QUOTE(defaultname365 @ Jun 16 2012, 03:12 PM)
Wait wait... so this is a movie that
intentionally makes everything look badly written so as to somehow achieve whatever Ridley Scott / the writers intended to achieve (the whole God-creator thing)?
Wow. Seriously?

Is this a new era where "supposedly bad films" are actually good but
ONLY IF you do your homework and a whole lot of reading? WTH...
I can't accept this, perhaps others can. If a movie is not good then it probably is. When you leave the cinema, that's it. How you feel after leaving your seat is what the movie experience had on yourself. Simple.... and for me, it was not really that great.
I understand what you're saying about the satisfactory feeling when leaving the cinema ... however, I often believe that feeling corresponds to the expectation before entering the cinema. But let's say for casual movie-goers, who usually choose movies based on posters/movie stars and who want to enjoy the movie as standalone, without the need to consult external FAQs; I guess the feeling of being disappointed with Prometheus' scientifically 'stupid' with plenty of unanswered questions movie, is expected.
For me, I was wary of the mixed reviews before watching, so maybe that's why I could accept and shrugged off most of the minor complaints, but those 'bad writings' don't distract me from the bigger picture ... I was actually excited when the Engineer 'suited' up the Space Jockey gear; ya, the link to the 1st Alien film, however distant, is cool for me. And when I left the cinema, the movie got me thinking, made me read up more online and wanted to discuss more ... so, in that sense, it's a good movie for me; unlike some genuinely bad movies that made me wanna forget the whole thing.
A case in comparison; last weekend, I watched Synecdoche, New York (2008), the debut directorial film by the writer Charlie Kaufman who often used some scientific speculations in his screenplays. I thought based on his previous works, Being John Malkovich, Adaptation, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Human Nature, etc., I would be sufficiently entertained even though I might not get the whole film on 1st viewing. I watched without expectation, without even looking up the ratings/review score ... halfway thru the movie, I was totally confused and then sleep-watched thru the 2nd half. When the film ended, I was like WTF did I just watched? I went on imdb, expecting low if not mixed reviews ... it has 7.2/10 on imdb, and 67 metascore. So, I'm the one that don't get the film, I guess ... after reading the FAQs, I'm was humbled ... this is one of those films that required a lot of pre-requisite knowledge before watching in order to fully enjoy it. Is this the type of serious artistic movies that shouldn't be watched for pure entertainment? I'm not sure ... those who got it wrote reviews saying that it made them laugh...it is categorized as a drama & comedy. So, can it be considered an intellectual film and is the writing too clever for average audience? I guess so ... one user review said that half the cinema audience walked out half-way. And Roger Ebert considered "Synecdoche, New York" the best film of the decade ... (of course, we don't often agree with Mr. Ebert). So, without fully understanding, I could easily dismissed the film as a bad movie. What is a bad, a good or a great movie then? That I think, is what's interesting about films made not just for casual commercial entertainment ... it could be one man's meat or another man's poison, which reflects the diversity of human minds. When one starts to feel all films are boring, then one should analyze one's jaded life. We are all still learning ... no such thing as boring if our minds aren't.
Sorry, too much thinking aloud ...
QUOTE(rastablank @ Jun 18 2012, 09:51 AM)
The birth of Predator perhaps, hence the war between both species (AvP), while human is torn apart in the middle, hey, we're all cousins btw

As mentioned before, Ridley Scott and James Cameron don't consider the AvP 'prequels' canon. Anyway, AvP could be said are more to Predator series, the xenomorph aliens are just animals to be hunted.