QUOTE(IccyAsd @ Jan 31 2012, 04:12 PM)
yeah, actually i have looked at the darksouls wiki regarding weapons to forge it doesnt really looks ultimate... i mean the dmg look at quelaag fury +5 @ 90 physical+255 fire with B dex scalling, if i didnt boost dex it would also means min scalling dmg. my large club +10 is atleast 400dmg with 180 poison effect A str scalling at 29str ... i mean for me i like range+dmg.
i think Greatsword of Artorias is not for me, i have 12 int & 8 faith =/ as a pyro
btw what do we do to the left over boss souls? if i only need 1? consume it ?
Added on January 31, 2012, 4:34 pmwell i think im going for Greatshield of Artorias & Great Lord Greatsword...(argh this looks like its final boss soul i wonder whats the point of making it other than going NG+?)
One of the reason's why quelagg is really good is that it swings fast and it doesn't use much endurance, so with the club it's 2 swings per endurance bar (I'm just guessing as it depends on how much endurance you have), whereas with queelag's furysword you can swing 4-7 times. in MMO speak while damage per swing is important (moreso for pvp), it's the damage per second that's important.
also with my +10 dagger i'm critting for close to 700 damage with 300 bleed on the unarmored mobs and i've not levelled my stats yet since i started

But then my playstyle is to go for backstabs and parry/ripostes.
Anyway, i recommend trying the furysword anyway since the other boss weapon alternatives with queelag's suck really bad.
I don't recommend consuming boss souls especially since it's so easy to get souls nowadays anyway. And the point of the greatsword is for NG+