Vidic! Urat dawai tulang besi

This post has been edited by johnjenin: Sep 20 2007, 10:55 AM

after this..got many thread comparing which forwards, midfieders,defenders is the best..erm...kinda useless thread....

this thread present me with a rare opportunity to use this smilies

with Vidic's occasional blunders and Agger's not reaching his true potential yet, i would go for Toure and Terry anytime.

mods, boleh tutup tak? kinda useless ler this thread, no?

it's a waste of time trying to discuss who's better. it's all biased opinions here.

Use players comparison on Football Manager 2007/08 laaaa

victor andrag pawns all....

hah>>>??


to me vidic is better...but u can combine each of their advantages, they will be complete CB!
agger have cun left foot, can shoot like a midfielder/striker,vidic can head without fear, so combine, they are complete !

I tried not to be drawn into this argument but my resistance proved futile. I like both of them for different reasons. Vidic is more straightforward and no nonsense, much like our Carra. Agger on the other hand has a better touch and plays the ball more ala Alan Hansen. Both can score, Vidic with his head and Agger more with his feet. Both have also been prone to errors but with experience, they will only get better. As for who I prefer, I'll go with Agger because I feel he complements the more straight forward Jamie Carragher.

lol!he is the kedah defender rite?

as a liverpool fan...
i go for Vidic too...
he can score goals from conners or freekicks...
he is strong in the air....

his characteristic makes me feel like he is a very good candidate for the movie "300"....SPARTAA !!!!
LOL...

then why u even bother to post then since u got no opinion?




VIDIC! anytime of the day, current performance Vidic outrun agger, but agger too doing very good. vidic's header last epl game is awesome.

yeah man kinda think of it, i think ur right,he really suits, haha

two of them will make a ideal partner at the back..

one with a great header and another one with a good long shot...

both of them still young but Vidic is better than Agger especially his physical and tackle..

BTW i am liverpool fan..Vidic is a good player tat is no-nonsense type..rather than some defender would give a rough comments

this thread need poll.

ya..

but tat make no sense...man.utd fan is majority here

Yeap. Just like how Vidic complements Rio for Man Utd.

Actually there is no fix/default guidelines on deciding who is better? How to consider as better? In what sense? In terms of shooting skill like Agger? Or heading skill during setpiece like Vidic?

How nice if there's a way to merge their ability together

This post has been edited by alien2003: Sep 20 2007, 04:47 PM

i'll go for Vidic... he got the ability in the air , no nonsense , read the game well and score vital goals.

i choose vidic too as same reason with most of u all but agger will make better partnership with carra. I think agger have lots of potential to develop himself into one of the better defender, vidic seem to already reach his limits. anyway, its just my opinion