Wow, quite a long post, that one. But at least it has substance with a reasonable amount of evidence. Thank you for posting despite my apparent glaring mistakes.
1) Could you give me a source that says the 2G laser sensor is by Phillips? A quick google reveals nothing on that. Cause as far as I know, the 2G has a tracking speed only slightly better than 1G, though I can't seem to find the source. I also remember it stating that the 2G was not an improvement in tracking speed, only resolution. Will do a more thorough search tomorrow. Mind you, rather high speeds are easily reached on larger monitors with low-sens. And also, SteelSeries themselves admit that their optical sensors are superior to their laser ones.
2) Uhh, where did I say that the Ikari Optical can't track? My opinion was only about the Laser. If I'm wrong about that one, it's a mistake I made about the 2G laser sensor, related to the point above. Regardless, my comment was directed as his claim that the DA tracks worse than the Optical. In which case your point supports me, because all the new mice track just as well, according to you at least.
3) A certain amount. Try switching off the LED and feel the difference. It's certainly a little warm normally, but my statement was directed at an uncomfortable amount of heat, solvable by switching off the LEDs. As you mentioned, the IR sensor produces a small warm patch on the mousepad, not completely warming the mouse. So perhaps you, sir, should do a little thinking as well. And to answer your question, yes, I do study physics. IR is the lower range of the electromagnetic spectrum, on the opposite end of UV.
4) Before splashing 250 on a mouse, I'd definitely want to test it. If you'll notice, I left out most of the subjective elements of mice, including grip and feel. It was slightly uncomfortable to me, but no doubt it just takes getting used to. I was commenting on mostly objective elements, such as specs and features rather than personalised aspects. Owning the mouse is therefore irrelevant.
5) Precisely. Personal preference.
6) Again, precisely. Resolved. Question closed, no? It's a non-issue if the issue does not exist.
If you read through my posts carefully, at no point did I intend to troll or bash anyone using any products until someone came along with some rather provocative statements. I was simply searching for enlightenment on certain points which I wished to clarify, especially those that would justify the price tag. As you can see, your post is not quite killing mine, perhaps my first two were factual errors, but the remainder seemed to be more of misinterpretation and miscommunication rather than any actual error in statement.
As for mice being personal, that is absolutely true. Which is why all my points are again about objective elements rather than the subjective ones. I perfectly understand the individuality of each mouse. I should know, considering that I very much love the Razer Lachesis's much-derided shape. Thus, the arguments and points were based on specs and features, not grip and "feel". I actually believe that our points are very much in agreement, and I thank you for taking the time to make a post with actual substance rather than an uneducated one dedicated to bashing me.
edit: Come to think of it, this is precisely the sort of post I was looking for after my first post. The second post was made in a rather sour mood having been bashed by someone who is at the very least, as biased and prejudiced as he claims I am. Perhaps apologies are in order. But most importantly, I would like to make it absolutely clear that at *NO POINT* do I condemn SteelSeries or any other companies and their products. I am simply pointing out what I believe are weaknesses in their products, and if I am proven wrong, that I have no problem swallowing that pill. We all live and learn, but only through educated posts, not ones including four letter words for no apparent reason.
QUOTE(somiao5625 @ Oct 5 2008, 11:21 PM)
Wow, u made so many invalid points i dont even feel like correcting you, should just leave you as ignorent and uneducated as you are,
but for G_ken sake, being called a morons, prob me too, and every1 using steelstuff~
1) Laser skips, yeah, the first gen doest, i personally test the G5, stops traking at slightly fast movement speed, the 2nd gen you claimed thou, is no other different then your beloved razer 3rd gen, its made by the same manufacture, phillips to be exact, its called the twin-eye sensor, basically the same product in G9, ikari laser and lachesis, and they all perform up to 42cm/360, wothout neg accel or skipping or any tracking problems, but sir, who the hell play at that kind of sens? You have any idea how low is that? For example in cs, u have to swipe you mice in your mantis/everglide/goliathus, not even one full swipe in the largest mice mat can you turn over, some other people would knife you down from the back be4 you could even turn...
If you says skipping the da skips too, only after 4m/persecond, so it skips too right? But who the hell play at that sens? Its just too low~
So your argument is invalid and undoubtly stupid~
2)Esreality, yeah that famous gaming site, ah well, sujoy's review is usefull, but did you know why didn't updte the chart? 1st, his busy, 2nd, he said there is no more needs because the new generation of mices can all track at good enough speed for lowsensers~
You sir, you only know to use other sources and can't think by yourself,
is considered very ignorant and rude, by make others sound like idiots
makes you feel better?
3)Utter b$! Every IR mouse produces heat, the krait too, did u even studied physics? IR producest heat, to some extend, its not an isolated case, all da's, kraits produce a certain amount of heat, go check ur beloved esreality, some users stated it too...
Still dont trust me dont you? Good, leave ur da on ur cloth pad for some time and touch the spot u left it at, its warm!
4)No comment, except how could you not even own the mouse and says its bad? Haha...
5)Feel is a subjective term, to me, the da feels sturdier, but the side are sliperry, and its heavy, the feet is thin can small, so i prefer the ikari, but is my personal experience, there is no standard to judge the feel of a mice.
6)Yes, its all resorted, dont tell me the largest gaming gear company cant fix a flawed driver in such a long period?
Please sir, if you feel like trolling, go somewhere else, whats the point of bashing people with less knowledge on gaming gear then you? Do you really feel better because u read the esr charts and they didn't?
Get real my friend, each person's experience towards a certaint product
is different, god made no human equall, but some are certainly
dummer. ^^
Af for razer or steelseries? Which is better? Its personal judgement,
to me, i dislike the da's weight, strong button tension, and the alogarithm and correction used in the chip in order to attain the so
call good tracking speed up till 4ms, it simply felt less sensitive,
and accurate to me~ Where the ikari, felt easier to move,
more responsive and in place to me~
So? It doesnt mean ss is better? No, I just like it better!
Are razer's product bad? Nop, it is really subjective
and whats important buy what you like, dont just buy a product,
praise it to heave and condemn every one using other brands...
*Sigh* I thought a person with 3xx post might have slightly more depth...
This post has been edited by PhantomThief: Oct 6 2008, 12:25 AM