» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
QUOTE(Albert B @ Oct 12 2015, 09:55 AM)
Radiators normally should not be the problem if there is no leak, no blockage
internally at the tubes and externally at the cooling fins. If I remember correctly
you have done flushing of the radiator. I assume there is no water loss from
your radiator i.e. no need to top up the water.
Looking at the symptoms again, I would suggest that the following things be
checked/replaced if not already done so (before proceeding with the radiator) :
1) If the 5 bars occur again, try what you did last time : switch to ACC then to
ON, and see if it resets back to 3 bars. If so, then it is not overheating problem
but is a false reading or electronics problem. (Note: not sure if the temperature
gauge sensor could be out of calibration, giving the false readings. The resistance
values are given in the Haynes manual page).
2) With cold engine, before starting, open the radiator cap. The water must be
full to the neck. This is to prove there is no air bubbles inside, and the cap return valve
is working.
3) Check the water pump belt tension. Possibility of slippage, reducing the water
circulation. This may explain why at higher speeds the problem goes away.
4) Change the radiator cap and see if any improvement. Possibility of the cap
not able to hold the pressure, and cooling efficiency drops with lower pressure.
5) Replace the thermostat. Possibility of it stuck halfway, reducing the water
circulation. Like the belt slippage, this may also explain why at higher
speeds the problem goes away.
6) Replace the fan temperature switch (the one at the bottom of the radiator).
Possibility of the switch is out of calibration causing the fan activated and cut
off at higher temperature.
Updated on new situation:
1) Using method 1 can always drop the temp meter reading and make the situation better. Anyway, had replaced the coolant temperature sensor with a new one.
2) Radiator cap supposed working quite flawlessly, has about 10000km on it, 0.88bar as opposed to stock 0.9bar. Maybe a bit lower in boiling point? And since I DIY changed parts related to cooling systems, sometimes air bleeding may not be enough, it will take in the coolant from the coolant spare tank. I guess this can prove the cap is working as it seems. Oh Yå the neck I always full, best indication of return valve is working.
3) All AUX Belts has been renewed at less than 1000km due to belt slippage, they refused to tighten so just changed it lol. Slippage only occurs during morning starts and go away after 5secs or so. Seemed to be out of suspect.
4) Refer 2.
5) Thermostat replaced as well together with coolant temperature switch. Proton Iswara LMST thermostat is 82C as compared to Haynes 88C. Old thermostat seems to be working well based on the "water stains marks".
6) Just got it replaced yesterday for fan temp switch. Spare part shops selling 90C ones, and matches with Haynes manual.
However things seems to get worse since after replaced fan switch. I supposed the original proton fan switch might had cut in at a lower temp. The original switch has none markings, which makes it more difficult to trace what temp it is unless I have a thermometer with me. For the moment it'll be 4bar on normal driving. Yet radiator fan can kick out even sometimes it reaches 5 bar blinking.
EDIT: No signs of boiling as coolant will sure overflow the tank or boilling sounds can be heard from engine bay.
Now i'm suspecting radiator fan is weak. However based on my logic and understanding after a month of DIY and troubleshooting, got some ques in my head...
1) If fan is weak, the cooling of radiator would not be as fast, therefore needs longer time to cool, fan switch will keep the fan on, therefore fan should stay on longer, but still cools the system. If the fan is really really weak, it should be on always as the fan switch would be always activated. Therefore no need to change fan motor.
2) Since the fan switch still turns off the fan. If fan is weak, the cooling is not a fast as intended, resulting slower cooling of the system, and maybe the "a bit slow" of cooling results in big difference of an aging cooling system which makes it to 4-5bar? Therefore, need to change the fan motor.
3) Question is, is the fan motor weak? Using hand "feeling" compared to another LMST, the "wind" feeling is similar and doesn't seem to be weak. But may give a try to change as at a certain 800-900rpm, can hear slight bearing noise when fan kicks in. the bearing noise is not present when air con fan kicks in though.
4) Based on observation, radiator doesn't seem to be clogged yet, as when draining the cooling system, by leaving radiator cap open and drain valve open, the water just gushes out immediately. Therefore the radiator may still have quite some life on it.
5) Will go back to the old fan switch if found out the stock fan switch has much lower cut in temperature.
6) OR after all it is the coolant sensor/electrical/meter problem? I'm quite puzzled already. Resistance check on sensor is OK, but might be due to meter / sensor grounding. Using a multimeter, it seems that grounding for the sensor to firewall and sensor to battery shows no resistance at all. And had a looked at forums suggested adding additional grounding to meter. I think not achievable unless by splicing meter wire, my last resort i'll say.
This post has been edited by cyanboy: Oct 23 2015, 04:09 PM