I voted for Ledley King. coz in the list, i don't think any of the establish player is overrated. Yes, Walcott is a little overrated, i admit. But this sort of things happen to young footballers. Walcott will play a big big part in next season's campaign, i'm sure. But price tag wise, Bent is by far the worst. He's worth a Thierry Henry. Now that's overrated...

u can compare by looking at their contribution to the team and performance at the pitch
did they do their job brilliantly or just nothing special
need to look at their consistency too

This post has been edited by MADReaLJL: Jun 5 2008, 09:19 PM

Maybe but that only measures their contribution and not their talent

u have good talent, u polish it, u produce something from ur polished talent, then there is contribution

This post has been edited by MADReaLJL: Jun 5 2008, 09:20 PM

Walcott has all the natural talent to make him a superstar and he is at the right club to develop that talent.

lol.. Walcott is overrated because he isn't in the 1st team at Arsenal?
What about Nani and Anderson?

They have selective vision....

Nani and Anderson both featured regularly and were integral in Manchester United winning the title.

Towards the 2nd half of the season Nani frequently started until the return of Park Ji Sung, even then Nani still played very frequently.

Anderson started in big matches, amongst them against Arsenal at Emirates. There are Michael Carrick, Paul Scholes, Owen Hargreaves and Anderson who feature for United in central midfield, so obviously Anderson being the new kid won't get as much playing time.

Anderson and Nani both have made significant impact in their first season at United. Some say they play like seasoned pros, especially Anderson.

Walcott on the other hand, has been with Arsenal for so long, yet barely starts or even plays. So.............

This post has been edited by Desvaro: Jun 5 2008, 09:41 PM

this thread for english footballer, rite? how come nani and anderson involve??

btw, walcott ok for me

This post has been edited by PrinceOfPersia: Jun 5 2008, 09:46 PM

Excuse me? "Most overrated footballers in England" ?
Or Englishmen?

nani scored 2 wondergoals and 2 more against liverpool and arsenal
he got 1X assists.. forgot how much

anderson stats cant be measured directly as his yardstick
in fact all man utd CM doesnt have dazzling stats
but he really gives energy to the team
when scholes injured he fit in the team nicely and helps our free flowing football

TS said english footballers

It was initially made to be most overrated players in England but my poll only consisted of Englishmen so....

next season walcott will shine as long as he is wenger main LW ...

the title is Most overrated footballers in England?
so who play in FA competition directly involve

LoL..
then should we follow the title or?

better RW..

ok sorry, just follow the title

i voted for darren bent

This post has been edited by PrinceOfPersia: Jun 5 2008, 09:58 PM

follow the title lor..

This post has been edited by vutsi: Jun 5 2008, 09:54 PM

Well, that is how you rate their contribution to MU.
Walcott to me is NOT overrated for being equally important to the team as well.
Take a look in his substitutes effect, and you will see how he worth every penny.
For example, in the Liverpool game, he demonstrate his quality.
The other thing is Nani and Anderson were playing in the Sporting Lisbon regularly before joining MU?
Walcott was only in the Saints academy before joining Arsenal?

This post has been edited by -Nos-: Jun 5 2008, 10:05 PM