Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

27 Pages « < 19 20 21 22 23 > » Bottom

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Compilation of Good And Bad Contractors V2

views
     
xphr3ak
post Feb 26 2021, 11:33 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,797 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
Bad contractor (extremely slow, keep giving empty promises and now MIA).

Name: CK Soh/Chi Kin Soh
Phone no: 0126164169 | 0143339186
Car Plate no: VAM9186 (Toyota Camry - White)
JR ID AND RENOVATION
154, Jalan S2 B21, Pusat Dagangan Seremban 2, 70300 Seremban, Negeri Sembilan.

I have lodged a police report and will proceed to KPDNHEP next.

Attached Image



This post has been edited by xphr3ak: Oct 5 2021, 01:59 PM
surfsmurf
post Feb 26 2021, 12:09 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
101 posts

Joined: Mar 2005
Just sharing my experience with a bad contractor.

I found Mr Lim Swee Weng (012-3060017) doing a major reno opposite my house and asked him to do some reno on my house. Work started in Jun 2019 and should be completed within 3 months. I expected it to complete later as 3 months is too good to be true.

Initially everything was ok and he was quite helpful. Payment was partial according to job done or by month. I was prompt with my payment. Then job progress became slower and his worker became less and less. He's concurrently doing reno for my house and the opposite house and have 3 workers for each house. it gradually reduced to 2 and sometimes 1 for my house. I should have suspected something really wrong when he paid his worker late. Some left because of late salary. He will say house owner never pay him hence he cannot pay them. Worker ask me if it's true and i say my payment is up to date. Since I've been paying him quite prompt, he kept asking money from me almost every month till i felt I've paid almost all my reno cost.

As of last year just before the 1st MCO, he beg me for money saying he needed to pay his supplier and to complete my reno. I did not give his the required amount as I felt I've paid a lot. I compiled my payment against his quote and remove whatever that is no longer required and found I only owe him a few thousand. Outstanding work worth 20K is still not done !

After MCO when people starting working, he cannot be contacted anymore. He will switch off his phone and only certain times you're able to get him. When ask about completing the job, he would say he needed money to pay for materials and worker. I sat down with him and showed his my outstanding balance is only a few thousand and I should not be paying him till he finish the job. From then on he would only send one worker to do complete my reno. At times he would as me to buy materials as deduct my outstanding. After a few deduction, I no longer owe him money but he owe me instead.

From them on no worker came and he completely avoided mt by not answering my calls and switching off the phone.

Balance work not much now about 5k and i thik he's not going to complete it. I ask other suppliers and they say nothing much I can do and accept the loss. During CMCO few supplier came looking for him claiming he owe them money. His worker also not paid for many months till they left for other jobs.

My advice to you who's doing reno, DO NOT pay your contractor till the job is done especially the last few payment. My feedback from other people is the same. Contractors cannot be trusted.

This contractor is based in PJ and driving a silver Vios W2252Q

Please avoid him at all cost.





ponyznon
post Mar 17 2021, 08:40 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
26 posts

Joined: Oct 2008
From: KL


Bad Water Proofing company

Hydro armour
Job : Water Tank storage area water proofing
Problem: Water Tank keep over flow after they install back the tank

They cut my pipe that flow water to toilet so I won't notice over flow and claim they did the job.
Lucky my wife heard water sound so I climb up and saw water tank overflow, end up have to call plumber and spend 150 to fix it..you are screwed if your installation got problem..they won't come back and fix it..

Call the supervisor also FFK..make appointment with the HQ also FFK..
Justin.Loong
post Mar 18 2021, 04:49 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,293 posts

Joined: Feb 2014


QUOTE(ponyznon @ Mar 17 2021, 08:40 PM)
Bad Water Proofing company

Hydro armour
Job : Water Tank storage area water proofing
Problem: Water Tank keep over flow after they install back the tank

They cut my pipe that flow water to toilet so I won't notice over flow and claim they did the job.
Lucky my wife heard water sound so I climb up and saw water tank overflow, end up have to call plumber and spend 150 to fix it..you are screwed if your installation got problem..they won't come back and fix it..

Call the supervisor also FFK..make appointment with the HQ also FFK..
*
Is it this company?

Justin.Loong
post Mar 18 2021, 04:55 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,293 posts

Joined: Feb 2014


QUOTE(surfsmurf @ Feb 26 2021, 12:09 PM)
Just sharing my experience with a bad contractor.

I found Mr Lim Swee Weng (012-3060017) doing a major reno opposite my house and asked him to do some reno on my house. Work started in Jun 2019 and should be completed within 3 months. I expected it to complete later as 3 months is too good to be true.

Initially everything was ok and he was quite helpful. Payment was partial according to job done or by month. I was prompt with my payment. Then job progress became slower and his worker became less and less. He's concurrently doing reno for my house and the opposite house and have 3 workers for each house. it gradually reduced to 2 and sometimes 1 for my house. I should have suspected something really wrong when he paid his worker late. Some left because of late salary. He will say house owner never pay him hence he cannot pay them. Worker ask me if it's true and i say my payment is up to date. Since I've been paying him quite prompt, he kept asking money from me almost every month till i felt I've paid almost all my reno cost.

As of last year just before the 1st MCO, he beg me for money saying he needed to pay his supplier and to complete my reno. I did not give his the required amount as I felt I've paid a lot.  I compiled my payment against his quote and remove whatever that is no longer required and found I only owe him a few thousand. Outstanding work worth 20K is still not done !

After MCO when people starting working, he cannot be contacted anymore. He will switch off his phone and only certain times you're able to get him. When ask about completing the job, he would say he needed money to pay for materials and worker. I sat down with him and showed his my outstanding balance is only a few thousand and I should not be paying him till he finish the job. From then on he would only send one worker to do complete my reno. At times he would as me to buy materials as deduct my outstanding. After a few deduction, I no longer owe him money but he owe me instead.

From them on no worker came and he completely avoided mt by not answering my calls and switching off the phone.

Balance work not much now about 5k and i thik he's not going to complete it. I ask other suppliers and they say nothing much I can do and accept the loss. During CMCO few supplier came looking for him claiming he owe them money. His worker also not paid for many months till they left for other jobs.

My advice to you who's doing reno, DO NOT pay your contractor till the job is done especially the last few payment. My feedback from other people is the same. Contractors cannot be trusted.

This contractor is based in PJ and driving a silver Vios W2252Q

Please avoid him at all cost.
*
If you don't mind me asking, so how's the condition of your house now? Still many things undone?
What about the renovation parts that Mr Lim has done earlier? Is it all OK? Was the workmanship good quality or you need to fork out more money to rectify Mr Lim's errors? sweat.gif
Justin.Loong
post Mar 18 2021, 05:00 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,293 posts

Joined: Feb 2014


QUOTE(im_awsm @ Dec 5 2020, 12:53 PM)
I engaged Yap Peng Kim (012-329 1682) this year to do my toilets (retiling, general fixes & plumbing) after reading your reviews about him on LowYat, how good la, how polite, great work done.

But it turned out to be a nightmare, where not only he NEVER showed up even once after getting the contract but his contract workers were not even doing any work, and after taking more than a week to break my toilet tiles, I had to step in and ask him. Turns out his supervisor, Chong Chee Onn (016-332 2826) also wasn't on site, unlike Yap’s promises.

Yap did sloppy work on my toilet, didn’t know much about plumbing, didn’t fix the heater hose properly, just did a half past six job, even didn’t finish the tiling properly, never added grouting for most of the tiles. But he was very busy promoting his relative’s shop to me to buy things from them (some Ga Hing Trading), instead of working on my toilet. Our toilet leaked once they fixed the sink, and his workers didn't even inform us even while we were on-site. We found out from management about this leak due to complaints from our downstairs neighbour. We had to follow up with him AND his workers to repair the leak and do our own water ponding test to check if it was fixed or not. He even told us another nonsense story about his supervisor left and he was so busy with other contracts he had.

When asked on the progress, he always said "don’t worry, small matter", for a work he promised to finish in 2 weeks, took more than a month and a lot of our own time to supervise- he never once came to supervise on his foreign workers, even after I asked him to check on the work done, as it was quite sloppy, he kept giving excuses to not come and check. He even said he thought we were not serious about the date that was discussed and agreed upon in the contract.

Worse is the lighting to our toilets, it was done in a really bad way, that the housing fell after a few months and we found out from another electrician that we engaged that the bulbs were not fixed and were free-hanging.

He is very condescending towards females, and will launch a tirade justifying why his workers haven’t finished the work within the deadline, but won’t address the actual issue with you, which is to ask his workers and supervisor to be on site and DO WORK! And by do work, I mean do QUALITY WORK, not sloppy work!

Towards the end, he instructed his workers to hide my house keys, and wanted us to pay in full asap (before inspecting) and launched a BS story about his deputy Chong stealing my keys, and he lodged a police report on his deputy. He STILL did not want to meet us to inspect the unit for defects together before we make the payment! Really a nightmare to hire Yap Peng Kim! Stay away from him at all cost! NEVER AGAIN  mad.gif !

A word of advice to the rest of you, please do remember to add in a clause in your renovation contract about penalty for late delivery of the property.
*
Jeez...this is really a sad case. sad.gif
Like some readers in this thread, I was also on the lookout for a reliable contractor but upon reading these kind of horror stories, I'll avoid some of the mentioned contractors at an arm's length. bruce.gif
SUSRobert.johor
post Mar 20 2021, 09:12 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
106 posts

Joined: Mar 2020

QUOTE(Justin.Loong @ Mar 18 2021, 05:00 PM)
Jeez...this is really a sad case.  sad.gif
Like some readers in this thread, I was also on the lookout for a reliable contractor but upon reading these kind of horror stories, I'll avoid some of the mentioned contractors at an arm's length.  bruce.gif
*
Can you show some prove to show us, so we might be avoid from him, if you cannot proved that... that are meaning you are trying to talk Nonsense at this forum!
I’m fully support Mr Yap and he doing very well done job at the oval Resideces Klcc .
Please make sure that your words are correct and can show us the shit problem he been done.
surfsmurf
post Mar 20 2021, 11:49 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
101 posts

Joined: Mar 2005
QUOTE(Justin.Loong @ Mar 18 2021, 04:55 PM)
If you don't mind me asking, so how's the condition of your house now? Still many things undone?
What about the renovation parts that Mr Lim has done earlier? Is it all OK? Was the workmanship good quality or you need to fork out more money to rectify Mr Lim's errors?  sweat.gif
*
From 1st look ok. If u look closer, many walls not straight. From tiling u will know. Wall plastering not even m some wall got hairline cracks. Have to complain many times n redo still not perfect like most houses. Plaster ceiling amateur work. Not smooth n straight. Floor tiling, some tiles not even. Electrical, 1mcb trip. Since he did not pay the electrician, i cannot get him to help. Mr Lim promised to get someone to look into it. As usual empty promises. One part external wall not plastered n painted properly. Clog drains n reno rubbish, he suppose to get bin but did not. I have to slowly clear myself.

Now left autogate motor n those defects he's suppose to rectify. Quality of work juz moderate. Some work supposed to sub to a pro todo but he got no money so he ask his worker to do a sloppy job. Kitchen counter top tile edges not smoothen. He drag so long to do until i cannot wait, i install the kitchen cabinet. He assured me he will not damage the cabinet but as expected some parts got scratched.

When he first started the reno, he install the security m folding door first. Floor tiling start from the back room. He raised the floor by 4". Halfway, he realised, the security n folding door is too low. Ask me if can di slope n drop. I say no. No choice he have to remove the door frame n replace it. From this 4" raised he need to redo the windows n ceiling coz everything look too low. Best part he want to charge me for his mistake. I told him by right i should not pay for his mistake n best i could do his pay half.

Some of the not so obvious defects no choice have to live with it. More obvious ones need to get someone to rectify it. Till today he's not picking up call. Some furniture i booked more than 1 year still cannot be delivered due to this
ponyznon
post Mar 30 2021, 01:59 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
26 posts

Joined: Oct 2008
From: KL


QUOTE(Justin.Loong @ Mar 18 2021, 04:49 PM)
Is it this company?

*
Yah, is a company. You can find their company in FB or google it.

Call the technician who I deal with FFK, then I request for new technician (maybe he busy), make appointment did not come and did not call at all after that.

Dead silent.
SUSRobert.johor
post Apr 24 2021, 10:34 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
106 posts

Joined: Mar 2020

https://instagram.com/ytc_renovation?igshid=1xqt4lkn3pkh
squidsquid
post Apr 25 2021, 09:51 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
124 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
Beware of k&s specialist waterproofing. They are also known by a few other names, can google/search in facebook to know incident experienced by others. They just dont bother to reply after "finishing" their work after promising warranties.

This post has been edited by squidsquid: Apr 25 2021, 09:52 PM
donhay
post Apr 26 2021, 04:36 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Junior Member
722 posts

Joined: Apr 2008
I planed to renovated my bathroom and here is some of the quotes I got from the plumbing contractor.


To dismantle existing 2 nos bathroom sanitary ware and accessories RM400

Supply and install 2 nos 20mm chrome stop valve RM300

Supply and install 1 nos 15mm chrome stop valve RM120

Labor charges for installation 3 nos bathroom sanitary ware RM2,700

Labor charges for installation 3 nos bathroom accessories RM600


I was wondering, are the quotation fair price? Hope I get some helps here.

Thanks
vernee26
post Apr 29 2021, 12:54 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
68 posts

Joined: Jul 2010
QUOTE(Robert.johor @ Mar 20 2021, 09:12 AM)
Can you show some prove to show us, so we might be avoid from him, if you cannot proved that... that are meaning you are trying to talk Nonsense at this forum!
I’m fully support Mr Yap and he doing very well done job at the oval Resideces Klcc .
Please make sure that your words are correct and can show us the shit problem he been done.
*
Sharing my input here.

TLDR
Conclusion : I would recommend my friends and family to reach out to him if they have reno work, purely based on my discussion with him as he seems practical, honest and NO UPFRONT DEPOSIT required for wet works
Quality of work : I have no idea, have never met him before nor seen his work

I've been reading this thread and looking for tiling contractors and decided to reach out to Mr Yap and see how's it like.
My current situation : I have engaged an ID to redo my landed home. Generally, pricing still acceptable (of course slightly higher than general contractors) but tiling price was crazy expensive.

I reached out to Mr Yap today to provide a quotation for tiling works (hack existing tiles, cement screed + retile whole ground floor and toilets)

I whatsapped Mr Yap and gave him my measurements. He requested to have a call to understand better (quick response from him). He was quite chatty and wanted to provide lots of comments/input. During the call he understood my situation and provided very good practical advise :

1. Why pay deposit to wet work contractors??? (although he did say it was stupid of me to have done so, it was not harsh and I guess he was quite frustrated that consumers would do that).
His practise is that he never collects deposit but starts work first. His argument is if the company no cashflow to start work, you trust that company?
(caveat : not applicable for carpentry/built-ins as it's customized built)
Sound good in theory, but so hard to find any general contractors or even ID that doesn't require down payment

2. I shared with him my current quotation by my ID and he shared the market pricing/his indicative PSF pricing for tiling works.
He commented that my ID quote (with self purchased tiles) is expensive. If included tile price, then it's still acceptable. As there were demolishing works required (remove existing cabinets, hacking works for plumbing and electrical), he advised, better to nego with my current ID (since I've paid deposit) instead of looking for multiple subcons which will cause more communications/defect blaming headache later.

Based on the conversation I had with him, Mr Yap is practical and seems honest. Instead of wasting both our time and trying to win the job (him providing quote, site survey, me deciding whether to engage), he provided sound advise.




SUSRobert.johor
post May 1 2021, 11:09 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
106 posts

Joined: Mar 2020

QUOTE(donhay @ Apr 26 2021, 04:36 PM)
I planed to renovated my bathroom and here is some of the quotes I got from the plumbing contractor.
To dismantle existing 2 nos bathroom sanitary ware and accessories  RM400

Supply and install 2 nos 20mm chrome stop valve  RM300

Supply and install 1 nos 15mm chrome stop valve  RM120

Labor charges for installation 3 nos bathroom sanitary ware  RM2,700

Labor charges for installation 3 nos bathroom accessories RM600
I was wondering, are the quotation fair price? Hope I get some helps here.

Thanks
*
SUSRobert.johor
post May 1 2021, 11:11 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
106 posts

Joined: Mar 2020

QUOTE(Robert.johor @ May 1 2021, 11:09 PM)

*

Pricing is slightly high, perhaps it’s not bangla worker to do the installation for you. Than that all be fine.
SUSRobert.johor
post May 1 2021, 11:15 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
106 posts

Joined: Mar 2020

QUOTE(donhay @ Apr 26 2021, 04:36 PM)
I planed to renovated my bathroom and here is some of the quotes I got from the plumbing contractor.
To dismantle existing 2 nos bathroom sanitary ware and accessories  RM400

Supply and install 2 nos 20mm chrome stop valve  RM300

Supply and install 1 nos 15mm chrome stop valve  RM120

Labor charges for installation 3 nos bathroom sanitary ware  RM2,700

Labor charges for installation 3 nos bathroom accessories RM600
I was wondering, are the quotation fair price? Hope I get some helps here.

Thanks
*


The pricing are slightly high, but still ok if all worker are skill foreign worker, but must not a bangla. That should be fine from my opinion. Thanks
zzzpk
post May 2 2021, 02:29 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
48 posts

Joined: Nov 2012


I have engaged Mr. Yap for my renovation of my condo unit and please find my honest review below.

Scope of Work:
1. Plaster ceiling of the entire unit except wet kitchen and bathroom
2. Painting work for the entire unit
3. Some miscellaneous wet works (conceal water heater pipe, relocation of water outlet in wet kitchen, miscellaneous installation)
4. Wiring work (lighting installation, smart switch installation, fan installation, air conditioner installation etc.)

In general, I was very satisfied with the work done.
1. Mr. Yap provides good advice. He spends time talking to you, understanding the scope of work and providing ideas which at times is better than what my ID gave me. For example, he gave me a very good piece of advice on the wet kitchen design which I appreciate very much. He gave me suggestion on the color of the paint which I ended up using, and am very satisfied with the end result.

2. Mr. Yap insists on mutual trust between contractor and client. He does not chase me for payments, most of the time when he requested for payment, it is after the work is completed and the customer (me) is satisfied with the outcome. I have no problem in trusting him in getting the work done. He still attends to my call after receiving the final payment and arranges his workers for rectification work for defects that I only notice after I had moved in.

3. Mr. Yap is not always on site supervising his workers. Throughout my dealings with him, I think he has only been to my unit for less than 5 times in total. He has a team of very experienced workers (a team doing wet works, a team for painting and another team for wiring works). He trusts his workers a lot, some of them have been working for him for more than 10 years. There have been at times miscommunication between Mr. Yap and his workers and it would be a lie to say that I wasn't frustrated occasionally. However his workers did a good job in rectifying the issues without impacting the progress.

4. Yes it is true that the price that he quotes is higher than other contractors. I engaged two contractors for quotation but ended up going with Mr. Yap despite the higher price as I was more comfortable dealing with him.

5. His workers do smoke, but most of the time they do it in my balcony, hence I did not think it is a huge issue.

6. On the allegations regarding Mr. Yap and his partner Mr. Chong in the previous post. Personally I am not sure who Chong Chee Onn is. He does have a team doing wiring works which I always refer to as Mr. Chong (not sure if it is the same person). I had no issues dealing with Mr. Chong and his son.


Disclaimer: My reviews are based on my personal experience dealing with Mr. Yap and his team and therefore may vary for others.

This post has been edited by zzzpk: May 2 2021, 02:30 PM
neo_6053
post May 2 2021, 11:58 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
650 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


hmm.. I wonder does this Mr Yap take smaller project like around 20k one .. LOL
waghyu
post May 3 2021, 12:13 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,389 posts

Joined: Sep 2019
Pay cheap and want to complaint?
SUSRobert.johor
post May 3 2021, 01:26 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
106 posts

Joined: Mar 2020

QUOTE(neo_6053 @ May 2 2021, 11:58 PM)
hmm.. I wonder does this Mr Yap take smaller project like around 20k one .. LOL
*

You can have a try....

27 Pages « < 19 20 21 22 23 > » Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0211sec    0.58    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 25th November 2025 - 09:21 PM