QUOTE(Gimli @ Jan 27 2006, 02:27 PM)
Hi fellas,
Seems everyone's raving about SHP-895 so I was wondering, compared to a cheaper model say the 805(which is about $100 difference), what would you say the plus points of the 895 model?i.e. where does the pricing difference go to?
I tried googling for a review on cnet-asia and epinions but unable to find one. Is the 895 known differently elsewhere?
Forgive my ignorance, I dont have much experience with headphones so I hope someone can enlighten me.
I found some interesting review in head-fi.orgSeems everyone's raving about SHP-895 so I was wondering, compared to a cheaper model say the 805(which is about $100 difference), what would you say the plus points of the 895 model?i.e. where does the pricing difference go to?
I tried googling for a review on cnet-asia and epinions but unable to find one. Is the 895 known differently elsewhere?
Forgive my ignorance, I dont have much experience with headphones so I hope someone can enlighten me.
The SHP805
My first impression was: incredible detail, good soundstage, but a rather plasticky/dull/timbre-less presentation. The sonic balance is indeed somewhat off, perhaps a bit too much bass and definitely too much treble -> the famous V-shaped EQ, which Philips phones are known for. The specific equalization will depend on your taste, I applied a treble roll-off starting at 2000Hz descending to about -2-3db at the upper end of the spectrum. Then I tried "stuffing" them as sgrossklass suggested, and it did wonders to the performance -> the "plastickyness" is allmost completely gone. The stuffing took also care off the slightly overblown bass, now I feel they could actually need a tiny bit more bass (but beware that the Fortissimo is not an especially bassy source). The next thing I did was adding the amp, as I wrote above - this helped a lot.
Stuffed, amped and equalized, the SHP805 is a killer phone that proves a worthy challenge for any phone in the sub 80 EUR class.
The SHP895
Now to the big brother. He didn't leave such a favorable impression and will be returned, so I'm mostly going to tell you what Philips screwed up here (and ramble a lot). That is especially silly, as they did many things wrong with the SHP895, that were actually well done with the HP890.
1. Sound
It lacks the (residual) "plastickyness" of the SHP805 and add more timbre and body to everything. Instrument separation is also clearly better, although I wouldn't call the SHP805 exactly "muddy" in the first place. The bass is a bit tighter and definitely extends deeper than the SHP805's. The highs on the other hand have a rather annoying touch to them - I would call them harsher and a bit too "in your face", plus the are even more boosted than the SHP805's. Also note that the SHP895 didn't improve as much with the amp as the SHP805 did.
2. Comfort
Dumb, dumb, dumb. The HP890 had a self-adjusting headband plus a "bow" above it as "superstructure". That looked rather ugly and the headband was a little to loose, so the cups could start to sag and ride on your ears. Philips obviously wanted the SHP895 to look nicer, so they gave it only a sturdy headband, but some dumbo decided that the notoriously flawed concept was just to good to leave out. Then there was the designer of the SHPs, which wanted the headband/bow to be flatter shaped (flatter than your head, so only the mid part rests on your skull). Let's add all that up: when on my head, the cups constantly keep pulling the mid part of the (rather hard) headband down on the middle of my skull. Add to that a little too much clamping force from the side, and the SHP895 beats the famous Sennheiser "death claw" by far.
Not enough uncomfyness for you? Guess what - they are hot. No, not in a positive sense. They are hot, hot, hot. I can hardly keep them on my head for more than half an hour before my ears start to smoke/sweat. That is no wonder as there is not much space inside the SHP895's cups, the padding of the drivers rests right againt your ears. I tried to counteract this by stuffing them like the SHP805, but the issue wasn't really resolved through that and the sound got too distant with the necessary amount of stuffing.
Still not enough? They are heavy. I suspect that the HP890 wasn't (much) lighter, but through cleverly distributing that weight on a surface as large es possible (wide and smooth headband, very large and smooth cups), they could actually make you forget that you are wearing them. With the SHP895's weight resting mostly on only one point of your skull, that is just the opposite.
Bottom line is, the sonic improvement over the modded SHP805 has a hard time justifying 3 times their price. The comfort should also be better and not significantly worse the the SHP805's. And although the build quality is clearly superior to the SHP805, the dissadvantages overweigh in my eyes.
Feb 9 2006, 08:44 AM

Quote

0.0188sec
0.42
6 queries
GZIP Disabled