QUOTE(Irhe21 @ Jan 17 2011, 12:05 AM)
Different people has different needs of their gadgets. It does not mean the iPad is a poorer choice ; just that based on my needs the SGT serves me better. The reason I bought the ipad then was for its portability and long battery life. However using it for 8 months I have found it to be a poor replacement for my mobile computing. Before buying it, I was aware of its limitations but since it was the then the best choice, I bought it. However when the latest MBA ( 11") models were released in Oct, the iPad becomes really a handicapped gadget. Since the day I bought the MBA, I had never touch it. Even my son ( a U student ) is not even interested in it - he still prefer his MBPro. Those who like games, playing with apps - the ipad is unbeatable. These is however not my interests. I was disappointed with the ipad :
1. Need to work with iTunes to sync/transfer files or use cloud services
2. Browser was hopelessly poor - I replace it with Atomic which was slightly better with tabs function. Anytime the Android browser especially Dolphin HD and XScope beats it flat ( based on my experience using these on my Dell Streak ).
3. Email header download is fast but downloading content - agonizing slow ( Yahoo, Gmail, TM ) . How slow ?? - both my Dell Streak and present SGT is almost immediate while the ipad needs to wait up to 5 to 10 secs to download full mail content. With attachments - just need to wait
4. Was initially attracted to its Magazines feature , but got tired reading it as involve too much scrolling up-down, left right and pinch to zoom. It is really a tiring task reading magazines on it - few sections is OK ; whole magazine just forget about it
5. The editing function in ipad is unbelievably ridiculous to the point i must say is " stupid". Being a not so good typist, the editing work is really frustrating
6. I cannot update my blog on the iPad as incompatible issues ( on all browsers I have tried )
I was attracted to the SGT as it was really portable and all my out of home needs is fully met with no issues ( just using it only 2 days now ). I do not faced browsing, email lag. My RSS, news feed, tweeter works superb and download speeds on the SGT is amazingly good.
So in summary which is better for you, decide based on your needs
Some negatives on the SGT I found in these 2 days:
1. The default UI is even worse than the Galaxy S ; I do not seem to hear/read of such issue. It is not smooth . Small issue - I replace it with ADW Launcher - it is now many times smoother and slick
2. Because of its 7" some apps not full screen ; easily overcome - I downloaded spare parts , run the Compatibility mode , boot it twice. Now all my apps works full screen including PaPago X5. Papago X5 however the small menu box is floating. Anyway I find using it as a GPS is too big - will still use my Streak for GPS. But is good to know Papago X5 works well on the SGT. I have read some games still cannot run fullscreen even with this tweak but is no concern to me as I dont play games on it
3. Similarly to SGS, KIES SUCKS big time. I couldn't get it connected /detected at all on Win 7 ( on my MAC) but could get it connected on my Mac OSX but only for USB mass storage - on my MacOSX I can transfer files to and fro between my MAC and the SGT internal card and external SD card. KIES was working OK only on my Windows PC ( Win XP ) but is slow