QUOTE(TheLegend27 @ May 19 2020, 08:45 AM)
ya, this is what i mean. a lot of switch i saw mostly is touch switch instead of tactile switch. so a lot of tactile switch but need neutral to work on. so thinking if those switch that need neutral cable, possible to be done by install capacitor?
Actually you should ask why smart switch without neutral line can work?
Smart switch is powered device, it requires power, a basic electrical knowledge tells you, a powered device require a electrical loop in order to let current complete a cycle.
so, a smart switch without a neutral means it does not have a loop, which mean no current flow through it! how come it can draw power?
Smart switch requires power, but it only requires a small amount of power, usually less than few watts, smart engineer hence design the smart switch to be always closed (slightly connected both hot wires with small current) even the switch is normally open, in this case, it establish the loop and powered the smart switch.
Now, next question, since the smart switch is always closed and let small amount of current go through it, why the lights do not turn on? because current also flow through lights, it should be on.
The key point is small amount of current, most bulb/CFL requires certain amount of current to flow through it in order to generate light, the small amount of current is not big enough to power the bulb/CFL to emit lights, so smart switch allows small amount of current to pass through it but the current does not have enough power to turn on the lights. clever design right?
The problem here is when this type of smart switch encounter small LED which only requires few watts to turn on, since this type of LED will turn on even a small amount current pass through it, hence, the LED blink or emitting small amount of lights.
That is the pass through capacitor comes in, the capacitor allows to bypass the small amount of current without flow through the LED, and problem solved.
in a nut shell, it is nothing to do with the switch apparent, whether or not it is touch or tactile.