QUOTE(shootkk @ Dec 17 2012, 04:06 PM)
Ok. I'm going to do a little analysis here with regards to the movie and Tolkien's book.
Don't get me wrong. The Hobbit : An Unexpected Journey is not a bad movie by far. Great production values and special effects. I'm just a little bummed out that they dragged it out like they did but that's just me.
As always, analysis cannot be made without revealing details of the movie so spoilers are ahead.
Actually, to be fair, The Fellowship does start off light as well, with the long expected party and it's related events...and only become progressively darker as the books move along.
I do agree on some of your points though...some parts were certainly unnecessary. Example, I thought the stone giants, while being well done, was really just for eye candy's sake.
Added on December 17, 2012, 9:36 pmQUOTE(defaultname365 @ Dec 17 2012, 04:32 PM)
It's
based on the books. A film should never punish it's viewers for not knowing the source material. Oddly, it seems now that knowing the source material is what the problem is right now. I didn't even know "The Hobbit" was more of a children's story until recently.
The tie-in factor with LOTR was present because the film is an adaptation of the book and I'm confident it was seen an opportunity to have the references in it. Had the film been done just like books, the question would then be on why make the less menacing and the lack of coherence with the LOTR plot would come into questioning. Perhaps if I did read the book, I would have a different opinion altogether but I didn't.
I didn't find much issues with the film at all except for the darn IMAX. I think my viewing experience would be even better in 48fps.
On another note, the film has grossed over $220 million.
Hmm, however from my view, there were many references that people NOT knowing the source material would simply get overwhelmed with too. I appreciated it since I read all the books, but most non-readers would simply be wondering what that was all about perhaps? And some of those are incidental stuff that relates to LOTR but doesn't directly impact on it.
I'm more worried about the tone of the movies...overall, The Hobbit : An Unexpected Journey is pretty respectful of the books. I hope PJ doesn't screw around much like he did for Two Towers and Return of the King.
Thranduil, abandoning the Dwarves? I haven't read the Hobbit for a couple of years, but I certainly don't remember this issue. Thorin's father getting killed in battle? I seem to remember he was captured and tortured rather than falling in battle.
This post has been edited by axoloke: Dec 17 2012, 09:40 PM