QUOTE(General_Nic @ Mar 9 2021, 03:38 PM)
your point is right, what you're asking is why would ppl recommend 5800x, and what I gave you were the reasons, doesn't mean the reasons must be right
I got my 5800x because I missed the period when 5900x was still at RM2.5k, followed by out of stock for a couple of months, but I already bought X570 mobo
I saw 5800x being sold at old msrp in January, so I just buy first think later, having a bad cpu is better than no cpu at all, thinking maybe future can get 5900x and sell off 5800x
Fair point. With prices on market fluctuating these days, it's difficult to compare just with MSRP alone.
QUOTE(raydenex @ Mar 9 2021, 04:09 PM)
I got a 5800x for about RM 2130 (slightly above its RM 2049 MSRP) as well back in late December when the 5900x was nowhere to be found for MSRP. Initially if you're comparing 5800x at RM 2049 to the 5900x at RM 2499 (was the MSRP 2449, 2459 or 2499, my memory fails me), then yes no way in hell I'd go for a 5800x, make so little sense even from a price point, we haven't even start talking about the temperature issues that were cropping up online specific to the 5800x.
Then I got the 5800x, installed it, used it and... pleasantly surprised. Cooled by an EK AIO 240, CP2077 load temps never breach 70c. Idles at 40-41c, and with my room A/C on, I've seen idles at 33c even. Most likely got a golden sample I guess.

Nice temps, definitely won the lottery there. No issues with USB connectivity, cold boot, or WHEA errors?