I tried not to be drawn into this argument but my resistance proved futile. I like both of them for different reasons. Vidic is more straightforward and no nonsense, much like our Carra. Agger on the other hand has a better touch and plays the ball more ala Alan Hansen. Both can score, Vidic with his head and Agger more with his feet. Both have also been prone to errors but with experience, they will only get better. As for who I prefer, I'll go with Agger because I feel he complements the more straight forward Jamie Carragher.