If compared to some fundamental good stocks, then stock outperform UT generally.
As one major disadvantage of UT, is its management fee. If the stock you hold not rising, then you breakeven, but in UT, due to the management fee, you will lose 1.5% annually, so if the stock is not moving 10 years, then in stock, you breakeven, in UT, you lose 15% already, no including initial service charges of 5% compared to 1.5% commission of stock trading.
UT portfolio is more diversified, so it will normalise both upside and downside. You holding 2 to 3 stocks in your hand, if those stocks surge 50%, then you gain 50%. But in UT, they have bunch of stock in their portfolio, 2 to 3 stocks surge 50%, won't able to result the fund gain 50%, as there might be other perform not so good or bad one, so other will normalise it which result fund only gain 20-30%.
But on the downside, if your holding stocks drop 50%, then you loss 50%, but if the UT portfolio is diversifed enough to have some stocks that are still performing quite good, then the fund performance might loss only 20%.
But currently, it is not the case in most funds, as recent stock market plunge is worldwide and across.
Only a handful of stocks are able to offset in recent downturn, locally and typically like BAT, F&N etc, which one hand finger already enough to count.
But the main problem and issue in stock & UT comparison is the stock pick, if you pick the wrong stock to invest then it could be a lot poorer than UT.
So can't totally which one is better, stock pick is the key.
Just my 2 cents.
Thx for the excellent explanation.
I would conclude that UT are cushioned more as compared to stocks. I understand the dividends are also less i.e. less risk, less returns and high risk, high returns (and loss!!)
Honestly, I do wished that good stocks drop a bit more than that so that I can buy them cheaper!! Including the ones you mentioned i.e. BAT & F&N, others are like public bank, BJTOTO, SIME, etc. I actually acquired SIME at RM5.00 (500 shares only) because it had a significant drop last week!!! My target price was below it's lowest price of RM5.50 but since it dropped so much, might as well stock up on it....