Axia chassis is one decade newer than Myvi. That is why it handles better and the interior is similar in size. Only the 1KR-VE 67hp engine is lacking unless u turbo it becomes 1KR-VET to 97hp found in Ativa

This pix is Myvi.

Together w Axia, Viva and your kancil.. all milo tin.

Better u go for stronger Proton

Alza and Veloz is basically the same car but u pay extra 20k for a little extra fittings and gadgets.
It does have 3 rows of seats though hence can still sit 5 with the last row folded for 500 liters of cargo space.

XV or HRV is in a different league altogether, they are much better built, more robust and can cruise above highway speed limit comfortably fully loaded (eg hrv 140hp vs alza 105hp). But with smaller boot space.

Their maintenance is definitely more than the cheaper Perodua and especially when they start to age approaching 10 years old, replacing major parts will cost more.

However if you can set aside a few K yearly in anticipation of major component replacements, the Subaru and Honda will definitely be nicer to drive.

Agree w Amscouzach, if you are inexperience, better get new for much increased reliability.

Go test drive both Axia and Saga. Decide on which models (and variants) suit u better. And forget about Bezza, worst handling car in MY

There are only 6 sedans within 85K range.
Saga, Persona, Bezza
Vios, City, Almera.

Protons are eliminated due to less than excellent fuel economy.
Bezza should be thrown out too for poor handling undermining safety unless u drive below legal speed limit always

Therefore just go test-drive the 3 Japanese models see which one feels better. Note Vios new model launching in Thailand.and may arrive here next year.

Looking for reliable car, proceed to list 2nd hand Koreans & Volkswagon? A new car will always offer higher reliability.

Since you need good comfort to travel long distance, the Persona has the most comfortable seats and is the best handling sedan below 100K. The new standard variant at 45K cannot fold back seat though.

This post has been edited by dogbert_chew: Aug 2 2022, 09:23 PM

If you already decided on Vios and need help deciding which variant to book, the Vios thread in Car Clubs might get u more details

https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4358245

Stuff such as new Vios just launched in Thailand and presumely coming to MY next year should be in your radar as well. Either aiming for new model or squeezing your SA for substantial discount for the current one..

Some generic feedback for new models up to 50K

Perodua - good FC, resale, safety gadgets
Axia - new model expected 2023
Bezza - super bad handling
Myvi - ubiquitous

Proton - good handling, comfort, stronger bodyframe
Saga - entry level sedan. Cos bezza handling really cannot
Iriz - 1.3 underpowered at this max pricing
Persona - comfortable long distance tourer, big boot

Most important consideration - test drive.

If losing income is the main issue,
Perhaps try posting in Jobs& careers see any feedback.
Either look to move internally within the company to more secure position or find another company since current one shaky already.

Back to Forester, how much can get if sell next year? Cos if you book new car now still have waiting list. If it is a pure financial decision, how about sell now and get a cheap second hand car?

First 2 choices seems can manage.
Mazda 3 need to set aside maintenance & repair fund (Total.Cost of Ownership over say 7-8 years and not just purchase price only)

Civic / Altis .see if u got interest.. then can explore..

If you have some experience dealing with mechanics, knowledge of certain models their pros and cons eg City and can set aside higher maintenance and repair bills for say 7-8 years of ownership, then used Japanese models offer better value for money.

If first time car owner, haven't got a clue what function of parts when looking into engine bay and no budget for repairs first few years of ownership, then better buy new car w warranty.

Btw, if u looking at Myvi 1.3.. Suggest add 2K extra for
1.5 engine more power
15" rims handle better
Auto headlamps
Steering audio control
Folding wing mirrors
Hillstart assist
Higher resale value

Have you made a decision?

Relooked at your situation and notice that X50 Exec at 94K is going to stretch your 1K monthly commitment for loan (assumed), petrol wear& tear, maintenance to the max.

If considering SUV, perhaps the Ativa H at 66K might be much more comfortable financially.

Else your friends Mazda3 (after trusted mechanic check through for parts to repair, replace) will offer the most comfortable drive.

Nice car. Long distance travel shouldn't be a problem once you get it into tiptop condition. Will let mini owners comment on how and the pricing.

My old Pug experience tells me 3 things
a. Gotta have a standby car
b. Good mechanic who is really otai w your model
c. Cannot be OCD.. If it fails it fails.

Unless the car really in bad shape needing major repairs, i think regular care (& budget) should suffice to keep it in good running condition. Do a thorough check w your future mini mechanic if possible.

One of /K golden rule.. Happy wife, happy life

I would take sedan over SUV for handling anytime.
Only because my regular route has a bit of unpaved roads, large potholes, feel more secure using a vehicle with higher ground clearance (lets call it crossover rather than SUV) and 5 doors for easier goods loading. So if u don't need these qualities, sedan will handle better.

As for Japanese brands, my experience Toyota still better than Honda for reliability although my main drive today is a 2016 HRV which i bought last year cos i wanted its proven 1.8l NA engine before it disappeared.

Got 3 friends driving X50 past 12 months no issue at all. But if you're aiming for this, be prepared to get it in 2024 or close to it.

OK my bad. Im still stuck in pre SST timeframe. Good that u can get the X50 earlier.

HRV is a super smooth cruiser 140kmh at 2500rpm with slick CVT calibration. Its 140hp 170Nm pulling 1250kg provides quick enough acceleration for city drives too. I get around 13kml for pure city and 16+ for fast highway journeys. Been faultless after 1.5 years. Drives much better than my kid Ativa.

New SUV (and MPV) <100K budget and their ground clearance (which might or might not translate into 'high riding' car. Do test drive)

X50 Exec 180mm
Veloz 190mm
Ativa 200mm
X70 Std 200mm
Xpander 205mm
BRV 220mm
Aruz 220mm

Let others comment for Used vehicles,
And your 1K/monthly meaning possibly a 9yr loan ? Ouch.

Axia new model launching next year.
Really need to get current model now?

Wow, in that case can book now possibly get new model next year?