QUOTE(8066 @ Apr 12 2025, 12:09 AM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
I'm back again, this time im setting the budget at 60k for a used Japanese MPV, I saw 2019 Honda BRV seems to be selling around this price. My questions:
1. How is the car in terms for reliability?
2. Maybe ocassional long distance driving in peninsula with wife and/or extended family
3. Any workshops in KL/Selangor region that are good with Honda cars? or back to the Honda workshop?
I would put Honda BRV in the same category as Toyota Avanza/Rush G1 and Perodua Aruz.
Reason why is they're all made from a van platform and should be categorised as MPV not SUV, but at the time SUV is all the rage so they repurposed Van platforms to make cheap SUV's. That's why these models usually sit higher than true compact SUV's of the time, e.g. Toyota C-HR and Honda HRV.
So they up the interior to look nicer as an SUV usually means it sits higher and most plush interior compared to MPV/Van.
But it has terrible ride and handling because of its van roots.
Reliability? Yeah it is good enough but under powered thus long distance driving is tiring.
Generally for Honda and Toyota most workshops can handle them, only issue is they honest or not.
2021 Toyota Rush - so this generation of Rush is the twin of the Perodua Aruz, nothing really between them. As a used car punter I suggest you hunt around for G-spec Rush because it will have better accessories than Aruz as even the top spec of Aruz will usually be around the mid-spec for Rush. This is how Toyota plays the game.
2021 Toyota Avanza - the current generation of Avanza and Veloz are basically the same thing. Similar like how they market the Alphard and Vellfire which is basically the same thing but one which is more basic and cheaper used for fleets and the other has design elements and accessories that makes is more luxurious and sporty. However, under the hood it is basically the same, upkeep wise. If you want to go cheaper and max out your money woof then get the full spec Perodua Alza which the current generation is a mirror to the Veloz and Avanza.
2010 Toyota Mark X Zio - if you're wondering what you can get which isn't a shitbox / greybox then you have to look at something older and it will surely be a cash buy. The Mark X Zio is basically the Mark X but stretched to become a 7 seater which is targeting Honda Odyssey as their size and engine displacement are similar, also they're both considered low slung for MPV having that crossover ride height which is a welcome change for two reasons. (1) easier to get in and out, no step so while you're standing the seat height is about as high as your bum. This is a plus point for seniors as too low or too high is not easy for them. (2) drives better as lower on the road. It is a JDM and at this level you should expect it to be a very nice car to be in new grey import was upwards of 180k back in the day. As a car you buy today as long as it wasn't abused setting aside RM5000 for a full service including aircon cleaning and service plus new brake pads, replacing all rubber based parts like timing belts, brake hose, window seals. It will feel refreshed. If there is extra funds replace the shocks and the car will drive like new.
2018 Renault Koleos - okay so you want something newer so you can loan and since it is newer you don't really need/want to set aside funds for any repairs then consider this. It is actually the mirror to the Nissan X-Trail except for the fact that it only seats 5 and have a redone interior and exterior, the engine and gearbox is the same as an X-trail so you can go to any workshop to be maintained no need any conti car specialist. It will have the same pros and cons as the X-trail.
2020 Subaru Forrester - if you can look past the badge this is a good bargain for under 60k you get an SUV body, 7 seater, power boot, relatively reliable and japanesse brand. The biggest downside to most Subaru cars is their selling point, which i the AWD. If you're worried about grip and handling in all sorts of terrains as you travel around then the AWD is a blessing, if you're just driving it around the taman to send kids to school or stuck in traffic then you wouldn't think the AWD is helpful and think it is a fuel guzzler. Since Toyota acquired Subaru their newer cars are all quite reliable. However, Subaru cars not having the critical mass will tend to have slightly more expensive spare parts like Mazda, Mitsubishi, etc.
QUOTE(LostAndFound @ Apr 13 2025, 05:05 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
Well, perhaps can consider a Toyota?
And then you can also realise that if you buy the Veloz its assembled at the exact same plant that the Alza is.
An even worst scenario than when we had Mitsubishi Lancer 2.0 and Proton Inspira 2.0
It was almost 1:1 but Proton using proprietary shocks and Lotus tuning meant it is going to be more expensive to replace unless you change all 4 to Lancer shocks.
QUOTE(Jason @ Apr 13 2025, 06:07 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
How is a Toyota Alza not Japanese?
You believe it’s engineered by Perodua? lol
G1 Alza was based on G1 Myvi which was based on G1 Daihatsu Boon.
Boon is the granddaddy for the other similar clones such as Sirion, Justy and Passo.
For the case of Myvi the collab part from P2 was mostly on reengineering parts for CKD then local assembly with localized parts makers.
G1 Alza is based on Daihatsu Boon Luminas or Toyota Passo Sette, again I think the collab was mostly on localizing and reducing cost for local production.
P2 only really worked on G3 Myvi on their own based on Toyota's platform and engines at the time.
So saying Alza is Japanese is mostly true.
It has very Toyota-like DNA being a reliable work horse, just enough power, and not fuel guzzler while being an unremarkable grey box to most car lovers, it is a precious work horse for the everyday man.