Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 DIY (smart, energy efficient) house building, another house from scratch. DIY style.

views
     
TSpaskal
post Apr 28 2014, 06:20 PM, updated 8y ago

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
lets get things straight.
1. i'm not a contractor. i'm not trying to sell you anything.
this is my own house, on my own piece of land. not a documentation on some other fella house/project.
2. respect is warranted. this is not kopitiam.

the initial plan was to acquire this land and build a house at this location:
user posted image
effective ~10,000 sqft after minus all the road reserve and sea reserve.

imagine opening your door to this, every morning, for the rest of your life.
user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image

and kitchen and deck opens up to this
user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image

there's a wave breaker as you can see, and even at high tide, the sea level doesn't rise past the barrier. even then there's a drainage system to avoid seawater from going into paddy fields. MADA takes great precaution to avoid such situation from ever happening.

the land deal however, didn't went through. sigh.
proceeding with backup plan.

This post has been edited by paskal: Jun 19 2018, 03:08 PM
TSpaskal
post Apr 28 2014, 06:26 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
proceeding with backup plan.
user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image
~7000 sqft effective (100ftx70ft).
with a small stream in front of the land. and the soil is naturally good for plants.

not as nice, but i do get ~15km unobstructed view at the back. naturally windy, and safe from tsunami hahaha.

This post has been edited by paskal: Nov 9 2014, 05:25 PM
ShadowR1
post Apr 28 2014, 06:31 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


Since you are already doing what I just had in mind, perhaps I can learn a thing or two from here.


koinibler
post Apr 28 2014, 06:53 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,050 posts

Joined: Dec 2009
From: DC
Okay, already track this topic. Waiting for further post.
DeanWong118
post Apr 28 2014, 08:07 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
255 posts

Joined: Mar 2014


QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 28 2014, 06:26 PM)
proceeding with backup plan.
user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image
~7000 sqft effective (100ftx70ft).
with a small stream in front of the land. and the soil is naturally good for plants.

not as nice, but i do get ~15km unobstructed view at the back. naturally windy, and safe from tsunami hahaha.
jokes aside the area posted before did get hit by the previous tsunami. you know the one where some died at batu ferigghi? yes, it hit the area and low area are flooded with some damages done to people houses. some houses are even swept away.
*
I want see ur further post rolleyes.gif
PangurBan
post Apr 28 2014, 08:38 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
584 posts

Joined: Nov 2008
From: Ulaan Baatar, Mongolia


Not scared kena another tsunami ah?
cdspins
post Apr 28 2014, 10:44 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,714 posts

Joined: May 2008


nice piece of land you have there....
TSpaskal
post Apr 29 2014, 08:19 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
if you engage an architect, insist that they do a site survey or site study.
it's the only way to check for sun movement and wind direction in the area. simple info that will make your house cooler and properly ventilated.

avoid orientating the largest wall in the house against sunshine as it will heat up the area inside. avoid arranging bedrooms directly facing the evening sun as it'll make your room hot at night.
and change the direction of your window opening to guide wind into your house, rather than deflecting them away.

user posted image
user posted image
can't find the complete 3D design since there's so many interation and revisions to the plan. it's in here, somewhere.
but the cheapest i got quoted for this plan is RM260k.
basic house, basic equipment, good build quality (from contractor past build history).

specs agreed for RM260k:
12 feet wall
metal deck (because roof pitch is only 5 degrees x 40 feet)
insulated roof
folding door, folding window
full plaster ceiling, 10 feet high
normal downlight, cfl bulb
normal ceiling fan with regulator
16" tile, entire house
full height tile in bathroom
normal paint, indoor and outdoor
normal bathroom finishing
no outdoor tile
no glass railing as in pic

IIRC 4 bathroom, 5 bedroom, 1 ht room, wet & dry kitchen, separated guest living room & dining area, family area, 2nd floor family area, 2 decks.
~3000 sqft interior floorspace.
translates to ~RM86-something psft

edit: (refer post below for accurate floorspace)

This post has been edited by paskal: May 5 2014, 10:23 AM
jagjag
post Apr 29 2014, 09:15 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
537 posts

Joined: Jan 2012
From: Rachong


Where is the location..???
TSpaskal
post Apr 29 2014, 09:33 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


found the floorplan to the 3D which i've submitted for quotation.
user posted image
user posted image
correction it's not 2400 sqft. total interior space is 3143 sqft.
RM260k, which translate to ~RM83 psft.

deck and porch at half of the interior price. total build price not breaching RM300k.
5 bedroom, 1 ht room.
separated wet & dry kitchen.
2 family area at ground floor & 2nd floor.
6 bathroom
indoor store room
separated guest area & dining area

hard to believe?
believe it.
SUSsupersound
post Apr 29 2014, 09:36 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
Building a bungalow you can't avoid west.
Only way is extend the roof by another 2-3 ft
rm86 is dirt cheap already.
With 7000sqft of land, I'll prefer to build single storey rather than double storey. 2400sqft of total build up, if double storey translate to about 30*40ft or 20*60 which will make the land area very big(and hard to maintain if your family are not big).
weikee
post Apr 29 2014, 09:37 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
Nice project. The price you got is it including fitting and id? Ready move in (excluding appliances and furniture)


QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 09:33 AM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


found the floorplan to the 3D which i've submitted for quotation.
user posted image
user posted image
correction it's not 2400 sqft. total interior space is 3143 sqft.
RM260k, which translate to ~RM83 psft.

deck and porch at half of the interior price. total build price not breaching RM300k.
5 bedroom, 1 ht room.
separated wet & dry kitchen.
2 family area at ground floor & 2nd floor.
6 bathroom
indoor store room
separated guest area & dining area

hard to believe?
believe it.
*
mx007
post Apr 29 2014, 09:41 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
153 posts

Joined: Jul 2008


U sure you are going with metal decking roof next to a beach? better get a properly treated one, and plus, wouldnt you want a roof deck so you can have an outdoor barbecue next to the beach on your house? or probably just a lemonade on your roof?

You can have a flat roof first
TSpaskal
post Apr 29 2014, 09:51 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Apr 29 2014, 09:36 AM)
rm86 is dirt cheap already.
*
2 friends managed to negotiate with the same contractor and got their houses build for RM75 & RM78 psft. already finished construction in 2013 and moved in.

QUOTE(supersound @ Apr 29 2014, 09:36 AM)
With 7000sqft of land, I'll prefer to build single storey rather than double storey. 2400sqft of total build up, if double storey translate to about 30*40ft or 20*60 which will make the land area very big(and hard to maintain if your family are not big).
*
spot on.
after discussion with friends and relatives owning double storey houses, they advised against proceeding with the plan since there's no constraint with land area.

but but but. double storey looks really nice.
but they suggested that it's a nuisance having to climb up and down the stairs everyday.

QUOTE(weikee @ Apr 29 2014, 09:37 AM)
Nice project. The price you got is it including fitting and id? Ready move in (excluding appliances and furniture)
*
no ID. contractor only gonna include a concrete table top at the wet kitchen.
SUSsupersound
post Apr 29 2014, 09:55 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 09:51 AM)
2 friends managed to negotiate with the same contractor and got their houses build for RM75 & RM78 psft. already finished construction in 2013 and moved in.
spot on.
after discussion with friends and relatives owning double storey houses, they advised against proceeding with the plan since there's no constraint with land area.

but but but. double storey looks really nice.
but they suggested that it's a nuisance having to climb up and down the stairs everyday.
no ID. contractor only gonna include a concrete table top at the wet kitchen.
*
Listen to old man says.
Actually I prefer bungalow land of 5000-6000sqft, easier to maintain. Now I in the search of such sized land also, sadly, all are >7000sqft and shouting for rm40-50 per sqft doh.gif
toekong
post Apr 29 2014, 10:02 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
240 posts

Joined: Aug 2007


QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 09:33 AM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


found the floorplan to the 3D which i've submitted for quotation.
user posted image
user posted image
correction it's not 2400 sqft. total interior space is 3143 sqft.
RM260k, which translate to ~RM83 psft.

deck and porch at half of the interior price. total build price not breaching RM300k.
5 bedroom, 1 ht room.
separated wet & dry kitchen.
2 family area at ground floor & 2nd floor.
6 bathroom
indoor store room
separated guest area & dining area

hard to believe?
believe it.
*
1) May i ask why do u have a 6.5' of empty space beside the study? why not extend it all the way there?
2) open staircase concept?? nice...
weikee
post Apr 29 2014, 10:09 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 09:51 AM)
2 friends managed to negotiate with the same contractor and got their houses build for RM75 & RM78 psft. already finished construction in 2013 and moved in.
spot on.
after discussion with friends and relatives owning double storey houses, they advised against proceeding with the plan since there's no constraint with land area.

but but but. double storey looks really nice.
but they suggested that it's a nuisance having to climb up and down the stairs everyday.
no ID. contractor only gonna include a concrete table top at the wet kitchen.
*
Look like need another 300 - 400k on ID depend your taste smile.gif
ShadowR1
post Apr 29 2014, 01:04 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


Thanks for sharing guys, can the property build on any type of land or it must be on a residential gazetted land.

SUSsupersound
post Apr 29 2014, 01:37 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 29 2014, 01:04 PM)
Thanks for sharing guys, can the property build on any type of land or it must be on a residential gazetted land.
*
Must be resident land.
TSpaskal
post Apr 29 2014, 02:06 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(mx007 @ Apr 29 2014, 09:41 AM)
U sure you are going with metal decking roof next to a beach? better get a properly treated one, and plus, wouldnt you want a roof deck so you can have an outdoor barbecue next to the beach on your house? or probably just a lemonade on your roof?

You can have a flat roof first
*
did considered flat roof, but considering the amount of things that could go wrong with the concrete, i would pass.
also considered a parapet wall, with metal decking to cover. but considering that it'll only welcome fungus growth, also avoided.

anyway i didn't get the seaside land.

QUOTE(toekong @ Apr 29 2014, 10:02 AM)
1) May i ask why do u have a 6.5' of empty space beside the study? why not extend it all the way there?
2) open staircase concept?? nice...
*
there's an entrance there, family entrance. the space is the walkway.

QUOTE(weikee @ Apr 29 2014, 10:09 AM)
Look like need another 300 - 400k on ID depend your taste smile.gif
*
how did you arrive at that estimation? another couple of hundred thousand just for interior design is a bit too much don't you think?

QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 29 2014, 01:04 PM)
Thanks for sharing guys, can the property build on any type of land or it must be on a residential gazetted land.
*
if it's an agricultural land, you're entitled to 1 building per each land title. so don't have to change the land type if you're thinking of building.

otherwise you need to change the type to residential or development. changing agricultural type to residential do take time and you need written consent from your local council. they have specific rules on what type of land that cannot be changed so be wary.
weikee
post Apr 29 2014, 02:11 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 02:06 PM)
did considered flat roof, but considering the amount of things that could go wrong with the concrete, i would pass.
also considered a parapet wall, with metal decking to cover. but considering that it'll only welcome fungus growth, also avoided.

anyway i didn't get the seaside land.
there's an entrance there, family entrance. the space is the walkway.
how did you arrive at that estimation? another couple of hundred thousand just for interior design is a bit too much don't you think?
if it's an agricultural land, you're entitled to 1 building per each land title. so don't have to change the land type if you're thinking of building.

otherwise you need to change the type to residential or development. changing agricultural type to residential do take time and you need written consent from your local council. they have specific rules on what type of land that cannot be changed so be wary.
*
ID as in finishing like tiles, marbles, flooring, doors, windows all this not cheap. My wet work on my house vs interior is almost 1:1 ratio.
ShadowR1
post Apr 29 2014, 02:49 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 02:06 PM)
if it's an agricultural land, you're entitled to 1 building per each land title. so don't have to change the land type if you're thinking of building.

otherwise you need to change the type to residential or development. changing agricultural type to residential do take time and you need written consent from your local council. they have specific rules on what type of land that cannot be changed so be wary.
*
Thanks for the info, in short we can build one building in a piece of land say (1 acre size) in any type of land other than resi land where you can build more, does it constrain on the height (eg not more than 3 story) or the size of that one building.
SUSsupersound
post Apr 29 2014, 03:11 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 02:06 PM)
did considered flat roof, but considering the amount of things that could go wrong with the concrete, i would pass.
also considered a parapet wall, with metal decking to cover. but considering that it'll only welcome fungus growth, also avoided.

anyway i didn't get the seaside land.
there's an entrance there, family entrance. the space is the walkway.
how did you arrive at that estimation? another couple of hundred thousand just for interior design is a bit too much don't you think?
if it's an agricultural land, you're entitled to 1 building per each land title. so don't have to change the land type if you're thinking of building.

otherwise you need to change the type to residential or development. changing agricultural type to residential do take time and you need written consent from your local council. they have specific rules on what type of land that cannot be changed so be wary.
*
Forgot totally that agri land can build a house inside doh.gif
Too bad Seremban most of the agri land are for bumi only cry.gif
No need to engage ID whistling.gif since it will bring up your overall building cost by 100-200% for the same work if you design your self.
Since you have plenty of space, built in ceiling height cabinets are not a must compare to terrace house.
Always put practicality, ergonomics in mind.
Air cond compressor mounting you can make concrete table for it, look more neat thumbup.gif
ShadowR1
post Apr 29 2014, 03:19 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(supersound @ Apr 29 2014, 03:11 PM)
Forgot totally that agri land can build a house inside doh.gif
Too bad Seremban most of the agri land are for bumi only cry.gif
No need to engage ID whistling.gif since it will bring up your overall building cost by 100-200% for the same work if you design your self.
Since you have plenty of space, built in ceiling height cabinets are not a must compare to terrace house.
Always put practicality, ergonomics in mind.
Air cond compressor mounting you can make concrete table for it, look more neat thumbup.gif
*
Agree on this, huge difference in $$$ when im doing my DS house 6 years ago.
Jenn77
post Apr 29 2014, 03:20 PM

Look Ma' Im Flyin! Gee~
*******
Senior Member
3,118 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: SA.KD.SA.KD


Nice.. following the developments.. all the best paskal kianwee

This post has been edited by Jenn77: Apr 29 2014, 03:20 PM
SUSsupersound
post Apr 29 2014, 03:32 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 29 2014, 02:49 PM)
Thanks for the info, in short we can build one building in a piece of land say (1 acre size) in any type of land other than resi land where you can build more, does it constrain on the height (eg not more than 3 story) or the size of that one building.
*
I will just build single storey with that size of land. Then plant tree around to cover the building biggrin.gif

QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 29 2014, 03:19 PM)
Agree on this, huge difference in $$$ when im doing my DS house 6 years ago.
*
If we know the basics, we don't need ID in the first place. If you are a Chinese, feng shui is 1 of the element we need to consider, so can't simply use reflecting materials on the cabinet doors, on the wall and so on.
Using solid finishing will look dull or old fashioned. Some soft color finish will be the best and nearer to wet kitchen should be using darker color(dirty also not that obvious).
If worry to get wet, aluminum cabinet at bottom(mine are concrete table and finish it with aluminum sliding doors) while MDF/chipboard cabinet on top.
ShadowR1
post Apr 29 2014, 04:50 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(supersound @ Apr 29 2014, 03:32 PM)
I will just build single storey with that size of land. Then plant tree around to cover the building biggrin.gif
*
Something like this ...



Attached thumbnail(s)
Attached Image Attached Image
SUSsupersound
post Apr 29 2014, 08:15 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 29 2014, 04:50 PM)
Something like this ...
*
thumbup.gif thumbup.gif thumbup.gif
lionfish77
post Apr 29 2014, 08:43 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
207 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 09:33 AM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


found the floorplan to the 3D which i've submitted for quotation.
user posted image
user posted image
correction it's not 2400 sqft. total interior space is 3143 sqft.
RM260k, which translate to ~RM83 psft.

deck and porch at half of the interior price. total build price not breaching RM300k.
5 bedroom, 1 ht room.
separated wet & dry kitchen.
2 family area at ground floor & 2nd floor.
6 bathroom
indoor store room
separated guest area & dining area

hard to believe?
believe it.
*
rm83/sqft is do-able based on the plan shown and with basic finishing. I completed my house last year and it cost me around rm130/sqft. but my house is much bigger at 6000sqft and with slightly better finishing. The amount of concrete used also quite a lot since part of my roof is concrete roof.
For this to be possible, you cannot engage a contractor; you need to hire the indon workers yourself and be the project manager - manage everything yourself. One important thing is to get a good "chief indon" worker - who can help you manage the other workers. Other than that you will get a bit of headache every now and then ... after then you house will be ready! not impossible at all.

lionfish77
post Apr 29 2014, 08:47 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
207 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 29 2014, 04:50 PM)
Something like this ...
*
something like this looks simple but actually not that easy to build. concrete formwork must be good ... otherwise, you cannot get this beautiful fair-face concrete.

i have only seen a few houses like this in kl but not as nice as in the picture.
DeanWong118
post Apr 29 2014, 11:52 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
255 posts

Joined: Mar 2014


QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 29 2014, 04:50 PM)
Something like this ...
*
Don't build this type of house, no gate and fence here.
Later kena rob.
starmexx
post Apr 30 2014, 02:08 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
11 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
No where near to building my own house from scratch yet... But this thread will be a good read!!!

p/s: TS, great land!!!!
ShadowR1
post Apr 30 2014, 12:46 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(lionfish77 @ Apr 29 2014, 08:43 PM)
rm83/sqft is do-able based on the plan shown and with basic finishing. I completed my house last year and it cost me around rm130/sqft. but my house is much bigger at 6000sqft and with slightly better finishing. The amount of concrete used also quite a lot since part of my roof is concrete roof.
For this to be possible, you cannot engage a contractor; you need to hire the indon workers yourself and be the project manager - manage everything yourself. One important thing is to get a good "chief indon" worker - who can help you manage the other workers. Other than that you will get a bit of headache every now and then ... after then you house will be ready! not impossible at all.
*
thumbup.gif
Noobl3t
post Apr 30 2014, 09:33 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Apr 30 2014, 12:46 PM)
thumbup.gif
*
TS already stated that 2 houses have already been completed, and these 2 houses were his friends'. If it was that terrible, his friend wouldn't have recommended to him.
TSpaskal
post May 4 2014, 03:49 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
site survey.

user posted image

there's 2 prevalent wind direction, which change according to the northeast or southwest monsoon season.
sunrise and sunset movement are also shown. the sun rises at relatively the same position but sets at different location according to the season.

land plot is actually square, but drawn in trapezoid because i'm bad at drawing artsy.
drawing not according to scale. it's a sketch afterall.
Noobl3t
post May 5 2014, 11:06 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 02:06 PM)
otherwise you need to change the type to residential or development. changing agricultural type to residential do take time and you need written consent from your local council. they have specific rules on what type of land that cannot be changed so be wary.
*
What are the cons and pros if having a property on agriculture land vs residential land?

What kind of paper work/authorities do I have to approach in order to build a house in agriculture/residential land?

Thx. Hehe I can't wait to see ur dream house coming true. smile.gif
TSpaskal
post May 5 2014, 01:27 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
there's quite a number of arrangement that we could make to integrate the view, wind direction and sunshine.
the only thing that have to be fixed is the car porch which should be facing the entrance.
user posted image

in total, i think there's more than 20 revisions made to the plan before we finalized the layout.
friends commented that if were to engage an architect for all of this, it's surely going to cost me an arm just for the drawing.
user posted image

QUOTE(Noobl3t @ May 5 2014, 11:06 AM)
What are the cons and pros if having a property on agriculture land vs residential land?

What kind of paper work/authorities do I have to approach in order to build a house in agriculture/residential land?

Thx. Hehe I can't wait to see ur dream house coming true. smile.gif
*
no idea. maybe the land + house value is lower because the land type is agriculture.

first check with your land office. as land code is different from state to state. then check with your local council because they're the one you're gonna be submitting the plans to.
meteoraniac
post May 5 2014, 02:21 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,099 posts

Joined: Aug 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ May 5 2014, 01:27 PM)
there's quite a number of arrangement that we could make to integrate the view, wind direction and sunshine.
the only thing that have to be fixed is the car porch which should be facing the entrance.
office. as land code is different from state to state. then check with your local council because they're the one you're gonna be submitting the plans to.
*
It seems like the wind are directed to the walls. Have you considered positioning the house in a way where the wind directly flows into the living room/open deck, through the house for an unobstructed open ventilation? Most traditional kampung houses are designed in this way, which is why it's always feel more cooling in kampung house.

Just to share, I'm modelling this house for my upcoming construction (not my pics*).

good luck in your construction.


user posted image

user posted image

user posted image
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «




TSpaskal
post May 6 2014, 12:20 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(meteoraniac @ May 5 2014, 02:21 PM)
It seems like the wind are directed to the walls. Have you considered positioning the house in a way where the wind directly flows into the living room/open deck, through the house for an unobstructed open ventilation? Most traditional kampung houses are designed in this way, which is why it's always feel more cooling in kampung house.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
*
thanks for the suggestion. we indeed have positioned the layout so that the wind is directed into the house, tho not following the one in your picture.
reason being, the wind do get quite violent at times, so arranging large glass panels directly opposing them is avoided in my design.

the side of the house facing the wind direction are filled with bedrooms. nice view from the bedroom, smaller glass panels facing the wind and hidden from the entrance/service road.

you're considering that much glass panel to your design? it's gonna be hard to secure from break-ins with that much unprotected glass. and adding iron grille to it would just be too ugly.
what's your idea on this issue?
ShadowR1
post May 6 2014, 12:43 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


You opt for 5mm tempered lami glass which is much stronger than normal glass ... but if given ample time and tools, the burglar will still be able to break in.

I use 8mm tempered lami glass as flooring for my fish pond and its safe for human traffic on top of it.
TSpaskal
post May 6 2014, 12:58 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ May 6 2014, 12:43 PM)
You opt for 5mm tempered lami glass which is much stronger than normal glass ... but if given ample time and tools, the burglar will still be able to break in.

I use 8mm tempered lami glass as flooring for my fish pond and its safe for human traffic on top of it.
*
wahlauweh. issit true? at the recent homedec, i was quoted something around ~RM70+ psft for folding doors and windows with 8.38mm laminated glass. indeed i'm considering them as the budget for folding door & window is RM20k.

gosh. all this discussion make me wanna revise the plan, AGAIN. arghhhh
meteoraniac
post May 6 2014, 01:57 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,099 posts

Joined: Aug 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ May 6 2014, 12:20 PM)
thanks for the suggestion. we indeed have positioned the layout so that the wind is directed into the house, tho not following the one in your picture.
reason being, the wind do get quite violent at times, so arranging large glass panels directly opposing them is avoided in my design.

the side of the house facing the wind direction are filled with bedrooms. nice view from the bedroom, smaller glass panels facing the wind and hidden from the entrance/service road.

you're considering that much glass panel to your design? it's gonna be hard to secure from break-ins with that much unprotected glass. and adding iron grille to it would just be too ugly.
what's your idea on this issue?
*
yea, we prefer natural lighting and a bit more breeze, so we have to compromise that for higher budget on security systems

we allocate this budget on slightly better aluminium doors/windows with security tinted glass and a better lock mechanism and hinges. grilles are not our cup of tea too due to aesthetic reasons and also it doesn't 100% deter would be burglars breaking in, more to delaying their time.

our planned security system would have these layers:

layer 1. perimeter guard
layer 2. secure windows/door
layer 3. vibration/motion sensors

perimeter guard:
user posted image
ShadowR1
post May 6 2014, 02:25 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(paskal @ May 6 2014, 12:58 PM)
wahlauweh. issit true? at the recent homedec, i was quoted something around ~RM70+ psft for folding doors and windows with 8.38mm laminated glass. indeed i'm considering them as the budget for folding door & window is RM20k.

gosh. all this discussion make me wanna revise the plan, AGAIN. arghhhh
*
I cant really recall how much I pay for the glass as its a few years ago. I have try to jump from a 5 feet high onto the glass and it doesnt crack (do not do this) So giving that, it will surely delay the break in while the vibration sensor is kick in.

QUOTE(meteoraniac @ May 6 2014, 01:57 PM)
yea, we prefer natural lighting and a bit more breeze, so we have to compromise that for higher budget on security systems

we allocate this budget on slightly better aluminium doors/windows with security tinted glass and a better lock mechanism and hinges. grilles are not our cup of tea too due to aesthetic reasons and also it doesn't 100% deter would be burglars breaking in, more to delaying their time.

our planned security system would have these layers:

layer 1. perimeter guard
layer 2. secure windows/door
layer 3. vibration/motion sensors

perimeter guard:
user posted image
*
Nicely thought off, may I suggest :-
layer 1. perimeter guard (Alarm buzzer and electrical shock wire, voltage is just enough to shock and not kill)

TSpaskal
post May 6 2014, 04:45 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
sketched the outlook if should i use parapet walls to cover the low angle roof.
and got this:
user posted image
10 degrees pitch and 5 degrees pitch, covered with 3' parapet wall.

user posted image
17 degrees pitch and 5 degrees pitch, 6' parapet

user posted image
3' parapet, 5 degrees pitch.

but i still think this looks better:
user posted image
15 degrees pitch

user posted image
17 degrees pitch

we've experimented with quite a number of roof design:
user posted image

any suggestion?
SUSsupersound
post May 6 2014, 05:30 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
Should be DIY style design, unless you build your own.
ShadowR1
post May 6 2014, 06:04 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


How about a one piece slanted cantilever roof.
TSpaskal
post May 6 2014, 07:36 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ May 6 2014, 06:04 PM)
How about a one piece slanted cantilever roof.
*
something like this?
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
windwong
post May 6 2014, 08:04 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
196 posts

Joined: Nov 2008


15 and 17 degree looks great. Looks more cosy. the one piece slanted looks like factory design
ShadowR1
post May 6 2014, 08:12 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(paskal @ May 6 2014, 07:36 PM)
something like this?
user posted image
user posted image
*
This two looks good. Its very good for rain harvesting as well if you are into it and you have high ceiling height.

This is not bad too, construction wise I can only think of I beam and wrap with aluminium ...
Attached Image

This post has been edited by ShadowR1: May 6 2014, 08:14 PM
TSpaskal
post May 8 2014, 12:32 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
floorplan:
user posted image

with dimension:
user posted image
TSpaskal
post May 9 2014, 10:58 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
walls, windows and openings added.
user posted image

all the walls are spec-ed at 12cm, except for the ht room wall which is spec-ed at 24cm.
24cm ala DIY style. double bricked wall with an air gap to have maximum sound attenuation. thick wall, so should have no problem mounting double door to the ht room. if required. maybe.

user posted image
walls and interior spaces rearranged so that there's minimal cutting needed to the tile.
since it's DIY, i could spec the walls and spaces to be in exact feet length, to the nearest cm, nearest half a meter or whatever i want. might as well spec it to be in multiples of 60cm.
SUSsupersound
post May 9 2014, 11:07 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
Kitchen should not be too near to main door.
ShadowR1
post May 9 2014, 11:51 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


Wet kitchen ... heavily ventilated ?

Edited ...
Stuffing fiberglass in the air gap of the HT wall ?

Structural drawing ?

This post has been edited by ShadowR1: May 9 2014, 11:55 PM
TSpaskal
post May 16 2014, 05:50 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ May 9 2014, 11:07 PM)
Kitchen should not be too near to main door.
*
why's that? any particular reason it's not recommended?

QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ May 9 2014, 11:51 PM)
Wet kitchen ... heavily ventilated ?
*
you could say that. i'll try and post the 3d for the wet kitchen.
not planning to put cooker hood on top of the cooking area. so there's no top cabinet at the cooking cabinet. just exhaust fan.

QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ May 9 2014, 11:51 PM)
Stuffing fiberglass in the air gap of the HT wall ?
*
nope. just gonna leave it empty. air gap.

QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ May 9 2014, 11:51 PM)
Structural drawing ?
*
don't have it yet. it's all diy, so haven't draw.
got a sketch for the main structures tho. drawn sketched by a civil engineer.
DBKL
post May 16 2014, 05:55 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Apr 2014

impressive, as an architect, i like 17 inch pitch roof, anything regarding the design layout, can ask me, i can give my opinion.

Thnks!
ShadowR1
post May 16 2014, 05:58 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(DBKL @ May 16 2014, 05:55 PM)
impressive, as an architect, i like 17 inch pitch roof, anything regarding the design layout, can ask me, i can give my opinion.

Thnks!
*
thumbup.gif
champu
post May 16 2014, 05:59 PM

Champu
****
Senior Member
633 posts

Joined: Apr 2014



are you thinking abt self-sustaining module? i.e. Solar panels etc. If so then more roof-area could be useful.

My 2 cents if I plan on doing a DIY house smile.gif
DBKL
post May 16 2014, 06:01 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Apr 2014

how about internal courtyard... open bath... private space... interesting right.. you can play around!! dont be scared! biggrin.gif
DBKL
post May 16 2014, 06:03 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Apr 2014

your master bedroom so pity, the shape not defining the 'MASTER' itself.. wink.gif
DBKL
post May 16 2014, 06:04 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Apr 2014

how about a bit of privacy of outdoor deck for your beautiful queen. brows.gif
DBKL
post May 16 2014, 06:06 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Apr 2014

QUOTE(champu @ May 16 2014, 05:59 PM)
are you thinking abt self-sustaining module? i.e. Solar panels etc. If so then more roof-area could be useful.

My 2 cents if I plan on doing a DIY house smile.gif
*
no need solar panel..expensive i guess..
why not passive energy?

natural ventilation..
sun orientation..
wind stack effect

rclxm9.gif

wowwiiii
champu
post May 16 2014, 07:29 PM

Champu
****
Senior Member
633 posts

Joined: Apr 2014



QUOTE(DBKL @ May 16 2014, 06:06 PM)
no need solar panel..expensive i guess..
why not passive energy?

natural ventilation..
sun orientation..
wind stack effect

rclxm9.gif

wowwiiii
*
If i have the kind of real-estate you do, I'd be intent on making some money out of it.

Say you consume less than the what the solar panel provides, you can supply the excess energy to TNB line and get money out of it. So the ROI for the expensive solar panels can be paid off quicker.

Just my thoughts biggrin.gif
jattmisc
post May 16 2014, 07:55 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
72 posts

Joined: Nov 2006


Hi..is this located sumwhere in yan?
SUSsupersound
post May 16 2014, 09:15 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ May 16 2014, 05:50 PM)
why's that? any particular reason it's not recommended?
you could say that. i'll try and post the 3d for the wet kitchen.
not planning to put cooker hood on top of the cooking area. so there's no top cabinet at the cooking cabinet. just exhaust fan.
nope. just gonna leave it empty. air gap.
don't have it yet. it's all diy, so haven't draw.
got a sketch for the main structures tho. drawn sketched by a civil engineer.
*
Logical thinking.
Is like putting your backside in front.
Anything should go on order, eat with mouth, sheet from back side.
shonen2004
post May 17 2014, 10:03 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
5 posts

Joined: May 2014
QUOTE(paskal @ May 8 2014, 12:32 PM)
floorplan:
user posted image

with dimension:
user posted image
*
Why do I feel that the master bedroom is a bit small..
Overall, the floorplan is very nice though..
TSpaskal
post May 17 2014, 01:33 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(champu @ May 16 2014, 05:59 PM)
are you thinking abt self-sustaining module? i.e. Solar panels etc. If so then more roof-area could be useful.

My 2 cents if I plan on doing a DIY house smile.gif
*
solar panels are not viable for implementation. the cost is too high.
the house will be built in area that have lots of sunshine, but the panel cost is too much considering how much output it generates.

QUOTE(DBKL @ May 16 2014, 06:01 PM)
how about internal courtyard... open bath... private space... interesting right.. you can play around!! dont be scared! biggrin.gif
*
trying to avoid those as budget is limited. we're steering clear of negative spaces to maximize interior space.
tho internal garden will be implemented as part of future extension plan.

refer plan below.

QUOTE(DBKL @ May 16 2014, 06:03 PM)
your master bedroom so pity, the shape not defining the 'MASTER' itself.. wink.gif
*
the master bedroom size is already 17'x15'. the toilet took a lot of space since wife really (really really) wants a jacuzzi in there.
so to fit in a 1.5mx1.5m jacuzzi we have to compromise the bedroom size.

i have to agree the master bedroom size isn't as large as most RM1million houses that i've been, but for my requirement it's adequate. i'm not planning to put a TV or a work desk in there. my previous main bedroom is only 12'x12'

QUOTE(DBKL @ May 16 2014, 06:04 PM)
how about a bit of privacy of outdoor deck for your beautiful queen.  brows.gif
*
budget constraints.

QUOTE(champu @ May 16 2014, 07:29 PM)
If i have the kind of real-estate you do, I'd be intent on making some money out of it.

Say you consume less than the what the solar panel provides, you can supply the excess energy to TNB line and get money out of it. So the ROI for the expensive solar panels can be paid off quicker.

Just my thoughts  biggrin.gif
*
do more extensive research for the solar feed-in-tariff to change your mind.
currently it costs circa RM10k for 1kW panel. say you get 10 hours of sunlight from 8am-6pm everyday, generating 10kW of electricity.
that's 10 unit of power, which you paid in average 30 cents per unit from TNB. so everyday you generate RM3 of electricity at best case scenario.
every month RM90. so RM10k will take you 9.2 years to break even. in a perfect situation.

after 10 years something will almost certainly break. and if it does then there goes your investment.
the only reason people are going for solar FIT is because TNB is paying them a lot more compared to the rate. 4-5 times more.
read more about the solar fit tariff. there's even a few threads here in lowyat.

QUOTE(jattmisc @ May 16 2014, 07:55 PM)
Hi..is this located sumwhere in yan?
*
no. further north near the border to perlis.

QUOTE(supersound @ May 16 2014, 09:15 PM)
Logical thinking.
Is like putting your backside in front.
Anything should go on order, eat with mouth, sheet from back side.
*
logic not found.
we purposely put the kitchen there so it's easier to see if someone's coming through the entrance and porch.
furthermore it's not wet kitchen there. it's the dry kitchen, which is more functional as the dining area.

i find it a hassle having to drag an entire trunk full of groceries through the main door, living room, pass the dining area just to get to the kitchen.
the proposed plan fully separate guest and family area. guests don't have to see the kitchen and family area. and family members have easy access to the family area and bedrooms.
SUSsupersound
post May 17 2014, 01:38 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ May 17 2014, 01:33 PM)
solar panels are not viable for implementation. the cost is too high.

logic not found.
we purposely put the kitchen there so it's easier to see if someone's coming through the entrance and porch.
furthermore it's not wet kitchen there. it's the dry kitchen, which is more functional as the dining area.

i find it a hassle having to drag an entire trunk full of groceries through the main door, living room, pass the dining area just to get to the kitchen.
the proposed plan fully separate guest and family area. guests don't have to see the kitchen and family area. and family members have easy access to the family area and bedrooms.
*
So basically you are following a flat's concept.
TSpaskal
post May 17 2014, 01:51 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(DBKL @ May 16 2014, 06:06 PM)
no need solar panel..expensive i guess..
why not passive energy?

natural ventilation..
sun orientation..
wind stack effect
*
natural ventilation is indeed considered. together with sun orientation.
sun movement and natural lighting for the proposed design is even simulated in google earth and sketchup to make sure i don't get too much sunlight and heat up the house.

any good idea on how to improve the ventilation? i've posted the wind direction and sun movement before.
user posted image

QUOTE(shonen2004 @ May 17 2014, 10:03 AM)
Why do I feel that the master bedroom is a bit small..
Overall, the floorplan is very nice though..
*
it is quite small. the HT room is the single biggest room in the house.
for the current funding situation, must make do. can move the master bedroom to another part of the house if should i proceed to extend the house. refer extension plan below.

user posted image
something like this. not in any way final.
but i could add another ~1000 sqft to the house for another RM80-100k. additional 4 more bedrooms and an indoor garden.
in 10 years time, maybe. if necessary.
TSpaskal
post May 17 2014, 01:58 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ May 17 2014, 01:38 PM)
So basically you are following a flat's concept.
*
i'm not an architect. not familiar as to how flats are designed.
it looks like a flat, designed like a flat, but 3x the space of a flat. must be an expensive condo.
SUSsupersound
post May 17 2014, 02:15 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ May 17 2014, 01:58 PM)
i'm not an architect. not familiar as to how flats are designed.
it looks like a flat, designed like a flat, but 3x the space of a flat. must be an expensive condo.
*
Well, when we have the land to design, might as well design it perfectly.
Try design it such that it is truly square or rectangle without too much angles, it will really make the house looks bigger.
And I won't build too much of kitchen cabinets also. Big house with cramped cabinets will make it small.
payamam
post May 17 2014, 05:58 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
347 posts

Joined: Nov 2013
Tracking this thead. I'm very interested with building own house. Now i'm in the quest of finding land at the reasonable price.
TSpaskal
post May 18 2014, 05:02 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
tiles bought.
niro granite basaltina.
grey basalt and dark grey basalt.
user posted image
these have been sitting outside for a couple of weeks now. for testing purposes.

we're going for a modern look, without all that shiny shiny mirror finish floor effect.

user posted image
experimented with a couple of designs, and opting for a simple straight parallel line across the room.

proposed tiling plan.
user posted image
most of the house will be using the basaltina, except for main living room and guest dining area.
wife wants a cement or concrete finish for that area.

she won't let me put the same tile in my ht room. mad.gif
Noobl3t
post Jun 3 2014, 10:22 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
I'm wondering who else did you hire to build your house...like planner, M&E consultant, etc. What kind of paper work is require at certain stages of the house building, paper work for authorities etc?

How's your tiles durable test going?


blahnik
post Jun 3 2014, 11:19 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
37 posts

Joined: Nov 2008


Interesting post! Am gonna follow this post
ozak
post Jun 4 2014, 09:08 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ May 17 2014, 01:51 PM)
natural ventilation is indeed considered. together with sun orientation.
sun movement and natural lighting for the proposed design is even simulated in google earth and sketchup to make sure i don't get too much sunlight and heat up the house.

any good idea on how to improve the ventilation? i've posted the wind direction and sun movement before.
user posted image
it is quite small. the HT room is the single biggest room in the house.
for the current funding situation, must make do. can move the master bedroom to another part of the house if should i proceed to extend the house. refer extension plan below.

user posted image
something like this. not in any way final.
but i could add another ~1000 sqft to the house for another RM80-100k. additional 4 more bedrooms and an indoor garden.
in 10 years time, maybe. if necessary.
*
Since you built your own house and looking some idea and solution, you can read something from here --> http://www.cooltek.org/

This site is from a British couple who retired here and built their own house in golf course air keroh. He write very detail how to cool down, save energy and other about built a house. Earn many award also.

But he no longer update his website since he pass away suddenly 2yrs ago . sad.gif You can download his report and others to read and follow.
TSpaskal
post Jun 10 2014, 09:31 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(Noobl3t @ Jun 3 2014, 10:22 PM)
I'm wondering who else did you hire to build your house...like planner, M&E consultant, etc. What kind of paper work is require at certain stages of the house building, paper work for authorities etc?

How's your tiles durable test going?
*
i didn't hire anyone. it's DIY so i (we) did it ourselves. pandai pandai try try like that one. haha
tho there's an architect directly involved in the design. indirectly involved an electrical engineer, mechanical engineer and 3 civil engineer. well basically everyone from my wife's office. tongue.gif

residential plan submission for my area only involves the local council. but since it's a rural area even the local council doesn't bother about it. check with your local council.

the tile is freakin durable. kindda expected from a full bodied heavy duty tile. i've compared the tile after sitting outside for 1 month against the others from the box and there's no fading.

QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 4 2014, 09:08 AM)
Since you built your own house and looking some idea and solution, you can read something from here --> http://www.cooltek.org/

This site is from a British couple who retired here and built their own house in golf course air keroh. He write very detail how to cool down, save energy and other about built a house. Earn many award also.

But he no longer update his website since he pass away suddenly 2yrs ago .  sad.gif  You can download his report and others to read and follow.
*
thanks. i've came across the site before. it's properly measured and the results are quite scientific in nature.
too bad the owner passed away. no wonder it's not updated for quite a while. would really to know how the current cost of their fully air-conditioning cost since the entire house is fully air conditioned 24/7.

after a few years the air-cond efficiency drop and the cost goes up. i've read that it used to cost them RM70/month to fully air-cond the house 24/7.
TSpaskal
post Jun 10 2014, 09:36 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
i've asked for a few lighting proposal.
here's the one that really makes sense and i really like:
user posted image

converted to visio for easy understanding:
user posted image

the PDF is attached. pardon the missing right side wall. my pdf printer is stupid. it's free so yeah.
Attached File  Visio_electrical_wiring.pdf ( 97.83k ) Number of downloads: 38

TSpaskal
post Jun 10 2014, 10:48 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
bought some LED lights and your normal CFL lights to check for their efficiency and light output.
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image

i don't trust manufacturer specs, especially those from shady brands like these oxyone lights. so bought the ones that my wife really like to do an actual measurement.
the oxyone leds are rated for 18w, compared against phillips 18w, phillips 11w and panasonic 18w.
TSpaskal
post Jun 10 2014, 11:13 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
also bought these ge10 and mr16 small led lights to measure their power efficiency and light output.
user posted image
user posted image

i did my phd in energy efficiency so yes it's a major consideration.

opting for 100w energy usage for wall light, garden light, flood light and any other lights turned on during sleep time. makes no sense to put all those nice nice mood & outdoor lighting only to be turned off most of time because they're too expensive to run.
100w x 10 hours everyday from 9pm-7am x 30 day = 30kw = RM9 to run every month. ngam ngam budget haha
Noobl3t
post Jun 10 2014, 06:54 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
Nice work!

Maybe "lumens per watt" might be a better measurement of efficiency? The usual ones are around 65 lpw, good ones are approaching or exceed 100 lpw.

I'm an electrical engineer too, hehe if you don't mind me been nosey and offering my opinion.

Hope we can exchange ideas.

halcyon27
post Jun 10 2014, 09:03 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


Hi Paskal,

Thanks for sharing your journey.

I think building on stilts is another idea given the reasons below:
a. coastline - wind or storm surge will bring in the water esp if there's a river nearby.
b. Ventilation - easily allows for wind to come in.

The car park area could be either heightened with an elevated bay or their structure augmented with storm doors if build at ground level.

Building materials like AAC help slow down heat build up on from the exterior. Natural lighting via clerestory windows as shown in some of your sketches and as some mentioned taking advantage of prevailing winds to naturally ventilate the house.

This post has been edited by halcyon27: Jun 10 2014, 09:03 PM
TSpaskal
post Jun 10 2014, 09:08 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(Noobl3t @ Jun 10 2014, 06:54 PM)
Nice work!

Maybe "lumens per watt" might be a better measurement of efficiency? The usual ones are around 65 lpw, good ones are approaching or exceed 100 lpw.

I'm an electrical engineer too, hehe if you don't mind me been nosey and offering my opinion.

Hope we can exchange ideas.
*
it is, but i still don't have any good method of measuring the light output. haven't researched how manufacturers carry out their measurement to come up with their lumens per watt rating.

i do have access to a lux meter, but need to build a makeshift reflector to channel the light and avoid diffraction. so for now it's just relative comparison when the room lights are turned off and the sample lamps turned upwards to light the ceiling.

nice to see another engineer. the led lights are freakin simple to construct. can even build ourselves DIY style. biggrin.gif
evangelion
post Jun 10 2014, 10:09 PM

The Ancient Ones
******
Senior Member
1,057 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 10 2014, 09:08 PM)
it is, but i still don't have any good method of measuring the light output. haven't researched how manufacturers carry out their measurement to come up with their lumens per watt rating.

i do have access to a lux meter, but need to build a makeshift reflector to channel the light and avoid diffraction. so for now it's just relative comparison when the room lights are turned off and the sample lamps turned upwards to light the ceiling.

nice to see another engineer. the led lights are freakin simple to construct. can even build ourselves DIY style. biggrin.gif
*
Hope this info will speed up some of your research:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminous_efficacy#Examples_2

Have thought of return of investment? Price of LED with power saving(TNB Bill) vs CFL with much lower capital(Half as much if im not wrong [With Fixtures, etc]) while both having the same-ish LPW (Lumen per watt).

Personally, i have did a rough calculation on this topic, it turns out to be CFL favour...ROI was just too long and the warranty are usual 1 year or 2.

But i'm eager to read your thoughts and findings on these.

BTW, have you thought of have a 2nd floor or a ventilated roof system to isolate your first floor from direct sunlight heat ray, to saves A/C bills =P . Another topic im interested in.
ozak
post Jun 10 2014, 10:24 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 10 2014, 10:48 AM)
bought some LED lights and your normal CFL lights to check for their efficiency and light output.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
i don't trust manufacturer specs, especially those from shady brands like these oxyone lights. so bought the ones that my wife really like to do an actual measurement.
the oxyone leds are rated for 18w, compared against phillips 18w, phillips 11w and panasonic 18w.
*
It is good to know the actual running watt. Sometime really difficult to believe what they claim. Specially for the LED.

Is this the actual watt for the led light 18w? Or their state spec? What is the lumens ? How is the Amp measure before and after the power supply?
evangelion
post Jun 10 2014, 10:26 PM

The Ancient Ones
******
Senior Member
1,057 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 10 2014, 10:24 PM)
It is good to know the actual running watt. Sometime really difficult to believe what they claim. Specially for the LED.

Is this the actual watt for the led light 18w? Or their state spec? What is the lumens ? How is the Amp measure before and after the power supply?
*
Agree, verify their "claims" first. We can crunch the numbers later =P
TSpaskal
post Jun 10 2014, 11:13 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(halcyon27 @ Jun 10 2014, 09:03 PM)
Hi Paskal,

Thanks for sharing your journey.

I think building on stilts is another idea given the reasons below:
a. coastline - wind or storm surge will bring in the water esp if there's a river nearby.
b. Ventilation - easily allows for wind to come in.

The car park area could be either heightened with an elevated bay or their structure augmented with storm doors if build at ground level.

Building materials like AAC help slow down heat build up on from the exterior. Natural lighting via clerestory windows as shown in some of your sketches and as some mentioned taking advantage of prevailing winds to naturally ventilate the house.
*
i've read that them Autoclaved aerated concrete-AAC have some sort of health issue? got a thread before this discussing the aac building material.
searched the net and found there's a sort of lawsuit regarding aac. no idea if the same issue is apparent in malaysia since i've seen a couple of building in my area built using something that resembles an aac block.

there's just the master bedroom wall that's gonna heat up from the evening sun. thinking of adding a sunshading wall later if the heat buildup is too much. quite sceptical of adopting aac after reading about the issues.

QUOTE(evangelion @ Jun 10 2014, 10:09 PM)
Hope this info will speed up some of your research:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminous_efficacy#Examples_2

Have thought of return of investment? Price of LED with power saving(TNB Bill) vs CFL with much lower capital(Half as much if im not wrong [With Fixtures, etc]) while both having the same-ish LPW (Lumen per watt).

Personally, i have did a rough calculation on this topic, it turns out to be CFL favour...ROI was just too long and the warranty are usual 1 year or 2.

But i'm eager to read your thoughts and findings on these.
*
it serves as a rough guideline, but the actual light efficacy have to be measured since not all LED have the same efficacy.
manufacturing process, material used, the housing, etc etc all have a direct effect to the light output. i got a friend that's from the industry, worked till senior engineer post at a japanese company manufacturing led solutions before resigning. detailed explanation from him till get earbleed. rclxub.gif

anyway the ROI is just too long. kindda not worth to implement the entire house with LED. at some parts of the house it's more logical and cheaper to use cfl.

QUOTE(evangelion @ Jun 10 2014, 10:09 PM)
BTW, have you thought of have a 2nd floor or a ventilated roof system to isolate your first floor from direct sunlight heat ray, to saves A/C bills =P . Another topic im interested in.
*
roof insulation is integrated. i'm gonna use monier's bubble wrap roof insulation system just after the roof tile, with an air gap of 1-2 inch. that should provide the best possible insulation for the roof.
user posted image
i've came across a study on roof insulation and bubble wrap with an air gap is indeed the best possible way to get the highest heat attenuation. monier have another double layer bubble wrap called super r or something like that. no idea if it's available locally.
the current quotation is for the monier roof with bubble wrap insulation and air gap.

must consider roof insulation since electricity costs isn't coming down. after all, the difference isn't by much. i'm even considering of adding another bubble wrap layer (or a few more layer) laid on top of the plaster ceiling to further attenuate heat transfer from above. only problem is the FIRE HAZARD haha. tongue.gif

to improve ventilation inside the roof structure, i'm gonna use these ceiling panels for the outside:
user posted image
user posted image

i actually have this:
user posted image
so i visit friend's house, other peoples house, house in construction and measured their ceiling temperature. haha
some using high roof, low roof, metal deck, metal deck with insulation, asbestos ceiling, plaster ceiling, low pitch, high pitch, no ceiling, roof tile, etc etc.
with this little device it's all scientific and require no guesstimation tongue.gif

it's quite late. till next time.
Fazab
post Jun 10 2014, 11:34 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


In Saudi Arab, they have this kind of aerated clay brick. Very effective.
Even at mid noon can sleep in hotel room on high floor with just fan on.

But not sure if can get locally. Or if local sifus know how to build with this. Much bigger size than our standard brick.


Attached Image
ShadowR1
post Jun 11 2014, 02:39 AM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


Informative and interesting, thanks guys ...
ozak
post Jun 11 2014, 11:18 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 10 2014, 11:13 PM)
i've read that them Autoclaved aerated concrete-AAC have some sort of health issue? got a thread before this discussing the aac building material.
searched the net and found there's a sort of lawsuit regarding aac. no idea if the same issue is apparent in malaysia since i've seen a couple of building in my area built using something that resembles an aac block.

there's just the master bedroom wall that's gonna heat up from the evening sun. thinking of adding a sunshading wall later if the heat buildup is too much. quite sceptical of adopting aac after reading about the issues.
it serves as a rough guideline, but the actual light efficacy have to be measured since not all LED have the same efficacy.
manufacturing process, material used, the housing, etc etc all have a direct effect to the light output. i got a friend that's from the industry, worked till senior engineer post at a japanese company manufacturing led solutions before resigning. detailed explanation from him till get earbleed. rclxub.gif

anyway the ROI is just too long. kindda not worth to implement the entire house with LED. at some parts of the house it's more logical and cheaper to use cfl.
roof insulation is integrated. i'm gonna use monier's bubble wrap roof insulation system just after the roof tile, with an air gap of 1-2 inch. that should provide the best possible insulation for the roof.
user posted image
i've came across a study on roof insulation and bubble wrap with an air gap is indeed the best possible way to get the highest heat attenuation. monier have another double layer bubble wrap called super r or something like that. no idea if it's available locally.
the current quotation is for the monier roof with bubble wrap insulation and air gap.

must consider roof insulation since electricity costs isn't coming down. after all, the difference isn't by much. i'm even considering of adding another bubble wrap layer (or a few more layer) laid on top of the plaster ceiling to further attenuate heat transfer from above. only problem is the FIRE HAZARD haha. tongue.gif

to improve ventilation inside the roof structure, i'm gonna use these ceiling panels for the outside:
user posted image
user posted image

i actually have this:
user posted image
so i visit friend's house, other peoples house, house in construction and measured their ceiling temperature. haha
some using high roof, low roof, metal deck, metal deck with insulation, asbestos ceiling, plaster ceiling, low pitch, high pitch, no ceiling, roof tile, etc etc.
with this little device it's all scientific and require no guesstimation tongue.gif

it's quite late. till next time.
*
Maybe you have to create a vent hole up for the hot air to escape. The bubble wrap seem like wrap the whole top roof without giving any hot air to vent out. The ceiling panel is good for cool air in.

For the ceiling, it is best to use thick rockwool or Cellulose. This are fire retardant material. Any thin material doesn't help.
ShadowR1
post Jun 11 2014, 12:51 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


How about this ? Its a bit ugly tho.
Attached Image
TSpaskal
post Jun 15 2014, 02:22 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 10 2014, 10:24 PM)
It is good to know the actual running watt. Sometime really difficult to believe what they claim. Specially for the LED.

Is this the actual watt for the led light 18w? Or their state spec? What is the lumens ? How is the Amp measure before and after the power supply?
*
this is what i measured for the oxyone 18w led.
this is the product:
user posted image
QUOTE
OXY R18-GM
Power Consumption : 16W = 90W Incandescent (Saving up to 80%)
Size : 160mm (Diameter) x 35mm (Height)
Hole Size: 140mm (Diameter)
Lumen : 1620lm
sorry i thought it's rated for 18w power, but the spec says it's 16w.

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

252.2 VAC = 178.36 Vrms * 0.1107 = 19.74W

actual DC power sent to the LEDs after conversion:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

26V * 0.4890 A = 12.71W
efficiency of the DC converter = 12.71/19.74 = 64.38%
meaning it's freaking low. nearly 20W ac power sent, only 12.7w dc are received by the LED.

comparing the light output versus the 18w CFL from phillips and panasonic, i say these LEDs are on average ~15% brighter compared to the CFL.
is it worth it? probably not, considering it's gonna be a hassle to maintain them if should the LED driver malfunction after a few years. as with any electronics, it's not gonna last forever.

the oxyone leds says on the box that they're rated for 120lm/w efficacy. verry hard to believe since on average the actual led chips have 100lm/w efficacy at best. on DC power.

say you get an 18W led. that 18w is rated on AC.
18w * 65% efficient dc conversion = 11.7w of dc power. so at best you're gonna have 1170 lumens from it.
TSpaskal
post Jun 15 2014, 05:00 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
remember this small led lights?
supposed to be 9w (3 led) and 12w (4 led), epistar chip.
user posted image

actual measurements.
9w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

12w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

which makes the efficiency of the 9w at 42.5% and the 12w efficiency at 46.5%
not the led efficacy mind you, but the DC conversion efficiency.

it's freaking low. waste of electricity.
even if the epistar is capable of 100lm/w, the dc conversion efficiency pulled it down. say you get 300 lumen from the 6.56w ac input, the lumen per watt is only 45.73 lm/w.
for the 4 led chip, say you get 400 lumen from 8.64w ac input, the actual output would only be 46.3 lumen/w

lower than even the cheap 11w phillips CFL that i have which is rated for 54 lumen/watt.

install LED to save energy huh?
mitmivec
post Jun 16 2014, 01:39 AM

Creative Photo
****
Senior Member
641 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: USJ



QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 15 2014, 05:00 PM)
remember this small led lights?
supposed to be 9w (3 led) and 12w (4 led), epistar chip.
user posted image

actual measurements.
9w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

12w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

which makes the efficiency of the 9w at 42.5% and the 12w efficiency at 46.5%
not the led efficacy mind you, but the DC conversion efficiency.

it's freaking low. waste of electricity.
even if the epistar is capable of 100lm/w, the dc conversion efficiency pulled it down. say you get 300 lumen from the 6.56w ac input, the lumen per watt is only 45.73 lm/w.
for the 4 led chip, say you get 400 lumen from 8.64w ac input, the actual output would only be 46.3 lumen/w

lower than even the cheap 11w phillips CFL that i have which is rated for 54 lumen/watt.

install LED to save energy huh?
*
you know how to calculate aircon consumption?
ozak
post Jun 16 2014, 10:46 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 15 2014, 05:00 PM)
remember this small led lights?
supposed to be 9w (3 led) and 12w (4 led), epistar chip.
user posted image

actual measurements.
9w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

12w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

which makes the efficiency of the 9w at 42.5% and the 12w efficiency at 46.5%
not the led efficacy mind you, but the DC conversion efficiency.

it's freaking low. waste of electricity.
even if the epistar is capable of 100lm/w, the dc conversion efficiency pulled it down. say you get 300 lumen from the 6.56w ac input, the lumen per watt is only 45.73 lm/w.
for the 4 led chip, say you get 400 lumen from 8.64w ac input, the actual output would only be 46.3 lumen/w

lower than even the cheap 11w phillips CFL that i have which is rated for 54 lumen/watt.

install LED to save energy huh?
*
Thanks for your testing. Your testing do have similar patent to what I have test 2yrs ago.

I run a simple test on the famous CREE ecosmart led. https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/1481183/+560

Than lux check last yrs. https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/2872552/+20

I give 2yrs of testing for reliable. Time have pass fast. The LED still run without any problem. But haven't check the Lux reading got any output reduce. Will conduct the test when have the time. I have more confident on this product now. And probably looking at how to import more and modify it to be efficient running.

TSpaskal
post Jun 16 2014, 11:43 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(mitmivec @ Jun 16 2014, 01:39 AM)
you know how to calculate aircon consumption?
*
you could measure the current draw using a clamp meter or directly tap into the power line.
or use a wattmeter, which is in a way better because it provides the power factor reading.

power factor reading is needed to calculate the actual power usage, but some older tnb meters doesn't consider the power factor in calculating the power usage.
as far as i know, the newer tnb digital meter charges you in actual power usage by calculating the power factor while the older analog meter only calculate VA rating.

QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 16 2014, 10:46 AM)
Thanks for your testing. Your testing do have similar patent to what I have test 2yrs ago.

I run a simple test on the famous CREE ecosmart led. https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/1481183/+560

Than lux check last yrs. https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/2872552/+20

I give 2yrs of testing for reliable. Time have pass fast. The LED still run without any problem. But haven't check the Lux reading got any output reduce. Will conduct the test when have the time. I have more confident on this product now. And probably looking at how to import more and modify it to be efficient running.
*
to improve the efficiency, we could bypass the led driver like what you did and run them purely on DC using a high efficiency SMPS power supply. that should pump the conversion efficiency to over 80%. downside is there's no current limit and we're limiting the light output that we could extract from the led using this method.

or replace the led driver with better drivers from mean well. they have some pretty high quality drivers which is rated for upwards of 80% efficiency. from experience working with their SMPS, their products are pretty high quality rivalling those expensive unit. and their rated spec is pretty much spot on without any bloated artificial number.
i've opened quite a number of (expensive) equipment and not surprised to see the power supply from mean well in them. downside is that the choices is pretty limited. there's no peculiar current limit like 600mA, 125mA, 480mA and the such.
ozak
post Jun 16 2014, 03:51 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 16 2014, 11:43 AM)
to improve the efficiency, we could bypass the led driver like what you did and run them purely on DC using a high efficiency SMPS power supply. that should pump the conversion efficiency to over 80%. downside is there's no current limit and we're limiting the light output that we could extract from the led using this method.

or replace the led driver with better drivers from mean well. they have some pretty high quality drivers which is rated for upwards of 80% efficiency. from experience working with their SMPS, their products are pretty high quality rivalling those expensive unit. and their rated spec is pretty much spot on without any bloated artificial number.
i've opened quite a number of (expensive) equipment and not surprised to see the power supply from mean well in them. downside is that the choices is pretty limited. there's no peculiar current limit like 600mA, 125mA, 480mA and the such.
*
From the testing and the actual reading, pretty much that the LED can save energy. Provided the power supply(driver) is efficient. I run this test everyday for 8hr+ for 2yrs. And with a good driver, it can sum out,

1) 8hr x 2yrs = 6000hr average to date. That is already over the CFL rating at 8000hr with 4hr running everyday.
2) With the 6W consume, it only consume 1.5kwh/mth. For 2yrs, it only consume 35kwh or RM8 bill.

But ROI is long. Probably take about 5-6yrs equal to CFL ROI. Provided the LED doesn't blow up and TNB rate keep increase.

If the whole house or certain area is light with LED, what is the best setup? My initial plan is to have 1 driver for several led. Takeout the crap driver and run direct from the main driver. A 100W driver probably can drive 12pcs of led (6w). That should give,

1) max efficient.
2) reduce the break down,
3) less heat
4) cheaper cost.

I know this mean well brand but never use before. Selling a lot in local electrical shop. But mostly I m using Omron, TDK, idec or nemic lamda. Given Omron is my favour. Max average Efficiency is 86% while you can go for 3P which can drive till 91% efficiency.
TSpaskal
post Jun 17 2014, 10:14 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 16 2014, 03:51 PM)
From the testing and the actual reading, pretty much that the LED can save energy. Provided the power supply(driver) is efficient. I run this test everyday for 8hr+ for 2yrs. And with a good driver, it can sum out,

1) 8hr x 2yrs = 6000hr average to date. That is already over the CFL rating at 8000hr with 4hr running everyday.
2) With the 6W consume, it only consume 1.5kwh/mth. For 2yrs, it only consume 35kwh or RM8 bill.

But ROI is long. Probably take about 5-6yrs equal to CFL ROI. Provided the LED doesn't blow up and TNB rate keep increase.

If the whole house or certain area is light with LED, what is the best setup? My initial plan is to have 1 driver for several led. Takeout the crap driver and run direct from the main driver. A 100W driver probably can drive 12pcs of led (6w). That should give,

1) max efficient.
2) reduce the break down,
3) less heat
4) cheaper cost.

I know this mean well brand but never use before. Selling a lot in local electrical shop. But mostly I m using Omron, TDK, idec or nemic lamda. Given Omron is my favour. Max average Efficiency is 86% while you can go for 3P which can drive till 91% efficiency.
*
read below your posts and finally understood when you typed 6w. you corroborate my findings. the AC-DC converter that the LED lights are using have pretty low efficiency. surprising really, because yours are from CREE themselves.
ROI using the default led driver is just too long for me. i never believe electronics will last more than a couple of years, especially switching circuits. 5-6 years is just too long.

tho LEDs have a few important advantages that CFL could never provide. most important for me is:
1) heat dissipation to the backside of the case, which is to the ceiling.
2) can be powered by DC power using backup battery in case power failure.

best setup IMO is to isolate the DC conversion and current limit (led driver). use a high efficiency SMPS to convert to DC, then use a separate current limiter to drive the LED. you could use multiple LED per driver but there's a few downside.
upside:
- should provide higher efficiency as the current limiter is rated for ~97% efficiency, SMPS rating above 85%.
- cheaper maintenance cost since the smps and current limiter is isolated. replace just the problematic item.
- easily retrofitted to run from battery power for backup lights.
downside:
- switches will be handling DC. arching could destroy the switches in the long term.
- multiple equipment to maintain.

another easier setup is as you explained. using multiple LEDs wired in series to a single driver.
upside:
- cheaper initial cost. cheaper to modify existing wiring.
- easier to maintain. driver could be placed in easy to access area and since the LED itself are hard to spoil it's shorter downtime.
downside:
- higher replacement cost. single high power driver will cost more compared to either smps or current limiter.
- most led driver (integrated driver with smps and current limiter) have higher efficiency if nearly fully loaded. so it's gonna be hard to maintain high efficiency throughout the entire house.

have you considered building your own LED downlights?
i can't seem to find any supplier in ebay or aliexpress selling just the LED downlight case/housing. epistar 1w and 0.5w SMD LEDs are selling quite cheaply on the net. it's gonna be easy to hit 100 lumen/DC watt (or more) if we build the LED ourselves.
pair it with some cheap, high efficiency driver and string a couple of them together, it's gonna hit 90 lumens/watt or more on AC.

anyway for my garden lights, wall lights and flood lights, i'm gonna feed them DC directly (with or without current limiter) and build my own LED string. i've already bought the cases for the garden and wall lights so it's do or die.
TSpaskal
post Jun 17 2014, 10:16 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 16 2014, 03:51 PM)
I know this mean well brand but never use before. Selling a lot in local electrical shop. But mostly I m using Omron, TDK, idec or nemic lamda. Given Omron is my favour. Max average Efficiency is 86% while you can go for 3P which can drive till 91% efficiency.
*
mind to explain what is 3P? 91% efficiency is quite high.
TSpaskal
post Jun 20 2014, 07:55 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
main inspiration for the outdoor deck:
user posted image
integrated steps and sitting area. tiled.
integrated planter boxes, auto irrigation system.
plumbing works will be designed to support such system, gravity fed from elevated rainwater collection tank.

inspiration for the partly shaded deck:
user posted image

inspiration for the outdoor courtyard, with outdoor projection:
user posted image

why yes. the wiring and plumbing is gonna be complicated.
main reason why it has to be done in DIY fashion.
weikee
post Jun 20 2014, 10:06 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
For the fun and mother nature is really good to use the method you mention. But for pocket and practicality is another story. I doubt it will generate any good ROI.

Have you consider Solar -> Battery and Let the battery power the LED in series. This way you have minimal wastage in conversion, and "free" energy from solar. Than again, you have to spend money investing on Battery. I been researching lithium ion battery after Xiaomi selling a good and cheap Powerbank. It actually don't cost much to buy the similar battery Xiaomi using LGABB41865 (universal 18650), maybe RM 5 / unit for low quantity order.
If you can get the same or higher mAh batter capacity like Xiaomi powerbank using (2600mAh), you get 9.6watt hour per battery. That enough to power one 9watt Led for 45mins (assuming 75% efficiency).

Long I have not work on the power supply, I maybe wrong but I think the 97% efficiency can't be achieve in real world environment with the heat, and component quality.


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 17 2014, 10:14 PM)
read below your posts and finally understood when you typed 6w. you corroborate my findings. the AC-DC converter that the LED lights are using have pretty low efficiency. surprising really, because yours are from CREE themselves.
ROI using the default led driver is just too long for me. i never believe electronics will last more than a couple of years, especially switching circuits. 5-6 years is just too long.

tho LEDs have a few important advantages that CFL could never provide. most important for me is:
1) heat dissipation to the backside of the case, which is to the ceiling.
2) can be powered by DC power using backup battery in case power failure.

best setup IMO is to isolate the DC conversion and current limit (led driver). use a high efficiency SMPS to convert to DC, then use a separate current limiter to drive the LED. you could use multiple LED per driver but there's a few downside.
upside:
- should provide higher efficiency as the current limiter is rated for ~97% efficiency, SMPS rating above 85%.
- cheaper maintenance cost since the smps and current limiter is isolated. replace just the problematic item.
- easily retrofitted to run from battery power for backup lights.
downside:
- switches will be handling DC. arching could destroy the switches in the long term.
- multiple equipment to maintain.

another easier setup is as you explained. using multiple LEDs wired in series to a single driver.
upside:
- cheaper initial cost. cheaper to modify existing wiring.
- easier to maintain. driver could be placed in easy to access area and since the LED itself are hard to spoil it's shorter downtime.
downside:
- higher replacement cost. single high power driver will cost more compared to either smps or current limiter.
- most led driver (integrated driver with smps and current limiter) have higher efficiency if nearly fully loaded. so it's gonna be hard to maintain high efficiency throughout the entire house.

have you considered building your own LED downlights?
i can't seem to find any supplier in ebay or aliexpress selling just the LED downlight case/housing. epistar 1w and 0.5w SMD LEDs are selling quite cheaply on the net. it's gonna be easy to hit 100 lumen/DC watt (or more) if we build the LED ourselves.
pair it with some cheap, high efficiency driver and string a couple of them together, it's gonna hit 90 lumens/watt or more on AC.

anyway for my garden lights, wall lights and flood lights, i'm gonna feed them DC directly (with or without current limiter) and build my own LED string. i've already bought the cases for the garden and wall lights so it's do or die.
*
ozak
post Jun 21 2014, 08:23 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 17 2014, 10:14 PM)
read below your posts and finally understood when you typed 6w. you corroborate my findings. the AC-DC converter that the LED lights are using have pretty low efficiency. surprising really, because yours are from CREE themselves.
ROI using the default led driver is just too long for me. i never believe electronics will last more than a couple of years, especially switching circuits. 5-6 years is just too long.

tho LEDs have a few important advantages that CFL could never provide. most important for me is:
1) heat dissipation to the backside of the case, which is to the ceiling.
2) can be powered by DC power using backup battery in case power failure.

best setup IMO is to isolate the DC conversion and current limit (led driver). use a high efficiency SMPS to convert to DC, then use a separate current limiter to drive the LED. you could use multiple LED per driver but there's a few downside.
upside:
- should provide higher efficiency as the current limiter is rated for ~97% efficiency, SMPS rating above 85%.
- cheaper maintenance cost since the smps and current limiter is isolated. replace just the problematic item.
- easily retrofitted to run from battery power for backup lights.
downside:
- switches will be handling DC. arching could destroy the switches in the long term.
- multiple equipment to maintain.

another easier setup is as you explained. using multiple LEDs wired in series to a single driver.
upside:
- cheaper initial cost. cheaper to modify existing wiring.
- easier to maintain. driver could be placed in easy to access area and since the LED itself are hard to spoil it's shorter downtime.
downside:
- higher replacement cost. single high power driver will cost more compared to either smps or current limiter.
- most led driver (integrated driver with smps and current limiter) have higher efficiency if nearly fully loaded. so it's gonna be hard to maintain high efficiency throughout the entire house.

have you considered building your own LED downlights?
i can't seem to find any supplier in ebay or aliexpress selling just the LED downlight case/housing. epistar 1w and 0.5w SMD LEDs are selling quite cheaply on the net. it's gonna be easy to hit 100 lumen/DC watt (or more) if we build the LED ourselves.
pair it with some cheap, high efficiency driver and string a couple of them together, it's gonna hit 90 lumens/watt or more on AC.

anyway for my garden lights, wall lights and flood lights, i'm gonna feed them DC directly (with or without current limiter) and build my own LED string. i've already bought the cases for the garden and wall lights so it's do or die.
*

The plan still at my drawing board. Having a led downlight for the whole house is expensive with the unreliable product. I once ask locally what is the price of the led downlight without the driver. Some show suprise face and some told me no warranty. rclxub.gif





ozak
post Jun 21 2014, 08:36 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 17 2014, 10:16 PM)
mind to explain what is 3P? 91% efficiency is quite high.
*
It is a 3phase 415vac/240vac SMPS. You can check their SMPS and efficiency at here --> http://www.omron-ap.com.my/products/catego...lies/index.html

SMPS like this Japan product surprising in not expensive. A 24vdc 50watt SMPS efficiency over 80% cost only rm45. Thanks to the crap china product driving their price down. But actual it manufacturing from china also.

For the reliable, 5 yrs is not a problem. Some I see running more than 8yrs. Just don't get their low end product.
ozak
post Jun 21 2014, 08:56 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 20 2014, 10:06 AM)
For the fun and mother nature is really good to use the method you mention. But for pocket and practicality is another story. I doubt it will generate any good ROI.

Have you consider Solar -> Battery and Let the battery power the LED in series. This way you have minimal wastage in conversion, and "free" energy from solar. Than again, you have to spend money investing on Battery. I been researching lithium ion battery after Xiaomi selling a good and cheap Powerbank. It actually don't cost much to buy the similar battery Xiaomi using LGABB41865 (universal 18650), maybe RM 5 / unit for low quantity order. 
If you can get the same or higher mAh batter capacity like Xiaomi powerbank using (2600mAh), you get 9.6watt hour per battery. That enough to power one 9watt Led for 45mins (assuming 75% efficiency).

Long I have not work on the power supply, I maybe wrong but I think the 97% efficiency can't be achieve in real world environment with the heat, and component  quality.
*
My those outdoor solar light, modify solar decor light are still surprising function well after 2yrs. Some using nicad battery and some is lithium ion. I put it at outdoor with rain and sun abuse. Some run in ON till drain the battery (about 6-7hr) and morning charge again. Some run on motion sensor and morning charge.

But the solar garden light all kong liau. cry.gif the cheapest 1.

I think can consider using solar with battery for non critical light usage. You won't get back your ROI. But it won't burden you monthly bill.
TSpaskal
post Jun 22 2014, 05:34 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 20 2014, 10:06 AM)
For the fun and mother nature is really good to use the method you mention. But for pocket and practicality is another story. I doubt it will generate any good ROI.

Have you consider Solar -> Battery and Let the battery power the LED in series. This way you have minimal wastage in conversion, and "free" energy from solar. Than again, you have to spend money investing on Battery. I been researching lithium ion battery after Xiaomi selling a good and cheap Powerbank. It actually don't cost much to buy the similar battery Xiaomi using LGABB41865 (universal 18650), maybe RM 5 / unit for low quantity order. 
If you can get the same or higher mAh batter capacity like Xiaomi powerbank using (2600mAh), you get 9.6watt hour per battery. That enough to power one 9watt Led for 45mins (assuming 75% efficiency).

Long I have not work on the power supply, I maybe wrong but I think the 97% efficiency can't be achieve in real world environment with the heat, and component  quality.
*
you mean this right?
user posted image
i've bought some for sampling. another project for another day. a viable source of energy pack for embedded systems.
yes i agree they're worth more than what xiaomi is asking for them. so good that i've bought more than i need and given as gifts to family members. biggrin.gif

have considered solar charging. but the costs are not justifiable. as least for me.
got a friend using them tho, with a 1kw panel powering his led downlights.

he's using your normal lead acid battery. a car battery to be exact. and i'm with him on this. lithium ion cells are expensive and require extensive protection circuit. even charging circuit is quite complicated. the advantage is only for size and energy density where lithium cells stores more energy for the size.

it's better to use lead acid in this case as we have no size and weight constraints. it's reliable, have no problem supplying huge amount of current, robust, no problem with heat, less risk, doesn't require complex monitoring circuit, able to work with unstable charging voltage, and it's cheap. and it doesn't have memory effect.
having previously worked with NiCad & NiMH cell, LiOn and lead acid i really think lead acid is the best for this situation.

the reason why i won't implement it is because of the adoption costs.
it should cost about RM10k for a 1kW panel.
and if my memory serves me right, that 1kw panel should give you around 3kW per day average. 4kw at most. i'm realistic so we're gonna go with 3kw.

N70 battery at RM250 a piece. 12v x 75A = 900W per battery. 3 years working life.
say you're using all 3kW to power all the lights inside the house. realistic as it's gonna cost RM0.90 per night, ~RM30/month to power just the lights.

adoption cost at RM10k (panel) + RM750 for the battery + ~RM250 for the charging circuits, wiring, etc etc.
total RM11k, for a saving of RM30 a month for the lights.
that RM11k / RM30 per month saving = 366 month just to break even.

that's 30 years. just to break even.
not worth it IMO.

QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 21 2014, 08:36 AM)
It is a 3phase 415vac/240vac SMPS. You can check their SMPS and efficiency at here --> http://www.omron-ap.com.my/products/catego...lies/index.html

SMPS like this Japan product surprising in not expensive. A 24vdc 50watt SMPS efficiency over 80% cost only rm45. Thanks to the crap china product driving their price down. But actual it manufacturing from china also.

For the reliable, 5 yrs is not a problem. Some I see running more than 8yrs. Just don't get their low end product.
*
thanks for the link. will take a look.

QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 21 2014, 08:56 AM)
My those outdoor solar light, modify solar decor light are still surprising function well after 2yrs. Some using nicad battery and some is lithium ion. I put it at outdoor with rain and sun abuse. Some run in ON till drain the battery (about 6-7hr) and morning charge again. Some run on motion sensor and morning charge.

But the solar garden light all kong liau.  cry.gif  the cheapest 1.

I think can consider using solar with battery for non critical light usage. You won't get back your ROI. But it won't burden you monthly bill.
*
alternatively, can power all the non-essential lights using LED that's gonna be run throughout the night time. it's cheap and won't cost much. and even they burn, they're non-essential and no problem if it takes months to replace. biggrin.gif
TSpaskal
post Jun 22 2014, 06:02 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
the backyard area that will be turned to house the outdoor projection system:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

yes the area must be cleaned beforehand.

how it looks after 3 layers of soil. it's pretty flat now. raised 2 feet from the water level.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


the stream:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


will let the soil set for another 3 month before starting construction.
total damage for the land fill?
219 lorry. and the cost per lorry will depend heavily on your area. i got it pretty cheap. biggrin.gif

then again, cheap is pretty relative.
you KL people don't mind paying over 1mil for an apartment so my price is like your leftover coin in your pockets lah. tongue.gif
weikee
post Jun 22 2014, 06:34 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
Haha, as to date, I brought 10 units of Xiaomi power bank smile.gif
ozak
post Jun 24 2014, 06:03 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 22 2014, 05:34 PM)
you mean this right?
user posted image
i've bought some for sampling. another project for another day. a viable source of energy pack for embedded systems.
yes i agree they're worth more than what xiaomi is asking for them. so good that i've bought more than i need and given as gifts to family members. biggrin.gif

have considered solar charging. but the costs are not justifiable. as least for me.
got a friend using them tho, with a 1kw panel powering his led downlights.

he's using your normal lead acid battery. a car battery to be exact. and i'm with him on this. lithium ion cells are expensive and require extensive protection circuit. even charging circuit is quite complicated. the advantage is only for size and energy density where lithium cells stores more energy for the size.

it's better to use lead acid in this case as we have no size and weight constraints. it's reliable, have no problem supplying huge amount of current, robust, no problem with heat, less risk, doesn't require complex monitoring circuit, able to work with unstable charging voltage, and it's cheap. and it doesn't have memory effect.
having previously worked with NiCad & NiMH cell, LiOn and lead acid i really think lead acid is the best for this situation.

the reason why i won't implement it is because of the adoption costs.
it should cost about RM10k for a 1kW panel.
and if my memory serves me right, that 1kw panel should give you around 3kW per day average. 4kw at most. i'm realistic so we're gonna go with 3kw.

N70 battery at RM250 a piece. 12v x 75A = 900W per battery. 3 years working life.
say you're using all 3kW to power all the lights inside the house. realistic as it's gonna cost RM0.90 per night, ~RM30/month to power just the lights.

adoption cost at RM10k (panel) + RM750 for the battery + ~RM250 for the charging circuits, wiring, etc etc.
total RM11k, for a saving of RM30 a month for the lights.
that RM11k / RM30 per month saving = 366 month just to break even.

that's 30 years. just to break even.
not worth it IMO.
Car battery are not mean for solar usage way. It charatistic is to supply high burst amp in short time. But it need to be charge back immediately. It usage cannot be more than 50-60%. Otherwise will be shortlife. Solar do have lead acid battery called deep cycle battery. It design to be use in steady amp supply with more than 50% can be drain. Last 2 yrs asking the GP deep cycle battery price. Cost RM750-850 for a 100A. sweat.gif

Lead acid require maintenance to top up and place outside. Seal lead acid , lithium, NiMH etc don't require maintenance. All this require dedicate charger to maintain the charging. So the battery life can be last longer. Lithium ion is getting popular for solar usage. Probably the price is coming down.

This is the solar battery charger which I brought from state. It have efficiency about 90% more if not mistaken. It program to charge few type battery, maintain and monitoring usage.
user posted image

ozak
post Jun 24 2014, 06:04 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 22 2014, 06:34 PM)
Haha, as to date, I brought 10 units of Xiaomi power bank smile.gif
*
Walau, brought so many for what? Pasar malam sell? tongue.gif

But this power bank is only 5V only wor. What you want to do with 5Vdc?
weikee
post Jun 24 2014, 07:02 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 24 2014, 06:04 PM)
Walau, brought so many for what? Pasar malam sell?  tongue.gif

But this power bank is only 5V only wor. What you want to do with 5Vdc?
*
Haha, add another 2 more units, just bought today smile.gif

I referring battery inside,, is 3.6v or was it 3.7v exactly good for led light.
ozak
post Jun 25 2014, 09:06 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 24 2014, 07:02 PM)
Haha, add another 2 more units, just bought today smile.gif

I referring battery inside,, is 3.6v or was it 3.7v exactly good for led light.
*
Depend the length size. The max length can go 3.7v, 3400mah. That can fired up a 1w led for 10hr+.

Those in my solar deco are 3.6v 2200mah. Can run about 6hr+ for a 1w led.

Next to get is solar panel and charger.
weikee
post Jun 25 2014, 09:19 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 25 2014, 09:06 AM)
Depend the length size. The max length can go 3.7v, 3400mah. That can fired up a 1w led for 10hr+.

Those in my solar deco are 3.6v 2200mah. Can run about 6hr+ for a 1w led.

Next to get is solar panel and charger.
*
Yeah, and is cheap if buy in bulk. Saw in Alibaba can go down to less than 1USD each. Imagine buy 200 units biggrin.gif

The killing is the panel and inverter.
ozak
post Jun 25 2014, 10:52 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 25 2014, 09:19 AM)
Yeah, and is cheap if buy in bulk. Saw in Alibaba can go down to less than 1USD each. Imagine buy 200 units biggrin.gif

The killing is the panel and inverter.
*
Can use or not so cheap? The price is abit suspicious.

I brought this last yrs if not mistaken. Cost RM55/pcs from subang jaya. sweat.gif
user posted image

The panel (12v/10w) and charger cost less than RM200 from local. Not that expensive anymore nowaday. Maybe even more cheaper from ebay or aliexpress.
weikee
post Jun 25 2014, 11:15 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 25 2014, 10:52 AM)
Can use or not so cheap? The price is abit suspicious.

I brought this last yrs if not mistaken. Cost RM55/pcs from subang jaya. sweat.gif
user posted image

The panel (12v/10w) and charger cost less than RM200 from local. Not that expensive anymore nowaday. Maybe even more cheaper from ebay or aliexpress.
*
Lets use Xiaomi Powerbank as a base to calculate, is selling at RM 36 with circuit + 4 battery 2600mah inside. If i take everything as zero cost except the battery, that make it RM 9 per battery. I don't think Xiaomi selling at lost right? Think they maybe getting it at RM 3-4 per unit.
ozak
post Jun 25 2014, 11:43 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 25 2014, 11:15 AM)
Lets use Xiaomi Powerbank as a base to calculate, is selling at RM 36 with circuit + 4 battery 2600mah inside. If i take everything as zero cost except the battery, that make it RM 9 per battery. I don't think Xiaomi selling at lost right? Think they maybe getting it at RM 3-4 per unit.
*
Xiaomi buying crazy qty stock. We consumer can't get that price. A simple check at Aliexpress already cost over RM10/pcs.

But getting indirectly from Xiaomi also very good price already.
weikee
post Jun 25 2014, 12:13 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 25 2014, 11:43 AM)
Xiaomi buying crazy qty stock. We consumer can't get that price. A simple check at  Aliexpress already cost over RM10/pcs.

But getting indirectly from Xiaomi also very good price already.
*
Think can get lower, need to buy more lo. Think we are oot already wink.gif
ozak
post Jun 25 2014, 12:44 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 25 2014, 12:13 PM)
Think can get lower, need to buy more lo. Think we are oot already wink.gif
*
You want to power your whole house light with this battery? Sapu habis the xiaomi power bank.
K for Ketamine
post Jun 25 2014, 07:07 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,188 posts

Joined: Sep 2006
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 24 2014, 06:03 PM)
Car battery are not mean for solar usage way. It charatistic is to supply high burst amp in short time. But it need to be charge back immediately. It usage cannot be more than 50-60%. Otherwise will be shortlife.  Solar do have lead acid battery called deep cycle battery. It design to be use in steady amp supply with more than 50% can be drain. Last 2 yrs asking the GP deep cycle battery price. Cost RM750-850 for a 100A.  sweat.gif 

Lead acid require maintenance to top up and place outside. Seal lead acid , lithium, NiMH etc don't require maintenance. All this require dedicate charger to maintain the charging. So the battery life can be last longer. Lithium ion is getting popular for solar usage. Probably the price is coming down.

This is the solar battery charger which I brought from state. It have efficiency about 90% more if not mistaken. It program to charge few type battery, maintain and monitoring usage.
user posted image
*

to make battery to last, need battery optimizer like hybrid (nvr go below 30% & charge up to 70% nvr full) & automated process top-up dehydrated lead acid

with 10000mAh, usable is 3000-4000mAh

base on NiMH can last abt 18months- charge full n drain 10% (battery power flashlight)

maybe consider this Iron Edison

Attached Image

This post has been edited by K for Ketamine: Jun 25 2014, 07:07 PM
weikee
post Jun 25 2014, 07:47 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(K for Ketamine @ Jun 25 2014, 07:07 PM)
to make battery to last, need battery optimizer like hybrid (nvr go below 30% & charge up to 70% nvr full) & automated process top-up dehydrated lead acid

with 10000mAh, usable is 3000-4000mAh

base on NiMH can last abt 18months- charge full n drain 10% (battery power flashlight)

maybe consider this Iron Edison

Attached Image
*
This setup not cheap.
TSpaskal
post Jun 26 2014, 08:40 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 25 2014, 12:13 PM)
Think we are oot already wink.gif
*
nice to see so much technical discussion going on. sorry i can't add much since class is just starting.
i don't mind you guys OOT and continue your discussion.
Noobl3t
post Jun 26 2014, 09:39 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
I think you would save much more, by investing time and effort into ventilation design. Just my small opinion.
ozak
post Jun 26 2014, 10:20 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(K for Ketamine @ Jun 25 2014, 07:07 PM)
to make battery to last, need battery optimizer like hybrid (nvr go below 30% & charge up to 70% nvr full) & automated process top-up dehydrated lead acid

with 10000mAh, usable is 3000-4000mAh

base on NiMH can last abt 18months- charge full n drain 10% (battery power flashlight)

maybe consider this Iron Edison

Attached Image
*
Walau, so hardcore meh. This single cell battery can cost a bom. sweat.gif think how many battery need in serial to get a 12v? And require space to store.

This setup of course is good. Long life and high amp per battery.
ozak
post Jun 26 2014, 10:22 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 26 2014, 08:40 PM)
nice to see so much technical discussion going on. sorry i can't add much since class is just starting.
i don't mind you guys OOT and continue your discussion.
*
We hijack your post already. He... tongue.gif
-oc-gassa
post Jul 14 2014, 02:43 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
967 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: setapak
Nice to see someone that go thoroughly for almost every aspect..please do more R & D since I love R & D but im in Finance field.. cant do much.. how about HT room? any details? any special insulation? BTW I vote for e Post #12 design... Cheers
SUSsupersound
post Jul 14 2014, 09:38 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(Fazab @ Jun 10 2014, 11:34 PM)
In Saudi Arab, they have this kind of aerated clay brick. Very effective.
Even at mid noon can sleep in hotel room on high floor with just fan on.

But not sure if can get locally. Or if local sifus know how to build with this. Much bigger size than our standard brick.
Attached Image
*
Most middle east countries the humidity are quite low compare to Malaysia, so there will be different. You need to know the heat index first.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 14 2014, 09:40 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 15 2014, 05:00 PM)
remember this small led lights?
supposed to be 9w (3 led) and 12w (4 led), epistar chip.
user posted image

actual measurements.
9w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

12w:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

which makes the efficiency of the 9w at 42.5% and the 12w efficiency at 46.5%
not the led efficacy mind you, but the DC conversion efficiency.

it's freaking low. waste of electricity.
even if the epistar is capable of 100lm/w, the dc conversion efficiency pulled it down. say you get 300 lumen from the 6.56w ac input, the lumen per watt is only 45.73 lm/w.
for the 4 led chip, say you get 400 lumen from 8.64w ac input, the actual output would only be 46.3 lumen/w

lower than even the cheap 11w phillips CFL that i have which is rated for 54 lumen/watt.

install LED to save energy huh?
*
Energy conversion will result to lost. Especially AC to DC. AC known to be low in efficiency.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 14 2014, 09:42 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 16 2014, 11:43 AM)
you could measure the current draw using a clamp meter or directly tap into the power line.
or use a wattmeter, which is in a way better because it provides the power factor reading.

power factor reading is needed to calculate the actual power usage, but some older tnb meters doesn't consider the power factor in calculating the power usage.
as far as i know, the newer tnb digital meter charges you in actual power usage by calculating the power factor while the older analog meter only calculate VA rating.
to improve the efficiency, we could bypass the led driver like what you did and run them purely on DC using a high efficiency SMPS power supply. that should pump the conversion efficiency to over 80%. downside is there's no current limit and we're limiting the light output that we could extract from the led using this method.

or replace the led driver with better drivers from mean well. they have some pretty high quality drivers which is rated for upwards of 80% efficiency. from experience working with their SMPS, their products are pretty high quality rivalling those expensive unit. and their rated spec is pretty much spot on without any bloated artificial number.
i've opened quite a number of (expensive) equipment and not surprised to see the power supply from mean well in them. downside is that the choices is pretty limited. there's no peculiar current limit like 600mA, 125mA, 480mA and the such.
*
Not really, the TNB newer digital meter run faster by 25% compare to old school meter.
PJusa
post Jul 14 2014, 10:31 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,025 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: PJ
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 14 2014, 09:42 PM)
Not really, the TNB newer digital meter run faster by 25% compare to old school meter.
*
where did you get that info from? if the meter runs properly the reading will be (+-) the same.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 15 2014, 03:29 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(PJusa @ Jul 14 2014, 10:31 PM)
where did you get that info from? if the meter runs properly the reading will be (+-) the same.
*
Off everything and only run air cond or washing machine, taking efficiency at 75%.
If the equipment to be test is 1000W(per hour), running it for 1 hour should be using less than 1 unit. But it moves 1 unit before 1 hour.
Not to mention people that complaint on this. Come out in most chinese paper every now and then.
PJusa
post Jul 15 2014, 10:01 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,025 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: PJ
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 15 2014, 03:29 AM)
Off everything and only run air cond or washing machine, taking efficiency at 75%.
If the equipment to be test is 1000W(per hour), running it for 1 hour should be using less than 1 unit. But it moves 1 unit before 1 hour.
Not to mention people that complaint on this. Come out in most chinese paper every now and then.
*
just by beeing in the newspaper doesnt make it true - more likely previous meter was undercounting.

your test also doesnt work that well if you dont ensure 100% load. if there would be an overcount of 25% surely you can a) get a new meter, b) get a refund from tnb. there is a margin of error in those things but it will be more like +- 1 or 2% - not 25%.
weikee
post Jul 15 2014, 10:28 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
My house digital meter measure the same as the analog meter. I actually find it run slower.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 15 2014, 02:43 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(PJusa @ Jul 15 2014, 10:01 AM)
just by beeing in the newspaper doesnt make it true - more likely previous meter was undercounting.

your test also doesnt work that well if you dont ensure 100% load. if there would be an overcount of 25% surely you can a) get a new meter, b) get a refund from tnb. there is a margin of error in those things but it will be more like +- 1 or 2% - not 25%.
*
Yup, you are right on this. Since Chinese are just by comers in Malaysia. What we says carry no weight.
Just tell me, setting 16'C is full load or not? Or even it is not, it will work harder on initial.
And the rated power on the spec is just a short burst, typical power are the right measurement and it won't go to rated power most of the time. So the actual load are even lower.
TSpaskal
post Jul 15 2014, 11:03 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 15 2014, 02:43 PM)
Yup, you are right on this. Since Chinese are just by comers in Malaysia. What we says carry no weight.
Just tell me, setting 16'C is full load or not? Or even it is not, it will work harder on initial.
And the rated power on the spec is just a short burst, typical power are the right measurement and it won't go to rated power most of the time. So the actual load are even lower.
*
seriously dude, let's not add to the race bigotry. it's bad enough the segregation that we're all so accustomed to.
whatever race you might be, whatever colour of your skin, holds no correlation to the significance of information, and/or truth.

actual power measurement is quite complicated. but if you had any credible proof that the digital meter is overcharging consumers, by all mean sue TNB, report to the consumer tribunal, report to suruhanjaya tenaga, and/or report to KETTHA. if it's too much of a hassle, pass the info to a consumer association and let them proceed with it.

the simplest way to actually measure whether tnb is overcharging is to turn off all the circuit breakers at the fuse box, and use a kill-a-watt meter that could measure the energy used (in relation to time) and check the consumption for a single high power item and validate that to the meter reading.
but even that is still not bulletproof, since the kill-a-watt isn't exactly a precision instrument and it's not calibrated.

to actually be credible enough for a solid proof, you need at least one of these:
user posted imageuser posted image
problem is, it's freaking expensive. a used unit is still going for ~RM5k.
i'm trying to get my hands on one since my mum's house is experiencing some huge voltage sag, causing the power bill to shoot sky high. reported the matter 4 times to tnb this year. without any further action.

QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 15 2014, 02:43 PM)
Just tell me, setting 16'C is full load or not? Or even it is not, it will work harder on initial.
And the rated power on the spec is just a short burst, typical power are the right measurement and it won't go to rated power most of the time. So the actual load are even lower.
*
it's full load. but power rating will always be different compared to the manufacturer specs printed on the label. usually it'll be within 10%, but it's not unusual for the power usage to within 10%-25% offset compared to the label. thus the reason to carry out actual measurement, rather than relying on the label and extrapolating from it.
K for Ketamine
post Jul 16 2014, 02:07 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,188 posts

Joined: Sep 2006
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 15 2014, 03:29 AM)
Off everything and only run air cond or washing machine, taking efficiency at 75%.
If the equipment to be test is 1000W(per hour), running it for 1 hour should be using less than 1 unit. But it moves 1 unit before 1 hour.
Not to mention people that complaint on this. Come out in most chinese paper every now and then.
*

tnb meter
analog vs digital

positive
when the bill is lower, this new digital so accurate, all the while the analog i spent XXXX, with digital my bill only XXX. i had been paying all my life, lucky switch to digital.

negative
when the bill is higher, this new digital is bloody sucker, last time i paid only XXX, but this stupid digital my bill now XXXX. i'm stuck for life, tnb cheating me don't allowed my go back analog.

moral of story no one like to pay higher bill charges. imo newspaper nvr explain another side of story.

we don't have much option, either stuck with grid or off the grid (solar,wind,genset)
SUSsupersound
post Jul 17 2014, 11:34 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 15 2014, 11:03 PM)
seriously dude, let's not add to the race bigotry. it's bad enough the segregation that we're all so accustomed to.
whatever race you might be, whatever colour of your skin, holds no correlation to the significance of information, and/or truth.

actual power measurement is quite complicated. but if you had any credible proof that the digital meter is overcharging consumers, by all mean sue TNB, report to the consumer tribunal, report to suruhanjaya tenaga, and/or report to KETTHA. if it's too much of a hassle, pass the info to a consumer association and let them proceed with it.

the simplest way to actually measure whether tnb is overcharging is to turn off all the circuit breakers at the fuse box, and use a kill-a-watt meter that could measure the energy used (in relation to time) and check the consumption for a single high power item and validate that to the meter reading.
but even that is still not bulletproof, since the kill-a-watt isn't exactly a precision instrument and it's not calibrated.

to actually be credible enough for a solid proof, you need at least one of these:
user posted imageuser posted image
problem is, it's freaking expensive. a used unit is still going for ~RM5k.
i'm trying to get my hands on one since my mum's house is experiencing some huge voltage sag, causing the power bill to shoot sky high. reported the matter 4 times to tnb this year. without any further action.
it's full load. but power rating will always be different compared to the manufacturer specs printed on the label. usually it'll be within 10%, but it's not unusual for the power usage to within 10%-25% offset compared to the label. thus the reason to carry out actual measurement, rather than relying on the label and extrapolating from it.
*
Well, I like when some jerks like to deny something without doing more research. Tell you what, the English and Malay papers never have a news stating people are complaining about once the meter changed, their bill raise up buy 100-300%. Only Chinese papers has.
So instead of looking at the "rated" spec, I will dig more on typical rated spec at full or low load which is ~50% from it.

QUOTE(K for Ketamine @ Jul 16 2014, 02:07 AM)
tnb meter
analog vs digital

positive
when the bill is lower, this new digital so accurate, all the while the analog i spent XXXX, with digital my bill only XXX. i had been paying all my life, lucky switch to digital.

negative
when the bill is higher, this new digital is bloody sucker, last time i paid only XXX, but this stupid digital my bill now XXXX. i'm stuck for life, tnb cheating me don't allowed my go back analog.

moral of story no one like to pay higher bill charges. imo newspaper nvr explain another side of story.

we don't have much option, either stuck with grid or off the grid (solar,wind,genset)
*
Analog meters are using mechanical parts, so wear and tear is there. Still it won't cause a huge spike when changing to new meter. Have to know that, no third party independent party to calibrate those digital meters and it is open secret that TNB asked their contractors to make it run faster than normal.
TSpaskal
post Jul 18 2014, 10:31 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 17 2014, 11:34 AM)
Well, I like when some jerks like to deny something without doing more research. Tell you what, the English and Malay papers never have a news stating people are complaining about once the meter changed, their bill raise up buy 100-300%. Only Chinese papers has.
*
things is improving dear friend. look at how the community is condemning the malay tudung lady for her racial remarks against the old chinese uncle. she's bashed left and right from the entire community, even muslims alike.

racial tension, racial hatred, racial prejudice is pretty much reduced after the few past elections. even some big issue like the whole JAIS/MAIS raid on the bible association, the usage of 'Allah' by other religions, all of those issue can't stop people from coming together. muslims are now adopting a more moderate stance. which is rarely seen during the reign of you know who.

it might take a while more. but things is definitely improving.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 18 2014, 01:56 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 18 2014, 10:31 AM)
things is improving dear friend. look at how the community is condemning the malay tudung lady for her racial remarks against the old chinese uncle. she's bashed left and right from the entire community, even muslims alike.

racial tension, racial hatred, racial prejudice is pretty much reduced after the few past elections. even some big issue like the whole JAIS/MAIS raid on the bible association, the usage of 'Allah' by other religions, all of those issue can't stop people from coming together. muslims are now adopting a more moderate stance. which is rarely seen during the reign of you know who.

it might take a while more. but things is definitely improving.
*
That lady deserves a bash from all. If the accident are not serious and repair work > rm300, just lodge a police report, case close.
No need to use object to hit others.

TSpaskal
post Jul 18 2014, 05:17 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 18 2014, 01:56 PM)
That lady deserves a bash from all. If the accident are not serious and repair work > rm300, just lodge a police report, case close.
No need to use object to hit others.
*
she should be put in jail on the charge of aggression using a weapon. the way she hit the car using the steering lock shows her intention to use the weapon to assault and hurt others.

that kind of people should be put in jail.
PJusa
post Jul 18 2014, 05:42 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,025 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: PJ
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 17 2014, 11:34 AM)
Well, I like when some jerks like to deny something without doing more research. Tell you what, the English and Malay papers never have a news stating people are complaining about once the meter changed, their bill raise up buy 100-300%. Only Chinese papers has.
So instead of looking at the "rated" spec, I will dig more on typical rated spec at full or low load which is ~50% from it.
Analog meters are using mechanical parts, so wear and tear is there. Still it won't cause a huge spike when changing to new meter. Have to know that, no third party independent party to calibrate those digital meters and it is open secret that TNB asked their contractors to make it run faster than normal.
*
i am not dignifying the race card game - this is a fav malaysian pasttime and serves no purpose besides dividing ethnical groups so that incompetent and possible c*** politicians can ab*** power. if you play their game, good for them bad for the country.

first of and again for the record. just because something is printed it doesnt become true (thank god). if i think of all the *** published in "newspapers" like berita hariam i am really thankfull for that.

second: if what you say were true then you can easily and successfully sue TNB for meter tempering which is a crime. since its on a large scale its more serious. demand a couple of millions compensation for kicks.

third: measuring power consumption through a meter can be verified. get your meter tested in a lab if you feel like it.

i am sure you will be able to get a credible finding with a definite answer. your tests just dont hold up to a test environment - sorry.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 18 2014, 05:49 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 18 2014, 05:17 PM)
she should be put in jail on the charge of aggression using a weapon. the way she hit the car using the steering lock shows her intention to use the weapon to assault and hurt others.

that kind of people should be put in jail.
*
Well, she think she was the princess. Thanks to the Malaysian education.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 18 2014, 06:07 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(PJusa @ Jul 18 2014, 05:42 PM)
i am not dignifying the race card game - this is a fav malaysian pasttime and serves no purpose besides dividing ethnical groups so that incompetent and possible c*** politicians can ab*** power. if you play their game, good for them bad for the country.

first of and again for the record. just because something is printed it doesnt become true (thank god). if i think of all the *** published in "newspapers" like berita hariam i am really thankfull for that.

second: if what you say were true then you can easily and successfully sue TNB for meter tempering which is a crime. since its on a large scale its more serious. demand a couple of millions compensation for kicks.

third: measuring power consumption through a meter can be verified. get your meter tested in a lab if you feel like it.

i am sure you will be able to get a credible finding with a definite answer. your tests just dont hold up to a test environment - sorry.
*
first, everything printed in papers may not be true, but that will be more on political issue. On this, Chinese papers are more fair in some sense.
second, nobody can verify as no third party independent tester can be approved by government.
thirdly, I can use a FLIR camera to measure by comparing temperature between 2 meters. By cut off every electrical appliance and take temperature, the digital meter's incoming wire will still be warmer compare to analog type.
TSpaskal
post Jul 18 2014, 06:22 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 18 2014, 05:49 PM)
Well, she think she was the princess. Thanks to the Malaysian education.
*
integration should start where there's no prejudice, at the root, at a young age, at the primary school. or even younger at the preschool.

yet the plan to scrap all the different vernacular schools in malaysia are heavily opposed and could not be done previously. we're still continuing the segregation, and indirectly supporting it by avoiding the school integration.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 18 2014, 06:34 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 18 2014, 06:22 PM)
integration should start where there's no prejudice, at the root, at a young age, at the primary school. or even younger at the preschool.

yet the plan to scrap all the different vernacular schools in malaysia are heavily opposed and could not be done previously. we're still continuing the segregation, and indirectly supporting it by avoiding the school integration.
*
Now working in Qatar, when tell them that we have throwing animal's head in front of a house, they also surprise.
Their electric bill is ~rm1000 for a family of 4 but then they never complaint as their average income is rm30000.
Fazab
post Jul 18 2014, 06:43 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


The house, what happened to the house.......
sailen
post Jul 18 2014, 07:29 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
173 posts

Joined: Mar 2006


QUOTE(Fazab @ Jul 18 2014, 06:43 PM)
The house, what happened to the house.......
*
+1

Following this thread as a guide for my new house too.
PJusa
post Jul 19 2014, 11:01 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,025 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: PJ
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 18 2014, 06:07 PM)
first, everything printed in papers may not be true, but that will be more on political issue. On this, Chinese papers are more fair in some sense.
second, nobody can verify as no third party independent tester can be approved by government.
thirdly, I can use a FLIR camera to measure by comparing temperature between 2 meters. By cut off every electrical appliance and take temperature, the digital meter's incoming wire will still be warmer compare to analog type.
*
seriously - if you are so sure about being cheated go ahead and file a claim. and this has *nothing* to do with government. the court will accept and expert witness with credentials. i encourage you to sue tnb if you think they cheat you. get evidence, confront them, demand compensation and rectification and if they dont budge, sue them - easiest is in small claims trial which limits your claim to RM 5000 but you can add side demands (working meter, affirmation of a no future overcharges etc. etc.). the problem i see is that ppl like to complain but they dont act on it. if i were you, i'd be breathing down tnb's neck already. no need to be scared of glc-companies - i personally took three to court before results: two wins, one settlement (which essentially was a win too). and mind you this involved a major local government controlled bank. no need to be afraid to use the tools at hand. but honestly: under normal cicrumstances their meters are spot on - i have my own data to compare to (old/new meter). so i dont see a case but then i havent seen your individual setup.

SUSsupersound
post Jul 19 2014, 05:33 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(PJusa @ Jul 19 2014, 11:01 AM)
seriously - if you are so sure about being cheated go ahead and file a claim. and this has *nothing* to do with government. the court will accept and expert witness with credentials. i encourage you to sue tnb if you think they cheat you. get evidence, confront them, demand compensation and rectification and if they dont budge, sue them - easiest is in small claims trial which limits your claim to RM 5000 but you can add side demands (working meter, affirmation of a no future overcharges etc. etc.). the problem i see is that ppl like to complain but they dont act on it. if i were you, i'd be breathing down tnb's neck already. no need to be scared of glc-companies - i personally took three to court before results: two wins, one settlement (which essentially was a win too). and mind you this involved a major local government controlled bank. no need to be afraid to use the tools at hand. but honestly: under normal cicrumstances their meters are spot on - i have my own data to compare to (old/new meter). so i dont see a case but then i havent seen your individual setup.
*
Well, if there is a lawyer that willing to take this case, I already filed a law suit against them.
Even a lawyer from DAP also said this cannot be a case as there is no government certified third party independent company that can confirm the meter's accuracy. Or you want me to look for an UMNO laywer to sue his boss?
File a law suit is easy, but winning it is another story.
This is just like some people won in Indah Water's case. But did they specify clearly how they won it? Most of the people that won on such law suit is mainly because their "dirty" water a routed to a tank rather than routed to a Indah Water's facility. And Indah Water are charging normal rate to them. So for such group of people they just only need to provide their floor plan and other legal documents and that's it.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 19 2014, 05:34 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(Fazab @ Jul 18 2014, 06:43 PM)
The house, what happened to the house.......
*
Wow, you think so easy to build a house?
wow1wow2
post Jul 20 2014, 01:46 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
283 posts

Joined: Sep 2009


what is the location of this land
4g15p
post Jul 20 2014, 10:20 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
61 posts

Joined: Jun 2007
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 18 2014, 05:49 PM)
Well, she think she was the princess. Thanks to the Malaysian education.
*
N u think a chinese lady who slapped a malay lady enforcer in penang is her majesty?
No need to resort to physical attack, just paying a ticket for the offence u made is suffice. Duh

PJusa
post Jul 21 2014, 09:45 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,025 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: PJ
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 19 2014, 05:33 PM)
Well, if there is a lawyer that willing to take this case, I already filed a law suit against them.
Even a lawyer from DAP also said this cannot be a case as there is no government certified third party independent company that can confirm the meter's accuracy. Or you want me to look for an UMNO laywer to sue his boss?
File a law suit is easy, but winning it is another story.
This is just like some people won in Indah Water's case. But did they specify clearly how they won it? Most of the people that won on  such law suit is mainly because their "dirty" water a routed to a tank rather than routed to a Indah Water's facility. And Indah Water are charging normal rate to them. So for such group of people they just only need to provide their floor plan and other legal documents and that's it.
*
seriously you are going all wrong. why stroll to a pary lawyer? what for?

you file a small claims suit in your local court, provide evidence and serve a notice, wait for TNB to reply and then continue. you do not need (nor are you allowed) a lawyer in small claims court. max. damage to you is 100 RM court fees.

to win a law suit you need to have evidence and an argument. i told you before that your evidence and arguments are not good. that's your problem. you dont need a government certified blah - an expert testimony and witness statement is good enough (i.e. get someone from the field to check our your situation). if your evidence is good its TNBs job to proof you wrong. going for political parties for support is the wrong way to get anything done. personally i see the quality of the politicians in malaysia and i feel very sad. the incompetency and lack of knowledge in pretty much everything is sad and frightening and it persists across all parties with one no two standing out in this ocean of incompetence. but all that is irrelevant to a court case. try to read up on it instead of ranting around.

all that*s needed is your willingness to act if you feel someone it doing you wrong. small claims court is easy and even a laymen can get through it. the court helps and advises you. trust me if you have a case the court will be in your favour. been there done it. bank went against me with one lawyer, saw i had good arguments beefed up with 3 and in the end 4 lawyers, still they lost on all grounds and had to fullfill all my demands, i only was asked to skip the demand for a public personal apology in a national newspaper. as part of the settlement this was moved to a public apology in the bank's branch in front of all customers that happened to be there. mind you all my contract changes and damages demand had to be met and they paid me my court expenditures too.

so to sum it up: if i had actual evidence (which once again i dont think you have, gather proper evidence first) i would send tnb a warning and then sue them. we actually need more consumers to go and sue irresponsible companies. but only if there is a case.
y00ng
post Jul 21 2014, 04:49 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
74 posts

Joined: Jun 2014
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 28 2014, 06:20 PM)
lets get things straight.
1. i'm not a contractor. i'm not trying to sell you anything.
this is my own house, on my own piece of land. not a documentation on some other fella house/project.
2. respect is warranted. this is not kopitiam.

the initial plan was to acquire this land and build a house at this location:
user posted image
effective ~10,000 sqft after minus all the road reserve and sea reserve.

imagine opening your door to this, every morning, for the rest of your life.
user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image

and kitchen and deck opens up to this
user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image

there's a wave breaker as you can see, and even at high tide, the sea level doesn't rise past the barrier. even then there's a drainage system to avoid seawater from going into paddy fields. MADA takes great precaution to avoid such situation from ever happening.

the land deal however, didn't went through. sigh.
proceeding with backup plan.
*
Hi,
I have a plan for you. You can have a design of a container to transform into a house. You may look according, to the picture inline.

For more details, you can message me or call me. My number is 016-3272143


Attached thumbnail(s)
Attached Image Attached Image
makunouchi
post Jul 21 2014, 05:19 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
77 posts

Joined: Aug 2011
From: KL
Hi, ive been reading your thread.
Very impressive project smile.gif

Im very much interested once you ve designed your LED downlights with
Acceptable efficiency..

I recently furnished a studio with individual oem leds units, no idea on the bill yet tongue.gif
SUSsupersound
post Jul 21 2014, 10:08 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(PJusa @ Jul 21 2014, 09:45 AM)
seriously you are going all wrong. why stroll to a pary lawyer? what for?

you file a small claims suit in your local court, provide evidence and serve a notice, wait for TNB to reply and then continue. you do not need (nor are you allowed) a lawyer in small claims court. max. damage to you is 100 RM court fees.

to win a law suit you need to have evidence and an argument. i told you before that your evidence and arguments are not good. that's your problem. you dont need a government certified blah - an expert testimony and witness statement is good enough (i.e. get someone from the field to check our your situation). if your evidence is good its TNBs job to proof you wrong. going for political parties for support is the wrong way to get anything done. personally i see the quality of the politicians in malaysia and i feel very sad. the incompetency and lack of knowledge in pretty much everything is sad and frightening and it persists across all parties with one no two standing out in this ocean of incompetence. but all that is irrelevant to a court case. try to read up on it instead of ranting around.

all that*s needed is your willingness to act if you feel someone it doing you wrong. small claims court is easy and even a laymen can get through it. the court helps and advises you. trust me if you have a case the court will be in your favour. been there done it. bank went against me with one lawyer, saw i had good arguments beefed up with 3 and in the end 4 lawyers, still they lost on all grounds and had to fullfill all my demands, i only was asked to skip the demand for a public personal apology in a national newspaper. as part of the settlement this was moved to a public apology in the bank's branch in front of all customers that happened to be there. mind you all my contract changes and damages demand had to be met and they paid me my court expenditures too.

so to sum it up: if i had actual evidence (which once again i dont think you have, gather proper evidence first) i would send tnb a warning and then sue them. we actually need more consumers to go and sue irresponsible companies. but only if there is a case.
*
Well, it is easy for you to say. But again if 100% I can win then only I go for it. Else I won't waste time on it.
PJusa
post Jul 22 2014, 09:55 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,025 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: PJ
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 21 2014, 10:08 PM)
Well, it is easy for you to say. But again if 100% I can win then only I go for it. Else I won't waste time on it.
*
then there is no need to complain.
SUSsupersound
post Jul 22 2014, 11:50 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(PJusa @ Jul 22 2014, 09:55 AM)
then there is no need to complain.
*
I never complaint, just to let more people know on TNB's dirty way of making money.
Does verbal statement from a TNB contractor's statement carry any weight? You think of it.
PJusa
post Jul 23 2014, 02:50 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,025 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: PJ
QUOTE(supersound @ Jul 22 2014, 11:50 AM)
I never complaint, just to let more people know on TNB's dirty way of making money.
Does verbal statement from a TNB contractor's statement carry any weight? You think of it.
*
i am lost - i really dont understand you issue then. nvr mind, i dont think this serves any purpose.
TSpaskal
post Aug 2 2014, 08:10 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
this is what happened to the house.

this is the original, simple outlook.
front perspective from the entry road:
user posted image

back perspective from the master bedroom:
(furthest right is the master bedroom)
user posted image

front perspective from the left, overlooking the family deck.
user posted image

it's too simplistic. doesn't look that nice, especially from the back.
well it's supposed to be that way, since it's just a rough sketch to get a basic idea on the house outlook. in no way final.

time for some architecture magic. courtesy of the wife.
TSpaskal
post Aug 2 2014, 08:28 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
we're going for modern-minimalist outlook for both the exterior and interior.
pardon the extra things visible in the drawing. it's a work in progress after all.

walls are fixed at 12 feet high, because we're going for at least 10 feet high ceiling minimum.
opting for 10.5-11 feet high ceiling for the rooms, 14-16 feet high ceiling for the living room, family area and kitchen.

main structure beam is 1.5 feet high, for a floor raised to around 20 inch effective from the ground. it will act as a natural deterrent for rodent and snake from entering the house. the house is flanked by paddy fields around it, and snakes and rat is a natural problem here.

front perspective from the the entry road.
user posted image

back perspective from the left. left side is the HT room, right side is the master bedroom.
user posted image

back perspective from the right. master bedroom and deck visible.
user posted image

front perspective from the deck
user posted image

view of the deck with the integrated planter box and raised floor that will act as sitting area.
user posted image

now it looks much nicer. i was a little worried with the basic outlook of the house previously.
after messing around with the windows design and wall arrangement, it looks pretty modern to me.

architecture magic!
the floorplan is the same, but only some parts the wall are extended by a brick length. i was surprised to see how a simple modification could change the outlook so much.
TSpaskal
post Aug 2 2014, 09:23 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
wife provides the architectural insight, and i provide the engineering standpoint.
i can understand why architect and engineer fight all the time.

been designing things and building them for a few years now, made that much easier with the advent of sketchup.
it's much easier to use compared to autocad (for 3d design/editing in 3d space), much faster result, less hassle, while retaining much of the precision that you get from a cad software.

some of my past projects designed and fully built with the help of sketchup:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

all built with less than 1mm error. the precision is there, provided you could accurately follow the design.
project is documented over in lowyat's home entertainment section and hifi4sale's DIY section.

i freakin love sketchup. because i freckin hate autocad. laugh.gif
TSpaskal
post Aug 2 2014, 09:37 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(wow1wow2 @ Jul 20 2014, 01:46 AM)
what is the location of this land
*
somewhere in kedah, near the perlis border.
not revealing the exact location.

QUOTE(y00ng @ Jul 21 2014, 04:49 PM)
Hi,
I have a plan for you. You can have a design of a container to transform into a house. You may look according, to the picture inline.

For more details, you can message me or call me. My number is 016-3272143
*
thanks for the offer. i (we) already have a plan that we're comfortable with.

QUOTE(makunouchi @ Jul 21 2014, 05:19 PM)
Hi, ive been reading your thread.
Very impressive project smile.gif

Im very much interested once you ve designed your LED downlights with
Acceptable efficiency..

I recently furnished a studio with individual oem leds units, no idea on the bill yet tongue.gif
*
i've order individual smd chips supposedly from epistar. well the seller says it's from epistar, can't confirm even he's lying.
0.5w chips, from 3 different sellers. 100 pieces each. testing purposes laugh.gif

hopefully i could hit the targeted 100w power usage for overnight lighting.
in no way possible with off the shelf solution.
ozak
post Aug 3 2014, 01:30 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 2 2014, 09:23 PM)
wife provides the architectural insight, and i provide the engineering standpoint.
i can understand why architect and engineer fight all the time.

been designing things and building them for a few years now, made that much easier with the advent of sketchup.
it's much easier to use compared to autocad (for 3d design/editing in 3d space), much faster result, less hassle, while retaining much of the precision that you get from a cad software.

some of my past projects designed and fully built with the help of sketchup:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

all built with less than 1mm error. the precision is there, provided you could accurately follow the design.
project is documented over in lowyat's home entertainment section and hifi4sale's DIY section.

i freakin love sketchup. because i freckin hate autocad. laugh.gif
*
Your space partition look confuse. Seems like a maze. rclxub.gif and I would be get lost inside there. tongue.gif

I not really like sketchup as it difficult to navigate view around. I have to buy a 3d mouse to aid me. Of course autocad is not as attractive as 3d software. But it give better 2d dimensions drawing where builder need it.

I learn that building doesn't require high accuracy. If I follow that high accurate and talk to contractor, I think I will pull my hair and many arguement. biggrin.gif My job require precision accuracy of 20micron. That sometime make my outside life difficult.
TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2014, 12:58 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Aug 3 2014, 01:30 AM)
Your space partition look confuse. Seems like a maze.  rclxub.gif  and I would be get lost inside there.  tongue.gif

I not really like sketchup as it difficult to navigate view around. I have to buy a 3d mouse to aid me. Of course autocad is not as attractive as 3d software. But it give better 2d dimensions drawing where builder need it.

I learn that building doesn't require high accuracy. If I follow that high accurate and talk to contractor, I think I will pull my hair and many arguement.  biggrin.gif  My job require precision accuracy of 20micron. That sometime make my outside life difficult.
*
it's not space partition, but internal bracing for the outside walls. it's a subwoofer, a high power at that.
the internal pressure at high output causes the outside walls to flex. so internal bracing is designed to provide more support than is needed, to avoid the flexing issue.

the internal space can't be partitioned as it'll reduce the effective internal area. large opening for the bracing is needed to avoid wind noise when the sub is pressurized.
thus the maze look.
ozak
post Aug 3 2014, 01:21 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 3 2014, 12:58 PM)
it's not space partition, but internal bracing for the outside walls. it's a subwoofer, a high power at that.
the internal pressure at high output causes the outside walls to flex. so internal bracing is designed to provide more support than is needed, to avoid the flexing issue.

the internal space can't be partitioned as it'll reduce the effective internal area. large opening for the bracing is needed to avoid wind noise when the sub is pressurized.
thus the maze look.
*
Sorry. I mean your house partition wall design. It look like a lot of wall which look like a maze.
TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2014, 04:14 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
roofed.
17 & 19 degrees pitch.

floorplan is relatively unchanged. tho it won't hurt experimenting with 13 feet high walls just to see how that will look like. 13 feet wall would allow us to go with 11.5 feet high ceiling. that will certainly improve ventilation throughout the entire house.

guest outboard deck attached to the living room/guest dining area looks like it'll be nicer if it's extended. shaded of course.

user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image

TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2014, 04:26 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Aug 3 2014, 01:21 PM)
Sorry. I mean your house partition wall design. It look like a lot of wall which look like a maze.
*
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
the house layout is really straight forward. there's not even a pathway or walkway inside the house.
there's no change to the floorplan when we erected the 3D.

we purposely went with a straightforward design to maximize space.
ozak
post Aug 3 2014, 10:55 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 3 2014, 04:26 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

the house layout is really straight forward. there's not even a pathway or walkway inside the house.
there's no change to the floorplan when we erected the 3D.

we purposely went with a straightforward design to maximize space.
*
Seems ok looking from the top view. Will the family area, living hall and dinning area too dark? It surround by the room etc.

Another is the ventilation of the house. The roof it totally seal off and no hot air vent out. Are you planning for whole house aircon?
TSpaskal
post Aug 4 2014, 11:26 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Aug 3 2014, 10:55 PM)
Seems ok looking from the top view. Will the family area, living hall and dinning area too dark? It surround by the room etc.
*
no idea if it's gonna be dark. but there's gonna be a large glass opening at the kitchen wall to aid lighting. wife did say that the kitchen area looks like it won't receive much natural lighting as it is. the dry kitchen needs a lot of lighting for cooking.

for family area and living hall i think we're keeping natural light off of those. the house area usually gets too much sun during midday.


QUOTE(ozak @ Aug 3 2014, 10:55 PM)
Another is the ventilation of the house. The roof it totally seal off and no hot air vent out. Are you planning for whole house aircon?
*
good question. someone also asked previously, mentioning roof turbine.
user posted image
it's gonna look horrendous spoiling the entire modern outlook of the house.

tho to aid roof ventilation, we're incorporating 3 solution. the first two was mention before this.
first being the outdoor ceiling with opening.
second being the roof insulation with an air gap, supposedly moving air from the roof edges to the top of the structure.

and third, we're incorporating this:
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image

i'm gonna put aluminium louvres on the wall. that will force and channel wind from outside of the house into the roof structure, promoting better ventilation. air will escape at the outside ceiling.

there's a risk that rainwater will be forced into the ceiling together with heavy rain and strong wind.
but if we didn't put up the holes right now, there's no way to cut the walls later on. at the worst case, i could just seal off the louvres at the back if there's too much problem with water.
or change the angle of the fin.
or redesign the louvres.

it's an experiment laugh.gif
TSpaskal
post Aug 4 2014, 12:14 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
skinned. materials added.
my son's room will have an attic since he wants a staircase. sorry son mommy and daddy can't afford a double storey house. but your room will have a play area overlooking the nice view.

user posted image
user posted image
user posted image

so with this we're proceeding with negotiations with the contractor(s). house outlook and floorplan is finalized.
ozak
post Aug 4 2014, 01:12 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 4 2014, 11:26 AM)
no idea if it's gonna be dark. but there's gonna be a large glass opening at the kitchen wall to aid lighting. wife did say that the kitchen area looks like it won't receive much natural lighting as it is. the dry kitchen needs a lot of lighting for cooking.

for family area and living hall i think we're keeping natural light off of those. the house area usually gets too much sun during midday.
When going oversea, I checked their house design. What important to them. Either western (Oz) or Asia (japan). So far what I can check on this country.

First is the living/hall/family area. This must face garden or scenery area. With large open glass door of whatever that you can see through. I sit down and try to feel it from their hall/living/family area. It is really soothing your eye and relax when sitting in there to enjoy the outside view. Even I watching tv or talking in there, the nice view outside keep disturb my eye. biggrin.gif Since your house is surround by the rice field scenery, why not try to use this advantage. The natural light is bright enough for your whole hall.

Than the dining area is close to the kitchen. Probably don't 1 walk that far with the dish. biggrin.gif Than the room. If you want the master bedroom face the scenery/garden, than align to it. But all the room door is away or face away from the hall/kitchen/dining area. For toilet, western will put inside the room while Japanese will put outside.

All are max using natural light for the room/hall. So there is no room or hall is hiding or middle and away from natural light.
ozak
post Aug 4 2014, 01:56 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 4 2014, 11:26 AM)
good question. someone also asked previously, mentioning roof turbine.
user posted image
it's gonna look horrendous spoiling the entire modern outlook of the house.

tho to aid roof ventilation, we're incorporating 3 solution. the first two was mention before this.
first being the outdoor ceiling with opening.
second being the roof insulation with an air gap, supposedly moving air from the roof edges to the top of the structure.

and third, we're incorporating this:
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image

i'm gonna put aluminium louvres on the wall. that will force and channel wind from outside of the house into the roof structure, promoting better ventilation. air will escape at the outside ceiling.

there's a risk that rainwater will be forced into the ceiling together with heavy rain and strong wind.
but if we didn't put up the holes right now, there's no way to cut the walls later on. at the worst case, i could just seal off the louvres at the back if there's too much problem with water.
or change the angle of the fin.
or redesign the louvres.

it's an experiment laugh.gif
*
From your location and place, it is a large flat padi field area. With occasionally 1-2 small hill like granite. I use to travel there. More toward to perlis.

It is a very hot place. And you have to endure the burning crops of land and field twice or thrice a yrs. sweat.gif I guess you have to look at the ventilation seriously.

The ventilation have to separate into 2. The roof ventilation and the in house ventilation. If you seal off the roof, the air inside will heat up and no place to go. I m not sure insulate your ceiling will help. Will the heat slowly travel down to the ceiling through conducting. Since the heat no where to go.

For the in house air flow, as usual, hot air rise and in/out airflow have to consider.
ozak
post Aug 4 2014, 03:28 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


For the ventilation, I have plan it on my drawing board for a while now. Initially this is how it look from the side for what I have plan on my house. Maybe something you can pick up here from my stupid plan. biggrin.gif

user posted image

Behind below hatching is a concrete slab. While the roof is front side. Most of the wind is from front side of the house. So I create an air flow for the roof from front and vent out at behind cover with aluminium lourve. The shade rain will help shelve the rain storm. Actually it doesn't really need that shade also. As the lower side is a hot air vent out area. Which is a toilet.

The roof vent is taking care. Now the in house. The hot air raise and air flow will flow up top through the toilet and vent out at the same lourve. I m using the air spray/jet flow theory. If there is an air flow in the roof, it create a vacuum at the hot air vent. That will force the hot air out from inside the house. A + point additional beside the normal hot air out.

Create a middle concrete slab but shade a way by the roof can help reduce the rain storm getting in. You also have a space for water tank and an outdoor aircon unit to place. All this hide away on the roof without damage your exterior house look. Easy maintenance too.
TSpaskal
post Aug 9 2014, 09:51 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Aug 4 2014, 01:12 PM)
When going oversea, I checked their house design. What important to them. Either western (Oz) or Asia (japan). So far what I can check on this country.

First is the living/hall/family area. This must face garden or scenery area. With large open glass door of whatever that you can see through. I sit down and try to feel it from their hall/living/family area. It is really soothing your eye and relax when sitting in there to enjoy the outside view. Even I watching tv or talking in there, the nice view outside keep disturb my eye. biggrin.gif  Since your house is surround by the rice field scenery, why not try to use this advantage. The natural light is bright enough for your whole hall.

Than the dining area is close to the kitchen. Probably don't 1 walk that far with the dish. biggrin.gif Than the room. If you want the master bedroom face the scenery/garden, than align to it. But all the room door is away or face away from the hall/kitchen/dining area. For toilet, western will put inside the room while Japanese will put outside.

All are max using natural light for the room/hall. So there is no room or hall is hiding or middle and away from natural light.
*
thanks for the pointer. wife did her part 2 in aussie so i hope she's versed with the architecture there.
we do have a large folding door that opens nearly all the entire wall span at the family deck and guest deck area. 12 feet of folding door.

QUOTE(ozak @ Aug 4 2014, 01:56 PM)
From your location and place, it is a large flat padi field area. With occasionally 1-2 small hill like granite. I use to travel there. More toward to perlis.

It is a very hot place. And you have to endure the burning crops of land and field twice or thrice a yrs.  sweat.gif I guess you have to look at the ventilation seriously.

The ventilation have to separate into 2. The roof ventilation and the in house ventilation. If you seal off the roof, the air inside will heat up and no place to go. I m not sure insulate your ceiling will help. Will the heat slowly travel down to the ceiling through conducting. Since the heat no where to go.

For the in house air flow, as usual, hot air rise and in/out airflow have to consider.
*
yes it's very hot. but even during midday it's naturally windy. sometimes too violent.
and we have to endure this:
user posted image
which causes lots and lots of small insects at night.

then this:
user posted image
user posted image
which causes lots of smoke and flying ash.

there's gonna be 2 harvesting season a year, which will last for a week. so everything have to be considered. we can't have an open plan, or an indoor courtyard without needing some major cleanup during the harvesting season.

QUOTE(ozak @ Aug 4 2014, 03:28 PM)
For the ventilation, I have plan it on my drawing board for a while now. Initially this is how it look from the side for what I have plan on my house. Maybe something you can pick up here from my stupid plan.  biggrin.gif

user posted image

Behind below hatching is a concrete slab. While the roof is front side. Most of the wind is from front side of the house. So I create an air flow for the roof from front and vent out at behind cover with aluminium lourve. The shade rain will help shelve the rain storm. Actually it doesn't really need that shade also. As the lower side is a hot air vent out area. Which is a toilet.

The roof vent is taking care. Now the in house. The hot air raise and air flow will flow up top through the toilet and vent out at the same lourve. I m using the air spray/jet flow theory. If there is an air flow in the roof, it create a vacuum at the hot air vent. That will force the hot air out from inside the house. A + point additional beside the normal hot air out.

Create a middle concrete slab but shade a way by the roof can help reduce the rain storm getting in. You also have a space for water tank and an outdoor aircon unit to place. All this hide away on the roof without damage your exterior house look. Easy maintenance too.
*
thanks for the suggestion.
your idea is the same as mine. tho i have to consider that we're gonna see wind from both direction. so i can't exactly implement the rising hot air movement as wind will force the hot air from rising and move to the bottom of the structure. so in my design the ceiling is sealed from the room to avoid hot air from the ceiling structure being forced into the room during heavy wind.
TSpaskal
post Aug 9 2014, 10:16 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
got back a quote.
RM88 per square feet.

which translates to RM320k for the entire structure.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

IDs and maybe other contractors will say it's gonna cost me another RM600k or at least RM300k more to do the interior. icon_rolleyes.gif
much bloated price IDs charge, eh?
Fazab
post Aug 9 2014, 11:02 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


Plumbing & electrical?
SUSsupersound
post Aug 10 2014, 01:56 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
For effective natural ventilation, with the roof open fully also useless.
You need to make sure the ceiling are flat, windows are opened.
TSpaskal
post Aug 10 2014, 08:08 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(Fazab @ Aug 9 2014, 11:02 PM)
Plumbing & electrical?
*
included.
single phase wiring. each room will get a set of basic downlight, one plug point and one ceiling fan. extra item must be paid directly to the electrician assigned to the project. if i'm not satisfied with him, i can appoint my own wireman and the company will pay the wireman for the cost. single metal db.

interior and exterior plumbing is included with the quote. also full house apron with cement drainage. PE septic tank. 4 water closet at all 4 toilet location, can't remember the brand but we are shown our options to choose from. acceptable quality.
the company also agreed to cover the fancy stone tile at the structure beam that my wife wants.

everything will be done in black and white agreement, signed by both parties with a witness present. if should i choose to proceed with them. not just verbal agreement, and valid as evidence in court. laugh.gif

6 years warranty for the paint. 20 year warranty for the house structure.
the owner is also willing to put it in black and white for both warranty. brows.gif

but it's not without downside, right?
the contractor won't proceed with the proposed roof pitch at 17 degrees. he wants 28 minimum. else he won't cover the roof leaking issue. but that would put my roof too high of an angle. and will look terrible.

will try and mod the design to see how it looks with 28 pitch.
TSpaskal
post Aug 10 2014, 08:13 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
forgot to mention.
it's a sendirian berhad company. 20 years track record. 3 large hardware shops at 3 different location. 2 main warehouse. they even branched into retail supermarkets, hotels. previously built mosques, shoplots, hotels.
SUSsupersound
post Aug 10 2014, 09:36 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 10 2014, 08:08 AM)

6 years warranty for the paint. 20 year warranty for the house structure.
the owner is also willing to put it in black and white for both warranty. brows.gif

*
Main structure shall be lifetime, not with period.
-oc-gassa
post Aug 10 2014, 12:24 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
967 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: setapak
red brick advantages vs cost? any comment if using cheaper alternative?
TSpaskal
post Aug 10 2014, 03:07 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Aug 10 2014, 09:36 AM)
Main structure shall be lifetime, not with period.
*
and yet i don't see any of the housing development projects giving any warranty after 1-2 years.
this one is willing to cover 20 years if should there's any crack on the wall.

i see lots of housing over here have crack forming on the wall under a year.

QUOTE(-oc-gassa @ Aug 10 2014, 12:24 PM)
red brick advantages vs cost? any comment if using cheaper alternative?
*
some people say red clay brick have better insulation against heat by sunshine. better cooling effect.

wife says red clay bricks have better heat retention ability, thus frequently used in western countries. they absorb heat during the day, making the house cooler during the day but they excrete the stored heat during the night. thus heating the walls making it warmer. a welcomed trait for western countries where night time is very cold and it would reduce the heating costs.
not exactly an appealing proposition for the weather here.

anyway we're planning for AAC bricks for the west facing walls to improve the insulation. it's only ~60 feet of walls that face the evening sunshine. and the rest of the house probably the normal cement bricks. undecided yet.
SUSsupersound
post Aug 10 2014, 04:49 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 10 2014, 03:07 PM)
and yet i don't see any of the housing development projects giving any warranty after 1-2 years.
this one is willing to cover 20 years if should there's any crack on the wall.

i see lots of housing over here have crack forming on the wall under a year.
some people say red clay brick have better insulation against heat by sunshine. better cooling effect.

wife says red clay bricks have better heat retention ability, thus frequently used in western countries. they absorb heat during the day, making the house cooler during the day but they excrete the stored heat during the night. thus heating the walls making it warmer. a welcomed trait for western countries where night time is very cold and it would reduce the heating costs.
not exactly an appealing proposition for the weather here.

anyway we're planning for AAC bricks for the west facing walls to improve the insulation. it's only ~60 feet of walls that face the evening sunshine. and the rest of the house probably the normal cement bricks. undecided yet.
*
Main structure and wall are different.
Walls warranty coverage is 18 months while main structure is lifetime.
This is government's requirement.
Also, red brick's quality also are quite poor, it will expand over the time, especially if it expose to water frequently.
evangelion
post Aug 10 2014, 05:56 PM

The Ancient Ones
******
Senior Member
1,057 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 10 2014, 03:07 PM)
i see lots of housing over here have crack forming on the wall under a year.
some people say red clay brick have better insulation against heat by sunshine. better cooling effect.
I think these cracking is due to either workmanship, not enough vent for an extended period of time & external work which vibrates and shifts the alignment even so slightly. As far as workmanship is concerned, it will be best to refer to your friends' houses finishes.
I'm impressed and enjoying your work TS, keep it up.

QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 10 2014, 03:07 PM)
wife says red clay bricks have better heat retention ability, thus frequently used in western countries. they absorb heat during the day, making the house cooler during the day but they excrete the stored heat during the night. thus heating the walls making it warmer. a welcomed trait for western countries where night time is very cold and it would reduce the heating costs.
not exactly an appealing proposition for the weather here.

anyway we're planning for AAC bricks for the west facing walls to improve the insulation. it's only ~60 feet of walls that face the evening sunshine. and the rest of the house probably the normal cement bricks. undecided yet.
*
Personally, i prefer red brick, not sure whether red brick or cement is better.
U might use "double wall" to better vent the house.

Something to contribute, i find this site really useful:
http://www.yourhome.gov.au/passive-design/passive-cooling

SUSsupersound
post Aug 10 2014, 06:17 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(evangelion @ Aug 10 2014, 05:56 PM)
I think these cracking is due to either workmanship, not enough vent for an extended period of time & external work which vibrates and shifts the alignment even so slightly. As far as workmanship is concerned, it will be best to refer to your friends' houses finishes.
I'm impressed and enjoying your work TS, keep it up.
Personally, i prefer red brick, not sure whether red brick or cement is better.
U might use "double wall" to better vent the house.

Brick have problem, the sand/cement ratio not right and using poor quality sand.
Building a 22*75 double storey house only need rm90000-100000 max, if the materials are sourced in bulk, it will be cheaper by 20-30%
TSpaskal
post Aug 10 2014, 06:19 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
thanks for the pointer guys.
will make more info available once we receive more reply from the contractors.
SUSsupersound
post Aug 10 2014, 08:10 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 10 2014, 06:19 PM)
thanks for the pointer guys.
will make more info available once we receive more reply from the contractors.
*
Wall break the roof won't really collapse, but pillar breaks, you know what I mean.
BTW, I think I never ask you is the land flat and stable land or reclaim land?
ShadowR1
post Aug 11 2014, 02:20 AM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(evangelion @ Aug 10 2014, 05:56 PM)
U might use "double wall" to better vent the house.
*
I agree to this... the west wall.

Noobl3t
post Aug 11 2014, 09:53 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
Delete

This post has been edited by Noobl3t: Aug 11 2014, 09:54 AM
TSpaskal
post Aug 11 2014, 10:41 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Aug 10 2014, 08:10 PM)
Wall break the roof won't really collapse, but pillar breaks, you know what I mean.
BTW, I think I never ask you is the land flat and stable land or reclaim land?
*
it's previously a paddy field.
user posted image

QUOTE(ShadowR1 @ Aug 11 2014, 02:20 AM)
I agree to this... the west wall.
*
if AAC is cheaper i might just go with AAC blocks just for the west wall.
if not have to consider double bricking that wall as i did to the HT room.

if even that is too expensive i just consider double bricking the master bedroom wall. but seeing that we have lots of 7'x7' windows, brick cost can't be that much anyway.
ozak
post Aug 11 2014, 11:08 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 11 2014, 10:41 AM)
if AAC is cheaper i might just go with AAC blocks just for the west wall.
if not have to consider double bricking that wall as i did to the HT room.

if even that is too expensive i just consider double bricking the master bedroom wall. but seeing that we have lots of 7'x7' windows, brick cost can't be that much anyway.
*
AAC not really expensive. Since it bigger size. I block of AAC equal to few pcs normal brick. I did plan to use AAC for the sun hitting wall side when do reno. It come in few thick dimension. Get the slighty thicker type.

But recently someone wrote here that AAC have some quality issue when it age. It become porous. Try search the infor here.

Beside better insulate, AAC also good for fire retention. It stand better in heat when fire happen. Won't collapse the wall compare normal brick. And you can use it as bearing load wall.

1 thing I not so sure is how good it can hang a load if drill and wall plug in.
SUSsupersound
post Aug 11 2014, 11:14 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 11 2014, 10:41 AM)
it's previously a paddy field.
user posted image
if AAC is cheaper i might just go with AAC blocks just for the west wall.
if not have to consider double bricking that wall as i did to the HT room.

if even that is too expensive i just consider double bricking the master bedroom wall. but seeing that we have lots of 7'x7' windows, brick cost can't be that much anyway.
*
Solid or not? That's more important.
CoffeeDude
post Aug 12 2014, 04:31 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,609 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: KL


QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 08:19 AM)
if you engage an architect, insist that they do a site survey or site study.
it's the only way to check for sun movement and wind direction in the area. simple info that will make your house cooler and properly ventilated.

avoid orientating the largest wall in the house against sunshine as it will heat up the area inside. avoid arranging bedrooms directly facing the evening sun as it'll make your room hot at night.
and change the direction of your window opening to guide wind into your house, rather than deflecting them away.

user posted image
user posted image
can't find the complete 3D design since there's so many interation and revisions to the plan. it's in here, somewhere.
but the cheapest i got quoted for this plan is RM260k.
basic house, basic equipment, good build quality (from contractor past build history).

specs agreed for RM260k:
12 feet wall
metal deck (because roof pitch is only 5 degrees x 40 feet)
insulated roof
folding door, folding window
full plaster ceiling, 10 feet high
normal downlight, cfl bulb
normal ceiling fan with regulator
16" tile, entire house
full height tile in bathroom
normal paint, indoor and outdoor
normal bathroom finishing
no outdoor tile
no glass railing as in pic

IIRC 4 bathroom, 5 bedroom, 1 ht room, wet & dry kitchen, separated guest living room & dining area, family area, 2nd floor family area, 2 decks.
~3000 sqft interior floorspace.
translates to ~RM86-something psft

edit: (refer post below for accurate floorspace)
*
whoa I'm tracking this topic biggrin.gif

My target is to build a 3000sq ft single storey house in 5-10 years time biggrin.gif

Did you hire architect?
Do you need specialized contractor to do the HT room?
TSpaskal
post Aug 14 2014, 09:23 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
predicting that there's gonna be quite a problem with the room size.
room mode distribution is nice, distributed evenly throughout the spectrum. giving me this:
user posted image

but room simulation shows that the interaction between the walls and the planned listening position ~6 feet from the back, there's gonna be a null at 100hz in all listening position. and another null at 145hz. probably because of interaction from the back wall.
user posted image
should be able to take care of these by minidsp and arc, but the null directly at 100hz is worrying.
these nulls happen even though i had good distribution of the room modes. really perfect for the length. don't think you could get much better than that first graph.

anyway simulation shows that 14' 9" is gonna be better in all listening position:
user posted image

14' won't do much:
user posted image

increasing the ceiling to 9.5' is even worse:
user posted image

10' is the worst. not planning for a ceiling higher than 10' for the ht room, otherwise i'm gonna need more subs to pressurize it.
user posted image

have to consider increasing the ht room by another 9 inch. 14.5' looks better than the planned 13' 9":
user posted image

but that will reduce the porch length to 17 feet.
3 feet overhang from the roof, i should still get ~20 feet cover at the porch. hopefully my wife agrees haha. tongue.gif
SUSsupersound
post Aug 14 2014, 09:30 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
Tapped horn should able to solve your problems.
TSpaskal
post Aug 14 2014, 09:50 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
confirmed interaction with the rear wall. changing the crossover frequency also didn't do shit:
100hz xover
user posted image
90hz xover
user posted image

meanwhile changing xover freq for 14.5' did wonders:
user posted image
user posted image

also did wonders to 14' 9":
user posted image
user posted image

pretty much confirmed my fears. the planned size is gonna pose a problem with that huge null at 100hz. it doesn't happen at the middle of the room, but interaction with the rear wall at the listening position causes that huge null that's gonna be hard to correct with EQ.

not gonna risk it. ht room will be widen by 9 inch to 14' 6".
room mode distribution isn't as nice as 13.8', but the freq response at the LP is the absolute priority.

turns out you can't just design a room based on the mode distribution huh.
TSpaskal
post Aug 14 2014, 10:32 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Aug 11 2014, 11:14 AM)
Solid or not? That's more important.
*
solid.

QUOTE(CoffeeDude @ Aug 12 2014, 04:31 PM)
whoa I'm tracking this topic biggrin.gif

My target is to build a 3000sq ft single storey house in 5-10 years time biggrin.gif

Did you hire architect?
Do you need specialized contractor to do the HT room?
*
nope. we suka suka draw draw and give it to the contractor for estimation.
nope. not gonna hire a dedicated contractor for the ht room. it's diy, remember? biggrin.gif

QUOTE(supersound @ Aug 14 2014, 09:30 PM)
Tapped horn should able to solve your problems.
*
care to explain why a horn setup will solve this null?
CoffeeDude
post Aug 14 2014, 11:24 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,609 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: KL


Wow you did all the drawings yourself? shocking.gif

But for contractors don't they need the drawings for the internal wirings, water piping, air-con piping?

How about security - CCTV, alarm?
SUSsupersound
post Aug 15 2014, 01:23 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 14 2014, 10:32 PM)
solid.
care to explain why a horn setup will solve this null?
*
Tapped horn are used to make a small woofer sound big. Like a 10" can sound like 15" with this concept.
Simulation won't be accurate most of the time.
Have to know that, music are dynamic, so I won't trust simulation most of the time, trust your ears.
TSpaskal
post Aug 15 2014, 10:34 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Aug 15 2014, 01:23 AM)
Tapped horn are used to make a small woofer sound big. Like a 10" can sound like 15" with this concept.
Simulation won't be accurate most of the time.
Have to know that, music are dynamic, so I won't trust simulation most of the time, trust your ears.
*
a tapped horn will be even worse in this room. tapped horn have a fundamental null at 100hz-150hz. it's not suggested for rooms where freq above 100hz are required from the sub.

simulation is pretty accurate when it comes to soundwave. even tapped horn design process are heavily dependent on the hornresp predicted responses.
user posted image
see that null? it's not gonna improve the room null that's already there.

room response could be accurately predicted. refer the paper "Subwoofers: Optimum Number and Locations" by Todd Welti, Research Acoustician, Harman International Industries, Inc.
my own testing shows the room simulation could predict actual responses to a high degree of precision. findings are posted before in the audiophiles subforum.

can't trust my own ears as the room have yet to be built. so it's all simulation to avoid building a problematic room.
halcyon27
post Aug 15 2014, 11:11 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 10 2014, 03:07 PM)
some people say red clay brick have better insulation against heat by sunshine. better cooling effect.

wife says red clay bricks have better heat retention ability, thus frequently used in western countries. they absorb heat during the day, making the house cooler during the day but they excrete the stored heat during the night. thus heating the walls making it warmer. a welcomed trait for western countries where night time is very cold and it would reduce the heating costs.
not exactly an appealing proposition for the weather here.

anyway we're planning for AAC bricks for the west facing walls to improve the insulation. it's only ~60 feet of walls that face the evening sunshine. and the rest of the house probably the normal cement bricks. undecided yet.
*
Yes, we've been using the wrong material in this land all this while. AAC is the way to go provided its obtained from the right source.
SUSsupersound
post Aug 15 2014, 12:06 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 15 2014, 10:34 AM)
a tapped horn will be even worse in this room. tapped horn have a fundamental null at 100hz-150hz. it's not suggested for rooms where freq above 100hz are required from the sub.

simulation is pretty accurate when it comes to soundwave. even tapped horn design process are heavily dependent on the hornresp predicted responses.
user posted image
see that null? it's not gonna improve the room null that's already there.

room response could be accurately predicted. refer the paper "Subwoofers: Optimum Number and Locations" by Todd Welti, Research Acoustician, Harman International Industries, Inc.
my own testing shows the room simulation could predict actual responses to a high degree of precision. findings are posted before in the audiophiles subforum.

can't trust my own ears as the room have yet to be built. so it's all simulation to avoid building a problematic room.
*
If in this world all speakers having the same spec, sound same, all human ear are same then I'll agree with you on this.
Sound wave are travelling in wave form, so the placement of the microphone plays an important role. Not to mention is that microphone calibrated or not hmm.gif
TSpaskal
post Aug 15 2014, 03:08 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(CoffeeDude @ Aug 14 2014, 11:24 PM)
Wow you did all the drawings yourself?  shocking.gif

But for contractors don't they need the drawings for the internal wirings, water piping, air-con piping?

How about security - CCTV, alarm?
*
not by myself. me and my wife.
the first, initial drawing and planning started last year so it's been a year.

there's no electrical and plumbing drawing yet. it's a work in progress. have to finalize the walls and structure first before drawing the electrical and plumbing route. there's a proposed lighting arrangement though. posted before.

QUOTE(supersound @ Aug 15 2014, 12:06 PM)
If in this world all speakers having the same spec, sound same, all human ear are same then I'll agree with you on this.
Sound wave are travelling in wave form, so the placement of the microphone plays an important role. Not to mention is that microphone calibrated or not hmm.gif
*
calibrated mics could be bought for ~RM300. tho i have to agree that preference plays a major part.
but it's been a few years since i've started with audio measurement and i could judge my preferences from the graph.
if you did enough measurement, for long enough time, you know what's your preference from a brief look at the room response.

here's my previous experience with the simulated response:
predicted:
user posted image

measured:
user posted image

overlaid:
user posted image
see how accurate that is? pretty darn accurate that made me a believer. google for 'rew room simulation accuracy'.
TSpaskal
post Aug 15 2014, 03:38 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
anyway... contractor appointed.
RM32 psft

user posted image

basic structure.
piling.
main structure beam as per JKR spec.
y12 steel with r6 link throughout.
13 feet wall.
16 inch high main structure beam.
effective ~20 inch raised floor from the ground.
cement brick.
concrete support block for all windows and door. dunno the exact term.
concrete overhang for all windows as shown in the drawing. 30cm x 5 cm.
no roof.
no windows.
inclusive indoor plumbing.
inclusive outdoor drainage.
inclusive outdoor apron with cement gutter.
2 septic tanks for toilets, separated for family area and guestroom.
1 septic tank for greywater discharge.
no wiring.

RM115k for 3621 sqft (indoor + outdoor area).


now my wife wanna add another toilet next to the laudry area. sweat.gif
5 toilets for 4 people? what for need so many toilets ah?
initially she wants the toilet inside my garage. saying the garage is too big for me. doh.gif
payamam
post Aug 15 2014, 03:56 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
347 posts

Joined: Nov 2013
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


I think RM32 psft is a good price. I've searched around in Selangor area, asking for ridiculous RM100++ psft...

doh.gif doh.gif doh.gif doh.gif
SUSsupersound
post Aug 15 2014, 04:24 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
Look on those numbers, it never state what type of sub being used? I don't do measurements most of the time, so I won't bother to know this, haha.
To manage a dip, there's more to be done other than just keep on looking at the graphs.

SUSsupersound
post Aug 15 2014, 04:24 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(payamam @ Aug 15 2014, 03:56 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


I think RM32 psft is a good price. I've searched around in Selangor area, asking for ridiculous RM100++ psft...

doh.gif  doh.gif  doh.gif  doh.gif
*
Must know where our friend is first icon_idea.gif
Noobl3t
post Aug 16 2014, 06:45 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
QUOTE(payamam @ Aug 15 2014, 03:56 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


I think RM32 psft is a good price. I've searched around in Selangor area, asking for ridiculous RM100++ psft...

doh.gif  doh.gif  doh.gif  doh.gif
*
Includes finishes, flooring, etc?
Rm 32 psf is bare basic only. If yours include finishes, price looks right to me.
TSpaskal
post Aug 16 2014, 08:39 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(payamam @ Aug 15 2014, 03:56 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


I think RM32 psft is a good price. I've searched around in Selangor area, asking for ridiculous RM100++ psft...

doh.gif  doh.gif  doh.gif  doh.gif
*
it's normal for contractors to ask for >RM100 for a complete build. usually RM120-RM130 psft including tile, ceiling, paint, etc.
mine at RM32 psft, but there's no roof, no windows, no doors, no bathroom utensil, no tile, no wiring.

pretty much the basic structure only. we're gonna be our own main contractor. it's DIY from start to end laugh.gif

QUOTE(supersound @ Aug 15 2014, 04:24 PM)
Look on those numbers, it never state what type of sub being used? I don't do measurements most of the time, so I won't bother to know this, haha.
To manage a dip, there's more to be done other than just keep on looking at the graphs.
*
it's a dual 15 inch ported sub tuned to 20hz. each powered by a 600w class d amp.

null because of the sub response, or amp response could be corrected. but a large null because of the room could never be corrected by a brute force solution. i (we) have experimented to correct a huge room null by giving the sub 4x the power, it only improves the response by 2db. 400% more power, only ~5% correction.
SUSsupersound
post Aug 17 2014, 03:48 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 16 2014, 08:39 PM)
it's normal for contractors to ask for >RM100 for a complete build. usually RM120-RM130 psft including tile, ceiling, paint, etc.
mine at RM32 psft, but there's no roof, no windows, no doors, no bathroom utensil, no tile, no wiring.

pretty much the basic structure only. we're gonna be our own main contractor. it's DIY from start to end laugh.gif
it's a dual 15 inch ported sub tuned to 20hz. each powered by a 600w class d amp.

null because of the sub response, or amp response could be corrected. but a large null because of the room could never be corrected by a brute force solution. i (we) have experimented to correct a huge room null by giving the sub 4x the power, it only improves the response by 2db. 400% more power, only ~5% correction.
*
I don't know, I assume that both sub are placed together? If yes, guess they are self cancelling each other.
Ujin
post Aug 17 2014, 04:55 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
41 posts

Joined: Apr 2009
Really enjoying your thread, good luck on your endeavour and cant wait to see when it's done!
payamam
post Aug 18 2014, 08:22 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
347 posts

Joined: Nov 2013
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 16 2014, 08:39 PM)
it's normal for contractors to ask for >RM100 for a complete build. usually RM120-RM130 psft including tile, ceiling, paint, etc.
mine at RM32 psft, but there's no roof, no windows, no doors, no bathroom utensil, no tile, no wiring.

pretty much the basic structure only. we're gonna be our own main contractor. it's DIY from start to end laugh.gif
it's a dual 15 inch ported sub tuned to 20hz. each powered by a 600w class d amp.

null because of the sub response, or amp response could be corrected. but a large null because of the room could never be corrected by a brute force solution. i (we) have experimented to correct a huge room null by giving the sub 4x the power, it only improves the response by 2db. 400% more power, only ~5% correction.
*
oh, no wonder so cheap sweat.gif
lainux
post Aug 18 2014, 12:38 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
650 posts

Joined: Nov 2006


Nice discussions & a good job you did.

Just my 2 cents below:
1) ever consider built in closet for each room? it will save you money.

2) for ventilation, maybe ventilation fan on high wall to suck the hot air out?

3) you seem to have big windows in your guest room which is facing west? I think most people in malaysia would have the curtains closed, and thus the big windows are kind of useless. For me, I would build the windows on 5' & above so that there is privacy without the need to put curtain & will be bright enough too. You can put another vertical window for viewing outside.

4) can consider rain/air cond water harvesting for toilet flush & gardening.

5) passive hot water, it is actually quite easy to build one yourself. I have done mine, and it is working quite OK.

6) where are you gonna put your aircon compressors? Should put this into the design as well.

Just my suggestions for you to consider.
TSpaskal
post Aug 22 2014, 09:04 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
some update.

the initial plan is to adopt a total roof solution from monier. complete coolroof solution together with insulation, supply and installation.
user posted image
nice right? monier perspective, minimum roof pitch at 15 degrees.
but monier asked us to increase the pitch to 17 degrees to avoid leaking. better not to stick to the minimum recommendation when an additional 2 degrees won't change the roof outlook much.

but a lot of people that we approached have the same comment. the roof is still gonna leak.
even contractors don't wanna do the roof as the pitch is just too risky. the same recommendation from architect and civil engineers.

but my wife die die don't wanna change to the roof to another material. hard headed she is. her auntie even said the same, increase the pitch to 23 degrees minimum. why yes, ask for auntie advice lah compared to an internet forum. tongue.gif

even my gut is saying it's gonna leak. and it's gonna cost me. moreover, the longest roof length is right where the strongest wind is.
user posted image
marked the direction of the strongest wind. the left side wind blowing to the 15m long roof is much stronger compared to the right side wind.

if the roof leak, it's gonna be hard to pinpoint the source of the leak since the roof is gonna be insulated, effectively blocking any way of seeing the leaking area. sigh.
insulating the roof is gonna be a problem in the long run. talk about double edge solution.

so i started my own research. read read and more reading.
as the roof pitch is low, we must adopt an underlay/sarking/insulation layer to channel any leak to the roof edge.
but as i said earlier, it's gonna be hard to pinpoint the leaking area.

or build another secondary roof below the roof tile. which is stupid to me.
if there's gonna be another aluminium/metal roof underneath, might as well don't have that roof tile primary roof. too much cost. heavy roof. more structural support needed. redundant primary roof. too complex roof design just to avoid leaking, which could be effectively avoided by not adopting roof tile in the first place.

but i did considered putting an aluminium sheet underneath the insulation layer just to be safe. but yeah, complicated stuff.

user posted image
leak will happen at these area. when there's a heavy rain coupled with strong wind the roof can't dissipate as much water as fast as needed.
strong wind will blow the water upwards, blocking the water from falling to the gutter. more and more water will be accumulated from the falling rain, eventually forced into the roof structure. hence causing a leak.

low roof pitch + long roof length + strong prevalent wind = problem.

this is described inside monier own roof structural guide:
user posted image
sigh. 23 degrees does seem like the minimum. 28-30 degrees as a safe bet.

TSpaskal
post Aug 22 2014, 09:41 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
or we could change the roof structure and adopt a traditional design. no more modern design.
a couple of contractors that we went even suggested this.

but we already fixed our eyes (and mind) on the modern design. change to traditional design? change to higher roof pitch? and make it look like a cathedral?
how about no.

so what do you do when you hit a design problem?
you call your auntie, of course.

and your auntie pointed you to this roof material:
user posted image
user posted image
if nobody said it's not roof tile in those pic, nobody would even know.
all the good looks of a roof tile, none of the problem.

expect nothing less from an experienced Ar.
CoffeeDude
post Aug 22 2014, 09:49 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,609 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: KL


I would choose the solution that would avoid water leak problems.

Functionality out weighs aesthetics.
TSpaskal
post Aug 23 2014, 05:34 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(CoffeeDude @ Aug 14 2014, 11:24 PM)
How about security - CCTV, alarm?
*
security will be handled by mostly active security system. proximity sensors and cctv at the entry road. distributed perimeter sensors consisting of proximity, motion and IR (heat) sensors. windows, doors and any glass opening will be installed with vibration and motion sensor. probably another layer of motion and proximity sensor around the roof overhang and apron area.

cctv will all be using ip cameras, wired with power-over-ethernet, running on a separate network wiring. 100mbps cat5e rj45. each of the 4 corners will be fixed with fixed lens outdoor ip camera. indoor maybe a couple more of those pan-tilt-zoom (or no zoom) ip camera at the entrance, living room, deck area, family area and kitchen.

i'll try and get those 3 megapixel or those 1.3 megapixel at least. probably from foscam/wanscam or trendnet or axis if i have the money.
all monitored, logged and centrally managed by zoneminder, operating on intel atom SoC mini-itx board which will also act as the house NAS and media server.

i might not have the budget to do all of these implementation during the build, but since 1000 feet/305 meter of them cat5e cabling only costs RM150-ish, might as well run the entire house with them. planning to even run the sensors wiring with cat5e. a meter is only 49 sen, cheaper than even copper cable, and i get 8 solid copper core to work with.


QUOTE(CoffeeDude @ Aug 22 2014, 09:49 PM)
I would choose the solution that would avoid water leak problems.

Functionality out weighs aesthetics.
*
the most leak-proof solution would have to be these clip-lock metal roofing.
user posted image
they could be made in very long length, avoiding any joints. cut to any length required by the user and shipped for installation. as there's no joints, no connection and no screw holes, there's no way for water to leak from.

but my god those look hideous. upside is that minimum required pitch is only 1 degrees.

QUOTE(lainux @ Aug 18 2014, 12:38 PM)
Nice discussions & a good job you did. 

Just my 2 cents below:
1) ever consider built in closet for each room?  it will save you money.

2) for ventilation, maybe ventilation fan on high wall to suck the hot air out?

3) you seem to have big windows in your guest room which is facing west?  I think most people in malaysia would have the curtains closed, and thus the big windows are kind of useless.  For me, I would build the windows on 5' & above so that there is privacy without the need to put curtain & will be bright enough too.  You can put another vertical window for viewing outside.

4) can consider rain/air cond water harvesting for toilet flush & gardening.

5) passive hot water, it is actually quite easy to build one yourself.  I have done mine, and it is working quite OK. 

6) where are you gonna put your aircon compressors?  Should put this into the design as well.

Just my suggestions for you to consider.
*
1. built in cabinet is considered. will be implemented.

2. ventilation fan on a high wall looks ugly. to me. seen some houses integrate them and don't like the outlook. have to pass.

3. the guest room is facing east. there's only less than 2 feet of window which is facing east. west facing window is at the master bedroom, which will have nothing but paddy fields for 15km. refer graphic below.

4. the simple, 2 side monopitch roof is implemented for the sole reason of rainwater harvesting.
user posted image
yellow marking shows the planned area for rainwater collection tank. roof gutter will fall here to the filter and discharge pipe.
blue marking shows the planned area for elevated storage tank. as there's gonna be separate tank for rainwater and tap water, each area will probably have 2 tanks. too much for most people, but water disruption and low water pressure is a normal problem that we face nearly every week. just last week there's a water disruption for 3 days. it's a rural area so it's expected.

i rather have multiple storage tanks hidden inside the roof than large tanks blocking the view.

5. passive hot water will be adopted. probably from monier. installed at the roof section above the kids toilet, providing hot water to only 3 toilets below it. the guestroom toilet and kitchen toilet will run on instant water heater.

6. haven't thought about aircond compressors yet. to be frank we're trying to make do without aircond. right now the only place that's gonna have aircond is the HT room. opting for 2hp or 2.5hp inverter from mitsubishi electric.
all the rooms have integrated lourves at the window and very high ceiling (11-11.5 feet). living room, family area and dry kitchen have 16 to 14 feet sloping ceiling.

if even after those 'optimizations' it's still uncomfortable then there's no option but to adopt active air conditioning. active AC is just not part of the design process. if we want active AC then it's better to adopt low ceiling, small windows and less opening to keep the cold air from escaping. it's just the exact opposite of what we're currently doing.

how it will turn out? i have no idea.
halcyon27
post Aug 24 2014, 08:11 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


Roof leakage is expected where wind infiltration is expected. Monier cool roof Alu membrane foil is suppose to form a second skin functioning as radiant barrier and moisture barrier. One area you might want to investigate is Miami-Dade County rules on such aspects and see if you could improvise a solution therefrom for your installation.

There's also solar air conditioning solution that can be leveraged. It's the in thing now. Uses Microsolar collector.

Since Solar water heater has proportional heat losses the longer the runs, smaller volume collectors per outlet could help alleviate that esp for a large property.

Also, since thermal heat recovery is a relatively unexplored area, a R410A heat pump placed near the compressors (concentrate the compressors as close as possible without causing them to overheat one another and induce a heat stack so that the hot air rises) could in effect harvest waste heat and give out drier air (less humid). For ocassions where padi field burning or haze may bring in dust, pass the air through a rotating drum filter first commonly use in Scandanavian countries and Germany. The dust is captured in water. The waste can be periodically drained through an irrigation filter and a ball cock replenish the water from an readily available source - condensate that drains from all the AC. UV could keep the storage tank sterile as possible so that we do not unwittingly let it be a place where legionnella bacteria to breed. After which pass the filtered and drier air through Airegard ERV or Fresh Air Vent Systems to all the rooms.

Just to elaborate on the above concept, since we have abundant heat rejection through AC and also from from re-radiation of heat accumulated throughout the day, one aspect of economic use is to re-harvest the heat for useful purposes. If efficient enough, even solar AC could run through the night for some hours after sun down so long as the heat gain at the collectors is efficient enough to drive the compressor. Even if not, heat could be used to convert into heated water through a thermal recovery appliance. This requires a rethink functionally as to where to place the compressors. One idea visualized is an enclosed 4'x4' or 6'x6' or 8'x8' chiminey column of sorts with the thermal heat recovery unit at the top and the compressors staggered in height below it. Taking into account of the heat stack and aiding the thermal convection process is some form of mechanical ventilation that draws this air into a small room where the rotating drum filter resides with its water replenished via AC condensate and the dust collected constant and regularly drained at a predetermined rate. The cleaner air from the drum filter is passed through to the next chamber that houses the R410a heat pump which could act as a backup either for pre-heat to or post-heat downmix from the solar thermal water heater. after that the drier air could be cleaned again with another rotating drum filter and the air revitalized with an air cleaner before letting it through Airegard series to all the rooms. This way the air is cleaned twice and also dried twice and used twice.

One advantage is that the AC compressors would be somewhere in the interior open air space much like the old open roof in single storey houses. To address the noise due to the number of compressors accumulated there, surround it with brick (where the compressors anchors will be mounted), rock wool (to dampen sound transmission) and AAC (to minimse heat gain accumulated from the rock wool) into the interior to dampen the droning sound. A door access into that area could be thick door with rubber seals (Raven) all round.

Anything is possible. Happy tinkering.

This post has been edited by halcyon27: Aug 24 2014, 08:44 PM
TSpaskal
post Aug 25 2014, 11:37 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(halcyon27 @ Aug 24 2014, 08:11 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

*
thanks for the detailed suggestion. highly appreciated!

have you seen the solar AC in action?
i've been researching about them previously and the whole concept is just seem dubious to me. as far as my understanding goes, it makes no sensor to superheat the gas as it'll reduce the efficiency. or maybe i just don't understand the concept.

some websites even mentioned that the solar AC is just bogus claim. what's your opinion?
halcyon27
post Aug 25 2014, 01:25 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 25 2014, 11:37 AM)
thanks for the detailed suggestion. highly appreciated!

have you seen the solar AC in action?
i've been researching about them previously and the whole concept is just seem dubious to me. as far as my understanding goes, it makes no sensor to superheat the gas as it'll reduce the efficiency. or maybe i just don't understand the concept.

some websites even mentioned that the solar AC is just bogus claim. what's your opinion?
*
No worries. See here and here. Both are locally sourced. The first one IMO manufactures one of the world's most efficient solar thermal water heater which I own (M60VTHE). They have updated their model specification I think as shown here.

This post has been edited by halcyon27: Aug 25 2014, 01:29 PM
TSpaskal
post Aug 28 2014, 09:22 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
more updates.
wife drew 3 different 2nd floor extension plan.
user posted image

from the 3, the middle is the nicest.
additional ~1500sqft floorspace upstairs. 1 family area, 4 large rooms, 4 additional toilets. 1 of the largest room could be isolated with a sliding fake wall since it's 14'x21', affectively making space for 5 room.
the right plan allows for ~1200sqft additional floorspace. smaller extension of the middle plan.

discussed with a civil engineer the strengthening that we needed to do to allow this 2nd floor extension.
a few piling point that's best if we did 2 pile per cap. and the HT room wall needs to be moved and aligned to provide additional support and strength for the lower ground beam.
user posted image

QUOTE(halcyon27 @ Aug 25 2014, 01:25 PM)
No worries. See here and here. Both are locally sourced. The first one IMO manufactures one of the world's most efficient solar thermal water heater which I own (M60VTHE). They have updated their model specification I think as shown here.
*
that's solar water heater bro. have you tried solar AC? does it improve the AC efficiency as claimed by the manufacturer? 50% better efficiency is A LOT! hard to believe such a simple concept and modification could allow that much improvement.
too good to be true.
halcyon27
post Aug 28 2014, 12:47 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 28 2014, 09:22 AM)
that's solar water heater bro. have you tried solar AC? does it improve the AC efficiency as claimed by the manufacturer? 50% better efficiency is A LOT! hard to believe such a simple concept and modification could allow that much improvement.
too good to be true.
*
I have not tried the solar AC but it takes the thermosyphon design from Microsolar. That part is the secret sauce to really hot water because of the solar heat gain from ambient to 95-100 depending upon sunny conditions.

The first [correction] link show the solar AC installed in the Port Klang North port. Keyword is UP TO. I think we have to take this with a dose of reality as how often that kind of savings is acheived actually depends upon how frequently sunny the location is. For your place, how many annual wet days per year? Compared that to Port Klang

Also compare that with this.

This post has been edited by halcyon27: Aug 28 2014, 12:56 PM
TSpaskal
post Sep 4 2014, 05:22 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
changed the ht room dimension to realign the floor beam to provide extra support for the 2nd floor extension.
the ht room is extended by ~1.2 feet to a final dimension of 5880 mm x 4680 mm.

planned arrangement inside the room:
user posted image
currently not planning a screen larger than 120" since i'm gonna start with a lower level projector first. probably optoma hd25 or sony hw40es. would like to preserve some sharpness. and not to mention i'm opting for 2 rows of seat, with 30 degrees of FOV at the 2nd row.

4 subs at each corner, LCR speaker hidden behind the screen. DIY acoustic transparent screen, steel or zincalume frame.

simulation shows that this is the projected response at the LP.
9 feet ceiling:
user posted image

9.5 feet ceiling:
user posted image

10 feet high ceiling:
user posted image

of course i'm going with 9 feet high ceiling. 9.5 feet is gonna require more output from the subs to pressurize the room. 10 feet have the pesky cancellation at 50hz.
now whoever said that higher ceiling is better for sound?

floor beam structure plus planned pile point:
user posted image
12-14 feet pile, 14 inch diameter. a lot more than needed, but i got them for cheap.
3 extra pile point (not shown in figure). 2 will be put at the house edge and another one at the laundry room. pretty nice and evenly spread throughout the house with extra precaution at the planned 2nd floor extension.
cwhong
post Sep 6 2014, 01:21 AM

Growth company seeker ..... :)
*******
Senior Member
4,342 posts

Joined: Apr 2010
From: The place that i call home :p

WOW !!! very professional.....
TSpaskal
post Sep 8 2014, 02:02 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
doubt other people is gonna be as detailed as this.
it's my own house, might as well make it as properly engineered as possible.

light simulation for the house.
geo-referenced to the accurate GPS position, and aligned to the accurate alignment using a compass, compensated to true north of course.

user posted image

this is how it's gonna shade at 4.30pm, in december.

other than a single point in time, i've also simulated and animated the sun position throughout the entire year, and sun movement from early morning to late evening,
all to avoid getting too much evening sun to the bedrooms.

also got a cost quote for individual AAC bricks.
one wall is gonna be ~RM200 extra to adopt AAC. rough calculation it's gonna be RM1k-ish (under RM2k) to adopt AAC for the entire bedroom wall. there's also an option to use cement brick for the toilet wall and just AAC the 3 bedroom wall and master bedroom. that should bring down the extra cost closer to RM1k.

seems that AAC doesn't cost all that much compared to cement bricks. might even be the same cost as clay bricks.
payamam
post Sep 8 2014, 03:02 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
347 posts

Joined: Nov 2013
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


I really like how detail your project is. I wish I know all these technical stuff so that I can monitor my house construction progress (when it starts building, of course).

Care to share what software you use for this simulation?
CoffeeDude
post Sep 8 2014, 03:45 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,609 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: KL


Are you sure about using AAC bricks.
I've read somewhere that it is not strong enough for load bearing.
halcyon27
post Sep 10 2014, 05:20 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(CoffeeDude @ Sep 8 2014, 03:45 PM)
Are you sure about using AAC bricks.
I've read somewhere that it is not strong enough for load bearing.
*
True, plus 3 storey height limit. However, it's compensated by thickness to achieve the equivalent strength or have strategic load bearing borne by masonry bricks at critical points with AAC covering in front with an air gap as thermal break so as to prevent direct heat transfer over these.

TSpaskal
post Sep 14 2014, 05:18 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(payamam @ Sep 8 2014, 03:02 PM)
I really like how detail your project is. I wish I know all these technical stuff so that I can monitor my house construction progress (when it starts building, of course).

Care to share what software you use for this simulation?
*
it's built into google sketchup. pretty accurate if you could get the alignment right.

QUOTE(CoffeeDude @ Sep 8 2014, 03:45 PM)
Are you sure about using AAC bricks.
I've read somewhere that it is not strong enough for load bearing.
*
they're not. aac aren't designed for load bearing applications. they're brittle and soft enough that you could hack through the wall with a hammer.

but to compensate, you could design the house so that the load are sustained by the house structure rather than the walls.
TSpaskal
post Sep 14 2014, 05:30 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
visited decra sales office last week in subang USJ21.
and met with decra rep yesterday.

they're the only metal roof product with stone coating that have that rough surface. looks like ordinary roof tiles. and since they're metal roof, have a lot of advantages compared to roof tiles.
1. leak proof.
2. wind lift proof.
3. burglar proof.
4. approved to ~200km/h wind speed.
5. approved to cyclone or hurricane prone areas.

and this:


they're lightweight.
they're bendable.
they're flexible.
you could walk over it.

but gosh. they're freaking expensive.
i was quoted over RM20 psft.

ordinary roof tiles could be had for less than half of that, complete with roof structure, roof truss, insulation and installation.
sigh. i was opting to go with decra even if they're priced the same as roof tiles. even with +20% premium i'd still go with them. now it's just too expensive to consider.

backup plan.
1. find some other metal roof with a rough surface that have the same outlook as roof tiles.
or
2. go crazy and adopt a 2 layer roof.
primary roof consisting of flat (or nearly flat) roof tiles (or roof shingles) and do a thin layer metal roofing (with a high standing seam) as secondary roof.

we have a very simple roof design. second plan makes a lot of sense.
Yamma
post Sep 15 2014, 05:16 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
736 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
this project expected to complete in 2021?
TSpaskal
post Sep 15 2014, 06:26 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
started the land fill in march.
first layer completed by april.
top and final layer completed by may.

it's only been 4 month. less than 6 month for the soil to set.
not even enough time in you follow JKR specs.

so some changes had to be made to accommodate the short time for the land to set. either by rolling the site, or by rolling the site. yeah you have to roll the site. but we can't roll the site. not in this weather.

user posted image
pilings have arrived. in stages since it's raining cats and dogs for the last 2 weeks.

original plan to have the site rolled by a 15 tonne vibrating roller had to be cancelled. we've successfully negotiated the vibrating roller for RM900 including transportation costs. it requires a frekkin transport trailer to come here. 3-4 tonne vibrating roller could be had for ~RM300 per day, ~RM600 including transport since it could fit on a loader lorry.

but since the soil is now too soft from the never ending downpour, we're skipping the roller and going with bigger piling.
original plan is to just use square column, 8-10 inches (RM85 a piece) and have the site rolled.

pile boring, and pressing will commence next week, weather permitting.

QUOTE(Yamma @ Sep 15 2014, 05:16 PM)
this project expected to complete in 2021?
*
dude, is this a genuine question or just a sarcastic remark?

This post has been edited by paskal: Sep 15 2014, 06:41 PM
TSpaskal
post Sep 15 2014, 06:51 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
oh. one more thing.

user posted image
these. i got these for RM120 a piece (shipped)(lorried).
all 38 of them for RM4.6k, shipped (lorried) to the site.

as per agreement, the contractor will now bear the cost for the boring, and pile pressing at the site.
all 38 of them. biggrin.gif

feeling sorry for him. i have no idea how he's going to put all of them into the ground. not my problem tho. it's all in the agreement.
-oc-gassa
post Sep 16 2014, 07:07 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
967 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: setapak
for pilling.. any type of pilling used?
38 isn't that bit more than for 1 house?
Noobl3t
post Sep 17 2014, 12:08 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
22 posts

Joined: Apr 2014
QUOTE(paskal @ Sep 15 2014, 06:51 PM)
oh. one more thing.

user posted image
these. i got these for RM120 a piece (shipped)(lorried).
all 38 of them for RM4.6k, shipped (lorried) to the site.

as per agreement, the contractor will now bear the cost for the boring, and pile pressing at the site.
all 38 of them. :D

feeling sorry for him. i have no idea how he's going to put all of them into the ground. not my problem tho. it's all in the agreement.
*
How much would cost just to pile in the pillars? Including/excluding pilar cost?
ShadowR1
post Sep 18 2014, 06:11 PM

Im still HeRe ...
******
Senior Member
1,879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: The Long river ...


QUOTE(paskal @ Sep 14 2014, 05:30 PM)
visited decra sales office last week in subang USJ21.
and met with decra rep yesterday.

they're the only metal roof product with stone coating that have that rough surface. looks like ordinary roof tiles. and since they're metal roof, have a lot of advantages compared to roof tiles.
1. leak proof.
2. wind lift proof.
3. burglar proof.
4. approved to ~200km/h wind speed.
5. approved to cyclone or hurricane prone areas.

and this:


they're lightweight.
they're bendable.
they're flexible.
you could walk over it.

but gosh. they're freaking expensive.
i was quoted over RM20 psft.

ordinary roof tiles could be had for less than half of that, complete with roof structure, roof truss, insulation and installation.
sigh. i was opting to go with decra even if they're priced the same as roof tiles. even with +20% premium i'd still go with them. now it's just too expensive to consider.

backup plan.
1. find some other metal roof with a rough surface that have the same outlook as roof tiles.
or
2. go crazy and adopt a 2 layer roof.
primary roof consisting of flat (or nearly flat) roof tiles (or roof shingles) and do a thin layer metal roofing (with a high standing seam) as secondary roof.

we have a very simple roof design. second plan makes a lot of sense.
*
Thanks for sharing this, its blardy expensive tho but impresive.
abcde90
post Sep 18 2014, 09:51 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
183 posts

Joined: Dec 2012


Nice sharing bro
TSpaskal
post Sep 29 2014, 10:35 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
updated reading material.
which could be interesting to some. those who already knew, please move on.

thanks to the guy that pointed them to me.

user posted image

never knew about the negative pressure to suck wind into the house.
implemented.
user posted image
this 2 large openings will (probably) have large louvers to provide large leeward opening for negative pressure.

user posted image
implemented.
user posted image
sides of the casement windows will have that concrete protruding thingy.
one as a wall feature.
two as a rain shield.
three as a fin to provide negative pressure to aid cross ventilation inside the room.

wife refused to add them to all windows tho.
TSpaskal
post Sep 29 2014, 11:03 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
construction update.

renegotiation with the contractor update.
1. moved the HT room walls by 1.2 feet
2. added 1 more toilet to the garage (inclusive plumbing)
3. added 3 feet of apron around the house (not mentioned in the original agreement)
4. installation of ceramic drainage around the house. we supply the ceramic drain.
5. ceiling slab for water reservoir at 3 different places. 14.2'x6.3' , 14.2'x8.3', 14.2'x6.3'
6. separate drainage system around the house for greywater discharge and blackwater overflow.

additional.... get this.... RM5k


wife pestered me last month for a vacation. so we stayed at morib gold coast resort for a couple of days.
we got the room with the jacuzzi, and the size of the bathroom is just nice to accommodate the 1.5m jacuzzi in it.

and since we are planning to install a 1.8m unit, the master bedroom toilet is so freakishly small.
yes some of you have pointed it out before. thanks.

so we expanded the master bedroom another ~4 feet, for the full 18' span. turning the floorplan to this:
user posted image
also expanded the toilet to ~8.5' x ~8.5'. wife doesn't want it bigger than that. her choice.
better to do it now than to hack the walls later on.

re-nego with the contractor, again. and we agreed for an addition RM2.2k for it.
RM2.2k for an extension of 4' x 18' & bigger toilet. biggrin.gif

yes. i'm a cheapskate.
and yes, it's gonna be a problem if the contractor decides to run away.
but no, i'm not gonna pay exorbitant price to scalpers. please move along.

and finally.
project is delayed. estimated to complete by 2085. pile pressing estimated to complete by 2021.
so expect pictures to be up by 2022. laugh.gif
halcyon27
post Sep 30 2014, 11:48 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


Nice and good posting.

Yes, louvres has great flexibility in air circulation. One thing to note though is that air blowing through the house is aided by a negative pressure differential between the inside and outside. It's hard for the wind to blow in if:
1. if it's not directed at the house
2. the inside of the house is hotter than the outside (positive higher pressure differential) - can be mitigated with extractor fans to induce flow.

One thing about Queensland is that architects in that state has taken various innovation in our climate to adapt over there. Some homes built over there reminds me of those we see here. One prime distinction is that they are built on stilts to minimise ground heat intrusion because air is a poor conductor and not for them but relevant in your site is to prevent the black swan event of flooding. Those innovation added is such that the architecture is called the 'Queenslander'. Actually would be good to see if there are any relevant points there to integrate back to your design approach.

2085 - wah I don't know if I live that long.
TSpaskal
post Oct 1 2014, 11:00 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
oh what do you know. it's already near 2021.

so site have been marked for pile pressing and construction of the structure beam.
user posted image
user posted image

only after site marking it puts everything into perspective.
user posted image
only ~10 feet setback at the side. from the absolute edge of the land plot to the house apron.

user posted image
~13 feet of setback from the back.
we only have ~10 feet of clearance at the front, side and back.

mind you, the plot is 7,000 sqft.
and we're only left with 10 feet of clearance. gosh, it's certainly not gonna be a small house. that's for sure.

the plot have to enlarged.
but that's another project for another day.
TSpaskal
post Oct 2 2014, 10:37 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
after site marking, the contractor have asked for some changes to the floor plan to ease construction.
since the requested changes doesn't have any major effect to the design, we agreed.

current (final) floorplan:
user posted image
lucifah
post Oct 5 2014, 10:36 PM

St. Fu
Group Icon
Staff
7,948 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
From: Soviet Sarawak


nice house

just to remind you of rainwater piping for your enormous roof

pls share pics when it's completely done and call us for a housewarming party thumbup.gif
TSpaskal
post Oct 6 2014, 02:43 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(lucifah @ Oct 5 2014, 10:36 PM)
nice house
just to remind you of rainwater piping for your enormous roof
pls share pics when it's completely done and call us for a housewarming party thumbup.gif
*
yes. the roof is very large indeed. roof rafter length is longer than any roofing guide that i've read.

what do you mean with the rainwater piping? do you think a single drain pipe (per side) is not gonna be sufficient? i was opting to collect the rainwater, thus the single drain at the middle span.
the roof drain pipe area is marked with yellow in this figure:
user posted image
SUSsupersound
post Oct 6 2014, 03:09 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Oct 6 2014, 02:43 PM)
yes. the roof is very large indeed. roof rafter length is longer than any roofing guide that i've read.

what do you mean with the rainwater piping? do you think a single drain pipe (per side) is not gonna be sufficient? i was opting to collect the rainwater, thus the single drain at the middle span.
the roof drain pipe area is marked with yellow in this figure:
user posted image
*
You are collecting rain water for what?
No matter what it is, must consume it fast and cover it properly, aedes likes rain water very much.
TSpaskal
post Oct 6 2014, 06:50 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(supersound @ Oct 6 2014, 03:09 PM)
You are collecting rain water for what?
No matter what it is, must consume it fast and cover it properly, aedes likes rain water very much.
*
rainwater harvesting. will be used for plant irrigation and toilet flushing. ground level collection from the drain pipe will be stored inside this:
user posted image
or something like it. which will then be pumped into storage tanks inside the ceiling structure (marked blue in the previous figure).

there's enough space on the ceiling slab to store 12 tonne of water. no that's not a typo.
SUSsupersound
post Oct 6 2014, 06:59 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Oct 6 2014, 06:50 PM)
rainwater harvesting. will be used for plant irrigation and toilet flushing. ground level collection from the drain pipe will be stored inside this:
user posted image
or something like it. which will then be pumped into storage tanks inside the ceiling structure (marked blue in the previous figure).

there's enough space on the ceiling slab to store 12 tonne of water. no that's not a typo.
*
rclxms.gif rclxms.gif rclxms.gif rclxms.gif
Good concept on conserving water, wish I have a bangalow or semi-d to do the same.
Still make sure the top tank is covered type.
lucifah
post Oct 6 2014, 07:22 PM

St. Fu
Group Icon
Staff
7,948 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
From: Soviet Sarawak


QUOTE(paskal @ Oct 6 2014, 02:43 PM)
yes. the roof is very large indeed. roof rafter length is longer than any roofing guide that i've read.

what do you mean with the rainwater piping? do you think a single drain pipe (per side) is not gonna be sufficient? i was opting to collect the rainwater, thus the single drain at the middle span.
the roof drain pipe area is marked with yellow in this figure:
user posted image
*
unless you have a 12" diameter pipe or larger, i will see the downpipe get choked with water if it rains too heavily

you may have water spillover from the raingutter if that happens


imagine pouring a pail of water rapidly into this funnel:

user posted image

just sharing info for you. maybe will neeed consideration and see your rainfall record in your area.
TSpaskal
post Oct 24 2014, 10:44 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
sure, call it a pipe dream if you like.
but the pipe is being built. the dream is taking shape.
user posted image
champu
post Oct 24 2014, 02:04 PM

Champu
****
Senior Member
633 posts

Joined: Apr 2014



well done mate, you're on your way now..keep at it and don't compromise for anything less
payamam
post Oct 24 2014, 03:11 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
347 posts

Joined: Nov 2013
QUOTE(paskal @ Oct 6 2014, 06:50 PM)
rainwater harvesting. will be used for plant irrigation and toilet flushing. ground level collection from the drain pipe will be stored inside this:
user posted image
or something like it. which will then be pumped into storage tanks inside the ceiling structure (marked blue in the previous figure).

there's enough space on the ceiling slab to store 12 tonne of water. no that's not a typo.
*
This is a very interesting way of reusing rain water. Is this thing available widely in Malaysia? What is it called?
TSpaskal
post Oct 24 2014, 08:31 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
user posted image
user posted image
pile boring is a verry elegant solution. there's very little damage to the soil.
good thing if you don't wanna disturb the soil structure.

no idea how much it costs.
SUSsupersound
post Oct 24 2014, 09:01 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
QUOTE(payamam @ Oct 24 2014, 03:11 PM)
This is a very interesting way of reusing rain water. Is this thing available widely in Malaysia? What is it called?
*
You need to have 2 level switch to stop the pump, 1 from the collector tank and another at receiving tank.

TSpaskal
post Oct 25 2014, 05:22 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
user posted image
this is the site after all 38 piles buried in them. as you can see, there's very little damage to the landfill. now i'm gonna let them rest, and set.

the proper way to confirm if the pile is already set is to do a pile test. let them rest for a while, then do a pile test. if it doesn't move then start construction. if it moves then let it rest some more. but this way you need to pay piling company to do the test. which i've been told will cost circa RM2k.

so a civil engineer friend suggests to let them set for at least a month if we're in a hurry. if we're not in a hurry, let them rest for 3 month. he said that he's never seen a pile move after being left to rest for 3 month.

QUOTE(payamam @ Oct 24 2014, 03:11 PM)
This is a very interesting way of reusing rain water. Is this thing available widely in Malaysia? What is it called?
*
some hip projects in the central region brag about the use of such rainwater harvesting system. i have no idea if they're called some other name other than rainwater harvesting.

anyway it's not a good thing to use the rainwater harvested for drinking purposes as they're not treated. so you either separate the rainwater from tap water system or you treat the rainwater before mixing them together. i'm planning to separate them.

most rainwater harvesting will cost you quite a hefty sum to implement. roughly RM3k-RM4k for the entire system together with the collection tank. mind boggling when the system is very simple and shouldn't cost more than RM1k.
billyboy
post Nov 6 2014, 11:23 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,220 posts

Joined: Apr 2006
simple rain water harvesting can do for a few hundred ringgit. but the quality of water not so great. just use for watering plants.

the issue is water is quite cheap in Malaysia.

if you are a true nature lover (irrespective of cost), consider filtering the rainwater (which adds up the cost; first flush, filter), storing in the tank, and use for TOILET FLUSHING (much like HK apartment use filtered seawater for toilet flushing).

Commercially, it does not make sense since treated water is cheap, so only if you are a true nature lover.
OneMoreDay
post Nov 6 2014, 11:54 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
580 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
Off the top of my head, Monier and Aura Lite are two brands who have rainwater harvesting systems. Rainwater is relatively clean depending on how clean your roof and gutter is but it is definitely non-potable.

Considering how water insecure we are even with our tropical climate, harvesting rainwater on your own now and self treating/filtering in the future doesn't sound too bad an idea.

Here's a checklist for inspecting and managing rainwater safety and quality. Pretty useful.

This post has been edited by OneMoreDay: Nov 6 2014, 11:56 AM
TSpaskal
post Nov 6 2014, 12:12 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(billyboy @ Nov 6 2014, 11:23 AM)
simple rain water harvesting can do for a few hundred ringgit.  but the quality of water not so great.  just use for watering plants.

the issue is water is quite cheap in Malaysia.

if you are a true nature lover (irrespective of cost), consider filtering the rainwater (which adds up the cost; first flush, filter), storing in the tank, and use for TOILET FLUSHING (much like HK apartment use filtered seawater for toilet flushing). 

Commercially, it does not make sense since treated water is cheap, so only if you are a true nature lover.
*
true. to a certain degree.
filtering and processing the rainwater to potable water isn't cheap. kampung people used to add chlorine to stagnant water to make them safe for consumption. that is the simplest method if one is thinking to use them for everything.

the sole reason for adopting rainwater harvesting in my approach is not to save money, or to go green. but rather, to avoid the chlorine in the tap water entirely.

you see, the rainwater will be used for irrigation, and probably for aquaculture as well. there's gonna be fish somewhere in the system. and them fish don't like chlorine. so rather than filtering tap water to remove chlorine, it's easier to harvest rainwater and avoid them from the start.

rainwater in my approach won't be treated. they'll be used for toilet flushing, but that's about it. main application for the rainwater is plant irrigation and fish farming. well not fish farming per se. but i think it'd be nice to have a fish pond somewhere in the house, or next to the house. rainwater will be used for the pond.
OneMoreDay
post Nov 6 2014, 12:18 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
580 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
Bravo. Chlorine is the easiest way of treating water but it's hardly the healthiest solution.
TSpaskal
post Nov 6 2014, 01:50 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
since we're already on the topic of water harvesting and storage. maybe someone will find this beneficial.

the house will have 3 ceiling slab for water storage. i've spec-ed these area for slabs since they can't be used for anything better.
user posted image

the area is enough for 6 of the biggest tanks, 500 gallons each.
roof structure will be spec-ed not to intrude in this area. which i think is really possible since we're kindda decided for metal roofing, which doesn't require complicated support structure.

anyway the problem is, is to have that much water on top of your head. if should the tank burst it's gonna flood the house. it's a real problem and my cousin had gone through it before. it flooded her house, destroying nearly half of the house.
she had a single 300 gallon tank in the ceiling. we're gonna have 6x500 gallon tank. that's more than 12 tonne of water.

so we're designing the house to have brick wall closing the tank area. the tank is essentially outside of the house, covered by fascia board.
user posted image
see the front portion? that will be fascia board.

user posted image
the tank will be shielded by brick wall on all sides, except for the front. if for any reason the tank decides to burst, it'll at least be shielded from flooding into the house.

user posted image
fascia board.

user posted image

the toilet slab will have 3 sides covered by walls.
user posted image
one of the side wall will have 2 feet of barrier. leakage pipe will be directed outside of the house and 2 more downward to the toilet beneath.
but if it's still not enough, at least only one room will be sacrificed.
billyboy
post Nov 6 2014, 01:53 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,220 posts

Joined: Apr 2006
i have more than 10 160l tanks which i use for my own rain water harvesting.

the easiest way to ensure no mosquito (think Aedes) is to keep it covered. everyday, when i open it there are loads of dead mosquitoes on top of the water. i think the mosq eggs are everywhere and when they hatch, and there is a cover on top, after some time they crash and drown in exhaustion.

consider putting a simple wire mesh (small enough so that the mosquitoes can't fly off) before the storage tanks. cheap and cheerful solution.

i have surveyed the 'proper' way but it cost several thousand ringgit.

your fish will love the rain water. its much more refreshing than tap water. in fact, your fish will also love all the dead mosquitoes on top !

OneMoreDay
post Nov 6 2014, 02:00 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
580 posts

Joined: Aug 2013
We had loads of koi before in a rather deep pond. Hardly any mozzies. Then again we had fountains that kept the water from being stagnant the pond was filtered.
lainux
post Nov 6 2014, 02:01 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
650 posts

Joined: Nov 2006


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 6 2014, 01:50 PM)
since we're already on the topic of water harvesting and storage. maybe someone will find this beneficial.

the house will have 3 ceiling slab for water storage. i've spec-ed these area for slabs since they can't be used for anything better.
user posted image

the area is enough for 6 of the biggest tanks, 500 gallons each.
roof structure will be spec-ed not to intrude in this area. which i think is really possible since we're kindda decided for metal roofing, which doesn't require complicated support structure.

anyway the problem is, is to have that much water on top of your head. if should the tank burst it's gonna flood the house. it's a real problem and my cousin had gone through it before. it flooded her house, destroying nearly half of the house.
she had a single 300 gallon tank in the ceiling. we're gonna have 6x500 gallon tank. that's more than 12 tonne of water.

so we're designing the house to have brick wall closing the tank area. the tank is essentially outside of the house, covered by fascia board.
user posted image
see the front portion? that will be fascia board.

user posted image
the tank will be shielded by brick wall on all sides, except for the front. if for any reason the tank decides to burst, it'll at least be shielded from flooding into the house.

user posted image
fascia board.

user posted image

the toilet slab will have 3 sides covered by walls.
user posted image
one of the side wall will have 2 feet of barrier. leakage pipe will be directed outside of the house and 2 more downward to the toilet beneath.
but if it's still not enough, at least only one room will be sacrificed.
*
wow... are all 6 for rain water harvesting? Do you need so much rain water?

There will be drainage in the storage areas right?

Very good design...
halcyon27
post Nov 6 2014, 02:06 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 6 2014, 01:50 PM)
since we're already on the topic of water harvesting and storage. maybe someone will find this beneficial.

the house will have 3 ceiling slab for water storage. i've spec-ed these area for slabs since they can't be used for anything better.
user posted image

the area is enough for 6 of the biggest tanks, 500 gallons each.
roof structure will be spec-ed not to intrude in this area. which i think is really possible since we're kindda decided for metal roofing, which doesn't require complicated support structure.

anyway the problem is, is to have that much water on top of your head. if should the tank burst it's gonna flood the house. it's a real problem and my cousin had gone through it before. it flooded her house, destroying nearly half of the house.
she had a single 300 gallon tank in the ceiling. we're gonna have 6x500 gallon tank. that's more than 12 tonne of water.

so we're designing the house to have brick wall closing the tank area. the tank is essentially outside of the house, covered by fascia board.
user posted image
see the front portion? that will be fascia board.

user posted image
the tank will be shielded by brick wall on all sides, except for the front. if for any reason the tank decides to burst, it'll at least be shielded from flooding into the house.

user posted image
fascia board.

user posted image

the toilet slab will have 3 sides covered by walls.
user posted image
one of the side wall will have 2 feet of barrier. leakage pipe will be directed outside of the house and 2 more downward to the toilet beneath.
but if it's still not enough, at least only one room will be sacrificed.
*
would it be sound practice if the slabs were perforated with a 6" drainage hole for maintenance purposes (tangki wash) as well as emergency drainage in the unlikely remote event that the tanks do burst.

Although not related to rain harvesting but more to plumbing, would separation of pipes for toilet and shower/basin taps be practical such that the latter two can be on pump if needed but the toilet one without it.

This post has been edited by halcyon27: Nov 6 2014, 02:11 PM
TSpaskal
post Nov 6 2014, 02:11 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(halcyon27 @ Nov 6 2014, 02:06 PM)
would it be sound practice if the slabs were perforated with a 6" drainage hole for maintenance purposes (tangki wash) as well as emergency drainage in the unlikely remote event that the tanks do burst.
*
good advice. thanks a lot! will be implemented.
SUSsupersound
post Nov 6 2014, 02:22 PM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
11,554 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
I won't conceal the tanks in such manner. Just let them on top of the roof, can get some warm water, easier to clean the tank.
Fazab
post Nov 6 2014, 03:46 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


Seriously, need so many rainwater tanks if just to flush toilets and supply a fishpond?

They are not easy to maintain. Without chlorination, all sort of things will start growing inside if the collected water is not used quickly.

Not to mention you are adding unnecessary load to your house, and the unnecesary risk of flooding.

What billyboy sees in his tanks are probably not mosquitoes, but chironomid flies. They die after laying eggs, so you see loads of dead ones. If your tank have them, it means the conditions are suitable for mosquitoe larvae to breed. Better check regularly.

I am also planning a rainwater harvesting system, but one 300L will be enough for my purpose. It will collect form the main gutter pipe, and used to siram bunga, wash the garden etc. For my fishpond, I still plan to use tap water treated to remove residual chlorine. Rainwater is acidic in my area. The size of my pond may not be enough to neutralize that effect. Don't want my fish to suffer.....

TSpaskal
post Nov 6 2014, 05:39 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(Fazab @ Nov 6 2014, 03:46 PM)
Seriously, need so many rainwater tanks if just to flush toilets and supply a fishpond?

They are not easy to maintain. Without chlorination, all sort of things will start growing inside if the collected water is not used quickly.

Not to mention you are adding unnecessary load to your house, and the unnecesary risk of flooding.

What billyboy sees in his tanks are probably not mosquitoes, but chironomid flies. They die after laying eggs, so you see loads of dead ones. If your tank have them, it means the conditions are suitable for mosquitoe larvae to breed. Better check regularly.

I am also planning a rainwater harvesting system, but one 300L will be enough for my purpose. It will collect form the main gutter pipe, and used to siram bunga, wash the garden etc. For my fishpond, I still plan to use tap water treated to remove residual chlorine. Rainwater is acidic in my area. The size of my pond may not be enough to neutralize that effect. Don't want my fish to suffer.....
*
would a UV lamp installed inside the tank remove the possibility of bacteria or larvae from growing?
thought about the bacteria and larvae issue. was planning to adopt a UV light inside the tank if there's an issue from growth.

that much rainwater is unnecessary. but see, there's a space there. wasted space. if piping isn't in place, it's gonna be hard to add in later. so i'm thinking, why not. load is already considered in the 2nd floor expansion plan. the structure should be able to handle the weight as it's meant to hold another floor.
ozak
post Nov 7 2014, 11:40 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


This is strange setup. 6 tank of rain water tank? Or 3 tank rain water and 3 tank fresh water tank?
TSpaskal
post Nov 7 2014, 02:40 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 7 2014, 11:40 AM)
This is strange setup. 6 tank of rain water tank? Or 3 tank rain water and 3 tank fresh water tank?
*
3+3. maybe 4+2.
rain like during last march, doesn't fall for nearly 3 month.

so the system needs some sort of bypass system to divert to pipe water in case the water level is too low. furthermore for a complete solution, pipe water topup should never be to full capacity to allow for rainwater.

it's gonna be quite a challenge. biggrin.gif
mirzan007
post Nov 7 2014, 02:46 PM

On my way
****
Junior Member
501 posts

Joined: Jul 2005


Learning a lot from this tered ts.. nicely done!
ozak
post Nov 7 2014, 04:33 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 7 2014, 02:40 PM)
3+3. maybe 4+2.
rain like during last march, doesn't fall for nearly 3 month.

so the system needs some sort of bypass system to divert to pipe water in case the water level is too low. furthermore for a complete solution, pipe water topup should never be to full capacity to allow for rainwater.

it's gonna be quite a challenge. biggrin.gif
*
You probably going to have nightmare to do maintenance. 6 tank cleaning, 3 separate place with tight space. sweat.gif Not a good idea.

Suggest you not to use rain water to flush. It is not 'clean'. Unless you treat the water. Your toilet will be full of germ.

You can have separate water inlet to the rain tank. Set the clean water inlet to lower level cut off (the ball). While the rain water inlet cut off higher. This way the clean water topup will never be full and allow the rainwater in.

As suggest by halcyon27, 6" drain hole on the concrete will solve your flood problem.
TSpaskal
post Nov 8 2014, 12:14 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 7 2014, 04:33 PM)
You probably going to have nightmare to do maintenance. 6 tank cleaning, 3 separate place with tight space.  sweat.gif  Not a good idea.

Suggest you not to use rain water to flush. It is not 'clean'. Unless you treat the water. Your toilet will be full of germ.

You can have separate water inlet to the rain tank. Set the clean water inlet to lower level cut off (the ball). While the rain water inlet cut off higher. This way the clean water topup will never be full and allow the rainwater in.

As suggest by halcyon27, 6" drain hole on the concrete will solve your flood problem.
*
i was planning to use a simple sediment filter from the ground collection tank to the ceiling storage tank. that should remove any large particles from entering the storage tanks.
would it be enough to have a relatively clean supply?

2 of the cheap 100-150w panasonic pumps will provide pressure at each collection tanks. 3X 2' UV lights installed at the tank cover will intermittently light the tanks to provide sterilization. no idea how they'll fare against algae and mosquito larvae. larvae should probably be killed, but algae growth?

not planning to treat the rainwater as that could be quite a hassle. thought about chlorine injection or salt injection, but UV sterilization requires less maintenance and simpler to implement.

QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 7 2014, 04:33 PM)
You probably going to have nightmare to do maintenance. 6 tank cleaning, 3 separate place with tight space.  sweat.gif  Not a good idea.

You can have separate water inlet to the rain tank. Set the clean water inlet to lower level cut off (the ball). While the rain water inlet cut off higher. This way the clean water topup will never be full and allow the rainwater in.
*
the ceiling slab on top of the toilet have quite a large space to move around. i'll arrange the pipe's position so that it won't sit next to the wall.
the other 2 areas will have much less space. thus the reason i'm gonna use fascia board for the cover. it'll be removable if there's any large maintenance to be done at the tanks.

anyway this is just planned. will see how the roof structure is built. if there's not much space to move around i'll adopt smaller tanks. for someone that frequently go inside the ceiling they'll understand how important this is.

your suggestion to mount the ball valve at the middle of the tank, i think that risk leaking the area where the hole is. stress from the ball valve pipe when it flex will accelerate damage to the tank wall.
i think mounting the inlet at the same level near the top, with longer steel arm to hold the ball is better.

heck i even thought about an electronic system to measure the tank level and electronic solenoid to open and stop the water flow. with backup mechanical system (ball valve) of course, in case the electronic system fails.
genielee_83
post Nov 8 2014, 01:15 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
120 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: Ipoh, Perak


i dont know bout the tanks but i do know uv light bulbs have life span.
I keep fishes and reptiles. Every 6 month i change the bulbs. So, TS, dont ever think the bulbs will last u forever. The UV will deplete and only has the heat or light effect in the end. So, also a hassle to change.
TSpaskal
post Nov 8 2014, 01:48 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(genielee_83 @ Nov 8 2014, 01:15 PM)
i dont know bout the tanks but i do know uv light bulbs have life span.
I keep fishes and reptiles. Every 6 month i change the bulbs. So, TS, dont ever think the bulbs will last u forever. The UV will deplete and only has the heat or light effect in the end. So, also a hassle to change.
*
i'm not planning to turn them on for 24/7. probably intermittently turned on once a day. after all, this tank won't store any drinking water.

your feedback on the UV light lifespan, is something to be considered for people using UV sterilized water filters. quite a number of water filters on the market brag about their UV sterilization process which kill of any bacteria. even coway is using them. they don't last forever right?

at least in my application i'm not depending on the UV to sterilize my drinking water. say, do you turn on your aquarium UV lights 24/7? 6 months is quite rapid degradation.
ozak
post Nov 8 2014, 04:03 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 8 2014, 12:14 PM)
i was planning to use a simple sediment filter from the ground collection tank to the ceiling storage tank. that should remove any large particles from entering the storage tanks.
would it be enough to have a relatively clean supply?

2 of the cheap 100-150w panasonic pumps will provide pressure at each collection tanks. 3X 2' UV lights installed at the tank cover will intermittently light the tanks to provide sterilization. no idea how they'll fare against algae and mosquito larvae. larvae should probably be killed, but algae growth?

not planning to treat the rainwater as that could be quite a hassle. thought about chlorine injection or salt injection, but UV sterilization requires less maintenance and simpler to implement.
A simple sediment filter is good enough for whole house clean water. The size would be depend on how many person in your house. Bigger size, last longer.

You don't need a pump if your rain tank water is for toilet. Let the gravity do the job. Do you need fast refill for the WC tank? If you want the water for the outdoor clean which require higher pressure, just install a pump for the outdoor only. That save your pump cost and running cost.

UV can sterilize the water. But as Genielee said, UV light have lifespan. So every yrs you need to change 3pcs light. And you don't no when the light going to spoil. Till you climb up and check. So it not going to be 100% bac free. Don't worried about the algae. As is don't grow in the dark tank. Unless you use the transparent tank. Actually algae is not harmfull.

If you ask me to choose between chlorine and uv treatment, I will choose chlorine. Less and easy maintenance. Since you don't use for drink.

Again I would said, I don't recommend to use rain water for toilet flush. Not a good experience for me. sad.gif
ozak
post Nov 8 2014, 04:24 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 8 2014, 12:14 PM)
the ceiling slab on top of the toilet have quite a large space to move around. i'll arrange the pipe's position so that it won't sit next to the wall.
the other 2 areas will have much less space. thus the reason i'm gonna use fascia board for the cover. it'll be removable if there's any large maintenance to be done at the tanks.

anyway this is just planned. will see how the roof structure is built. if there's not much space to move around i'll adopt smaller tanks. for someone that frequently go inside the ceiling they'll understand how important this is.

your suggestion to mount the ball valve at the middle of the tank, i think that risk leaking the area where the hole is. stress from the ball valve pipe when it flex will accelerate damage to the tank wall.
i think mounting the inlet at the same level near the top, with longer steel arm to hold the ball is better.

heck i even thought about an electronic system to measure the tank level and electronic solenoid to open and stop the water flow. with backup mechanical system (ball valve) of course, in case the electronic system fails.
Just makesure your body size can move around the tank for easy maintenance. If give yourself difficult to maintain, you will be tired after few yrs. 6 tank to maintain, not easy. You going to be busy whole yrs with your house maintain. sweat.gif I understand this cause every yrs, twice I do cleaning on my 2 water tank.

If you using the poly tank, not a problem to make a hole for the ball valve. And it is pretty common to have hole on the wall tank for pipe. Mind is already last for 16yrs under the sun.

The ball valve is pretty easy to install, simple, low cost and maintain free. Compare a complicated electrical control. Try to get a ball valve wheee the material is brass. Hard to find now. But it last freaking long and easy to adjust the ball. You can't bend the plastic for the cheap 1.

The is how the ball valve look like in the tank. The fish is optional. tongue.gif
Attached Image

This post has been edited by ozak: Nov 8 2014, 04:24 PM
halcyon27
post Nov 8 2014, 05:06 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


Talking about sediment filter, there's one spin down type from Hyflux Singapore called Automatic Sediment Filter ASF35. It's programmable to do a 30sec flush between 1-30days. Default is 7 and can be disabled not to flush ie manual. It runs off a heavy duty 9v battery or from a 240VAC-12VDC power supply. Not cheap about 800SGD. Discount if bought from their online shop.

Other brands would be Rusco or Honeywell.

This post has been edited by halcyon27: Nov 8 2014, 05:07 PM
TSpaskal
post Nov 8 2014, 05:59 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 8 2014, 04:03 PM)
Again I would said, I don't recommend to use rain water for toilet flush. Not a good experience for me. sad.gif
*
what's your bad experience with it? mind to explain?
maybe we could all learn something from it.
TSpaskal
post Nov 8 2014, 06:07 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(halcyon27 @ Nov 8 2014, 05:06 PM)
Talking about sediment filter, there's one spin down type from Hyflux Singapore called Automatic Sediment Filter ASF35. It's programmable to do a 30sec flush between 1-30days. Default is 7 and can be disabled not to flush ie manual. It runs off a heavy duty 9v battery or from a 240VAC-12VDC power supply. Not cheap about 800SGD. Discount if bought from their online shop.

Other brands would be Rusco or Honeywell.
*
am i reading the specs correctly? it says the mesh is 60 micron. a bit too large don't you think?
Fazab
post Nov 8 2014, 11:05 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


UV has very short penetration range, and is suitable only for point-of-use last step treatment, when a small amount of water flow directly next to the light source. Not useful at all for big tank.

The uv lights in aquariums are actually full spectrum fluors for plant growth. You want a healthy bacteria community in an aquarium, you don't want to kill them.

Simplest way will be to drain the tanks regularly and avoid bulid-up of organic matter which encourage bacteria to grow. If need to store the water for extended period add chlorine sparingly.

halcyon27
post Nov 10 2014, 12:07 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 8 2014, 06:07 PM)
am i reading the specs correctly? it says the mesh is 60 micron. a bit too large don't you think?
*
Aiks, my bad. Didn't read your requirement properly. This is to pre-filter rain water before tangki right? If you're concerned about purity in the first place, membrane is technically correct but not economically viable since there's 3 tanks. Anything else would encourage lots of undesirable stuff like what ozak mentioned. If for plants and washing car should be ok. Toilet flushing maybe need a little rethinking like a chlorine mixing tank or ozone like some in Oz. Problem is that sometimes run-off from roof carries with it organic substances like bird poo and dead leaf unless these can be screened off. Rain water will dilute these and the phosphorus is what encourages algae growth. Those gutter leaf screen made from stainless steel that helps maintain the gutter free from these but bio sludge can still develop over time.

One time, I did fancy thinking up if it were possible to do what's now popular in ME, Western countries, US, Australia and New Zealand. There's a growing movement called natural swimming pool (NSP) pioneered by an Austrian guy in 1985. They discovered biochemically that to preclude strong growth of algae, phosphorus has to be removed. Over here, hmmm no. Besides the usual suspects Cryptosporidium, Giardia spp, Legionella bacterium to the uncommon Leptospirosis (found in rat's urine) there's also the rare but enviromentally plausible brain eating bug (Naegleria Fowlerii), flesh eating bacteria (necrotizing fascitis) to contend with not to mention unwanted myriad hosts of helminth.
Read it up under waterborne diseases. Think disinfection for toilet use should be considered. UV in the WC cistern perhaps?

This post has been edited by halcyon27: Nov 10 2014, 12:07 AM
ozak
post Nov 10 2014, 01:20 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 8 2014, 05:59 PM)
what's your bad experience with it? mind to explain?
maybe we could all learn something from it.
*
I once get infected by the dirty toilet bow. So it is very important to keep the bow clean germ free.

Suppose the toilet bow is clean by flush clean water. But you are using not clean water to flush. The water droplet or the mist will be everywhere around the toilet. Next you sit on the toilet. Where your crotch will be? I guess you know how the germ craw up to your skin.
champu
post Nov 10 2014, 03:40 PM

Champu
****
Senior Member
633 posts

Joined: Apr 2014



QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 10 2014, 01:20 PM)
I once get infected by the dirty toilet bow. So it is very important to keep the bow clean germ free.

Suppose the toilet bow is clean by flush clean water. But you are using not clean water to flush. The water droplet or the mist will be everywhere around the toilet. Next you sit on the toilet. Where your crotch will be? I guess you know how the germ craw up to your skin.
*
Ouch! Hope it wasn't bad?
cooldownguy86
post Nov 14 2014, 12:33 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
896 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Ampang
QUOTE(paskal @ May 4 2014, 03:49 PM)
there's 2 prevalent wind direction, which change according to the northeast or southwest monsoon season.
sunrise and sunset movement are also shown. the sun rises at relatively the same position but sets at different location according to the season.
hi, thanks much for sharing all the useful info. can you also share how you measured the prevalent wind direction, and also the sun movement?
TSpaskal
post Nov 16 2014, 05:45 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(cooldownguy86 @ Nov 14 2014, 12:33 AM)
hi, thanks much for sharing all the useful info. can you also share how you measured the prevalent wind direction, and also the sun movement?
*
bro i didn't measure the wind speed, just the direction. just by using a flag, or a piece of cloth or throwing dirt or smoke you could see the direction that the wind is blowing.
anyway i used a piece of thread to get the general direction of the wind direction.

sun movement i checked using a compass, protractor, cotton thread and the shadow from a piece of pole.
timed the date, and time of measurement and took the angle of shadow to the magnetic north.
then verified the 3D model simulated sunshine and shadow to the actual location and orientation at the date and time.

sun simulation i'm using the built in features inside google sketchup.
verified that it's dead accurate to nearest degree.
TSpaskal
post Nov 16 2014, 08:41 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(Fazab @ Nov 8 2014, 11:05 PM)
UV has very short penetration range, and is suitable only for point-of-use last step treatment, when a small amount of water flow directly next to the light source. Not useful at all for big tank.

The uv lights in aquariums are actually full spectrum fluors for plant growth. You want a healthy bacteria community in an aquarium, you don't want to kill them.

Simplest way will be to drain the tanks regularly and avoid bulid-up of organic matter which encourage bacteria to grow. If need to store the water for extended period add chlorine sparingly.
*
reading back all the feedbacks i'm guessing i need to implement some sort of treatment before storage.
the UV lights inside the water tank is a hassle since i need to dunk the lights inside the large tank for illumination. make more sense to treat the water at the pipe before they're put inside the tanks.
easier to achieve high dosage of UV also.

and probably chlorine injection at the untreated storage if necessary, since those could be easily maintained.

QUOTE(halcyon27 @ Nov 10 2014, 12:07 AM)
Aiks, my bad. Didn't read your requirement properly. This is to pre-filter rain water before tangki right? If you're concerned about purity in the first place, membrane is technically correct but not economically viable since there's 3 tanks. Anything else would encourage lots of undesirable stuff like what ozak mentioned. If for plants and washing car should be ok. Toilet flushing maybe need a little rethinking like a chlorine mixing tank or ozone like some in Oz. Problem is that sometimes run-off from roof carries with it organic substances like bird poo and dead leaf unless these can be screened off. Rain water will dilute these and the phosphorus is what encourages algae growth. Those gutter leaf screen made from stainless steel that helps maintain the gutter free from these but bio sludge can still develop over time.

One time, I did fancy thinking up if it were possible to do what's now popular in ME, Western countries, US, Australia and New Zealand. There's a growing movement called natural swimming pool (NSP) pioneered by an Austrian guy in 1985. They discovered biochemically that to preclude strong growth of algae, phosphorus has to be removed. Over here, hmmm no. Besides the usual suspects Cryptosporidium, Giardia spp, Legionella bacterium to the uncommon Leptospirosis (found in rat's urine) there's also the rare but enviromentally plausible brain eating bug (Naegleria Fowlerii), flesh eating bacteria (necrotizing fascitis) to contend with not to mention unwanted myriad hosts of helminth.
Read it up under waterborne diseases. Think disinfection for toilet use should be considered. UV in the WC cistern perhaps?
*
ozone sounds like a hassle to implement and maintain. maybe i didn't read much about it. anyway i was thinking 3-5 micron cartridge filters that you could buy cheaply at tesco. i just need 2 prefilter location for the 2 collection tank (untreated water).

there will be a first flush system and a prefilter mesh to filter off the large organic particles. hopefully that will reduce the amount of large organic compound. while there might an issue, but considering that a lot of other countries are implementing rainwater harvesting system successfully, can get pointers from them.

i was looking to implement a variation of this:
user posted image

if the water quality is still bad i'll do a chlorine injection at the untreated tank. and since the rainwater will now have some sort of proper treatment to them (tho maybe not to level of drinking quality), i'm also gonna use them for laundry.
that should make better use of the large storage.

QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 10 2014, 01:20 PM)
I once get infected by the dirty toilet bow. So it is very important to keep the bow clean germ free.

Suppose the toilet bow is clean by flush clean water. But you are using not clean water to flush. The water droplet or the mist will be everywhere around the toilet. Next you sit on the toilet. Where your crotch will be? I guess you know how the germ craw up to your skin.
*
did you use a first flush and any prefilter for this to happen?
i've been reading quite a lot and most of them say rainwater from the roof is quite clean without any harmful bacteria in them.
halcyon27
post Nov 17 2014, 08:10 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,140 posts

Joined: Nov 2010


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 16 2014, 08:41 PM)
did you use a first flush and any prefilter for this to happen?
i've been reading quite a lot and most of them say rainwater from the roof is quite clean without any harmful bacteria in them.
*
No comments on the earlier part which I think is sound since that's disinfection. But on this part I want to clarify. Rain water is indeed clean but the roof may not necessarily be. It will pick up stuff along the way which hopefully the first flush will clear. But microbially, that's not always so clearcut as the sludges in the drain pipes if it remains will always have unwanted contaminants. Typically in any home's roof top, if you see a lot of birds perched on the roof frequently chances are there might be guano deposits which means very high urea and phosphorus content which basically is a potent algae starter mix. Every time it rains, these things gets flushed down and depending upon the thickness and hardness of their encrustation. Maybe less of a chance if roof is very hot. But just observe it on your current place esp the neighbour's roof and gauge to what extent there are these things and possibly others (dead leaves, etc).
Fazab
post Nov 17 2014, 09:26 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


Rainwater is indeed clean, I will happily bath in freshly collected rainwater, and will even drink fresh rainwater collected directly in a clean glass. (provided this is in kampung area, no acid rain problem.)

There is just an issue if you need to store them for extended period (e.g. > 1 week). The organic matter is the water (bird poo, dust, dead leaves etc) provide food for bacteria growth, which will start off a food chain. Insect larvae etc will feed on the bacteria etc. etc. This happen very fast in our warm weather.
Most of these will be heterotrophic bacteria, generally they are not likely to cause disease. If you don't bath and drink OK.
Algae is not a problem if you close your tanks and no sunlight.

Worst case scenario you get foul-smelling water that might cause a rash to people with highly sensitive skin. And you might see some larvae of sorts swimming in your toilet bowl after a flush.

And you will likely be storing, since your peak collection is >12000 liters, enough for > 2000 toilet flushes. That's two months worth of pooing and peeing.

Installing a UV flow cell and a prefilter is a good option, if you don't mind the cost of extra plumbing and tanks. Make sure the uv cell is properly sized for the correct flow rate.

Otherwise I will just drain it regularly and add chlorine once a week if I need to store the water. Connect a huge shower in the garden and play with the kids.

If you want to use for laundry best include another filter in the laundry line. Fine particles and rust can do hell to white cloths.

If I do this, my actual worry is the extra 12000 kg sitting on my roof. But then again, condominiums probably have 100,000 liter tanks on their roofs.
ozak
post Nov 17 2014, 10:13 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 16 2014, 08:41 PM)
did you use a first flush and any prefilter for this to happen?
i've been reading quite a lot and most of them say rainwater from the roof is quite clean without any harmful bacteria in them.
*
This is a fresh water. Not even using rain water.

The point is, the harmfull bacterial. How to makesure your toilet bow stay clean from harmfull bacteria. If you insisting of using rain water, just makesure every drop of it is bac free water.

From your implementation, it look like very high cost inorder to use rain water. Your monthly consumption is high for water?


TSpaskal
post Nov 17 2014, 10:43 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(halcyon27 @ Nov 17 2014, 08:10 AM)
No comments on the earlier part which I think is sound since that's disinfection. But on this part I want to clarify. Rain water is indeed clean but the roof may not necessarily be. It will pick up stuff along the way which hopefully the first flush will clear. But microbially, that's not always so clearcut as the sludges in the drain pipes if it remains will always have unwanted contaminants. Typically in any home's roof top, if you see a lot of birds perched on the roof frequently chances are there might be guano deposits which means very high urea and phosphorus content which basically is a potent algae starter mix. Every time it rains, these things gets flushed down and depending upon the thickness and hardness of their encrustation. Maybe less of a chance if roof is very hot. But just observe it on your current place esp the neighbour's roof and gauge to what extent there are these things and possibly others (dead leaves, etc).
*
thus the importance of first flush system.
most other guides doesn't mention how much is needed to be flushed from use prior to storage, but this texas guide does have a formula for calculation:

warning! boring alert.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


and the all important formula:
user posted image

2749 sqft of roof cover on one side, and 2047 sqft on the other.
i'm gonna have to flush ~30 gallon and ~20 gallon.
how am i gonna flush that much i have no idea. a simple 6" downpipe, 6 feet high will only hold ~9 gallon of water. multiple downpipes in series will have added benefits i reckon. less chance for the contaminants to go through.

constant flowrate flush system could be implemented by this aussie system:
user posted image
but it needs a leak-proof downpipe for it to work. gonna pass.

and for those that's interested in adopting a gutter screen with the cheapest amount of money, this might do well:
user posted image
an aluminium mosquito netting should be small enough to filter most of the debris, cheap to buy, readily available and should last quite a bit.
TSpaskal
post Nov 17 2014, 06:47 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(Fazab @ Nov 17 2014, 09:26 AM)
Rainwater is indeed clean, I will happily bath in freshly collected rainwater, and will even drink fresh rainwater collected directly in a clean glass. (provided this is in kampung area, no acid rain problem.)

There is just an issue if you need to store them for extended period (e.g. > 1 week). The organic matter is the water (bird poo, dust, dead leaves etc) provide food for bacteria growth, which will start off a food chain. Insect larvae etc will feed on the bacteria etc. etc. This happen very fast in our warm weather.
Most of these will be heterotrophic bacteria, generally they are not likely to cause disease. If you don't bath and drink OK.
Algae is not a problem if you close your tanks and no sunlight.

Worst case scenario you get foul-smelling water that might cause a rash to people with highly sensitive skin. And you might see some larvae of sorts swimming in your toilet bowl after a flush.

And you will likely be storing, since your peak collection is >12000 liters, enough for  > 2000 toilet flushes. That's two months worth of pooing and peeing.

Installing a UV flow cell and a prefilter is a good option, if you don't mind the cost of extra plumbing and tanks. Make sure the uv cell is properly sized for the correct flow rate.

Otherwise I will just drain it regularly and add chlorine once a week if I need to store the water. Connect a huge shower in the garden and play with the kids.

If you want to use for laundry best include another filter in the laundry line. Fine particles and rust can do hell to white cloths.

If I do this, my actual worry is the extra 12000 kg sitting on my roof. But then again, condominiums probably have 100,000 liter tanks on their roofs.
*
i did considered an underground tank. but those would be a hassle to clean. but since they're on the ground it'd be easier to to add salt or chlorine manually. skipped since it's hard to remove the sludge after a while.

anyway while the system is able to store 12 tonne of water, only 6 tonne will be rainwater. the other 6 will be treated tap water. 3-3 or 4-2 if there's a need for reconfiguration. the master bedroom will have a large tub that will take 250-300 gallons of water to fill. that is, if what i'm reading is correct. so the tap water cycling should be enough if my wife fills the tub once a week.

as for the rainwater cycling, guess i'm gonna have to recycle them back through the filter and UV once a while. will be implemented as part of the design.


QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 17 2014, 10:13 AM)
This is a fresh water. Not even using rain water.

The point is, the harmfull bacterial. How to makesure your toilet bow stay clean from harmfull bacteria. If you insisting of using rain water, just makesure every drop of it is bac free water.

From your implementation, it look like very high cost inorder to use rain water. Your monthly consumption is high for water?
*
okay you got me concerned. is this because of too long storing the water?

i'm not planning for a costly system. if it's too expensive might as well scrap the idea. monthly consumption isn't much anyway, my previous house we're paying the minimum bill of RM6 every month.
the idea of harvesting the rainwater is because the roof structure is perfect enough for it to be harvested. i'll try and keep the cost down else i'll just scrap it.
patryn33
post Nov 17 2014, 11:00 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,940 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Apr 29 2014, 09:33 AM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


found the floorplan to the 3D which i've submitted for quotation.
user posted image
user posted image
correction it's not 2400 sqft. total interior space is 3143 sqft.
RM260k, which translate to ~RM83 psft.

deck and porch at half of the interior price. total build price not breaching RM300k.
5 bedroom, 1 ht room.
separated wet & dry kitchen.
2 family area at ground floor & 2nd floor.
6 bathroom
indoor store room
separated guest area & dining area

hard to believe?
believe it.
*
3000 sqft so many rooms and bathrooms. Sounds small to me. I am 2200 sq ft living area and I just have 3 bedrooms. 2.5bath, 2 living area and a small office. Of course I have like 300 sq ft of unfinished storage area.
Fazab
post Nov 17 2014, 11:43 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


Too many opinion confusing you. biggrin.gif

Your idea is OK. So just go ahead.

If you dun mind the capital outlay, install a uv treatment, gutter shield etc. Guarantee cantik.

If dun want to spend money, just spend a bit more time to maintain.

My opinion worst case scenario you get some not nice smelling water with a few larvae, but perfectly OK to flush toilets.

ozak
post Nov 17 2014, 11:47 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 17 2014, 06:47 PM)
okay you got me concerned. is this because of too long storing the water?

i'm not planning for a costly system. if it's too expensive might as well scrap the idea. monthly consumption isn't much anyway, my previous house we're paying the minimum bill of RM6 every month.
the idea of harvesting the rainwater is because the roof structure is perfect enough for it to be harvested. i'll try and keep the cost down else i'll just scrap it.
*
Rm6 only? You talk like serious implementation for a high usage? Thaught your monthly bill like rm50 or rm80.

From your plan, the monthly cost for this rain harvesting is already probably cost rm5. A monthly change filter, uv light depreciate and energy cost. How to keep it low?

It happen many many yrs ago. Not serious. But enough to educate me. It is probably of long holiday back and didn't clean the toilet. After this, did clean the tank and disinfect everything.


TSpaskal
post Nov 18 2014, 11:52 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(patryn33 @ Nov 17 2014, 11:00 PM)
3000 sqft so many rooms and bathrooms. Sounds small to me. I am 2200 sq ft living area and I just have 3 bedrooms. 2.5bath, 2 living area and a small office. Of course I have like 300 sq ft of unfinished storage area.
*
that's an old plan. been scrapped for a single storey design. the updated floorplan is in this thread, somewhere.
yes it's a small house. can't afford bigger because i'm poor. nod.gif

QUOTE(Fazab @ Nov 17 2014, 11:43 PM)
Too many opinion confusing you.  biggrin.gif
Your idea is OK. So just go ahead.
If you dun mind the capital outlay, install a uv treatment, gutter shield etc. Guarantee cantik.
If dun want to spend money, just spend a bit more time to maintain.
My opinion worst case scenario you get some not nice smelling water with a few larvae, but perfectly OK to flush toilets.
*
the lots of varying opinions is quite hard to take all in.
but it's all good. because of all of the feedback that i'm planning for a recycling process to move the rainwater through the filtration and UV to avoid them stagnant for too long.

QUOTE(ozak @ Nov 17 2014, 11:47 PM)
Rm6 only? You talk like serious implementation for a high usage? Thaught your monthly bill like rm50 or rm80.

From your plan, the monthly cost for this rain harvesting is already probably cost rm5. A monthly change filter, uv light depreciate and energy cost. How to keep it low?

It happen many many yrs ago. Not serious. But enough to educate me. It is probably of long holiday back and didn't clean the toilet. After this, did clean the tank and disinfect everything.
*
old house bro. back then it was me and wife and a baby. 2 toilets. no garden. no tub. no maid.

with the planned planter boxes, garden, growing up child, tub and all; i'm guessing the water bill north of RM50.
while that is still quite low, and the rainwater system won't break even ever, i rather use the rainwater for something.

after all, the house is an experiment.
ozak
post Nov 18 2014, 01:41 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 18 2014, 11:52 AM)
old house bro. back then it was me and wife and a baby. 2 toilets. no garden. no tub. no maid.

with the planned planter boxes, garden, growing up child, tub and all; i'm guessing the water bill north of RM50.
while that is still quite low, and the rainwater system won't break even ever, i rather use the rainwater for something.

after all, the house is an experiment.
*
Don't worry too much la. smile.gif

Suggest just go for simple rain harvesting. Net trap-->micron filter-->storage + chlorine injection. If good than expand it to better system. If no good, chop off the pipe and convert to clean water tank.



In my planning design of piping system, I always treat the water as very low consumption and is always the lowest cost in my monthly bill.(Free) I pay RM6 from day 1. And now for 7yrs, totally free. So

1) running an electrical applicance to get a free water is waste to me. Cause electric is expensive than the water.
2) Try best to design the backup piping system, etc using gravity or auto run mechanisms without intervention from human or using electrical parts.

My way of seeing the rain is a free water. If my monthly bill require to pay just to get a free rain water is a waste. A filter change cost RM4, chlorine probably RM0.5 and pump running cost RM0.5. Total up RM5 monthly bill for a free rain water. Why not just pay additional RM5 to syabas to get another 5m cubic of clean water on top of my monthly water bill? No money invest, no maintenance, no worry about bac, syabas happy. biggrin.gif

But this is just me who spoilt by the free water thinking. He.....
Fazab
post Nov 18 2014, 03:59 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
519 posts

Joined: Jun 2011


I got 4 kids, wife planted loads of don't-know-whats, 4 midi -fish ponds, wash my own cars - monthly water bill seldom exceed RM10. Now I pay Syabas RM50 beginning of January, until Dec no need pay, got credit somemore.

Water is cheap, but I am also installing a cheapo rainwater harvest - just to remind myself and the kids not to take anything for granted. And of course, it's just fun and gratifying to do these sort of stuff.

Will start with one 300 liter tank, sitting on a concrete bench 3 ft above ground behind kitchen. Water collected off gutter from ~1200 sf of roof, and will be used mainly to water my wife's herb garden and other plants using irrigation pipes and gravity flow. And washing the car porch.
The concrete bench is to house my two gas tanks, might as well make it real strong and plonk the water tank on it.

Will fabricate most of the stuff like first flush valve DIY. Long term plan if lots of rain, plan to install another tank and a pump to pump the water up to main tank, after chlorine treatment and 3um filtration.

Won't break even in my lifetime, but, you know, fun stuff to do.
patryn33
post Nov 18 2014, 11:12 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,940 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 3 2014, 04:26 PM)
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
the house layout is really straight forward. there's not even a pathway or walkway inside the house.
there's no change to the floorplan when we erected the 3D.

we purposely went with a straightforward design to maximize space.
*
final design? alot of walls.. not my style.
I like open concept
AlexLee277
post Nov 25 2014, 01:06 AM

Dihujani kenangan masa lalu
*******
Senior Member
4,221 posts

Joined: Dec 2007
From: Somewhere on Earth



leave my footprint here first, very interesting :3
Vip3R
post Nov 27 2014, 01:27 AM

~ Expect The Un-Expected ~
*****
Senior Member
721 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Sabah (Currently in JB/SG)



first of all, did you get a SI report for your site prior to your construction of foundation. this is dirt cheap to get and certainly helps you the hassle of differential settlement in the long run.

I think your pile qty a bit too much. frm the SI, we can know if your soil is strong enough. A raft foundation will do or combination with shallow pile which should cost a lot less with more provision for future upgrading...say 3 sty tongue.gif

Just my 2 cents.

Anyway, gr8 sharing here...keep it up. can't wait to see the end picture. thumbup.gif

This post has been edited by Vip3R: Nov 27 2014, 02:31 PM
TSpaskal
post Nov 28 2014, 07:55 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
fuh. it's been 15 pages. and 25,000 views. garnered quite an interest eh?
too bad i'm not earning anything from all the traffic.

all future updates will be relegated to my blog. further documentation on the construction, rainwater system, electrical & plumbing systems, and automation will done at my site to help isolate all the different topics.
serves larger viewership and avoid daily update/posting from irritating other forumers.

as such, this topic will be closed.
TSpaskal
post Jun 19 2018, 03:23 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
thread reopened.

the sheer amount of incorrect information and wrong assumption in these parts are just breathtaking. cool2.gif
-oc-gassa
post Jun 19 2018, 03:34 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
967 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: setapak
nice 1 paskal.. been waiting long enuf.. haha... any update on the project?
keen to know the progress
TSpaskal
post Jun 19 2018, 03:46 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
so i've built an energy monitoring system based on the EmonLib library.
with a little bit of changes here and there to suit my requirement.

tested the long term accuracy for 24/7 operation with a cheap ESP8266 off aliexpress and the ADC loses its precision here and there causing erroneous spikes in the measurement.
also tested the ESP8266 with an external ADC through ADS1015 and ADS1115 and but the measurement lags here and there because of the ESP SDK messes around with the response.

got a good result using an arduino that acts solely as the measurement node and an ESP that is used solely for the data transmission.

user posted image
user posted image
calibrated the sensor response to a water kettle with a PF of 1.0

and proceeded to install the prototype inside my DB.
user posted image
user posted image

measurement is taken off the neutral line to get a total sum of the entire 3 phases.

user posted imageuser posted image
user posted image

data transmitted using MQTT to a central server through wifi.
SUSAmeiN
post Jun 19 2018, 03:56 PM

★★★★★★★
*******
Senior Member
4,735 posts

Joined: Feb 2010
From: ★~Starlight~★
House completed?
TSpaskal
post Jun 19 2018, 04:01 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
user posted image

fair enough resolution.
able to detect the fridge compressor being turned on and off with the waterpump spikes, instant boiler and everything else with acceptable accuracy.

user posted image
also able to detect the house external lighting power requirement.
the house have a 100w energy budget for outdoor lighting that is turned on every night from 8pm-6am (1kW budget for 10 hours, 30 cents everyday, rm9 budget monthly)

well that's not interesting.
this is what's interesting.
user posted image
this is 3 bedroom airconds being turned on one after the next.

see this?
user posted image
this is the main bedroom aircond being throttled down within a few minutes of it being turned on.

this is the effect of inverter airconds.
it will save you money so long as you don't set it to freezing temperatures.

this is the aircond being set to 26 degrees, with ceiling fan turned on, in a room facing the evening sun.
weikee
post Jun 19 2018, 04:32 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 19 2018, 04:01 PM)
user posted image

fair enough resolution.
able to detect the fridge compressor being turned on and off with the waterpump spikes, instant boiler and everything else with acceptable accuracy.

user posted image
also able to detect the house external lighting power requirement.
the house have a 100w energy budget for outdoor lighting that is turned on every night from 8pm-6am (1kW budget for 10 hours, 30 cents everyday, rm9 budget monthly)

well that's not interesting.
this is what's interesting.
user posted image
this is 3 bedroom airconds being turned on one after the next.

see this?
user posted image
this is the main bedroom aircond being throttled down within a few minutes of it being turned on.

this is the effect of inverter airconds.
it will save you money so long as you don't set it to freezing temperatures.

this is the aircond being set to 26 degrees, with ceiling fan turned on, in a room facing the evening sun.
*
Nice work.

What sensors are you using to supply the data to Arduino?
TSpaskal
post Jun 19 2018, 04:34 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
user posted image
refer to the graph.

this is normal consumption in my house with 3 bedroom airconds running.

once the temperature reaches saturation point, the usage is about A. around 3.3A (759W)
759 watt is fricking low considering there's 3 aircond running that is rated at 900W+ each.

B is when i decide to go out from my study room and go make coffee.
so B is me making coffee.

then you get C which is higher compared to the saturation point at A because the door is opened, compressor has to be run at higher load to reach back saturation temp.


anyway once the set temp is reached. i turned off the AC to check how much it costs to keep the AC at the temp preset.
user posted imageuser posted image
the current goes down from 3.69A to 3.05A.
meaning one of the AC is only using (3.69-3.05) * 230V = 0.64A * 230V = 147W

~150W of power to keep the room temp at 26 degrees after the set temp is reached.
so no, you don't need 8 hours of run time for an inverter AC to save energy.

provided that your AC is installed correctly, and there is absolutely no air inside the AC system which will cause the AC to run at reduced efficiency.

user posted image
this vacuum evacuation process is imperative in ensuring the AC gas line is free from air before the system is charged.
but nobody does it.
ozak
post Jun 19 2018, 04:36 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


Current transformer lor.
weikee
post Jun 19 2018, 04:42 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 19 2018, 04:36 PM)
Current transformer lor.
*
Maybe my question not detail enough, i am more keen on good grade device, and good accuracy model. Tried few china version the variance between two same device can >10% offset.
ozak
post Jun 19 2018, 04:51 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 19 2018, 04:42 PM)
Maybe my question not detail enough, i am more keen on good grade device, and good accuracy model. Tried few china version the variance between two same device can >10% offset.
*
Don't have any better quality from the west ?

Somehow, you need to calibrate it and fine tune the prg for each sensor install.

Unless the sensor can be tune.
TSpaskal
post Jun 19 2018, 04:53 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
this is an article on the effects of air trapped inside the refrigerant line.
user posted image

air particle will insulate the gas lines causing excess pressure making the system less efficient and uses more energy to reach the same cooling power.
https://www.achrnews.com/articles/93443-pur...eration-systems
TSpaskal
post Jun 19 2018, 04:59 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 19 2018, 04:42 PM)
Maybe my question not detail enough, i am more keen on good grade device, and good accuracy model. Tried few china version the variance between two same device can >10% offset.
*
it requires calibration for each device.

i'm using YHDC SCT-013
the accuracy have been tested and measured so it's well known.
https://learn.openenergymonitor.org/electri...t-sensor-report
https://learn.openenergymonitor.org/electri...t-sensor-report

if you need higher accuracy with simpler interface can consider the fluke voltage output current clamp. it has internal conversion and amplification.
pricey though.
TSpaskal
post Jun 19 2018, 05:10 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(-oc-gassa @ Jun 19 2018, 03:34 PM)
nice 1 paskal.. been waiting long enuf.. haha... any update on the project?
keen to know the progress
*
moved in.
now completing the rest of the integration. and stuffs

QUOTE(AmeiN @ Jun 19 2018, 03:56 PM)
House completed?
*
not fully complete.
it'll take at least 5 more years to complete.
weikee
post Jun 19 2018, 05:30 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 19 2018, 04:59 PM)
it requires calibration for each device.

i'm using YHDC SCT-013
the accuracy have been tested and measured so it's well known.
https://learn.openenergymonitor.org/electri...t-sensor-report
https://learn.openenergymonitor.org/electri...t-sensor-report

if you need higher accuracy with simpler interface can consider the fluke voltage output current clamp. it has internal conversion and amplification.
pricey though.
*
Thanks, i saw this model from the website you share earlier. I don't have oscilloscope to calibrate the accuracy. If its already +-3%, i am good with it.
weikee
post Jun 19 2018, 05:30 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 19 2018, 05:10 PM)
moved in.
now completing the rest of the integration. and stuffs
not fully complete.
it'll take at least 5 more years to complete.
*
The future of Tony Stark house brows.gif
Two5Kid
post Jun 19 2018, 06:57 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
629 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Kota Bharu


What is the address of your blog?

So after 4 years, what are the myths and what are the real truths that you have learned from the project?


TSpaskal
post Jun 20 2018, 08:54 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
user posted image
the entire house is mostly using these panasonic ceiling fan.

a 3 blade ceiling fan has the best energy efficiency per air moved. there's a study on this.
but looks too old school and wife don't want. the 5 blade is too pricey.
so bought the 4 blade since wife is okay with it.

but nevermind that.
the well known problem with these remote controlled KDK and panasonic fan is that they generate motor whine (or some kind of whining noise) after a while.
mine starts giving the same problem. most of the unit is affected.

i tot it's the coil whine. some people says it's the coil.
the coil loosen up after a while and must be glued down or tied down. opened the unit during operation and it does sound like coming from the PCB.

user posted image
so i've glued down the coils and capacitors.

nope. didn't work. still whining.
i've swapped the PCB to a unit that doesn't whine.
doesn't work either. the new PCB instantly generates whining noise right after.

some people are saying to remove the bottom cover, foam tape the covers etc etc.
helps a bit, but doesn't solve the whine.

user posted image
this solves it.
tie down the wires.
this completely removes the whining noise.

seems like there's no general rule to it.
one unit tied down in the same manner as another silent one still generates noise.
i need to tie down one part. then turn it on. if there's still noise, tie down another part, then turn it on. then repeat until all noise is gone.

and too much clamping seems to be worse compared to less. so less is more.

hope it helps you guys with the same problem.
weikee
post Jun 20 2018, 09:02 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 20 2018, 08:54 AM)
user posted image
the entire house is mostly using these panasonic ceiling fan.

a 3 blade ceiling fan has the best energy efficiency per air moved. there's a study on this.
but looks too old school and wife don't want. the 5 blade is too pricey.
so bought the 4 blade since wife is okay with it.

but nevermind that.
the well known problem with these remote controlled KDK and panasonic fan is that they generate motor whine (or some kind of whining noise) after a while.
mine starts giving the same problem. most of the unit is affected.

i tot it's the coil whine. some people says it's the coil.
the coil loosen up after a while and must be glued down or tied down. opened the unit during operation and it does sound like coming from the PCB.

user posted image
so i've glued down the coils and capacitors.

nope. didn't work. still whining.
i've swapped the PCB to a unit that doesn't whine.
doesn't work either. the new PCB instantly generates whining noise right after.

some people are saying to remove the bottom cover, foam tape the covers etc etc.
helps a bit, but doesn't solve the whine.

user posted image
this solves it.
tie down the wires.
this completely removes the whining noise.

seems like there's no general rule to it.
one unit tied down in the same manner as another silent one still generates noise.
i need to tie down one part. then turn it on. if there's still noise, tie down another part, then turn it on. then repeat until all noise is gone.

and too much clamping seems to be worse compared to less. so less is more.

hope it helps you guys with the same problem.
*
Nice one, i had this problem with my fans in living room and master bedroom, while i replace a new one in my master bedroom and yet to replace the other. I will try out your method.

The sound feel like the motor is heated up and some bearing noise.
ozak
post Jun 20 2018, 09:14 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 20 2018, 08:54 AM)
user posted image
the entire house is mostly using these panasonic ceiling fan.

a 3 blade ceiling fan has the best energy efficiency per air moved. there's a study on this.
but looks too old school and wife don't want. the 5 blade is too pricey.
so bought the 4 blade since wife is okay with it.

but nevermind that.
the well known problem with these remote controlled KDK and panasonic fan is that they generate motor whine (or some kind of whining noise) after a while.
mine starts giving the same problem. most of the unit is affected.

i tot it's the coil whine. some people says it's the coil.
the coil loosen up after a while and must be glued down or tied down. opened the unit during operation and it does sound like coming from the PCB.

user posted image
so i've glued down the coils and capacitors.

nope. didn't work. still whining.
i've swapped the PCB to a unit that doesn't whine.
doesn't work either. the new PCB instantly generates whining noise right after.

some people are saying to remove the bottom cover, foam tape the covers etc etc.
helps a bit, but doesn't solve the whine.

user posted image
this solves it.
tie down the wires.
this completely removes the whining noise.

seems like there's no general rule to it.
one unit tied down in the same manner as another silent one still generates noise.
i need to tie down one part. then turn it on. if there's still noise, tie down another part, then turn it on. then repeat until all noise is gone.

and too much clamping seems to be worse compared to less. so less is more.

hope it helps you guys with the same problem.
*
How does the whinning sound like ?

My KDK 4 blades sound like tuk, tuk tuk. Some mechanism touch while spinning. And a start up whinning sound too.

I change the capacitor in the board. All the sound gone. I have post in the ceiling fan side.
enduser
post Jun 20 2018, 10:26 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,280 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
Got planning to installed solar panel at roof or nearby ur house smile.gif
weikee
post Jun 20 2018, 10:50 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,019 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 20 2018, 09:14 AM)
How does the whinning sound like ?

My KDK 4 blades sound like tuk, tuk tuk. Some mechanism touch while spinning. And a start up whinning sound too.

I change the capacitor in the board. All the sound gone. I have post in the ceiling fan side.
*
Mine is like a faulty bearing sound. only happen after 15-20mins on.
ozak
post Jun 20 2018, 11:14 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(weikee @ Jun 20 2018, 10:50 AM)
Mine is like a faulty bearing sound. only happen after 15-20mins on.
*
The sound might misleading.

I also think the sound is mechanism problem. It really sound like mechanism touching while spinning.

But I try the easy and cheaper way 1st. Since google search mostly said come from the board. It is true. Running for 2yrs till now no problem.
siauann
post Jun 21 2018, 01:54 PM

Music-Movies-Coffee
*******
Senior Member
3,375 posts

Joined: May 2005
From: MeeRee


QUOTE(paskal @ Nov 28 2014, 07:55 AM)
fuh. it's been 15 pages. and 25,000 views. garnered quite an interest eh?
too bad i'm not earning anything from all the traffic.

all future updates will be relegated to my blog. further documentation on the construction, rainwater system, electrical & plumbing systems, and automation will done at my site to help isolate all the different topics.
serves larger viewership and avoid daily update/posting from irritating other forumers.

as such, this topic will be closed.
*
what is your blog?
-oc-gassa
post Jul 11 2018, 10:03 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
967 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: setapak
QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 19 2018, 04:34 PM)
user posted image
refer to the graph.

this is normal consumption in my house with 3 bedroom airconds running.

once the temperature reaches saturation point, the usage is about A. around 3.3A (759W)
759 watt is fricking low considering there's 3 aircond running that is rated at 900W+ each.

B is when i decide to go out from my study room and go make coffee.
so B is me making coffee.

then you get C which is higher compared to the saturation point at A because the door is opened, compressor has to be run at higher load to reach back saturation temp.
anyway once the set temp is reached. i turned off the AC to check how much it costs to keep the AC at the temp preset.
user posted imageuser posted image
the current goes down from 3.69A to 3.05A.
meaning one of the AC is only using (3.69-3.05) * 230V = 0.64A * 230V = 147W

~150W of power to keep the room temp at 26 degrees after the set temp is reached.
so no, you don't need 8 hours of run time for an inverter AC to save energy.

provided that your AC is installed correctly, and there is absolutely no air inside the AC system which will cause the AC to run at reduced efficiency.

user posted image
this vacuum evacuation process is imperative in ensuring the AC gas line is free from air before the system is charged.
but nobody does it.
*
Bro Paskal.. can attached image via lowyat forum image.. since unable to refer back as the image unviewable sad.gif ... thx for the details info nod.gif .. really like this kind specifi cost to cost info which hardly shared thumbup.gif
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 08:26 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
the house has a tank monitoring system.
to monitor all the 4 tonnes of tapwater i have stored inside the roof structure.

i do have 4000 liters stored in there.
which is really cumbersome to go and check how much capacity is in there.
and i don't wanna run an always on auto pump from the bottom tank to the ceiling tank. implementation (site) constraint. but more on that some other day.

user posted image
this is what a normal, daily low water consumption looks like.
the ground pump turns on every now and then and the tank capacity goes up.
us using the water will reduce the percentage (duh).
so it'll be reflected when most of the water will be used (morning >6am and evening around 5.30pm-7pm)

earlier this week (monday) i got a ping by the system that water capacity goes below 70% even with the ground tank pumping as usual.

user posted image
user posted image

quick check through the system shows the water level being pumped in, then slowly reduce.
nope, not normal.

looks like a leak.
somewhere.
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 08:40 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
found the leak coming from the irrigation system.
the solenoid valve controlling the irrigation system keeps turning on.
the microcontroller decides to go haywire, not grounding the GPIO pin properly causing the darlington pair that does the high voltage switching to receive floated signal, giving the valve 7V (out of 12), hence turning the valve partially and leaking water.

reflashed the controller with new firmware.
inserted pull down resistor to the GPIO to force ground the line with no signal.
and reprogrammed the logic.

this is how it looks now.
user posted image
flatline during the wee hours. suggesting that there's no leak to the system.

user posted image
A - ground level pump.
then flatline.
B - another ground level pump. after 3 hours of sedimentation.
C - irrigation system being turned on. 5 minutes cycle.
D - kids taking a bath for school. because sunday is a school day in kedah.
E - another irrigation watering cycle. 5 minutes cycle.

user posted image

and being informed by the system.
user posted image

Two5Kid
post Jul 22 2018, 03:54 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
629 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Kota Bharu


Seems like your water tank always hovering around 80% and above capacity, any reason why do you need the continuous monitoring? Even when kids shower, it doesn't drop below 50%.

But nevertheless, an impressive job to put all these into use.
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 09:59 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jun 20 2018, 09:14 AM)
How does the whinning sound like ?

My KDK 4 blades sound like tuk, tuk tuk. Some mechanism touch while spinning. And a start up whinning sound too.

I change the capacitor in the board. All the sound gone. I have post in the ceiling fan side.
*
whining.
like wing wing wing wing screeching sound.
swapping the PCB with a silent unit doesn't solve it.

QUOTE(enduser @ Jun 20 2018, 10:26 AM)
Got planning to installed solar panel at roof or nearby ur house smile.gif
*
too expensive.
already have a 200w panel bought for past students project. now collecting dust.
planning to integrate that to supplement running cost for the house management system, maybe later.

needs solar MPPT charging circuit. only read about it briefly, needs a circuit prototype to test.
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 10:11 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(siauann @ Jun 21 2018, 01:54 PM)
what is your blog?
*
not maintained.
now domain suspended i only maintain the hosting.

QUOTE(-oc-gassa @ Jul 11 2018, 10:03 AM)
Bro Paskal.. can attached image via lowyat forum image.. since unable to refer back as the image unviewable  sad.gif ... thx for the details info  nod.gif .. really like this kind specifi cost to cost info which hardly shared  thumbup.gif
*
sorry but hard to attach images to post using lowyat image hosting.
furthermore i need to access it from somewhere else. hard to maintain if using lyn hosting.

QUOTE(Two5Kid @ Jul 22 2018, 03:54 PM)
Seems like your water tank always hovering around 80% and above capacity, any reason why do you need the continuous monitoring? Even when kids shower, it doesn't drop below 50%.

But nevertheless, an impressive job to put all these into use.
*
cos the water supply in the area is really problematic.
it's a rural area. with incoming water pressure hovering around 0.1-0.2 bar. sometimes during the day i have 0 bar incoming pressure in the pipe. i've measured. even logged the pressure using a sensor.
wee hours can see water pressure going up to 0.5 bar.
and nearly every month can expect to see at least 1 day no incoming water.

i've tried straight waterpump pulling direct from incoming pipe to ceiling reservoir.
got stuck with air pockets.

tried timer to turn waterpump only after midnight and stop at 4am.
still got stuck with air pockets already in the pipes.

tried timer for 15 minutes then off 45 minutes cycle.
still doesn't solve the air pockets issue.
auto air release valve is expensive. and doesn't solve the dirt in the incoming water.
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 10:44 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
don't feel like doing work tonight.
so i'll write a bit.

problems:
1. incoming water pressure is really low. most of the time less than 0.2 bar.
2. lots of air pockets inside the incoming water pipe. because (nearly) everyone in this village is directly attaching booster pump to their incoming line, right after meter. causing air pockets to form from any leak within the supply line.
3. dirt in the incoming line. water filter gets really dirty, really fast.
4. lots of unscheduled water disruption. could last for days. usually happen during festive season. last raya 3 days no water. SADA says too much demand, existing supply can't cope. this happens really frequent.
5. goddam people using booster pump. water could reverse flow, back into the pipes. bet you never seen that at your place.
6. lots of sediment in the incoming water. causing filters to get really dirty really fast.

tried all sorts of solution.
none works reliably over time. main problem is the air pockets, causing pumps to dry run.
best solution that i could think of is using a sedimentation tank.
let the water fill by itself. then let it sit and allow the dirt to settle at the bottom.
then after a while, pump it to the ceiling reservoir.

solves the incoming water disruption monitoring and air pockets without an electronic control.
so lets do that.

user posted image
i'm using this 30 gallon blue tank as a sedimentation tank.
after letting the water sit, pump it to a sand filter, then through a PP sediment filter to remove any leftover dirt.

(1st try)
user posted image
A. float switch to detect water level.
B. flow sensor to detect outgoing flow from the tank.
user posted image
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 10:51 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
1st iteration running.
user posted image
got a bypass switch installed.
got an RCB installed to detect leakage.
and the relay control is using these electrodragon wifi relay.

user posted image

keeps rebooting with pump switching off. the internal SMPS has a problem with inductance load.
not a really good device.

the system also has a problem with incoming water. if the flexible pipe bends too much the pump will vacuum too much causing the pipe to contract, blocking it from sucking water.
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 10:59 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
2nd iteration.
user posted image
moved the outgoing line to the bottom. internal pressure from the filled water should provide some initial pressure to kickstart the pumping and avoid air from getting inside the outgoing line.

user posted image
user posted image

using the bottom feed line also allows the system to run without needing me to monitor the flow. becos there's no air. so no dry run.
but still has to consider what will happen if the float switch doesn't work and the pump sucks till empty.

so i've implemented a stop signal after 10 minutes regardless of float signal.
from test run, the tank should be empty after around 5 minutes of pumping.
ozak
post Jul 22 2018, 11:08 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 22 2018, 10:59 PM)
2nd iteration.
user posted image
moved the outgoing line to the bottom. internal pressure from the filled water should provide some initial pressure to kickstart the pumping and avoid air from getting inside the outgoing line.

user posted image
user posted image

using the bottom feed line also allows the system to run without needing me to monitor the flow. becos there's no air. so no dry run.
but still has to consider what will happen if the float switch doesn't work and the pump sucks till empty.

so i've implemented a stop signal after 10 minutes regardless of float signal.
from test run, the tank should be empty after around 5 minutes of pumping.
*
You can run the whole system automatic from the sediment tank till the ceiling tank. Without need to monitoring.

Use electrical system rather electronic to control for more reliable and less failure run. (mostly is only sensor/switch fail)
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 11:14 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
user posted image

the pump control has a simple control logic to it.

settling time is variable according to the ceiling reservoir capacity.
>90% - 4 hours of settling time.
>80% - 3 hours
>70% - 2 hours
>60% - 10 minutes
(target daily capacity to be at least 80% in case there's a long water disruption)

the reservoir tank will send its current capacity to the waterpump.
if there's still lots of water, the waterpump will let the incoming water to settle for longer periods of time.
if there's no capacity information received from the reservoir tank, the waterpump will default to 1 hour of settling time.

data is transmitted wirelessly.
updated every minute from the tank to the waterpump.
so yeah, that's why continuous monitoring is required.

also the irrigation system will reduce the cycle count to half if it's below 40%.
and stop the irrigation cycle if the tank cap drops below 25%.

bypass-able of course. control command can be sent to force cycle.
TSpaskal
post Jul 22 2018, 11:28 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jul 22 2018, 11:08 PM)
You can run the whole system automatic from the sediment tank till the ceiling tank. Without need to monitoring.

Use electrical system rather electronic to control for more reliable and less failure  run. (mostly is only sensor/switch fail)
*
i disagree.
even simple control mechanism is gonna be hard to implement using purely electrical system.

like how do you set the settling time to run the pump for 10 minutes, after the tank is left to settle for 1 hour?
considering if it takes 2 hour to fill the tanks after the last run?

10 am pump run.
10.10am pump stops. tank empty.
12.10pm tank full.
1.10pm pump run
1.20pm pump stop. tank empty.
ozak
post Jul 22 2018, 11:52 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 22 2018, 11:28 PM)
i disagree.
even simple control mechanism is gonna be hard to implement using purely electrical system.

like how do you set the settling time to run the pump for 10 minutes, after the tank is left to settle for 1 hour?
considering if it takes 2 hour to fill the tanks after the last run?

10 am pump run.
10.10am pump stops. tank empty.
12.10pm tank full.
1.10pm pump run
1.20pm pump stop. tank empty.
*
Don't use timer. It is not accurate running and require frequent adjust. Cause the pump flow amount is not constant.

The whole system depend on switch/sensor to detect the level to run/stop the pump.

Use electric logic to wired it. It is the most fail safe system to run. And best for outdoor.


TSpaskal
post Jul 23 2018, 12:13 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jul 22 2018, 11:52 PM)
Don't use timer. It is not accurate running and require frequent adjust. Cause the pump flow amount is not constant.

The whole system depend on switch/sensor to detect the level to run/stop the pump.

Use electric logic to wired it. It is the most fail safe system to run. And best for outdoor.
*
you don't make sense.
the sedimentation tank requires settling time to allow sludge deposit.

either that or construct a large, slow flow sedimentation tank used at water treatment plants.
how to allow enough time for deposit if no timer is involved?
ozak
post Jul 23 2018, 03:13 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 23 2018, 12:13 AM)
you don't make sense.
the sedimentation tank requires settling time to allow sludge deposit.

either that or construct a large, slow flow sedimentation tank used at water treatment plants.
how to allow enough time for deposit if no timer is involved?
*
Can la.

Let sturdy your case. Problem summarize list.

1) i do have 4000 liters stored in there.
which is really cumbersome to go and check how much capacity is in there.

2) cos the water supply in the area is really problematic.
it's a rural area. with incoming water pressure hovering around 0.1-0.2 bar. sometimes during the day i have 0 bar incoming pressure in the pipe. i've measured. even logged the pressure using a sensor.
wee hours can see water pressure going up to 0.5 bar.
and nearly every month can expect to see at least 1 day no incoming water.

3) lots of air pockets inside the incoming water pipe. because (nearly) everyone in this village is directly attaching booster pump to their incoming line, right after meter. causing air pockets to form from any leak within the supply line.

4) dirt in the incoming line. water filter gets really dirty, really fast. (sendiment)

5) lots of unscheduled water disruption. could last for days. usually happen during festive season. last raya 3 days no water. SADA says too much demand, existing supply can't cope. this happens really frequent. (That related to 1) 4000L stored)


Something like this ? Sorry for the bad draw.

user posted image

1) 1st tank is received the inlet water. Ball valve to control the water level. Funnel pipe to received the water flow down the bottom level. Also to control the sediment stirring around. Bottom valve for cleaning the sediment. Outlet pipe level lower abit than the ball valve open flow level. Pressure regulate is a cap over the pipe but not seal it. It is to regulate the pressure inside while not let the bug go in.

2) 2nd tank to received the 1st tank water that reduce the sediment. Water is calmer here where might sediment still present. Outlet pipe same level as 1st tank or lower (maybe). Pressure regulate pipe ontop. Drain valve below.

3) 3rd tank might not necessary need. Depend how bad is the sediment. Level switch (Or floating switch) install to ON/OFF the pump. Set the pipe and floating switch how much the water amount need it to pump each cycle. Pressure regulate pipe ontop. Drain valve below.

4) Water filter placing before the pump will help the pump lifespan longer. Also filter doesn't constant in high pressure with possible leak. ( I not sure this tank type filter construction inside. Might be good at after pump ?)

5) Pump built in pressure switch. When the ceiling tank is full by the ball valve shut, pressure built up in the pipe. Pressure switch sense the pressure and stop the pump. Once the ball valve open, water flow and pressure drop, pump start to run back. Check valve is to prevent the water back flow. Also lock the water inside the pump not to have air pocket. Flow switch is an additional safety switch incase the pump run dry. It will shut off the pump incertain set time.

6) Rooftop tank with ball valve. Pipe place below tank with valve to transfer water to another tank. Water level will be same across all the tank. Use the last tank for all the outlet. (no stall water and very clean water) Bypass pipe to outlet pipe from others tank with valve incase tank cleaning. Float mechanism water level install from the tank till inside house. (wall placing) Instant know direct water level. Everybody easy to read and understand. (well, you can integrate some smart read if want)

For electrical control logic, I comeout later if this system is ok to you. I m rusty with electric logic. sweat.gif
TSpaskal
post Jul 24 2018, 07:39 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jul 23 2018, 03:13 PM)
Can la.

Let sturdy your case. Problem summarize list.

1) i do have 4000 liters stored in there.
which is really cumbersome to go and check how much capacity is in there.

2) cos the water supply in the area is really problematic.
it's a rural area. with incoming water pressure hovering around 0.1-0.2 bar. sometimes during the day i have 0 bar incoming pressure in the pipe. i've measured. even logged the pressure using a sensor.
wee hours can see water pressure going up to 0.5 bar.
and nearly every month can expect to see at least 1 day no incoming water.

3) lots of air pockets inside the incoming water pipe. because (nearly) everyone in this village is directly attaching booster pump to their incoming line, right after meter. causing air pockets to form from any leak within the supply line.

4) dirt in the incoming line. water filter gets really dirty, really fast. (sendiment)

5) lots of unscheduled water disruption. could last for days. usually happen during festive season. last raya 3 days no water. SADA says too much demand, existing supply can't cope. this happens really frequent. (That related to 1) 4000L stored)
Something like this ? Sorry for the bad draw.

user posted image

1) 1st tank is received the inlet water. Ball valve to control the water level. Funnel pipe to received the water flow down the bottom level. Also to control the sediment stirring around. Bottom valve for cleaning the sediment. Outlet pipe level lower abit than the ball valve open flow level. Pressure regulate is a cap over the pipe but not seal it. It is to regulate the pressure inside while not let the bug go in.

2) 2nd tank to received the 1st tank water that reduce the sediment. Water is calmer here where might sediment still present. Outlet pipe same level as 1st tank or lower (maybe). Pressure regulate pipe ontop. Drain valve below.

3) 3rd tank might not necessary need. Depend how bad is the sediment. Level switch (Or floating switch) install to ON/OFF the pump. Set the pipe and floating switch how much the water amount need it to pump each cycle. Pressure regulate pipe ontop. Drain valve below.

4) Water filter placing before the pump will help the pump lifespan longer. Also filter doesn't constant in high pressure with possible leak. ( I not sure this tank type filter construction inside. Might be good at after pump ?)

5) Pump built in pressure switch. When the ceiling tank is full by the ball valve shut, pressure built up in the pipe. Pressure switch sense the pressure and stop the pump. Once the ball valve open, water flow and pressure drop, pump start to run back. Check valve is to prevent the water back flow. Also lock the water inside the pump not to have air pocket. Flow switch is an additional safety switch incase the pump run dry. It will shut off the pump incertain set time.

6) Rooftop tank with ball valve. Pipe place below tank with valve to transfer water to another tank. Water level will be same across all the tank. Use the last tank for all the outlet. (no stall water and very clean water) Bypass pipe to outlet pipe from others tank with valve incase tank cleaning. Float mechanism water level install from the tank till inside house. (wall placing) Instant know direct water level. Everybody easy to read and understand. (well, you can integrate some smart read if want)

For electrical control logic, I comeout later if this system is ok to you. I m rusty with electric logic. sweat.gif
*
thanks for the suggestion.
but requires the use of multiple tanks. prefer to reduce the number of tanks that i have exposed and can be seen.
TSpaskal
post Jul 24 2018, 07:46 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
data is collected from multiple nodes.
environment data that i'm interested with is temperature. which will be used later by other (planned) systems.

candidate sensors that was considered for this usage is the ds18b20, lm35, ntc, etc etc.
but the cheapest, simple interfacing, doesn't require external circuit and pre-calibrated response is the bmp280.

1st interation:
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
TSpaskal
post Jul 24 2018, 07:57 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
2nd iteration:
* integrated an sql database (sqlite3) to the system since the chart display node has a problem displaying huge number of points. gets unstable.
* upside to the sql database is that i have all the past historical record of all the data being received by the system.
* downside to that is constant writes to the sdcard.
* and downside to that is that the sdcard gets corrupted over time causing system wreck not able to boot properly, missing files nodes yada yada.

inb4 use a hdd/usb platter driver.
inb4 then i have to configure the CCTV server to store files from the pi. it's now an isolated, dedicated system and i intend to keep it that way. thanks.

user posted image
user posted image


user posted image
user posted image

since the system could cope and store and display more data, i also send, store, and log system uptime, rssi and system load from the nodes.
because, why not?
user posted image
user posted image
ozak
post Jul 24 2018, 09:04 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 24 2018, 07:39 AM)
thanks for the suggestion.
but requires the use of multiple tanks. prefer to reduce the number of tanks that i have exposed and can be seen.
*
Ok.

Anyway I already design the electric logic. Just post here.

user posted image

For pump run,
1) Pressure switch high (PS) --> Pump off. (Ball valve top tank close)
2) Pressure switch low --> Pump on (Ball valve top tank open)
3) Floating Swicth high (FS) --> Pump on (Receiving tank water level high)
4) Floating Switch low --> Pump off (Receiving tank water level low)

Logic,
1) If PS high and FS high --> Pump off
2) If PS low and FS low --> Pump off
3) If PS high and FS low --> Pump off
4) If PS low and FS high --> Pump on

1) Entire system run in auto with 2 switch to detect water pressure and level. All switch at the pump side and receiving tank. No switch or any electrical ontop ceiling tank for easy maintenance and problem solving. Pump run in interval depend on water refill time and margin level set for the floating switch.

2) Indicator light for full, low level and pump error can be wired to indoor if require.

3) Timer (T) is to delay in sec for stabilize switch signal receiving. Timer (T1) is to delay in 10 over sec for flow detect error. (Incase the pump priming). Both can be adjustable timing.

4) Overload relay (TR) is to protect the motor pump incase run dry and hot. It is self reset.

5) Magnetic Contactor (MC) is for pump.

6) Last minute add on the Manual Over Ride Switch. For maintenance and priming of water pump.

The electrical logic are not perfect as it lack on safety prevention. It can be add in and modify.


TSpaskal
post Jul 24 2018, 10:53 AM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(ozak @ Jul 24 2018, 09:04 AM)
Ok.

Anyway I already design the electric logic. Just post here.

user posted image

For pump run,
1) Pressure switch high (PS) --> Pump off. (Ball valve top tank close)
2) Pressure switch low --> Pump on  (Ball valve top tank open)
3) Floating Swicth high (FS) --> Pump on  (Receiving tank water level high)
4) Floating Switch low --> Pump off  (Receiving tank water level low)

Logic,
1) If PS high and FS high --> Pump off
2) If PS low and FS low    --> Pump off
3) If PS high and FS low  --> Pump off
4) If PS low and FS high  --> Pump on

1) Entire system run in auto with 2 switch to detect water pressure and level. All switch at the pump side and receiving tank. No switch or any electrical ontop ceiling tank for easy maintenance and problem solving. Pump run in interval depend on water refill time and margin level set for the floating switch.

2) Indicator light for full, low level and pump error can be wired to indoor if require.

3) Timer (T) is to delay in sec for stabilize switch signal receiving. Timer (T1) is to delay in 10 over sec for flow detect error. (Incase the pump priming). Both can be adjustable timing.

4) Overload relay (TR) is to protect the motor pump incase run dry and hot. It is self reset.

5) Magnetic Contactor (MC) is for pump.

6) Last minute add on the Manual Over Ride Switch. For maintenance and priming of water pump.

The electrical logic are not perfect as it lack on safety prevention. It can be add in and modify.
*
looks a lot more complicated than what i have right now.

this is what the current system looks like.
user posted image

the rest of the logic is software.
any modification to the control logic can be done remotely through network.
the system supports OTA update.
salimbest83
post Jul 24 2018, 11:45 AM

♥PMS on certain day♥
*******
Senior Member
8,633 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
From: Jelutong Penang



parking
ozak
post Jul 24 2018, 12:16 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Jul 24 2018, 10:53 AM)
looks a lot more complicated than what i have right now.

this is what the current system looks like.
user posted image

the rest of the logic is software.
any modification to the control logic can be done remotely through network.
the system supports OTA update.
*
If you know how to wiring, the circuit is consider easy and simple.

Sure of course you can put it into logic program with PIC, PLC or arduino. No problem at all. It take away 60% of the wiring. And easy modify the circuit anytime.

I m rusty with such circuit design. But fun to do once a while to recycle back my mind. Complicated wan, I move to PLC or arduino.

For running a pump at 1hp, I will not use the onboard relay to do switching. With the rapid interval switching cycle perday, that short life the relay. I will move it into motor relay or magnetic contactor with thermal relay (TR) as protection.

For outdoor use and box placing, I will not use 240v for contact control. For the micro controller is fine. But dealing with water and outdoor, I will place the switch, button and light into smaller DC volt.


TSpaskal
post Jul 24 2018, 11:03 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
environment monitoring, 3rd (current) iteration.

i've migrated the internet service provider from screamyx 4mbps that i had previously to digi infinite.
upside i could hit >30mbps, averaged at >20mbps consistently.
downside i lose port forwarding and exposed IP.
downside to that, i lose the ability to use dynamic dns and map the house IP to a domain.
and downside to all of that, is that i lose ability to remotely access the any of the internal servers, cctv and mqtt included.

so i can't send mqtt packets from remote monitoring nodes to the house mqtt server and logging server.

user posted image
re-mapped the (local) mqtt server to bridge some particular topics to a public mqtt server.
so using the public broker to bounce messages back to the home network for logging.

it works. with some servers. some services prolly turned off mqtt bridges.
nvm that. re-acquired the ability to receive and log remote nodes that i have somewhere else through the internet.

user posted image
user posted image

also have 2 nodes sensing humidity parameter.
one at the roof area (has contact to outside air) and another one at my lab, 35km away enclosed in a room.
TSpaskal
post Jul 25 2018, 05:20 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
user posted image

this is how one of the node looks like.
i'm using nodemcu modules based on the esp8266 microcontroller.
because it's cheap and comes with wifi capability. i like them.
not the cheapest tho. that would be the realtek rtl8591. i think. can't remember.

the node above connects to a bmp280, a switch (to remotely trigger the booster pump) and controls the irrigation valve through a darlington transistor array.

anyway the entire system is running on a single DC power supply at 19V output.
19V because i'm using a leftover laptop power brick that i have lying around.

the DC-DC buck converter that i have regulating power to the CCTV and other stuffs accepts max 24VDC.
so the system could work with anything up to 24v.
tried with 12v but too much voltage drop since i run the entire system off a PoE LAN. best is to have 48VDC in the system but 60V buck converters are too expensive for my blood.

sure it's off a breadboard.
but need to test mah. site implementation before i move to PCB.
needs design, test, implementation, correction, implementation, redesign, retest etc. takes a while.

user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image
user posted image

because buying off the shelf items are too mainstream.
enduser
post Jul 25 2018, 08:04 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,280 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
Hardcore stuff u got there haha:)
Lucky got lab to test.
cdspins
post Jul 26 2018, 09:39 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,714 posts

Joined: May 2008


QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 19 2018, 03:46 PM)
so i've built an energy monitoring system based on the EmonLib library.
with a little bit of changes here and there to suit my requirement.

tested the long term accuracy for 24/7 operation with a cheap ESP8266 off aliexpress and the ADC loses its precision here and there causing erroneous spikes in the measurement.
also tested the ESP8266 with an external ADC through ADS1015 and ADS1115 and but the measurement lags here and there because of the ESP SDK messes around with the response.

got a good result using an arduino that acts solely as the measurement node and an ESP that is used solely for the data transmission.

user posted image
user posted image
calibrated the sensor response to a water kettle with a PF of 1.0

and proceeded to install the prototype inside my DB.
user posted image
user posted image

measurement is taken off the neutral line to get a total sum of the entire 3 phases.

user posted imageuser posted image
user posted image

data transmitted using MQTT to a central server through wifi.
*
Hi Paskal, I would like to build a power monitoring device, may I know where you buy the power measuring meter? Any recommendation in brand? How do you install into DB as I see the measuring device is socket type... confused.gif

By the way... your project brows.gif is neat
enduser
post Jul 26 2018, 02:51 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,280 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(cdspins @ Jul 26 2018, 09:39 AM)
Hi Paskal, I would like to build a power monitoring device, may I know where you buy the power measuring meter? Any recommendation in brand? How do you install into DB as I see the measuring device is socket type...
*
For energy monitoring can buy off the shelf like this

https://maevi.my

But for power , u mean pq rite? maybe need to survey more.
cdspins
post Jul 27 2018, 03:00 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,714 posts

Joined: May 2008


QUOTE(enduser @ Jul 26 2018, 02:51 PM)
For energy monitoring can buy off the shelf like this

https://maevi.my

But for power , u mean pq rite? maybe need to survey more.
*
Thank you for your reply... That is very expensive stuff, a gateway + 1 energy meter cost RM900
Anyway, I found this sonoff china brand, wondering if it is ok?
http://sonoff.itead.cc/en/products/sonoff/sonoff-pow-r2
Anybody use before?
TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2018, 06:06 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
#throwbeg

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2018, 06:10 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
#throwbeg

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2018, 06:23 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
#throwbeg

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2018, 06:30 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
#throwbeg

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

TSpaskal
post Aug 3 2018, 07:02 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
yeah yeah yeah
all this throwbeg wanna make you throw up.

so let's talk current.
user posted image

this is current. 200 amp of current.
been contemplating on getting a multiprocess welder for quite some time now.
took me a year. nearly a year.

user posted image
a multiprocess because i want need something small.
a full blown high freq TIG welder is too slow for the amount of continuous weld that i do. don't think i'm gonna use it much.

so a multiprocess welder that could do MIG and TIG and small would be a nice compliment to the collection.

trying the small welder for a few days i'm surprised at the result.
user posted image
user posted image

this is what i'm getting from the larger, workshop grade welder.
it's not as nice to look at. but that is done on a really thin 1.0mm mild steel square tubing.
most people will never even do a continuous weld on thin mild steel. not even workshops, they'd just spot weld the metal to avoid burn through.

that is not interesting. but this is:
user posted image
user posted image

this is what i'm getting on the small multiprocess welder.
the metal deposition from the small unit is not as smooth as the larger unit.
inductance control is also relatively worse.
weld pool progress also a bit harder to control on the smaller unit.

but damn, the weld looks nicer.
prolly the weld voltage can be reduced lower than the older unit.
it doesn't weld as nice for thicker metal, but thin material this unit welds better.

now need to build a cart for the unit.
TSpaskal
post Aug 7 2018, 10:48 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
QUOTE(cdspins @ Jul 26 2018, 09:39 AM)
Hi Paskal, I would like to build a power monitoring device, may I know where you buy the power measuring meter? Any recommendation in brand? How do you install into DB as I see the measuring device is socket type... confused.gif

By the way... your project  brows.gif is neat
*
i got it off aliexpress.
the current clamp is also available in ebay, gearbest, banggood, amazon, etc. i've posted the model before.

installed inside db because it's a current clamp, a non-intrusive to the circuit.


QUOTE(cdspins @ Jul 27 2018, 03:00 PM)
Thank you for your reply...  That is very expensive stuff, a gateway + 1 energy meter cost RM900
Anyway, I found this sonoff china brand, wondering if it is ok?
http://sonoff.itead.cc/en/products/sonoff/sonoff-pow-r2
Anybody use before?
*
the sonoff uses a shunt resistor paired with a hlw8012 monitoring ic. the ic measures the current drop across the resistor.
it's an intrusive design where the line is inserted with that shunt resistor causing a voltage drop to happen across the resistor and measured by the ic.
not perfect if you consider the thermal drift on the resistor and thermal limit of the resistor with high load. but it'll work, suitable for low power devices.

the sonoff can be flashed to some other firmware that supports tweaking to the output messages, don't need to send it to sonoff server.
not well versed with sonoff since i don't use them. don't intend to use them since there's no exposed GPIO on sonoff pcb, which severely limit external sensors that be attached to the sonoff.
TSpaskal
post Aug 7 2018, 11:20 PM

armchair commando couch potato
*******
Senior Member
2,801 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Darul Aman
unrelated to the whole renovation/civil/building stuffs.
but will be used later on with sensors casing. and stuffs.

never had a 3d printer before.
user posted image

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


bought the ender3 model from creality.
raving review on the net.
wanna try it mah, get a hang of it. see if works for my usage.

was contemplating on getting the cr10, but the really high build really need 2 z-axis lead screw.
that would require splurging on cr10s, and too expensive (for me) as a starter printer.

maybe later if i feel 220mmx220mmx250mm not enough.
ozak
post Aug 8 2018, 09:35 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
17,013 posts

Joined: Jan 2005


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 7 2018, 11:20 PM)
unrelated to the whole renovation/civil/building stuffs.
but will be used later on with sensors casing. and stuffs.

never had a 3d printer before.
user posted image

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


bought the ender3 model from creality.
raving review on the net.
wanna try it mah, get a hang of it. see if works for my usage.

was contemplating on getting the cr10, but the really high build really need 2 z-axis lead screw.
that would require splurging on cr10s, and too expensive (for me) as a starter printer.

maybe later if i feel 220mmx220mmx250mm not enough.
*
Congrat. It is another kind of experience.

You can check out here https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/2249129


cdspins
post Aug 14 2018, 10:40 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,714 posts

Joined: May 2008


QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 7 2018, 10:48 PM)
i got it off aliexpress.
the current clamp is also available in ebay, gearbest, banggood, amazon, etc. i've posted the model before.

installed inside db because it's a current clamp, a non-intrusive to the circuit.
the sonoff uses a shunt resistor paired with a hlw8012 monitoring ic. the ic measures the current drop across the resistor.
it's an intrusive design where the line is inserted with that shunt resistor causing a voltage drop to happen across the resistor and measured by the ic.
not perfect if you consider the thermal drift on the resistor and thermal limit of the resistor with high load. but it'll work, suitable for low power devices.

the sonoff can be flashed to some other firmware that supports tweaking to the output messages, don't need to send it to sonoff server.
not well versed with sonoff since i don't use them. don't intend to use them since there's no exposed GPIO on sonoff pcb, which severely limit external sensors that be attached to the sonoff.
*
Sorry I must have miss it, I gone through previous post but cannot find the current clamp modal. Can you please let me know the modal? Or if you have the product link is also ok.
Thank you.
evangelion
post Sep 28 2018, 05:04 PM

The Ancient Ones
******
Senior Member
1,057 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 16 2014, 08:39 PM)
it's normal for contractors to ask for >RM100 for a complete build. usually RM120-RM130 psft including tile, ceiling, paint, etc.
mine at RM32 psft, but there's no roof, no windows, no doors, no bathroom utensil, no tile, no wiring.

pretty much the basic structure only. we're gonna be our own main contractor. it's DIY from start to end laugh.gif
it's a dual 15 inch ported sub tuned to 20hz. each powered by a 600w class d amp.

null because of the sub response, or amp response could be corrected. but a large null because of the room could never be corrected by a brute force solution. i (we) have experimented to correct a huge room null by giving the sub 4x the power, it only improves the response by 2db. 400% more power, only ~5% correction.
*
Bro, just wondering, will the rm120 psf include bathroom items like sink, shower head, heater, etc?

Btw congrats on ur built!!


 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.2014sec    0.30    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 25th November 2025 - 07:48 PM