when it comes 2 defence it is essential to have a partnership. wt a partnership one can cover each other weakness. so it can compliment wt one another. if both player is too similar thn thy will go 4 the same ball tht eventually will lead 2 a mistake. so both player hav their own qualities which will make a good partnership if thy were 2 play together.

If you put Ferdinand on the line with another player, you may get a different answer. But ATM, I would do anything for us to get a Sergio Ramos. We desperately need a top class right back to replace Gary.

useless thread..shut it down..

I agreed with Vidic a better player...for now at least. His aerial ability is good not to mention he scores more goals.

Vidic head + Agger left foot , complete defender

i agree that vidic is a more straight forward and no nonsense player... but i kinda like Agger style of play...

but the bottom line is, defender should be defender and no nonsense is what defenders should be! haha VIDIC!

dont have a poll?

no need poll la sure vidic won the poll since they're a lot of mu fans

agger is a nonsense player?

lorr...just try it out..then we know the actual result..anyway, its just my opinion..

As an arsenal fan, personally I feel Vidic is a better player, but that's because he plays alongside Ferdinand. But I really remember the mistakes he did against 3-0 trashing of AC Milan last season. He played horribly, wrong-time tackles, not marking Kaka & etc. But overall, when he's on top gear, he's good defensively. & not to forget, he's a good header in set-pieces. As for Agger, well, he's still young & can improve. Amazing cracker against West Ham last season. Haha... So, the verdict, both are ok-ok defender. Without Ferdinand or Carragher alongside them, i think they'll stuggle...

kolo toure - pace, strength, influence, bought cheap, etc lol

Daniel Alves would be a more realistic option.

I still like Ramos more. I know we wont get him but I am just saying if I had it my way

no centre defender lives by himself...

so many people worship Kaiser Franz Beckenbauer but dont forget Vogts doing all the dirty work

Hansen is always remembered as the skillful elegant defender but he will thank Lawrenson, the tough robust tackling defender...

At one point, even Pahang has a player called alan davidson...calm cool sweeper, but dont forget how the non nonsense Sellehudin Che ros as his stopper

Soh Chin aun maybe the greatest but how effective is he without Santokh Singh?


Its difficult to say Vidic better or Agger

Vidic complements Rio very well. Agger is developing into a true partner for the straightforward safety first Carragher. .

both are nice player....great quality signing....can't figure out who is the best player since they both play well so far...

This post has been edited by juniortit@n: Sep 20 2007, 11:56 PM

i prefer vidic as he is more aggresive

Correct, just like all the other players who like to play the ball more, like Ronaldinho, Messi, Henry, etc. Wonder what they're doing playing for top sides.

Yeah I do agree with ya there. Ramos is class. I'm still worried who would step up to the plate once Gary's gone. Brown? Nah, not good enuff

westham.
on the other hand...agger n vidic who scores more goals???
I tink agger rite???
as vidic only scores from header and corner only...
though CB is not judged from the amount of goals they scored...

This post has been edited by pandazhun: Sep 21 2007, 08:16 PM