of this world.

Whilst financial freedom is the goal for retirement, having a purposeful endeavour sustains you thru that golden period, instead of money alone.

I for one look up to my old boss. He's 80, goes to his professional work at 830am and leaves work at 4pm mon-sat. He doesn't receive a salary, just paid for expenses. I hope I can still be the same as I age, to have purposeful vocation until the day I leave.
Garysydney
post Aug 22 2018, 10:59 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(kingz113 @ Aug 22 2018, 10:15 AM)
Yes theyre smack in the centre of PJ where everything is more expensive. I've observed that it is super imperative for me to be somewhere super convenient and strategic during retirement. First being the convenience. Second being ppl tend to visit u more. Thirdly u have a better community with more entertainment options (ppl are more willing to do things undeterred by distance for a wider range of activities).

From my close observations of retirees, there is a stark difference between those who have a PT gig, and those that isolate themselves at home doing gardening everyday. Those without a side gig tend to be more reclused (a natural consequence of isolation) and alot more intolerable by just being a pain to be with. The years of boredom will take a toll on someone's mental health.

Those that do a side gig (for supplementing income or otherwise) can be the gentlest nicest ppl to talk to. It's like they've reached this level of zen when they leave the busyness of this world.

Whilst financial freedom is the goal for retirement, having a purposeful endeavour sustains you thru that golden period, instead of money alone.

I for one look up to my old boss. He's 80, goes to his professional work at 830am and leaves work at 4pm mon-sat. He doesn't receive a salary, just paid for expenses. I hope I can still be the same as I age, to have purposeful vocation until the day I leave.
*
Actually post-retirement can be extremely boring! You need to find things to do and usually interesting activities require money. Usually after 70, we tend to slow down a lot and we usually tend not to want to go faraway places, i.e. we prefer to do things that involves being around home more as we tend to get tired more easily. Now medical costs tend to increase most during this period. The best financial plan after 70 is 'good health' because it can save you a lot of money.

Now most people will work till 60 so they tend to be still quite active between 60-70. They probably like to travel more if they can afford it. Also another big ticket item is eating out in good restaurants during this period. Some people like to drive a flashy car after they retire but most will be happy to drive a more basic car because our reflexes tend to slow down when older and we don't crave high speeds anymore. Also getting in/out of the car tend to be more problematic because the knees get sore more often (esp going up stairs). I am bringing up overseas travel and eating out (in better restaurants) because usually these are the few items (that i can think of) that will bump up retirement costs. If you tend not to have these extravagances, retirement costs can be lowered significantly.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 22 2018, 11:00 AM
Showtime747
post Aug 22 2018, 11:55 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 22 2018, 10:59 AM)
Actually post-retirement can be extremely boring! You need to find things to do and usually interesting activities require money. Usually after 70, we tend to slow down a lot and we usually tend not to want to go faraway places, i.e. we prefer to do things that involves being around home more as we tend to get tired more easily. Now medical costs tend to increase most during this period. The best financial plan after 70 is 'good health' because it can save you a lot of money.

Now most people will work till 60 so they tend to be still quite active between 60-70. They probably like to travel more if they can afford it. Also another big ticket item is eating out in good restaurants during this period. Some people like to drive a flashy car after they retire but most will be happy to drive a more basic car because our reflexes tend to slow down when older and we don't crave high speeds anymore. Also getting in/out of the car tend to be more problematic because the knees get sore more often (esp going up stairs). I am bringing up overseas travel and eating out (in better restaurants)  because usually these are the few items (that i can think of) that will bump up retirement costs. If you tend not to have these extravagances, retirement costs can be lowered significantly.
*
Hey Gary, long time no talk....

I stay in Australia quite often, so I know a little bit about the cost of living in both Malaysia and Australia...

I can tell you cost of living in Malaysia is lower than Australia. Especially your passive income is in AUD. After conversion, everything is 3 times cheaper.

For food (home cook), 2 person in Australia need maybe $200 per fortnight. In Malaysia, maybe RM800 per month is enough. I am talking about fruits, vege and some meat. Pork is about $15/kg in Coles, in Malaysia about RM30/kg. Free range chicken is about $6/kg. In malaysia about RM9/kg. Vege maybe average $2 per kg in Aust, in Malaysia, RM2-4/kg can get many types of vege. But I find that the quality of meat and vege is way better in Australia. In Malaysia, you may not be able to get the same quality. Onion, lettuce, carrot, tomato, lamb, steak, port are top quality in Australia. While in Malaysia, the quality is second grade.

For eating out, that is where malaysia is much cheaper and taste better too. In tai chow, 2 person 3 dishes maybe around RM60. If you order seafood, maybe RM100. For fried rice/chow kui teow is around RM6 or RM7 each. KFC in malaysia RM13/meal. In Australia, fried rice alone is already $12. Red Rooster is $12/meal. For dimsum, maybe already $60 for 2 person. For posher restaurant, it will be >$100. Price aside, it is the taste which matters. Malaysia best food is not in those posh restaurant, but cheaper street food and kopitiam. So I think you will enjoy yourself eating out in Malaysia. So many varieties authentic chinese, malay, indian, not like Australia international food are prepared for kuai loh taste

Petrol in Malaysia is about 50% cheaper too.

Electricity is maybe $0.20-$0.40 per unit on average depending on provider. While in malaysia, it is about average RM0.30-RM0.50 depending on usage

Water is free in Selangor. And very cheap other parts of Malaysia. While in Australia it cost a bomb at least $100 per month !

Movie is also cheaper in Malaysia about RM13 per ticket. Hoyts is about $15. I think both Malaysia and Australia has 50% concession for age above 60...

You have already a house in Malaysia, so that is taken care of. Car price is slightly more expensive in Malaysia by maybe 25%, both small car or luxury car. But that is a one-off cost

For medical, we have GP clinics in malaysia which is considered affordable. Small sickness consultation+medicine is under RM100. Maybe for serious illness, you get insurance. Depending on the amount covered, it may range from RM400-RM1000 per month for older people. If I were you, I will keep PR or convert to citizen. If got big health problem, then fly back to Australia for treatment. The hospital service is better there.

So, I would think for basic living, RM2k for a retired couple with no kid is very comfortable. Throw in another RM1k for eating out per month. RM3k will be sufficient for simple but enjoyable life. Your passive income from Australia has a lot of buffer !






Showtime747
post Aug 22 2018, 12:06 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
Ah....another thing you will enjoy here is the cheap manpower

If you ask bangla to mow your lawn, RM30 or maybe cheaper. In Australia, $50

Haircut you still can get about RM15 in the small salon. $20-$30 for simple haircut there

Household repair you can easily afford in Malaysia. Plumber, Electrician, Contractor for roof repair you can ask them to do it here. In Australia, everything DIY because too expensive...
Garysydney
post Aug 22 2018, 12:25 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 22 2018, 11:55 AM)
Hey Gary, long time no talk....

I stay in Australia quite often, so I know a little bit about the cost of living in both Malaysia and Australia...

I can tell you cost of living in Malaysia is lower than Australia. Especially your passive income is in AUD. After conversion, everything is 3 times cheaper.

For food (home cook), 2 person in Australia need maybe $200 per fortnight. In Malaysia, maybe RM800 per month is enough. I am talking about fruits, vege and some meat. Pork is about $15/kg in Coles, in Malaysia about RM30/kg. Free range chicken is about $6/kg. In malaysia about RM9/kg. Vege maybe average $2 per kg in Aust, in Malaysia, RM2-4/kg can get many types of vege. But I find that the quality of meat and vege is way better in Australia. In Malaysia, you may not be able to get the same quality. Onion, lettuce, carrot, tomato, lamb, steak, port are top quality in Australia. While in Malaysia, the quality is second grade.

For eating out, that is where malaysia is much cheaper and taste better too. In tai chow, 2 person 3 dishes maybe around RM60. If you order seafood, maybe RM100. For fried rice/chow kui teow is around RM6 or RM7 each. KFC in malaysia RM13/meal. In Australia, fried rice alone is already $12. Red Rooster is $12/meal. For dimsum, maybe already $60 for 2 person. For posher restaurant, it will be >$100. Price aside, it is the taste which matters. Malaysia best food is not in those posh restaurant, but cheaper street food and kopitiam. So I think you will enjoy yourself eating out in Malaysia. So many varieties authentic chinese, malay, indian, not like Australia international food are prepared for kuai loh taste

Petrol in Malaysia is about 50% cheaper too.

Electricity is maybe $0.20-$0.40 per unit on average depending on provider. While in malaysia, it is about average RM0.30-RM0.50 depending on usage

Water is free in Selangor. And very cheap other parts of Malaysia. While in Australia it cost a bomb at least $100 per month !

Movie is also cheaper in Malaysia about RM13 per ticket. Hoyts is about $15. I think both Malaysia and Australia has 50% concession for age above 60...

You have already a house in Malaysia, so that is taken care of. Car price is slightly more expensive in Malaysia by maybe 25%, both small car or luxury car. But that is a one-off cost

For medical, we have GP clinics in malaysia which is considered affordable. Small sickness consultation+medicine is under RM100. Maybe for serious illness, you get insurance. Depending on the amount covered, it may range from RM400-RM1000 per month for older people. If I were you, I will keep PR or convert to citizen. If got big health problem, then fly back to Australia for treatment. The hospital service is better there.

So, I would think for basic living, RM2k for a retired couple with no kid is very comfortable. Throw in another RM1k for eating out per month. RM3k will be sufficient for simple but enjoyable life. Your passive income from Australia has a lot of buffer !
*
Hi Showtime

I must thank you very much because you were the one who answered a lot of my questions when i first joined LYN. To be honest when i first made the query in the USD/MYR thread, there was someone who complained about what i was asking being out of topic and i was totally confused as i was so new to LYN. You took me to another thread about retirement and i totally was lost (at that time) because i didn't know how to get back to that thread after i left it. rclxub.gif

I have always been a very 'careful person' esp in the later years of my life which is why i worry a lot about finances. My friends/relatives around me all worry about their retirement expenses because cost of living is very high in Sydney. When the govt gives a couple A$700/wk for the most basic lifestyle in retirement, you can imagine how expensive living costs are and that is the reason why a lot of people still want to work till their 70s in Sydney. A lot of old-age pensioners (who solely rely on the govt pension) complain that A$700 is not enough because things have gone up so much!! Sydney (and for that fact Australia) is so far away from everywhere, travel expenses are greatly exacerbated due to the distance away from the rest of the world. People who rely solely on the old-age pension will struggle unless they have a little of extra retirement fund.

I have given it considerable consideration about going back to KL to live and i suspect that i will definitely have to give up my PR one day. The alternative is to take up Aussie citizenship and apply for MM2H but i need to wait 18 months (after applying nowadays) before you will get it and i plan to go back to KL mid-2019 when i turn 57. For your info, if you leave the country (during the period when you are applying for citizenship), your application is suspended until you are back in Aust. This will throw my retirement plan into chaos!!

I thank you for giving me the information for a comparison of the price of goods/services in the 2 countries. Both my wife and myself love eating out quite a lot (even though it is a lot less healthy) - we are probably catching up with the 'eating-out in KL' for the lost time we weren't in KL (close to 40 years now).

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 24 2018, 08:10 AM
Garysydney
post Aug 22 2018, 01:22 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 22 2018, 12:06 PM)
Ah....another thing you will enjoy here is the cheap manpower

If you ask bangla to mow your lawn, RM30 or maybe cheaper. In Australia, $50

Haircut you still can get about RM15 in the small salon. $20-$30 for simple haircut there

Household repair you can easily afford in Malaysia. Plumber, Electrician, Contractor for roof repair you can ask them to do it here. In Australia, everything DIY because too expensive...
*
If you need help with problems in the house, you are in big trouble in Sydney!! Plumbers charge A$100 just to step in your house during work hours 8am-5pm Mon-Sat. An easy 15 min job can easily cost A$300. The plumbers are usually quite smart - they slowly change whatever they need to so that it looks very time-consuming so they can charge more. I had a Msian friend who needed his garden dug up because the pipe under the garden was cracked. 2 plumbers came and quoted him A$7500 cheapest for the 2-day job!! That is why you better pray that it is a small job when a trades person turn up at your place (a lot of times they don't even turn up and you had to take time off work!). We learn how to do simple things like changing tap gasket so we can save a bit of money. A lot of my friends change their own lubricant oil/filter esp those who have a few cars. Labor is ridiculously expensive as most trades persons charge about $120-180/hr for their services. That is why i like so much about Msia - the labour is so cheap! Do you know that in a recent report, it quoted Sydney cars are the dirtiest in the world and you know why? It is because the cheapest car wash (wash exterior only) is more than A$25 where i live. What can you do when min wage is more than A$20/hr (incl super). Good for workers and not good for the consumer.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 22 2018, 01:26 PM
Showtime747
post Aug 22 2018, 03:29 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 22 2018, 12:25 PM)
Hi Showtime

I must thank you very much because you were the one who answered a lot of my questions when i first joined LYN. To be honest when i first made the query in the USD/MYR thread, there was someone who complained about what i was asking being out of topic. You took me to another thread about retirement and i totally was lost (at that time) because i didn't know how to get back to that thread after i left it.  rclxub.gif 

I have always been a very 'careful person' esp in the later years of my life which is why i worry a lot about finances. My friends/relatives around me all worry about their retirement expenses because cost of living is very high in Sydney. When the govt gives a couple A$700/wk for the most basic lifestyle in retirement, you can imagine how expensive living costs are and that is the reason why a lot of people still want to work till their 70s in Sydney. A lot of old-age pensioners (who solely rely on the govt pension) complain that A$700 is not enough because things have gone up so much!! Sydney (and for that fact Australia) is so far away from everywhere, travel expenses are greatly exacerbated due to the distance away from the rest of the world. People who rely solely on the old-age pension will struggle unless they have a little of extra retirement fund.

I have given it considerable consideration about going back to KL to live and i suspect that i will definitely have to give up my PR one day. The alternative is to take up Aussie citizenship and apply for MM2H but i need to wait 18 months (after applying nowadays) before you will get it and i plan to go back to KL mid-2019 when i turn 57. For your info, if you leave the country (during the period when you are applying for citizenship), your application is suspended until you are back in Aust. This will throw my retirement plan into chaos!!

I thank you for giving me the information for a comparison of the price of goods/services in the 2 countries. Both my wife and myself love eating out quite a lot (even though it is a lot less healthy) - we are probably catching up with the 'eating-out in KL' for the lost time we weren't in KL (close to 40 years now).
*
At our age, nothing is more important than making ourselves and our other half happy. I am sure you and your wife will enjoy living in malaysia.

Living in KL is not a problem for you financially. The only thing left outstanding in your plan is medical insurance. It’s good to research now. Because you need to undergo medical checkup and also a waiting period. Get you and your wife a family coverage of about RM1m pa and no lifetime limit, and guaranteed renewal too. Insurance here must have “life” portion and “medical” portion. You don’t need the “life” portion so put “medical” portion to the max, “life” portion to min.

There are many choice of insurance companies. Allianz, HLA, prudential etc etc. No good to ask for recommendations from relatives. Once you ask, then you are stuck with the relative. Best is you research and compare the medical policy from different companies, and once you have selected the policy, only ask your relatives whether they know any agent from that company.

Actually the public hospitals in Malaysia is not that bad. The only bad thing is you have to wait in the long queue. Also there could be times when the hospitals run out of medicine supplies. Hopeful with the change of government, we can have better service. I have been to selayang and sungai Buloh hospitals, the environment is quite modern and they have all the medical equipment and specialists there. So, even without private insurance, there are still public hospitals we can go to. And really cheap too.
Showtime747
post Aug 22 2018, 03:38 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 22 2018, 01:22 PM)
If you need help with problems in the house, you are in big trouble in Sydney!! Plumbers charge A$100 just to step in your house during work hours 8am-5pm Mon-Sat. An easy 15 min job can easily cost A$300. The plumbers are usually quite smart -  they slowly change whatever they need to so that it looks very time-consuming so they can charge more. I had a Msian friend who needed his garden dug up because the pipe under the garden was cracked. 2 plumbers came and quoted him A$7500 cheapest for the 2-day job!! That is why you better pray that it is a small job when a trades person turn up at your place (a lot of times they don't even turn up and you had to take time off work!). We learn how to do simple things like changing tap gasket so we can save a bit of money. A lot of my friends change their own lubricant oil/filter esp those who have a few cars. Labor is ridiculously expensive as most trades persons charge about $120-180/hr for their services. That is why i like so much about Msia - the labour is so cheap! Do you know that in a recent report, it quoted Sydney cars are the dirtiest in the world and you know why? It is because the cheapest car wash (wash exterior only) is more than A$25 where i live. What can you do when min wage is more than A$20/hr (incl super). Good for workers and not good for the consumer.
*
shocking.gif

That’s why the tradies earn more than some of the professionals like accountants, chemists and even architects in australia. Plumbers, electricians, carpenters, construction workers earns close to 6 figure while the professionals average only $60-70k

One more thing, are you affected by the vacant residence tax like Melbourne if you move to Malaysia ?

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Aug 22 2018, 03:45 PM
icemanfx
post Aug 22 2018, 08:06 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 22 2018, 03:29 PM)
At our age, nothing is more important than making ourselves and our other half happy. I am sure you and your wife will enjoy living in malaysia.

Living in KL is not a problem for you financially. The only thing left outstanding in your plan is medical insurance. It’s good to research now. Because you need to undergo medical checkup and also a waiting period. Get you and your wife a family coverage of about RM1m pa and no lifetime limit, and guaranteed renewal too. Insurance here must have “life” portion and “medical” portion. You don’t need the “life” portion so put “medical” portion to the max, “life” portion to min.

There are many choice of insurance companies. Allianz, HLA, prudential etc etc. No good to ask for recommendations from relatives. Once you ask, then you are stuck with the relative. Best is you research and compare the medical policy from different companies, and once you have selected the policy, only ask your relatives whether they know any agent from that company.

Actually the public hospitals in Malaysia is not that bad. The only bad thing is you have to wait in the long queue. Also there could be times when the hospitals run out of medicine supplies. Hopeful with the change of government, we can have better service. I have been to selayang and sungai Buloh hospitals, the environment is quite modern and they have all the medical equipment and specialists there. So, even without private insurance, there are still public hospitals we can go to. And really cheap too.
*
Hope you went to hospital to visit friends or relatives rather than been admitted.

Imported foods in this country is more of 3rd grade than 2nd grade.

Labourers always find comfort in labourers' foods/cooking.

Earning in foreign country and spend in cheap country is always value for money.

Garysydney
post Aug 23 2018, 06:24 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 22 2018, 03:38 PM)
shocking.gif

That’s why the tradies earn more than some of the professionals like accountants, chemists and even architects in australia. Plumbers, electricians, carpenters, construction workers earns close to 6 figure while the professionals average only $60-70k

One more thing, are you affected by the vacant residence tax like Melbourne if you move to Malaysia ?
*
As far as i know Victoria is the only state that imposes vacant residence tax. There is no such tax in NSW.

Residential property prices in Sydney has taken quite a significant fall since the beginning of the year. There is fear among those who bought recently that there may be further falls in the coming 12 months as banks are tightening up their lending due to the Royal Commission (into Banking). The Royal Commission exposed a lot of illegal banking practices where income/expenses were forged and mortgage brokers were collaborating with the lenders to 'close an eye' on figures that were highly dubious. That is why the share price in banks dropped quite significantly earlier in the year.

I take consolation that you have stated quite a significantly lower figure (than i expected) for monthly expenses than (i thought possible) that a couple could live with in retirement in KL. In Sydney, no matter how thrifty you are, you will need at least A$30k+/yr in retirement (couple). I was still having doubts about my passive income (as i tend to worry more than i should) being sufficient to retire in KL earlier in the year.

Regarding maintaining the PR status, we need to fulfill the '2/5 years stay' and i think i may not be able to fulfill that condition - over the last 15 years, i have known a lot of parents (older) bringing their children over (under business migration) and eventually the old man decided to go back to KL to live because they prefer the lifestyle in KL and leaving the wife with the children here.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 23 2018, 06:27 AM
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 07:25 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(icemanfx @ Aug 22 2018, 08:06 PM)
Hope you went to hospital to visit friends or relatives rather than been admitted.

Imported foods in this country is more of 3rd grade than 2nd grade.

Labourers always find comfort in labourers' foods/cooking.

Earning in foreign country and spend in cheap country is always value for money.
*
Hi son, was visiting my staff. One was giving birth, the other car accident.

The service for giving labour is even better than private hospital. They will send nurses to your house after discharge just to make sure the new mother knows how to take care of the baby like bathing and correct way to use diapers. Private hospitals don’t have such service !
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 07:38 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 23 2018, 06:24 AM)
As far as i know Victoria is the only state that imposes vacant residence tax. There is no such tax in NSW.

Residential property prices in Sydney has taken quite a significant fall since the beginning of the year. There is fear among those who bought recently that there may be further falls in the coming 12 months as banks are tightening up their lending due to the Royal Commission (into Banking). The Royal Commission exposed a lot of illegal banking practices where income/expenses were forged and mortgage brokers were collaborating with the lenders to 'close an eye' on figures that were highly dubious. That is why the share price in banks dropped quite significantly earlier in the year.

I take consolation that you have stated quite a significantly lower figure (than i expected) for monthly expenses than (i thought possible) that a couple could live with in retirement in KL. In Sydney, no matter how thrifty you are, you will need at least A$30k+/yr in retirement (couple). I was still having doubts about my passive income (as i tend to worry more than i should) being sufficient to retire in KL earlier in the year.

Regarding maintaining the PR status, we need to fulfill the '2/5 years stay' and i think i may not be able to fulfill that condition - over the last 15 years, i have known a lot of parents (older) bringing their children over (under business migration) and eventually the old man decided to go back to KL to live because they prefer the lifestyle in KL and leaving the wife with the children here.
*
Gary, you have about 4-5x more buffer than the amount needed. If your passive income isn’t enough, then majority of KL retirees will be staving biggrin.gif

Your income level is the dream of many youngsters in this thread. If you notice, some aim for only RM1m nest egg to generate RM30-40k of passive income. You already have way more than that.

There is a Chinese saying “if your horse dies, get off the horse and walk”. Life will work out. Just enjoy the moment biggrin.gif

Garysydney
post Aug 23 2018, 09:09 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 07:38 AM)
Gary, you have about 4-5x more buffer than the amount needed. If your passive income isn’t enough, then majority of  KL retirees will be staving  biggrin.gif

Your income level is the dream of many youngsters in this thread. If you notice, some aim for only RM1m nest egg to generate RM30-40k of passive income. You already have way more than that.

There is a Chinese saying “if your horse dies, get off the horse and walk”. Life will work out. Just enjoy the moment  biggrin.gif
*
Thank you Showtime.

After living in Sydney for about 40 years now, i have only known that if you come across problems, you better fix it yourself or find a friend to help you because it is so expensive to get help in Sydney as labour costs are so high (thanks to the high minimum wage! and high trades-person hourly rate). Can you imagine that we need more than A$30k/yr for basic survival (this is the 'poverty line' according to govt definition) in Sydney.

I will let you know the story of a good friend of mine who is 81 years old now (with on-coming alzheimer's) and he retired with more than A$2mil in 2006. He thought he had plenty as he sold his surgery (he is a doctor and the wife was the receptionist/nurse) and put all that into his superfund. He spent his retirement with all the usual comforts (like eating out 3-4 times a week and 1 overseas trip back to Batu Pahat for about a week every yr). To cut a long story short, his A$2mil+ is nearly all gone (he didn't want to get the old-age pension because he is a very proud man and doesn't want to rely on govt welfare). He doesn't gamble and has no vices at all. He helped one son and one daughter a little financially as the kids were struggling financially. He didn't spend much on luxuries at all (he drives a small Japanese car and the house is still the same one since he retired) as he doesn't believe in luxuries and was quite a simple man. From looking at him (he is a very good friend of mine and i have known him since 1981), i was telling my wife that retirement in Sydney is very expensive as he is a good example!! This is the reason why i find it so hard to convince myself that an overseas retirement can be so much cheaper!!

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 23 2018, 09:10 AM
cheefai7
post Aug 23 2018, 09:34 AM

making coffee constantly
****
Senior Member
609 posts

Joined: Apr 2006



QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 22 2018, 01:22 PM)
If you need help with problems in the house, you are in big trouble in Sydney!! Plumbers charge A$100 just to step in your house during work hours 8am-5pm Mon-Sat. An easy 15 min job can easily cost A$300. The plumbers are usually quite smart -  they slowly change whatever they need to so that it looks very time-consuming so they can charge more. I had a Msian friend who needed his garden dug up because the pipe under the garden was cracked. 2 plumbers came and quoted him A$7500 cheapest for the 2-day job!! That is why you better pray that it is a small job when a trades person turn up at your place (a lot of times they don't even turn up and you had to take time off work!). We learn how to do simple things like changing tap gasket so we can save a bit of money. A lot of my friends change their own lubricant oil/filter esp those who have a few cars. Labor is ridiculously expensive as most trades persons charge about $120-180/hr for their services. That is why i like so much about Msia - the labour is so cheap! Do you know that in a recent report, it quoted Sydney cars are the dirtiest in the world and you know why? It is because the cheapest car wash (wash exterior only) is more than A$25 where i live. What can you do when min wage is more than A$20/hr (incl super). Good for workers and not good for the consumer.
*
About the dirtiest car part, I have to agree, during my travel to Perth, I thought Aussie weather are dry, windy and duty, thus the dirty car, or the Aussie are born adventurous to roam the outback, so don't bother to clean the car. That until one day, I walk passed a car wash shop and the washing is $20A... Malaysia only RM15 with washing, vacuuming and deodorizing.
Garysydney
post Aug 23 2018, 09:44 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(cheefai7 @ Aug 23 2018, 09:34 AM)
About the dirtiest car part, I have to agree, during my travel to Perth, I thought Aussie weather are dry, windy and duty, thus the dirty car, or the Aussie are born adventurous to roam the outback, so don't bother to clean the car. That until one day, I walk passed a car wash shop and the washing is $20A... Malaysia only RM15 with washing, vacuuming and deodorizing.
*
In Sydney, car wash is a luxury. If you want to do interior and exterior, you are looking at about A$50. It is because labour is so expensive!!
MUM
post Aug 23 2018, 09:44 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(cheefai7 @ Aug 23 2018, 09:34 AM)
About the dirtiest car part, I have to agree, during my travel to Perth, I thought Aussie weather are dry, windy and duty, thus the dirty car, or the Aussie are born adventurous to roam the outback, so don't bother to clean the car. That until one day, I walk passed a car wash shop and the washing is $20A... Malaysia only RM15 with washing, vacuuming and deodorizing.
*
in Msia, the minimum wage is about RM35 per day
thus RM15 is about 1/2 day salary

In Australia, $20A is about how many hours pay of a minimun pay salaried worker?
cheefai7
post Aug 23 2018, 09:55 AM

making coffee constantly
****
Senior Member
609 posts

Joined: Apr 2006



QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 23 2018, 09:44 AM)
In Sydney, car wash is a luxury. If you want to do interior and exterior, you are looking at about A$50. It is because labour is so expensive!!
*
Looking at another perspective is, people is being well paid, thus low in thief and robbery, educated and good civil. To save cost, go for robotic automation or diy.
cheefai7
post Aug 23 2018, 09:56 AM

making coffee constantly
****
Senior Member
609 posts

Joined: Apr 2006



QUOTE(MUM @ Aug 23 2018, 09:44 AM)
in Msia, the minimum wage is about RM35 per day
thus RM15 is about 1/2 day salary

In Australia, $20A is about how many hours pay of a minimun pay salaried worker?
*
I think Australia minimum wage is about $20A per hour.
Garysydney
post Aug 23 2018, 10:54 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(cheefai7 @ Aug 23 2018, 09:56 AM)
I think Australia minimum wage is about $20A per hour.
*
Yes - that is correct. If you include super, the min wage in Aust is A$23/hr. The unions are very strong and have been pushing this figure higher and higher every year. Min wage is for jobs that don't require any skills like waitresses/delivery drivers/labourers... Actually this minimum wage has actually pushed the whole wage system higher because if the minimum wage is high, you will have to pay a lot higher than that for skilled labour. This is the reason why Aust wages are higher than Spore but Spore has much lower personal-income taxes than Aust so if you compare net salaries, there is only a slight difference for middle income earners. The difference in directors/senior executives pay will be much higher in Spore (in favour of Spore) because they pay a lot less tax while in Aust, you will be paying close to 50% tax if you are a high-income earner.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 23 2018, 10:55 AM
MUM
post Aug 23 2018, 11:37 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,854 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(cheefai7 @ Aug 23 2018, 09:56 AM)
I think Australia minimum wage is about $20A per hour.
*
thks for the info...
hmm.gif in this case,...it costed about 1/2 days wage to wash a car in M'sia, where else it just cost 1 hour's wage in Australia...
icemanfx
post Aug 23 2018, 12:10 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(MUM @ Aug 23 2018, 11:37 AM)
thks for the info...
hmm.gif in this case,...it costed about 1/2 days wage to wash a car in M'sia, where else it just cost 1 hour's wage in Australia...
*
Similarly for meal at mcdonald's, restaurants, etc. eating out in australia may be expensive in absolute number but not relative to income.

tax on income is high in australia because of the welfare system e.g pensions, etc.

wages is high in australia largely because of legislation (trade man must be licensed), trade union, etc and policy to even income between blue collar and white collar workers.

if one find expensive to retire in sydney could relocate to queensland, house price difference would be more than enough to live a comfortable life.

Garysydney
post Aug 23 2018, 12:13 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(MUM @ Aug 23 2018, 11:37 AM)
thks for the info...
hmm.gif in this case,...it costed about 1/2 days wage to wash a car in M'sia, where else it just cost 1 hour's wage in Australia...
*
The min wage has to be kept at that level and there will be no way that it can be lowered because the wage structure in Aust is based on that min wage. If there are any attempts to bring it down, the whole wage structure in Aust will collapse because skilled wages will also need to come down and it will totally destroy the fabric of this wage structure - it will have snowballing effect which will create chaos in the wage system in Aust. The only plausible thing the govt can do (to lower min wage) is to freeze the min wage (for a period of time).

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 23 2018, 12:13 PM
SUSyklooi
post Aug 23 2018, 12:21 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


QUOTE(MUM @ Aug 23 2018, 11:37 AM)
thks for the info...
hmm.gif in this case,...it costed about 1/2 days wage to wash a car in M'sia, where else it just cost 1 hour's wage in Australia...
*
WOW...more expensive in Malaysia than in Australia to wash a car.....
luckily, i think water in malaysia are cheaper, thus many car DIY in Malaysia
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 01:13 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 23 2018, 09:09 AM)
Thank you Showtime.

After living in Sydney for about 40 years now, i have only known that if you come across problems, you better fix it yourself or find a friend to help you because it is so expensive to get help in Sydney as labour costs are so high (thanks to the high minimum wage! and high trades-person hourly rate). Can you imagine that we need more than A$30k/yr for basic survival (this is the 'poverty line' according to govt definition) in Sydney.

I will let you know the story of a good friend of mine who is 81 years old now (with on-coming alzheimer's) and he retired with more than A$2mil in 2006. He thought he had plenty as he sold his surgery (he is a doctor and the wife was the receptionist/nurse) and put all that into his superfund. He spent his retirement with all the usual comforts (like eating out 3-4 times a week and 1 overseas trip back to Batu Pahat for about a week every yr). To cut a long story short, his A$2mil+ is nearly all gone (he didn't want to get the old-age pension because he is a very proud man and doesn't want to rely on govt welfare). He doesn't gamble and has no vices at all. He helped one son and one daughter a little financially as the kids were struggling financially. He didn't spend much on luxuries at all (he drives a small Japanese car and the house is still the same one since he retired) as he doesn't believe in luxuries and was quite a simple man. From looking at him (he is a very good friend of mine and i have known him since 1981), i was telling my wife that retirement in Sydney is very expensive as he is a good example!! This is the reason why i find it so hard to convince myself that an overseas retirement can be so much cheaper!!
*
Personal opinion.....I think your friend made a mistake in his investment. He is using his nest egg A$2m to retire, instead of using "the returns from his nest egg" to retire.

As we don't know to what age we will live until, eating into the nest egg is not a good retirement plan

We should use the return instead for retirement, leaving the nest egg untouched.

I think you are calculating your retirement budget based on the return of your nest egg, so your plan is way better than your friend.

Now, come to the next question - how to use only the returns of a retiree's nest egg to retire ? We have many topics in this forum which touched on that thumbup.gif
Garysydney
post Aug 23 2018, 01:37 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 01:13 PM)
Personal opinion.....I think your friend made a mistake in his investment. He is using his nest egg A$2m to retire, instead of using "the returns from his nest egg" to retire.

As we don't know to what age we will live until, eating into the nest egg is not a good retirement plan

We should use the return instead for retirement, leaving the nest egg untouched.

I think you are calculating your retirement budget based on the return of your nest egg, so your plan is way better than your friend.

Now, come to the next question - how to use only the returns of a retiree's nest egg to retire ? We have many topics in this forum which touched on that  thumbup.gif
*
This doctor friend of mine runs his own superfund (self-managed superfund (SMSF)) and in those days, retirees in Aust would invest heavily in companies that gave high fully-franked dividends (with the 30% tax rebate, retirees were very happy) - most popular at that time were the 4 big banks and Telstra.

When the GFC hit in 2008/9, these retirees were very vulnerable as a lot of their portfolio were in shares and they were hit badly (never thinking something like this would ever happen!). I remembered he told me in late-2008 that his shares had dropped a lot during dinner one evening and that if he had not invested in shares, he could be eating lobster every day. I am only guessing that he must have panic and sold out since a person's wealth can be totally wiped out in shares (no matter how blue chip it is!). What he was investing in was his retirement savings and it would crazy not to cash-out. He probably only started buying back in after the market had recovered and confidence was back but by then he had also lost quite a fair bit of his capital. I am only guessing because A$2mil in 2006 was a lot of money!!

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Aug 23 2018, 01:39 PM
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 03:17 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Aug 23 2018, 01:37 PM)
This doctor friend of mine runs his own superfund (self-managed superfund (SMSF)) and in those days, retirees in Aust would invest heavily in companies that gave high fully-franked dividends (with the 30% tax rebate, retirees were very happy) - most popular at that time were the 4 big banks and Telstra.

When the GFC hit in 2008/9, these retirees were very vulnerable as a lot of their portfolio were in shares and they were hit badly (never thinking something like this would ever happen!). I remembered he told me in late-2008 that his shares had dropped a lot during dinner one evening and that if he had not invested in shares, he could be eating lobster every day. I am only guessing that he must have panic and sold out since a person's wealth can be totally wiped out in shares (no matter how blue chip it is!). What he was investing in was his retirement savings and it would crazy not to cash-out. He probably only started buying back in after the market had recovered and confidence was back but by then he had also lost quite a fair bit of his capital. I am only guessing because A$2mil in 2006 was a lot of money!!
*
His risk is too concentrated....

Nowadays with internet, we can invest way wider and further. Our portfolio should be very diversified and spread the risk, like :

1. Different industry and sector (financial, tech, food, infrastructure, property, etc)
2. Different instrument (shares, ETF, bonds, money market, precious metal, mutual funds, etc)
3. Different geography (countries, hence forex)
4. Different capitalization (small, medium and large companies)
5. Different aggressiveness (growth, income, low yield, value)

I always think that we should have a balanced portfolio. Even for retiree, it may not necessarily be a good thing to invest everything in low risk low return investment. Like 100% in FD. Because even FD has its risk. What if RM FD return becomes like USD interest rates (close to zero) ? We used to have FD rates close to 8% in late 1990s. But it has decreased so much since. Even now, RM FD is getting close to zero real returns (ie after inflation). Also, if we only have RM FD, what if one day malaysia becomes Greece or Venezuela ? So it is always good to spread the risk and have a balanced portfolio


flight
post Aug 23 2018, 03:23 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 03:17 PM)
His risk is too concentrated....

Nowadays with internet, we can invest way wider and further. Our portfolio should be very diversified and spread the risk, like :

1. Different industry and sector (financial, tech, food, infrastructure, property, etc)
2. Different instrument (shares, ETF, bonds, money market, precious metal, mutual funds, etc)
3. Different geography (countries, hence forex)
4. Different capitalization (small, medium and large companies)
5. Different aggressiveness (growth, income, low yield, value)

I always think that we should have a balanced portfolio. Even for retiree, it may not necessarily be a good thing to invest everything in low risk low return investment. Like 100% in FD. Because even FD has its risk. What if RM FD return becomes like USD interest rates (close to zero) ? We used to have FD rates close to 8% in late 1990s. But it has decreased so much since. Even now, RM FD is getting close to zero real returns (ie after inflation). Also, if we only have RM FD, what if one day malaysia becomes Greece or Venezuela ? So it is always good to spread the risk and have a balanced portfolio
*
The gfc brought down all sectors. Malaysia will nvr become greece or venezuela.

Despite all the negative press, many parts of the government have been protected agaisnt capital flight. While oil is still important. It doesnt play as ative a part as last time.

Oil is only about 20% of the economy. The country is diversified enough that it is not subject to fluctuations in oil. Unlike venezuela.

There r alot of parts of the economy protected, we r not exposed to foreign currency risk as we have large forex reserves. And say what u will about capital controls. The limited form of capital controls malaysia practices prevents these types of crisises like what turkey is facing.

I think the key is to get some knowledge on companies and investing. Also to have some cash so the crashes become opportunities.

This post has been edited by flight: Aug 23 2018, 03:31 PM
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 03:59 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 03:23 PM)
The gfc brought down all sectors. Malaysia will nvr become greece or venezuela.

Despite all the negative press, many parts of the government have been protected agaisnt capital flight. While oil is still important. It doesnt play as ative a part as last time.

Oil is only about 20% of the economy. The country is diversified enough that it is not subject to fluctuations in oil. Unlike venezuela.

There r alot of parts of the economy protected, we r not exposed to foreign currency risk as we have large forex reserves. And say what u will about capital controls. The limited form of capital controls malaysia practices prevents these types of crisises like what turkey is facing.

I think the key is to get some knowledge on companies and investing. Also to have some cash so the crashes become opportunities.
*
I have gone through a few rounds of crashes. 1987, 1994, 1998, 2008.

Since 2008, there is no serious crash. That is when most of the youngsters born in 80s and 90s started to invest. And they never been through the plight of a crash. Some talked very big like investment guru biggrin.gif So much confidence backed with numbers, charts and theories....

Until they experience their first crash, then I am sure they will learn what is risk and returns.

Same thing happened to Greece and Venezuela. Before the crisis, nobody would have thought the country would go bankrupt. There were 101 theories to back up stability of the economy. But you can see what happened to them now...

And look at Gary’s friend who only invest in Aussie banks. A big chunk of portfolio was gone

Diversification is the universally accepted practice to mitigate investment risk. Because there is no certainty in investment world. Anything could happen. And usually they catch you by surprise. By that time, it would be too late for you to do anything.
flight
post Aug 23 2018, 04:09 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 03:59 PM)
I have gone through a few rounds of crashes. 1987, 1994, 1998, 2008.

Since 2008, there is no serious crash. That is when most of the youngsters born in 80s and 90s started to invest. And they never been through the plight of a crash. Some talked very big like investment guru  biggrin.gif So much confidence backed with numbers, charts and theories....

Until they experience their first crash, then I am sure they will learn what is risk and returns.

Same thing happened to Greece and Venezuela. Before the crisis, nobody would have thought the country would go bankrupt. There were 101 theories to back up stability of the economy. But you can see what happened to them now...

And look at Gary’s friend who only invest in Aussie banks. A big chunk of portfolio was gone

Diversification is the universally accepted practice to mitigate investment risk. Because there is no certainty in investment world. Anything could happen. And usually they catch you by surprise. By that time, it would be too late for you to do anything.
*
U r the guy who got caught in the property downturn and have been arguing with icy for 3 years +. All the while property prices have come down. U lose a lot of credibility in my eyes.

Just so u know. Bank of australia at its peak in 2008 was trading at aud 61. Today it is at aud 72 and paying a 6% dividend. So nobody was wiped out unless they sold.

I started learning investment in 2007. Waiting for a crash that did happen and thinking how ridiculous it is that a company with net cash higher than their market cap. Trading at 5 times earnings paying a 4% dividend was trading so low.

The cos name is mfcb, and it was trading at 90 cents.

Edit: u have no idea how much better malaysia stands vis a vis some of the other countries. Now najib is out of the picture the skies are better.


Almost 100% of venezuelas economy is reliant on oil. It was a matter of time before they went bust. Greece almost went down because they were cooking their books.

Malaysia might have gone down the same path, but our Mahathir managed to bring down najib. 1mdb is thankfully. One of its only species of corruption introduced by our ex pm.

This post has been edited by flight: Aug 23 2018, 04:24 PM
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 04:41 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 04:09 PM)
U r the guy who got caught in the property downturn and have been arguing with icy for 3 years +. All the while property prices have come down. U lose a lot of credibility in my eyes.
I have invested in property since ~30 years ago. To the contrary, the property price has gone up tremendously. Maybe I have better luck ? biggrin.gif

May I ask what has my credibility got to do here ? In a forum, my point of view is more important than credibility. If it makes sense, that is the thing a reader can take away. If my point of view doesn’t make sense, even if I am the most credible person in the world, how would you benefit from it ?

Sorry I cannot remember, did I said something bad about you previously ? Just curious....

QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 04:09 PM)
Just so u know. Bank of australia at its peak in 2008 was trading at aud 61. Today it is at aud 72 and paying a 6% dividend. So nobody was wiped out unless they sold.
Bank of Australia ? Never heard of it

You must be talking about Commonwealth Bank of Australia biggrin.gif

Gary was telling you a real life story. His good friend loss million of dollar by holding substantial shareholdings in banking sector during the financial crisis.

I don’t understand what are you trying to get to....are you trying to prove his friend did the wrong thing by selling the shares ?


QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 04:09 PM)
I started learning investment in 2007. Waiting for a crash that did happen and thinking how ridiculous it is that a company with net cash higher than their market cap. Trading at 5 times earnings paying a 4% dividend was trading so low.

The cos name is mfcb, and it was trading at 90 cents.

Edit: u have no idea how much better malaysia stands vis a vis some of the other countries. Now najib is out of the picture the skies are better.
*
Diversification is trying to address the issue of “what if something goes wrong”

Even if a country’s economy is extremely sound, there are also benefits to diversify to other countries.

Just look at the thread in this forum. There are SGX, ASX, US stock, ETFs etc. Forummers here do diversify. They don’t put all their eggs in one basket.

However, if you feel that your investment objective is to invest in only Malaysia, that is entirely up to you. Nobody here can stop you. Everybody has his own choice and preference.
flight
post Aug 23 2018, 05:16 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 04:41 PM)
I have invested in property since ~30 years ago. To the contrary, the property price has gone up tremendously. Maybe I have better luck ?  biggrin.gif

May I ask what has my credibility got to do here ? In a forum, my point of view is more important than credibility. If it makes sense, that is the thing a reader can take away. If my point of view doesn’t make sense, even if I am the most credible person in the world, how would you benefit from it ?

Sorry I cannot remember, did I said something bad about you previously ? Just curious....
Bank of Australia ? Never heard of it

You must be talking about Commonwealth Bank of Australia  biggrin.gif

Gary was telling you a real life story. His good friend loss million of dollar by holding substantial shareholdings in banking sector during the financial crisis.

My main holdings are in asx and us. I have nothing in malaysia.

I don’t understand what are you trying to get to....are you trying to prove his friend did the wrong thing by selling the shares ?
Diversification is trying to address the issue of “what if something goes wrong”

Even if a country’s economy is extremely sound, there are also benefits to diversify to other countries.

Just look at the thread in this forum. There are SGX, ASX, US stock, ETFs etc. Forummers here do diversify. They don’t put all their eggs in one basket.

However, if you feel that your investment objective is to invest in only Malaysia, that is entirely up to you. Nobody here can stop you. Everybody has his own choice and preference.
*
Ur obviously someone with too much time. Unlike some of the other forumers, i wont engage with u. My point being that based on ur past comments u seem to have taken quite a hit. Investment wise.

But instead of being humble about it ur trying push this holier than thou attitude agaisnt ppl with an opposing view.

Anyway, are u FIRE? If not... at ur age, i wish u the very best.

This post has been edited by flight: Aug 23 2018, 05:16 PM
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 05:49 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 05:16 PM)
Ur obviously someone with too much time. Unlike some of the other forumers, i wont engage with u. My point being that based on ur past comments u seem to have taken quite a hit. Investment wise.
Yes, I have a lot of free time. I am an unker close to 60 years old....

I thought you know me well enough if you have followed closely those BBB DDD thread in Kopitiam ? BTW you know the rules here is not like in kopitiam forum right ?

Oh...appreciate it if you won’t engage with me. Seems that you forgot that just a few hours ago, you are the one who initiate it. I did nothing and suddenly out of nowhere, I got some weird opinion on my personality biggrin.gif

QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 05:16 PM)
But instead of being humble about it ur trying push this holier than thou attitude agaisnt ppl with an opposing view.

Anyway, are u FIRE? If not... at ur age, i wish u the very best.
*
“Humble” ? “ur trying push this holier than thou attitude...” ?

Bro, since when is my post so imposing ? I did not point a gun at your head to accept my view. I am just sharing my view and experience. I never claim my view is gospel. If you feel my writing is not humble until it is offending you, you can always choose not to read biggrin.gif

There is an ignore button down there if you press my username FYI. If you really hate what I said, feel free to press the button. I also don’t want you in the future suddenly appear in a thread to accuse me I have “no credibility”, “not humble” etc

Make sure you press the button.....Goodbye !

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Aug 23 2018, 05:53 PM
flight
post Aug 23 2018, 06:00 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 05:49 PM)
Yes, I have a lot of free time. I am an unker close to 60 years old....

I thought you know me well enough if you have followed closely those BBB DDD thread in Kopitiam ? BTW you know the rules here is not like in kopitiam forum right ?

Oh...appreciate it if you won’t engage with me. Seems that you forgot that just a few hours ago, you are the one who initiate it. I did nothing and suddenly out of nowhere, I got some weird opinion on my personality  biggrin.gif
“Humble” ? “ur trying push this holier than thou attitude...” ?

Bro, since when is my post so imposing ? I did not point a gun at your head to accept my view. I am just sharing my view and experience. I never claim my view is gospel. If you feel my writing is not humble until it is offending you, you can always choose not to read  biggrin.gif

There is an ignore button down there if you press my username FYI. If you really hate what I said, feel free to press the button. I also don’t want you in the future suddenly appear in a thread to accuse me I have “no credibility”, “not humble” etc

Make sure you press the button.....Goodbye !
*
Anyway, i rest my case. Unlike some other forumers, im not biting. Best of luck to u.
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 06:28 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 06:00 PM)
Anyway, i rest my case. Unlike some other forumers, im not biting. Best of luck to u.
*
Thanks bro for the wishing....appreciate it...

I can’t help but to do a search on your posting....hope you don’t mind me asking here....

Do you still feel when reading forummers’ post here, inadvertently you relate the post is directing to you in a negative manner ? It seems that you said so in this thread

QUOTE(flight @ Jun 20 2018, 03:38 PM)
Why these story all sound like poking fun at my personal life. . .

Just for the record. I have a pretty high networth, but money is made from investments. Not from working.
*
https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4600862/+300 Starting from post #308

You may be too sensitive, bro....
flight
post Aug 23 2018, 06:59 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 06:28 PM)
Thanks bro for the wishing....appreciate it...

I can’t help but to do a search on your posting....hope you don’t mind me asking here....

Do you still feel when reading forummers’ post here, inadvertently you relate the post is directing to you in a negative manner ? It seems that you said so in this thread
https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4600862/+300 Starting from post #308

You may be too sensitive, bro....
*
My networth is about rm1.5mil. Im turning 31 this september.
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 07:18 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 06:59 PM)
My networth is about rm1.5mil. Im turning 31 this september.
*
Bro, not asking about the second sentence. But your first sentence....

Forgive me because I am more kuailow style very direct one....can I ask you a few question ? if you don’t want to answer, it’s ok.....

1. You think that others are trying to insult you ? You may hear a person say one thing, but you think that they mean something else ?

2. You think that certain people are trying to make you look bad to others ? You may react by getting angry or attacking them back ? You may also believe that your reputation is being threatened ?

3. You think other people will harm, trick, or take advantage of you ?

4. You often hold grudges against people who you believe have done something bad to you. You believe that the actions were done to hurt you, and you cannot forgive the people who did them. You may see people as your enemies, and want to get back at them.

As said, just ignore me if you don’t feel like answering. No offense ya....

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Aug 23 2018, 08:57 PM
flight
post Aug 23 2018, 07:29 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 07:18 PM)
Bro, not asking about the second sentence. But your first sentence....

Forgive me because I am more kuailow style very direct one....can I ask you a few question ? if you don’t want to answer, it’s ok.....

1. Do you sometimes think that others are trying to insult you ? You may hear a person say one thing, but you think that they mean something else ?

2. Do you sometimes think that certain people are trying to make you look bad to others ? You may react by getting angry or attacking them back ? You may also believe that your reputation is being threatened ?

3. You sometimes think other people will harm, trick, or take advantage of you ?

4. You often hold grudges against people who you believe have done something bad to you. You believe that the actions were done to hurt you, and you cannot forgive the people who did them. You may see people as your enemies, and want to get back at them.

As said, just ignore me if you don’t feel like answering. No offense ya....
*
U r very clearly, trying to get a rise out of me. I think this is not ur first time arguing with ppl online. I used to like arguing. If u r so particular that u look at my past posts im sure u can see this.

I dont know ur financial situation, but maybe u should work on ur retirement.... rather than trolling someone 30 years younger than u.
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 07:41 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(flight @ Aug 23 2018, 07:29 PM)
U r very clearly, trying to get a rise out of me.
*
Ok bro....I got all your answer for Q1, 2, 3 and 4

If you want to know more, shoot me a pm.....I may able able to help...this is a sincere offer, not trolling...

Good luck, bro !

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Aug 23 2018, 07:42 PM
flight
post Aug 23 2018, 07:48 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 07:41 PM)
Ok bro....I got all your answer for Q1, 2, 3 and 4

If you want to know more, shoot me a pm.....I may able able to help...this is a sincere offer, not trolling...

Good luck, bro !
*
Good job derailing the thread. All those episodes arguing about god knows what must have given u an appetite for this type of nonsense.

How old r u btw? 65?

Some ppl only grow old.
perplexedstill
post Aug 23 2018, 07:59 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
143 posts

Joined: Oct 2017
????????
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 08:02 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(perplexedstill @ Aug 23 2018, 07:59 PM)
????????
*
All I can say is google is your best friend
flight
post Aug 23 2018, 08:04 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,567 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
Im not sure retiring is all what its cut out to be. I think it would get boring even if u r financially free.
perplexedstill
post Aug 23 2018, 08:26 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
143 posts

Joined: Oct 2017
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 08:02 PM)
All I can say is google is your best friend
*
I was refer to flight who suddenly mad. Google really can help me?
Showtime747
post Aug 23 2018, 08:52 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(perplexedstill @ Aug 23 2018, 08:26 PM)
I was refer to flight who suddenly mad. Google really can help me?
*
Most probably. But only after you read the link I provided to the thread in Property section
perplexedstill
post Aug 23 2018, 11:27 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
143 posts

Joined: Oct 2017
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 08:52 PM)
Most probably. But only after you read the link I provided to the thread in Property section
*
Sorry? Do you mind link me to the thread?
Showtime747
post Aug 24 2018, 07:21 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(perplexedstill @ Aug 23 2018, 11:27 PM)
Sorry? Do you mind link me to the thread?
*
https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4600862/+300

Starting from post #308 page 16 to page 18
sky18
post Aug 24 2018, 08:10 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(firedfire2018 @ Aug 20 2018, 10:30 AM)
FI RE D - Financial Independence Retire Early Done

so i have decided to be fired and need advise from all here. Please only valuable advise.

1. Quit job 17 August 2018 (one of the most stressful workplace)
2. Managed to pay of car and house
3. 1 Kid
4. 1 wife
5. Passive income from interest rm3500
6. No bad habits
7. KWSP 800K (cannot touch for 15 years)
8. Other savings rm600k (including benefits & insurance termination from company) -- in process
8. Other income 7k pm
9. Healthy
10. Family expenses pm rm3k-4k
why quit? too much stress and empty promises.

what am i considered now? jobless? or retired?

plan to just reinvest the cash and generated interest. Waiting for the payout which plan to just put in FD or ASNB ( 4-6% interest ) 2-3k pm

Consider generation of monthly income rm3500 + 7000 + 2500 = 13000

with my current expenses only 3-4k pm, can save up another rm10k pm but some months indeed have other expenses like insurance or etc which i say maybe rm10k per annum. so saving per year approx (rm13k-4k) x 12 - 10k = rm98000 and again to be invested in safe deposits to generate interest.
did i make a wise decision?
*
Instead of derail, must well throws some words on above.

I guess you probably around 40 (15 years to go on epf) but not sure how old is ur kids?thus,is edu fund ready? Ur 7K income probably from ur wife, is she plan continuing to work and until when; can u sustain once she stop working? What u plan to do after u after FIRE?

Perhaps u can take ur career break and decide later once u had clearer pictures.

Actually nobody can judge how wise ur decision is except your own self.


icemanfx
post Aug 24 2018, 11:25 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 03:59 PM)
I have gone through a few rounds of crashes. 1987, 1994, 1998, 2008.

Since 2008, there is no serious crash. That is when most of the youngsters born in 80s and 90s started to invest. And they never been through the plight of a crash. Some talked very big like investment guru  biggrin.gif So much confidence backed with numbers, charts and theories....

Until they experience their first crash, then I am sure they will learn what is risk and returns.

Same thing happened to Greece and Venezuela. Before the crisis, nobody would have thought the country would go bankrupt. There were 101 theories to back up stability of the economy. But you can see what happened to them now...

And look at Gary’s friend who only invest in Aussie banks. A big chunk of portfolio was gone

Diversification is the universally accepted practice to mitigate investment risk. Because there is no certainty in investment world. Anything could happen. And usually they catch you by surprise. By that time, it would be too late for you to do anything.
*
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 23 2018, 04:41 PM)
I have invested in property since ~30 years ago. To the contrary, the property price has gone up tremendously. Maybe I have better luck ?  biggrin.gif

May I ask what has my credibility got to do here ? In a forum, my point of view is more important than credibility. If it makes sense, that is the thing a reader can take away. If my point of view doesn’t make sense, even if I am the most credible person in the world, how would you benefit from it ?

Sorry I cannot remember, did I said something bad about you previously ? Just curious....
Bank of Australia ? Never heard of it

You must be talking about Commonwealth Bank of Australia  biggrin.gif

Gary was telling you a real life story. His good friend loss million of dollar by holding substantial shareholdings in banking sector during the financial crisis.

I don’t understand what are you trying to get to....are you trying to prove his friend did the wrong thing by selling the shares ?
Diversification is trying to address the issue of “what if something goes wrong”

Even if a country’s economy is extremely sound, there are also benefits to diversify to other countries.

Just look at the thread in this forum. There are SGX, ASX, US stock, ETFs etc. Forummers here do diversify. They don’t put all their eggs in one basket.

However, if you feel that your investment objective is to invest in only Malaysia, that is entirely up to you. Nobody here can stop you. Everybody has his own choice and preference.
*
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Aug 24 2018, 07:21 AM)
https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4600862/+300

Starting from post #308 page 16 to page 18
*
For a 50/60 y.o unker to buy property 30 years ago is consistent with people to buy their first home at that period, is nothing to shout about. property price appreciate at about inflation rate in the long term, any property bought many years ago would have appreciated. whether is a worthwhile investment is another matter. those experienced a few economic recession know it is debt that brought people and business down and every bull run will come to an end. when bullrun end, those over leveraged are often the first batch of casualty. property investment is illiquid and highly leveraged.

only those suffer inferiority complex and reject from regular fraternity would dig out people previous post for personal attack and names calling.

This post has been edited by icemanfx: Aug 24 2018, 04:10 PM
sky18
post Sep 8 2018, 03:35 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Ramjade

since you were an extreme frugal, read this and perhaps it sparks you an new perspective.

https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindepende...i_have_learned/
Ramjade
post Sep 8 2018, 05:41 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 8 2018, 03:35 PM)
Ramjade

since you were an extreme frugal, read this and perhaps it sparks you an new perspective.

https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindepende...i_have_learned/
*
Well for me, very simple. Seeing my account grows and money coming in without working is extremely satisfying.

People look forward to paycheck every month as they are living paycheck to pay check. I look forward to it so that you chest is refilled and I have more money to invest

Know what you want and work on it and be happy with it as you are responsible for your own action.
Showtime747
post Sep 8 2018, 07:00 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 8 2018, 03:35 PM)
Ramjade

since you were an extreme frugal, read this and perhaps it sparks you an new perspective.

https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindepende...i_have_learned/
*
That is really an impactful piece of writing ! Thanks for the link thumbup.gif

Especially point #4 and 5

For everybody's ease of reading :

QUOTE
What I Have Learned

So having participated in many threads here in recent months, as well as other financial forums going back to before the 2008 crash, and having been at various points in my life a broke college student/graduate student, having net worth at my absolute lowest point somewhere in the neighborhood of -$155,000 (negative number), quickly digging myself out of debt, marrying into more debt and helping my wife pay her debt off, putting my wife through school and teaching her about investing even when she wasn't entirely on board but agreed to get started (and now is saving aggressively), these are some of the general principles I have learned:

1. No matter how much of your income you save every month, there is always someone on some message board who will claim to save more and say you aren't doing enough. You save 70%? Well someone else saves 80% and plans to save even more moving forward. It doesn't matter. Comparing yourself to people on this forum in this regard is just as futile as comparing your vehicle to people on the opposite end of the spectrum and wondering why they have a nicer car than you do. They might have more income, more debt, more help from family, an inheritance, a wealthy SO. So don't come here and ask "is saving 20% enough?" any more than you would ask the guy in the BMW 5 series, "is driving a 10 year old toyota enough?"

2. There is no shame in enjoying "things" on occasion, even if those "things" cost money.

3. Given #1 and #2, it is a worthwhile exercise to sit down and look at exactly how many hours you have to work to pay your fixed monthly expenses. Want a new car? Calculate exactly how many hours you have to work every month to pay for it. Ask yourself if the tradeoff is worth it. If the answer is "yes, it is worth it" don't fret about the fact that some person on a forum tells you it is an expense you should avoid, or how it might delay your retirement in 1-2 decades, or how you could buy a car for $5K and that would be plenty adequate and you should be happy because you have more than people do in third world countries.

4. When your entire goal is to stop working as soon as feasible, a negativity creeps in about the value of your work, and what it means to be employed and contribute in some way. I am not in any way rationalizing being in a terrible work environment. I fully recognize the work place can be malignant and unpleasant, depending on your supervisors and the culture of your job. I am just pointing out there is a certain value in doing something to feel like you are contributing to the world and helping others and trying to approach your job with a positive frame of mind. If you are a young person who is a decade or more away from retirement, and you are already approaching work with an attitude of, "I don't want to do this a day more than I have to", you would serve yourself well to find a new line of work or change your attitude/perspective just as much as you would by saving every penny available to get out as soon as possible. And sometimes treating yourself a little bit will make you feel better about your work, more so than watching your account balances go up with the goal being to "get out as soon as possible". If you are too extreme with saving a substantial portion of your earnings, your work immediately feels less rewarding because you are not seeing the fruits of your labor other than on paper, which leads me to #5....

5. Reaching financial milestones is not as gratifying as you may imagine. I have met many of them, including paying off significant CC debt and student loans, building up retirement accounts, etc. I have yet to join the "two comma" net worth club but I am not far away. None of the financial milestones have been nearly as meaningful as I imagined they would be when I was younger and my net worth was a large negative number. The reason for this is I know how much I have sacrificed for each of them. When I reach the "two comma" net worth I suspect that day will be no different than any other day of my life thus far or any other milestone I have met. I thought the six figure net worth would be a big milestone for me. I felt no different than the day before. Same with 250K and 500K. You get there and there is no celebratory moment or major life change other than realizing you put a lot of things on hold to get there. It ain't all bad but it certainly isn't the way I imagined it when I was younger.

6. There is a wisdom in pursuing hobbies/outside interests that are inexpensive, but if there is something you feel you need or want to do it might be worth shelling out the money. I have never owned a boat but I would love to and could afford it, could have years ago. I sometimes wonder if I am putting off things that I won't enjoy as much when I am older, whenever I choose it is finally "the right time". You might even find yourself more motivated to work more to support a hobby that makes you happy, if the cheap or free ones don't quite do it for you.

What is my point? I am not sure I have one. I still to this day spend a lot of time on financial forums, here and elsewhere. I still spend a lot less than I earn, although I have loosened up a little recently. But I have noticed in forums such as these there is such an extreme point of view in some cases that doesn't sit well with me. It seems as if many are recommending what I would consider extreme measures which in some cases make people less happy.

There are people who go through life spending way too much money, more than they have, and they are miserable. There are also people who save every last penny and they are miserable too. Each may have their own regrets later in life. The best balance is somewhere in between and there are some extreme points of view in this forum, which may not always be the best way to proceed.

j.passing.by
post Sep 8 2018, 08:41 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,639 posts

Joined: Nov 2010
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 8 2018, 07:00 PM)
That is really an impactful piece of writing ! Thanks for the link  thumbup.gif

Especially point #4 and 5

For everybody's ease of reading :
*
My #4 is splurging on a car that I don't mind driving and yet within my affordability - something that makes me want to drive to work every morning.

#5, one of my first milestones when I was younger was more materialistic, a watch costing me one whole month wage. Years later, upgraded to a 2 months salary piece... another milestone achieved.


This post has been edited by j.passing.by: Sep 8 2018, 09:03 PM
Showtime747
post Sep 8 2018, 09:19 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(j.passing.by @ Sep 8 2018, 08:41 PM)
My #4 is splurging on a car that I don't mind driving and yet within my affordability - something that makes me want to drive to work every morning.

#5, one of my first milestones when I was younger was more materialistic, a watch costing me one whole month wage. Years later, upgraded to a 2 months salary piece... another milestone achieved.
*
Yea....having lots of money is not always the only goal in life.

Job satisfaction will bring joy money can't buy. Like a doctor saving lives, an engineer building a tall building, an artist drawing a masterpiece, a teacher's students score straight As, bosses who created jobs and indirectly support many families etc etc. If a person's only goal is to make money so that he does not have to work again, I doubt he will enjoy his job. He would drag himself to work everyday, and life is like hell to him

Instead, if everyday a person achieves something, reaches a milestone, people thank him for his work (like saving a person's life).... he won't rank money highly. Volunteers social workers are this category of people. They are not after money, but they are happy contributing back to the society. They are selfless people, compared to people who only want FIRE.


AvenueX
post Sep 8 2018, 11:05 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
241 posts

Joined: Sep 2011
Hi guys, thought I would join the discussion how much do you think is enough to FIRE on per month in KL with a fully paid off home?
j.passing.by
post Sep 9 2018, 01:26 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,639 posts

Joined: Nov 2010
Jack Ma, age 54, just announced his retirement.

j.passing.by
post Sep 9 2018, 01:52 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,639 posts

Joined: Nov 2010
QUOTE(AvenueX @ Sep 8 2018, 11:05 PM)
Hi guys, thought I would join the discussion how much do you think is enough to FIRE on per month in KL with a fully paid off home?
*
Do read the long post above on making comparison between yourself and others... it can be meaningless.

Just like comparing how much one should save, it all depends on one's individuality and lifestyle.

Years ago when James Clavell wrote Noble House, the drop dead money was 2 million. I guess it should be 5 million now. But of course it could be less and enough for anyone to retire.

With house, car and other assets fully paid, the minimal can be as low as 2k. Or 24k per year.

At 4% interest from a fixed deposit, the untouched nest egg to generate this 24k is 600k.

This post has been edited by j.passing.by: Sep 9 2018, 01:55 AM
Garysydney
post Sep 9 2018, 06:11 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 8 2018, 09:19 PM)
Yea....having lots of money is not always the only goal in life.

Job satisfaction will bring joy money can't buy. Like a doctor saving lives, an engineer building a tall building, an artist drawing a masterpiece, a teacher's students score straight As, bosses who created jobs and indirectly support many families etc etc. If a person's only goal is to make money so that he does not have to work again, I doubt he will enjoy his job. He would drag himself to work everyday, and life is like hell to him

Instead, if everyday a person achieves something, reaches a milestone, people thank him for his work (like saving a person's life).... he won't rank money highly. Volunteers social workers are this category of people. They are not after money, but they are happy contributing back to the society. They are selfless people, compared to people who only want FIRE.
*
I think a person's attitude to life is very important (to be happy) whether in retirement or working. Now if we are able to appreciate/value our hard-earned assets/possessions more easily than others, we generally tend to be happier than others. I think the secret is being able to feel gratitude (感恩) for the things we have. If we are able to do this, we will feel that a lot of times, we really don't need more (money) in life.

Like in my case, compared to my group of Msians friends (all migrated to Sydney in 70s/80s), i am probably one of the poorest in the group but i am one of the happiest. Most of them have built up retirement/income-producing assets of more A$4-5mil (doesn't include their house) but yet they feel poor. They are all in their 60s/70s and they keep telling me to working to generate more assets/retirement funds. I ask them how much they need in retirement and they don't really know because they don't really calculate/plan. I don't really compare myself with these friends (they all have a few kids so may need a bit more to help the kids out devil.gif ) because when you start to compare then you will feel miserable.

A very good link by sky18 - must say i learnt a few things from it.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Sep 9 2018, 06:15 AM
Showtime747
post Sep 9 2018, 08:52 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 06:11 AM)
I think a person's attitude to life is very important (to be happy) whether in retirement or working. Now if we are able to appreciate/value our hard-earned assets/possessions more easily than others, we generally tend to be happier than others. I think the secret is being able to feel gratitude (感恩) for the things we have. If we are able to do this, we will feel that a lot of times, we really don't need more (money) in life.

Like in my case, compared to my group of Msians friends (all migrated to Sydney in 70s/80s), i am probably one of the poorest in the group but i am one of the happiest. Most of them have built up retirement/income-producing assets of more A$4-5mil (doesn't include their house) but yet they feel poor. They are all in their 60s/70s and they keep telling me to working to generate more assets/retirement funds. I ask them how much they need in retirement and they don't really know because they don't really calculate/plan. I don't really compare myself with these friends (they all have a few kids so may need a bit more to help the kids out devil.gif ) because when you start to compare then you will feel miserable.

A very good link by sky18 - must say i learnt a few things from it.
*
I personally think right attitude comes with life experience. When a person gets older, the attitude will change and align to a person’s goal. Cannot be taught, but have to learn and realise it himself at some stage.

It takes a lot of wisdom to understand that our life is not only about making a lot of money. I totally agree with you as I have also many business associates whom is filthy rich but not necessarily happier

I think only old chaps like us can truly understand what we are talking about biggrin.gif
sky18
post Sep 9 2018, 09:20 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Sep 8 2018, 05:41 PM)
Well for me,  very simple. Seeing my account grows and money coming in without working is extremely satisfying.

People look forward to paycheck every month as they are living paycheck to pay check. I look forward to it so that  you chest is refilled and I have more money to invest

Know what you want and work on it and be happy with it as you are responsible for your own action.
*
Find your balance point, else, your burn out is much higher, dont let yourself "hate" your jobs especially there're more years away from FI.
One of my key believe is there is no absolute black or white, almost most of them fall in between.

Go checkout the millionaires interviews. (https://esimoney.com/category/millionaires/), you'll noticed there're many way to reach the goal and common trait among them too.

I wish read all these sharing a decade+ ago prior my journey is started. And trust me, there is no different than the day before when you hit a million or multi-million.













Garysydney
post Sep 9 2018, 09:53 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 9 2018, 09:20 AM)
Find your balance point, else, your burn out is much higher, dont let yourself "hate" your jobs especially there're more years away from FI.
One of my key believe is there is no absolute black or white, almost most of them fall in between.

Go checkout the millionaires interviews. (https://esimoney.com/category/millionaires/), you'll noticed there're many way to reach the goal and common trait among them too.

I wish read all these sharing a decade+ ago prior my journey is started. And trust me, there is no different than the day before when you hit a million or multi-million.
*
Yes - i agree with you. My group of friends still worry when DJIA drops 500 pts!! They don't sleep till around 2am because they want to see what happens when the US market opens! I think the more money one has the more worried (something will happen) they become. They keep telling me to work another 10 years and i will be able to hit the A$3mil mark (combined with my wife) in income-earning assets. I keep telling them that i don't need that much partially because i don't have kids. I now don't even bother checking my super balance (updated every 2 days online). I used to always check it regularly as i feel that i don't have enough!! Sometimes it drops more than A$10k in 2 days and i will start worrying but now i feel that there is no use to worry because even if there is another GFC, i should be able to weather the storm. My colleague told me that my International Shares portfolio is very risky as they are partially geared so they move up and down very quickly (dropped about 52% in 2 years during the GFC) but i told him in the last 5 years it went up 100%!! I guess i will have to lower my risk appetite after i retire as i won't have guaranteed income like i do now. My balance in 2008 is much lower than what i have now - in fact my retirement balance has doubled in the last 5 years because i have all my entire balance in International Shares (all quoted in US dollars which is good as the A$ has been dropping). I am not the type to brag notworthy.gif because when you are my age, you don't really care what other people think of ourselves as long as we know what we are doing ourselves.
chonghe
post Sep 9 2018, 10:06 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 8 2018, 07:00 PM)
That is really an impactful piece of writing ! Thanks for the link  thumbup.gif

Especially point #4 and 5

For everybody's ease of reading :
*
Totally agree and point 4 & 5 really resonances me

With FI in mind one can really tend to think "I don't want to do this a day more than I have to" or the like
Sure, we want FI but one have to at least be serious with our work and do the necessary. One shouldn't let the negativity creeps in and affects one's life, this is not the right way
If possible, love what we do in our job while having the clear goal of FI is probably the best possible scenario - enjoy working at the same time of seeing the capital growing

And yes, as the author says, when the capital gets big could make no difference in feelings when you finally make it, which is in big contrast to the previous day that one imagine "once I have this amount that amount I can..."
Therefore I realise the mportance of spending the money and rewarding ourselves at times e.g., travelling and buy some stuff that we want
I know it is hard to see the capital goes down but appropriately withdrawing the capital can make us feel very good and the sense of rewarding is priceless

After all, balance & moderation, I would say, is the way in FI, and in many other things in life


Garysydney
post Sep 9 2018, 10:16 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


Actually i must thank Showtime because he took a lot of time/effort to convince me about having sufficient funds to retire.

I have lived/worked in Sydney for close to 40 years too and the longest holiday i have had in KL was 6 weeks so i wasn't very sure about cost of living in KL - people tell me it is cheaper than Sydney but i wasn't still too sure. If i had planned to retire in Sydney, i will probably continue to work because life can pretty boring in Sydney and most people don't retire unless they get retrenched here. Voluntary retirement before 60 is a luxury in Sydney because of the high cost of living here. This is the reason why all my friends tell me to continue working.

I take great assurance from one of Showtime's comments recently that i have sufficient to retire because i used to get nightmares waking up in the middle of the night dreaming that i have run of funds after retirement in KL and there is no chance of ever deriving an income anymore.
icemanfx
post Sep 9 2018, 10:30 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 06:11 AM)
I think a person's attitude to life is very important (to be happy) whether in retirement or working. Now if we are able to appreciate/value our hard-earned assets/possessions more easily than others, we generally tend to be happier than others. I think the secret is being able to feel gratitude (感恩) for the things we have. If we are able to do this, we will feel that a lot of times, we really don't need more (money) in life.

Like in my case, compared to my group of Msians friends (all migrated to Sydney in 70s/80s), i am probably one of the poorest in the group but i am one of the happiest. Most of them have built up retirement/income-producing assets of more A$4-5mil (doesn't include their house) but yet they feel poor. They are all in their 60s/70s and they keep telling me to working to generate more assets/retirement funds. I ask them how much they need in retirement and they don't really know because they don't really calculate/plan. I don't really compare myself with these friends (they all have a few kids so may need a bit more to help the kids out devil.gif ) because when you start to compare then you will feel miserable.

A very good link by sky18 - must say i learnt a few things from it.
*
Contented is happiness. If one used to travel by biz class, stay in suite and wish to continue similar lifestyle in retirement, will need over a$5m to sustain. If one has the capability to earn, there is nothing wrong to it. One may rant about need to make $ but satisfaction from e.g biz class, suite stay make it worthwhile.

If one couldn't bare daily fluctuations of stock price, should reduce or exit.

Garysydney
post Sep 9 2018, 10:57 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(icemanfx @ Sep 9 2018, 10:30 AM)
Contented is happiness. If one used to travel by biz class, stay in suite and wish to continue similar lifestyle in retirement, will need over a$5m to sustain. If one has the capability to earn, there is nothing wrong to it. One may rant about need to make $ but satisfaction from e.g biz class, suite stay make it worthwhile.

*
Actually it is very true about our lifestyle getting more expensive as we have more money - i find that as i grow older, i am spoiling myself with more comforts compared to before. When i go to HK nowadays, i would stay at 4-star hotels (HK hotel prices are quite similar to Sydney hotel prices) rather than a 3-star hotel (which i used to 10-15 years ago when i was not so financially well off as now). I love HK because i like to eat and the food is good there!! When we get older, we change but there are may be some areas where we will not.

Like nowadays, i prefer to drive a small-mid Japanese car while in my younger days, i would have liked a BMW or Merc. Overall, i think my lifestyle costs (in holidays and food) definitely is higher nowadays compared to 10-15 years ago while my preference for 'luxury goods' has dropped significantly. I no longer indulge in Rolex watches or Dunhill wallets/clothes which i was crazy for when younger. I guess all of us are different so it is probably different for every individual.
chonghe
post Sep 9 2018, 10:59 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 10:16 AM)
Actually i must thank Showtime because he took a lot of time/effort to convince me about having sufficient funds to retire.

I have lived/worked in Sydney for close to 40 years too and the longest holiday i have had in KL was 6 weeks so i wasn't very sure about cost of living in KL - people tell me it is cheaper than Sydney but i wasn't still too sure. If i had planned to retire in Sydney, i will probably continue to work because life can pretty boring in Sydney and most people don't retire unless they get retrenched here. Voluntary retirement before 60 is a luxury in Sydney because of the high cost of living here. This is the reason why all my friends tell me to continue working.

I take great assurance from one of Showtime's comments recently that i have sufficient to retire because i used to get nightmares waking up in the middle of the night dreaming that i have run of funds after retirement in KL and there is no chance of ever deriving an income anymore.
*
Hi Gary it is good to know that you are staying in AU but choose to retire in KL, at least MY isn't that bad right rclxm9.gif

From my observation people in AU work until very old because the welfare there is too good and people thought they can always depend on the government, which I think is a really bad idea
It is better to depend on ourselves rather than on government. This is especially the case in MY because we don't have good welfare system but is not too far off with western countries like AU even though the welfare is so good. This is because (i) with inflation the money we get from the welfare is smaller in value in years to come so never depend on that (ii) as you said the welfare system is not sustainable and the increase in retirement age proposal meaning people have to work even longer and (ii) let's be frank, those in power will only think for themselves and not the people (as in the dramatic frequent-change of PM in AU and just 2 weeks ago AU has a new PM, again. I already lost count of how many PM change in AU for the last few years)

P/S: I saw your signature that you stay in Randwick. I stayed there for some time and really love Randwick. It is nostalgic thinking back

icemanfx
post Sep 9 2018, 11:22 AM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(chonghe @ Sep 9 2018, 10:59 AM)
Hi Gary it is good to know that you are staying in AU but choose to retire in KL, at least MY isn't that bad right rclxm9.gif

From my observation people in AU work until very old because the welfare there is too good and people thought they can always depend on the government, which I think is a really bad idea
It is better to depend on ourselves rather than on government. This is especially the case in MY because we don't have good welfare system but is not too far off with western countries like AU even though the welfare is so good. This is because (i) with inflation the money we get from the welfare is smaller in value in years to come so never depend on that (ii) as you said the welfare system is not sustainable and the increase in retirement age proposal meaning people have to work even longer and (ii) let's be frank, those in power will only think for themselves and not the people (as in the dramatic frequent-change of PM in AU and just 2 weeks ago AU has a new PM, again. I already lost count of how many PM change in AU for the last few years)

P/S: I saw your signature that you stay in Randwick. I stayed there for some time and really love Randwick. It is nostalgic thinking back
*
People live longer and gomen need tax to sustain, retirement age is getting older. Without state pension, many of those retired early ended up living below poverty level or dependence on financial assistance from other family members.

Garysydney
post Sep 9 2018, 11:57 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(chonghe @ Sep 9 2018, 10:59 AM)
Hi Gary it is good to know that you are staying in AU but choose to retire in KL, at least MY isn't that bad right rclxm9.gif

From my observation people in AU work until very old because the welfare there is too good and people thought they can always depend on the government, which I think is a really bad idea
It is better to depend on ourselves rather than on government. This is especially the case in MY because we don't have good welfare system but is not too far off with western countries like AU even though the welfare is so good. This is because (i) with inflation the money we get from the welfare is smaller in value in years to come so never depend on that (ii) as you said the welfare system is not sustainable and the increase in retirement age proposal meaning people have to work even longer and (ii) let's be frank, those in power will only think for themselves and not the people (as in the dramatic frequent-change of PM in AU and just 2 weeks ago AU has a new PM, again. I already lost count of how many PM change in AU for the last few years)

P/S: I saw your signature that you stay in Randwick. I stayed there for some time and really love Randwick. It is nostalgic thinking back
*
The old-age pension cost the govt A$44bil/yr. This is the biggest area of welfare spending for the govt. It is clearly unsustainable but no govt dares to increase the age (currently 65-67 depending on your age). There were plans to increase it to 70 but Morrison has killed it altogether. The reason why the Aussie dollar is plunging is because we are known as the 'welfare country'. For people like me, we will not be able to get the age-pension because both of us way exceed the A$800k cut-off point.

I have lived in Randwick ever since 1981. I live quite near Centennial Park which is quite a leafy area. Today is a beautiful spring day and i am going out now. I am very free these 4 mths because my wife is in Kl looking after her old-aged father and she is due back in Sydney tonight. She normally doesn't like me to go on LYN because she says i shouldn't be talking to young kids that i don't know on the net. doh.gif

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Sep 9 2018, 11:59 AM
Ramjade
post Sep 9 2018, 12:10 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 11:57 AM)
The old-age pension cost the govt A$44bil/yr. This is the biggest area of welfare spending for the govt. It is clearly unsustainable but no govt dares to increase the age (currently 65-67 depending on your age). There were plans to increase it to 70 but Morrison has killed it altogether. The reason why the Aussie dollar is plunging is because we are known as the 'welfare country'. For people like me, we will not be able to get the age-pension because both of us way exceed the A$800k cut-off point.

I have lived in Randwick ever since 1981. I live quite near Centennial Park which is quite a leafy area. Today is a beautiful spring day and i am going out now. I am very free these 4 mths because my wife is in Kl looking after her old-aged father and she is due back in Sydney tonight. She normally doesn't like me to go on LYN because she says i shouldn't be talking to young kids that i don't know on the net. doh.gif
*
Er how about moving money out of AU. That way you get both pension and enjoy your earnings.
tippman
post Sep 9 2018, 01:38 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Sep 9 2018, 12:10 PM)
Er how about moving money out of AU. That way you get both pension and enjoy your earnings.
*
so now advising how to skim the government for pension?
Ramjade
post Sep 9 2018, 01:44 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 9 2018, 01:38 PM)
so now advising how to skim the government for pension?
*
If is legal, do it. You already pay lots of money in form of income tax, time for govt yo pay you back the money.

Like banks. Banks are sucker/leech. Learn to suck from banks where possible.

If you feel like donating money to govt, be my guest. I don't donate money to govt and banks if I can help it. The only thing worth donating to is charity bodies or for global warming causes.
tippman
post Sep 9 2018, 01:55 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Sep 9 2018, 01:44 PM)
If is legal, do it. You already pay lots of money in form of income tax, time for govt yo pay you back the money.

Like banks. Banks are sucker/leech. Learn to suck from banks where possible.

If you feel like donating money to govt, be my guest. I don't donate money to govt and banks if I can help it. The only thing worth donating to is charity bodies or for global warming causes.
*
it is not legal. How does skimming the government is legal?

By the way, how can you have additional $$ for donation? thought most of your monthly expenses is about Rm300?
Ramjade
post Sep 9 2018, 02:03 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 9 2018, 01:55 PM)
it is not legal. How does skimming the government is legal?

By the way, how can you have additional $$ for donation? thought most of your monthly expenses is about Rm300?
*
If the law clearly state amount inside the country means amount inside the country. So it does not include amount outside the country. Hence make use of such loop holes. Those are legal ways.

Why cannot? I save > RM2k. I use the remaining cash to make sure I pay less money to govt. Why do you think I restrict my budget? The leftovers use for investment or use to claim money back from govt. If you spend everything, you have less cash available to claim free money back from govt. There's so many legal ways to pay less cash to govt and make the govt work for you.

This post has been edited by Ramjade: Sep 9 2018, 02:07 PM
tippman
post Sep 9 2018, 02:07 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Sep 9 2018, 02:03 PM)
If the law clearly state amount inside the country means amount inside the country. So it does not include amount outside the country. Hence make use of such loop holes. Those are legal ways.

Why cannot?  I save > RM2k. I use the remaining cash to make sure I pay less money to govt. There's so many legal ways to pay less cash to govt and make the govt work for you.
*
Australian Taxation system cover income generated and/or assets located in elsewhere from Aus.

You mentioned you are earning RM4k so what tax you are paying?
Ramjade
post Sep 9 2018, 02:08 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 9 2018, 02:07 PM)
Australian Taxation system cover income generated and/or assets located in elsewhere  from Aus.

You mentioned you are earning RM4k so what tax you are paying?
*
Income tax.
Showtime747
post Sep 9 2018, 02:35 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 11:57 AM)
She normally doesn't like me to go on LYN because she says i shouldn't be talking to young kids that i don't know on the net. doh.gif
*
There are many experienced forummers in Finance section here. Hensel, Propetjul, wongmunkeong, elea, gark, cherroy, avfan, nexona, xuzen off my head and a few others I cannot remember their nick as they may not be as active nowadays...We share a lot of useful info and tips.

There are some young forummers who are also willing to share their knowledge and experience. So, keep an open mind, and filter all the information. Many usefu information from them too....

You can remain strictly anonymous, don't respond to any offers or pm, then you will be safe from any scam
utellme
post Sep 9 2018, 02:56 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
919 posts

Joined: May 2005
QUOTE(j.passing.by @ Sep 9 2018, 01:52 AM)
Do read the long post above on making comparison between yourself and others... it can be meaningless.

Just like comparing how much one should save, it all depends on one's individuality and lifestyle.

Years ago when James Clavell wrote Noble House, the drop dead money was 2 million. I guess it should be 5 million now. But of course it could be less and enough for anyone to retire.

With house, car and other assets fully paid, the minimal can be as low as 2k. Or 24k per year.

At 4% interest from a fixed deposit,  the untouched nest egg to generate this 24k is 600k.
*
Not sure how to live with 2k per month in KL. 2k properly only for 3 simple meal daily and normal utility and assessment bills and public transportation. I think minimum 2.5k - 3k more likely.
Showtime747
post Sep 9 2018, 03:13 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
For the young man and woman who have set their mind on FIRE, I would like to throw you guys and girls a bigger picture :

1. Retiring early at age 40 sounds nice.

2. But if you think beyond yourself, your plan has a significant impact on the economy, society and human advancement. Sounds exaggerating ?

3. In economics, RE means a person does not contribute to the production of GDP anymore. He no longer is a net contributor to the economy

4. He is now a net consumer of scarce resources of the economy

5. An economy needs new blood to support the old and young people. That’s why countries with aging population face economic issues (eg Japan). If everybody retires at 40s, the economy will collapse. Just imagine 50% of the population are retirees, with the other 50% produce necessities for everyone else.

6. If you don’t understand in macro-economics terms, then think of it from the taxation point of view. When more people retire early, the tax revenue of a country will reduce. If a country has less income, the economy as a whole will suffer. The government cannot afford public services and the society will be in chaos

7. We all know our EPF is a quasi-ponzi scheme. If there are no new contributors, it will collapse. Remember those who retire at age 40 still have 15 years to go before they can dip into their retirement pot

8. From science progression point of view, people in the mid-40s are at their prime, most productive and most knowledgable. If all scientists have the same FIRE mindset, mankind won’t achieve what we achieved today. There will be very few inventions

9. If the seniors in work place retire early, the juniors may not be able to learn the trade in the most efficient manner.

10. RE is a selfish act. You enjoy the education provided to you for first 20 years. Bear in mind education are paid for by taxes from your predecessors who work hard. If they RE, taxes will drop, and you will not be able to enjoy the free education

11. After you graduate, you learn the skills from experienced seniors who don't retire early. You add value to yourself and progress through the corporate ladder and make more money

12. But when you reach 40 y/o, you have made enough money to retire and say bye bye

13. Instead of giving back to your country/society, you leave them and enjoy your personal lives. Younger generation will suffer

14. And when you become older and weaker 30 years later, you consume the resources and become a burden to the society.

RE at 40 years old is too early. If you have this mindset, you are a selfish person in the big picture. Work at least to the official retirement age. The country/society/younger generation needs you. Give back and contribute your part so that both the generations before and after you can enjoy the benefit you have enjoyed.

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 9 2018, 03:15 PM
Garysydney
post Sep 9 2018, 04:17 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Ramjade @ Sep 9 2018, 12:10 PM)
Er how about moving money out of AU. That way you get both pension and enjoy your earnings.
*
It is very hard to get old-aged pension now if you have hidden your assets overseas. The govt is getting very smart nowadays because they are aware a lot of Honkies and PRCs have assets overseas and claiming full pension. It used to be easy to get the full pension because the govt didn't really care but they have definitely tighten their cross-checking with other jurisdiction/countries in the last couple of years.

My Honkie colleague was already teaching me (move assets overseas) this 25 years ago - she would be nearly 75 years old now after taking redundancy about 10 years ago. Just goes to show how their minds worked - i never even thought about it and they were already planning it years before!!
Garysydney
post Sep 9 2018, 04:25 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 9 2018, 02:35 PM)
There are many experienced forummers in Finance section here. Hensel, Propetjul, wongmunkeong, elea, gark, cherroy, avfan, nexona, xuzen off my head and a few others I cannot remember their nick as they may not be as active nowadays...We share a lot of useful info and tips.

There are some young forummers who are also willing to share their knowledge and experience. So, keep an open mind, and filter all the information. Many usefu information from them too....

You can remain strictly anonymous, don't respond to any offers or pm, then you will be safe from any scam
*
I guess my wife is telling me an old man like me shouldn't go talking with younger people and that i should be talking with people my age. What she doesn't know is that i have picked up a lot of things in LYN which will prove useful when i go back to KL to retire. Some of the things/tips that are expressed in this forum are actually very useful to me as i am living overseas and have not much clue about living long-term in Msia.
icemanfx
post Sep 9 2018, 05:44 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
21,456 posts

Joined: Jul 2012


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 9 2018, 03:13 PM)
For the young man and woman who have set their mind on FIRE, I would like to throw you guys and girls a bigger picture :

1. Retiring early at age 40 sounds nice.

2. But if you think beyond yourself, your plan has a significant impact on the economy, society and human advancement. Sounds exaggerating ?

3. In economics, RE means a person does not contribute to the production of GDP anymore. He no longer is a net contributor to the economy

4. He is now a net consumer of scarce resources of the economy

5. An economy needs new blood to support the old and young people. That’s why countries with aging population face economic issues (eg Japan). If everybody retires at 40s, the economy will collapse. Just imagine 50% of the population are retirees, with the other 50% produce necessities for everyone else.

6. If you don’t understand in macro-economics terms, then think of it from the taxation point of view. When more people retire early, the tax revenue of a country will reduce. If a country has less income, the economy as a whole will suffer. The government cannot afford public services and the society will be in chaos

7. We all know our EPF is a quasi-ponzi scheme. If there are no new contributors, it will collapse. Remember those who retire at age 40 still have 15 years to go before they can dip into their retirement pot

8. From science progression point of view, people in the mid-40s are at their prime, most productive and most knowledgable. If all scientists have the same FIRE mindset, mankind won’t achieve what we achieved today. There will be very few inventions

9. If the seniors in work place retire early, the juniors may not be able to learn the trade in the most efficient manner.

10. RE is a selfish act. You enjoy the education provided to you for first 20 years. Bear in mind education are paid for by taxes from your predecessors who work hard. If they RE, taxes will drop, and you will not be able to enjoy the free education

11. After you graduate, you learn the skills from experienced seniors who don't retire early. You add value to yourself and progress through the corporate ladder and make more money

12. But when you reach 40 y/o, you have made enough money to retire and say bye bye

13. Instead of giving back to your country/society, you leave them and enjoy your personal lives. Younger generation will suffer

14. And when you become older and weaker 30 years later, you consume the resources and become a burden to the society.

RE at 40 years old is too early. If you have this mindset, you are a selfish person in the big picture. Work at least to the official retirement age. The country/society/younger generation needs you. Give back and contribute your part so that both the generations before and after you can enjoy the benefit you have enjoyed.
*
When enough people retire early i.e leave work force, those remaining in the work force could and will demand for higher price for their services i.e inflation will rise. Some or many of those retired may be forced to return to work.

In practice, without state sponsored education and welfare, few with children could truly fi/re

sky18
post Sep 9 2018, 06:27 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 9 2018, 03:13 PM)
For the young man and woman who have set their mind on FIRE, I would like to throw you guys and girls a bigger picture :

1. Retiring early at age 40 sounds nice.

2. But if you think beyond yourself, your plan has a significant impact on the economy, society and human advancement. Sounds exaggerating ?

3. In economics, RE means a person does not contribute to the production of GDP anymore. He no longer is a net contributor to the economy

4. He is now a net consumer of scarce resources of the economy

5. An economy needs new blood to support the old and young people. That’s why countries with aging population face economic issues (eg Japan). If everybody retires at 40s, the economy will collapse. Just imagine 50% of the population are retirees, with the other 50% produce necessities for everyone else.

6. If you don’t understand in macro-economics terms, then think of it from the taxation point of view. When more people retire early, the tax revenue of a country will reduce. If a country has less income, the economy as a whole will suffer. The government cannot afford public services and the society will be in chaos

7. We all know our EPF is a quasi-ponzi scheme. If there are no new contributors, it will collapse. Remember those who retire at age 40 still have 15 years to go before they can dip into their retirement pot

8. From science progression point of view, people in the mid-40s are at their prime, most productive and most knowledgable. If all scientists have the same FIRE mindset, mankind won’t achieve what we achieved today. There will be very few inventions

9. If the seniors in work place retire early, the juniors may not be able to learn the trade in the most efficient manner.

10. RE is a selfish act. You enjoy the education provided to you for first 20 years. Bear in mind education are paid for by taxes from your predecessors who work hard. If they RE, taxes will drop, and you will not be able to enjoy the free education

11. After you graduate, you learn the skills from experienced seniors who don't retire early. You add value to yourself and progress through the corporate ladder and make more money

12. But when you reach 40 y/o, you have made enough money to retire and say bye bye

13. Instead of giving back to your country/society, you leave them and enjoy your personal lives. Younger generation will suffer

14. And when you become older and weaker 30 years later, you consume the resources and become a burden to the society.

RE at 40 years old is too early. If you have this mindset, you are a selfish person in the big picture. Work at least to the official retirement age. The country/society/younger generation needs you. Give back and contribute your part so that both the generations before and after you can enjoy the benefit you have enjoyed.
*
Sorry but I guess lots of ppl had misunderstand / disagreement / bias on RE part. Many had take the stand that RE is equivalent to normal retirement post 55 or 60 years olds where ppl only "makan, tidur dan main". Well, if you looks more carefully, especially from angmo blogger, many of them effective transit into another type of works (something meaningful to their believe) instead of corporate 9-5 job. Thus, i can't agreed on all the points above as the very fundamental view on FI/RE is different; but I'm really feel RE (retirement early) is a misleading terminology.

Besides, we had to admit that not everyone can archive FI, and among these ppl, not all of them can resist the greed and move on to RE. Anyhow, the world is huge enough to accept these diversity, similiar to religion & races. Thus, many points wont's happened as not every can FI/RE, and affect the whole economy eventually, similar to you can't expect ALL smoker stop smoking as all of us knew is not good for health. I guess you were old enough appreciate this is not a perfect world.

One the other hand, if one success reached his FI at 40 and break away from his corporate minion job could due to his prioity on health/family or being forced i.e:layoff. His still contributing in other forms, eg: funding for business via investment/stock/etc, spend more focus and raise their kids be a better person, charity works, or even writing an self-help book etc. Would you agreed these are much better than those still works but on sin industries related to gambling, human or weapon trafficker, drug dealer, etc?

FI essentially is an enablement on finacially wise to allow someone move to next stage. while RE part is one trying find a new balance of his life. So long this new balance is not hurting anyone, we shouldnt' take any prejudicement on it.

Many breakthru and innovation mainly from "passionated" scientist, and these ppl unlikely take RE as their passion and purpose is what they doing in their dayjob. FI is just meant there is no financial stress for them. Unfortunately, in corporate world, most of corporate minion are soulless and all these cog are replaceable when it needed. Furthermore, some new youngester not neccessary value their senior opinion, and corporate life is getting worse due to ever demanding and constant changes. Afterall, the manager, senior manager or even CEO just another cog. smile.gif


TSmeonkutu11
post Sep 9 2018, 08:05 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,597 posts

Joined: Apr 2009


After someone achieved FI and choose to quit from his/her 9-5jobs, he/she will have a lot of freedom in term of time.

To not be SELFISH as someone said, use that time to participate in volunteering, giving back in term of you knowledge to your University, spend more times to take care of your parents or with your kids.

Also you can choose to work what you like or part time which will eventually needs to pay income tax to government. (Tutor/lecturer, financial consultant, unit trust consultant, or Real Estate Negotiator). Selling enough products to many people will have you to pay tax maybe more than someone who still on his/her 9-5jobs.

My opinions.
NightHeart
post Sep 9 2018, 08:34 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 04:25 PM)
I guess my wife is telling me an old man like me shouldn't go talking with younger people and that i should be talking with people my age. What she doesn't know is that i have picked up a lot of things in LYN which will prove useful when i go back to KL to retire. Some of the things/tips that are expressed in this forum are actually very useful to me as i am living overseas and have not much clue about living long-term in Msia.
*
You'd be surprised, there are quite a number of experienced veterans or retirees around. I've met a few already, it's quite easy to tell based on the way their write.
Ramjade
post Sep 9 2018, 09:43 PM

20k VIP Club
*********
All Stars
24,333 posts

Joined: Feb 2011


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 9 2018, 03:13 PM)
For the young man and woman who have set their mind on FIRE, I would like to throw you guys and girls a bigger picture :

1. Retiring early at age 40 sounds nice.

2. But if you think beyond yourself, your plan has a significant impact on the economy, society and human advancement. Sounds exaggerating ?

3. In economics, RE means a person does not contribute to the production of GDP anymore. He no longer is a net contributor to the economy

4. He is now a net consumer of scarce resources of the economy

5. An economy needs new blood to support the old and young people. That’s why countries with aging population face economic issues (eg Japan). If everybody retires at 40s, the economy will collapse. Just imagine 50% of the population are retirees, with the other 50% produce necessities for everyone else.

6. If you don’t understand in macro-economics terms, then think of it from the taxation point of view. When more people retire early, the tax revenue of a country will reduce. If a country has less income, the economy as a whole will suffer. The government cannot afford public services and the society will be in chaos

7. We all know our EPF is a quasi-ponzi scheme. If there are no new contributors, it will collapse. Remember those who retire at age 40 still have 15 years to go before they can dip into their retirement pot

8. From science progression point of view, people in the mid-40s are at their prime, most productive and most knowledgable. If all scientists have the same FIRE mindset, mankind won’t achieve what we achieved today. There will be very few inventions

9. If the seniors in work place retire early, the juniors may not be able to learn the trade in the most efficient manner.

10. RE is a selfish act. You enjoy the education provided to you for first 20 years. Bear in mind education are paid for by taxes from your predecessors who work hard. If they RE, taxes will drop, and you will not be able to enjoy the free education

11. After you graduate, you learn the skills from experienced seniors who don't retire early. You add value to yourself and progress through the corporate ladder and make more money

12. But when you reach 40 y/o, you have made enough money to retire and say bye bye

13. Instead of giving back to your country/society, you leave them and enjoy your personal lives. Younger generation will suffer

14. And when you become older and weaker 30 years later, you consume the resources and become a burden to the society.

RE at 40 years old is too early. If you have this mindset, you are a selfish person in the big picture. Work at least to the official retirement age. The country/society/younger generation needs you. Give back and contribute your part so that both the generations before and after you can enjoy the benefit you have enjoyed.
*
3. That's if you use govt related stuff. If not? Is out of your own pocket.

5. True. But how many can afford to retire early if they spend > what they earn? biggrin.gif Saving is hard and spending is easy. Guess how many will choose the easy way? biggrin.gif

10. You are already working hard your life, why should you not reward yourself after all the hard work? Family come first over work/country.

13. Well is their choice whether they want to work their way towards self sustainability or they want to work their way by becoming slaves to the banks/countries.
I know what I prefer.

14. Not if you keep in good health.

Sorry if I don't reply all but you get my idea.
j.passing.by
post Sep 9 2018, 10:49 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,639 posts

Joined: Nov 2010
QUOTE(utellme @ Sep 9 2018, 02:56 PM)
Not sure how to live with 2k per month in KL. 2k properly only for 3 simple meal daily and normal utility and assessment bills and public transportation. I think minimum 2.5k - 3k more likely.
*
smile.gif you are right.

To be really FI/RE at a young age of 45 and below, you would need much more if you are married with several children still in school/college.

Those, me inclusive, who were talking about retiring a few years earlier than the mandatory retirement age were talking about retirement in general.

To be really FI/RE, I don't think working part time or having a business that doesn't require your presence all the time counts as 'retirement'.

FI/RE is possible if your spouse is working!



sky18
post Sep 10 2018, 07:01 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(j.passing.by @ Sep 9 2018, 10:49 PM)
smile.gif you are right.

To be really FI/RE at a young age of 45 and below, you would need much more if you are married with several children still in school/college.

Those, me inclusive, who were talking about retiring a few years earlier than the mandatory retirement age were talking about retirement in general.

To be really FI/RE, I don't think working part time or having a business that doesn't require your presence all the time counts as 'retirement'.

FI/RE is possible if your spouse is working!
*
Perhaps this is a good read. RE is not constrained to traditional retirement as you mentioned.

https://qz.com/work/1274905/understanding-f...retiring-early/
cherroy
post Sep 10 2018, 10:11 AM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(j.passing.by @ Sep 9 2018, 10:49 PM)
To be really FI/RE at a young age of 45 and below, you would need much more if you are married with several children still in school/college.

Those, me inclusive, who were talking about retiring a few years earlier than the mandatory retirement age were talking about retirement in general.

To be really FI/RE, I don't think working part time or having a business that doesn't require your presence all the time counts as 'retirement'.

FI/RE is possible if your spouse is working!
*
There is needless when achieve FI, then must retire already.


cherroy
post Sep 10 2018, 10:17 AM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 04:17 PM)
It is very hard to get old-aged pension now if you have hidden your assets overseas. The govt is getting very smart nowadays because they are aware a lot of Honkies and PRCs have assets overseas and claiming full pension. It used to be easy to get the full pension because the govt didn't really care but they have definitely tighten their cross-checking with other jurisdiction/countries in the last couple of years.

My Honkie colleague was already teaching me (move assets overseas) this 25 years ago - she would be nearly 75 years old now after taking redundancy about 10 years ago. Just goes to show how their minds worked - i never even thought about it and they were already planning it years before!!
*
The newly implemented AEOI under CRS, means every participant country has greater access to overseas info.
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 10:38 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 9 2018, 04:25 PM)
I guess my wife is telling me an old man like me shouldn't go talking with younger people and that i should be talking with people my age. What she doesn't know is that i have picked up a lot of things in LYN which will prove useful when i go back to KL to retire. Some of the things/tips that are expressed in this forum are actually very useful to me as i am living overseas and have not much clue about living long-term in Msia.
*
I am the opposite biggrin.gif

In real life, I am the most senior in the family. So when I meet my family, the juniors only dare to speak nice words out of respect. Typical asian culture.

While in my company, my staff only talked business to me. There is a certain fear towards their boss. So, not many people dare to point out my mistake except those very senior staff (I consider them as my partner)

Only in forum, everybody doesn't know everybody. We are all equal. So everybody speaks truth and give their unreserved opinion. That's why there are much to be learned from a forum. I always keep an opened mind. And speak out unreservedly my opinion without fear of being termed undiplomatic. In real life, we cannot speak our mind and must stick with politically correct statement
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 10:39 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(icemanfx @ Sep 9 2018, 05:44 PM)
When enough people retire early i.e leave work force, those remaining in the work force could and will demand for higher price for their services i.e inflation will rise. Some or many of those retired may be forced to return to work.

In practice, without state sponsored education and welfare, few with children could truly fi/re
*
In a rare occasion, I agree with my son thumbup.gif
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 11:00 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 9 2018, 06:27 PM)
Sorry but I guess lots of ppl had misunderstand / disagreement / bias on RE part. Many had take the stand that RE is equivalent to normal retirement post 55 or 60 years olds where ppl only "makan, tidur dan main". Well, if you looks more carefully, especially from angmo blogger, many of them effective transit into another type of works (something meaningful to their believe) instead of corporate 9-5 job. Thus, i can't agreed on all the points above as the very fundamental view on FI/RE is different; but I'm really feel RE (retirement early) is a misleading terminology.
1. The impression I got from reading the pages of this thread is that the Retire Early age is around 40 years old. So my hypothesis is based on RE at 40 years old. Not 55 or 60. If it was 55 or 60, my hypothesis does not hold water


QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 9 2018, 06:27 PM)
Besides, we had to admit that not everyone can archive FI, and among these ppl, not all of them can resist the greed and move on to RE. Anyhow, the world is huge enough to accept these diversity, similiar to religion & races. Thus, many points wont's happened as not every can FI/RE, and affect the whole economy eventually, similar to you can't expect ALL smoker stop smoking as all of us knew is not good for health. I guess you were old enough appreciate this is not a perfect world.
2. My hypothesis is that FIRE is a advocation/teaching/belief. If the advocation/teaching/belief is so widespread, until it reaches a point where 30% of the workforce are aiming for it and achieving it, then my hypothesis would sadly become a reality. The economy would be in critical condition

3. Taking your smoking example as the analogy of my hypothesis. FIRE is actually like smoking habit. If everybody believe FIRE/smoking is good, and everybody practise it, then it is not good for the society

QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 9 2018, 06:27 PM)
One the other hand, if one success reached his FI at 40 and break away from his corporate minion job could due to his prioity on health/family or being forced i.e:layoff. His still contributing in other forms, eg: funding for business via investment/stock/etc, spend more focus and raise their kids be a better person, charity works, or even writing an self-help book etc. Would you agreed these are much better than those still works but on sin industries related to gambling, human or weapon trafficker, drug dealer, etc?
4. You are making an assumption here "working" and "other things" cannot co-exist. "other things" being investment, raise kinds, charity works, writing books.

5. Working doesn't take up all your 16 hours of active life.

6. If it does, then you may want to think of changing your job. It is not normal. And it is detrimental to your long term life.

7. We must find out the root cause of the problem, instead of finding get around to the problem. If your current job makes you think FIRE is the solution, then it is just a "get around solution". The root cause of the problem is your job. Go solve the root cause of your problem by finding a job that don't take up 16 hours of your time, and at the same time gives you job satisfaction.

8. A good job is a job where you look forward to Mondays, not fearing Mondays biggrin.gif


QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 9 2018, 06:27 PM)
FI essentially is an enablement on finacially wise to allow someone move to next stage. while RE part is one trying find a new balance of his life. So long this new balance is not hurting anyone, we shouldnt' take any prejudicement on it.
9. My hypothesis does indicate that RE before official retirement will hurt the economy, society and country as a whole. If you look at the macro level



QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 9 2018, 06:27 PM)
Many breakthru and innovation mainly from "passionated" scientist, and these ppl unlikely take RE as their passion and purpose is what they doing in their dayjob. FI is just meant there is no financial stress for them. Unfortunately, in corporate world, most of corporate minion are soulless and all these cog are replaceable when it needed. Furthermore, some new youngester not neccessary value their senior opinion, and corporate life is getting worse due to ever demanding and constant changes. Afterall, the manager, senior manager or even CEO just another cog. smile.gif
*
10. If a person can RE at age 40, he must be a talent. He can achieve something 20 years earlier than a normal people would.

11. Those corporate minion would not even retire at age 70 because they are the plain old vanilla.

12. Scientists are the cream of the crop. If they believe in FIRE, then there will be no more humanity advancement

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 10 2018, 11:02 AM
Garysydney
post Sep 10 2018, 11:03 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(cherroy @ Sep 10 2018, 10:17 AM)
The newly implemented AEOI under CRS, means every participant country has greater access to overseas info.
*
Yes - a few of my friends (working in Sydney) have been asked to provide information about their bank accts in Spore by the ATO. When the ATO sees money going/coming in from overseas to your acct, you are very likely to be a target by the ATO (Aust Tax Office).

My wife sold an investment property in 2013 in Sydney and transferred about A$110k back to KL via NAB and she was queried by ATO recently even though there were no tax owing to the ATO. Nowadays the ATO computer-matching IT systems are very sophisticated so defrauding Centrelink (social security here) is made extremely difficult.
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 11:07 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Sep 9 2018, 08:05 PM)
After someone achieved FI and choose to quit from his/her 9-5jobs, he/she will have a lot of freedom in term of time.

To not be SELFISH as someone said, use that time to participate in volunteering, giving back in term of you knowledge to your University, spend more times to take care of your parents or with your kids.
Full time job = full pay = full tax = economy gets full benefit

Part time job = part pay = part tax = economy gets only part of the benefit

You are just consoling/justifying your selfishness


QUOTE(meonkutu11 @ Sep 9 2018, 08:05 PM)
Also you can choose to work what you like or part time which will eventually needs to pay income tax to government. (Tutor/lecturer, financial consultant, unit trust consultant, or Real Estate Negotiator). Selling enough products to many people will have you to pay tax maybe more than someone who still on his/her 9-5jobs.

My opinions.
If you can generate more income after retired, then what makes you want to stay on your current job ? Retire now is better....
Garysydney
post Sep 10 2018, 11:12 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 10:38 AM)
I am the opposite  biggrin.gif

In real life, I am the most senior in the family. So when I meet my family, the juniors only dare to speak nice words out of respect. Typical asian culture.

While in my company, my staff only talked business to me. There is a certain fear towards their boss. So, not many people dare to point out my mistake except those very senior staff (I consider them as my partner)

Only in forum, everybody doesn't know everybody. We are all equal. So everybody speaks truth and give their unreserved opinion. That's why there are much to be learned from a forum. I always keep an opened mind. And speak out unreservedly my opinion without fear of being termed undiplomatic. In real life, we cannot speak our mind and must stick with politically correct statement
*
My wife keeps her money separately from me and even though she is Msian, people (esp women) change after living in Aust for a while. She likes to give her opinion and i would normally accept it if it is fair. She is not as submissive as 30 years ago.

Due to the push for women equality, a lot of govt and semi-govt jobs (very cushy job!) now have a quota whereby women must be employed to meet the 45-50% participation rate. It is probably a bit like the bumi policy but here the women is the bumi. biggrin.gif Call it unfair or whatever for men but this is the direction that Aust is heading towards where people are employed not by merit but by gender.

This post has been edited by Garysydney: Sep 10 2018, 11:14 AM
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 11:12 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Sep 9 2018, 09:43 PM)
3. That's if you use govt related stuff. If not? Is out of your own pocket.

5. True. But how many can afford to retire early if they spend > what they earn?  biggrin.gif Saving is hard and spending is easy. Guess how many will choose the easy way?  biggrin.gif

10. You are already working hard your life, why should you not reward yourself after all the hard work? Family come first over work/country.

13. Well is their choice whether they want to work their way towards self sustainability or they want to work their way by becoming slaves to the banks/countries.
I know what I prefer.

14. Not if you keep in good health.

Sorry if I don't reply all but you get my idea.
*
3. Water, road, road ligths, police (security), ambulance, fire brigade, parks you do your jogging, government department staff (passport, IC, JPJ) etc etc are stuff government provided.

10. "Family come first over work/country" --> this is what I mean by "selfish"

13. "....becoming slaves to the banks/countries" --> again another example of "selfishness".

14. You are not immortal
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 11:15 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 10 2018, 11:12 AM)
My wife keeps her money separately from me and even though she is Msian, people (esp women) change after living in Aust for a while. She likes to give her opinion and i would normally accept it if it is fair. She is not as submissive as 30 years ago.

Due to the push for women equality, a lot of govt and semi-govt jobs (very cushy job!) now have a quota whereby women must be employed to meet the 45-50% participation rate. It is probably a bit like the bumi policy but here the women is the bumi. biggrin.gif Call it unfair or whatever for men but this is the direction that Aust is heading towards where people are employed not by merit and by gender.
*
Yea....wife is about the only source of true opinion we get at my age, and willing to raise her voice to make me heard biggrin.gif
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 12:24 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 11:07 AM)
Full time job = full pay = full tax = economy gets full benefit

Part time job = part pay = part tax = economy gets only part of the benefit

You are just consoling/justifying your selfishness
If you can generate more income after retired, then what makes you want to stay on your current job ? Retire now is better....
*
I don't think there is right or wrong if some one choose to retire early. If his/her financial situation permit then what is the issue of him/her to retire early.

In relation to the whole economy picture, I am sure there are plenty of people who are looking for full time job and they will be plenty of people to replenish the vacant post that just created. If some one wanted to contribute their time full times for charity work/raising this and raising that, who are we to say no them? Take note those charity organisation doesn't work on its own.

Jack ma is retiring at 54 which I don't thin Alibaba group is going to close down when he retired. When Steve job passed away, is Apple going away with him together?


Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 12:46 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 12:24 PM)
I don't think there is right or wrong if some one choose to retire early. If his/her financial situation permit then what is the issue of him/her to retire early.

In relation to the whole economy picture, I am sure there are plenty of people who are looking for full time job and they will be plenty of people to replenish the vacant post that just created. If some one wanted to contribute their time full times for charity work/raising this and raising that, who are we to say no them? Take note those charity organisation doesn't work on its own.

Jack ma is retiring at 54 which I don't thin Alibaba group is going to close down when he retired. When Steve job passed away, is Apple going away with him together?
*
Yes, my hypothesis is not talking about right or wrong / legal or illegal. Just like smoking. It's not illegal. It's a matter of personal choice.

But in big picture, RE is no good for the economy/society/country.

Just like smoking, it is a selfish act.

Jack Ma retires close to 55 years old. If he retires at 40 years old, Alibaba would be not as big as it is today. In fact, I would speculate that if he is a believer of FIRE, he would not be so ambitious and Alibaba would be non-existance
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 12:52 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 12:46 PM)
Yes, my hypothesis is not talking about right or wrong / legal or illegal. Just like smoking. It's not illegal. It's a matter of personal choice.

But in big picture, RE is no good for the economy/society/country.

Just like smoking, it is a selfish act.

Jack Ma retires close to 55 years old. If he retires at 40 years old, Alibaba would be not as big as it is today. In fact, I would speculate that if he is a believer of FIRE, he would not be so ambitious and Alibaba would be non-existance
*
I don't think there is big picture or small picture, do take note that everyday there is new born baby and everyday there is some one pass away so the world is continue to move when one person choose to retire and his spot will be filled by some one it is eco balance of the whole universe.

I can't speculate whether he is believer or not because I don't him and I can't comment but basing with your logic I can say he is a believer otherwise he will continue to work till 70.

Smoking is not a selfish act, smoking is a preference for each individual. If a person smoking in front of children then I would call it selfish.


aspartame
post Sep 10 2018, 02:35 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
I think part of the reason capitalism works has got to do with the allure of riches , including the freedom that comes with it. If there is a "law" preventing early retirement and hence ”preventing loss of productivity".... I am sure the drive to excel will be much less across society ..in short, why accumulate wealth if one can never ever stop work if he wants to?

Another point I would like to make is - I think only a small number of people can achieve full financial independence by age 55.... an even smaller % can achieve at age 40 to 45... the % is so small that it is negligible to productivity
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 02:52 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 12:52 PM)
I don't think there is big picture or small picture, do take note that everyday there is new born baby and everyday there is some one pass away so the world is continue to move when one person choose to retire and his spot will be filled by some one it is eco balance of the whole universe.
In economics, the status quo is the equilibrium. Population growth rate changes will affect the equilibrium and shift to a new equilibrium. Aging population like that of Japan has brought negative effect on its economy

In my hypothesis, if FIRE becomes a trend, like aging population issue, the equilibrium will shift. The shift will have adverse effect on the economy.

Bear in mind that my hypothesis is largely based on macro-economics point of view. For those without Economics background, it might be difficult to grasp my hypothesis

So far, only my son understands what I am talking about biggrin.gif

QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 12:52 PM)
I can't speculate whether he is believer or not because I don't him and I can't comment but basing with your logic I can say he is a believer otherwise he will continue to work till 70.
Again, my hypothesis based strictly on RE before the official retirement age.

In Jack Ma’s case, he is going to retire at 55 or thereabouts, so his data is relevant in my hypothesis, ie. If he is a believer of RE, Alibaba most probably would not exist


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 12:52 PM)
Smoking is not a selfish act, smoking is a preference for each individual. If a person smoking in front of children then I would call it selfish.
*
Yes, I am referring to smoking when there are people around

You can’t be retiring and live alone and away from the society, can you ?

So, my hypothesis refers RE as a selfish act, just like smokers smoke in public

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 10 2018, 02:55 PM
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 03:10 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 02:52 PM)
In economics, the status quo is the equilibrium. Population growth rate changes will affect the equilibrium and shift to a new equilibrium. Aging population like that of Japan has brought negative effect on its economy

In my hypothesis, if FIRE becomes a trend, like aging population issue, the equilibrium will shift. The shift will have adverse effect on the economy.

Bear in mind that my hypothesis is largely based on macro-economics point of view. For those without Economics background, it might be difficult to grasp my hypothesis

So far, only my son understands what I am talking about  biggrin.gif
Again, my hypothesis based strictly on RE before the official retirement age.

In Jack Ma’s case, he is going to retire at 55 or thereabouts, so his data is relevant in my hypothesis, ie. If he is a believer of RE, Alibaba most probably would not exist
Yes, I am referring to smoking when there are people around

You can’t be retiring and live alone and away from the society, can you ?

So, my hypothesis refers RE as a selfish act, just like smokers smoke in public
*
Can you show me what is the statistic that people are actually retiring early? an official retirement age is just a number put on retirement. At one point Australia trying to implement retirement age at 70 so are you saying the whole world should set the retirement age at 70?

Jack Ma founded alibaba in 1999 when he was 35 so why you think Alibaba would not exist?

Since when in my comment that I indicated that when I retiring and I will live alone? Can you please show me?


I don't think smoking in public is a selfish act and I dont agree with your comment on smoking.
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 03:13 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(aspartame @ Sep 10 2018, 02:35 PM)
I think part of the reason capitalism works has got to do with the allure of riches , including the freedom that comes with it. If there is a "law" preventing early retirement and hence ”preventing loss of productivity".... I am sure the drive to excel will be much less across society ..in short, why accumulate wealth if one can never ever stop work if he wants to?
I think those with FIRE mindset are not ambitious. They are contented bunch of people

If you read back the pages, they are talking about RM2k to RM5k per month to retire.

With such small amount, capitalism failed big time.

Coming back to analogy of RE and smoking. You can see the trend of enacting laws that “preventing/discouraging” both acts. Smoking become more and more restricted. And EPF contribution/withdrawing age deferment and extending our official retirement age are being talked about more and more. It doesn’t only happen in malaysia, but all around the world

QUOTE(aspartame @ Sep 10 2018, 02:35 PM)

Another point I would like to make is - I think only a small number of people can achieve full financial independence by age 55.... an even smaller % can achieve at age 40 to 45... the % is so small that it is negligible to productivity
*
RE is a trend. And my hypothesis is coming from the Macro-Economics point of view that RE is a selfish act that if a sizeable population RE, it would have an adverse effect on the economy

Again I give you the smoking analogy. You can argue that the smokers population is very small thus the effect to the other non-smoker is negligible. But regardless of the number, smoking is a selfish act. Because it affects people around you. And when half of our population becomes smokers, then it would become a big problem.


tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 03:23 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:13 PM)
I think those with FIRE mindset are not ambitious. They are contented bunch of people

If you read back the pages, they are talking about RM2k to RM5k per month to retire.

With such small amount, capitalism failed big time.

Coming back to analogy of RE and smoking. You can see the trend of enacting laws that “preventing/discouraging” both acts. Smoking become more and more restricted. And EPF contribution/withdrawing age deferment and extending our official retirement age are being talked about more and more. It doesn’t only happen in malaysia, but all around the world
RE is a trend. And my hypothesis is coming from the Macro-Economics point of view that RE is a selfish act that if a sizeable population RE, it would have an adverse effect on the economy

Again I give you the smoking analogy. You can argue that the smokers population is very small thus the effect to the other non-smoker is negligible. But regardless of the number, smoking is a selfish act. Because it affects people around you. And when half of our population becomes smokers, then it would become a big problem.
*
You keep talking about your comment as hypothesis, do you have statistics to show that people who retire early will severely affect the economy?

Yes EPF is extending the age of retirement this is part contributed by the longevity of population.

If a person can choose to retire early while his financial permitted so who are you to judge people are selfish?

Smoking also contribute to the tax and economy so based on your logic that people should not retire early because they don’t contribute to economy then why you said smoker is selfish? They contribute to economy via sin tax and the more cigarette they buy the more workforce required.
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 03:29 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 03:10 PM)
Can you show me what is the statistic that people are actually retiring early? an official retirement age is just a number put on retirement. At one point Australia trying to implement retirement age at 70 so are you saying the whole world should set the retirement age at 70?
Depends on country. In Malaysia, 55 is the official retirement age. So, any age earlier that that is early

For Australia, I think it was 67 ?

No, I am not saying the whole world have a single number. It depends on the official age of the country

QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 03:10 PM)
Jack Ma founded alibaba in 1999 when he was 35 so why you think Alibaba would not exist?
Because those with FIRE mindset try very hard not to work another day if they could. They have no passion to work. Working is just for money.

Jack Ma on the other hand is a visionary. He is ambitious. He created new way of life and changed a new world.

Any proponent of FIRE here has Jack Ma’s ambition ? I don’t think so.

QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 03:10 PM)
Since when in my comment that I indicated that when I retiring and I will live alone? Can you please show me?
I don't think smoking in public is a selfish act and I dont agree with your comment on smoking.
*
I am referring to my analogy of smoking vs RE.

You said that smoking is selfish in front of children.

So, when a person retires, he retires and live in a society. It will affect people around you. Unless you can retire and live in the mountain alone, then my hypothesis does not stand
aspartame
post Sep 10 2018, 03:31 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:13 PM)
I think those with FIRE mindset are not ambitious. They are contented bunch of people

If you read back the pages, they are talking about RM2k to RM5k per month to retire.

With such small amount, capitalism failed big time.

Coming back to analogy of RE and smoking. You can see the trend of enacting laws that “preventing/discouraging” both acts. Smoking become more and more restricted. And EPF contribution/withdrawing age deferment and extending our official retirement age are being talked about more and more. It doesn’t only happen in malaysia, but all around the world
RE is a trend. And my hypothesis is coming from the Macro-Economics point of view that RE is a selfish act that if a sizeable population RE, it would have an adverse effect on the economy

Again I give you the smoking analogy. You can argue that the smokers population is very small thus the effect to the other non-smoker is negligible. But regardless of the number, smoking is a selfish act. Because it affects people around you. And when half of our population becomes smokers, then it would become a big problem.
*
I am not sure smoking analogy is appropriate. Smoking is discouraged..yes. Extending retirement age is exactly because most people cannot achieve FI by age 55 to 60 and hence have to work longer...otherwise they will run out of money after age 55 and becomes a social problem..

There is a difference between "trend to FIRE" and "actual FIRE” Yes, there is an increasing desire to FIRE. How that trend translates to actual achievement of FIRE is not known. I suspect the % achieving FIRE will remain low.

sky18
post Sep 10 2018, 03:33 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 11:00 AM)
1. The impression I got from reading the pages of this thread is that the Retire Early age is around 40 years old. So my hypothesis is based on RE at 40 years old. Not 55 or 60. If it was 55 or 60, my hypothesis does not hold water
*
I'm neutral on those capable calls FI/RE on their 40. Afterall, it's their choice and leveraging on capitalism system.


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 11:00 AM)
2. My hypothesis is that FIRE is a advocation/teaching/belief. If the advocation/teaching/belief is so widespread, until it reaches a point where 30% of the workforce are aiming for it and achieving it, then my hypothesis would sadly become a reality. The economy would be in critical condition

9. My hypothesis does indicate that RE before official retirement will hurt the economy, society and country as a whole. If you look at the macro level

3. Taking your smoking example as the analogy of my hypothesis. FIRE is actually like smoking habit. If everybody believe FIRE/smoking is good, and everybody practise it, then it is not good for the society

*
Agreed. it'll affect economy condition if hit 30%. However, it ain't going to happened. I doubt FI population can exceed 1% of population, not to mention those jump into RE at age 40-50.
Even your hypothesis 30% occur, many of them will fall back from financial freedom as their projected return is way lower to sustain their life. The capitalism rules just not allow it happened.

QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 11:00 AM)
4. You are making an assumption here "working" and "other things" cannot co-exist. "other things" being investment, raise kinds, charity works, writing books.

5. Working doesn't take up all your 16 hours of active life.

6. If it does, then you may want to think of changing your job. It is not normal. And it is detrimental to your long term life.

7. We must find out the root cause of the problem, instead of finding get around to the problem. If your current job makes you think FIRE is the solution, then it is just a "get around solution". The root cause of the problem is your job. Go solve the root cause of your problem by finding a job that don't take up 16 hours of your time, and at the same time gives you job satisfaction.

8. A good job is a job where you look forward to Mondays, not fearing Mondays  biggrin.gif 
*
I can't deny it can happened these thing can potential co-exist (4). However, the magnitude or effort required if much higher. You probably missed the point where core essence of FI/RE is about buying more time (finite good) vs money (fiat money practically just a number in core banking system).

Agreed on most of the points above. Again, our fundamental understanding of FI/RE is different. In fact, all these happened since old day without such glamour word FI/RE.
Old saying would be a person change his career path in mid-life from corporate white colar to book writer/voluntary or hawker char kway teow. Points 4-8 is archive by leaving their 9-5 corporate dayjob with solid financial as backup.


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 11:00 AM)
10. If a person can RE at age 40, he must be a talent. He can achieve something 20 years earlier than a normal people would.

11. Those corporate minion would not even retire at age 70 because they are the plain old vanilla.

12. Scientists are the cream of the crop. If they believe in FIRE, then there will be no more humanity advancement
*
In fact, I would says FI/RE is more archivable nowaday due to capatilism, and ease of access to various investment vehicle, knowledge & information aside from self awakening and determination.

QUOTE(aspartame @ Sep 10 2018, 02:35 PM)
I think part of the reason capitalism works has got to do with the allure of riches , including the freedom that comes with it. If there is a "law" preventing early retirement and hence ”preventing loss of productivity".... I am sure the drive to excel will be much less across society ..in short, why accumulate wealth if one can never ever stop work if he wants to?

Another point I would like to make is - I think only a small number of people can achieve full financial independence by age 55.... an even smaller % can achieve at age 40 to 45... the % is so small that it is negligible to productivity
*
Agreed! Finally saw someone like minded and relates FI/RE as a by-product of capitalism. It's all about exceed and concentration of wealth to smaller group of ppl.
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 03:37 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 03:23 PM)
You keep talking about your comment as hypothesis, do you have statistics to show that people who retire early will severely affect the economy?

Yes EPF is extending the age of retirement this is part contributed by the longevity of population.
Like I have said, look at countries which has aging population problem, then you will understand from the Economics point of view

RE has similar effect to aging population problem.


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 03:23 PM)
If a person can choose to retire early while his financial permitted so who are you to judge people are selfish?
My hypothesis says so.

I have list down the argument in my hypothesis clearly why RE is termed a selfish act


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 03:23 PM)
Smoking also contribute to the tax and economy so based on your logic that people should not retire early because they don’t contribute to economy then why you said smoker is selfish? They contribute to economy via sin tax and the more cigarette they buy the more workforce required.
*
Smokers is used as an analogy because :

Smoker —> secondhand smoke —> selfish

Early retiree —> early net consumer of economic resource —> selfish

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 10 2018, 03:58 PM
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 03:40 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(aspartame @ Sep 10 2018, 03:31 PM)
I am not sure smoking analogy is appropriate. Smoking is discouraged..yes. Extending retirement age is exactly because most people cannot achieve FI by age 55 to 60 and hence have to work longer...otherwise they will run out of money after age 55 and becomes a social problem..

There is a difference between "trend to FIRE" and "actual FIRE” Yes, there is an increasing desire to FIRE. How that trend translates to actual achievement of FIRE is not known. I suspect the % achieving FIRE will remain low.
*
I think so too. FIRE although is a trend, but no many people will achieve it.

But in my hypothesis (and remain as a hypothesis), if a sizeable population achieve RE, it would have adverse effect on the economy. It is not a good thing. And a selfish act like smoking
aspartame
post Sep 10 2018, 03:47 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:40 PM)
I think so too. FIRE although is a trend, but no many people will achieve it.

But in my hypothesis (and remain as a hypothesis), if a sizeable population achieve RE, it would have adverse effect on the economy. It is not a good thing. And a selfish act like smoking
*
I know what you mean. There are some who take this to the extreme. They save like mad, up to 70%, and then they "retire" at age 35, living on subsistence level of passive income, and they call it "freedom"... yes, taken to the extreme, it is toxic!
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 03:54 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(aspartame @ Sep 10 2018, 03:47 PM)
I know what you mean. There are some who take this to the extreme. They save like mad, up to 70%, and then they "retire" at age 35, living on subsistence level of passive income, and they call it "freedom"... yes, taken to the extreme, it is toxic!
*
And the root cause of their problem is their disliking of the job. RE is just a get around. Not the true solution

If they have a job they are passionate about, they won’t retire at all biggrin.gif

All in all, what I want to say is FI is a good thing. But RE is a bad thing, both personal or society/economy as a whole
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 03:57 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:33 PM)
I'm neutral on those capable calls FI/RE on their 40. Afterall, it's their choice and leveraging on capitalism system.
Agreed. it'll affect economy condition if hit 30%. However, it ain't going to happened. I doubt FI population can exceed 1% of population, not to mention those jump into RE at age 40-50.
Even your hypothesis 30% occur, many of them will fall back from financial freedom as their projected return is way lower to sustain their life. The capitalism rules just not allow it happened.
I can't deny it can happened these thing can potential co-exist (4). However, the magnitude or effort required if much higher. You probably missed the point where core essence of FI/RE is about buying more time (finite good) vs money (fiat money practically just a number in core banking system).

Agreed on most of the points above. Again, our fundamental understanding of FI/RE is different. In fact, all these happened since old day without such glamour word FI/RE.
Old saying would be a person change his career path in mid-life from corporate white colar to book writer/voluntary or hawker char kway teow.  Points 4-8 is archive by leaving their 9-5 corporate dayjob with solid financial as backup.
In fact, I would says FI/RE is more archivable nowaday due to capatilism, and ease of access to various investment vehicle, knowledge & information aside from self awakening and determination.

*
thumbup.gif

Again thanks for the link that “inspire” my economic hypothesis laugh.gif
NightHeart
post Sep 10 2018, 04:09 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,991 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
Macro economics = seeing things in a very big picture.

If more & more people are being miser or "living frugal", generally the economy will go bearish as majority population are holding onto their hard earned money. Money is something that's meant to be passed around, hence the term "currency". The more it moves, the economy will grow. Government implements either expansionary or contractionary fiscal policies to drive up to or lower down the economic growth.

Ultimately the FIRE trend will burn back at the same people who practices it if more & more people follow suit, making it a trend until it affects the macro-economy. Lesser spending leads to lesser economic growth. Lesser economic growth leads to possible deflation or worse; stagflation. Then investors gain lesser & lesser from their investments, pushing their FIRE goals further & further. In the worse case scenario, investing yields nothing & saving loses its value every minute.

FIRE is only ideal in a bullish economy. Where majority of the people are spending & actively contributing to the economy. That's when lotsa bank/govt borrowing is happening, driving up cost of funds & pushing up the market's ROI rates. When the ROI is high, investors' portfolio flourish as well.

So the whole concept of FIRE or the number of FIRE people are kept in balance by the market forces. When too many people jumped on the FIRE bandwagon, the economy goes bearish. Hence, pushing people's FIRE goals further or forcing FIREd people back into the workforce - essentially reducing the number of FIRE people.
aspartame
post Sep 10 2018, 04:12 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:54 PM)
And the root cause of their problem is their disliking of the job. RE is just a get around. Not the true solution

If they have a job they are passionate about, they won’t retire at all  biggrin.gif

All in all, what I want to say is FI is a good thing. But RE is a bad thing, both personal or society/economy as a whole
*
I don't think that there are jobs that people can remain passionate about their whole life. Certainly, not enough people are having such jobs. I don't think such "dream jobs" exist often enough. I also think FI is definitely a good thing. However, I dun think RE is necessarily a bad thing. In fact, personally to me, RE is a good thing. If one needs to stay in a job to kill time or to remain "productive" in the eyes of society, that in itself is quite pathetic. Of course, if one personally derives lots of pleasure in continuing to work even after achieving FI, then, by all means, go ahead. But there is no one size fits all..
aspartame
post Sep 10 2018, 04:17 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,165 posts

Joined: Feb 2015
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Sep 10 2018, 04:09 PM)
Macro economics = seeing things in a very big picture.

If more & more people are being miser or "living frugal", generally the economy will go bearish as majority population are holding onto their hard earned money. Money is something that's meant to be passed around, hence the term "currency". The more it moves, the economy will grow. Government implements either expansionary or contractionary fiscal policies to drive up to or lower down the economic growth.

Ultimately the FIRE trend will burn back at the same people who practices it if more & more people follow suit, making it a trend until it affects the macro-economy. Lesser spending leads to lesser economic growth. Lesser economic growth leads to possible deflation or worse; stagflation. Then investors gain lesser & lesser from their investments, pushing their FIRE goals further & further. In the worse case scenario, investing yields nothing & saving loses its value every minute.

FIRE is only ideal in a bullish economy. Where majority of the people are spending & actively contributing to the economy. That's when lotsa bank/govt borrowing is happening, driving up cost of funds & pushing up the market's ROI rates. When the ROI is high, investors' portfolio flourish as well. 

So the whole concept of FIRE or the number of FIRE people are kept in balance by the market forces. When too many people jumped on the FIRE bandwagon, the economy goes bearish. Hence, pushing people's FIRE goals further or forcing FIREd people back into the workforce - essentially reducing the number of FIRE people.
*
In a way, we never have to fret that enough people will FIRE to tank the economy. Economies will balance on its own. If enough people are on the path to FIRE and thus shrinking the economy, returns will be low and hence those who are borderline FIRE will be forced back into the workforce because their passive income can no longer sustain them.
sky18
post Sep 10 2018, 04:55 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:57 PM)
thumbup.gif

Again thanks for the link that “inspire” my economic hypothesis  laugh.gif
*
LOL.... I originally intent to 'inspire' our extreme frugal young friends.

After all, it's kinda like we can't says certain religion is bad... the core problem is ppl take it to extreme with their bias belief.

FI/RE just another lifestyle system within capitalism. Cant simply judge such capitalism lifestyle is pure good or absolute bad.

Impremenant, its not realistic to expect human mind stay same as one perspectives get evolves. And its natural progression ppl opt for FI/RE due to its more accessible now.

tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 06:51 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:29 PM)
Depends on country. In Malaysia, 55 is the official retirement age. So, any age earlier that that is early

For Australia, I think it was 67 ?

No, I am not saying the whole world have a single number. It depends on the official age of the country
Because those with FIRE mindset try very hard not to work another day if they could. They have no passion to work. Working is just for money.

Jack Ma on the other hand is a visionary. He is ambitious. He created new way of life and changed a new world.

Any proponent of FIRE here has Jack Ma’s ambition ? I don’t think so.
I am referring to my analogy of smoking vs RE.

You said that smoking is selfish in front of children.

So, when a person retires, he retires and live in a society. It will affect people around you. Unless you can retire and live in the mountain alone, then my hypothesis does not stand
*
Law on Retirement Age in Malaysia. The Minimum Retirement Age Act 2012 (MRA Act) came into effect on 01.07.2013, stating that the minimum retirement age of an employee shall be the age of 60 years old. The MRA Act applies to all employers and employees in the private sector throughout Malaysia.

"Financial independence typically means having enough income to pay your living expenses for the rest of your life without having to work full time. Some people achieve this through saving and investing over many years, while others build successful businesses that can generate income without daily supervision"

which part of the FIRE mean the person who chose to retire will be a financial burden?

You keep talking about aging population, now tell me what is the co-relation between aging population and person who chose to retire early? A person at 40-45 can chose to retire early but he still can contributes to economy via other mean.

"Population ageing is an increasing median age in the population of a region due to declining fertility rates and/or rising life expectancy."

Your hypothesiss is merely a limited guess with limited fact. How do you know a person who retire early will not work on another area that he/she prefer? I have seen people who retire early but they want to dedicate them self to charity ngo, mission, religion outreach, and etc. so are you saying all people who chose to retire early will stay at home and wait till they die? By the way, do you know those chose to retire early because their financial situation allow them to do so and they are still continue to spend money and they amount of money they spend have got multiplier effect in the economy? Just because they might not contribute to tax but doesn't mean they don't spend money in the economy chain.

I believed you and I do not know whether Jack Ma chose to retire early or not. Well according to the article, he choose to retire at 54 and prefer to spend more time in education. so are you saying he is a useless person now?

What make you think a person retires and he will affect people around them? He still can continue to spend money (if he financial permitted, if not I don't think he want to retire early)

I said smoking in front of children is selfish but if the area is allow to smoke so what is so selfish?

This post has been edited by tippman: Sep 10 2018, 06:55 PM
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 06:58 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:54 PM)
And the root cause of their problem is their disliking of the job. RE is just a get around. Not the true solution

If they have a job they are passionate about, they won’t retire at all  biggrin.gif

All in all, what I want to say is FI is a good thing. But RE is a bad thing, both personal or society/economy as a whole
*
No you do not have facts to back up that person who chose to retire early because they are not passionate about the job. A businessman can chose to retire early because the business is self sustain and he is manage to look for a partner that running the whole business for him while he continue to receive passive income from the dividend that the business generate.


Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 07:46 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(NightHeart @ Sep 10 2018, 04:09 PM)
Macro economics = seeing things in a very big picture.

If more & more people are being miser or "living frugal", generally the economy will go bearish as majority population are holding onto their hard earned money. Money is something that's meant to be passed around, hence the term "currency". The more it moves, the economy will grow. Government implements either expansionary or contractionary fiscal policies to drive up to or lower down the economic growth.

Ultimately the FIRE trend will burn back at the same people who practices it if more & more people follow suit, making it a trend until it affects the macro-economy. Lesser spending leads to lesser economic growth. Lesser economic growth leads to possible deflation or worse; stagflation. Then investors gain lesser & lesser from their investments, pushing their FIRE goals further & further. In the worse case scenario, investing yields nothing & saving loses its value every minute.

FIRE is only ideal in a bullish economy. Where majority of the people are spending & actively contributing to the economy. That's when lotsa bank/govt borrowing is happening, driving up cost of funds & pushing up the market's ROI rates. When the ROI is high, investors' portfolio flourish as well. 

So the whole concept of FIRE or the number of FIRE people are kept in balance by the market forces. When too many people jumped on the FIRE bandwagon, the economy goes bearish. Hence, pushing people's FIRE goals further or forcing FIREd people back into the workforce - essentially reducing the number of FIRE people.
*
Very good explanation thumbup.gif
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 07:57 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 06:51 PM)


which part of the FIRE mean the person who chose to retire will be a financial burden?
My hypothesis has already clearly stated and answered your question.


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 06:51 PM)
You keep talking about aging population, now tell me what is the co-relation between aging population and person who chose to retire early? A person at 40-45 can chose to retire early but he still can contributes to economy via other mean.

"Population ageing is an increasing median age in the population of a region due to declining fertility rates and/or rising life expectancy."
AS I said, googled Japan population aging problem.


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 06:51 PM)
Your hypothesiss is merely a limited guess with limited fact. How do you know a person who retire early will not work on another area that he/she prefer? I have seen people who retire early but they want to dedicate them self to charity ngo, mission, religion outreach, and etc. so are you saying all people who chose to retire early will stay at home and wait till they die? By the way, do you know those chose to retire early because their financial situation allow them to do so and they are still continue to spend money and they amount of money they spend have got multiplier effect in the economy? Just because they might not contribute to tax but doesn't mean they don't spend money in the economy chain.
Looks like you don't understan what "hypothesis" means. Yes, you are right, it is a guess biggrin.gif


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 06:51 PM)
I believed you and I do not know whether Jack Ma chose to retire early or not. Well according to the article, he choose to retire at 54 and prefer to spend more time in education. so are you saying he is a useless person now?
I never used the word "useless". I used the word "selfish" for people who retire early, according to my hypothesis

Jack Ma retires close to official retirement age. So he is not selfish

QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 06:51 PM)
What make you think a person retires and he will affect people around them? He still can continue to spend money (if he financial permitted, if not I don't think he want to retire early)
Read back my hypothesis. My hypothesis has already clearly stated and answered your question.

QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 06:51 PM)
I said smoking in front of children is selfish but if the area is allow to smoke so what is so selfish?
*
It's an analogy for my hypothesis. According to my hypothesis, yes, smoking in public is selfish, even if the area legally permits smoking. Same goes for RE, there is no law to say it is illegal
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 07:59 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 06:58 PM)
No you do not have facts to back up that person who chose to retire early because they are not passionate about the job. A businessman can chose to retire early because the business is self sustain and he is manage to look for a partner that running the whole business for him while he continue to receive passive income from the dividend that the business generate.
*
Oh....I now know you don't understand what a "hypothesis" means....

Before my hypothesis raise your blood pressure further, do google and understand what a hypothesis mean biggrin.gif
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 08:15 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 07:59 PM)
Oh....I now know you don't understand what a "hypothesis" means....

Before my hypothesis raise your blood pressure further, do google and understand what a hypothesis mean  biggrin.gif
*
You can have your own hypothesis but I don’t think it is right to call those who want to retire earlly selfish like you said you are not anyone to judge whether people are selfish or not.

Your hypothesis is a guess so what make you think you have the right to said people is selfish?
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 08:18 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 07:59 PM)
Oh....I now know you don't understand what a "hypothesis" means....

Before my hypothesis raise your blood pressure further, do google and understand what a hypothesis mean  biggrin.gif
*
Again you are assuming and you make your judgement based on your so call hypothesis.

Are you saying no one can chose not to agree with your hypothesis? You mean everyone in this thread hve to agree to your hypothesis?
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 08:22 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 08:15 PM)
You can have your own hypothesis but I don’t think it is right to call those who want to retire earlly selfish like you said you are not anyone to judge whether people are selfish or not.

Your hypothesis is a guess so what make you think you have the right to said people is selfish?
*
You still don't understand what a hypothesis means.

I think out of everyone who reply to my comments, only you take a hypothesis so personal and bring out the "right" issue biggrin.gif

All other forummers are cool with my hyphothesis and we discussed the hypothesis in a calm and matured manner.
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 08:25 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 08:18 PM)
Again you are assuming and you make your judgement based on your so call hypothesis.

Are you saying no one can chose not to agree with your hypothesis? You mean everyone in this thread hve to agree to your hypothesis?
*
You start to sound immature....

I am not pointing a gun to anyone to agree with me. And I have in the beginning already highlighted it was a "hypothesis"

Of course anyone can disagree with me. Many do openly disagree with me if you read their comments doh.gif
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 08:25 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 07:57 PM)
My hypothesis has already clearly stated and answered your question.
AS I said, googled Japan population aging problem.
Looks like you don't understan what "hypothesis" means. Yes, you are right, it is a guess  biggrin.gif  
I never used the word "useless". I used the word "selfish" for people who retire early, according to my hypothesis

Jack Ma retires close to official retirement age. So he is not selfish
Read back my hypothesis. My hypothesis has already clearly stated and answered your question.
It's an analogy for my hypothesis. According to my hypothesis, yes, smoking in public is selfish, even if the area legally permits smoking. Same goes for RE, there is no law to say it is illegal
*
I am seriously think you don’t understand what is the meaning of aging population and person who chose to retire early.

My question to you is are you saying a person who choose to retire early it mean he don’t contribute to the economy via money multiplier effect?

You are fixated to you so called hypothesis but when one ask you to provide some facts to back up your hypothesis and yet you choose not to answer.

Hypothesis is a guess so do not called people who chose to retire early selfish based on your so called guess.

You can put your guesses in the thread but please try to refrain imposing your ideology of selfish to everyone.

This post has been edited by tippman: Sep 10 2018, 08:30 PM
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 08:27 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 08:25 PM)
I am seriously think you don’t understand what is the meaning of aging population and person who chose to retire early.

My question to you is are you saying a person who choose to retire early it mean he don’t contribute to the economy via money multiplier effect?

You are fixated to you so called hypothesis but when one ask you to provide some facts to back up your hypothesis and yet you choose not to answer.

Hypothesis is a guess so do not called people who chose to retire early selfish based on your so called guess.

You can put your guesses in the thread but please try to refrain imposing your ideology of selfish to everyone.
*
All I can say is doh.gif doh.gif doh.gif
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 08:29 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 08:25 PM)
You start to sound immature....

I am not pointing a gun to anyone to agree with me. And I have in the beginning already highlighted it was a "hypothesis"

Of course anyone can disagree with me. Many do openly disagree with me if you read their comments  doh.gif
*
I do read their comment and I am merely replying to your so call hypothesis.

I do believed your hypothesis is quite immature as well
tippman
post Sep 10 2018, 08:34 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 08:27 PM)
All I can say is  doh.gif  doh.gif  doh.gif
*
Just like you said, you expect people not to agree with your hypothesis and I do believed you can accept my comment about why I am not agreeing with your hypothesis
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 08:44 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(aspartame @ Sep 10 2018, 04:12 PM)
I don't think that there are jobs that people can remain passionate about their whole life. Certainly, not enough people are having such jobs. I don't think such "dream jobs" exist often enough. I also think FI is definitely a good thing. However, I dun think RE is necessarily a bad thing. In fact, personally to me, RE is a good thing. If one needs to stay in a job to kill time or to remain "productive" in the eyes of society, that in itself is quite pathetic. Of course, if one personally derives lots of pleasure in continuing to work even after achieving FI, then, by all means, go ahead. But there is no one size fits all..
*
It is sad that not everyone can be passionate about their job. But if we are flexible, maybe we can find jobs which are at least "not dragging their feet".

I think job satisfaction sums everything up about and ideal job.

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 10 2018, 08:51 PM
Showtime747
post Sep 10 2018, 08:49 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 10 2018, 04:55 PM)
LOL.... I originally intent to 'inspire' our extreme frugal young friends.

After all, it's kinda like we can't says certain religion is bad... the core problem is ppl take it to extreme with their bias belief.

FI/RE just another lifestyle system within capitalism. Cant simply judge such capitalism lifestyle is pure good or absolute bad.

Impremenant, its not realistic to expect human mind stay same as one perspectives get evolves. And its natural progression ppl opt for FI/RE due to its more accessible now.
*
Bro ramjade has his own way of life biggrin.gif

His choice which I guess is due to upbringing, and I respect that. I for one, can't live like him...

For any investment, if you want to know how to minimise the cost, he is the best person to ask. And he is always willing to share thumbup.gif
sky18
post Sep 10 2018, 09:16 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 10 2018, 08:34 PM)
Just like you said, you expect people not to agree with your hypothesis and I do believed you can accept my comment about why I am not agreeing with your hypothesis
*
Be cool. Everyone have their own perspective. U can't forced other take yours as good. brows.gif

I'm on the "support" clan but still respect Showtime747 views which generally "bias" against FI/RE. smile.gif


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 08:49 PM)
Bro ramjade has his own way of life  biggrin.gif

His choice which I guess is due to upbringing, and I respect that. I for one, can't live like him...

For any investment, if you want to know how to minimise the cost, he is the best person to ask. And he is always willing to share  thumbup.gif
*
He is a potential youngster to become millionaire / multi-millionaire by 40. Just wish him all the best as his "extreme" would probably harder for him get into relationship nowaday.






ChessRook
post Sep 11 2018, 01:59 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
375 posts

Joined: Mar 2018
This FiRe is very personal. Depends on how one defines Fi and Re, each could end up a different and yet still reasonable answer.

For myself, I have two daughters, and a wife who likes to spend. So i have much given up on the Re part. I am planning to retire at about 67-70 depending on the financial and medical situation of the family. I am very happy with my job and i am not sure what I want to do full time. Maybe volunteering? Or scale back my current job into part time? All these questions can only be answered by myself.

For Fi, I have paid all my debts and have some money for emergency funds and long term investments. Does this meet the definition of FI? I still need to work to support my 3 dependents. If i am only single, i can Re pretty much in 4-5 more years of working.

I believe the FiRe question depends on the situation, priority and personal choices. Not many people can do FiRe nor should they.
tippman
post Sep 11 2018, 02:02 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(ChessRook @ Sep 11 2018, 01:59 PM)
This FiRe is very personal. Depends on how one defines Fi and Re, each could end up a different and yet still reasonable answer.

For myself, I have two daughters, and a wife who likes to spend. So i have much given up on the Re part. I am planning to retire at about 67-70 depending on the financial and medical situation of the family. I am very happy with my job and i am not sure what I want to do full time. Maybe volunteering? Or scale back my current job into part time? All these questions can only be answered by myself.

For Fi, I have paid all my debts and have some money for emergency funds and long term investments. Does this meet the definition of FI? I still need to work to support my 3 dependents. If i am only single, i can Re pretty much in 4-5 more years of working.

I believe the FiRe question depends on the situation, priority and personal choices. Not many people can do FiRe nor should they.
*
Nice to have all the debts pay off. Does your company allow you to continue working after retirement age? (60 for Malaysia) I assume you are working in Malaysia.


ChessRook
post Sep 11 2018, 02:05 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
375 posts

Joined: Mar 2018
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 11 2018, 02:02 PM)
Nice to have all the debts pay off. Does your company allow you to continue working after retirement age? (60 for Malaysia) I assume you are working in Malaysia.
*
It is by contract for 1-3 years. Contract renewal subject to performance whatever that means
tippman
post Sep 11 2018, 02:21 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(ChessRook @ Sep 11 2018, 02:05 PM)
It is by contract for 1-3 years. Contract renewal subject to performance whatever that means
*
Thanks for the update.
cherroy
post Sep 11 2018, 04:26 PM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(ChessRook @ Sep 11 2018, 01:59 PM)
This FiRe is very personal. Depends on how one defines Fi and Re, each could end up a different and yet still reasonable answer.

For myself, I have two daughters, and a wife who likes to spend. So i have much given up on the Re part. I am planning to retire at about 67-70 depending on the financial and medical situation of the family. I am very happy with my job and i am not sure what I want to do full time. Maybe volunteering? Or scale back my current job into part time? All these questions can only be answered by myself.

For Fi, I have paid all my debts and have some money for emergency funds and long term investments. Does this meet the definition of FI? I still need to work to support my 3 dependents. If i am only single, i can Re pretty much in 4-5 more years of working.

I believe the FiRe question depends on the situation, priority and personal choices. Not many people can do FiRe nor should they.
*
FI /= debt paid off.

FI = There is stream of passive income that can sustain your monthly/yearly expenses.
Showtime747
post Sep 11 2018, 07:46 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 10 2018, 09:16 PM)

I'm on the "support" clan but still respect Showtime747 views which generally "bias" against FI/RE. smile.gif

*
Oh.....I support FI, but not RE.... biggrin.gif

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 11 2018, 09:27 PM
tippman
post Sep 11 2018, 08:10 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 11 2018, 07:46 PM)
Oh.....I support FI, but not RE.... biggrin.gif

I think the main reasons people set their mind to RE is plain simple --> they don't like their job.

There are many studies on the reasons, like :
https://www.forbes.com/sites/lizryan/2016/1...s/#1ad0cbb21ed9
Some are personal problems
https://www.2knowmyself.com/Why_some_people...nt_like_to_work
Many who set an early retirement target can relate one of more of the above to their job environment/personalities ?

At 40 years old, a worker is at his prime. He makes the most money at this age. He should be a senior already and well respected by the subordinates. He can contribute back to the company/society/economy/country. So much he can do.

Those who said after RE they have more time for family/charity/health/thing I like to do, are just giving excuses for failure in good time management. Those 4 things cannot be neglected at any age. They should learn how to improve on their time management instead.
*
Like some one quoted he work 12 hrs a days and how can he managed his time for other stuff?

Can you show me your opinion if a person who would want to do volunteer work I.e working in animal shelter or old folks home, how much time he/she should have for his volunteer work? If he volunteer as a cook in orphanages Home and do you think, the employer can allow him to go off to cook every day before finishing work?

If a person is a volunteer rescue worker, can you tell me can the employer allow him to be absent from works for more than a month if there is some major disasters?

I think this thread is for people who share ideas on how to be Financial independent/freedom and if they want they can choose to retire early and if you are so dead against it then you might want to start off another thread on why people don’t like to work.

Do you think everyone is lucky enough to find a job that he/she is passionate about?

Showtime747
post Sep 11 2018, 09:41 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 11 2018, 08:10 PM)


I think this thread is for people who share ideas on how to be Financial independent/freedom and if they want they can choose to retire early and if you are so dead against it then you might want to start off another thread on why people don’t like to work.


*
If you cannot accept alternative opinion, and respect the opinion of others, it may be better you don't join any forum discussion.

By your logic, every thread in LYN forum must not be disputed. Those with alternative opinion have to take the trouble to open another thread

So far, only you are so fired up towards my opinion. Other readers seems ok and I enjoyed the matured discussion with them.

Ok ok.....to reduce your blood pressure, I put spoiler hope that would be of help to you biggrin.gif
coca^cola
post Sep 11 2018, 09:44 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
327 posts

Joined: Oct 2007


Sorry

This post has been edited by coca^cola: Sep 11 2018, 09:47 PM
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 06:41 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 11 2018, 09:41 PM)
If you cannot accept alternative opinion, and respect the opinion of others, it may be better you don't join any forum discussion.

By your logic, every thread in LYN forum must not be disputed. Those with alternative opinion have to take the trouble to open another thread

So far, only you are so fired up towards my opinion. Other readers seems ok and I enjoyed the matured discussion with them.

Ok ok.....to reduce your blood pressure, I put spoiler hope that would be of help to you   biggrin.gif
*
When the thread is all about discussing how to be financial independent/freedom and/or retire early and you are calling those who want to retire early selfish and putting all this negative vibe to everyone. I don't think this is call discussion. You called your point as hypothesis and hide under the name of "hypothesis" when some one ask you for facts to back up your point. Alternative opinion means you voice out your opinion and let people to decide not calling people selfish just because they think otherwise

Like I said before, every human have their own preference to life how they want to live (as long as it doesn't breach the law" so who are we to judge others?

Let me put some question to you, (you have not answer me this before) you talk about managing time while working full time and a person want to contribute themselves to charity work/volunteer and etc.

1. A person who works 12-14 hrs a day, how he spare time to do what he is passionate about?

2. If a person is a volunteer rescue worker and he has to be away from his job for a month for rescue work, do you think employer will allow him to do that?

3. If a person is a chef in a orphanage home and do you think the employer will allow him/her to go off early every day to cook/prepare meal for the under privileged?

When I ask few simple question, you refuse to answer and question about others why so fired up? and hide under the so called "hypothesis"?

QUOTE
Early retirement isn't about how wealthy you are, say several early retirees.
For many early retirees, the value of life during early retirement is priceless  — the happiness it brings doesn't depend on the dollar.
Instead, early retirement is about two things: time and lifestyle.
When it comes to early retirement, there's no discounting the importance of having enough money saved to retire early, but many early retirees will tell you the truth: money doesn't really matter once you get there.

Brandon of the blog Mad Fientist, who retired at age 34, previously told Business Insider he wishes he knew how "unimportant and insignificant" money would be after retiring early.

"I always thought that I would spend my early retirement doing entrepreneurial things, but now that I have enough money, doing things for the sole purpose of getting more money doesn't make sense anymore," Brandon said. "Money has been the primary motivator for my entire adult life, but now that I have enough, I've had to find new sources of motivation."

Money is so unimportant to early retirees that in hindsight, many said they wish they didn't wait so long to retire early, even if they didn't have as much money saved as they would have liked. For them, you can't put a price on the value of early retirement.

Consider John from ESI Money: after a few calculations, he realized that by retiring at 52 instead of the official retirement age of 65, he gave up $3.1 million in earnings.

But to him, it was the best $3.1 million he ever spent, for several reasons: it wouldn't have changed his lifestyle, he probably added a few extra years to his life by escaping the stress of work, and he found early retirement way more enjoyable than working.

"Imagine 13 years of life enjoyment in retirement versus 13 years of life enjoyment if I remained working — especially in the last 13 years of my career," he wrote. "What is that life enjoyment worth?"

'Money is infinite, but time is not'
The enjoyment John speaks of doesn't depend on a dollar, but instead on two other factors — time and lifestyle.

Grant Sabatier, who retired at age 30 with $1.25 million and runs the blog Millennial Money, has said financial independence has always been about time, not money. "If you view money as the goal, then you miss the point," he wrote in a post published on Business Insider. "Money is infinite, but time is not."

He explained that time becomes more valuable as we age because we have less of it left — but the concept doesn't frequently align with people's perspectives on valuing their own time or how they think about money in their lives.

"To me, early retirement simply meant having enough money so that I didn't have to worry about money and could finally follow my passions and find new passions," Sabatier wrote on Business Insider.

In addition to time, early retirement is also about your lifestyle, according to blogger Mr. Crazy Kicks, who retired at age 34. In fact, he says, an early retirement lifestyle is something you should develop while preparing to retire early.

"Instead of living in a cardboard box eating ramen to save money, one should pursue financial independence by honing a lifestyle that is based on living well for less," he wrote in a post previously published on Business Insider. "The goal is to continuously cut excess spending while building your own early retirement lifestyle that doesn't depend on tons of cash for happiness."

The key, he says, is maximizing happiness per dollar — put your money where your heart is, but get the most bang for your buck.

As Sabatier puts it, "Money only matters if it helps you live a life you love."


https://sg.news.yahoo.com/people-retire-ear...-141800426.html

MONEY IS INFINITE, BUT TIME IS NOT.

QUOTE
Most people retire during their 60s. To retire earlier than that requires planning, discipline and paying close attention to your savings and investments. But the sacrifices and extra effort are worth the trouble. Early retirement planning makes you rethink what brings you happiness and life satisfaction outside of your career and improves your financial footing. Here are eight reasons to pursue early retirement:

Address the future today. Many Americans are unprepared for retirement and may need to continue working during their 60s and beyond. A primary reason for being unprepared is a lack of planning and saving in their younger years. By setting a goal to retire early, you begin to analyze your finances and design and implement a plan to get there. The sooner you begin planning and making serious efforts to secure your retirement future, the greater your chances of achieving it. Analyzing your current financial situation and creating a plan is good at any stage of your life, but preparing for retirement gets more difficult the longer you wait to start saving.

[Read: 5 Challenges of Early Retirement.]

Increase income. Once you decide on an early retirement goal, you’ll quickly realize there’s a good chance you won’t be able to do it without spending sacrifices or extra income. Sacrifices are hard to adjust to, so many people prefer to accelerate their retirement savings. Planning for early retirement motivates workers to excel at their current job to receive promotions and raises. Some savers also seek out ways to earn money beyond their primary source of income. Extra income ideas can include a second job, side business or real estate investing.

Circumstances may require you to retire early. Not everybody retires in their desired fashion. At some point, you may not be able to work. However, when you prepare your life and finances to be able to retire early, you’ll also be better off in the case that you are forced to retire early. For example, during the recession in 2008, some older workers retired due to job loss and difficulty finding work in a pool of younger workers. Health ailments can also sideline a career, especially for workers in professions that require physical activity. Pursuing early retirement can reduce the hardship if your working years are cut short for reasons outside of your control.


Improve your relationships. Early retirees have more opportunities to spend time with people they care about. By achieving early retirement status, social activities can become priorities in your life instead of a slice of your calendar. Your spouse and family will also benefit from the added time you have to enjoy each other’s company. That’s not to say you can’t have strong relationships while you work full-time, but early retirement gives you more time to dedicate to family members. Another benefit is the ability to be available to friends and family who need help. Freedom from work requirements allows you to serve others in need, which is far more gratifying than writing status reports.

[Read: The New Target Retirement Age: 66.]

Travel. Vacations from work are rarely long enough. Travel is best when it’s unrestricted by time. Early retirement allows for extended travel, which is difficult to schedule when you’re employed full-time. It also helps to prevent age from being a limiting factor in your travel decisions. Plan a month or two in an intriguing city, volunteer in a recent disaster region or travel by land through multiple countries. When your time allotments are less restricted, the opportunities to explore are more abundant. Extended visits will make you appreciate each destination more thoroughly than a quick tour stop.

Prioritize your health. Commuting, work travel and firm time commitments are consequences of a full-time career. When you’re working full-time, exercise tends to be secondary to the rest of your daily responsibilities. Sitting most of the day in a chair is inherently unhealthy, while the constant temptation of office treats is a detriment to healthy eating decisions. Good health is perhaps our most important asset. When you retire early, you can prioritize your health while you’re still relatively young, allowing you to improve your overall well-being and potentially extend your longevity.

Lower consumption and spending. One of the most effective strategies for retiring early is lowering your annual cost of living. A lower cost of living requires a smaller retirement nest egg, enabling you to stop full-time work earlier. A secondary benefit of reducing your costs is becoming more conscious of your consumption and spending decisions. Smarter consumption habits are better for your pocketbook and reduce your global footprint.


https://money.usnews.com/money/blogs/on-ret...arly-retirement

This post has been edited by tippman: Sep 12 2018, 06:46 AM
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 06:54 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 10 2018, 03:29 PM)
Depends on country. In Malaysia, 55 is the official retirement age. So, any age earlier that that is early

For Australia, I think it was 67 ?

No, I am not saying the whole world have a single number. It depends on the official age of the country
Because those with FIRE mindset try very hard not to work another day if they could. They have no passion to work. Working is just for money.

Jack Ma on the other hand is a visionary. He is ambitious. He created new way of life and changed a new world.

Any proponent of FIRE here has Jack Ma’s ambition ? I don’t think so.
I am referring to my analogy of smoking vs RE.

You said that smoking is selfish in front of children.

So, when a person retires, he retires and live in a society. It will affect people around you. Unless you can retire and live in the mountain alone, then my hypothesis does not stand
*
On your question whether Jack Ma is a visionary and FIRE or not.

QUOTE
The self-made billionaire has also spoken of his dissatisfaction with his busy life and longing to become a teacher once again. He has repeatedly talked about his expected hectic travel schedule, since retiring as chief executive officer of Alibaba, to become executive chairman.

"When I retired from the CEO position, I told the CEO team (in 2013) I should have more time playing golf on the beach.

"But I find, oh my God, spent 870 hours in the air last year, and this year, 1,000 hours," said Mr Ma, in an interview with American talk show host, Charlie Rose at a conference in Detroit in June, 2017.

"The thing is, I don't want to die in my office. I want to die on the beach."

As Alibaba has grown into one of the world's most valuable companies, joining the ranks of Apple, Microsoft and Amazon, Mr Ma has made unlikely remarks about his mixed feelings towards the company he co-founded in 1999.

He famously said his "biggest mistake was I made Alibaba", because of the enormous pressure and responsibility he has had to shoulder to steer the US$420 billion (S$578 billion) company with more than 86,000 employees.

"I was just trying to do a small business and (not) grow that big, take that many responsibilities and get so much trouble.

"Every day is like being as busy as a president, and I don't have any power. I don't have my life," said Mr Ma, at the St Petersburg International Economic Forum in June 2016.

"If I still can have a next life, I will never do a business like this. I will be my own self, I want to enjoy my life," he continued.To head such a tech titan also requires unparalleled political wisdom and calculation, as maintaining a good relationship with the government can be vital to a large company's success in China

Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 07:27 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 06:41 AM)


1. A person who works 12-14 hrs a day, how he spare time to do what he is passionate about?

2. If a person is a volunteer rescue worker and he has to be away from his job for a month for rescue work, do you think employer will allow him to do that?

3. If a person is a chef in a orphanage home and do you think the employer will allow him/her to go off early every day to cook/prepare meal for the under privileged?

When I ask few simple question, you refuse to answer and question about others why so fired up? and hide under the so called "hypothesis"?
https://sg.news.yahoo.com/people-retire-ear...-141800426.html
Good morning ! Glad you still can reply to a post first day of work after a long holiday.

Here are the answers :

1. This is the job problem. Change job. Find something with job/life balance. If malaysia cannot find, go elsewhere. That’s why so many people migrate. Look at our friend Garysydney, his job does not require 12-14 hours day.

2. I am a boss. I have 2 staff who is with chizi. I am very supportive of them. Whenever they apply for leave for their charity work, I encourage them. There are employers who have the same belief. Just because you haven’t seen them doesn’t mean they don’t exist. Look harder if your priority is doing charity work

3. You mistaken a full time and part time charity. When you are still working, choose charity work which is more flexible. If you think there is only full time charity work, that is just an excuse to overlook part time charity work

I don’t answer some of your questions because I felt they are childish. Sorry, no offense....

Many people accepted that a job must consume 100% of their attention. Overtime is a good thing and you are hardworking. That is very wrong. Maybe that is the Asian culture. In other countries, a job is a job. If you need to spend more than your normal working hours to complete your work, that is called inefficient, not hardworking.

From how you wrote, you are trained to fall into the trap of a work slave.

Take a step back, re-evaluate what a job mean to you. Then you will have a different perspective.

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 12 2018, 07:28 AM
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 07:33 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 06:54 AM)
On your question whether Jack Ma is a visionary and FIRE or not.
*
He still work until close to his retirement age.

I salute his unselfishness, despite his “unsatisfaction of his busy life”.

Those who only work until 40 years old is selfish compared to Jack Ma.

He is a good example for my hypothesis thumbup.gif
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 07:42 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 07:33 AM)
He still work until close to his retirement age.

I salute his unselfishness, despite his “unsatisfaction of his busy life”.

Those who only work until 40 years old is selfish compared to Jack Ma.

He is a good example for my hypothesis  thumbup.gif
*
The retirement age in China currently is 60 for men and 55 for female civil servants and 50 for female workers.
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 07:52 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 07:27 AM)
Good morning ! Glad you still can reply to a post first day of work after a long holiday.

Here are the answers :

1. This is the job problem. Change job. Find something with job/life balance. If malaysia cannot find, go elsewhere. That’s why so many people migrate. Look at our friend Garysydney, his job does not require 12-14 hours day.

2. I am a boss. I have 2 staff who is with chizi. I am very supportive of them. Whenever they apply for leave for their charity work, I encourage them. There are employers who have the same belief. Just because you haven’t seen them doesn’t mean they don’t exist. Look harder if your priority is doing charity work

3. You mistaken a full time and part time charity. When you are still working, choose charity work which is more flexible. If you think there is only full time charity work, that is just an excuse to overlook part time charity work

I don’t answer some of your questions because I felt they are childish. Sorry, no offense....

Many people accepted that a job must consume 100% of their attention. Overtime is a good thing and you are hardworking. That is very wrong. Maybe that is the Asian culture. In other countries, a job is a job. If you need to spend more than your normal working hours to complete your work, that is called inefficient, not hardworking.

From how you wrote, you are trained to fall into the trap of a work slave.

Take a step back, re-evaluate what a job mean to you. Then you will have a different perspective.
*
I am glad that you finally answer my question in the early hour of morning.

1. Do you think that is so simple that if it is job problem then just change job? Do you thin it is easy just to migrate if someone can't find job in Malaysia and you expect can be easily migrate to other countries? Show me which countries any Malaysia can just go and get a work permit/PR and start working? From the way you said this, i can assume that you are quite retard and your brain can't really function well. sorry no offence this is my hypothesis.

2.
QUOTE
The Difference Between a Boss and a Leader. Share: A boss manages their employees, while a leader inspires them to innovate, think creatively, and strive for perfection. Every team has a boss, but what people need is a leader who will help them achieve greatness.


My hypothesis a boss doesn't inspires and impose what he think to his employees.

3. Now you are saying full time and part time charity work, so if a person choose to let go his/her full time job and contributes full time to charity, why is this call selfish? You have always mentioned in your previous post that some one must be passionate about his job and now, you are saying In other countries, a job is a job? if what you said a job is a job then why cant a person choose to contributes his time to charity work or something that he is passionate about?

Against that is your hypothesis whether I am a work slave or not. If you look closely at how frequent that I reply your post and almost instantaneous reply, you would realize that your hypothesis about I am work slave is wrong. I can sit in front of my computer to reply your post almost instantly except the hour that I need to sleep and do something that I am passionate about which is unlike somebody still working for a job just a job




tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 08:07 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
Just out of topic

https://www.volarisgroup.com/blog/article/t...ss-and-a-leader
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 08:19 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 07:42 AM)
The retirement age in China currently is 60 for men and 55 for female civil servants and 50 for female workers.
*
Good info.

Jack Ma is very close. Definitely an unselfish contributor to the economy thumbup.gif
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 08:25 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 08:19 AM)
Good info.

Jack Ma is very close. Definitely an unselfish contributor to the economy  thumbup.gif
*
so retirement age 60 and he retired at 54. 6 years is very close?


Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 08:33 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 07:52 AM)
I am glad that you finally answer my question in the early hour of morning.
I am close to 60 y/o. Don't need so much sleep. I wake up quite early.


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 07:52 AM)
1. Do you think that is so simple that if it is job problem then just change job? Do you thin it is easy just to migrate if someone can't find job in Malaysia and you expect can be easily migrate to other countries? Show me which countries any Malaysia can just go and get a work permit/PR and start working? From the way you said this, i can assume that you are quite retard and your brain can't really function well. sorry no offence this is my hypothesis.
When there is a will, there is a way.

Many people has migrated to other countries. If they can do it, why can't you ?

Yes, it is not easy, but it is possible

The highlighted part above is why I don't reply to you, because it is very childish biggrin.gif


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 07:52 AM)
2.

My hypothesis a boss doesn't inspires and impose what he think to his employees. 
A hypotheses must have some argument and backed up with some detailed explanation. Must have enough information to let people understand it.

You don't just write a sentence and make some quotes to form a hypothesis



QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 07:52 AM)
3. Now you are saying full time and part time charity work, so if a person choose to let go his/her full time job and contributes full time to charity, why is this call selfish? You have always mentioned in your previous post that some one must be passionate about his job and now, you are saying In other countries, a job is a job? if what you said a job is a job then why cant a person choose to contributes his time to charity work or something that he is passionate about?
My hypothesis detailed down all the points that conclude RE is a selfish act. To the economy, society and country.

It was very specific.

Of course, some readers would agree and some would disagree. That is why it is called a hypothesis


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 07:52 AM)
Against that is your hypothesis whether I am a work slave or not. If you look closely at how frequent that I reply your post and almost instantaneous reply, you would realize that  your hypothesis about I am work slave is wrong. I can sit in front of my computer to reply your post almost instantly except the hour that I need to sleep and do something that I am passionate about which is unlike somebody still working for a job just a job
*
No, my hypothesis doesn't mention you are a work slave. My hypothesis is vey specific, and it was listed down in point form a few pages back

It was my observation when I see your question that a person has to work for 12-14 hours that I conclude "work slave"

An observation is not a hypothesis

If a person has to work for 12-14 hours a day, in my observation he is a work slave

Your ability to reply to LYN forum during your 12-14 hours work does not matter in my observation, as long as a person needs to work that long hours is not correct. It is an exploitation

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 12 2018, 08:36 AM
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 08:34 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 08:25 AM)
so retirement age 60 and he retired at 54. 6 years is very close?
*
Yes

40 y/o is selfish, according to my hypothesis
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 08:42 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 08:34 AM)
Yes

40 y/o is selfish, according to my hypothesis
*
May I should say you are envy of what other people can achieve and you can't
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 08:49 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 08:33 AM)
I am close to 60 y/o. Don't need so much sleep. I wake up quite early.
When there is a will, there is a way.

Many people has migrated to other countries. If they can do it, why can't you ?

Yes, it is not easy, but it is possible

The highlighted part above is why I don't reply to you, because it is very childish  biggrin.gif
A hypotheses must have some argument and backed up with some detailed explanation. Must have enough information to let people understand it.

You don't just write a sentence and make some quotes to form a hypothesis
My hypothesis detailed down all the points that conclude RE is a selfish act. To the economy, society and country.

It was very specific.

Of course, some readers would agree and some would disagree. That is why it is called a hypothesis
No, my hypothesis doesn't mention you are a work slave. My hypothesis is vey specific, and it was listed down in point form a few pages back

It was my observation when I see your question that a person has to work for 12-14 hours that I conclude "work slave"

An observation is not a hypothesis

If a person has to work for 12-14 hours a day, in my observation he is a work slave

Your ability to reply to LYN forum during your 12-14 hours work does not matter in my observation, as long as a person needs to work that long hours is not correct. It is an exploitation
*
Please do not give me a bullshit about there is a will, there is a way.

Let me ask you, if I want to marry a princess from UK, will I be able to do so? Not I won't be able to because I am not in the same league with those high profile.

I am quite amuse that if you call people childish and yet you are replying to his post and arguing with him on your hypothesis, what should it call you?

Your character just nicely sum it all up in the link that i posted as a boss.

I would like to say again I do not agree with you hypothesis and calling others selfish. Who do you think you have the right to judge? are they your children? or may be your son?

Your observation is wrong and which part of my comment that i said I work 12-14 hrs?


Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 08:54 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 08:42 AM)
May I should say you are envy of what other people can achieve and you can't
*
Now when I think back.... if I were to have the RE mindset in my 20s or 30s, I definitely would not achieve what I achieved today....

That's the reason why I come out with the hypothesis to give the young readers here an alternative view.

When you are set for RE, be prepared to live/achieve below your potential. That is a waste, both for you personally, and for the society/country.

Or course, plan for FI, but don't plan for RE.

Instead of looking at RE, take a step back and evaluate what your job means to you. 9 out of 10, I would say it is your current job which makes you think of RE.


Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 08:58 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 08:49 AM)


Let me ask you, if I want to marry a princess from UK, will I be able to do so? Not I won't be able to because I am not in the same league with those high profile.
Another example why I said your comment is childish. We don't live in a fantasy...


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 08:49 AM)
I would like to say again I do not agree with you hypothesis and calling others selfish. Who do you think you have the right to judge? are they your children? or may be your son?

Your observation is wrong and which part of my comment that i said I work 12-14 hrs?
*
Noted. You are not the only one who disagree with me.

In a forum, I expect disagreement. There is nothing wrong with that. But it seems that everybody must agree to your comment...

That's why I said some of your comment is childish....
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 08:59 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009

[/QUOTE]Baby Boomers have been hitting our official retirement age of 65 for the past few years. Along the way, a funny thing has begun to happen. Less people are actually retiring. The trend started a few years ago and I wouldn’t be surprised if it continues and even accelerates over the next several years.

There are lots of reasons why this is happening. Here are some of the reasons I like.

Baby Boomers can’t afford to retire

We’ve heard a fair amount of this from many different news outlets. For years we’ve read about the terrible savings rates Americans have had. In fact, the national savings rate went below zero for a period of time. As the saying goes, “our actions are now coming home to roost.” Many baby boomers can’t afford to retire so they continue working.

Baby Boomers don’t want to retire

Some of the comments we hear from clients are things like “retire to what”. The idea for many people moving towards and through 65 is why retire; I enjoy what I’m doing now.

Baby Boomers are often the most productive part of a work force. Having them stick around a little longer is a good thing. (At least in my opinion.) With many people looking at a life span of 85 years or longer, twenty years of retirement and playing golf is a long time.

Baby Boomers don’t know what to do next

For some people moving towards 65 retirement is a scary thought. They’ve seen their friends retire and then become a non-person to those they used to work with. Retiring is just plain scary and many Baby Boomers don’t want to deal with things that are scary.

In addition, many people get their identity from who they are at work. For those who retire, that identity just might disappear.[QUOTE]

http://www.stage2planning.com/blog/bid/382...ancial-Planning
Smurfs
post Sep 12 2018, 09:04 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,060 posts

Joined: Feb 2008


QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 08:33 AM)

If a person has to work for 12-14 hours a day, in my observation he is a work slave

*
It depends.

If a person is so passionate about his job, work for 12-14 hours a day proved that he/she found the fulfillment at work, and vice versa.

From what i observed in my company (MNC), quite a number of employee practices the following thinking :

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


- They come on time, leave on time.
- Work as per instructed, won't go extra miles
- Free time ? Lazada / fb / whatsapp
- get average performance appraisal and blame company do not appreciate hard work of employee

The concept is good but t it is often MISUSED . If one is able to concentrate during their working hours, no FB/lazada/whatsapp and such, then come on time and leave on time is consider highly efficient and productive.


tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 09:08 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 08:58 AM)
Another example why I said your comment is childish. We don't live in a fantasy...
Noted. You are not the only one who disagree with me.

In a forum, I expect disagreement. There is nothing wrong with that. But it seems that everybody must agree to your comment...

That's why I said some of your comment is childish....
*
You quoted there is a will there is a way and now you said don't live in a fantasy? so are you saying now " there is a will, there is a way" is selective being apply ?

Against, let me put my question to you, which part of my comment said that I work 12-14 hrs?

Which part of my comment that I expect everybody must agree to my comment? I am merely responding to your comment .

This post has been edited by tippman: Sep 12 2018, 09:10 AM
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 09:13 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Smurfs @ Sep 12 2018, 09:04 AM)
It depends.

If a person is so passionate about his job, work for 12-14 hours a day proved that he/she found the fulfillment at work, and vice versa.

From what i observed in my company (MNC), quite a number of employee practices the following thinking :

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


- They come on time, leave on time.
- Work as per instructed, won't go extra miles
- Free time ? Lazada / fb / whatsapp
- get average performance appraisal and blame company do not appreciate hard work of employee

The concept is good but t it is often MISUSED . If one is able to concentrate during their working hours, no FB/lazada/whatsapp and such, then come on time and leave on time is consider highly efficient and productive.
*
Yes, if a person is passionate about his work, 12-14 hours a day is not a work slave. I used to work from 8am to 3am the next day on a few projects related to national security over many months. Nobody complained in our team, and we were very happy to have the opportunity to work in the project

My post was in reference to bro tippman, where in his example the person has not enough time for other stuff like family/charity etc. That is a slave like in America a few hundred years ago

That MNC you talked about is like an employer of robots. I wonder how the staff still have motivation to work ?



Edit : oopps sorry, I thought the company policy practise that.....it was the employees with that thinking....

Actually, in Australia, many workers have the exact practice. Not much job satisfaction. Work/life balance elevated to another level....

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 12 2018, 09:27 AM
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 09:18 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 09:08 AM)
You quoted there is a will there is a way and now you said don't live in a fantasy? so are you saying now " there is a will, there is a way" is selective being apply ?

Against, let me put my question to you, which part of my comment said that I work 12-14 hrs?

Which part of my comment that I expect everybody must agree to my comment? I am merely responding to your comment .
*
You may not notice, but you use many question marks in your posting. Hence leading to my observation that you like people to agree to your comment.

To put it another way, you are quite insecure when other people's comments contradict that of yours.


tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 09:24 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 08:33 AM)


It was my observation when I see your question that a person has to work for 12-14 hours that I conclude "work slave"

If a person has to work for 12-14 hours a day, in my observation he is a work slave

*
This was quoted by you saying a person has to work for 12-14 hours a day, in your observation he is a work slave and now you are saying

QUOTE
Yes, if a person is passionate about his work, 12-14 hours a day is not a work slave.


Against I put a question mark it is because I would hope that you can have an answer for me. since you quoted your observation and your hypothesis in such a big way.

Like I said I don't like to judge other people and I also do not force others to agree to my comment. I do not agree to you that judging others that who choose how to live their own live, this tick me off.

You can put down your comment about your hypothesis but do you need to call others selfish?

Against, you are Mr. Know it all and you even know that I am insecure person.


tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 09:26 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 09:18 AM)
You may not notice, but you use many question marks in your posting. Hence leading to my observation that you like people to agree to your comment.

To put it another way, you are quite insecure when other people's comments contradict that of yours.
*
A question mark indicates that I would hope that you have facts to back up your comment.

Lots of people think in the virtual world can type any things they want because no one know his true identity but whether all this comment is back up by facts? or just a keyboard warrior trying to put something out in the virtual world and hope to find his own identity?
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 09:34 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 09:26 AM)
A question mark indicates that I would hope that you have facts to back up your comment.
That was my observation. Your disagreement is noted


QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 09:26 AM)
Lots of people think in the virtual world can type any things they want because no one know his true identity but whether all this comment is back up by facts? or just a keyboard warrior trying to put something out in the virtual world and hope to find his own identity?
*
Bro, you are bringing the /k culture here --> no drill GTFO biggrin.gif

Be matured a bit. If you don't agree with me, I am ok.

I am not here to convince everybody to agree with me. I respect disagreement.

Whilst if you see something which you don't agree, your world seems to be collapsing and you must ask enough question to the person to make yourself feel better....
tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 09:47 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 09:34 AM)
That was my observation. Your disagreement is noted
Bro, you are bringing the /k culture here --> no drill GTFO  biggrin.gif

Be matured a bit. If you don't agree with me, I am ok.

I am not here to convince everybody to agree with me. I respect disagreement.

Whilst if you see something which you don't agree, your world seems to be collapsing and you must ask enough question to the person to make yourself feel better....
*
Thanks for your notification. I would hope that you are mature a bit as well. Try not to calling others selfish or whatsoever. remember, every human have their rights to forge his/own path and you can't judge them. Just like some I can't call out all the keyboard warrior as well.

QUOTE
Questions are the best way to gain deeper insights and develop more innovative solutions. So why do so few people utilize them, asks Paul Sloane?
Children learn by asking questions. Students learn by asking questions. New recruits learn by asking questions. Innovators understand client needs by asking questions. It is the simplest and most effective way of learning. People who think that they know it all no longer ask questions – why should they? Brilliant thinkers never stop asking questions because they know that this is the best way to gain deeper insights.

Eric Schmidt, CEO of Google, said, “We run this company on questions, not answers.” He knows that if you keep asking questions you can keep finding better answers.

When Greg Dyke became Director-General of the BBC in 2000 he went to every major location and assembled the staff. They came expecting a long presentation. He simply sat down with them and asked a question, “What is the one thing I should do to make things better for you?” Then he listened. He followed this with another question, “What is the one thing I should do to make things better for our viewers and listeners?” He knew that at that early stage he could learn more from his employees than they could from him. The workers at the BBC had many wonderful ideas that they were keen to share. The fact that the new boss took time to question and then listen earned him enormous respect.

Columbo solves his mysteries by asking many questions; as do all the great detectives – in real life as well as fiction. All the great inventors and scientists asked questions. Isaac Newton asked, “Why does an apple fall from a tree?” and, “Why does the moon not fall into the Earth?” Charles Darwin asked, “Why do the Galapagos islands have so many species not found elsewhere?” Albert Einstein asked, “What would the universe look like if I rode through it on a beam of light?” By asking these kinds of fundamental questions they were able to start the process that lead to their tremendous breakthroughs.

The great philosophers spend their whole lives asking deep questions about the meaning of life, morality, truth and so on. We do not have to be quite so contemplative but we should nonetheless ask the deep questions about the situations we face. It is the best way to get the information we need to make informed decisions and for sales people it is the single most important skill they need to succeed.

Why don’t we ask questions?
If it is obvious that asking questions is such a powerful way of learning why do we stop asking questions? For some people the reason is that they are lazy. They assume they know all the main things they need to know and they do not bother to ask more. They cling to their beliefs and remain certain in their assumptions – yet they often end up looking foolish.

Other people are afraid that by asking questions they will look weak, ignorant or unsure. They like to give the impression that they are decisive and in command of the relevant issues. They fear that asking questions might introduce uncertainty or show them in a poor light. In fact asking questions is a sign of strength and intelligence – not a sign of weakness or uncertainty. Great leaders constantly ask questions and are well aware that they do not have all the answers.

Intelligent questions stimulate, provoke, inform and inspire.

Finally some people are in such a hurry to get with things that they do not stop to ask questions because it might slow them down. They risk rushing headlong into the wrong actions.

With prospect, with clients, at school, at home, in business, with our friends, family, colleagues or managers we can check assumptions and gain a better appreciation of the issues by first asking questions. Start with very basic, broad questions then move to more specific areas to clarify your understanding. Open questions are excellent – they give the other person or people chance to give broad answers and they open up matters. Examples of open questions are:

What business are we really in, what is our added value?
Why do you think this has happened?
What are all the things that might have caused this problem?
How can we reduce customer complaints?
Why do you think he feels that way?
What other possibilities should we consider?
As we listen carefully to the answers we formulate further questions. When someone gives an answer we can often ask, “Why?” The temptation is to plunge in with our opinions, responses, conclusions or proposals. The better approach is keep asking questions to deepen our comprehension of the issues before making up our mind. Once we have mapped out the main points we can use closed questions to get specific information. Closed questions give the respondent a limited choice of responses – often just yes or no. Examples of closed questions are:

When did this happen?
Was he angry?
Where is the shipment right now?
Did you authorise the payment?
Would you like to go to the cinema with me on Saturday evening?
By giving the other person a limited choice of responses we get specific information and deliberately move the conversation forward in a particular direction.

Asking many questions is very effective but it can make you appear to be inquisitorial and intrusive. So it is important to ask questions in a friendly and unthreatening way. Do not ask accusing questions. “What do you think happened?” will probably get a better response than, “Are you responsible for this disaster?” Try to pose each question in an way and ensure that your body language is relaxed and amicable. Do not jab your finger or lean forward as you as put your requests.

Try to practice asking more questions in your everyday conversations. Instead of telling someone something, ask them a question. Intelligent questions stimulate, provoke, inform and inspire. Questions help us to teach as well as to learn.


Does it make you looks weak when somebody ask you question to which you have commented?

I am not boss and I am not mr. knows it all, I am a person who is willing to learn. Thus I ask, I provoke.


Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 09:51 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 12 2018, 09:47 AM)

Does it make you looks weak when somebody ask you question to which you have commented?


*
To me, the way you asked it, yes.
Timberwolf83
post Sep 12 2018, 10:10 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
23 posts

Joined: Aug 2014
Hi All,

sorry to interject, as i do notice there are some disagreements in the forums at the moment, is good there are debates but hope it will come to a healthy discussion ya.
Perhaps let's call it a day?

Need some opinions on investment and creating passive income. I'm a sole breadwinner, wife at the moment is not working taking care of our child. in terms of my monthly commitment, it gotten dangerously close of not able to save enough for our future. i need to find additional sources of income to increase my savings for the future, things wont get cheaper anyway.

Below is my expenses and savings.

Commitments Expenses Contribution
Car Installment (2 cars) (2,000) -18%
Car Maintenance (average months) (300) -3%
House Installment (1,000) -9%
Wife (Full time house wife) (2,000) -18%
Kid (Milk/ Diapers/ Play School) (1,000) -9%
Lifestyle Expenses (Food / Groceries/ Utility bills) (2,000) -18%
Health Insurance / Saving Plans (1,000) -9%

Net Salary (after EPF & Income Tax deduction) 11,000
Monthly Passive Income 1,500
Balance Savings Net 3,200 29%
Bank Savings 250,000

I'm thinking of taking out rm150k to invest, seeking 2-3% monthly returns ( I don't know, if it is plausible to find a investment that have a stable returns of 2-3% on a monthly basis).
This will boost up my savings to 50-55% from 29%.

Any advise?
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 10:25 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Timberwolf83 @ Sep 12 2018, 10:10 AM)
I'm thinking of taking out rm150k to invest, seeking 2-3% monthly returns ( I don't know, if it is plausible to find a investment that have a stable returns of 2-3% on a monthly basis).
This will boost up my savings to 50-55% from 29%.

Any advise?
*
Perhaps your question should post here.... more relevant.. https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4381936/+520

Btw, if you looking for stable return 2-3% on monthly == 24-36% yearly, let me know if you found one rclxs0.gif devil.gif
Timberwolf83
post Sep 12 2018, 10:27 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
23 posts

Joined: Aug 2014
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 10:25 AM)
Perhaps your question should post here.... more relevant..  https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4381936/+520

Btw, if you looking for stable return 2-3% on monthly == 24-36% yearly,  let me know if you found one  rclxs0.gif devil.gif
*
yeah, it is actually quite impossible. Try luck only.
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 11:56 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Showtime747

What's your defination on RE. "Makan, tidur dan main" only once step out from primary job, or one opt out from his profession on other side gig, or take on fulltime/partime non profit charity work, other?

I sense there are gaps on "jobs" == "way to be productive member and benefit society"

Btw, we all had to thank to someone "RE" from his primary job as early as 42 way back at 18th century, and still doing a enormous contribution to the world. smile.gif
https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2018/01/ben...and-reinvention

Another point probably good to contemplate about is official retirement age is vary among country. Is such yeardstick really sound to every single ppl within that country? Or, isn't it sound a bit like personal inflation and country wide CPI inflation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retirement_age

Edit: fix the link

This post has been edited by sky18: Sep 12 2018, 12:07 PM
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 04:14 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 11:56 AM)
Showtime747

What's your defination on RE. "Makan, tidur dan main" only once step out from primary job, or one opt out from his profession on other side gig, or take on fulltime/partime non profit charity work, other?

I sense there are gaps on "jobs" == "way to be productive member and benefit society"
According to my hypothesis,

1. The person who does not contribute to the production of GDP, and become a net consumer of scarce resources of the society

2. The person who does not contribute to tax revenue of the country

3. The person who does not contribute to science progression / production efficiency by passing down his acquired knowledge from previous education and professional experience

4. In addition to that, I would go on to expand on the above 3 criteria to include the person contribute lesser to the production of GDP than before RE, pay lesser tax than before RE and contribute lesser to science progression/production efficiency than before RE

It is not only "makan, tidur dan main"


QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 11:56 AM)
Btw, we all had to thank to someone "RE" from his primary job as early as 42 way back at 18th century, and still doing a enormous contribution to the world. smile.gif
https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2018/01/ben...and-reinvention


*
For Benjamin Franklin, the "retirement at age 42" actually refers to "retirement from his printing business". In today's business term, we would say "exit from printing business and embark on another career". For the next 40 years, he went on to contribute to the field of science and invention, made remarkable contribution to his country for many important role/jobs, and eventually earned his picture on the US$100 bill. A great man in USA history

Should he really have the mindset of RE, the history would have lost such an important figure, and the history would be different.

For the young readers who have the mindset of RE, Benjamin Franklin is yet another example after Jack Ma that you could make great contribution to the society/country if you are not selfish

j.passing.by
post Sep 12 2018, 04:26 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,639 posts

Joined: Nov 2010
QUOTE(j.passing.by @ Sep 9 2018, 10:49 PM)
smile.gif you are right.

To be really FI/RE at a young age of 45 and below, you would need much more if you are married with several children still in school/college.

Those, me inclusive, who were talking about retiring a few years earlier than the mandatory retirement age were talking about retirement in general.

To be really FI/RE, I don't think working part time or having a business that doesn't require your presence all the time counts as 'retirement'.

FI/RE is possible if your spouse is working!
*
On the other hand, you can plan not to have a family and children.

If getting married, marry someone who is financially independence and don’t have to rely on you financially. In fact, this will cut down your housing cost, be it renting or owning, as each of you are booting half the cost.

Being debt free is not really that difficult. The biggest expenses are on houses and cars. So don’t own a house or a car. Rent and use public transport. And Grab is as convenient as having your own car. In fact, you are living the high life with a chauffeur at your beck and call.

Think of all the maintenance costs you can save by not owning a house or car, and not to forget the cost of interest you don’t need to spend on the loans in making these purchases.

How much you need to retire early depends on you. How you want it to be is up to you. There is always a way if you want to do it.

What stopping some people from doing it is also due to personal reasons, like the job has fringe benefits like flying on business class and 5-star hotel stays and it is hard to give them up. Or the job and position comes with ‘power’ and everyone is nice and courteous to you because of the position… the attention and ego fawning which you shall no longer get when you step down.

The major decision on early retirement is still on money. And making this decision is not that difficult as you think… since we can count money while other things as mentioned above is more difficult to analyse.

Do you think you have enough money or do you think you need more? Do you need to be greedy for more and more? Any particular reason you have to live in an expensive place like KL? Would it not be nice to live in a quieter place? Would it not be nicer to move around and staying a few months in different towns and cities?

So how much do you really need?

You can break this money issue into 2 parts, if there is EPF. This is the untouched nest egg that you need to carry you over the final part of your life. Determine how much you need to have in EPF at age 55.

At about 5.5% annual dividend, it would take 13 years of compounding interest to double the initial amount. So work backwards on the initial amount you need to have in EPF. This will set you a figure to target to achieve when you reach the age you want to stop work.

The second part is the shorter term savings you need to have before the supplementary income from EPF kicks in. If the income from EPF is inadequate, then you need to put aside some money for the longer term too.

You might or might not need to let the dividend in EPF compound itself a few more years till age 60 or later before touching it. The main concern here is running out of money before we run out of time. That is the money dries up before we are dead. Living on the dividends and not touching the principal amount ensures this from happening.

And since if the plan is to rent and not own any living space, and if you happen to live till a ripe old age, you will need to ensure that the longer term savings and EPF savings is enough to get you register into a private nursing home for the final years of your life.

If there is a will, there is a way. Go see “Captain Fantastic” for inspiration on living cheaply at low cost. There are parts that you can learn from… but not the part of being so cheap until funeral cost is saved by flushing the wife’s ashes down the toilet!

=========

BTW FI/RE is nothing new. In one of Somerset Maugham’s short stories, there was an Englishman who quit his banking job with enough money to last ten years living cheaply in Spain, and when the time comes to return back to London and work, he found that he could not step back into his former working life… so becomes a homeless drifter living on scraps given by other Brits on vacation.

There was also a blog – years and years ago - by an IT guy on quitting early in his late thirties, who was fortunate to be given shares for being one of the first few employees in a IT start-up, and getting his “drop dead money” when the firm was listed. Quit the city life and bought a ranch or something in Rocky Mountains. Our equivalent would be Sg. Lembing or somewhere more exotic like Laos or Vietnam.


tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 05:21 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 04:14 PM)
According to my hypothesis,

1. The person who does not contribute to the production of GDP, and become a net consumer of scarce resources of the society

2. The person who does not contribute to tax revenue of the country

3. The person who does not contribute to science progression / production efficiency by passing down his acquired knowledge from previous education and professional experience

4. In addition to that, I would go on to expand on the above 3 criteria to include the person contribute lesser to the production of GDP than before RE, pay lesser tax than before RE and contribute lesser to science progression/production efficiency than before RE

It is not only "makan, tidur dan main"
For Benjamin Franklin, the "retirement at age 42" actually refers to "retirement from his printing business". In today's business term, we would say "exit from printing business and embark on another career". For the next 40 years, he went on to contribute to the field of science and invention, made remarkable contribution to his country for many important role/jobs, and eventually earned his picture on the US$100 bill. A great man in USA history

Should he really have the mindset of RE, the history would have lost such an important figure, and the history would be different.

For the young readers who have the mindset of RE, Benjamin Franklin is yet another example after Jack Ma that you could make great contribution to the society/country if you are not selfish
*
QUOTE
The self-made billionaire has also spoken of his dissatisfaction with his busy life and longing to become a teacher once again. He has repeatedly talked about his expected hectic travel schedule, since retiring as chief executive officer of Alibaba, to become executive chairman.

"When I retired from the CEO position, I told the CEO team (in 2013) I should have more time playing golf on the beach.

"But I find, oh my God, spent 870 hours in the air last year, and this year, 1,000 hours," said Mr Ma, in an interview with American talk show host, Charlie Rose at a conference in Detroit in June, 2017.

"The thing is, I don't want to die in my office. I want to die on the beach."

As Alibaba has grown into one of the world's most valuable companies, joining the ranks of Apple, Microsoft and Amazon, Mr Ma has made unlikely remarks about his mixed feelings towards the company he co-founded in 1999.

He famously said his "biggest mistake was I made Alibaba", because of the enormous pressure and responsibility he has had to shoulder to steer the US$420 billion (S$578 billion) company with more than 86,000 employees.

"I was just trying to do a small business and (not) grow that big, take that many responsibilities and get so much trouble.

"Every day is like being as busy as a president, and I don't have any power. I don't have my life," said Mr Ma, at the St Petersburg International Economic Forum in June 2016.

"If I still can have a next life, I will never do a business like this. I will be my own self, I want to enjoy my life," he continued.To head such a tech titan also requires unparalleled political wisdom and calculation, as maintaining a good relationship with the government can be vital to a large company's success in China

cfkoon
post Sep 12 2018, 05:58 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
228 posts

Joined: Oct 2010
FI/RE is not a bad thing, nor it is a bad philosophy in life. Life is more than just work, and if a person is able to find that they have the capability to RE at age 40, it should be nothing short of an achievement for them. It could be a new generation way of thinking, rather than baby boomers whose mentality was to work to retirement at 60. With regard to whether this mentality will hurt the society and economy, this is very ambiguous.

My opinion on RE on how it will hurt the economy is only when and if these people who RE underestimated their financial capability, exited the workforce too early and find out few years down the road that their skills and experience are outdated hence unable to find employment again resulting in the need to depend on the govt to support them.

For those people who want to FI/RE, you should be able to meet a certain criteria :
1) Have certain skills and knowledge within your industry that when you retire, other companies will want to leverage on your experience that they will pay consultation fee, or employ you as a part time consultancy

2) Made certain connections that other companies would want you on their BOD as a non-executive director to manage the due diligence of company management

3) Have a stable recurring private business that no longer require your day-to-day management, e.g. petrol station, 7-eleven (convenience store) branch, fast food branch, laundromat (debatable).

4) Have multiple real estate portfolios (all paid up) that will net you a sizeable rental income. NOTE : if your real estate has a loan, its pointless - only count those with full loan settled, and giving you a net return. Besides real estate, you can also count on other types of investment assets like bonds, shares, REITS with a substantial value (total est , hmmm , maybe RM 5 million and above?).

For those that do not tick these criteria, please forget about FI/RE. The reason? It's because those that have FI/RE envision themself to be able to live a comfortable and stress free life where they can dine and enjoy themselves day to day with no worries on their expenditure - travelling and what not. For those who say they want to RE on a 2k-3k monthly income, may I ask what can you do with your life? In order to live within those means, you will have to live thriftily - you definitely wont be able to enjoy your retirement as you have planned. You will be so conscious with your expenditure that the rest of your retirement life will be drab and boring - then you will realise that actually being in retirement is not that fun.



sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 06:07 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 04:14 PM)
According to my hypothesis,

1. The person who does not contribute to the production of GDP, and become a net consumer of scarce resources of the society

2. The person who does not contribute to tax revenue of the country

3. The person who does not contribute to science progression / production efficiency by passing down his acquired knowledge from previous education and professional experience

4. In addition to that, I would go on to expand on the above 3 criteria to include the person contribute lesser to the production of GDP than before RE, pay lesser tax than before RE and contribute lesser to science progression/production efficiency than before RE

It is not only "makan, tidur dan main"
For Benjamin Franklin, the "retirement at age 42" actually refers to "retirement from his printing business". In today's business term, we would say "exit from printing business and embark on another career". For the next 40 years, he went on to contribute to the field of science and invention, made remarkable contribution to his country for many important role/jobs, and eventually earned his picture on the US$100 bill. A great man in USA history

Should he really have the mindset of RE, the history would have lost such an important figure, and the history would be different.

For the young readers who have the mindset of RE, Benjamin Franklin is yet another example after Jack Ma that you could make great contribution to the society/country if you are not selfish
*
IMHO, selfishness is dependent on the reason for retiring and what one retiring to. RE is neutral and the retirement age is just a relative figure. For example, mr money mustache who RE in early 30+, he managed to inspire many ppl start FI journey and many of them in better financial position today. He actually make more impact and good for society in general compared to stick in 9-5 office job. Isn't it such opputunity occur due to his RE?

Criteria 4 sound odd to me, my interpretation is prior RE, one is contribute tax via both active + passive income, once letting go active income, taxable income definately lesser. Thus, for those who forey into other fields that his/her passionated with much lesser / without additional income, or fulltime charity work, I dont see these group of ppl should marked as selfish.

Again, isn't it Benjamin Franklin retired on his printing (primary job) and working on his own passion at 42. If he failed, he probably just a normal early retiree. If we see from another perspective, isn't it RE is actually a positive move where create opputunity for one maximize their potential? For sure, when he attempt forey into his scientific research, he meet your criteria 4. tongue.gif
The same Benjamin Franklin story, it can have different interpretion is view from another angle.

Probably you could see more interesting discussion from here too... https://www.financialsamurai.com/the-dark-s...-risks-dangers/

AvenueX
post Sep 12 2018, 06:08 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
241 posts

Joined: Sep 2011
QUOTE(cfkoon @ Sep 12 2018, 05:58 PM)
For those who say they want to RE on a 2k-3k monthly income, may I ask what can you do with your life? In order to live within those means, you will have to live thriftily - you definitely wont be able to enjoy your retirement as you have planned. You will be so conscious with your expenditure that the rest of your retirement life will be drab and boring - then you will realise that actually being in retirement is not that fun.
*
With a fully paid up property 3k can live very comfortably la. If no kids and wife smile.gif.
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:07 PM)
IMHO, selfishness is dependent on the reason for retiring and what one retiring to. RE is neutral and the retirement age is just a relative figure. For example, mr money mustache who RE in early 30+, he managed to inspire many ppl start FI journey and many of them in better financial position today. He actually make more impact and good for society in general compared to stick in 9-5 office job. Isn't it such opputunity occur due to his RE?
Yes, Mr Money Mustache maybe made more impact after he retired, and he maybe earns more after he retired than his old 9-5 job biggrin.gif

He is actually using his new "title" (retired and successful) to make more money. Very clever guy !


QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:07 PM)
Criteria 4 sound odd to me, my interpretation is prior RE, one is contribute tax via both active + passive income, once letting go active income, taxable income definately lesser. Thus, for those who forey into other fields that his/her passionated with much lesser / without additional income, or fulltime charity work, I dont see these group of ppl should marked as selfish.
Again, selfish as defined in my hypothesis. They could have contributed more to the economy/society/countries should they decided not to RE. As stated in the hypothesis, if enough people RE, the economy would collapse

Many here do not agree with the hypothesis though.




QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:07 PM)
Again, isn't it Benjamin Franklin retired on his printing (primary job) and working on his own passion at 42. If he failed, he probably just a normal early retiree. If we see from another perspective, isn't it RE is actually a positive move where create opputunity for one maximize their potential? For sure, when he attempt forey into his scientific research, he meet your criteria 4. tongue.gif
The same Benjamin Franklin story, it can have different interpretion is view from another angle.
I don't see Benjamin Franklin as "retiring" at all. He moved on after selling his printing business and eventually his achievement is huge

Maybe I only see the history. If we talk about "what if", our discussion will never end.

So, I stick to history, so happen the history supports my hypothesis



tippman
post Sep 12 2018, 06:53 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM)
Yes, Mr Money Mustache maybe made more impact after he retired, and he maybe earns more after he retired than his old 9-5 job  biggrin.gif

He is actually using his new "title" (retired and successful) to make more money. Very clever guy !
Again, selfish as defined in my hypothesis. They could have contributed more to the economy/society/countries should they decided not to RE. As stated in the hypothesis, if enough people RE, the economy would collapse

Many here do not agree with the hypothesis though.
I don't see Benjamin Franklin as "retiring" at all. He moved on after selling his printing business and eventually his achievement is huge

Maybe I only see the history. If we talk about "what if", our discussion will never end.

So, I stick to history, so happen the history supports my hypothesis
*
I don't think it matter whether you see Benjamin Franklin as retiring or not but lots of article is using him as an example of early retirement.

QUOTE
As an early American entrepreneur, Ben Franklin worked hard to expand a small printing business and set himself up to ‘retire’ at 42. Before reading this fact about the American Founding Father, I didn’t even know ‘early retirement’ was a possibility. In simple terms, early retirement represents more time, and I think we would all agree with Ben when he said, “Lost time is never found again.”


http://thedrunkmillionaire.com/benfranklin/#

QUOTE
When I think of “early retirement,” my first thought goes to Ben Franklin. He essentially blogged (wrote almanacs as they were called in those days) about frugality and having an intense work ethic. He understood that, “lost time is never found again,” and he pursued financial independence to make sure he gained back as much time as possible.

Through building a print shop into a successful business, he was able to retire at the age of 42.

When I read more about Ben Franklin, I wasn’t drawn to the common story many people know about the inventor of the lightning rod or as one  of the Founding Fathers.


http://distilleddollar.com/2016/04/23/ben-...-early-retiree/


howszat
post Sep 12 2018, 08:47 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
This FIRE thing does not make sense for the following reason. The FI bit is always sensible and desirable, but the RE is questionable.

Scenario A: A person works very hard, and saves everything he can, and lives frugally, maybe to the extent of affecting his health if he cuts back on healthy living, eg nutritious food, takes time off to exercise rather than working overtime, etc. After FIRE, ask "now what do I do"? My interpretation = this means being miserable.

Scenario B: A person finds and works at a job he likes, saves what he can comfortably afford, looks after his health (gym or something else, but not overtime), sets his FI at a later date, and continues to do the job he likes after FI. Objective: find a job you like, and you can continue to keep meaningfully occupied rather than achieve this "RE" and then ask now what do I do?

This post has been edited by howszat: Sep 12 2018, 08:50 PM
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 09:06 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM)
Yes, Mr Money Mustache maybe made more impact after he retired, and he maybe earns more after he retired than his old 9-5 job  biggrin.gif
He is actually using his new "title" (retired and successful) to make more money. Very clever guy !

*
Yup. He smart and make ton of money via his blog. Like it or not, it's a something not anticipated during he opt for RE.
Isn't it sometime letting go is open up a new opportunity.

QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM)
Again, selfish as defined in my hypothesis. They could have contributed more to the economy/society/countries should they decided not to RE. As stated in the hypothesis, if enough people RE, the economy would collapse

Many here do not agree with the hypothesis though.
*
LOL. As I always believe, there is absolute black and white; we can't simply mark RE as selfish act without looking at other context. And to me, it's just neutral anywhere and it might open up a new door / opportunity for better.

Btw, if we talk about "what if" enough ppl RE, our discussion will never end. tongue.gif devil.gif

As I stated early, it ain't going to happened as mentioned in earlier post.

QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM)
I don't see Benjamin Franklin as "retiring" at all. He moved on after selling his printing business and eventually his achievement is huge

Maybe I only see the history. If we talk about "what if", our discussion will never end.

So, I stick to history, so happen the history supports my hypothesis
*
Showtime747
post Sep 12 2018, 09:57 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 09:06 PM)
Yup. He smart and make ton of money via his blog. Like it or not, it's a something not anticipated during he opt for RE.
Isn't it sometime letting go is open up a new opportunity.
Yes. That is what an unanticipated career change means.

Look at it another way, he jumped out of the rat race, and found another mountain of cheese (ie. from working --> retirement --> working again). Just that this time he found an ideal job !

I do hope everybody who RE can be as successful as him ! But that is a tall hope I must admit



QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 09:06 PM)
LOL. As I always believe, there is absolute black and white; we can't simply mark RE as selfish act without looking at other context. And to me, it's just neutral anywhere and it might open up a new door / opportunity for better.
A hypothesis remains a hypothesis. With the arguments as set out in the hypothesis, I still think selfishness is a reasonable conclusion for those who RE.

Many may have forgotten the content of the hypothesis. As a refresher, here it is again :

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 09:06 PM)
Btw, if we talk about "what if" enough ppl RE, our discussion will never end. tongue.gif devil.gif 

As I stated early, it ain't going to happened as mentioned in earlier post.
*
Yes, the same holds true when you bring out Mr Money Moustache. How many more Mr Money Moustache can you quote ? biggrin.gif




chonghe
post Sep 12 2018, 10:23 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
853 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


QUOTE(howszat @ Sep 12 2018, 08:47 PM)
This FIRE thing does not make sense for the following reason. The FI bit is always sensible and desirable, but the RE is questionable.

Scenario A: A person works very hard, and saves everything he can, and lives frugally, maybe to the extent of affecting his health if he cuts back on healthy living, eg nutritious food, takes time off to exercise rather than working overtime, etc. After FIRE, ask "now what do I do"? My interpretation = this means being miserable.

Scenario B: A person finds and works at a job he likes, saves what he can comfortably afford, looks after his health (gym or something else, but not overtime), sets his FI at a later date, and continues to do the job he likes after FI. Objective: find a job you like, and you can continue to keep meaningfully occupied rather than achieve this "RE" and then ask now what do I do?
*
Scenario A: this is why balance and moderation is important in achieving FI. Appropriate withdrawals to enjoy life will keep to process rewarding

Scenario B: disagree. One primary reason of FI is security, i.e., we really never knows when a company will sack us and therefore with FI this is no longer a worry. In addition, with FI we have the call of staying in the job over the boss than vice versa - I see this as a very important element because of the following third reason - no need to "see people face", if you know what I mean. Politics is always unavoidable in any institution and I find it tiring. And yeah, with FI we can focus on doing the things that we love to without all these factors coming in.
howszat
post Sep 12 2018, 10:30 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
QUOTE(chonghe @ Sep 12 2018, 10:23 PM)
Scenario A: this is why balance and moderation is important in achieving FI. Appropriate withdrawals to enjoy life will keep to process rewarding

Scenario B: disagree. One primary reason of FI is security, i.e., we really never knows when a company will sack us and therefore with FI this is no longer a worry. In addition, with FI we have the call of staying in the job over the boss than vice versa - I see this as a very important element because of the following third reason - no need to "see people face", if you know what I mean. Politics is always unavoidable in any institution and I find it tiring. And yeah, with FI we can focus on doing the things that we love to without all these factors coming in.
*

Just to repeat my post, I said "The FI bit is always sensible and desirable, but the RE is questionable."

So, actually you agree with me.

PS: Just to add, your post is not compatible with FIRE anyway. "FIRE" is not about "moderation". "FIRE" is about "EARLIER" -- that's the word in "E" = "earlier". If in moderation, that should become "FIMOD", but that's not the case. What you said and what FIRE stands for are two different things.

This post has been edited by howszat: Sep 12 2018, 10:46 PM
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 10:52 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 09:57 PM)
Yes. That is what an unanticipated career change means.

Look at it another way, he jumped out of the rat race, and found another mountain of cheese (ie. from working --> retirement --> working again). Just that this time he found an ideal job !

I do hope everybody who RE can be as successful as him ! But that is a tall hope I must admit 
A hypothesis remains a hypothesis. With the arguments as set out in the hypothesis, I still think selfishness is a reasonable conclusion for those who RE.

Many may have forgotten the content of the hypothesis. As a refresher, here it is again :

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

Yes, the same holds true when you bring out Mr Money Moustache. How many more Mr Money Moustache can you quote ?  biggrin.gif
*
ez peasy...

Mr Money Mustache
madFIentist
Frugalwoods
Physician on Fire
Early Retirement Extreme
jlcollinsnh
Root of Good
Go Curry Cracker!
1500 Days to Freedom
Our Next Life
Early Retirement Now
Millennial Revolution
Millennial Boss
The Escape Artist
OTHALAFEHU
howszat
post Sep 12 2018, 10:58 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
Can we avoid /k replies?

Thanks.
Garysydney
post Sep 13 2018, 04:43 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(j.passing.by @ Sep 12 2018, 04:26 PM)

Think of all the maintenance costs you can save by not owning a house or car, and not to forget the cost of interest you don’t need to spend on the loans in making these purchases.

How much you need to retire early depends on you. How you want it to be is up to you. There is always a way if you want to do it.


*
I think renting is not an ideal solution in old age. Firstly, you don't know what kind of rent increases will precipitate in the unforseeable future. Secondly, you want to have the security of not having to move (when you don't want to) in your ripe old age. Thirdly, landlords are less likely to engage you as a tenant when you are in your seventies/eighties for fear of you passing on in their house.

I think 'having a roof' over your head is essential/crucial (i.e. not having to pay rent) before you can even start to consider FI. Owning your own place will give you peace of mind esp in old-age (past 60).
Showtime747
post Sep 13 2018, 06:24 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 12 2018, 10:52 PM)
ez peasy...

Mr Money Mustache
madFIentist
Frugalwoods
Physician on Fire
Early Retirement Extreme
jlcollinsnh
Root of Good
Go Curry Cracker!
1500 Days to Freedom
Our Next Life
Early Retirement Now
Millennial Revolution
Millennial Boss
The Escape Artist
OTHALAFEHU
*
I have only heard of mr money moustache biggrin.gif He has a lot of traffic.

If it is that easy to be more successful after retirement than before, why not start immediately ? Don’t waste any more time on the current job...RE and become a blogger everybody ! thumbup.gif

This has begun to sound like MLM recruitment. Come join us the RE MLM to turn over a new life. See our platinum diamond leader Mr Moustache. He makes RM100k per month sitting at home after joining RE MLM. If he can do it, so can everyone of you....

This post has been edited by Showtime747: Sep 13 2018, 06:45 AM
tippman
post Sep 13 2018, 07:09 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(howszat @ Sep 12 2018, 08:47 PM)
This FIRE thing does not make sense for the following reason. The FI bit is always sensible and desirable, but the RE is questionable.

Scenario A: A person works very hard, and saves everything he can, and lives frugally, maybe to the extent of affecting his health if he cuts back on healthy living, eg nutritious food, takes time off to exercise rather than working overtime, etc. After FIRE, ask "now what do I do"? My interpretation = this means being miserable.

Scenario B: A person finds and works at a job he likes, saves what he can comfortably afford, looks after his health (gym or something else, but not overtime), sets his FI at a later date, and continues to do the job he likes after FI. Objective: find a job you like, and you can continue to keep meaningfully occupied rather than achieve this "RE" and then ask now what do I do?
*
I think people who want to retire early so that they can do something they are passionate about. Of course to achieve that, some one must be able to be financial independent/freedom in order to quit his full time job and use his passion to contribute to something that he/she think that can create a more impact in the society.

Some choose to retire early for church mission, they travel to orang asli area or remote area to provide medical aids and teaching those kids.
some choose to focus on what they do best and serve the public, like chef in the orphanage home, rescue worker and others.

These people they know what is their passion and they choose to retire early when they are able to and contributes to society on this.

Of course there are people who choose to retire early because they have inheritance wealth from their family and they don't know what to do.


Mattrock
post Sep 13 2018, 07:09 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
394 posts

Joined: Dec 2017
Let me share a bit about my journey to achieve FIRE, which I hope to do in couple of years. By FIRE, I mean no more working. First, I found that one needs to define the type of lifestyle you want after retirement, and then define your magic NW number which will give you target passive income to meet your chose lifestyle over the years, taking into account your ROI and inflation. Sounds simple. Anthony Robbins gave me a fresh way of looking at these targets. According to him, there are different levels of lifestyle which one can target. These range from having enough to provide shelter, food and pay bills, i.e., basic, next step is to be able to indulge in some dining out, shopping, entertainment, next will be ability to go on vacations, splurge on some pampering, more dining out and enetertainment, golfing, change car say every 8 years, upgrade furniture, etc, and maybe the final level will be to do things which you are not even doing now - charities, luxury vacations, branded clothing, 5 star hotels, business class flights, etc.. As I get closer to my NW number, I keep realizing that I need to account for things which I did not earlier, such as old age care for parents, maybe my kids wish to do post graduate studies, maybe help them with their first car, renovate the house after 10 years, etc, etc.. So all this kept increasing the target NW I require, which has delayed my RE date. Anyway, getting close now, may not be a significant E in the RE, but definitely and E, in any case.

So think carefully on the type of lifestyle you expect to have when retired and don't forget that there will always be something you have not thought of that will eat into your nest egg, so some contingency will be wise.

This post has been edited by Mattrock: Sep 13 2018, 07:10 AM
tippman
post Sep 13 2018, 07:14 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 13 2018, 06:24 AM)
I have only heard of mr money moustache  biggrin.gif He has a lot of traffic.

If it is that easy to be more successful after retirement than before, why not start immediately ? Don’t waste any more time on the current job...RE and become a blogger everybody !  thumbup.gif

This has begun to sound like MLM recruitment. Come join us the RE MLM to turn over a new life. See our platinum diamond leader Mr Moustache. He makes RM100k per month sitting at home after joining RE MLM. If he can do it, so can everyone of you....
*
Nothing is easy and I would say those who choose to retire early, they must know and plan what they want to do once retire. Like I said before, they are many people choose to retire early so that they can do something that they like and contributes to society.

I don't think sky18 sound like MLM recruitment. he is merely showing example of people who choose to retire early and still contributing to society and sharing the knowledge.

Anyway, you have mentioned in one post that you are 57 or so, so mind to share with everyone what is your retirement planning?


Showtime747
post Sep 13 2018, 08:59 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(tippman @ Sep 13 2018, 07:14 AM)

Anyway, you have mentioned in one post that you are 57 or so, so mind to share with everyone what is your retirement planning?
*
I am already semi-retired.

I have 4 businesses. Currently run by may long time staffs (I considered them as partner). I gave them 50% share in the respective companies (except property renting company). So the daily running of the businesses has since delegated to them, and they have been doing a great job. I usually go to the office in the morning. My partners will come and brief me if there is any new development. Otherwise, it was just a routine just to show face.

For passive income portfolio, currently I am out of the stock market. And let my RM manage for me. Mostly long term (15 months and above) bank products with capital guaranteed. So, less time spend on overseeing the portfolio now compared to when I was active in stock market

After that, it's all my free time biggrin.gif

I have quite a number of hobbies. I think I posted my expenses in the other thread about monthly expenses. Most of my expenses are related to my hobbies

55665566
post Sep 13 2018, 09:22 AM

Avengers Assemble!
*****
Senior Member
833 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
From: Earth



QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 13 2018, 08:59 AM)
I am already semi-retired.

I have 4 businesses. Currently run by may long time staffs (I considered them as partner). I gave them 50% share in the respective companies (except property renting company). So the daily running of the businesses has since delegated to them, and they have been doing a great job. I usually go to the office in the morning. My partners will come and brief me if there is any new development. Otherwise, it was just a routine just to show face.

For passive income portfolio, currently I am out of the stock market. And let my RM manage for me. Mostly long term (15 months and above) bank products with capital guaranteed. So, less time spend on overseeing the portfolio now compared to when I was active in stock market

After that, it's all my free time  biggrin.gif

I have quite a number of hobbies. I think I posted my expenses in the other thread about monthly expenses. Most of my expenses are related to my hobbies
*
Good plan for retirement there.
Just ignore what others said.

Some people just cannot accept criticism and red-eye when seeing others are more successful than them. These people usually will not learn and would not accept advice to change themselves in order to improve. In short, thick face rolleyes.gif
sky18
post Sep 13 2018, 09:32 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 13 2018, 06:24 AM)
I have only heard of mr money moustache  biggrin.gif He has a lot of traffic.

If it is that easy to be more successful after retirement than before, why not start immediately ? Don’t waste any more time on the current job...RE and become a blogger everybody !  thumbup.gif

This has begun to sound like MLM recruitment. Come join us the RE MLM to turn over a new life. See our platinum diamond leader Mr Moustache. He makes RM100k per month sitting at home after joining RE MLM. If he can do it, so can everyone of you....
*
I guess this is a sign the end of fruitful discussion on FI/RE=selfish.

The list above is the site with Alexa rank (500k min) complied by reddit. Just hit https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence/wiki/faq for more valueable info.

Among of them including JL Collins, JD Roth which contribute a lots of valuable knowledge in this space.

Showtime747
post Sep 13 2018, 10:00 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(55665566 @ Sep 13 2018, 09:22 AM)
Good plan for retirement there.
Just ignore what others said.

Some people just cannot accept criticism and red-eye when seeing others are more successful than them. These people usually will not learn and would not accept advice to change themselves in order to improve. In short, thick face rolleyes.gif
*
Thanks.

No lah....unlike the /k, the overwhelming majority here are ok. I know there are many silent readers. I was one before I joined....

I must say I learnt a lot of things here....its a forum with good source of info
Showtime747
post Sep 13 2018, 10:02 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,258 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(sky18 @ Sep 13 2018, 09:32 AM)
I guess this is a sign the end of fruitful discussion on FI/RE=selfish.

The list above is the site with Alexa rank (500k min) complied by reddit. Just hit https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence/wiki/faq for more valueable info.

Among of them including JL Collins, JD Roth which contribute a lots of valuable knowledge in this space.
*
It was fruitful nonetheless thumbup.gif

You and I got our points across, and readers are well informed and can choose their own path

Look at it this way, we have somewhat contributed to the forum biggrin.gif
cfkoon
post Sep 13 2018, 10:16 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
228 posts

Joined: Oct 2010
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 13 2018, 08:59 AM)
I am already semi-retired.

I have 4 businesses. Currently run by may long time staffs (I considered them as partner). I gave them 50% share in the respective companies (except property renting company). So the daily running of the businesses has since delegated to them, and they have been doing a great job. I usually go to the office in the morning. My partners will come and brief me if there is any new development. Otherwise, it was just a routine just to show face.

For passive income portfolio, currently I am out of the stock market. And let my RM manage for me. Mostly long term (15 months and above) bank products with capital guaranteed. So, less time spend on overseeing the portfolio now compared to when I was active in stock market

After that, it's all my free time  biggrin.gif

I have quite a number of hobbies. I think I posted my expenses in the other thread about monthly expenses. Most of my expenses are related to my hobbies
*
I previously mentioned the conditions to FI (RE if you achieved this at a younger age). Above is exactly the condition you have to meet in order to become FI - as in the case of @Showtime747 it is having multiple businesses (should be stable and recurring) and a significant enough amount of investable asset (which in this case provides capital gauranteed but stable returns - when you have a large enough investable asset, even a lower percentage return is enough to let u live handsomely).

When you are FI/RE, you will realise that you have more time on your hand and will slowly be bored of your lifestyle, sometimes even your hobbies won't be enough to fill up your time. Those FI/RE will actually prefer to work part time - meaning they are either high ranking/or owner that they don't have to be bounded at their desk 9-5 - i believe this is the true meaning of RE, whereby you can still work but under your own terms. So if you want to go golf at 10am and go into office at 2pm you can do that. You don't have to be completely retired.
Garysydney
post Sep 13 2018, 11:34 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
527 posts

Joined: Jul 2017


QUOTE(cfkoon @ Sep 13 2018, 10:16 AM)
I previously mentioned the conditions to FI (RE if you achieved this at a younger age). Above is exactly the condition you have to meet in order to become FI - as in the case of @Showtime747 it is having multiple businesses (should be stable and recurring) and a significant enough amount of investable asset (which in this case provides capital gauranteed but stable returns - when you have a large enough investable asset, even a lower percentage return is enough to let u live handsomely).

When you are FI/RE, you will realise that you have more time on your hand and will slowly be bored of your lifestyle, sometimes even your hobbies won't be enough to fill up your time. Those FI/RE will actually prefer to work part time - meaning they are either high ranking/or owner that they don't have to be bounded at their desk 9-5 - i believe this is the true meaning of RE, whereby you can still work but under your own terms. So if you want to go golf at 10am and go into office at 2pm you can do that. You don't have to be completely retired.
*
This is very true. Once you have achieved FI, you will have a lot of leisure time. You can travel all you want but after a while, you will probably be so sick of travelling. You will need a solution to your free time otherwise you will be dead-set bored. Having somewhere to go (to occupy your time) would be highly sought after.

I am currently working so i find time passes extremely quickly (even though bored at work but i am getting good money to sit down and do nothing thumbup.gif ). Once retired getting some hobbies would probably be quite desirable.
tippman
post Sep 13 2018, 11:57 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,650 posts

Joined: Feb 2009
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 13 2018, 08:59 AM)
I am already semi-retired.

I have 4 businesses. Currently run by may long time staffs (I considered them as partner). I gave them 50% share in the respective companies (except property renting company). So the daily running of the businesses has since delegated to them, and they have been doing a great job. I usually go to the office in the morning. My partners will come and brief me if there is any new development. Otherwise, it was just a routine just to show face.

For passive income portfolio, currently I am out of the stock market. And let my RM manage for me. Mostly long term (15 months and above) bank products with capital guaranteed. So, less time spend on overseeing the portfolio now compared to when I was active in stock market

After that, it's all my free time  biggrin.gif

I have quite a number of hobbies. I think I posted my expenses in the other thread about monthly expenses. Most of my expenses are related to my hobbies
*
Thanks for the information.
howszat
post Sep 13 2018, 08:24 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,932 posts

Joined: Sep 2007
This "contribute to society" after RE is just "meaningless".

You can contribute to society anytime. Contribute when you are young, middle age and when you are old. Throughout your whole life, in fact. When you have a job, you can contribute during your weekends. When you are working, you can contribute part of your salary. I'm sure society will welcome your financial contributions at any stage of your life with open arms.

spiderman17
post Sep 13 2018, 09:40 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
309 posts

Joined: Nov 2011
Deleted. Moot question.

This post has been edited by spiderman17: Sep 13 2018, 11:08 PM
kradun
post Sep 13 2018, 11:47 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
989 posts

Joined: Feb 2008


I not yet reach stage FI/RE, but I think if can I will just continue to work. Right now factor in weekend, public holiday, annual leave the total free activity days per annum are about 140++ days, for me the number is quite good enough.

Other than that, during working days nite time also can spend few hours on something that I preferred, isnt that bad to keep working unless I am hating my own job.

Like bro Garysydney mentioned on travel too frequent, keep doing the same thing whole year 365 days probably is too boring. What make it worst is when you are the only one retired early but your friend are all still working, last time you only need to find your friend once in a while but now your everyday is weekend you must have activity to keep the life moving but hardly got people free like you to entertain you.

Worst come to worst retired early just make yourself contribute to the statistic of retire early die early.

4 Pages  1 2 3 > » Top
Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.1782sec    0.41    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 28th November 2025 - 10:02 PM