QUOTE(Wan @ Feb 22 2009, 04:16 PM)
Carrick was in lala land? What was he supposed to do? Used his crystal ball and then move to cover Nani's & Scholes' asses and knew that Evra can't stop the advancing guy?
Sure the first 2 guys didn't deal with it, but it was still stoppable. Rio had him covered, barely, but still Santa Cruz was going wide.. and Kuszczak made a mess of it, crashing into Rio. Well done.
I'm not expecting him to be VDS, he's a good GK himself. But that decision to come out, and go to ground really I don't understand at all. Rio had him covered, until he made that last ditch tackle, which pushed him wide, but Kuszczak after seeing the move all the way, still decide to go to ground and crash into Rio leaving Santa Cruz with an empty net. Even Hargo with his super duper running wouldn't get in time. Kind of bizarre how you blame Carrick on that.
Without the benefit of a replay, I'm pretty sure Carrick was nearest to Oojier after Scholes and Nani but was ball watching (like the rest of the defense). But then, why is Kuszchak the only one who's stupid when Nani gave the ball away, Scholes and Nani being gentlemenly over whom should clear the ball, the rest of the defense ball-watching? Because looking at your post, all 3 made mistakes but Kuszczak's the only one coming off as stupid.
It was a mess of a goal but again, as I mentioned, I don't blame Kuszczak. But again, if we were to point fingers, I'd point them at other players as well whom started the whole mess. It'd be interesting to see the opinions here if Rafael gave away the penalty. Would he be defended or hammered?
And I was mentioning Hargo in response to alien's post stating he could partner Ferdinand as a last resort. Nothing to do with Carrick's play.
P.S.: I don't like Kuszczak as our goalkeeper but I don't see how we could blame him.