Let's continue to blow water in the new thread..

Version 1: https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/3480656

The road from eco majestic to ecohiill 2 already opened but eco majestic do road block at eco majestic, said road construction....I heard sp Setia and eco majestic got court case on the above matter.

Yup I faced the block today as well, went to ask because VP supposed to be later this month, the staff all very evasive, giving evasive answers to a simple & direct question of whether we can get access during VP or need to drive around old town to get there...

Lol, received this right after finish posting, at 530pm long after today's event over:

RM0.00 (SEH)Due to sudden excavation works by others at the Swan roundabout, pls use Jln Semenyih to reach South Creek @ SEH2. Apologies for the inconvenience.

This post has been edited by fztt: Aug 19 2018, 06:00 PM

EM is trying to be an arsehole here. If Setia want to play an for an eye...Setia should just block the road to leading redbridge.

very good timing from EM

Many versions of stories.. No matter which version it is, residents might need to suffer!

Hows ethg over at South???

Bring the issue up to YB...apa lagi...

Personally I won't consider bringing issue to politicians unless I know the real reason for what's happening.

Because IF SP is at fault (we won't know unless they stop being evasive), I consider it a misrepresentation of facts when they sold the units hyping the masterplan & access roads. This is not a highway dependent on highway authorities' approval, this is between 2 developers & they had years to sort it out.

SP should be more upfront about the real issues instead of being evasive when asked by purchasers, which raised suspicions as to who is actually at fault, I was quite pissed at the silly grins & conversation going round&round without addressing directly why & when. They seem to be afraid of future sales being affected but not afraid of anger of current purchasers about to VP.

Very disappointing.

Surprise to hear that EM and SP will have court case given that two companies were founded by the same group of people, similar corporate culture, similar contractor as well as complementing masterplanning....

Here is the link of the court case
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&es...-bd4b2AYYDBSJpi

Based on the document you linked, court ruled in favor of SP in Jan 2018, that was many months ago... seems like EM is still ignoring court order, or is there a newer case ongoing...

think in the process of appeal to Court of Appeals, ini baru high court

yup, the Court has already made a decision in favour of SP, unless EM wants to appeal which will take some time...

Not sure why EM suddenly come up the argument that they are in custody of the aforesaid land despite they have surrendered back to the Authority...

Dismissed with cost & land oredi surrendered, ie, govt land, still want to appeal

If it's the case to unable to access the ecohill 2 from eco majestic in future and need to route big road then only can go in there. I'm will very disappointed and regret to bought the house at ecohill 2. Haizzz

Big problem! SP Setia quickly rectify this issue before vp.


Attached thumbnail(s)

Spoke to a rep from Setia and was told that they have done their part in bringing this issue to local authority and request us to do the same. So we planned to comment in all EW/EM Fb wall and write to MPK & YB.

Thanks for your hard work clarifying and acting on behalf of purchasers, Devan, I appreciate it bro

Having said that... now they said they have done their part, after the issues get highlighted here and someone produced the court document.

When I asked prior to this, they gave me vague answers and the runaround from rep to rep in their showroom.

The SMS that came on Sunday implied it was an unexpected "sudden excavation work" that leads to temporary closure, a completely misleading message when read together with the court document posted here.

In fact, on Sunday's event, they put up directional buntings all the way along the old road and none in the direction through EM, which can only mean it was definitely prepared in advance and not in response to "sudden excavation work".


So if any of SP's rep reading this: I suggest SP "help us to help you" by drafting a FB infographics highlighting the LEGAL & other FACTS so that buyers can viral it, it's better than us ranting online individually WITHOUT the full facts since you are not being upfront about it. Take responsibility. If you have nothing to hide, this is the right way to engage your buyers & supporters to win the war through social media.

This post has been edited by fztt: Aug 21 2018, 08:56 AM

Can we go in by Beranang to see the ecohill 2 house?

Yup can see from main road but cannot drive in...

Most welcome bro, you are owner for unit at SE2 also?

Yup, I queued up when they first launched to get a unit.

I hope SP is taking responsibility and realize buyers can claim misrepresentation since this issue happen before VP. It's different if we have already VP'ed, moved in and suddenly EM block the road, if that were to happen, then SP can say they help us and we also need to help highlight, but not in this scenario.

Maybe they realize it and that's why all the evasive, pusing-pusing replies given prior to this.

As buyers, we can highlight our unhappiness publicly to help draw attention to it, however, it falls on SP to deliver on what they sold, including the access road which was heavily promoted in their masterplan.

They want us to do "our part", then they need to furnish the data and the tools so that we can help THEM.

I went there exactly a week before they launched and road to SEH 2 was closed as usual. No excavation work being done at that time.

Then I came back on Sunday 19th was surprised and immediately call the office. I was told the work is being done by third party but kinda skeptical about it.

I went there on saturday afternoon to try the new road.the excavation work has already started at that time

Social media is powerful, but if the information is not handled properly, might involve legal case.

The more feasible way is to gather the buyers and form the Residents Association quickly. After that committee can lodge report to MPKJ and other associated local authorities and of course follow up closely.

The committee then can invite VIP to come over, together with the reporters, "free publicity" to the developer..

I heard some initiate the online petition, is it true?


Ultimately, this is a resident issue, developer can help but the voice from residents stands out.

Actually what is the cause for the dispute between setia and ew? sorry just I dont understand those legal terms English....

I would agree with you if this is not the very first phase and if we have already VP'ed & moved in & EM came in & block the access... in this case the road was never opened so we do not know the facts & SP is not very open about it...

... and my point exactly regarding social media power, without knowing head or tail, I will not take SP's suggestion to highlight the issue to anyone... based on what? Give us something concrete to work on...otherwise, purchasers (not residents yet) are the pingpong ball while the 2 developers are the pingpong players.

This post has been edited by fztt: Aug 21 2018, 06:24 PM

The fact is the connecting road cannot be accessed, no one can deny that. As a resident, regardless what are the reasons, you have full right to lodge complaint to authority and seek for clarifications from the parties involved.


Even Setia tell you something, it might not reflect the whole story as well, don't you think so?

We already have a WhatsApp group for SE2 owners and lot of things pertaining to this being actioned.

Yes, plan some actions collectively. Residents should take lead in this effort.

SPA does not mention it is obligation SP Setia must provide you the access road in black and white. As a matter of fact, they did provide the road, but somehow it is blocked by other party.

Respectfully, I do understand your point of view and I believe we are looking at this from very different angles, cheers.

Erm, I don't think either Setia or EW will tell you the root cause in solid manner..

That's good.
It would be much easier to discuss and get consensus from the residents for the right course of actions to be taken. Anyway, someone has to take coordinate & take lead.

Hey guys...manage to take a few shots at SEH2...
Manage to go in but got kick out by guards

Thanks for your picture.....just too bad when I open the spoiler to see the picture those pictures are unable to show....

------DELETED DUE TO DUPLICATE POST------

This post has been edited by mascot_lim: Aug 23 2018, 09:24 AM

I got some pics and really hyped about the adventure park. Might go explore the area soon!



This post has been edited by woopex_: Aug 23 2018, 09:52 AM

Heard the track is nice to trek (got short route and long route). But when reach the peak, heard no nice views such as Broga Hill..

is a very simple issue.. that road belongs to EM.. if SP wants to use this road just pay. Why shud they allow them FOC?
the matter will be resolve once SP make the payment

This post has been edited by Yukieliow: Aug 23 2018, 01:01 PM

Lol... Then Setia should charge EW for using Ecohill link 1 as well...

yea they need each other infact.. should reach to an agreement

What about the stretch between Em toll and the 2tier roundabout? The land belongs to who Ecoworld or SP? It also a road, right?



Attached thumbnail(s)

This kind of case wont be the first case and last case in Malaysia.....

Just like road closure between Sungai Long and Persiaran Mahkota Cheras.

Broga is bukit lalang. The view is just there when you reach the peak. Nothing block your view such as big tree. Unlike this, is pretty much a hutan up there. Never went up yet but as expected, not much of a view. Nevertheless is a nice and big track and can possibly drown you in your own sweat! Kudos to SP Setia!

yea that small road really important. is a big round without it

Attached thumbnail(s)

Good one Selangor state government. Take back the link road and open to the public to use.

This post has been edited by Bieco: Aug 23 2018, 07:49 PM

Look at that Majestic Swan. LOL. Well done!

any barras buyer here?..i was informed that the plan still in progress for approvall in majlis daerah..so can we proceed with loan application?

VP letter received...

did you check if got water and electricity already? because, prior to VP, this should be fixed.

huh? If u mean physically check, u can't do that until VP day, otherwise, all relevant receipts been posted to me in good order b4 the vp letter came...

because some owners sneaked in after receiving the VP letter and found no water & electricity connection.

In SPA only mention "ready for connection", not "already connected".


Normally TNB is fast, Syabas is a bit slow.. Normally within one month after VP, both should be "already connected".

thanks for the clarification bro, however the swan roundabout issue still remains....

You already signed the petition?

the one with SPS not yet, but we have already submitted our individual complain via the portal...

Good... More people send, more effective it would be. The key point is "Follow Up".. It is well known MPKJ needs to be "chased" and "pushed"...

Perhaps can call for ADUN or reporters to come to report in main stream of media as well, "free ads" for the developer...

true, are you one of the purchaser at SE2 also?

Nope, SEH 1 purchaser instead...

can i add you in our SEH2 group? it will be very helpful since you have good experience to share. can ah?

SP Setia Ecohill just put up a Ecohill 2 link opening ceremony video in FB. EM swan roundabout was blocked by the excavation works. Here opening there blocking,parties involved of blocking works really slaps the face of Setia and no respect of YB.


Attached thumbnail(s)

Boss, me blow water can lah.. But to do the work, must collectively from the SEH 2 owners and residents nia...

I'm a unit owner too. May I join?

just booked a SE2 unit

which project?

elmera, doing my loan now.

0169033320

Attached thumbnail(s)

What happened?

wow. when you took this photo?

from other source, I guess also recently. It been a month plus blocked, maybe it take months or even year to settle it. See what setia n mpkj can do about it. Ecoworld will not easily open to let the traffic flow inside eco majestic.

This is d access road tht sp setia won a court case against ew 2 get ew 2 remove d blockades?

Thinking to buy a unit of double storey terrace for investment, any feedback on this? Investment in term of capital appreciation, as I know no one will rent a house here.

Very attracted to the environment.

How much u bought?

Does anyone has the room size of the utility room 1 at ground floor for Everna/Elmera?

Hi guys, im in dilemma on whether to buy or not to buy in SEH 2 or Mainly Semenyih, for my own stay. Its only for me n my wife no kids yet. Currently staying in Wangsa Maju, will be changing to new job soon near KLIA.

We're looking at either Clarus so that we can directly move in or the Amarus for later.

Any suggestions? Recommendations, or advice.

If work in KLIA, why not consider Nilai or Sepang housing project?

Nilai and Sepang not as near to KL/PJ like Semenyih.

Semenyih nearer to KL/PJ.

Furthermore Sepang not as developed as Semenyih.

Salak Tinggi consider selangor?

all depends on budget and timing.

When starting new job? expecting kids soon? your are ready to fork out the SE2 payments? or include house furnishing budget?

If not mistaken, clarus is much more expensive.

Amarus price seems to be quite cheap. Seldom u can get a landed in township with this price

Semenyih is not developed..it is just an old town redevelop.
in nilai / sepang they are really new town

Haha...good to heard from you...I’m stay Genting Kelang quitennear Wangsa Maju...lol
I’m buyer for Banyas 2...already collected the key and planning start renovation and move in soon

Cogratulation, want to ask, I am Anicus buyer, can I go in Springfield to look see the place because now the place is guarded by security? Because Anicus still not yet complete and block by the blue zinc.

Semenyih is old. Beranang is new!

Sepang all mostly hutan.

Sepang town old timer town from those days.

any of guys have an update on the road leading to SE2? last visited 2 weeks ago is still ünder renovation".

EM is repairing the roundabout now

You mean they are repairing the road to allow access into SEH2 from the swan roundabout?

After repairs work done, access or not don’t know yet.



Attached thumbnail(s)

Thanks Bieco, you're a future owner?

Ya, Anicus.

Upper foto, exit round towards EH2
Lower foto, from EH2 entry to roundabout.


Attached thumbnail(s)

Lets see when EW will put the pavement on that part and open to public,....haha....