QUOTE(Convael @ Jan 18 2024, 10:49 PM)
Mad Max Fury was graded with rec 2020 colorspace and 10000 nits , it was ahead of its times .
Because of that reason alone , all current commercial TVs have to do tonemapping while playing the movie.
Any direct comparison between TVs isn't going to be as clear cut. The difference could've been the result of different tone mapping approach.
It seems like a lot of ppl have been making the same conclusion based on youtube - " TV A looks brighter / more colorful than B on XX's channel videos ".
Despite the reviewers have repeatedly told the viewers not to use the video as a reference to comparing screens.
Yeah if it is 10000 nits, it will do tone mapping. If you have some spare time, you can watch one of Vincent's 2023 TV shootout. As usual it's attended by many people from the video and cinematography industry. The HX310 he uses all the time which is capable of hitting "full field 1000 nits only" was calibrated to D65 white point as usual , all the TV brands were covered/framed up to cover the brand names.
Under the tonemapping of 1000 nits (MI Fallout) and 4000 nits (Lord of the Rings) HDR presentation, ranking from high to low:
1000 nits - A95L, G3, S95C, MZ2000
4000 nits - A95L, S95C, G3, MZ2000
Combined score - A95L, S95C, G3- MZ2000 draw
For color accuracy check, there are low luminance, Rec709, WCG, High Luminance, out of the box, too long to type out results, so to sum up:
A95L, S95C, G3, MZ2000
One thing to note here if you watch the video, both A95L and S95C exhibit higher color saturation at high luminance as close as the ref monitor over the G3 and MZ2000.
So at least we know "at the moment", A95L and S95C QD OLEDs have a clear advantage in this segment over normal wRGB OLEDs (with ref to a 1000 nits capable monitor). What you seen and said is totally in line to the conclusion from the shootout, but like you said maybe its different tonemapping but I think wider rec2020 plays a big role also (G3 only about 75%-ish and S90 S95C ~90%) and at 1300 nits more or less, there is already distinction already between QD and normal wRGB. Don't know how 2nd gen MLA will help with the color boosting, but LG got a lot to catch up in the high luminance high color brightness segment. All this is assuming he doesn't get paid to say good thing about QD OLEDs hahaha...
I think most people will always revert back to youtube or rtings comparison for this or that be it inside or outside the forum...but at least most people in this forum is open for discussion, unlike certain individual who is blatantly ignorant few pages back when facts and numbers are being presented lol.