What do you mean keep buy and sell? They reoptimised like once maybe twice in a year. Is that too much for you?

Long term investment also needs periodic review to see if any adjustments are necessary.

Think it was mentioned before also, if someone is strongly opinionated in their investment strategies, then stashaway is not for them since it cant be manually controlled apart from the risk %.

That said tho, pretty interested to know why they chose australia for the reoptimisation.

Worst part is reoptimisation literally just happened so stashaway bought a whole bunch of kweb, and its dropping straightaway lolol.. imagine if the reoptimisation happen this week instead.

Why do people keep asking if investments are protected by PIDM?

well since they asked if it is protected by PIDM, shouldnt they know what PIDM does? If they do then they would know the answer already. or they just feel happy and secured with the words PIDM without knowing what they do...

Well since KWEB fell like 12% in the past few days, about most of deposits are going to KWEB to readjust that allocation.

This post has been edited by thecurious: Aug 19 2021, 10:56 PM

its your right to have doubts naturally, all I said was most of the deposit went into KWEB, a few times it was even purely KWEB.
Just sharing on the allocation. no need to go into detailed calculations, thats not why I use Stashaway.

So many people joined when kweb at ATH lol

Actually what do you hate about the reoptimisation anyway?
When I saw the reallocation, thought it was quite decent.
If its about Kweb, its allocation didnt change (for my RI).

This post has been edited by thecurious: Aug 22 2021, 01:18 PM

Dont really understand your objective here.
You seem to shut out all other comments... anything that doesnt align with your current view is hostile and Stashaway fanboy.
This is just a forum for people to share on their views. Its not like anyone here can change Freddy's or his teams mind even if everyone here is objecting against their methodology.
You say nobody gives you a good explanation or rationale and say most people just keep saying "tak suka u jeluar".
But I saw many comments that were reasonably well, you just discarded them or choose to think of them as stashaway fanboys.
Seriously, I'm not happy that stashaway is currently negative also. But don't judge the community here when you yourself are showing such an attitude.

If you go into a store to find something, but you didnt find what you want, do you go to another store to find the item? Or do you call the store manager and tell them they should start selling what you want?

"Tak suka, u keluar" may sound harsh but its basically just the solution if you dislike the platform so much that you hate its guts and cant agree with their policy.

Why would you use something you disagree with so much?

Anyway, its not like people ask him or them to keluar immediately. They chose to discard constructive feedback and discussion and cherry pick bits and pieces to argue.

If maybe what they want is for stashaway to change how they handle things, they are at the wrong place. They should go contact stashaway's management team. Not rant on a forum. Because nobody here can change how it operates.

Meaningful discussion is good, always good to have 2 sides to a subject. But being obstinate and completely disregarding other people's points and then getting offended when people suggest perhaps the platform is not suitable for them. Is that really meaningful discussion?

You might want to check who is being hostile lol...easy to see, just flip back some pages.

Btw, people already stopped talking about him yet he jumped back in just to provoke current users. So who is being hostile?

You are right about the alternatives, unfortunately that will be regarded as "tak suka, u keluar" by some.

It was removed last month.

About a week iirc.

You can check your recent reoptimisation for the estimated selling time.
The withdrawal was very long ago for testing, cant remember clearly.

Is that part of KWEB? How will it affect Stashaway portfolio?

This post has been edited by thecurious: Sep 15 2021, 02:30 PM

Because many people invested before February. YTD may be negative but over the years its positive.

What does this mean? You had a lot of gains when kweb was like a rocket? Now down to only a few hundred gains?

Or you had a large negative in the thousands and it recovered to only negative a few hundred now?

Prepare your popcorns, possibly some people will brag about their DIY portfolios against stashaway soon.

Just use search function for that. so much discussion on it already