QUOTE(peueq @ Sep 2 2013, 07:07 PM)
1. The prosperity gospel preachers I have heard mean it in a very economic sense. If not money per se, then material goods, houses etc.
2. The Bible never promises that Christians WILL be prosperous in this life. A simple glance into Christian history will show us Christians who are poor, persecuted and die sick and wretched. Is something wrong with them? Why aren't they prosperous?
3. Prosperity Gospel will lead to bitter and disillusioned people who see Christianity as nothing more than a money making scam and God as a liar because He didn't make them prosperous.
Before I start anything, Let me share part of my life testimony so that you know where I'm coming from.
I spend time with God everyday. EVERYDAY. So I know I have a relationship with Him. It's a 2 way.
It's not about bragging, I don't want ppl to think I talk base on head knowledge, I talk through my life experience.
I went through a tough period (trial of life) pertaining in trusting him to provide even when I have nothing, my business went to a standstill, my car was stolen and I couldn't find any job in the market. But God miraculously provided for me n my family even until TODAY, So I KNOW what I'm talking about when it comes to God's prosperity.
I've experienced miraculous healing, So I know what God promised is true.
I've prayed for others and the major bulk of it was answered, so I know God is faithful.
I don't really care if ppl call me name, I know for certain, I'm a child of God and now his servant.
I believe in the Holy Trinity and Jesus Christ came in the flesh, died for my sins and now resurrected, seated together with the Father in Heaven.
Now to answer your question.
1. Before saying prosperity is wrong, look at the overall context of the preacher. See whether He links it with proper scripture verses to match. IMO, Legitimate need is valid, like house per say and whatever material goods. Because God is not blind, He knows what is needed in this time and age. We don't live in barter age anymore. We don't travel by foot nor with animals anymore, so whatever cost incurred in our life, God will provide. (Matthew 6:25-34)
2. Not true. There are abundance of verses that promised God WILL prosper us in THIS life. (2 Corinthians 9:6-15), (Proverbs 3:9–10), (Proverbs 10:22), (Philippians 4:19), (Deuteronomy 28:12–13), etc. To say that our reward is only meant for Heaven, makes no sense. We have no needs in Heaven because the New Jerusalem is a perfect Heaven where even there is no tears. If there is no tears, I believe it means it's not a fallible world with needs like this corrupted world. (Revelation 21:4) What makes you think wealth is of any use there? We need all the help we can get in this life because there are many people suffering. In Heaven God is our life, King and provider. Without Him we have nothing so Everything is provided there.
Even his glory shines and brighten the entire Heaven. We probably don't need street lamp (my personal guess).
Nothing wrong with the martyr of God in the past. God have always allowed persecution from people. This type of trial is to teach us and strengthen us. All the incidents, good and bad in the Bible was recorded to teach us. (Romans 15:4 ), Including the people who died. Being prosperous doesn't mean you won't die, duh. Where did you get the idea? Everyone will die no matter what. As to whether they died poor, that we don't know. As to why they are poor, how long they remain poor, that we don't know. But did God provide for them despite of them being poor, that I believe God does. Why are there still poor Christians today? Probably because not everyone desire riches. They are contend with what they have even if you dangle RM 1Million, it doesn't twitch their eyes. God honours everyone according to their Faith. Not everyone is rich but does that mean God has stop prospering his people? No. Is something wrong with them? No.
Just for discussion sake do you know we have a better covenant than Moses, something the people of the NT coveted even Job. The covenant of God's grace. What's my prove?
Read the whole passage in Isaiah 54 but I want to bring this to your attention;
…14"In righteousness you will be established; You will be far from oppression, for you will not fear; And from terror, for it will not come near you. 15
"If anyone fiercely assails you it will not be from Me. Whoever assails you will fall because of you. 16"Behold, I Myself have created the smith who blows the fire of coals And brings out a weapon for its work; And I have created the destroyer to ruin. 17"No weapon that is formed against you will prosper; And every tongue that accuses you in judgment you will condemn. This is the heritage of the servants of the LORD, And their vindication is from Me," declares the LORD.
Do you see that why under the new covenant, it is not the same of old where it is not in the heart of God to let us suffer but the devil?
3. Of course. Who actually agreed that Christian should seek prosperity?