QUOTE(waja2000 @ Feb 18 2015, 09:55 AM)
your just see too suface thing....
well radar not only see size, also how good is Rx/Tx module, what is power of each module. how good is on board computer process.
for BVR .... no need much maneuver, only alot maneuver in dogfight, and too sample to said Rafale will loose, AIM-120C7 is 120km range, but it have to fire at 70km max because you attack target will run also, that jet not waiting there at 120km waiting you to shoot. at fire missile more than 70km range successfull hit rate only at 40%. 100km just less than 20%. and 120km just base on strait line range. so went both jet close betwwen 50-90km, is up to who get the position to fire the missile first. pilot skill and experience, how good pilot interactive with fighter also very importance.
and F16E APG-80 no better than RBE-2AA actually, mostly about same. and for Rafale/EF2000 soon will come with Meteor BVRAAM.
Other han that, our RMAF event can't get AIM-C7,only C5 we get. if we get F18, hopefully get C7, if not point get F18EF.
and nowdays jet figther also include IRST sensor to track target and fire missile, not necessary radar will turn ON. depend situation.
ground attack just Rafale best capability. it have 14 hardpoint and 9 tons+ payload. more hardpoint/payload than than F18EF, at lease capability on pair with F18EF. both no issue on Close Air Support mission.
When Amraam gets decreased effective range against agile fast fighters, the MICA too had the same range reduction. Check Falklands war, the British Harriers scored most of the air to air kills with Aim-9L (first all aspect IR guided) engaging Argentine mirages, etendards, skyhawks head on catching them by surprise as the argentineans were expecting to get by pass and dogfight.
Americans had more experience in detecting incoming missiles that they came up with radar incorporated RWR system. So aere the Russians who claimed their PESA has ability to track and shoot down air to air & SAM missiles like in stealth movie.
I would love to have russian and american fighters. The americans have buy back plan like car trade in if you bought from same manufacturer such as Boeing. RMAF could trade in their existing F/A-18D fleet for F/A-18F paying the remaining cash. Only downside of buying americans is lots of political rules to obey. French, brits, russians no trade in, have to sell at mudah 2nd hand.