I didn't say it was a joke did I?

I only mention that I chuckled when he mention that considering I myself drive a Honda City.

Lets say that City and Vios were to sell without tax and the price ranges about the same as this sedan, which would you get? Will you still get the sedan?

Heck as for me I'll buy even two, one Vios and another City.

The built, comfort, sheer driving pleasure, performance is still by far better better compare to sedan even tho City is assembled here.

With that in mind, shouldn't we chuckle when he says this?

I agree with that. Those 3rd party manufacturer for proton really bad. No quality control from Proton side.
Proton tech might not as good as Jap car, but at least we don't hear any complain on quality issue. Like this rosak or thing no tahan lasak. Proton should control their quality first before moving to technology. Even proton can give u true lotus design enginer but lousy parts, it also back to original problem.

becoz we are malaysian and we hv mindset Japanese is superior..
If u ask ppl in Indonesia,whereby vios and city is nothing for them...the answer wud be different.. there r ppl still buying proton neo instead of Vios (same range price)

Pls provide us the sales figures of car passenger sales and models in Indonesia to justify ur claim. Maybe in afew months time we would like to see how many proton models sold in Indonesia.

This post has been edited by travis_ckf: Aug 7 2007, 09:18 PM

is it true that indonesia is selling neo more expensive than a waja?

Yup, the Proton there come with tax and duty by the Indonesian Government.

I will reserve my judgment until the car comes out, then I'll choose which one to buy. I believe the new MD has what it takes to bring Proton places. I'm very happy with my Satria Neo, first batch but no funny QC problems so far, decent performance and great handling. Definitely better than some higher-priced cars. Honestly I was expecting some Proton nightmares when the car first arrived. Fortunately, so far, owning the Satria Neo has been a memorable experience.

I won't buy one Vios and one City, that's dumb. I would buy something more worth it rather than two entry-level cars. For the price of a Vios and City combined, I'd rather get a Civic 2.0S or Hybrid instead.

Wow, so how do you know that the built, comfort, sheer driving pleasure and performance is better than the New Sedan when it's not even released yet. Amazing.

Wait till the Sedan comes out, and we'll see which one's better.

But then again, even if the Sedan does offer better performance, comfort, built and driving pleasure, would Proton bashers admit it?

I don't think so........

P/S: Don't misinterpret my post by saying that the New Sedan will pwn the City and Vios, I never said that. I just said that it's best that I reserve my judgment and take a look at all three before passing one.

This post has been edited by nerd: Aug 7 2007, 09:33 PM

flat blue

Don't get me wrong, I used to drive a proton before I can afford to get a city, but to think when the proton representative tells you that the car is designed to compete with the city and he test drove it and its a wonderful car bla bla, don't you think its pretty funny since this is all based on his individual point of view.

Perhaps it could be their (proton) vision to compete with city , vios but we would not know until we have try it now, would we?

Yeah anyhow its too early for us to judge.

to my sense...vios and city is only a little bit better than the sedan.almost the same.vios, city n gen2 hv cheap plastic looking interior.

vios/city.. simply over rated car

im looking forward to buy this car if only the interest rate is at 2% or even cheaper.. and of coz they need to change a lot of the interior design..

way overated by proton basher......

gen2 sedan really rox.

this is also overated. the car is not officially out yet. lol

lol...

anything that QC by local...there is a problem

Lol!Overrated!!!

muahahha...is simply cheap car at tax free island o..
no matter how stupid n cheap plastic it is.it still toyota/honda. better 2nd hand value..kekeke.
broken power window?? ..nahh..wear n tear mar..but door handle oso can patah.??? toy car merr??? "fong mao" ..

be a wise customer. do some homework be4 purchase something. cost for 40-50k each.. not goreng pisang
of cos if proton offer the 'real' campro .i oso consider . gen2 so nice to modd