100 page tered incoming

Sorry i did missed your point. Actually i don’t understand you point. Why do i need to learn language other than national language again?

And when you say bahasa cina, you’re referring to hokkien, cantonese, hakka or which one?

This post has been edited by blanket84: Jan 19 2020, 05:36 PM

[quote=bigwolf,Jan 19 2020, 05:30 PM]
[/quote]

As usual, everyone of you missed the point. You demand & insult the other races for not knowing bahasa kebangsaan. But have you, as a malaysian, learn other languages yourself? Or are you going to hide your ignorance behind the label "kebangsaan"/"national" and only demand of 1 side while conveninently overlooking yourself?

And the local language here in malaysia is bahasa melayu, cina dan tamil (ofc you can argue there are many languages in malaysia, but lets just stick with the majority 3 shall we). What other languages you know beside your own mother tongue, which happened to be bahasa kebangsaan? Oh no need, imma just gonna hide behind the "kebangsaan "/"national" label yipeee, no need to learn anything else and throw cheap shot at those who dunno bahasa, calling them don't deserve to be called malaysian, yay???

[/quote]

Its hilarious that you should mention about other languages. I am actually not a Malay. I am a Punjabi who speaks English, Malay, Hindi, Punjabi and broken Hokkien.
I am proud to be a Malaysian and I am proud of the fact that I speak the Bahasa Kebangsaan fluently.

Coz malaysia is a multicultural multiracial multireligious nation. It is not monoracial monocultural like china, japan, korea etc. My question is simple, have you learned other languages to fit in as a citizen of a multicultural multiracial society? Or are you going to refuse to learn and just hide behind the label "kebangsaan"/"national"?

You’re saying you know how to speak tamil?

And you haven’t answered my question. Which bahasa cina were you referring to?

So why the racist review and comment to them when bahasa baku is not the main topic, it is just a language that still can be understandable by us.

At the end, it still how we communicate is more important than what language we must use to communicate. Like me, i don speak canto but I understand, so when ppl ask in canto i wil reply in Mandarin or english.

Then good for you. I'm a chinese who knows English, Malay, Cantonese, Mandarin (not so good but passable)

I'm proud to be Malaysian as well and also able to speak Bahasa Kebangsaan. Problem here is since when did this "you dunno national language you dun deserve to be called malaysian" started? Please tell me, who is more Malaysian- A person who doesn't speak bm but put in honest work and pays his taxes and lived honestly compared to another whose bm so power until can bersajak berpuisi but steals, robs, kill and cheat? Who is more deserving to be called Malaysian here?

This post has been edited by bigwolf: Jan 19 2020, 05:51 PM

It's okay. So called BM is not useful outside of Malaysia anyway

[quote=bigwolf,Jan 19 2020, 05:30 PM]
[/quote]

As usual, everyone of you missed the point. You demand & insult the other races for not knowing bahasa kebangsaan. But have you, as a malaysian, learn other languages yourself? Or are you going to hide your ignorance behind the label "kebangsaan"/"national" and only demand of 1 side while conveninently overlooking yourself?

And the local language here in malaysia is bahasa melayu, cina dan tamil (ofc you can argue there are many languages in malaysia, but lets just stick with the majority 3 shall we). What other languages you know beside your own mother tongue, which happened to be bahasa kebangsaan? Oh no need, imma just gonna hide behind the "kebangsaan "/"national" label yipeee, no need to learn anything else and throw cheap shot at those who dunno bahasa, calling them don't deserve to be called malaysian, yay???

[/quote]

Do you really understand what the word 'majority' mean?



Indian people go speak tamil to chinese people, do u think they will understand? Nope.
Chinese people go speak mandari to indian people, do u think they would understand? Nope.

Maybe english yes, but in rural area, even in sabah, sarawak, with different ethnic, speak those language on those people and English, i dont think so.

But if you speak bahasa Malaysia, they will.

Still in Malaysia malay is #1 language that most of different race, different ethnic both rural and city area could understand, and second is #2 English(mostly city people).

Unfortunately no, I didn't have the opportunity to learn tamil. But its kinda cool if I can know tamil.

Whichever bahasa cina that you can speak to the cina guy. Can be cantonese, hokkien, teochow, mandarin. Your point is?

Bahasa baku is the pronunciation. We are discussing people who can’t string a proper sentence.

BS

I've even seen ministers with good tatabahasa but just because their accent is typical cainis, they will be laugh at "Teruknya bahasa"

Meanwhile whenever I use powderful melei accent without caring about grammar, they will stare in amazement, "Fuiyo BM u power laaa"

You are still not getting the point. What other languages have YOU learned beside hiding behind the label "kebangsaan"/"national"? And you call yourself Malaysian, living in a multicultural multiracial multireligious society?

Racist people like you should go back to rahmatullah

Hate certain race only come from racist people. And I assume you realise the racist people is Imp Bron for implying Chinese cannot speak BM eventhough I speak like a Malay.

My point is, i can communicate with my multiracial friends in Bahasa Malaysia, why do i need to learn other languages?

And Malaysia is a multilingual, multi-religion, and multi-race, but the individual don’t have to be. Do i need to be muslim & christian at the same time? Enough for you to know BM and your dialect and English if you plan to be marketable.

I did planned to learn bahasa cina, then i realized there is just too many dialect and you can't understand the other dialect if you only learn one dialect. Heck even cina i befriended with mostly know one dialect only and only speak with their own kind.

Living in multi culture does not mean i need to learn every language, as other race could easily understand the national language

I know malay, english, a bit thai but forgot already since dint stay there many years already

i dunno why i need learn other language than that, unless if i stay in china or india, thai, spain, arab, vietnam, france, as i mentioned previously i will definitely learn the language as those are LOCAL/NATIONAL/MAJORITY language

as i living in Malaysia. Malay is enough for LOCAL, and English for INTERNATIONAL.

This post has been edited by Gyazo: Jan 19 2020, 06:06 PM

I don’t know your history with Imp Bron and what kind of people Imp Bron is before this. So i can’t assume he is racist from his initial post.

If you can speak BM, good for you.

This here is the problem. You expect others to know and learn your language to be able to communicate with you. But you do not want to learn and know their language to communicate with them if they don't know yours. And rather than acknowledging that, you use the label "kebangsaan"/"national" as though only 1 language can be allowed to be used here in Malaysia.

same as what I replied above

Well please don’t put me in the same category with those people. I have my own standard and i am not a sheep.