QUOTE(OMGila @ Oct 19 2015, 12:48 PM)
Saddle pricing is really subjective to how yr butt respond to the curvature of the saddle versus how much ur paying for the "pain". Unfortunately everyone's butt anatomy is different so it u can find a sample saddle to try for a week, then it's great. If not then it might be an expensive trial & error. I've had lots of friends using brooks & yes, they all seem to hv nice things to say. Initially all butts will hurt when you're new to Cycling no matter what saddle u use. I'd suggest after buying a saddle, that u tahan & use it for at least 2 months to properly judge whether a saddle fits u.
I also have many trials with saddles and till now still have not really get a fitting one. I did not try Brooks (though many have advised me to) but I just never liked Brooks. I tried the Fizik Gobi once and just 5 kilometers into riding, my butt ached and it spoils the whole ride. I did a lot of long distance rides in SR Ariel. It's OK but it still hurts after 100 km. But it is still the best for me though. I have even tried Trian Enduro by Morgaw. Incidently I saw the video clip about it and Kimbell Jaya have stocks of it, so I got a set and tried it. Cost more than a Brooks too but still hurts. It is now on my wife's MTB and she says it's good.

Initially the first 2 rides, it was painful but after a few rides after that, she says it fits her perfectly. So, I guess you need to break in as well, not the saddle have to break in.
Till now, I practically sticks to my Selle Royal Ariel (out of production as well now). It's the widest and also fairly light. A compromise between two criteria, comfort and light. I come to discover also price doesn't mean a thing in the selection of saddles. Before I transferred the SR Ariel onto my MTB, I was using a cheapo and it fits me nicely. But I have since sold off my Dash and took back the SR Ariel and put it on my MTB. SO, in MTB I don't have to sit on it all the time anyway, we usually stand on the pedal when going downhill, so, it should be OK.
Just for info, here's something about Morgaw saddles.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvN1_ja8_OgPS/ Oh yeah! First criteria in selection is measure the width of your pelvic bone. Take a piece of paper (fairly large piece) and place it on your bed. Sit on the paper. There will be 2 indentation on the paper. Measure the distance between the deepest depression on the paper and that's the width you need to look for on a saddle. SR makes many wide saddles and many also are UGLY !

Some even have gel and absorbers but they are heavy and ugly. That's why I settled for Ariel. It the lightest and widest in terms of compromise.
This post has been edited by etigge: Oct 20 2015, 12:18 AM