QUOTE(Michael J. @ Aug 22 2012, 09:17 AM)
As far as I know, most growers of gaharu/agarwood/aquilaria/eaglewood had mixed success. Some had moderate success, while many others have failed. The scientist from FRIM who pioneered its mass propagation himself had indicated doubt of its long term success. He has since left FRIM for greener pastures.
The problem is not so much with growing the aquilaria tree itself, or mass production of the plant. It has to do with the fungus used to inoculate the tree for the production of the gaharu, and the technology involved with getting the gaharu flowing. It is unreliable.
Let me list out some of the hurdles for successful gaharu production:
(i) Species and clonal variety of aquilaria tree. This is very important, as gaharu production depends heavily on the inoculated fungus infecting the tree and causing a response. In other words, you want clonal varieties that have proven record of successful infection AND production of the gaharu. So far, the success of this has been very low, even within FRIM. The best results I've seen is with an on-going project at UNIMAS, and even then, they have yet to release anything just yet. According to the scientist, it will take another 5 years or more before something concrete can be developed.
(ii) Inoculation technique. There as many techniques out there as there are species of aquilaria, and probably more. In other words, no one way has proven to have any greater success over the other. In fact, most techniques give very low results, about 7%-10% of inoculated trees forming the gaharu resin which is prized.
(iii) Quality and quantity. This is a standard problem in any industry and sector, more so in biology-based systems like farms and plantations. You just never know how much product you can expect, or what grade it will be. Of course, it would be convenient to brush this aspect aside by saying all agriculture ventures are likewise risky; however, with other agriculture ventures, you can actually see the production taking place (eg. how many eggs a day produced by poultry, how many oil palm fruit bunches on the palm, etc.). With gaharu production, you will never know until you've chopped down the tree and exposed the heartwood. If the said infection had failed, and the gaharu resin had not formed, then you've just killed a tree for no apparent reason. Not to mention the amount of time and resources wasted to grow it to harvesting stage.
I don't feel the need to list out too much, as I believe the gist of the matter has been adequately covered. Now, it is very important to be able to separate truth from myth, so please, do in depth research (from primary sources) on the subject matter beforehand. If the statement that "everything has a pricetag" holds true, then it would be prudent for anyone to first understand how that "pricetag" first came into being.
At this moment I can only say that it's a hardy plant and I don't see any trouble planting these. Planted some early this year (March, I think). Some are growing fast. Have rescued some from Herbicide injuries and some overgrown, fully covered with weeds. They are starting to grow now. These were gifts from a friend. Anyway, this is only a supplementary crop.The problem is not so much with growing the aquilaria tree itself, or mass production of the plant. It has to do with the fungus used to inoculate the tree for the production of the gaharu, and the technology involved with getting the gaharu flowing. It is unreliable.
Let me list out some of the hurdles for successful gaharu production:
(i) Species and clonal variety of aquilaria tree. This is very important, as gaharu production depends heavily on the inoculated fungus infecting the tree and causing a response. In other words, you want clonal varieties that have proven record of successful infection AND production of the gaharu. So far, the success of this has been very low, even within FRIM. The best results I've seen is with an on-going project at UNIMAS, and even then, they have yet to release anything just yet. According to the scientist, it will take another 5 years or more before something concrete can be developed.
(ii) Inoculation technique. There as many techniques out there as there are species of aquilaria, and probably more. In other words, no one way has proven to have any greater success over the other. In fact, most techniques give very low results, about 7%-10% of inoculated trees forming the gaharu resin which is prized.
(iii) Quality and quantity. This is a standard problem in any industry and sector, more so in biology-based systems like farms and plantations. You just never know how much product you can expect, or what grade it will be. Of course, it would be convenient to brush this aspect aside by saying all agriculture ventures are likewise risky; however, with other agriculture ventures, you can actually see the production taking place (eg. how many eggs a day produced by poultry, how many oil palm fruit bunches on the palm, etc.). With gaharu production, you will never know until you've chopped down the tree and exposed the heartwood. If the said infection had failed, and the gaharu resin had not formed, then you've just killed a tree for no apparent reason. Not to mention the amount of time and resources wasted to grow it to harvesting stage.
I don't feel the need to list out too much, as I believe the gist of the matter has been adequately covered. Now, it is very important to be able to separate truth from myth, so please, do in depth research (from primary sources) on the subject matter beforehand. If the statement that "everything has a pricetag" holds true, then it would be prudent for anyone to first understand how that "pricetag" first came into being.



Aug 22 2012, 10:01 PM

Quote




0.0669sec
1.90
7 queries
GZIP Disabled