Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

5 Pages « < 2 3 4 5 >Bottom

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Is working in Australia all that great?

views
     
LightningFist
post Aug 31 2014, 02:37 PM

Minion of the Damned
Group Icon
VIP
3,965 posts

Joined: Apr 2009
QUOTE(don391 @ Aug 28 2014, 03:41 PM)
I've been here for around half a year now. So far so good, haven't get a any racism remarks (and hope never will). Then again, its the case of grass greener on the other side. Neither Malaysia nor Australia (or any other countries) is perfect. Not like you never seen racism in Malaysia. Before I got to aussie, lots of my friends told me be careful might get aim for no reason, but until today I haven't seen anyone kena racist remarks.. yet.

But if you talk about culture, experience, money, etc. I would say Australia seems to have the upper hand. A simple example. Fresh grad malaysia 2.7k-3k and Aus roughly the same. Malaysia you buy iPhone one month salary gone. Australia you buy iPhone $1k. same price but your purchasing power stronger.

Culture wise, Malaysia *ahem* guy keep saying 1Malaysia, but in Sydney its even more diverse. There's Mainland chinese, Korean, Japanese, Indian, Caucasian, Europeans, Malaysians, Indonesian, etc etc. and the seem to get along better than we do tongue.gif

Experience wise, it totally depends on yourself. I would say some I like, some I don't. You can't get everything.

My advice, got chance go oversea, try it out! biggrin.gif
*
It is this positive attitude that temporary entrants (students or temporary workers) and migrants and potential migrants need to carry with them when they come to Australia. As a migrant you shouldn't be complaining very much, or behaving in such a way that gives migrants a bad name. Just be grateful. As a taxpayer I know how difficult or unfair it can feel sometimes, but there is always a price to pay.

Australian society gets about 200,000 migrants per year. Not all of this is "skilled migration" (it makes a small difference to the demographics). This puts understandable pressure on Australian society.

QUOTE(Babizz @ Aug 29 2014, 01:45 AM)
my friend just started work in Sydney pay on a dollar to dollar basis is higher than msia but the cost of living ($ to $) is higher as well.. clothes there are not 3 times cheaper!!

A close friend who migrated last year with more than RM10 mil isn't enjoying life though.. diff ppl have diff experiences.. My family there is alright although its not easy to find a job in Aussie(unlike Malaysia)

I think aussie is alright other than the exorbitant cost of living due to the high minimum wage.
*
That's a lot of cash, 3 mil.
segamatboy
post Aug 31 2014, 08:37 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
637 posts

Joined: Feb 2008

The reality is that in many parts of Asia, the system allows people to steal other people's idea and get away with it. This could be the primary reason why Chinese are 'kiasu'.Eg. Several years ago, my cousin did the donkey work...research and type up the report. Her supervisor read it, erased my cousin name, put his name on the report, signed it and passed it off as his own. My cousin was livid. It was between her vs the supervisor . Guess who the senior managers sided with and who was shown the door for being the trouble maker??? Cousins working in Singapore are also saying the same thing



QUOTE(maxmillion @ Aug 30 2014, 09:09 PM)


If you did the most brilliant piece of analysis at work, and only you knew about it, did you actually do the work? Answer: The answer is no you didn’t. If no one knows about your work, if you don’t share it, tell people about it, no matter how technically brilliant you are, in everyone’s mind, you and your work don’t exist. This isn’t about shameless self-promotion which I know is what the majority of you are thinking, this is about communicating. I was hired for this function, I did this work, and it probably is valuable. Now I need to be proactive about sharing that work, rather than just sending an email to my boss, or waiting for my boss to tell me what do . The reality is, culture and the Malaysian education system brought most of you up to obedient followers and not question anything. Just do you work and speak when i tell you to speak.

*
maxmillion
post Sep 1 2014, 07:07 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
73 posts

Joined: Jul 2011
QUOTE(segamatboy @ Aug 31 2014, 08:37 PM)
The reality is that in many parts of Asia, the system allows  people to steal other people's idea and get away with it. This could be the primary reason why Chinese are 'kiasu'.Eg.  Several years ago, my cousin did the donkey work...research and type up the report. Her supervisor read it, erased my cousin name, put his name on the report, signed it and passed it off as his own. My cousin was livid. It was between her  vs the supervisor . Guess who the senior managers sided with and who was shown the door for being the trouble maker??? Cousins working in Singapore are also saying the same thing
*
Not disputing what happened to your cousin, and whether it was wrong or right.

Let me challenge your thinking slightly though. If a CEO comes in and turns around a company, do you think he did it alone with his own ideas? No, he succeeded because of everyone else's ideas and people doing donkey work. His value add, was recognizing great ideas and empowering people to do the work. A CEO (even a lowly team manager) cannot be successful by him/herself. You don't climb the corporate ladder from stealing silver bullet ideas here and there. Getting to the top and being successful at the top is so much more than about having these single grand ideas. There's a much more significant social component which Asians just don't get and misjudge as company politics.

Are there bad managers who don't give credit where credit is due? Absolutely. Not disagreeing. Sounds like what happened to your cousin. But by that same token, what does whinging and complaining about it get you? Absolutely nothing. That's why you have to share and talk about your work with many others. Not do the work, give to your boss and wait for him to tell you what to do next. If you were socially attuned to what your boss was like, you could have taken pre-emptive steps to socialize work for feedback, for sharing, and to protect your domain.

At the end of the day, you can view the corporate world in two ways

- A series of transactional, adversarial zero sum interactions (if one person gains, another must lose). No such thing as generosity. Only for angmohs and the weak. I contend most asians view life this way. Truth be told, if I was raised in Malaysia, I would be bitter like this as well. God we love to complain about everything, even me. Unapologetically.

OR

- You can view life as a series of continuing relationships where you dont necessarily have had to have had the upperhand every single time. If you live life sharing without the expectations of being rewarded, I guarantee you'll find life much more bearable and people will view you far more favorably.

I know you now probably think I'm full of doggy do at this point. But you know what man, that's cool. I've lived my life in the second manner, both in Australia, and while working in KL and Jakarta. It has served me well. Just sharing my perspective on life.




This post has been edited by maxmillion: Sep 1 2014, 07:23 PM
feynman
post Sep 1 2014, 08:04 PM

Look at all my stars!!
Group Icon
Elite
4,781 posts

Joined: Dec 2004
QUOTE(Babizz @ Aug 29 2014, 01:45 AM)
my friend just started work in Sydney pay on a dollar to dollar basis is higher than msia but the cost of living ($ to $) is higher as well.. clothes there are not 3 times cheaper!!

A close friend who migrated last year with more than RM10 mil isn't enjoying life though.. diff ppl have diff experiences.. My family there is alright although its not easy to find a job in Aussie(unlike Malaysia)

I think aussie is alright other than the exorbitant cost of living due to the high minimum wage.
*
Individual expectations. RM10M is enough to live a middle class life.

Many want to move to Sydney and Melbourne and still want a big house. That means less money to be used elsewhere. Moving out of Melbourne or Sydney is not a bad thing. There are always jobs, just not the prestigious ones.
SUSGazprom200
post Sep 1 2014, 09:49 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
849 posts

Joined: Aug 2014


QUOTE(maxmillion @ Aug 30 2014, 09:09 PM)
As for the point about bamboo ceiling – I think this is a cop out. I am starting to believe this is a byproduct of Asian Confucius culture i.e. respect, not question elders, savings face and all that. There are a bunch of successful Indian CEOs in fortune 500s (Pepsi Co, Microsoft, McKinsey). No yellow faces. Why? The corporate world isn’t just simply about being technically competent and expecting to be promoted every 2-3 years because you do the same thing day in day out (like maybe in Japan). It’s about building personal relationships which is hard for Malaysians to do I Australia because there is little cultural commonality that allows you to build that most basic link in the first instance (what’s cricket and afl?). Question: If you did the most brilliant piece of analysis at work, and only you knew about it, did you actually do the work? Answer: The answer is no you didn’t. If no one knows about your work, if you don’t share it, tell people about it, no matter how technically brilliant you are, in everyone’s mind, you and your work don’t exist. This isn’t about shameless self-promotion which I know is what the majority of you are thinking, this is about communicating. I was hired for this function, I did this work, and it probably is valuable. Now I need to be proactive about sharing that work, rather than just sending an email to my boss, or waiting for my boss to tell me what do . The reality is, culture and the Malaysian education system brought most of you up to obedient followers and not question anything. Just do you work and speak when i tell you to speak. I always tell this anecdote to illustrate this point. I was waiting in the autogate line at the LCCT. There were three machines. One was clearly out of order. One had no line behind it. The remaining machine had a small but growing line. I joined this line. Not wanting to wait, I asked the gentleman in front, do you know why no one is using that machine is it broken? He said he didn’t know. I waited another 30 seconds, during which time more people joined our line.  I decided it was worth trying to use the machine with no line. Guess what? It worked. Everyone just assumed it was broken. As soon as I got through, the single line split in two. Believe it or not, Australia is far more of a meritocracy than Malaysia will ever be, where if you work for anything remotely government related, you will eventually hit a bumi-ceiling. So yes, that does mean if you are a bumi, you would be unwise not to stay and take advantage of all the advantages the system provides whether explicit or not.
*
I think the above is not something exclusive to Australia. It happens everywhere in the world even in Asia (places like Malaysia, Singapore, HK, etc). Its something very generic. That is why in every society you will find that people who can "toot their own horns" tend to get promoted faster/bigger bonus/fatter increments or fatter paychecques" and these people tend to be the more talkative ones while the quieter ones are confined to one corner regardless of their capabilities.It happens everywhere not just in caucasion countries.

I also think this is also partly due to culture as Asian usually observe humility and any attempts to "toot your own horn" might be construed as being boastful, which is frowned upon in asian society. Also a saying in Asia still rings true which goes something like " the nail that sticks out gets hammered down" which essentially means one conforms with the majority instead of speaking out which compounds the problem.This is stark contrast to the general caucasion / Indian culture of acceptance of one being individualistic or having one express themselves.

thoyol
post Sep 2 2014, 04:27 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
346 posts

Joined: Sep 2007


QUOTE(manickam123 @ Aug 27 2014, 11:20 PM)
hold water? U mean hold the whole dam.

U only got one example. I got ten thousand examples. Like my cousin who is a master grad from Uni of melb, but can't get hold of an engineering job for 4 years counting. He currently works as a waiter.

Then I know a former classmate who was a top scorer in his SAM, then went on to work high position in two MNCs in Malaysia...came to Australia for his kids education, 6 months can't get a job. Last i heard he was a librarian.

For every success in Australia, there's probably 10 failures.

Come on, there's gotta be some common sense. What is Australia really riding on???? On drugs ! Mining sector boom ! Where the heck is the job creation? Its not as if USA could come up with Silicon Valley and Space port, to create new job sectors. Or Malaysia, due to our low exchange rates were able to attract foreign manufacturing plants in the 80s and 90s...to create jobs...still present today.

Australia still have the some old, reliance on service sector. Why do they need migrants? Probably their workforce are too lazy? orthey moved up the value chain, nobody willing to take up their banggla jobs, so they take us migrants to do their dirty work.

Australia GDP may have grown...into a benemoth but it hasn't really translated into anything intrinsic. Their closing down their . manufacturing due to high exchange rates...they are offering waiter, toilet cleaning, garbage man jobs to banggla migrants. They don't have enough manpower for their farms, shopping malls and restaurants. But over the years, those white collar jobs that is what the migrants really aim for, Australia haven't done anything creative to create more of those jobs. Instead migrants have to compete with Australia for these positions. You have to be really damn smart to beat the Aussie for the role.
*
Yup, stand true. I interviewed 3-4 Malaysian engineers whom wanted to come back to Msia as they felt that mining business is dying there. smile.gif
maxmillion
post Sep 2 2014, 06:08 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
73 posts

Joined: Jul 2011
QUOTE(Gazprom200 @ Sep 1 2014, 09:49 PM)
I think the above is not something exclusive to Australia. It happens everywhere in the world even in Asia (places like Malaysia, Singapore, HK, etc). Its something very generic. That is why in every society you will find that people who can "toot their own horns" tend to get promoted faster/bigger bonus/fatter increments or fatter paychecques" and these people tend to be the more talkative ones while the quieter ones are confined to one corner regardless of their capabilities.It happens everywhere not just in caucasion countries.

I also think this is also partly due to culture as Asian usually observe humility and any attempts to "toot your own horn" might be construed as being boastful, which is frowned upon in asian society. Also a saying in Asia still rings true which goes something like " the nail that sticks out gets hammered down" which essentially means one conforms with the majority instead of speaking out which compounds the problem.This is stark contrast to the general caucasion / Indian culture of acceptance of one being individualistic or having one express themselves.
*
Hey thanks for sharing. Never heard of that saying.
tishaban
post Sep 4 2014, 09:14 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
3,615 posts

Joined: Feb 2007
QUOTE(manickam123 @ Sep 4 2014, 08:38 AM)
the list of people who wanna migrate, if this is their intention (they should not go):
*
Good list IMO.

I was thinking of going, simply because I'm a bit bored of being here yet the "racial discrimination" part despite having work experience in US and Europe is holding me back. No point in going there if I'm going to regress. Way too many people I know who went there looking for a better future but not really finding it.

empire23
post Sep 4 2014, 10:44 AM

Team Island Hopper
Group Icon
Staff
9,417 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Bladin Point, Northern Territory
QUOTE(thoyol @ Sep 2 2014, 04:27 PM)
Yup, stand true. I interviewed 3-4 Malaysian engineers whom wanted to come back to Msia as they felt that mining business is dying there. smile.gif
*
That's true. I used to do work for Anglo Grasstree and now people are saying it's a sinking ship. GlencoreXstrata already cutting jobs like mad at Oaky North and Oaky 1. Coal, Coking coal and Iron Ore are dying. Rio Tinto already downsizing their iron ore workforce. Saraji under BMA has already been mothballed.

At the same time, the gas industry is going from construction and consolidation phases into the "Sustainment phase", we've already been sent the emails to prepare. I predict that people without >70% upstream experience will start losing jobs in 1 year. That's 100,000 highly skilled OnG workers trained to the highest of standards with internationally recognized certifications flooding the market. It might be a bit hard for a migrant to compete.

But at the same time shale oil, offshore oil and other advanced unconventionals on the small scale look to be good.

http://www.news.com.au/finance/business/au...h-1227034281143

Either way, modeling by the RBA has shown that Australians are on average 13 percent richer because of the mining boom. Without it, we wouldn't be at US dollar parity as well, instead of the 95 US cents to the dollar we'd be at 65.
Yodatan
post Sep 4 2014, 08:51 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
55 posts

Joined: Feb 2013
Its your life, if you want to move, just move, if you dont want to move, don't move. Everyone has different life situation and starting points, don't have to try to force your opinions down each others throats
TSincrediblehulk
post Sep 10 2014, 06:58 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
32 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(Yodatan @ Sep 4 2014, 09:51 PM)
Its your life, if you want to move, just move, if you dont want to move, don't move. Everyone has different life situation and starting points, don't have to try to force your opinions down each others throats
*
yes. everyone has different experiences. depends on who they mixed with and where they stay. thumbup.gif
roseybunnykitty
post Sep 11 2014, 09:35 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
3 posts

Joined: Sep 2014
QUOTE(alaskanbunny @ Aug 25 2014, 05:03 PM)
talking bout gross... and she's making a managers salary back in msia... when she moved to aus, she got pushed up 2 bands above her msian paygrade.. lucky her

more than 6 figures aud, in msia not even 6 figures myr p.a.
*
What job? I want to work there too..!
honkkydorry
post Sep 12 2014, 12:28 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
676 posts

Joined: May 2012


To migrate or not depends on one's definition of happiness, imo. Not everyone who migrated ended up living a better life than while in Malaysia. Found out a friend intended to migrate to Australia a year ago cos wanted to provide better education for the kids, bla bla bla. Husband quit his job as a senior engineer with a well known MNC telco company and headed over to AUS first to fnd a job. One year later came back cos cannot find a job and is now looking for a job in MY. Lucky wife still got job here to sustain the monthly financials.

Another friend migrated whole family to Sydney many years back. They worked very low level jobs there. Before wife was an executive while hubby was a manager at a bank in MY. I heard a year ago they decided to come home to MY for good. Don't know why.

Someone here pointed out the mistake of ppl migrating for their kids education sake and I have to agree with his points. While our govt education system here deteriorated, it isn't the end of the world. Why not spend the money intended for migration to enrol the kids in private or international school here instead. Why go to another country and ended up with lower level jobs or worse, no job..facing possible discrimination and living a thrifty life while in MY you are surrounded by relatives, friends, decent job, decent life.

People get this perception that life is other countries is always greener than in MY. Maybe I am not ambitous like others but I'm contended to live my good life here because for me what is important is I don't need to suffer. Do I want more money? Sure...but not at the expense of living a "miserable" life elsewhere but painting the picture of a rosy life to folks back home. We all die one day so whatever time God has given to us on this earth, we should enjoy it to the way we are capable. Every individual has different standard or expectation of life. Our children can figure out their own future. As long as you teach them the right way of life and provide them a decent life, I am sure your children can be survivors, regardless the education system here is bad or fantastic. Don't sacrifice so much of your own life for your kids if their lives are already decent to begin with and ended up you don't get to enjoy your life during your time on Earth.

This post has been edited by honkkydorry: Sep 12 2014, 12:29 PM
MR 8925
post Sep 12 2014, 12:36 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
118 posts

Joined: May 2011
typing this from melbourne suburb. frankston is nearby (like PJ and Klang) from my place. what i can advise you is that, the outer you go from city, the more weird stares you get from locals. because its kinda kampung ady (country side). frankston is considered as kampung by locals living in city. and in kampung you dont find everyone educated enough, do you? but if you live closer to city or inner suburbs as they call it here, its better. more asians, educated locals, peaceful pipu. (I DIDNT READ ALL THE REPLIES FOR THIS POST. SO IF I REPEATED WHAT OTHERS MIGHT HAVE ALREADY TOLD, SORRY)
TSincrediblehulk
post Sep 12 2014, 04:21 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
32 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(MR 8925 @ Sep 12 2014, 01:36 PM)
typing this from melbourne suburb. frankston is nearby (like PJ and Klang) from my place. what i can advise you is that, the outer you go from city, the more weird stares you get from locals. because its kinda kampung ady (country side). frankston is considered as kampung by locals living in city. and in kampung you dont find everyone educated enough, do you? but if you live closer to city or inner suburbs as they call it here,  its better. more asians, educated locals, peaceful pipu. (I DIDNT READ ALL THE REPLIES FOR THIS POST. SO IF I REPEATED WHAT OTHERS MIGHT HAVE ALREADY TOLD, SORRY)
*
you said it exactly what i think abt many of their kampung type of pple but our tourist agencies here do not want travelers to know.
MR 8925
post Sep 12 2014, 05:17 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
118 posts

Joined: May 2011
QUOTE(incrediblehulk @ Sep 12 2014, 04:21 PM)
you said it exactly what i think abt many of their kampung type of pple but our tourist agencies here do not want travelers to know.
*
to know what? the attitude of kampung ppl?
hihihehe
post Sep 12 2014, 05:47 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
13,775 posts

Joined: Jan 2006
From: stress & confuse world



QUOTE(incrediblehulk @ Sep 12 2014, 04:21 PM)
you said it exactly what i think abt many of their kampung type of pple but our tourist agencies here do not want travelers to know.
*
lol. what you expect from suburb/kampung? the countries all over the world are the same too
the7signals
post Sep 18 2014, 09:59 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
585 posts

Joined: Aug 2009
i think it really depends on individual. some will feel great. and some will not.
TSOM
post Nov 21 2015, 03:56 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,145 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: 1BORNEO
QUOTE(bsehben @ Aug 25 2014, 04:03 PM)

Correct me if I'm wrong but Melbourne was recently voted as the World's Most Liveable City again. It is a wonderful place to live and work in as the Aussies emphasize alot on work-life balance, but ultimately i returned to Malaysia as many of my friends failed to secure their PR and it got kind of lonely over there. Hope this helps.
*
why can't your friends secure PR?
hihihehe
post Nov 21 2015, 10:01 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
13,775 posts

Joined: Jan 2006
From: stress & confuse world



QUOTE(manickam123 @ Nov 20 2015, 12:51 PM)
I sort of agree. I know a friend who work in singapore but lives in a banglo house in jb, but he wants to migrate to Australia. He says its for the kids education. I tell him, if he cares for his kids, then when his kids are big, why not send them for university education and have them to migrate there? After all with his superior SGD he can afford.

He just senyap. At end of the day, he is just making excuses cause he wants to migrate there himself.

Migrants who come back, usually do it senyap senyap. They don't advertise their "failure", because of the Asian culture of shame. I know 2 migrants who came back, ask them why, they just keep mum.
*
me too but that because i was doing well(sort of) in australia and have to come back because of visa and start over again sad.gif
"shame" to tell everyone i am not doing as great as the time in australia sad.gif

5 Pages « < 2 3 4 5 >Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0748sec    0.69    5 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 26th November 2025 - 11:59 PM