QUOTE(killerizm @ Mar 5 2019, 02:27 PM)
Hi, I need some advice from a Zelda fan who has played most of the series installments. I wanna know if BotW is a game for me.
I've never played a single Zelda game growing up (sad childhood). Recently I thought I'd try getting into the series starting with Ocarina of Time 3D. Not a fan of the previous 2D top down installments. Going into half of OoT (maybe half? After grown up Link.), I'm starting to get bored of its repetitive and almost similar dungeon format concept of "enter dungeon> solve puzzles> get key/map> kill boss> get gem/medallion". The main quests involving main dungeons felt generally similar in pattern to me and felt more restrictive compared to side quests in open world that spans throughout multiple areas. I do however enjoy some of the side quests and minigames such as the gold skulltulas, fishing, getting horse, and the mask shop quest.
So in terms of the dungeon system, how similar is BotW to OoT or to any other previous Zelda installments? Is there more freedom and diversity for the player to solve puzzles, taking on enemies and bosses? Is BotW for me?
Not sure if I should ask this here or on the BotW thread but since here more active I'll try asking here first. Thanks in advance for any sort of advice.

I've played almost every Zelda games, except Skyward Sword on the Wii, and the first 2 zelda games on the NES.
Now to answer your question, BOTW and OOT are very different games.
In OOT (or any classic Zelda games) you gain special tools by defeating bosses in dungeons to unlock next area to explore and progress. The game is very linear, you will not be able to progress unless you did what the game wants you to do, although you are free to explore the area you have opened up, finding secrets and stuff so near the end of the game you pretty much have an "open world" to explore. I liked what it is for its time, but the game mechanics can be very clunky by today's standard.
BOTW, it is a modern openworld sandbox game like it's been said, all the special tools are open up to you in the first hour of playing, you're then given the freedom use these tools to progress however you like, you can go wherever you want, do whatever you want, even go straight to the final boss , but be prepare to get your ass whooped.
There are only 4 main dungeons with 4 bosses and one final boss(correct me if I'm wrong, I have not finished the game yet), but the world is also packed with 120 mini dungeons (shrines) that you have to find yourself if you crave for more and you will want to do this because solving them is the only way to gain heart pieces and stamina. About diversity, some times there are more than 1 way to solve a puzzle, you just have to be creative with the tools given to you. There are also some mini boss scattered all over the world. The main quest here is to figure out your way to the 4 main dungeons, beat the 4 bosses, then to the final boss. As for the side quests and mini games, there are some but they are not that memorable imo, and sadly, no fishing, you can swim to catch them or bomb the hell out of them, that's pretty much about it.
To sum it all up, you are thrown into this world almost butt naked, you explore, beat shrines, upgrade yourself, hunt monsters/mini bosses/animals, gather loots, equipment and food, figure out how to traverse to the next area you want to go, repeat. Now it may sound boring but it is actually a lot of fun because of how well the world is crafted, there is so much to do.
Unlike the other Zelda games tho, there is very little story element in this game, most are told via flashbacks, in fact I think the game wants you to learn about the world and its lore by interacting with NPCs and exploring the world yourself.
So, will you like the game? I don't know, if you enjoy open world game that is all about exploration and survival, then you will probably like it. Think about Witcher3/RDR2/Skyrim with much less story, something like that. I love the game, but I am a bit disappointed at the same time, they added so much but also removed so much that made the earlier games great, like a much more engaging story. But Link's Awakening is coming, played that a lot on my huge gameboy when I was a kid.
This post has been edited by Kellicros: Mar 12 2019, 06:11 PM