QUOTE(xcrue @ Sep 3 2009, 03:37 PM)
Im budgeting less than RM2k for the lens
Btw..what do you meat by all rounder - like 18200/18250/18270? all-in-one lens?
like this ?
All-In-One Zooms
AF18-200mm F/3.5-6.3 XR Di-II LD Aspherical (IF) Macro = RM1050
AF18-250mm F/3.5-6.3 Di-II LD Aspherical (IF) Macro = RM1640
Does it meant we can zoom and macro ?
Planning to get a std prime lens and zoom/macro kit

Actually 55-200 is not bad..still considering either 55-200 or 18-135..

1. Yes, all in one zooms would make travelling easier/lighter because you dont need to carry a lot of lenses, but the negative side is that all in one zoom lenses have reduced IQ (image quality) and do not have a fast focus lock speed.
2. DO NOT BELIEVE all the "Macro" markings on lenses like tamron and sigma. IT IS NOT A TRUE MACRO! Newbies and even some seasoned photographers that i have met are tricked into believing that their lenses with "Macro" on it can do real macro. It is just a better close up lens and that's it. A real macro lens would cost a lot more and macro lenses are basically "Prime" lenses with fixed aperture. e.g Nikon 60mm f/2.8, Nikon 105mm f/2.8 and the famous Tamron 90mm f/2.8. Real macro lenses are not zoom lenses which like the 18-200mm, 18-55mm etc.
3. For a budget of around RM1.9K you can get a 2nd hand Nikon 18-200VR f/3.5-5.6. Notice that at the tele end, 200mm that the nikon has a faster f/5.6 rather than the slow f/6.3 of Tamron & Sigma. The Sigma/Tamron 18-200mm lenses are not impressive at all as it doesnt have VR, lower IQ and slower with f/6.3 at tele end compared to Nikon 18-200mm but of course it is cheaper.
4. With a shorter zoom lens like the Nikon 18-105VR, 55-200VR and 70-300VRii you will get a higher IQ (image quality) and have a faster focus lock speed. The Nikon 18-135mm (D80 kitlens) is not that good compared to the Nikon 18-70 (D70 kitlens) & Nikon 18-105VR (D90 kitlens)
BOTTOM LINE - Decide whether you want to have versatility over IQ & focus speed OR vice versa.If you want versatility/lightweight, decide on an all in one zooms.
If you want IQ and focus speed, decide on a standard zoom.
If you want much better IQ, decide on a prime lens + a standard zoom.
Tell me what u want & i can give a much better solution.
My suggestion for now:
1. Nikon 18-105VR / Nikon 18-70 + 55-200VR (IQ Wise)
2. Sigma 18-200/18-250 HSM + Nikon 35mm f/1.8 (Versatility wise)
ps. these are some that i would recommend because of their performance and AF with bodies like D5000/D60.
Nikon AFS 55-200mm VR - RM 9xx (New) RM 6xx (2nd hand)
Nikon AFS 18-105mm VR - RM 11xx (New) RM 700-RM850 (2nd hand)
Nikon AFS 18-70mm - RM 11xx (New) RM 700 (2nd hand)
Nikon AFS 70-300mm VR - RM 19xx (New) RM 13xx-15xx (2nd hand)
Sigma 18-250mm OS HSM - RM 23xx (New)
Tamron 18-270 VC - RM 23xx (New)
Nikon 35mm f/1.8 - RM 8xx (New) - Prime lens
Tamron SP 90mm f/2.8 - RM 15xx (New) - Macro lens
This post has been edited by alpha_company: Sep 4 2009, 08:05 AM