QUOTE(maraippo @ Jun 11 2016, 06:05 PM)
Ulama just tells people what is ok and what is not.
To do or not to do is up to the people themselves.
Unless its a mentioned ban in quran like zina, homosexual, theft, etc then is punishable. Other than that is depend on other law.
Like the issue of summons for woman wearing tight, i'd say its overkill. But as to why they decide to implement it? Maybe they thought its an alternative to reduce the rape statistics. Well, at least its a prevention. Maybe backwards, but thats they way they think of.
But does it say in Islam to punish those dress unmodestly, no.
Is it hudud? Then again, no.
Personally, if it's not in the Quran I don't really care what those songkok haji says.To do or not to do is up to the people themselves.
Unless its a mentioned ban in quran like zina, homosexual, theft, etc then is punishable. Other than that is depend on other law.
Like the issue of summons for woman wearing tight, i'd say its overkill. But as to why they decide to implement it? Maybe they thought its an alternative to reduce the rape statistics. Well, at least its a prevention. Maybe backwards, but thats they way they think of.
But does it say in Islam to punish those dress unmodestly, no.
Is it hudud? Then again, no.
As for those health bit, it's true that alcohol and tobacco create a cancer risk but then again I got skin cancer because exposure to sunlight.
Jun 11 2016, 10:14 PM

Quote
0.0141sec
0.58
5 queries
GZIP Disabled