QUOTE(apathen @ Mar 17 2014, 10:13 PM)
ok at least this is some fact you reference to, let me give my opinions below :-
Not sure you are clear that interest scheme actually is SSM product and not SC product, hence the trustee need not registered with SC as long as recognized by SSM, unless the trustee want to handle SC product then they need to register with SC. Will you expect for example a will trustee to registered under SC as well?
Looks like SSM was taking action against them, contradict to some say they are powerless.
https://www.ssm.com.my/en/press-release/pen...ad-dituduh-olehNow to be fair, for this case was it the fault of trustee that lead to this? I doubt so bcos no action taken on them so far ... otherwise some one with proof can sue them and make quick buck, just like you can't fault an accounting firm that do audit on a bankrupt firm as long the accounting firm do their job professionally.
I guess so far I can only fault them of still being unknown but not that they are illegal.
u need understand what is sow for trustee.
will company is different as it did not hold any $$ from investor.
and did u notice that majority of My Premier’s Trustee’s customer, which use My Premier’s Trustee’s is a potential scam company?
First, let’s look at REIT’s Trustees. I’ve found there are 14 REITs in Malaysia, and below are the REITs and the Trustee they used. Note that AR stands for Annual Report. All AR can be obtained (and verified) from
http://www.bursamalaysia.com/ .
1. AMANAH HARTA TANAH PNB – Amanah Raya Berhad (page 2 of 2010′s AR)
2. AMANAHRAYA REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – CIMB Trustee Berhad (page 4 of 2010′s AR)
3. AMFIRST REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – Mayban Trustees Berhad (page 5 of 2011′s AR)
4. ATRIUM REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – BHLB Trustee Berhad (page 15 of 2010′s AR)
5. AXIS REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – OSK Trustees Berhad ( page 3 of 2010′s AR)
6. AL-HADHARAH BOUSTEAD REIT – CIMB Trustee Berhad (page 28 of 2010′s AR)
7. CAPITAMALLS MALAYSIA TRUST – AmTrustee Berhad (page 20 of 2010′s AR)
8. HEKTAR REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – AmTrustee Berhad (page 32 of 2010′s AR)
9. AL-’AQAR KPJ REIT – Amanah Raya Berhad ( page 5 of 2010′s AR)
10. QUILL CAPITA TRUST – Mayban Trustees Berhad ( page 2 of 2010′s AR)
11. STARHILL REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – Mayban Trustees Berhad (page 14 of 2011′s AR)
12. SUNWAY REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – OSK Trustees Berhad (page 7 of 2011′s AR)
13. TOWER REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – Am Trustee Bhd (page 3 of 2010′s AR)
14. UOA REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – OSK Trustees Berhad ( page 5 of 2010′s AR)
How many of the 14 REIT uses Trustee that is listed in SC’s website? ALL !!!Or, let me rephrase the question differently. How many of the 14 REIT uses non-registered Trustee ? NONE !.
Just in case someone might say that this interest scheme by SSM is different from REIT or Unit Trust (since both REIT and Unit Trust uses registered Trustee which can be found in SC’s website), i’ve dug further to the SSM’s interest scheme companies.
There are currently 3 types of interest scheme in SSM, Sharefarming Scheme , Equipment Sharing and this Property Scheme. For convinience, let me list all the companies below, and the trustee they used.
- AZZ MARKETING BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE
- GOLDEN PALM GROWERS BERHAD – AmTrustee Berhad – (
http://goldenpalm.com.my/auditors.html )
- PLENTIFUL GOLD-CLASS BERHAD – BHLB Trustee Berhad (
http://www.chgs.com.my/trustee.asp )
- AROWANA VENTURE BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE
- SWIFTLET ECO PARK BERHAD – PB Trustee Berhad (
http://www.swiftletecopark.com.my/scheme_why_esris_5key.htm- EAST WEST ONE CONSORTIUM BERHAD – Equity Trust (Malaysia) Bhd – ( page 10 of the company’s eprospectus here:
http://www.eastwestone.com/downloads_eprospectus.html )
- ICT ZONE VENTURES BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE
- AVENUE PROPERTIES BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE