bro....unker finished the article liao....TBH, all these information just a story from someone don't know who....no technical information and not accurate at all...

If they are using the S70 which already applied in X50/x70....I'm sorry to say that non of them are BMA platform....

Whatever they copy RAV4 or not....even they improvise from there....this kind of reverse engineering usually just create more weakness rather than building any better platform...

I'm sorry to proton X50/X70 and even S70 owners, they are sold by Proton/Geely without proper information....被出卖了...LoL

This post has been edited by xiaojohn: Nov 30 2023, 08:44 PM

Bro...unker just check....even X50 is not in BMA platform....

which means they are using DIFF platform in Proton X50 and S70....it should be something much more older.....--> which means more parts (platforms), non-modular, less strength requirement, more noise chasis...



Proton actually can learn from Perodua x Toyota...

They don't hesitate to tell buyer they are sharing DNGA platform....and Toyota Vios is using DNGA platform....

bro....unker finished the article liao....

TBH, the link and article inside has no REFERENCE VALUE....

all these information just a story from someone don't know who....no technical information and not accurate at all...

If they are using the S70 which already applied in X50/x70....I'm sorry to say that non of them are BMA platform....

Whatever they copy RAV4 or not....even they improvise from there....this kind of reverse engineering usually just create more weakness rather than building any better platform...

I'm sorry to proton X50/X70 and even S70 owners, they are sold by Proton/Geely without proper information....被出卖了...LoL

I think only Proton/Geely know what they are doing secretly inside....

This post has been edited by xiaojohn: Nov 30 2023, 08:54 PM

X50 is BMA

X70 uses older NL platform

how to know/confirm X50 is using BMA platform?

Cause X50 is geely coolray.

Because it's reported in every media outlet, who got the info from press releases and press kits. Unless you're implying Geely/Proton lying through their teeth to everybody.

Tell me, before TNGA/DNGA, do Toyota market the name of the platform they are using? Do you know the name of the platform Honda is using?

China and Philippines using CVT because it is mated to the 1.5NA engine.

Proton opted for the 1.5T because of local market expectations, and also they are already manufacturing the engine in Malaysia. The entire drivetrain (engine + DCT gearbox) was lifted from the X50.

It is more cost efficient to share these components between 3 models (S70, X50, X70), instead of starting another drivetrain assembly line just for S70.

not true...china is using 1.5TDGi engine

So what are you saying? That the S70 is a completely different car from Emgrand? That Proton took another platform and built a car that looks exactly like the Emgrand, using up even more development funds, then sell it cheaper than Vios/City?

You can read this...

https://www.automachi.com/2023/11/is-the-20...rawang-factory/

the cross region using same-platform is something that recently developed not too long ago....to cut cost, also to have less parts of platform and increase the stability....

Source?

bro, it is not what UNKER want to say.....it is WHAT PROTON and GEELY want to say????

Unker is not PROTON SALESMAN....no point to questions unker...

What does this have to do with what I am asking?

Do you know the name of the 1st gen Vios? 2nd gen? 3rd gen? Did Toyota ever market it?

You said X50 and S70 not using BMA platform ma. So what are you implying? S70 is a totally different car from Emgrand? X50 is totally different from Binyue?

here you go

you don't sohai and directive....unker will not kena your trap btw...

This is a 1.5NA engine.

Look at the power and torque figures.

you please don't sohai ask back uncle questions...sendiri go see the specification okay?

You said ma, if platform good, sure will put in marketing materials.

Honda Civic FE use what platform?