I think thats really harsh. There is nothing wrong with singing a Christian song (this is America after all, and KLC is that all American girl personality), which was also good song by any measure.

I think its weeks like this which are the toughest. The ones who usually deliver consistent great performances visibly falter (Carly, Cook, Brooke), while the 'underdogs' blew it out of the water. Do you kick out the consistent ones over a poor performance, or punish an improving contestant? Tough pick.


Burga - who honestly thinks its Brooke's turn to go this week, as she has been rather boring the past few weeks.

KLCC - kristy lee cook COOKS.. well.. she was her usual ..'perky' self... sang well too...
yeah david cook a bit letdown this week but he'll still go thru.
JC should go first before Brooke IMHO...

2nite no elimination rite??

This post has been edited by EroS: Apr 10 2008, 10:52 AM

It's totally okay with me if she wants to sing a Christian song. But it's the personality that matters, especially when it comes to an inspirational song like this, which I think she lacks.

The other time Castro sang "Hallelujah", he didn't just sang it well, but it felt heartfelt which comes hand in hand with that song choice. KLC for me, is just singing that song to draw votes, and not because she means it, just like the time she sang the "patriotic" song.

I think - Carly will be voted out this week. Sad, but most probable. And she really needs to listen to Simon's advice and find a new fashion consultant. I know she was trying to pull off a Freddie Mercury attire last night, but it was horrendous.

OMG David Cook actually sang one of my fav Our Lady Peace's song,

yeah its IDOL GIVES BACK special show

---

Added on April 10, 2008, 12:44 pmanother great one hit wonder


This post has been edited by skylinegtr34rule4life: Apr 10 2008, 12:44 PM

Actually I think she was pretty in the zone with it. As for personality, I think Syesha comes up even shorter in that department (as did Ramiele) and Brooke's is somehow slightly annoying imo. I think its clear that Americana is really her element, and if it happens to draw votes, she's smart to choose it.

This post has been edited by BurgaFlippinMan: Apr 10 2008, 01:28 PM

what the... Our Lady Peace aint a one hit wonder band, I guess u've only heard of this song from the band, but dont label them as 'one hit wonders'....

I actually thought KLC sang pretty well this week. I think this is the first time I actually liked her performance
But my fav was Jason's one.
I'm with Burga. It'll be a tough elimination this week. I've a feeling Carly's in trouble but i hope she gets through.

are you sure? then how come i dont hear any of their new hits on radio these days?

Malaysian radio sucks, so don't compare good music with the music you hear on the radio.

And also that many hits abroad arent hits here.

Which I dunno whether it's a good thing or not. Most of my friends don't share the same taste as mine, but in the mean time, that separates me from the radio listeners

Wow... I have watched only 1 hour of the Idol Gives Back and I feel really sorry for the less fortunate. It makes us think about other people who have absolutely nothing in this world.

The kids who have no playground and can't enjoy themselves because of strong gang-related violence.

That lady who lost all her 3 daughters.

That family of brothers who have no parents and no grandparents, depending only on their eldest brother who is even younger than I am.

That was the last. I turned off the TV.

This post has been edited by almattitude_v1: Apr 10 2008, 07:24 PM

I usually can't be bothered. I love movie scores, the Beatles, some indie stuff....thats it.

what did ryan say after simon said that he doesnt have chihuahuas? i dint get that.

& are they always only helping the africans & most of their own ppl. why not help arfganistan, bosnia & all those other countries that seriously needs as much help?

Then truth is we can't help everyone. Arfgan is too sensitive to be helped anyway.

afghan & iraqis need to help themselves first by stop fighting among them.


btw, the highlight was the appearance of the russian idol

stalin's fav song is "every move you make, i'll be watching you"

Top 8 Performance Live & Studio is available now:
http://viz4u.blogspot.com

OMG!! OMG!! OMG!!