QUOTE(darklight79 @ May 6 2007, 09:09 PM)
^^^^^^^^^^
I second this.
Unlimited, visualize a sculptor who wants to sculpt the perfect statue. You want to create a beautiful work of art, you need a lot of material correct? You need a lot of marble/rock/whatever. If there isn't much material/mass to begin with, what's the point of trying to sculpt something? Do you get the point?
* Btw, about the one hour thing, if I'm doing back and shoulder day, they tend to extend beyond an hour, but i try not to let it go above 1.5 hours, but i try taking in my dextrose and creatine an hour into the workout, and then my whey upon completion of the workout.
Yeah. I do understand. That's why I made this statement
I might understand your advocacy on leaving out principles no 2 & 3 in devising workout routine.
Hehe. The thing is this. How can we define having enough mass or when to start sculpting. This is highly dependent on personal discretion.
Yeah. About sculpting. Which exercise are associated with sculpting? Let me guess , sculpting exercises are associated with isolation exercises right?
For e.g:
Barbell Curls , Overhead Dumbbell Tricep Extension , Side Laterals , Back Laterals and all isolation movement.
Before we move on:
Without a single doubt, compound movement initiates the greatest amount of hypertrophy for the muscle used.
But I don't see any harm for us to incorporate some isolation movement to induce extra hypertrophy for the muscle intended
provided that no compromise in terms of poundage/emphasis was made on compound movement.
Hehe. This is how I form my logic.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
For e.g:
Body Weight Wide Grip Pull Up
PRIMARY MUSCLES used: Lats, Upper Back & Shoulders
SECONDARY MUSCLES used: Biceps, Forearms
For e.g: This exercise requires a total force exertion of 100 N . (Or simply 100 Units)
This total force exertion is shared mainly by the primary muscles while the remaining goes to the secondary muscles.
Force exerted = The amount of controlled muscle fibre tear (Hence the emphasis on poundage for hypertrophy)
As we can't be sure of the exact amount of force exerted by each muscle. It is safe for us to adopt this assumption:
A majority of the force exerted are from the PRIMARY MUSCLES.
Less force exerted by the SECONDARY MUSCLES = Less amount of controlled muscle fibre tear
Hence, ISOLATION movements are incorporated with the purpose of causing ADDITIONAL hypertrophy on the secondary muscles.
Nothing else.
Note: My logic was formed without the additional effect of poundage on CNS for hypertrophy...
As there is NO doubt that.....
The greater amount of poundage used for Compound Movement has more effect on our CNS to initiate greater amount of growth hormone which translates to greater amount of hypertrophy.
IMO, for beginners like me who are keen on piling mass , one should:
1. Put greater emphasis (in terms of poundage) on Compound movement for each session.
2. Isolation movement is all right as long as it doesn't affect the performance of compound movement.
Do correct me if I'm wrong. I learn from mistake.
This post has been edited by Unlimited: May 7 2007, 01:20 AM