.....
QUOTE(Fyonne @ Apr 28 2009, 12:52 PM)
k-on kinda failed as music anime.
example like saki, it only has mahjong in it but main attraction is moe'tard stuff. same thing apply to k-on. music is like side dish n can live without any music anthology.
u dun really care if Saki cheat with extra mahjong tile on her hand or Mio can pick her bass with both of her hand on the mic.
K-On, main point to be music anime? Not for me.
It's more like depicting the daily quirks of a certain club's members, and in this case, a light music club. Hence the genre slice-of-life.
QUOTE(Thalmes @ Apr 28 2009, 07:21 PM)
Well...Just like some of the forumers said , It's slice of life . You can't really go wrong with the storyboard with exams and stuffs coming around. In real life , students start a band with a lot of factors blocking them to be successful just like K-On. If they are just going all on the music , It's just too good to be true. Schools with no exams ? Japan's standard is high.
This.
QUOTE(rikimtasu @ Apr 29 2009, 01:21 AM)
10% Music+60% MOE+20% Normal Life+10% of Kyoani Fanboy-ism=this anime.
Music is out of the story (watching OP/ED isn't an option for me anyway) for some, -10%
For those who don't pick shows for the MOE, -60%
Normal life? Okay 20% stays.
KyoAni fanboyism? Thrown out of the window for those aiming to be generic and not fanboys/fangirls of any studio etc, just hoping for the best to come out from an anime. -10%
So there'll be people watching this with only about 20% interest overall, eh?
... Wait, you forgot to allocate some percentage for the storyline. Even if it's from a 4koma a 4koma is nothing without a little story.
QUOTE(shah_ho_nam @ Apr 29 2009, 05:44 AM)
this anime is easier than the deep one like haruhi, so for leisure time and adding up some smiles in it, can be counted as viewable anime
QUOTE(Aoshi_88 @ Apr 29 2009, 06:27 AM)
Err wut>? Haruhi is deep? Dude... you need to watch more GiTS, Sky Crawlers and Osamu Tezuka.
If I were to take storyline into account, the Haruhi novels were already quite a pain to try to understand. I won't deny the said deepness of GiTS, Sky Crawlers, Osamu Tezuka's stories etc. But yeah. I haven't even finished reading the Baka-Tsuki translated novels yet, didn't have much time for it. Shah isn't wrong but you're not wrong either. Both of you are right, in a sense.
This post has been edited by FlameReaper: Apr 29 2009, 07:36 PM 
Feb 27 2009, 10:22 AM, updated 16y ago
Quote
Interesting...
. Better bought an epiphone here in msia instead and change the nut.
0.2117sec
0.62
6 queries
GZIP Disabled