QUOTE(max_cavalera @ Jun 7 2016, 12:29 AM)
Guys can i get some of ur experienced opinion:
Me and my wife invest long term to kenanga growth fund investment using our epf, im around 6k and my wife around 14k...
top up every 3 month...recently they distribute dividend/income...yeah i understand u guys said not much difference if undistribute the nav stays high...
But i look this at different point of view, its like they help us DCA the distribution by buying back the fund at cheaper NAV price....and over the long term would this benefit in our favour or to u guys it doesnt make any difference at all?
Let’s say the shop sells this 1 particular pizza, 6 inch. They usually cut it into 4 pieces and you buy 2 pieces @ RM0.80 per piece. Then on a separate day, they still sell this same 1 pizza, 6 inch. But they cut it into 8 pieces and you have to buy 4 pieces @ RM0.40 per piece so that you have the same amount of food.
What the fund house is doing is, they are cutting it into 8 pieces, giving you 4 instead of cutting it 4 pieces and giving you 2. Any difference? No. At the end of the day, to get the same amount of food, you paid RM1.60 for the pizza. Does it matter whether it is RM1.60 for 2 pieces or RM1.60 for 4 smaller pieces. No? Why? Because you get the same amount food.
Now put it in a numerical example.
2015, You bought this fund at RM0.85 for 3000 units = RM 2,550
2016, the current price of this fund is RM0.95 and you still have 3000 units = RM2,850
Now the next day, this fund has a distribution of RM0.05, so you will get RM150. So this RM150 will be used to buy the fund at RM0.90 (assuming no change of the asset value), hence you get 166.67 units.
So after distribution, you have 3166.67 units at RM0.90 = surprise, surprise RM2,850.
Conclusion:
1) yes, you have more units at the end of the day but it’s not units we are looking at, it is the investment fund value that we are interested in, ie I want it to grow beyond the RM2,850. Similarly, we want a bigger pizza, not the same pizza being cut into more pieces.
2) yes, they use back your money buy units at a lower price, please go back to the pizza example. Hence no difference.
3) in the long term, there’s no difference as long as your fund is growing and growing.
I repeat using different numbers, what is the difference of holding 1000 units of RM0.80 and 1600 units of RM0.50 when the money value is what you get eventually?