QUOTE(Hansel @ Dec 6 2016, 03:53 PM)
Wahh, bro,... you teach in the university, is it ??
I have just two inputs :-
1) If we do your above computation before the elections on Nov 9th,.. is there a possibility that the STI would have beaten the DJIA in both of your above periods ?
2) The performance of the above indices do not take into account the dividend payouts, which are also returns. Add-in the dividend payouts and you get even bigger figures beyond the KLSE return percentages because the numbers would be compounded by the dividend earned in the foreign currencies.
If we take 8 Nov, here are the numbers :
1 year :
KLCI 1672.00 / 1663.82 = -0.49%
STI 2876.03 / 2820.24 = -1.94%
DJI 17730.51 / 18332.74 = 3.40%
MYR/SGD 3.0031 / 3.0237
MYR/USD 4.215 / 4.2017
The returns in RM terms :
KLCI -0.49%
STI -1.27%
DJIA 3.07%
5 year :
KLCI 1460.13 / 1663.82 = 13.95%
STI 2694.60 / 2820.24 = 4.66%
DJIA 12184.26 / 18332.74 = 50.46%
MYR/SGD 2.4344 / 3.0237
MYR/USD 3.1475 / 4.2017
The returns in RM terms :
KLCI 13.95%
STI 30.00%
DJIA 100.86%
1. DJI climbed close to 1000 points since election. STI climbed close to 150 points. While KLCI dropped close to 20 poiints.
2. Agreed. The returns from dividend will be more in forex since RM lao sai in 2015
Conclusion : for the recent years, long term investment in STI and DJIA is better than KLCI mainly because of RM devaluation. Gains in KLCI is offset by the lost in RM value. KLCI is not a good hedge against inflation compare to investing overseas in forex dollars