Its almost pointless for this discussion.
What you say is great. You got a good jump start. That's you have to thank whoever give you this exposure.
When you have your job, your family, your kids, and eventually your parents that need your care. That's the time you realize. What your concept telling only applicable to those who are young, and do not have any high commitment yet.
Everyone have their own portfolio in saving or even go to investment. You cant say those who not agree to you is entirely wrong. Or those who agree with you are your allies.
Every family have different condition.
As long a we have our own portfolio that can give us a good future. That's it. Y'all cant force people going to this and that. Y'all cant change people is doing the correct thing. Yes, one may save less than you, less wealth than you, as long as they happy, and doing thing all right. What's the problem?
Not everyone want to become the slave of the money.
I rather the money work for me according to my wish.
I have that amount, I save that, from small perhaps in 10 years only able to buy some good stocks. Buying stock now is impossible for me.
I have my work, my study, my ptptn to pay off, my parents etc etc. Thus, I save bit by bit using my own instrument.
Sometimes I need vacation, I go, I need some good food for my parents I buy, I need to have my favourite gadget, I buy once in a blue moon, my car serve me well, that also I service accordingly. Why the hell I need to be the slave of money?
ASx and FSM is now my favourite. Why because this is the only I can save bit by bit. And at the same time open up radar on prop.
When come to investment, no one is wrong and no one is entirely correct.
Those in which initially rich and have a decent jobs for years, yes you can but this and that.
Why not you turn your perception on a middle income family, that have people to feed?
Hell no way you ask that person to quit his job and become plumber or barber in AU. That's a very high risk gambling. For me if that person have their own prop, car, FD. For me its good. And let their kid to have good edu in overseas, that's good.
And come to comparing, eliminate the jumpstart heaven package, people living in urban and living in outskirt have hell lot of different.
A friend of mine, a gov school teacher, she herself is a good saver and previously working in small district in Pahang, for 6 years. Save like mad, but having small vacation in MY thrice a year. Eat well, all well. Transfer to big city in KV can buy a 2 storey house and a myvi. So that's a bad saving huh? If she go stock market sure become Jack Ma? No, because she has no knowledge and people to teach her. Ands even yes, she may can go wrong, all saving become what? Dust? You can say she isn't good enough why no do homework etcetc. Now you have to know diff job have diff work load.
Teacher nowadays not easy also. 6 am to 4 pm. Go back home need do paperwork. Hold a few position in school. Then weekend need go school tuition. Prepare paper work. If I am she, I rather have my free time to relax. Hell no read index and news.
But those big bosses earn big money without doing anything, they deserve a slap then.
Its all down to your perception. You rich you lucky. If no rich, start from bottom slow and steady. From local derivative to foreign exposure. That's it. why so hurry and becoming slave to currency?
For me ASx is doing the right job. They provide something better than FD at least. Cant beat inflation rate is beyond my advise.
Want quit, its ok. Don't say this is bad and what not.
Don't want quit, just continue. And combine with other investment instrument.
I already mentioned one does not need a lot of money to start. Don't forget that I was a student with limited budget. What I save up over the years. I have put it to work. Even if you save RM300/month, that's RM3600/year. That's enough to get starting.
As I mentioned no need for overseas bank account. If can get one it's a bonus.
The thing is to get starting. If one invest in RM whether in bursa/fsm/amanah saham, one gets only RM which is depreciating on a yearly basis.
The same money if park overseas and put it to work, over time when you need to bring it back to malaysia would have gain significantly vs just parking in malaysian instruments if both have the same returns.
Eg.
Amanah saham fixed price fund 6%. Money is in RM. No forex gain.
SG stocks/AU stocks/HK stocks at 6% dividend (possible if you buy at depressed price) Money in foreign currency. Over time when bring back to malaysia (when needed for kids edu), may have forex gain of say 25%. I am not putting in capital appreciation for simplicity in calculation. That's a lot of return vs 0% forex gain. Money in RM will need to work harder to get the 25% edge for kids education.
- SG and HK are tax free for everything. Which means you get 100% dividend and their govt is not taking your returns.
- SG, HK, AU does not have inheritance tax.
- AU have 30% withholding tax but their generous dividend payout sort of cancel it.
Use warchest to deploy when needed (amanah saham). Never liquidate when the time is not right. Use emergency cash (again amanah saham) to fund your emergency stuff.
The reason I said use amanah saham is so that instant liquidity and money is working at maximum rate compare to FD/SA.