Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

141 Pages « < 2 3 4 5 6 > » Bottom

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Discussion about watercooling and the results, Version 2

views
     
PeowYong
post Aug 13 2005, 11:43 PM

PeowYong
*******
Senior Member
2,263 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: MMU Cyberjaya, Sandakan



QUOTE(ernie ball @ Aug 11 2005, 09:10 AM)
Em, i'm new to water cooling, so i really need something simple,and works well. Recently i have a bit of extra cash to spare, so i contemplated to buy either a CoolerMaster Mini Aquagate or Bigwater 12cm (i can only find non-SE model atm). Or i could also choose a Tt Big Typhoon (read about the great performance).

But i found one disturbing news from lyn, the Tt bigwater non-SE had a high RMA rate because of pump failure. The contrasting fact is many Bigwater users swear by bigwater. May i have a confirmation on this?

About Mini Aquagate 12cm model, i did google around, but all i could find is  very biased reviews, most of which compares the performance of Aquagate to very outdated heatsinks or even stock heatsinks (who use stock anyway). The same case applies to Bigwater. And most importantly, i didn't find a review done by the more reputable websites (overclockers.com or tomshardware.com)

What is better, aquagate or bigwater? Since the price is so similar. Or should i not get a water cooling at all? I'm currently using CAK4-88t, i swapped the fan  for 3 bladed Tt at very low fan speed for quieter pc. The temp i got is mere 37c web surfing and 42-43c full load. Before you complain my temp is inaccurate, please take note, i heavily underclocked my processor and it only throttle to full speed in heavy load conditions. Even at full speed the Vcore is only 1.375v-~40w max heat dissipation. Even the passively cooled CM NB cooler (Zalman clone) and my fancooled WD hdd  is much hotter than the heatsink.

I really need a honest review, aside from the fanboyish review and the biased review of the unreputable websites. I'm sorry if i threaded on anyone's foot.

Please advise.
*
Bigwater non-se have pump failure problem??
is it true?? luckily i have no problem with it... sweat.gif

if u r free enough to change water regularly, u may try using a watercooling kit... if not, u better stick with air cooling....
kelvin_hata
post Aug 14 2005, 03:02 AM

V.S.O.P
*******
Senior Member
2,696 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Butterworth,Penang Status: Available

QUOTE(PeowYong @ Aug 13 2005, 11:43 PM)
Bigwater non-se have pump failure problem??
is it true?? luckily i have no problem with it...  sweat.gif

if u r free enough to change water regularly, u may try using a watercooling kit... if not, u better stick with air cooling....
*
lol...air besar running in my barton system 24/7
no problem til 3month.... laugh.gif
ianho
post Aug 14 2005, 03:06 AM

Cucimangkoklife
Group Icon
VIP
15,705 posts

Joined: Mar 2005
From: Tg. Rambutan
QUOTE(kelvin_hata @ Aug 14 2005, 03:02 AM)
lol...air besar running in my barton system 24/7
no problem til 3month.... laugh.gif
*
Just make sure ure Airbesar don't actually buang airbesar on ure rig. Hahahahahaa.
irenic
post Aug 14 2005, 04:51 PM

extr3me n3wbie
*******
Senior Member
7,338 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Cybercity of Cyberjaya


QUOTE(almostthere @ Aug 11 2005, 10:03 PM)
Not to mention all these custom made systems are of 1/2 OD/ID which is still the recommended size compared to Tt's 3/8"
*
QUOTE(ianho @ Aug 13 2005, 05:24 PM)
The TT Airbesar is not even running 3/8 ID hose man. The hose is thin like a pencil.
*
dont kutuk 3/8" tubing size la.. laugh.gif my asetek waterchill also use that size but perform better than some pre made wc kit with 1/2" tube tongue.gif

tt airbesar use 1/4" if i not mistaken...

This post has been edited by irenic: Aug 14 2005, 04:53 PM
almostthere
post Aug 14 2005, 06:00 PM

Kepala abah ko
Group Icon
VIP
3,773 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Anywhere lah...as long got Kopi-O



QUOTE(irenic @ Aug 14 2005, 04:51 PM)
dont kutuk 3/8" tubing size la.. laugh.gif my asetek waterchill also use that size but perform better than some  pre made wc kit with 1/2" tube   tongue.gif

tt airbesar use 1/4" if i not mistaken...
*
Ok, I'm corrected over that matter. And yes, 3/8" not bad also. In fact the Europeans prefer to use that as it's a good compromise between flow rate restriction and airflow restriction if based on what I've seen so far actually. However, Cathar in Xtreme has recommended a new type of tubing which I'm not pretty clear about which is about 3/8" ID but has some property's similiar to TYgon's and has rather a smooth inner wall surface. But I'd bet that sort of tubing would cost a bomb

And ianho, I'd suggest you have a look at these charts

user posted image

user posted image

user posted image
irenic
post Aug 14 2005, 07:59 PM

extr3me n3wbie
*******
Senior Member
7,338 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Cybercity of Cyberjaya


QUOTE(almostthere @ Aug 14 2005, 06:00 PM)
Ok, I'm corrected over that matter. And yes, 3/8" not bad also. In fact the Europeans prefer to use that as it's a good compromise between flow rate restriction and airflow restriction if based on what I've seen so far actually. However, Cathar in Xtreme has recommended a new type of tubing which I'm not pretty clear about which is about 3/8" ID but has some property's similiar to TYgon's and has rather a smooth inner wall surface. But I'd bet that sort of tubing would cost a bomb

And ianho, I'd suggest you have a look at these charts

user posted image

user posted image

user posted image
*
thx for da info.. how bout hydor L35? i just thinking to buy that pump to replace my hydor L20..
almostthere
post Aug 14 2005, 08:26 PM

Kepala abah ko
Group Icon
VIP
3,773 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Anywhere lah...as long got Kopi-O



QUOTE(irenic @ Aug 14 2005, 07:59 PM)
thx for da info.. how bout hydor L35? i just thinking to buy that pump to replace my hydor L20..
*
Hydor L35? Hmmm....I'd be very careful in choosing that as the heat dump from the pump itself (Going by the known feedback of the Nirox P5800..I think cos allngap used it to test his WC kit) is quite a fair amount and would be of major consideration before trying it

For a second opinion, have a look at this topic at xtreme by Maxxracer about pumps

http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=41495
irenic
post Aug 15 2005, 01:29 AM

extr3me n3wbie
*******
Senior Member
7,338 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Cybercity of Cyberjaya


QUOTE(almostthere @ Aug 14 2005, 08:26 PM)
Hydor L35? Hmmm....I'd be very careful in choosing that as the heat dump from the pump itself (Going by the known feedback of the Nirox P5800..I think cos allngap used it to test his WC kit) is quite a fair amount and would be of major consideration before trying it

For a second opinion, have a look at this topic at xtreme by Maxxracer about pumps

http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=41495
*
how bout if i blow a fan direct to the pump?
almostthere
post Aug 15 2005, 01:51 AM

Kepala abah ko
Group Icon
VIP
3,773 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Anywhere lah...as long got Kopi-O



QUOTE(irenic @ Aug 15 2005, 01:29 AM)
how bout if i blow a fan direct to the pump?
*
The question is how much the water is heated up by the pump when at normal operation speeds. The pump's heat as in physically can be solved but as to the introduction of that heat into the loop is another.
irenic
post Aug 15 2005, 02:18 AM

extr3me n3wbie
*******
Senior Member
7,338 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Cybercity of Cyberjaya


QUOTE(almostthere @ Aug 15 2005, 01:51 AM)
The question is how much the water is heated up by the pump when at normal operation speeds. The pump's heat as in physically can be solved but as to the introduction of that heat into the loop is another.
*
owh ic.. hmm

btw i cant open the link u gave above..

and i have a problem which is totally out of topic, but i hope i can asked from help from any of u guys here since this is one the 'still' active topic for tonite..

i just bought a thermaltake aquabay mr1 coz i like it looks, so after installing the tube, i decided to run a leak test for several hours. since all the waterblock is inside the pc, and i was lazy to remove them, i short my psu 24pin cable (pin 13 n 14) but i forgot to unplug molex for other hardware. then i ran it and after an hour no problem occurred. so i switch off my psu then a 'pop' sound heard.. i feel worried so i switched on my psu again n my psu kaboom and smoke came out from it cry.gif
then i went to see dinster to borrow his psu (thx alot to him), and i quickly connect ONLY gfx, harddisk, watercooling pump and motherboard to the psu. all other things (ccfl, casing fan, optical drive) are still connected to my kaboom psu.

then i switch on my using dinster's psu and everything runs fine.. but the weird thing is, the ccfl, casing fan, optical drive, all run like usual.. like there is power connect to them unsure.gif sweat.gif why ek? huhu
almostthere
post Aug 15 2005, 06:01 AM

Kepala abah ko
Group Icon
VIP
3,773 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Anywhere lah...as long got Kopi-O



QUOTE(irenic @ Aug 15 2005, 02:18 AM)
owh ic.. hmm

btw i cant open the link u gave above..

and i have a problem which is totally out of topic, but i hope i can asked from help from any of u guys here since this is one the 'still' active topic for tonite..

i just bought a thermaltake aquabay mr1 coz i like it looks, so after installing the tube, i decided to run a leak test for several hours. since all the waterblock is inside the pc, and i was lazy to remove them, i short my psu 24pin cable (pin 13 n 14) but i forgot to unplug molex for other hardware. then i ran it and after an hour no problem occurred. so i switch off my psu then a 'pop' sound heard.. i feel worried so i switched on my psu again n my psu kaboom and smoke came out from it  cry.gif
then i went to see dinster to borrow his psu (thx alot to him), and i quickly connect ONLY gfx, harddisk, watercooling pump and motherboard to the psu. all other things (ccfl, casing fan, optical drive) are still connected to my kaboom psu.

then i switch on my using dinster's psu and everything runs fine.. but the weird thing is, the ccfl, casing fan, optical drive, all run like usual.. like there is power connect to them  unsure.gif  sweat.gif  why ek? huhu
*
OK, one time only OT reply, it's possible that the 12v and the 5v rails are still unharmed but it's possible that the 3.3v is a goner or one or a few pins of the 24 pin molexed blew edi. You have to narrow down the possible damages using a DMM

ernie ball
post Aug 19 2005, 02:02 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
459 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: The right side of wrong


Hello, i'm back.For those asking bout where i heard the high failure rate of Bigwater's pump, i read it from the OCParadise's forum. Since i got here, i'm willing to share something with you all.

Actually i'm one of those early users of water cooling, remenber Senfu? I used their first WC kit, but before that, i've made my own waterblock, fashioned from a couple of 1cm ID copper tubing. It's quite effective, could reduce the temp of stock K6-2 usual hsf ( who care about their hsf those days?) by more than 9c. That time i'm in secondary school, and together with a few friends, we displayed the homemade cooling at our science fair. Needless to say, most visitor didn't even knew we need a fan to cool our processor. Back then radiator is unnecessary, you could run the water off a bucket and the water will only get slightly warm after half days of gaming (half-life and counter-strike) Ah, those good old days, where processors were so cool....

Anyway, i quit using Watercooling after buying the Senfu because it scuks big time. If there's a worst industrial design award, Senfu WC Kit will be the first prize award. Imagine using a aluminium base, copper fin water block. The waterblock literally corrodes itself away, and not to mention the terrible cooling temp. My homemade copper piping waterblock is much better at cooling than the senfu waterblock. Finally i stop using it and replace my cooler to aircooling, my first cooler is Volcano 7+, cooling is good but the noise is terrible. I sold the cooler after 1 week, and had been using a Globalwin CaK4-88t until now, occasionally buying new fans, currently using Volcano12 extreme fan, because the Globalwin heatsink is still better than the Volcano12 heatsink. Imagine the heatsink cycled through the 4 complete pc upgrades i did in the past 2 years!!

Since i'd used the Globalwin for so long, i'm itchy to get a new cooler again. So, not willing to repeat the experience i've had with Senfu, i'm really pushing reliability as the main factor when i want to choose a cooler.

I think most people will switch back to aircooling after they grow out of their overclocking sickness, until watercooling had more to offer for their reliability and price.

P/s: I still have the Senfu waterblock with me, anyone willing to buy it for their pc museum? whistling.gif

This post has been edited by ernie ball: Aug 19 2005, 02:04 PM
almostthere
post Aug 22 2005, 02:20 PM

Kepala abah ko
Group Icon
VIP
3,773 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Anywhere lah...as long got Kopi-O



That depends on how commited one can be to the concept of WC'ing. Reliabillity, availabillity , and the abundance of users being able to share their experiences have made more and more users stay onto WC'ing even the compliacations arise as there's always someone willing to help to keep our addiction strong.n Speaking of addiction, I wish dinster's supplier wasn't such an a$$ and get those Storm G4's shipped ASAP
hmspower
post Aug 23 2005, 10:09 AM

Feel The POWWAHHH!!!
******
Senior Member
1,009 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: the bottom of my heart.. LOL



guys guys guys....

check this out: http://www.overclockers.com/tips1211/

the system got no pump!
use tec summore shocking.gif

is it just based on the concept that hot water go up, cold water go down?
PeowYong
post Aug 23 2005, 11:57 AM

PeowYong
*******
Senior Member
2,263 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: MMU Cyberjaya, Sandakan



interesting....
thought about that before(without pump) but without the tec...
evildonkey
post Aug 23 2005, 10:31 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
541 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: peejay


the thermosyphon is indeed interesting but the only problem is on how to suck out all the air inside and make it airtight.
PeowYong
post Aug 24 2005, 01:24 AM

PeowYong
*******
Senior Member
2,263 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: MMU Cyberjaya, Sandakan



hm.... seems like have to soak the whole unit into a big pail of coolant and run the pump and everything inside the coolant then remove the pump and connect back the tube after all the air is gone

sounds silly but thats wut i think how it will work....

mADmAN
post Aug 24 2005, 06:15 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
10,530 posts

Joined: Nov 2004
From: Petaling Jaya & Mid Valley


hey....anyone has any info on the vantec WC kit? price? availability? and most importantly reviews?

http://www.vantecusa.com/products/stg100/p_stg100.html
sniper on the roof
post Aug 24 2005, 06:18 PM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
VIP
23,414 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Taipei
Bosses.... apa bikin?

The vantec look quite cantik at first glance leh. Scary part is just alu rad + copper block only.
almostthere
post Aug 24 2005, 07:48 PM

Kepala abah ko
Group Icon
VIP
3,773 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Anywhere lah...as long got Kopi-O



Senang cerita, wait for online reviews or from someone who's using it since right now, not much info on it, no pics of the blocks design and the pumps a Hydor L20

141 Pages « < 2 3 4 5 6 > » Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0270sec    0.42    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 11th December 2025 - 06:39 PM