If the strategic review is successful, you would expect investors to price in growth in earnings...
I see the stock price flat since May 2021, when the "strategic reset" was announced. If you factor in rising interest rates throughout 2022 and 2023, that's a big opportunity cost for shareholders. Back on May 14 2021, it's 2.32 SGD, now it's 6% higher at 2.46 SGD, factor in dividends of 36.4 cents since May 2021's announcement, that's about 15.7% returns since May 2021, giving a total holding-period return of 21.7% = 6.77% p.a. since May 2021.
Benchmark STI closed at 3055.02 on May 14 2021, now it's around 3313.84 = 8.47% price return + dividends of 11.68% since May 2021 (using ES3 ETF dividend data as reference), we get 20.1% = 6.3% p.a. since May 2021. If you factor in the ETF expense, both Singtel and the STI are probably on par...
In short, I don't see any meaningful alpha generated by Singtel management here... I am not expecting NVDA-like stratospheric growth, but at least I should see something inching up on the total return side...
Let's do some more fundamental analysis, uhmm let's look at FCF from Singtel from May 2021:
https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/quote/Z74.SI/cash-flowI see a declining trend from 3.2 billion SGD to 2.4 billion SGD since financial year ending on 31st March 2021. OCF declines faster than Capex over the years since 2021.
Let's look at leverage, all the more important in a "higher for longer" world:
Current debt + long-term debt = 11.9 billion SGD as of FY 31/3/2024, up from 10.65 billion SGD as of FY 31/3/2021. The good news is cash is up a lot from 754.7 million SGD to 4.6 billion SGD...
The problem is with declining FCF, how are they going to service their 12 billion SGD debt going forward? Sell assets means less and less future OCF... And if they just focus on paying out sales proceeds to shareholders, that will barely prop up the stock price as a lot of shitty assets in the past are now realized at a lost, i.e., the bunch of impairments you see...
I see the management is stuck between the pan and the fire...
Appreciated your write-up in the above,... am pondering too your pts.
To your highlighted sentences, Singtel's share price has been rising. Broken the psychological barrier of 2.50,.......