QUOTE(weikee @ Oct 30 2013, 05:16 PM)
There won't be ending of argument. NSF and some other reputable organization will have it own benchmark.
The person buying it will be the one making final decision. I buy 3m because it was affordable (compare Amway), NSF certified, and its size. Some other may have different reason. If you search back think I am the one bring up the 3m filters into this forum discussion.
I used sand, membrane and now 3m. Sand is really no no to me. Bulky and not really clean, yes sometime my cloths still get the brown color problem, and I dont want a mini reactor look in front of my house. Lazy to do back wash. Membrane still bulky buy acceptable if 3m doesn't exist.
My ideal setup was amway for internal and 3m for external. Hey 3m give good promotion.. So I go all out for 3m.
I agree, sand filter is quite disappointing. I am using GE sand filter(3+ years now) and when water turbidity gets bad ( for example, right after you get your water back after a water cut ), the sand filter simply is unable to provide clean water. The dirty water then gets into my water tank, resulting in the tank accumulating dirt. I bought it because it was much cheaper than membrane at that time, and I was on a budget.
If I were to purchase a POE filter now, my choice would either be a membrane filter, or something similar to 3M too. My only problem with 3M is, my area gets water cut often, hence there would be many times when dirtier than usual water will go through the filter. Being unable to backwash it, it may have a shorter lifespan.
For membrane filters, in addition to the automatic flushing that's done once or twice a day, the filter needs to be backwashed once in a while too. Some installers do not provide the users with the ability to perform your own backwash ( by installing multiple levers and some funky pipe connections ). Hence, you would need to call them to service the filter once a year, with their water pump. You must remember, automatic flushing does not replace backwashing for membrane filters.