Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Bodybuilding Thread V11, Bodybuilding Q&A

views
     
darklight79
post Jan 30 2013, 01:32 PM

I'll eat your food
Group Icon
Elite
9,006 posts

Joined: Oct 2005
From: PJ


QUOTE(akiratm @ Jan 30 2013, 11:27 AM)
i think u missed your alcohol dose instead of coffee, bro
*
Lolololol....... And the reputation spreads.

QUOTE(DT1 @ Jan 30 2013, 11:41 AM)
Joeblows, shadowz, please explain the post-workout window. Been hearing it for some time now but never really managed to get the specifics on it.

Anyway from my understanding of the window, here's how I do it.

I take BCAAs 10 mins before a workout session, and immediately after (this time with a very fast digesting carb).

If I were to use whey for the same purpose, I would consume it about 1 hour before, rather than immediately after.

I guess the part where taking whey immediately after a session "leverages the window" is bro-science.

This practice of mine comes after reading some of Layne Norton's recommendations.
*
The post workout window is a garage door. It's 24 hours.

habibz84
post Jan 30 2013, 03:02 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
68 posts

Joined: Nov 2008
From: Land Below The Wind


hi, need some advise from sifu. correct me if im wrong ya. this is sumting i just learned.

my bodyfat
(264lbs x 1.082) + 94.42 = 380
380 - (40inch x 4.15) = 214
[(264lbs - 214)] x 100 / 264 = 18.93%

my BMR
66 + (13.7 x 120kg) + (5 x 185cm) - (6.8 x 29yrs) = 2437.8

my total calorie needs (active 6days a week)
= BMR x 1.725
= 2437.8 x 1.725
= 4205.2

if my goal is to loss weight and build muscle at the same time, i need to reduce my calorie intake to 15%-20% with good diet/meal ?

sorry if wrong thread sweat.gif
shadowz
post Jan 30 2013, 08:49 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
510 posts

Joined: Dec 2004
From: Somewhere in Msia >.< I might b lost. I cant tell~


QUOTE(darklight79 @ Jan 30 2013, 01:32 PM)
Lolololol....... And the reputation spreads.
The post workout window is a garage door. It's 24 hours.
*
Whos fault is that la? Even I thought the same thing when I saw his post tongue.gif Tsk tsk - making everyone associate him as an alcohol dependant drunkard. Sorry mike tongue.gif

QUOTE(DT1 @ Jan 30 2013, 11:41 AM)
Joeblows, shadowz, please explain the post-workout window. Been hearing it for some time now but never really managed to get the specifics on it.

Anyway from my understanding of the window, here's how I do it.

I take BCAAs 10 mins before a workout session, and immediately after (this time with a very fast digesting carb).

If I were to use whey for the same purpose, I would consume it about 1 hour before, rather than immediately after.

I guess the part where taking whey immediately after a session "leverages the window" is bro-science.

This practice of mine comes after reading some of Layne Norton's recommendations.
*
Like DL said, its 24 hours. Fortunately for me, research has been done so I don't have to use silly personal or 'a friend of a friends' story to prove this point. More intelligent persons have done so already. thumbup.gif

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21289204

The conclusion: results suggest that resistance exercise performed until failure confers a sensitizing effect on human skeletal muscle for at least 24 h. rclxms.gif

Also, where I was first enlightened:
http://www.t-nation.com/free_online_articl...nutrition_myths

Relevant excerpt:
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


The main reason the anabolic window( better known as Post workout window and meal) the importance of eating quick digesting protein after a workout (post workout meal) has been endlessly emphasized by supplement companies, is to try and create a market for specific PWO products.

They have been awfully successful don't you think? brows.gif

Now, it’s likely that you’ve seen somewhere the legend of a mystical, magical fueling window. From exercise books, magazine articles and websites to nearly every resource that exists on sports nutrition, you’ll commonly read that “after you finish a workout, you have 20-60 minutes to replace precious energy by consuming a mix carbohydrates and proteins”.

Here’s what they don’t tell you:

In every study or experiment that has investigated the benefit of immediate post-workout nutrition replacement, subjects were fed after completing an exercise session that they had performed in a fasted or semi-starved state.

In other words, of course you’re going to benefit if you eat a meal after a workout in which you were completely depleted of energy! But how many of us actually roll out of bed in the morning, hop on a bicycle, and ride hard for 90 minutes to 2 hours with absolutely no fuel? In most cases, this would unpleasant, difficult and not a standard workout protocol.}

So in individuals NOT FASTING, there is no reason to stress about the 'post workout window'. It is 24 hours. Mind you, no harm in eating right after if you are really hungry after working out - it just isn't a MUST to do so. And thank goodness for that because I sure as heck don't feel like eating for an hour or two after a gym session. sweat.gif
shadowz
post Jan 30 2013, 09:05 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
510 posts

Joined: Dec 2004
From: Somewhere in Msia >.< I might b lost. I cant tell~


QUOTE(habibz84 @ Jan 30 2013, 03:02 PM)
hi, need some advise from sifu. correct me if im wrong ya. this is sumting i just learned.

my bodyfat
(264lbs x 1.082) + 94.42 = 380
380 - (40inch x 4.15) = 214
[(264lbs - 214)] x 100 / 264 = 18.93%

my BMR
66 + (13.7 x 120kg) + (5 x 185cm) - (6.8 x 29yrs) = 2437.8

my total calorie needs (active 6days a week)
= BMR x 1.725
= 2437.8 x 1.725
= 4205.2

if my goal is to loss weight and build muscle at the same time,  i need to reduce my calorie intake to 15%-20% with good diet/meal ?

sorry if wrong thread  sweat.gif
*
Are you a beginner? If you are then you *MIGHT* be able to lose SOME fat as you build muscle the first few months. You are not obese (according to body fat %) so it wont be as dramatic. In all likelyhood you will probably add a little muscle and lose more fat. Why? Because building muscle requires a caloric surplus. Losing fat requires a deficit. Once the window of 'newbie gains/loss' is done with you will struggle to do both simultaneously (It isn't impossible, just EXTREMELY improbable for majority of the population).

Anyway

Stick to 15% calorie deficit: 4205 - 15% = 4205 - 630.75 = 3574.25
Round up to 3575 calories a day.

Track your calorie intake closely for a couple of weeks, if you are losing too fast (more than 1-1.5kg a week) then bump up the calories by 100 calories. If weight is too slow (Like 0.5kg or less in 2 weeks) then decrease calorie by 100-200 calories.

It is damn annoying at first but after a few weeks of estimating food, you can eyeball alot of food (that you eat and estimate regularly la) pretty accurately.

Avoid processed crap if you can - they tend to be really high in calories, hardly any micronutrients, hardly any fiber, etc. They just aren't great y'know? If you can't avoid the rubbish, minimise sugar intake. Drinks, sweets, etc. In the end though, if you are within your calories for the day, you hit your protein goals and you feel like a treat - have at it and don't stress. The stress will up your cortisol levels that are more likely to make you retain fat deposits. Kind of counter productive if you ask me.

Get a good multivitamin, high potency fish oil, and maybe a vitamin C or E if you believe it is beneficial. Find a simple and effective beginners lifting program - check out the stickies, darklight wrote one years ago that most can use and adapt later when they want to do more. GET ENOUGH SLEEP. This is bloody important. You are going to stress your body out, so make sure you give it time to heal and recuperate.

Oh. And read. Then THINK about what you read.

There is a lot (ALOT) of bro science and crap out there but there is alot you can learn and apply to improve yourself. smile.gif It is worth it. G'luck!
DT1
post Jan 31 2013, 12:35 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,186 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


Dang... that's so much to read, and complicated as hell. So the general consensus here is that the notion of post-workout window in the everyday context is either non-existent, or non-worthy to fret about, am I right?
alien9
post Jan 31 2013, 12:38 AM

These stars mean nothing
*******
Senior Member
3,030 posts

Joined: Dec 2009
From: Jelatek / Wangsa Maju


QUOTE(DT1 @ Jan 31 2013, 12:35 AM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


Dang... that's so much to read, and complicated as hell. So the general consensus here is that the notion of post-workout window in the everyday context is either non-existent, or non-worthy to fret about, am I right?
*
That is correct. The anaBROlic window is more on the supplement marketing side which want people to buy protein supps in order to meet the window. What would be the best meal to consumed within 30 minutes of workout? Protein supps is the answer, and lots of people fell for it
DT1
post Jan 31 2013, 01:07 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,186 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
QUOTE(alien9 @ Jan 31 2013, 12:38 AM)
That is correct. The anaBROlic window is more on the supplement marketing side which want people to buy protein supps in order to meet the window. What would be the best meal to consumed within 30 minutes of workout? Protein supps is the answer, and lots of people fell for it
*
Aight. Btw here's a post that gives some credits to BCAAs. Now if you guys could kindly comment on whether it's bs or not, would appreciate it. Could probably drop it off the supps list if it's deemed ineffective (pre & post wo consumption min. 5g + 10g as recommended by Layne).

QUOTE
Interviewer: One thing that occurred to me there is that if you look at a large meal, one with a slow digesting protein source such as casein or animal protein, you do find that the actual digestion of the meal can take several hours. Given that context, I’m assuming there is going to be an ongoing release of amino acids from the protein sources in that meal so in the situation when you introduce a BCAA is there not already protein synthesis going on at the same time?

Layne: Yes there is but the point being that the BCAA’s are going to cause a really rapid rise in plasma BCAA’s compared to eating another meal or a steady release of amino acids over time as with casein ingestion. Even if there are amino acids going in, as we’ve shown before a steady influx of amino acids is not sufficient to keep protein synthesis elevated, BCAAs are going to spike it even more which will increase BCAA oxidation in muscle, replenish ATP and keep protein synthesis going. It’s not an amino acid availability issue that limits the duration of protein synthesis in response to a meal, it’s an ATP issue.In the study I keep referencing we gave whey for the meal protein sources, which people see as a ‘fast’ digesting protein source but when you feed it in the context of a whole meal, we still had very high amino acid levels three hours post meal and that’s when protein synthesis had already fallen back to baseline. You have an elevated amino acid level even though protein synthesis is falling off and that was pretty shocking to us, which is again why we suggested eating another meal wouldn’t do it. Branched chain amino acids are not really touched by the gut or the liver and get into the bloodstream rapidly so we postulated they would act differently to simply eating another meal. The research seems to support our theories thus far. BCAAs are digested so rapidly, they cause a rapid spike and they act differently compared to eating intact protein. People will say ‘well there’s already BCAA’s in the food you eat, in whey protein etc.’ Yes, that’s true but those are peptide bounded. They are bound to other amino acids and you would have digest and release those, whereas when taking a free-form BCAA there is no digestion required. It goes straight through the digestive tract and into your bloodstream pretty rapidly and that’s why it tends to have a differential effect compared to eating another meal.

Source: http://www.predatornutrition.com/en/conten...ro-bodybuilder/


This post has been edited by DT1: Jan 31 2013, 01:30 AM
hh_yeap
post Jan 31 2013, 08:50 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
142 posts

Joined: Sep 2008
QUOTE(shadowz @ Jan 30 2013, 09:05 PM)
Are you a beginner? If you are then you *MIGHT* be able to lose SOME fat as you build muscle the first few months. You are not obese (according to body fat %) so it wont be as dramatic. In all likelyhood you will probably add a little muscle and lose more fat. Why? Because building muscle requires a caloric surplus. Losing fat requires a deficit. Once the window of 'newbie gains/loss' is done with you will struggle to do both simultaneously (It isn't impossible, just EXTREMELY improbable for majority of the population).

Anyway

Stick to 15% calorie deficit: 4205 - 15% = 4205 - 630.75 = 3574.25
Round up to 3575 calories a day.

Track your calorie intake closely for a couple of weeks, if you are losing too fast (more than 1-1.5kg a week) then bump up the calories by 100 calories. If weight is too slow (Like 0.5kg or less in 2 weeks) then decrease calorie by 100-200 calories.

It is damn annoying at first but after a few weeks of estimating food, you can eyeball alot of food (that you eat and estimate regularly la) pretty accurately.

Avoid processed crap if you can - they tend to be really high in calories, hardly any micronutrients, hardly any fiber, etc. They just aren't great y'know? If you can't avoid the rubbish, minimise sugar intake. Drinks, sweets, etc. In the end though, if you are within your calories for the day, you hit your protein goals and you feel like a treat - have at it and don't stress. The stress will up your cortisol levels that are more likely to make you retain fat deposits. Kind of counter productive if you ask me.

Get a good multivitamin, high potency fish oil, and maybe a vitamin C or E if you believe it is beneficial. Find a simple and effective beginners lifting program - check out the stickies, darklight wrote one years ago that most can use and adapt later when they want to do more. GET ENOUGH SLEEP. This is bloody important. You are going to stress your body out, so make sure you give it time to heal and recuperate.

Oh. And read. Then THINK about what you read.

There is a lot (ALOT) of bro science and crap out there but there is alot you can learn and apply to improve yourself. smile.gif It is worth it. G'luck!
*
I've notice that shadowz have great patience in teaching newbies... thumbup.gif thumbup.gif
I learn alot from this post...
habibz84
post Jan 31 2013, 09:21 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
68 posts

Joined: Nov 2008
From: Land Below The Wind


QUOTE(shadowz @ Jan 30 2013, 09:05 PM)
Are you a beginner? If you are then you *MIGHT* be able to lose SOME fat as you build muscle the first few months. You are not obese (according to body fat %) so it wont be as dramatic. In all likelyhood you will probably add a little muscle and lose more fat. Why? Because building muscle requires a caloric surplus. Losing fat requires a deficit. Once the window of 'newbie gains/loss' is done with you will struggle to do both simultaneously (It isn't impossible, just EXTREMELY improbable for majority of the population).

Anyway

Stick to 15% calorie deficit: 4205 - 15% = 4205 - 630.75 = 3574.25
Round up to 3575 calories a day.

Track your calorie intake closely for a couple of weeks, if you are losing too fast (more than 1-1.5kg a week) then bump up the calories by 100 calories. If weight is too slow (Like 0.5kg or less in 2 weeks) then decrease calorie by 100-200 calories.

It is damn annoying at first but after a few weeks of estimating food, you can eyeball alot of food (that you eat and estimate regularly la) pretty accurately.

Avoid processed crap if you can - they tend to be really high in calories, hardly any micronutrients, hardly any fiber, etc. They just aren't great y'know? If you can't avoid the rubbish, minimise sugar intake. Drinks, sweets, etc. In the end though, if you are within your calories for the day, you hit your protein goals and you feel like a treat - have at it and don't stress. The stress will up your cortisol levels that are more likely to make you retain fat deposits. Kind of counter productive if you ask me.

Get a good multivitamin, high potency fish oil, and maybe a vitamin C or E if you believe it is beneficial. Find a simple and effective beginners lifting program - check out the stickies, darklight wrote one years ago that most can use and adapt later when they want to do more. GET ENOUGH SLEEP. This is bloody important. You are going to stress your body out, so make sure you give it time to heal and recuperate.

Oh. And read. Then THINK about what you read.

There is a lot (ALOT) of bro science and crap out there but there is alot you can learn and apply to improve yourself. smile.gif It is worth it. G'luck!
*
thanks shadowz for ur reply notworthy.gif biggrin.gif nod.gif
hh_yeap
post Jan 31 2013, 09:42 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
142 posts

Joined: Sep 2008
from mathematical calculation habibz84 show.

I only lost 1% of bodyfat all this while working out.... sad.gif sad.gif
darn it....
alien9
post Jan 31 2013, 10:17 AM

These stars mean nothing
*******
Senior Member
3,030 posts

Joined: Dec 2009
From: Jelatek / Wangsa Maju


QUOTE(DT1 @ Jan 31 2013, 01:07 AM)
Aight. Btw here's a post that gives some credits to BCAAs. Now if you guys could kindly comment on whether it's bs or not, would appreciate it. Could probably drop it off the supps list if it's deemed ineffective (pre & post wo consumption min. 5g + 10g as recommended by Layne).
*
I do believe that BCAA have it's own purpose in supplement industry. The first supps that I bought is BCAA from GNC (yeah, I know doh.gif ) to accommodate my fasted training using IF protocol. One thing that BCAA helped is that hey prevent catabolism that happened during workout since I'm training fasted and no protein source is available in the blood stream after 15 to 16 hours of training but you can't see the effect of BCAA on catabolism.

Another one thing is that I've notice the energy level by consuming BCAA against not consuming BCAA while in fasted training. Sure, it must be something if it gives energy (Placebo effect, IDK).

But one thing for sure, Marc Lobliner (Ex CEO of Scivation) have pour some huge amount of money in order to make a study on BCAAs and if you do managed to read on the researches, I'll doubt that it is fake.
jimlim007
post Feb 1 2013, 08:15 AM

Enoch
*******
Senior Member
4,073 posts

Joined: Aug 2006


guys, my right hand arm (near to the elbow) muscle there feel pain, feel worry to continue the barbell bench press, bumbell incline press, etc.

Do i need to rest until it feel no pain only resume back on gym? I saw someone arm (elbow) and leg (knee) there wear kind of tight cloth, will this method help my condition and let me continue work out or minimize the risk of getting pain in work out?
myvi5949
post Feb 1 2013, 08:38 AM

Quiet Determination
******
Senior Member
1,527 posts

Joined: Jan 2008


QUOTE(jimlim007 @ Feb 1 2013, 08:15 AM)
guys, my right hand arm (near to the elbow) muscle there feel pain, feel worry to continue the barbell bench press, bumbell incline press, etc.

Do i need to rest until it feel no pain only resume back on gym? I saw someone arm (elbow) and leg (knee) there wear kind of tight cloth, will this method help my condition and let me continue work out or minimize the risk of getting pain in work out?
*
i would avoid from adding more stress to the injured area..give it a few days off. do a deload week..just do cardio.
but asking opinions on forums for injury related problem is not a good idea imho.. we have doctors for that.
jimlim007
post Feb 1 2013, 09:14 AM

Enoch
*******
Senior Member
4,073 posts

Joined: Aug 2006


QUOTE(myvi5949 @ Feb 1 2013, 08:38 AM)
i would avoid from adding more stress to the injured area..give it a few days off. do a deload week..just do cardio.
but asking opinions on forums for injury related problem is not a good idea imho.. we have doctors for that.
*
many of the set need to use arm.... this time really crap d cry.gif some more tonight and sat night need to play badminton hmm.gif

then i go for 8min abs practice. less arm use...
Seasick85
post Feb 1 2013, 09:36 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
229 posts

Joined: Oct 2012


QUOTE(jimlim007 @ Feb 1 2013, 09:15 AM)
guys, my right hand arm (near to the elbow) muscle there feel pain, feel worry to continue the barbell bench press, bumbell incline press, etc.

Do i need to rest until it feel no pain only resume back on gym? I saw someone arm (elbow) and leg (knee) there wear kind of tight cloth, will this method help my condition and let me continue work out or minimize the risk of getting pain in work out?
*
It maybe an elbow joint pain..i've had it many times.. if i am not mistaken the pain feels like burning sensation instead of normal muscular soreness? To be honest, if the pain location is at the joint itself, you may need to rest and ice to relief it..keep the weights down, deload, n try various stretches..

I've had mine when working on triceps exercises.. try n see what works for u as per advice.. give it at least 2 weeks.. if getting worse, consult ur doc..

The tight cloth can help to ignore the pain only, not curing it.. unless you're on some sports competitions and can't afford lose time for recovery.. smile.gif

This post has been edited by Seasick85: Feb 1 2013, 09:37 AM
Nama saya Amad
post Feb 1 2013, 11:22 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
458 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


Hey guys,

Lately I feel sore at my lower back, could it be from wrong form of deadlift/pendlay row? I thought I 've seen countless video,bbut I guess my form is so bad. sad.gif

I'm thinking to ditch those two and do more pullup for a while instead. Feel a bit stress out as those are good workout.

Ps after two days of resting, my sore is somewhat relieves abit
Seasick85
post Feb 1 2013, 11:33 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
229 posts

Joined: Oct 2012


QUOTE(Nama saya Amad @ Feb 1 2013, 12:22 PM)
Hey guys,

Lately I feel sore at my lower back, could it be from wrong form of deadlift/pendlay row? I thought I 've seen countless video,bbut I guess my form is so bad. sad.gif

I'm thinking to ditch those two and do more pullup for a while instead. Feel a bit stress out as those are good workout.

Ps after two days of resting, my sore is somewhat relieves abit
*
Really, wrong form generally results in injuries, but then again, you mentioned after two days of resting, soreness is gone indicating you only feel DOMS, normal musle soreness resulting from muscle breakdowns..it is totally normal..just need to rest n you can continue deadlift/row as u like with good form..

Ditching deadlift/row by doing more pull ups will not really help in targeting lower back muscle, more on upper backs.. rowing can be done alternately wif pull ups however but best done both..

Each exercise has its own advantage..use it wisely..
jimlim007
post Feb 1 2013, 12:04 PM

Enoch
*******
Senior Member
4,073 posts

Joined: Aug 2006


QUOTE(Seasick85 @ Feb 1 2013, 09:36 AM)
It maybe an elbow joint pain..i've had it many times.. if i am not mistaken the pain feels like burning sensation instead of normal muscular soreness? To be honest, if the pain location is at the joint itself, you may need to rest and ice to relief it..keep the weights down, deload, n try various stretches..

I've had mine when working on triceps exercises.. try n see what works for u as per advice.. give it at least 2 weeks.. if getting worse, consult ur doc..

The tight cloth can help to ignore the pain only, not curing it.. unless you're on some sports competitions and can't afford lose time for recovery.. smile.gif
*
i confirmed is not the joint, is the bottom muscle near to the elbow pain. I guess i go too intense on past week, same day have workout and night go play badminton with heavy + wrong method of smashes.

hmm... i still like workout and badmintons, need to be extra careful when doing both exercises.
Nama saya Amad
post Feb 1 2013, 12:07 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
458 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


s
QUOTE(Seasick85 @ Feb 1 2013, 11:33 AM)
Really, wrong form generally results in injuries, but then again, you mentioned after two days of resting, soreness is gone indicating you only feel DOMS, normal musle soreness resulting from muscle breakdowns..it is totally normal..just need to rest n you can continue deadlift/row as u like with good form..

Ditching deadlift/row by doing more pull ups will not really help in targeting lower back muscle, more on upper backs.. rowing can be done alternately wif pull ups however but best done both..

Each exercise has its own advantage..use it wisely..
*
Hey, thanks for the words man. Appreciate it, but not sure whether to take chances or not. The soreness sometime is there, sometime is not. Whenever I start doing back exercises, I could feel it's coming. I don't want to screw up my back. sad.gif

Feels like meeting physiotherapist yawn.gif





DT1
post Feb 1 2013, 01:03 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,186 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
QUOTE(alien9 @ Jan 31 2013, 10:17 AM)
I do believe that BCAA have it's own purpose in supplement industry. The first supps that I bought is BCAA from GNC (yeah, I know  doh.gif ) to accommodate my fasted training using IF protocol. One thing that BCAA helped is that hey prevent catabolism that happened during workout since I'm training fasted and no protein source is available in the blood stream after 15 to 16 hours of training but you can't see the effect of BCAA on catabolism.

Another one thing is that I've notice the energy level by consuming BCAA against not consuming BCAA while in fasted training. Sure, it must be something if it gives energy (Placebo effect, IDK).

But one thing for sure, Marc Lobliner (Ex CEO of Scivation) have pour some huge amount of money in order to make a study on BCAAs and if you do managed to read on the researches, I'll doubt that it is fake.
*
Thanks for the reply man.

127 Pages « < 123 124 125 126 127 >Top
Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0300sec    0.91    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 24th December 2025 - 05:33 PM