Urm, this is going to be a chicken and egg story...seriously. Look at it both sides too.
If the marketing didn't have a designer, the customers would be staring at something only a marketing person would understand or wouldn't catch the attention of the customer for that matter.
If the designer didn't have a marketing person, then the customer may go "ooo...aaaa" but in the end not take any action from the advertisement itself.
Hence, this is a chicken and egg story. So, I'd just quit it and instead provide the necessary advice then to say who wins between David and goliath.
My take in this matter; yes, most designers do not know how to run a marketing campaign. They are trained in design after all and not on business subjects. And a marketing person can beautify his sales presentation up but when it doesn't achieve the required impact without the necessary tools/designs than the client won't be happy as well. And to be honest, as the world unravels more we'll need more creative heads soon (not just designers think creatively). So it's a tie!
p/s: Just read your extended reply and I disagree not all business need a website. You know what many corporates nowadays are thinking. If you don't have a website, your company is a 'nobody'. If you were speaking to an international client and they were looking at your business card which then leads to the question, "I noticed you don't have a website...how come?" Then what'll the person say, "Because my business doesn't need one.." ?
A website is a necessary business presence for any corporate entity today. If they don't have a website, they may have a blog. If they don't have a blog, they'd be using Facebook or other online tools hosted in...a website. That said, the generation is adopting to the Internet so where would a business be without a website in future is what I would ask.
M1X:
You mentioned AfterEffects, I'd presume it's something to do with the Flash presentation later. I think even gaming clan websites should be treated as any other commercial corporate work. The clan is like the employees and the manager is like the director. So...same-same lor.
This post has been edited by etsuko: Sep 21 2007, 09:39 PM