QUOTE(paskal @ Jun 17 2014, 10:14 PM)
read below your posts and finally understood when you typed 6w. you corroborate my findings. the AC-DC converter that the LED lights are using have pretty low efficiency. surprising really, because yours are from CREE themselves.
ROI using the default led driver is just too long for me. i never believe electronics will last more than a couple of years, especially switching circuits. 5-6 years is just too long.
tho LEDs have a few important advantages that CFL could never provide. most important for me is:
1) heat dissipation to the backside of the case, which is to the ceiling.
2) can be powered by DC power using backup battery in case power failure.
best setup IMO is to isolate the DC conversion and current limit (led driver). use a high efficiency SMPS to convert to DC, then use a separate current limiter to drive the LED. you could use multiple LED per driver but there's a few downside.
upside:
- should provide higher efficiency as the current limiter is rated for ~97% efficiency, SMPS rating above 85%.
- cheaper maintenance cost since the smps and current limiter is isolated. replace just the problematic item.
- easily retrofitted to run from battery power for backup lights.
downside:
- switches will be handling DC. arching could destroy the switches in the long term.
- multiple equipment to maintain.
another easier setup is as you explained. using multiple LEDs wired in series to a single driver.
upside:
- cheaper initial cost. cheaper to modify existing wiring.
- easier to maintain. driver could be placed in easy to access area and since the LED itself are hard to spoil it's shorter downtime.
downside:
- higher replacement cost. single high power driver will cost more compared to either smps or current limiter.
- most led driver (integrated driver with smps and current limiter) have higher efficiency if nearly fully loaded. so it's gonna be hard to maintain high efficiency throughout the entire house.
have you considered building your own LED downlights?
i can't seem to find any supplier in ebay or aliexpress selling just the LED downlight case/housing. epistar 1w and 0.5w SMD LEDs are selling quite cheaply on the net. it's gonna be easy to hit 100 lumen/DC watt (or more) if we build the LED ourselves.
pair it with some cheap, high efficiency driver and string a couple of them together, it's gonna hit 90 lumens/watt or more on AC.
anyway for my garden lights, wall lights and flood lights, i'm gonna feed them DC directly (with or without current limiter) and build my own LED string. i've already bought the cases for the garden and wall lights so it's do or die.
The plan still at my drawing board. Having a led downlight for the whole house is expensive with the unreliable product. I once ask locally what is the price of the led downlight without the driver. Some show suprise face and some told me no warranty. ROI using the default led driver is just too long for me. i never believe electronics will last more than a couple of years, especially switching circuits. 5-6 years is just too long.
tho LEDs have a few important advantages that CFL could never provide. most important for me is:
1) heat dissipation to the backside of the case, which is to the ceiling.
2) can be powered by DC power using backup battery in case power failure.
best setup IMO is to isolate the DC conversion and current limit (led driver). use a high efficiency SMPS to convert to DC, then use a separate current limiter to drive the LED. you could use multiple LED per driver but there's a few downside.
upside:
- should provide higher efficiency as the current limiter is rated for ~97% efficiency, SMPS rating above 85%.
- cheaper maintenance cost since the smps and current limiter is isolated. replace just the problematic item.
- easily retrofitted to run from battery power for backup lights.
downside:
- switches will be handling DC. arching could destroy the switches in the long term.
- multiple equipment to maintain.
another easier setup is as you explained. using multiple LEDs wired in series to a single driver.
upside:
- cheaper initial cost. cheaper to modify existing wiring.
- easier to maintain. driver could be placed in easy to access area and since the LED itself are hard to spoil it's shorter downtime.
downside:
- higher replacement cost. single high power driver will cost more compared to either smps or current limiter.
- most led driver (integrated driver with smps and current limiter) have higher efficiency if nearly fully loaded. so it's gonna be hard to maintain high efficiency throughout the entire house.
have you considered building your own LED downlights?
i can't seem to find any supplier in ebay or aliexpress selling just the LED downlight case/housing. epistar 1w and 0.5w SMD LEDs are selling quite cheaply on the net. it's gonna be easy to hit 100 lumen/DC watt (or more) if we build the LED ourselves.
pair it with some cheap, high efficiency driver and string a couple of them together, it's gonna hit 90 lumens/watt or more on AC.
anyway for my garden lights, wall lights and flood lights, i'm gonna feed them DC directly (with or without current limiter) and build my own LED string. i've already bought the cases for the garden and wall lights so it's do or die.
Jun 21 2014, 08:23 AM

Quote












0.0326sec
0.27
6 queries
GZIP Disabled