QUOTE(sulifeisgreat @ Oct 10 2010, 09:23 PM)
I have read up on value investing, wb & FA stuff. but is graham as rich as wb?
more likely wb was at the right place & at the right time, something like li ka shing
otherwise, all of graham followers occupy the forbes top 100 rich list
do u even follow wb method 100% or r u just cherry picking?
furthermore, y dun u just follow what he buys & maybe can be the top 2 richest also
instead of reinventing the wheel & putting wb concept into bolehland context, it does save the work & hassle just to follow wb
doesn't want to set aside the collateral, and wants existing derivatives contracts to be exempted from the rules.
http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Inves...px?post=1747221
he states that his favorite holding period is forever
http://www.fool.com/investing/value/2010/0...fett-sells.aspx
wb does buy & sell, he does not keep EVERYTHING long term, remember ptr?
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Warren-Buffe...104421.html?x=0
anyway, I not here to start a topic on criticizing wb! just that some of his followers r hypocrites, only follow certain things abt wb & not follow in full
I do not take things at face value after staying in bolehland for so long. if govt says vote bn is good for rakyat, do u do / dun agree?
I read those anti wb to get a better perspective on investment & trading, which leads me to TA & etc
for bolehland, I just buy & hold those 1st liner & good track record unit trust. I dun trade much in bolehland
there are topics on securities, properties, unit trusts/mutual funds and fixed deposit, if someone would just use the search function
well, u can help those newbies out by showing them the way how u tackle this topic & get this topic back in track
As I noticed someone is trying to over-emphasis on TA, so I brought Warren Buffet as one of the FA type to neutralise the investment style. Whether anyone should have agreed how Warren Buffet works his way out base on Graham's theories or any other investment guru such as philip fisher, it is always up to them to find out the topics instead of some one is trying to sell something too hard over here.more likely wb was at the right place & at the right time, something like li ka shing
otherwise, all of graham followers occupy the forbes top 100 rich list
do u even follow wb method 100% or r u just cherry picking?
furthermore, y dun u just follow what he buys & maybe can be the top 2 richest also
instead of reinventing the wheel & putting wb concept into bolehland context, it does save the work & hassle just to follow wb
doesn't want to set aside the collateral, and wants existing derivatives contracts to be exempted from the rules.
http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Inves...px?post=1747221
he states that his favorite holding period is forever
http://www.fool.com/investing/value/2010/0...fett-sells.aspx
wb does buy & sell, he does not keep EVERYTHING long term, remember ptr?
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Warren-Buffe...104421.html?x=0
anyway, I not here to start a topic on criticizing wb! just that some of his followers r hypocrites, only follow certain things abt wb & not follow in full
I do not take things at face value after staying in bolehland for so long. if govt says vote bn is good for rakyat, do u do / dun agree?
I read those anti wb to get a better perspective on investment & trading, which leads me to TA & etc
for bolehland, I just buy & hold those 1st liner & good track record unit trust. I dun trade much in bolehland
there are topics on securities, properties, unit trusts/mutual funds and fixed deposit, if someone would just use the search function
well, u can help those newbies out by showing them the way how u tackle this topic & get this topic back in track
Added on October 11, 2010, 12:46 am
QUOTE(buylowsellhigh @ Oct 10 2010, 09:45 PM)
I didn't realise how hot this topic can be. How did we get sidetrack into TA huh? hehe..
Anyway, not to say whose right and wrong, just to sum it up, when it comes to personal financial management, different people have different knowledge, experience, perception, style, personality, etc. I guess what is right for someone may not be right for others. And it shows in this thread. There are some basic principles that applies to all but the approcah can still vary.
Some prefer Fundamental Analysis, some Technical Analysis, it is indeed part of financial management. And I guess there are very few who have spent years and years trying both and are qualified to judge both. I am definitely not one of those, so I reserve any criticism on Fundamental Analysis.
I guess I was seen as coming off too strong initially, such that it triggered quite some reaction, my apology. At the same time, ithe discussion has given me some important points I need for my presentation, thank you.
I welcome further enquiry as some of you have done through emails or even open minded discussion. I do appreciate that.
I look forward to participate in more open minded discussion.
I'm not sure if the discussion is leading to a genuine one. I always noticed some one who is promoting something too hard in the forum (not only this forum, any other forums that I been also caught in this kind of promotion).Anyway, not to say whose right and wrong, just to sum it up, when it comes to personal financial management, different people have different knowledge, experience, perception, style, personality, etc. I guess what is right for someone may not be right for others. And it shows in this thread. There are some basic principles that applies to all but the approcah can still vary.
Some prefer Fundamental Analysis, some Technical Analysis, it is indeed part of financial management. And I guess there are very few who have spent years and years trying both and are qualified to judge both. I am definitely not one of those, so I reserve any criticism on Fundamental Analysis.
I guess I was seen as coming off too strong initially, such that it triggered quite some reaction, my apology. At the same time, ithe discussion has given me some important points I need for my presentation, thank you.
I welcome further enquiry as some of you have done through emails or even open minded discussion. I do appreciate that.
I look forward to participate in more open minded discussion.
For example when one is promoting TA analysis, and some forumers who are interesting would post more queries and they would be told to PM or email. Then the forumers would be told in the PM or email to buy a TA software with a cost of few thousand Ringgit. Or those who are interested about the timing strategy and they are led to the direction that it is a good timing to buy. When the forumers ask what to buy since it is good time to buy, they were told "buy Public XXX Fund lah, PM I will help you this". Don't you smell something fishy over here?
This post has been edited by kinwing: Oct 11 2010, 12:46 AM
Oct 11 2010, 12:37 AM

Quote
0.0240sec
0.43
6 queries
GZIP Disabled