QUOTE(pikacu @ Mar 1 2012, 04:02 PM)
Im talking about the app, not interested with integrated features....as you said, fail as hell

But Android stock FB app was way better than N9 stock FB app in terms of usability.
QUOTE(Upsilon @ Mar 1 2012, 04:03 PM)
well, some of the webOS guy went to android camp, i guess they are heading the right direction in terms of UX
metro ui is awesome, but since it is marketed as 'windows', i don't feel like getting one lo, got very sick of windows :/ but they are indeed doing mobile OS the right way, finally
Added on March 1, 2012, 4:04 pmfb app feels snappy, but still not as full-featured as touch.facebook.com
The flat-2D style UX gives me a weird feeling, until I discovered a bug when I first play with the phone... It suddenly become clear to me while the UX gives me the familiar feeling, seems it's web based?
Anyway, right way or not, I think it depends on what type of user you are.
For me, definitely not; When using it, it feels like iOS, full of limitations and restrictions, honestly, I feel really stupid. I took a photo... I can't send to my friend, I can't transfer to the PC without Zune. I feel darn stupid, I can't figure out why and the reason.
It doesn't allow user to add more than 1 mobile number; as a sofware giant that provide database and developments tools, I feel stupid again. It feels like this is not done by microsoft, but some fresh graduate who don't understand database design.
In short, I personally feel it's not a good choice for TRUE smartphone users. What is a smartphone when it's first introduced? I still remember the first Windows Mobile phone MPX100, I attended the MS developer event at Sunway ages ago, it was definitely not the same as current Windows Phone. Current Windows Phone, it feels like someone trying to follow what everything iOS has done just because it's famous without considering what user actually wants.
You can follow the GOOD of iOS, but you don't have to follow the BAD of iOS. In this case, it feels like they blindly follow everything.
The only nice thing I find is the People Hub.... but still,... there's like still a lot of things to be done.
Well, I also like their voice command feature.
Anyway, I passed to one of my colleague. After using for 1 day, he come back to me: I don't know what to write about this phone.... I don't find anything nice, it feels like those old Nokia phones (as in old OS which can't do much). Sad, but true.
Quite a few people also ask me, how the Windows Phone, empty like iOS? And what's special about it? The selling point.
I guess the main selling point is People Hub as of now, but it depends who the users are. For TRUE smartphone users, "usually", they want more; but for those that don't bother about flexibility and just want a simple, smooth smartphone, Windows Phone is a good choice (so does N9, except for the lack of apps/games).
For many people, a reliable phone is still important, and Android fail in this department, you need very high spec hardware with huge amount of ram to have a smoother experience, but it doesn't stop the device from issues like "Force Close" or lag. The "smart" memory management is too smart, auto close for you, sooo darn smart, who ask it to close kill the app I still need? And soo smart, kill your homescreen and restart, kill your call function? So smart. Imagine you need to make a call, and the phone decide to lag and slow to respond.
So, in this case, many user get frustrated, it's not they don't want the flexibility, it's because those OS are failure in prioritizing the important process and provide smoother experience.
This is a phone, no matter what process is running, the phone process should have high priority and user can access it easily and quick; But seems they fail to get this right after so many years.
Only iOS which have quick and easy "Home" button which easily bring you back to the main screen and access the telephone and it's smooth.
Windows Phone also have something similar and it's smooth.
N9 also similar, just that it lacks in app/games and it's consider a COLD phone right now. It's just too bad; In future, seems only 3 OS in the game? iOS, WP and Android. All also not very good.