thinking bout it also ... any good recommendation ?

feel like wana give a try on edifier... dun bash me on this ..

haha.. better ask in edifier fan club oh. later eat bullet

Edifier? I'm sure you have better taste Ok, I'm using Klipsch GMXA-2.1 with X-Fi Elite Pro and they are great!

Yo guyz! juz found this thread ... im altec lansing old school fan

having 3 set of ATP3 at home ... if wan another set of speaker ... i think i'll still go for ATP3 ...

ATP3 loyal fans

Choose a speaker just like choose a computer, if we know well about the details then you will get benefits from it. I now just realize that VS4121 maximum frequency just 15KHz, no wonder you guys say it treble is suck.

Do you ever hear the sound with frequency of 15Khz and 20Khz? Do you have special software?

mayb he refer from Post #1813 gua

I dun have special software, but you can try with a long plastic ruler. The higher frequency show the faster wave. You can try to use a long plastic ruler, put the ruler on the side of table. I dunno how to say, see picture.

Low Frequency


High Frequency


Low Frequency more to bass, high frequency more to treble.

whre is coolkwc when we need him.. ....im atp3 loyal fan also...but need better speaker to match my soundcard..

This post has been edited by sucka3: May 7 2008, 09:38 PM

Hmm.. I'm science student and i know this as well.
What I wanna ask is about the relationship between the sound quality and the frequency.
Are our ears sensitive enough to differentiate the sound with frequency of 15Khz and 20Khz?

You try adjust and play around the media player equalizer in your PC, the amplifier in the car or the equalizer of your house home theatre then you will know. One software you can use to test the frequency (Sony SoundForge). Sometimes you can use it to cut mobile phone mp3 ringtones.

Bump

use Sony Soundforge to test the frequency response of your speaker, you can download from HERE, this is demo version, V9.0e, you need some 'special' way to turn into full version....

I can hear the different between 15kHz-20khz by using this software and MX5021..for MX response stated in spec sheet, the frequency response is 30hz-22khz, but take note, the figure follow behind is very important, which is '-10dB' , means that at this 'corner frequency', 30hz and 22khz actually the level is decay -10dB already, so in actual music playback this frequency are mask by others frequency....i test it using soundforge and notice that the MX actual response is between 40hz and 18kHz(depends on room condition and location of audience), any frequency below or beyond it the level will decay very fast and u need to turn up the volume in order to hear it more clearly.

But depends on people taste, i personally feel that the frequency beyond 16khz is amazing, not ear piercing, very smooth and airy, thats why i using the paragraphic EQ to boost 16khz to 20khz


This post has been edited by coolkwc: May 10 2008, 05:28 PM

Try this, 15 seconds constant tone for each specific frequency.

http://www.bnoack.com/downloads.html

Bump!!!

---

Added on May 11, 2008, 12:40 pmYa, test tone can test your speaker frequency response in different room, so that you can know how the certain band level and adjust EQ to compensate it...

This post has been edited by coolkwc: May 11 2008, 12:40 PM

Having a maximum frequency of 20khz doenst meant it is good either.

I give u a buzzer that can reach 20khz, is that a good speaker?

vs 4121

haha, i just realize that i can connect my notebook to mx5021
even though i already have my pc connected to it
to play songs from my notebook, i'll just mute my pc, and voila

wan to ask mx5021 can fight wif edifier s730 ornot?? which 1 is the best?? speaker n woofer!!

mx5021 user here~ all i can say it shakes my neighbour's walls and windows..